Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Getting back to basics today with an exploration of a thing and how it works. And today's thing works very differently from how I expected!

https://youtu.be/Khp3wb0QMpQ

Can you believe it's under 20 minutes? I know! It's wild!

Anywho, hope you like it! Captions will come soonish, and I'm looking to release this on Saturday.

Files

These common light controls are weirder than they seem

Thumbnail and other fun stuff will come later

Comments

Matthew Lowe

Really enjoyed this one. A little more time on how the photo resistor works would have been good; how light hitting it actually activates it.

Technology Connections

Honestly, I probably would have kept it to something like "its resistance decreases when photons hit it for weird Physics reasons" had I addressed it at all in the script. I deliberately kept scope creep in-check this time, and didn't go down avenues I might typically go. There was even a mystery involving the blue one! I might make a video on Connextras about that

Mike Bird

This explains a behaviour that is a major pet peeve. When I'm driving down a freeway in town at night, I keep seeing light poles turning off. When I was MUCH younger and lived near a freeway, from my apartment I could see these sodium vapor lights (yeah, the orange ones) starting up, getting bright. And turning off. But if heat turns the light off, and they put the module on top where heat from the bulb rises, then it would explain the behaviour. Mounting it on the back end of the fixture, actually on the pole, with the light sensor facing up, would fix it, I think.

ENP

Oh no, I hate to be that guy... but... actually there are a lot of different designs, including microcontroller based ones. I have a Zodion SS6 here that I don't want to open because I need it, but il looks like it uses a TRIAC and a photodiode, so probably a circuitry similar to the one in the night light. From the same supplier there are microcontroller based cells as well. They are used to time the period between sunset and midnight (or whatever programmed) to dim or turn off lights in the second half of the night. They also implement more fancy stuff I'm not familiar with. It's my first comment here and I feel the urge to stress out that I love your well researched videos. I almost feel guilty for being the smart-ass pointing out a detail here. Keep up the excellent work!

Technology Connections

Oh, don't feel bad. I was certain there are plenty of more designs out there, I'm just not covering them in this video.

Technology Connections

Most likely those lamps were just at the end-of-life. That's the failure mode of high pressure sodium lamps - it's called "cycling" Essentially, as they age the voltage required to sustain the arc creeps up. Eventually it exceeds the supply voltage, but not until the lamp is hot. So when they've worn out, they'll just keep coming on and off over and over again until someone changes the lamp.

Trevin Beattie

I saw a glitch in the video around 17:08 — the screen shows “Media pending” in 10 different languages, followed by a flash of the video upside-down and garbled audio, then the “Media pending” slide again for a few seconds.

Mike Bird

Cool (or rather, hot?). Of course you knew the answer! It's why I subscribe.

CJ

As someone who has worked in Adobe Premiere Pro, it immediately caused a stress response in me, but I realized it was a joke 🤣

Shanester366

One thing that's very convenient with the way these type of switches work is when trying to do troubleshooting you can turn the breaker off wait a few minutes and turn it back on and the lights will come on for a little bit during the day so you can figure out which ones aren't working. A common problem with a lot of the lighting control today is some of the companies make it so that you need to call their techs to service or program it and many maintenance guys will just end up bypassing it

Ryan Hatcher

This is such simple engineering design elegance. Public lighting is typically tied to public safety and for such a simple device, they can be fairly prone to failure. This leads to the condition that folks in the utility industry calls day-burners. Basically, in the absence of a functional photocell, it will run the light constantly until the light fails. Literally, the definition of fail-safe.

Grosporina

I am one of those people. Thanks for the "hysteresis".

Within

My knowledge of electronics is so rudimentary I didn't imagine I could understand something like this. So happy to support you.

For the Birbs (Jim Hooke)

FANTASTIC. Yes I'm shouting. One of my favourite little bits of technology. I happen to have a couple of Tyco branded PE cells tucked away. They are the chunkier but elegant numeral types. I'll send a pic via twitter. The voltage range is not just for International use but a lot of US streetlights can be 220/240 volts. In Australia there's been a move away from single PE cells and banks of lights. On overhead wiring it means they can be spliced into individual phases along the street, load balancing, and removing a single point of failure. Also removes the need for an extra pair of wires being strung. Areas with underground power now have an electrical box and power on separate lines. Utility companies have found out the hard way that the Chinesium PE cells are failing very quickly as they have caps and relays. Whi'd have thought. Lol. Lots of fittings have the PE on bottom of fitting as there's a little bit of UV protection, but more bird poop protection! Cheers

Jerrad Pierce

Solar cell plus normally closed relay. Done. Maybe a capacitor for hysteresis. But solar cells used to be much more expensive.

Stephanie

Somehow, I’ve had it in my head that all street lights were connected to a power station that uses the sunset and sunrise times to turn on and off the lights. This is way smarter of course! Loved this!

Jeremy

I did not know that there was a pressure campaign for you to say "hysteresis". I am glad you said it, as I do like the term, but I wonder why there was interest in you saying it? It's not *that* sesquipedalian, but the term is certainly a cromulent entry to embiggen a lexicon.

