Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello out there. It's been a while!

So... I've been going back and forth on whether I wanted to make this video. I had spent hours and hours on this script — revisions to pacing, removing unneeded minutia, agonizing over how angsty to be — and ultimately I decided I've spent too much time on it to shelve the project.

Plus, I want it to serve as something of a mea culpa. I was very publicly wrong about the outcome here, and not acknowledging that feels just as wrong. Maybe even wronger.

I didn't include bloopers or credits, in part because this shoot took forever and none of the bloopers were fun. But also, while I think I've kept myself more in check than I have before, I don't want to attach anybody's name to the, um, spicier opinions I have (which I can say in all honesty aren't directed towards Tesla! I'm actually quite pleased with what they've done).

https://youtu.be/ZJOfyMCEzjQ

In completely unrelated news, though, there's some behind-the-scenes stuff going on that's gonna slow me down a bit for a while. Nothing scary or life-altering, and you'll see the fruits of it eventually, but I'm keeping it a secret for now ;)

Also, I know I teased the pinball machine video forever ago - that's still definitely happening! It's just going to take me quite a while to reacquaint myself with the machine and turn my ideas into words, and I've been intimidated by that and procrastinating. I have learned if there's one thing I'm good at, it's procrastinating.

Speaking of procrastinating, captions will come soon. This video is longer than I thought it would be (are any of us shocked?) so it's gonna take me a while to polish them.

'kay bye.

Files

Tesla won the plug war - and that's good news!

A surprisingly good series of events have unfolded, and this video is my mea culpa. I'll have links and stuff here in a bit

Comments

Joel Eblin

At first I didn't have audio, and now it works. Seems like YouTube was finishing up processing

Marlo Delfin Gonzales

Seems like a temporary hiccup; I have audio now after reloading it.

Eric x Wolfman

Keep up the great work! We all have procrastination and are aware of items we are not ready to tackle yet. But the end result being wonderful videos on these topics is what really counts. That in the experience along the way. I'm always delighted to see the new videos and this will be no exception! Thank you for what you do and I and everyone really appreciate it.

triggthediscovery

I agree that DC fast chargers are going to end up resembling gas stations, but I suspect stuff like restaurants, lounges, and arcades make way more sense in an EV world. Travel centers are very liminal, designed to get in and out fast, often with a similarly speedy eatery connected. But if you're trapped there for at least 20 minutes as a rule, having amenities which eat up time makes more sense as well. If most people are going to be there for at least a half hour, why not slap a Denny's or similar chain restaurant to it?

Technology Connections

Oh, to be clear, that's why I was calling out truck stop chains. They typically already offer all those amenities. And speaking from experience, a Denny's is too slow. At least with my car ;)

Mark Hesse

Nice to see that your T-shirt suggests another option that would make the switch to EVs more feasible/amenable/viable--namely that we should expand Amtrak service and make rail travel easier and more ubiquitous. Don't want to take your EV on a long road trip because you dread the charging experience? Well, in the words of an old advertising campaign, "Next time, take the train." Even better if we could get more high-speed rail routes into operation.

Francis

Plug and charge would make sense if it just passed a credit card stored in the car up to the charger with some standardized protocol, without the need to sign up for each charger network individually. Essentially, your car becomes a giant Apple Pay/Google Wallet, and "taps" through the charging cord.

~

Of course, you could do both: the Britain-to-France tunnel runs carriages that carry cars, so you can put your car on the train, take a break on the train, and drive off at your destination with no charge expended.

John Deters

Re: your payment rant. Payment is the business of skimming money. At least in the retail world of "digital wallets", payment networks have long vied to provide the default payment type, because that's how they skim the most. Some would even choose the order of cards in your wallet for you. They don't want customers to pick which card they'd prefer as the default, as the wallet provider always wants the simplest, easiest default path for your money to flow effortlessly through their preferred payment network and into their pockets. I suspect the reason charging network apps fail so frequently and so badly is that they're incentivized primarily by the payment industry, not the charging company. It's as if they think they're making more money by providing a crappy but profitable payment system instead of delivering electrons to paying customers. It boggles the mind.

John Deters

I have a Bolt. Chevy should sponsor charging stations in movie theater parking lots. :-(

PerfectlyAdequate

I’m here to petition for jazz played over puppy videos for the outro

George Smart M1GEO

Alec, have you seen (UK company) GridServe has 'Electric Forecourts' which are an attempt to meet the needs you describe of an EV Gas Station. Canopy. Meeting space. Food. Comfy chairs. Etc.

Aleksei Besogonov

I hard-disagree on the plug-and-charge. It allows several interesting options like wireless charging or automated charging cable plugging devices (the Tesla charger snake). Because they make little sense without an automated payment infrastructure. Imagine, you just drive up to a marked spot on a parking lot and the car starts to charge with zero input. Now add autonomous vehicles to the mix, that might not even HAVE human drivers to plug in the cable.

