Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello!

Remember how I said that I thought I’d have the next video done by the end of May? Ha. Ha HA! HA HA HAAAHH ha ha.

Yeah, so this turned into a rabbit hole. I thought this would be a simple “wow, here’s a weird thing you used to be able to buy!” but the whole “but why?” angle led to me digging into the history and what I found is nuts. So it snowballed into this!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSnrQBfBCzY

I think you’ll get a kick out of this for sure. It’s gonna take me a while to get captions done since, y’know, it’s much longer than I figured it would be, but I’ll paste the script in soon. As of now, public release is scheduled for Friday.

As ever, thank you so very much for being here. There’s absolutely no way I could change gears so far into a project without your support!

Files

Digital sound wasn't possible without videotape

Oh boy. A titling conundrum! Oh, here's the mentioned link before I forget: https://www.kenrockwell.com/audio/sony/pcm-f1.htm

Comments

Thomas Fuchs

Take your time and do it right! I know you are. You could always do no effort November surprises in between, who cares if it’s actually November. :)

Mike Bird

I have a camera which wrote video directly on tape in DV format (Sony, if course). What got my knickers in a knot was that there was a perfectly good, compressed DV format video in the playback, but they converted it to some other stupid lossy format before sending it over my digital FireWire cable!

William Wallace

They also make "back up your PC to VHS tape" systems.

Jamie + Lion

This is fab. Listening along now to it not. Thanks for the warning on the flickering video. I swapped from watching to listening and it’s making a lot of sense even without the visuals.

Michael Mahr

It wouldn’t be a technology connections video without latent heat and the refrigeration cycle. Do what you gotta do!

Dave Hensley

If the audio data is stored entirely within the VHS tape's video signal, then that means you could theoretically use Kris Slyka's technique to store some real video data in the audio signal... so you could have a VHS tape where the (very high quality) audio is stored as video and the (very low quality) video is stored as audio. Wow what a stupid thought. Why did I even think of this?

CJ

Your last video caused such a stir in the HI5 community that it's still being talked about and I didn't even realize you were overdue for another one 🤣

Mathias

Good stuff as always. What a weird topic, fun to learn something new. Thank you!

triggthediscovery

I think the primary hurdle to VCR's adoption in data storage (besides just not needing that much space) would be the atrocious seek times. CD and even Laserdisk could access random data in less than 5 seconds. I imagine tape would be in the range of minutes. It's basically only usable as linear media or backup storage.

Travis Snoozy

Many hands make light work. CC's look mostly good, just a couple typos worth mentioning. 7:21 NHK's singl-channel 10:01 (wgucg might sound familiar)

Arthur Robillard

There was one other use for this system, OTA broadcasts in digital quality for those who wanted better than FM could deliver and had the money to buy such equipment (and could also store it on videotape).

Technology Connections

Now you raise an interesting question - were there PCM broadcasts? I suppose that's not out of the question, although most adaptors would still need a VCR to act as a tuner.

Technology Connections

Oh boy! I hope it wasn't too violent a stir (though causing a stir is absolutely what I wanted that vid to do)

Arthur Robillard

I vaguely recall that WGBX here in Boston simulcasted their WGBH Classical Radio FM station as such a video signal. I can't remember what timeframe we're talking about. Of course, at the time I was unaware of what digital was and what the hell I was looking at but I was fascinated nonetheless.

Technology Connections

Fascinating! That didn't even register as a possibility to me so I didn't look for any history like that

Blargity Blarg Blarg

I am so glad you did this. Back in the 1980s, I remember seeing it in 1987-1988, WGBX (the ‘eXperimental’ station run by WGBH, the well-known PBS station) ran PCM audio over-the-air. The idea was to broadcast a fully-digital simulcast of ‘classical’ WGBH radio.

Blargity Blarg Blarg

They still had the aural carrier on WGBX which would play exactly what was being sent over the PCM video, but if I remember right it also explained what you were looking at.

Blargity Blarg Blarg

When this was happening I was working at the PBS station in Providence. We were all floored by the technology.

Blargity Blarg Blarg

'It's quiet -- total quiet-- you can't hear anything else,' Well duh. That was utterly revolutionary at the time. With CDs becoming very popular at that time, to hear CD-quality audio over-the-air was a natural progression. However it never did take off as it was expected. Running a TV transmitter was much more expensive than a radio transmitter, and there was close to zero consumer saturation of PCM decoders. Nice try.

Blargity Blarg Blarg

God I seem like I’m spamming here..sorry about that. There is another blip in Audio magazine, December 1986, where WGBH was hoping “that this experiment could lead the FCC, now exploring frequency allocations in the upper UHF band, to allocate some of those frequencies to digital sound broadcasting. A digital station would take up about half the bandwidth of a UHF TV channel.”