MrHammond

Very interesting thought, it consuming maybe some more power but to make a very simple and robust design... But I wonder if that is still used in modern LED streetlighting, especially the ones which decrease their brightness if nobody is around... Maybe an idea for a next video? ;-)

MrHammond

You remind me of that "word of the week"-action we had in one of my study-internships: every week somebody should come up with some difficult, almost impossible-to-pronounce word (and Dutch, not even English where there is absolutely no relationship between spelling and pronounciation - https://monologues.co.uk/004/Chaos-The.htm), print it out in big letters including it's dictionary definition.

Technology Connections

Heh, honestly this is something of an inside joke that only I would get. In the video I made on thermostats, I described hysteresis without actually using the word itself. That led to a lot of comments asking why I didn't call it hysteresis, but from my perspective I'd have to describe the concept anyway as it's not exactly a common word and makes little sense on its own. So, naturally, when it came up again in this video, I described what it is and why it's useful in this application, and simply saying "this is called hysteresis" wouldn't add all that much. However! This time I did actually reference it a second time, so it was worth it.

C222

Story time: Back when I worked at $COMPANY, we gave customers ZigBee gateways to form a mesh network of their end devices in order to gather our required data and send it up to our cloud. All of these gateways and devices shared the same network ID because if one neighbor's device joined another neighbor's mesh, the unique device IDs would all get sorted out cloud-side and it would work out fine in the end. No problem there. One day a customer's gateway just straight up died. Reported 99% CPU, 99% RAM then never checked in again. After a ton of work, I eventually got the gateway connecting to the last-resort OS-level debug platform. After some poking around I found out that the gateway was using all of its resources managing a mesh of hundreds of devices. Turns out, and this is where street lights come in, some other company was selling mesh networked IoT street lights to the city, and they happened to choose the same network ID as us for this specific installation. This customer was connected to ALL of the street lights. The amusing part was, with the exact framework we were both using I could not only use the OS-level debug connection to download and upload our source code to our devices, but any devices it connected to. So I was able to grab their IoT device's source. Unfortunately it was pretty bare bones and not exciting. In the end, I changed the customer's and their neighbors' network ID, which kicked the street lights off the network. TL;DR a customer's product stopped working because $CITY made their street lights smarter than necessary.

Aleksei Besogonov

If you want a clever design, I have one for you! LEDs are also photodiodes, so they _generate_ power when lit. So some of the "light-sensitive" bulbs use the LEDs themselves to detect the ambient light.

Joshua Rouw

I have a fun childhood story regarding streetlights!!! My Dad was an amateur astronomer. When I was around 10 the city put a street light in front of our house. Not good thought Dad! Well he found a plug in laser a laser at Goodwill. He mounted to a tripod and pointed it at the sensor on top of our streetlight and turned it off! After a year or so it started malfunctioning and would always switch on and off. He called the city and they fixed it. Funny thing though. Somehow it malfunctioned again in a year or so.

Technology Connections

This seems sound, but there are two issues that come to mind: First, the LDR responds to very small amounts of light. The switching happens quite deep into twilight in both directions - I don't know if a solar cell could manage that. Secondly, photovoltaic cells wear out, and I'm unsure of the lifespan of a cell small and cheap enough to work in this application. This isn't to say these photocontrols never fail, but they do generally seem quite robust

Alan Medsker

Unbelievable that you said “hysteresis” at almost the exact moment I said it (in my head). Also, is that thyristor not more specifically an SCR (silicon controlled rectifier)? You made me think of Triacs for the first time in decades, too.

Technology Connections

There is apparently some debate on whether SCR is a tradename for a type of thyristor or something unique to itself. Upon seeing that, I just went with thyristor because that's what Big Clive called it when he toredown a nightlight circuit

Alan Medsker

I fell for it and went down the rabbit hold starting at Wikipedia which does indeed make it seem like it was made up by GE. I’d never heard that before and there’s some v interesting history there!

Gaurav Batta

We used one that was super tiny in our Glomensio Firefly, it works well when mounted correctly, but on one unit it did the strobing light thing at dawn/dusk. Was interesting to see you bring that up as design choice consideration in the video.

Gaurav Batta

Also sent you a message 😅.

Buckaroo Bunny Slippers

I would never have guessed that's how those sensor switches work. It's somehow both wildly disillusioning and heartening that at least I can follow the bouncing ball.

Circuitmike

I would have been "that guy" if you hadn't. I know for sure that there are definitely other designs, specifically that lack any hysteresis at all. The way I know this is because I used to be able to turn on and off the streetlight outside my old house with a laser pointer, and it would flick on and off as quickly as the beam would hit the sensor. When you're doing this from 100 feet away with a handheld laser pointer, that happened often, and quickly! I'm sure this did not do any good for the streetlight's longevity (this was years before LED-based streetlights), but I'm sure some bean counter in a county office somewhere saved money in the short term with these things and got an attaboy from their boss for having done so.

Circuitmike

Even without knowing that, I somehow knew that!