Technology Connections

I mean, you're welcome to disagree with me, but to be blunt... those ideas make little sense period. If charger reliability is a concern, I cannot imagine a world in which the Tesla snake (or any such thing) is a net positive. That adds sooooo many potential points of failure, and then that stall is useless if the robotics are offline. It's also just... not something I even want? Like, I'll have been driving for 2 or 3 hours. The last thing I desire is the ability to just stay in the car and wait - I'm gonna be getting out to stretch my legs anyway. Now, presuming we can make wireless charging efficient enough to be worth the added expense, then that is a decent opportunity. But, that's probably just gonna be level 2 power levels. And that's the use-case in which I think plug-and-charge has merit, anyway. For when I'm traveling long-distance, in an unfamiliar area with new charging networks I haven't used before, I just want to use my credit card. Those networks can guarantee compatibility with any car with nothing but a PIN pad.

Technology Connections

I have! I think that's a great concept. I do wonder, though, what the value of some of those amenities will be over time. As soon as 15 minute charges become the norm, which is undoubtedly around the corner as it's (not to brag) already a thing with my car, there's less time to wait around than you realize. While I don't have the best track record for making predictions, I think they'll probably simplify to the point of being virtually indistinguishable from today's truck stops - but perhaps a nicer environment.

Technology Connections

It would, and I might be more receptive to the idea if this is how it worked. I still can't see it as a anything but a solution in search of a problem, though, and from my perspective it adds a new point of failure - software.

Aleksei Besogonov

Charging snakes can probably be designed so that they can be operated manually if robotics fail. It's of course not something we need, but it'd be nice to have. And technologies have this annoying thing, if you don't do something that requires complicated infrastructure from the start (e.g. "plug-to-charge") it tends to just never happen. Card readers will be "good enough" and there'll be no impetus to add plug-to-charge. That's why it's important to get it right from the start. And finally, a properly implemented "plug-to-charge" does NOT have to require any setup. Even the current crappy standard technically allows ad-hoc transmission of the payment credentials. So you can just enter the card details in the car infotaiment system, and it can use them if there's no trust relationship between your car and the network. I don't think it's actually implemented anywhere in the US, but it is certainly possible and it's something that should be mandated.

Technology Connections

Again, though, is it solving an actual problem or is it nice to have? Remember, a key part of my perspective is that right now, it looks like the choice is between "Seamless, good, but non-standard" and "Terrible, maybe a card reader, maybe an app" when that's just not what the choice is. I would argue that if EA (and other networks) just incorporated actually-good card readers, they /would/ have gotten it right from the start.

Stephanie

I have absolutely no intereset in EV charging in the US, as I live in NL, but damn I can listen to you talk for hours.

George Smart M1GEO

Agreed. As a Tesla owner, I would love V2L (currently using an EcoFlow) and a higher voltage battery to help with charge speed. Many of the non Tesla 350kW chargers can't do more than around 75kW into 400V batteries, as they hit a current limit. I recall you've spoken to this point before. Anywho. Onward I go with my CCS2 car - nice video!

Colin Cogle

GM has announced that they’ll make a NACS-to-CCS adapter available in early 2024. Obviously, it won’t be free — “sorry we backed the wrong horse, here you go!” — but it should work with any CCS vehicle.

Michael Dunn

I share your frustration at being forced to make an account just to use some company's product. A couple years ago, I bought a ticket to a comedy show, and the ONLY way to get the barcode that would get me into the venue was through the ticket seller's app. I deleted the app later, of course, but now some of my data is out there in some database, and I don't know how securely it's being protected.

Ryan Butler

Huge proponent of puppy interludes going forward.

Dre

He kinda covered the problem with trains in a Connextras video about a year ago. But yeah, I vote for a North American public transit rant/video on main channel! Answer in Progress recently posted a decent one recently!

Aleksei Besogonov

Everything is "nice to have", including having a credit card reader. After all, _not_ having it is just a bit of trouble in practice, is it not? And yes, the current choice between proprietary and bad is not great. But it also doesn't have to be that.

MrHammond

Your T-Shirt (cool! :-D) reminds me to tell that my EV runs on 15 kV / 16.7 Hz AC from overhead wire :-P. But I agree from experience with the unnecessary complexity of charging electric cars that there could be a lot of improvement! I also don't understand why this couldn't become the core business of the oil companies that run the gas stations nowadays, it would be a way for them to secure their future, but no, they stick with their poisons...