Mark Johansson

As for storing computer data on video tape: Many years ago (1979-1988) I worked at Corvus Systems, which was the first company to make hard drive systems for the Apple II, and later, many other microcomputers. It was a 10MB, 8-inch drive and cost $5350.00. In November '79 they introduced the Mirror, which could back up your hard drive to VHS tape. Capacity was 100MB but I don't remember at what tape size/speed. If you had the very expensive Panasonic NV-8208 VCR you could connect the Mirror to the VCR's remote inteface and control it with the backup software. I still have a binder full of Corvus brochures, company newsletters, articles, etc. And here's a video about the company from 1982: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arkgOkjDagk.

Martin Deutsch

I used to work at the main TV control room at the BBC, and they had one of these units in the apparatus room. I never saw it used (I joined in 2008) but I think it may have been used to get higher quality audio links back from outside broadcasts before they had decent digital video contribution circuits. I'll see what I can find out. You can see it if you squint a bit near the top of the left-hand rack here: https://maps.app.goo.gl/JJJBgZiKgxSfRnBA6 The stuff further down that rack with the red patch cords are analogue audio multiplexers, could carry 5 signals in the space of one. Which we then put two of them in a NICAM carrier, then inside some sort of AoIP codec. In 2010. Don't ask me why, all I know is that it somehow worked.

Adrian S

Aw man, the closing mention that "digital audio data is still data" reminded me of a funny thing that happened at the local university, a couple of years ago. Basically whenever old offices & storage-rooms get cleaned out, students get to see pieces of obsolete hardware (like hard-drives from the '70s, the size of a washing machine, and the cost of a car at that time - no-one dares to throw them away because half a century ago those were really expensive). One such device was an eastern-european clone of the ZX-Spectrum computer, from the '80s (from when our professors were starting their careers). ZX-Spectrum, being intended for home/hobby use, didn't have a hard-drive (too expensive), but loaded data from an audio-jack (the user was expected to already have a casette deck & tapes laying around, and reuse those). While the students were looking around to see who had access to a cassette-deck, an older professors saw them, and was like "wait, no, let me show you how it's done!". The prof then took his iPhone, an audio patch-cable, downloaded some WAV files to the smartphone, and played those audio-files back using the headphone-port & the patch-cable into '80s computer. It was really fun to see the prof grinning while transferring files from a brand-new smartphone into an "ancient" computer. Digital data-> Audio Signal -> Digital data... because "data is still data", even when presented in the form of an audio signal.

MrHammond

"Digital" audio -> Piano music 🤣

Oscar Røhling

I used to multitrack on a couple ADAT XTs in the 90s, they each record 8 tracks 20bit/48k on S-VHS tapes. But I never thought of watching a sound recording on a VCR, probably because I didn't know anybody who had a S-VHS specimen, and I guess I knew S-VHS wasn't backward compatible with old school VHS anyway. At any rate the mechanism ran a lot faster than on standard VHS judging by the mechanical noise. Afraid I can't do much of a show & tell. I was smart enough to back up everything I needed to PC and tape backup (in real time - took two weeks out of my summer!) and trade them off before 2nd hand prices dropped as soon as I twigged that DAWs on PC was becoming a workable thing. I still have three or four tapes in storage, not that I believe they would work today.

Ian Flanigan

Mark, I came here to say exactly the same thing. I remember backing up a Corvus HD (10 MB!) to a VHS tape in my high school computer lab in 1986.

Ian Flanigan

BTW, the folks on the Applesauce FDC discord (and patreon.com/diskblitz) would probably be interested in your brochures and so forth.

Mike Richards

Is there a word for something that in retrospect seems so obvious - and yet is completely mind-blowing? I had never heard of this before and - wow! Is there any chance we could have a video about DAT and DCC? I'm sure there is lots to be told about how they were able to reduce the size of the tapes, the whole RIAA helping kill the format, and the niche uses they ended up in.

aboogaard

WOW! A binary burp.

cole

I thought your old Sony tank couldn't record?

Khitiara

i think he recorded with a different one and was using it for playback

Technology Connections

Ah, well. See, there's a whole bunch of little factors that piled up into me believe that it couldn't. For a start, it has a weird audio input (I'm assuming it's just a mono 1/8 inch jack but I'm not sure) so in my original Beta vs. VHS tests I didn't use it. I am almost certain that I tried recording with it in the past and the quality of the image was just not great. BUT. The contacts on the PCM switch are dirty, and you see a bunch of weird stuff on the screen when you switch it. I'm now thinking that this was messing up its ability to record and that, in actuality, it's fine. Either that or maybe there's something wrong with its color circuitry which the PCM recording don't use. I did in fact use it to record digital sound successfully, and maybe I'll do a Connextras follow-up to talk about that because honestly at this point even I'm confused! I should do test video recordings now and see the difference between it and the Toshiba Beta deck I have.