The 8-Bit Guy

I like the idea of Plug and Charge. Not for convenience as much as for reliability. As you stated, the biggest problem is getting over the hurdle of activating a station because the screens, credit card readers, and buttons are often broken. Of course, I think it is ridiculous that these stations feel they need large color LCD screens, and then sit them out in the elements. At least gas pumps usually have a canopy to protect them from the sun and rain. Another thing I have to give Tesla credit for, that few people seem to ever talk about. A Tesla will start charging almost immediately upon plugging in. With a CCS car, you have to fiddle around with the app or credit cards, or whatever, which can take anywhere from 1 to 5 minutes sometimes to get it going. But then to make matters worse, the station will often sit there for up to a minute just communicating or negotiating with the car before it even starts. This can turn an 10 minute charge into a 12 minute charge. That's a 20% difference!

BrandEver

I think that's how it should work too, or at least if you do need to have some kind of account you put credits on, then you should only need one and they should all work with each other. Whatever newfangled stuff they want to try is fine, but the old school payment options should always be an option (including cash at attended stations!)

BrandEver

Credit card readers have become somewhat of a necessity, as any unattended machine that takes cash is basically just a vandalism/theft magnet these days. That's why most vending machines use them now even though they are more difficult to implement, they certainly didn't do it just to make it easier on the customer.

BrandEver

There should definitely be an incentive/rebate program to help people who own CCS cars get adapters. I also wish someone would invent a damn Chademo adapter as well for all the leafs still on the road

BrandEver

Plug and charge will also have problems though, it's still the same problem of two different systems trying to communicate. The only reason it's so reliable with Tesla is because they programmed and control both sides of it. I do think it would be a nice option though. Also if a screen is broken on a charger, it may be worth checking station's app. If it shows that it is otherwise online, you may be able to use the app to activate it without the screen. I've had to do that at EA stations a few times.

Kevin Kostka

I'm glad to see you focus on not completely upsetting the gas station paradigm as part of this. We've had some conversations about that on various platforms and it seems like an obvious solution going forward, since the convenience store isn't just a sideline to the sale of gas. They're a package deal, especially on freeways. I will say, though, if we were to implement a plug-and-charge model for urban charging, the infrastructure would have to exist for that, and would likely be used for fast charging at that point. But I also see that stuff being integrated into existing parking infrastructure, which has fairly robust payment infrastructure. Whether it be being located in ticketed lots, run off of parking meters with apps or card readers, or involve some kind of license plate scanning tech, like the Illinois tolls use, there's not really a huge need to put that in the car either. Most payment problems could be solved by re-using existing car infrastructure to add charging, rather than reinventing the wheel.

Nitron F117

I haven’t used any Plug and Charge interfaces. Are there security checks at the time of the charge? Or do these systems just trust that the user driving the vehicle is authorized to use any stored payment information? If it’s just trusted, that’s going to be a problem for car rental companies… oh look, the underpaid rental return attendant forgot to reset the car’s payment storage, and the previous renter’s info is still here… I guess we’ve got free charging on this trip!

M@trixX

That's unfortunately also one of the cases, when someone had to decide on a different standard than everyone else and now it's too late to do anything about it.

Colin Cogle

That plug doesn’t speak the CCS protocol. Adapting would be harder. Fortunately for them, I still see plenty of CHAdeMO chargers out there.

Colin Cogle

EVgo supports it. I hear they use OnStar to verify the location of GM vehicles during the authentication process, even if the driver doesn’t subscribe to OnStar.

Colin Cogle

But yes, they do warn you to unsubscribe from Autocharge if you’re selling the car.

Ben Waxler

PnC as implemented today, is really just a glorified, albeit way more secure, RFID card. It links to an account setup w/ the automaker for payment and kind of assumes that only the person registered with the automaker will use it. Though on the plus side since it is typically tied w/ the auto, when you sell the car it nukes the certs in the vehicle when the owner removes the vehicle from their auto account.

Arthur Robillard

What, we have to hum the theme song for ourselves?!? :-)

Kadah

The timing on these deals to open up the Tesla charging network to others sooner than what the fed was going to eventually force was fortunate for my business. We had a Supercharging station installed earlier in the year. In the couple months its been online, its usually almost half full during the day, and soon Rivians are going to be able to use it to, and there's some of their Office's near by along with the increasing number of their cars in the county. Walk-in business is going to increase overtime, not to mention the possibly of Tesla wanting to expand their lease to add even more stations, though the current 30+ stalls require almost all of the 4KA service, which already took SCE around 6+ months to bring in that much additional capacity to our heavy commercial and light industrial area.

Within

This was great! Thank you.

Circuitmike

I disagree - I'll take cats over dogs any day! Kitten interludes, please!

Circuitmike

Am I the only one who thinks of the Addams Family theme when I hear the TC outro music?

Circuitmike

Hey, I had totally forgotten about SpeedPass! I had one of those RFID dongles back when that was a thing! It absolutely didn't solve any real problem, but it made me feel like I was living in the future and it WAS faster than paying any other way.

BrandEver

Are you still using ABRP, and do you have a BLE OBD2 to feed live data to it? If so, how well does it work? Can you see much difference from running ABRP without it?