The 8-Bit Guy

Never heard of this before. I guess the weird thing is, it seems it only has analog inputs and outputs. So there's no way to extract the digital data from the tape, or vice-versa. In which case, I sort of wonder if you'd have been better of just using a really nice analog reel-to-reel. Although, I guess once the audio is recorded, you could probably make multiply copies without any loss of fidelity.

Technology Connections

Yep, that's absolutely why in my mind it's a "who on Earth is this even for?" sort of a question. There was one model that had a S/PDIF in and out but most don't. Now, supposedly the Copy Out port is actually a newly-generated video feed and not simply a pass-through, that way you can make bit-perfect copies with a second VCR and not worry about generational loss. But that's such an /incredibly/ niche set of circumstances to encounter and overall the existing of home PCM adapters remains puzzling to me (and apparently they sold tons! Or at least enough to have several on eBay right now)

Circuitmike

You mean like the one he covered in this video?

István Nagy

I can't post this on YouTube because it gets filtered out. But during the "event" I was bored and created a program which can in real time play out WAV files into this encoded format over the composite output of a Raspberry Pi Zero (PiCM). There's a demo video on my YouTube channel of it in action, decoded back via a software decoder (unfortunately I don't have any original hardware to test with). It's not totally faithful as the Raspi can't draw outside the visible region and the PCM format spans a bit over that, but the error correction able to fill-in the missing lines, so it still works. Also, there's a video called "[PCM Video Course] Digital Audio on Video Tape - Part 1: EIAJ STC-007 PCM Structure" on YouTube which explains the structure of the video signal very nicely. The 14bit format does have a bit more error correction, the 16bit format is kind of a retro fit and sacrifices some of the error correction bits for the extra resolution.

Arthur Robillard

ADAT ran 3 times as fast as SP. A 120 tape recorded for 40 minutes. The tape was usually not resilient enough to survive too much back and forth transport for overdubbing. And synchronized units were just tons of fun to work with...not.

Jon Adams

I do appreciate the irony of the flashing 12:00

Nick Loh

The video output on the TV reminds me of a video I once saw that showed how TiVo DVRs got their program guide data if they weren't hooked up to a phone line. The company bought infomercial slots on certain stations and transmitted data over the video signal. The DVR knew to tune to that channel at the given time and decode the data, and what you would see looked kind of like what the TV in your video is showing (except for a scrolling "there is nothing wrong with your TV" marquee in the center of the screen - they also had a voiceover to that effect, interspersed with some muzak). I never saw this with our family's TiVo because we did have a phone line going to it, but I imagine me from that time would have been equal parts fascinated and terrified by it if I did. It makes sense that it looks similar to your device's output, since they're kind of doing the same thing (just with program data instead of digital audio)...

Oscar Røhling

Oh yeah, I remember the dread. I got so used to hitting Stop twice for peace of mind that I even did it (to no effect) on my cassette deck back home.

Gecko089

I feel you. Back in the days I bought a portable Sony MD-Recoder that could even put computer data on High-MD. I bought it because it was marketed as mp3 compatible and that sounded great at the time. 1GB of mp3s to go... What they did was not put files on there (which it obviously could), but convert it to some stupid ATRAC3+ format and put in on the disc linearly. It was expensive and I was very disappointed.

Jay Tee

Somebody wrote software to convert captured SD video back into audio again https://youtu.be/beZCRdq2Nt4 There's a github repo of it. In the 80s, the BBC provided 'telesoftware' for their computers over the teletext lines of a TV signal, and even now there are loads of home recordings out there (especially any made off air to SVHS tapes) that hold a time capsule of teletext data from when they were recorded.

John Hiesey

Here is a diagram of how the 14 bit and 16 bit formats are laid out on the video signal. TL;DR is that 16 bit format "steals" half of the error correcting space for the extra 2 bits per sample. See the previous and next page of the manual for more detail. You'll also notice a "copy prohibiting" bit in the signal, which I thought was interesting... https://www.manualslib.com/manual/466194/Sony-Pcm-F1.html?page=26

Mark Costa

I remember when WGBX 44 in Boston (a PBS UHF station that was part of WGBH) experimented for a while in the mid 80's with PCM Audio broadcasts over their TV channel. Viewers could use a Hi8 deck to play the digital audio stream.

Dan Colucci

This episode needs to be submitted somewhere for an award of excellence. This was great. Thank you!