Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • dup030124.mp3

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

David brings you the first update of 2024!

  • Manager on Killie win
  • Lundstram on new deal
  • Possible Yilmaz swap?

Today's song is 'I Don't Want To Know' by Fleetwood Mac).

Files

Previews only

Comments

SC81

Yilmaz injury record still concerns me. He looks a very good player but we need to get rid of the players that don't contribute enough games.

That UFO Podcast

A good hour after a shakey opening 30 last night. Let Phil work his magic on the squad during a touch camp with a few new faces in

That UFO Podcast

Ps- anyone saying Shankland isn’t worth £3.5m is just not thinking straight. He could win us a title that banks us £40m + for a new Champs League format. Pays itself 10 times

Gary King

Can we keep Ridvan and swap Barasic for Doig?

Scott Watson

£40m minus bonuses minus what we'd get in the europa league minus the chance we qualify anyway Mortgaging the club's security on "could happen" would be madness regardless of the numbers involved. Those days have to be behind us

Jim McCutcheon

Happy New year David, personally I feel confident for the future of our team under the managerial knowledge of PC 👏 hopefully we keep Ridvan, imo if he can secure a place he can be a success

That UFO Podcast

That’s what football transfers are, we need a striker, the most sensible and obvious option is go and buy a guy who we know scores domestically. ANYONE else we look at would be a gamble. Re-sell value? You can’t guarantee any players re-sell value. So from a pure logic point of view, 3 good seasons out Shankland is the most likely domestic success story we could go for… Otherwise then you are going after far less likely “could happens”

Luke

Thought yilmaz has done pretty well, at Celtic park his defending was decent. He's got energy just need to see it alot more.

Graham Roy

Technically correct however adding a goalscorer in our league is a close to a safe signing as possible. He would realistically add 10-15 goals till end of season that along with Silva could be difference between winning and 2nd!

Gregg

Agree with Scott - all too much hearing we should push the boat out, should have invested when we were on top etc. Give me some prudence - we shouldn’t be overpaying for anyone

Callum Dinnen

There's no guarantees with Shankland. People calling it a no-brainer are just assuming he comes in and will definitely score 15 goals for us in the 2nd half of the season. Yes, he is Scottish and plays his domestic football in Scotland, so there should be little to no risk of him not settling - but being a striker for Hearts and being a striker for Rangers aren't the same. He won't be playing against low blocks and he won't be playing against teams for whom we are their biggest game of the season. He isn't playing with the pressure of our support. There is no guarantee that Shankland will be able to handle any of that. I think he's coming to the peak of his career and I think he'd be a good option to have, but not at the rumoured price. 5 and a half years ago we signed Hearts' top goalscorer cheaply. It was the biggest no brainer of that summer. As a bonus, he had 4 years of prior experience as a Rangers player and had played a big role in 3 title run ins. Kyle Lafferty was a total flop 2nd time around. If Shankland came to us for £4m and flopped, then the same people crying out for us to sign him would be complaining in summer over wasting money.

James Mcgill

Happy new year to all at heart and hand.Beleive in this manager and believe 56 will be delivered

Martin Boyd

Unless Doig has improved massively I would certainly not swap him for Ridvan.

Doogz

If Ridvan could play consistently at levels we have seen in last couple games I would be for keeping him, but his injury record since joining has been poor. As for Shankland I think he will still be a Hearts player as the window closes, don’t see anyone going close to the figures mentioned for a guy that’s 29 on his next birthday.

Stan Templeton

I do not disagree that Shankland would score in our team, but I trust that the Gaffer has a wider knowledge of world football & a less parochial view than most of us armchair managers & as such may well have alternative targets as a strike option. Let's wait & see what he decides & who comes in.

Gary Shaw

Every time I’ve seen Shankland he’s looked bog standard (admittedly not a lot) but I watched the derby and at times he was towing a caravan and breathing out his arse and that’s the way he’s looked on all the occasions I’ve seen him….for those that say”but he’s better than Dessers”,then that’s just not the attitude to have because you could honestly go down to the Championship and take any striker that would probably give you what Dessers does.

Stace1ofthePeople

Genuinely curious why would we swap yilmaz for doig? Are they not very similar type of player? Would it be because both players fancy a move ?

Spoon

For me its pure football snobbery, we all relate to some players more than others but when a guy is doing it in your own league against the teams you will expect him to play against then it seems madness to overlook it. This obsession with what people can’t do or supposed limitations ignores that the idea is you bring a guy in and develop them, they improve alongside better players and as a coach you bring more out of someone. I would also like to think that with improved facilities and sports science you can eke out a bit more physically too. Shanklands value is down played simply as he’s familiar to us, a domestic product and not a fancy import. Having identified a traditional number 9 (who are back in vogue across the big leagues) in Colak we immediately down played his ability to bang in goals, set his limitations and then ultimately binned him as not good enough. Surely the hardest part of football remains putting the ball in the net and the idea is you build around the guys who can do this, supply ammo to them and keep the goals down to win games. Where you can get a natural finisher in they are worth their weight in gold, I have absolutely no doubt that with a proper goal scorer on board in the last OF game we give ourselves a far better chance of winning that. We know have a far better style and structure to feed a goalscorer, we have the wingers, we have the midfield and we have the defence but what we still lack are goals. Until this team has a solid striker giving 15 - 20 goals that the rest can build off we will continue to struggle, we dont score enough goals. Shankland for me is a no brainier even at £4m all the talk of what he isnt doesnt cancel out what he is…..a goal scorer who consistently scores goals. If we don’t get him in he will end up down south banging in goals at a level that will leave us regretting what we could have had. Grabbing a local talent and settling them in is 100 times easier than scouting a guy from half way around the world and hoping the stars align and they kick on.

Ewan White

Don't see the hype with Doig. Isn't a regular for Verona and his injury record isn't much better than Ridvan. Only completed 90mins once this season.

David Innes

If we can’t afford him we shouldn’t buy him but the fact that we can’t afford him is concerning and a damming incident of how badly we’ve done in the transfer market over the last 3 seasons - player trading model my arse

Callum Gordon

Shankland debate goes on , I wonder if there are others who are being overlooked but fill some of the same criteria, my offer as an alternative would be Ryan Hardie , he has gone on from us and learned his craft , gained promotion and is still scoring in a very competitive league , this isn’t a case of going back as he never really got a chance as a youngster . On the left back subject I have always liked Ridvan as he offers so much in an all round package , if there was a chance of a swap deal with Doig I would be looking to still have a sell on clause as I feel Ridvan’s future will be higher financially more so with the league status .

Scott Watson

Absolutely all transfers are gambles - but that's not the same thing as running up a credit card bill that you need silverware to pay off I've no idea if we can afford £3.5m for Shankland or not but the determination of whether we can afford it should be independent of what we do or don't win If you start making gambles that you must win to cover your costs, you are going to get one wrong sooner or later and end up in a vicious circle

Colin Mathie

Bearing in mind im just out of hospital, i had no clue this match was even happening.

Greig Chambers

Happy New year David, For the money for Shankland we could get Miovski, know which id rather have and one has potential sell on and is a better all round player. The Shankland chat is baffling given his age, pace and all round game isnt ideally suited to Rangers especially in Europe. Other strikers are out there.

scott burnett

Totally confused at people's aversion to Shankland. Would come in and score a lot of goals in the league, should be enough to win a title. There are plenty of other strikers but with him the settling in period would be minimal. As for Ridvan, decent player but his final ball is generally terrible, still not the best left back at the club.

Graham Jones

Happy New Year! It’s hard not to see the Doig transfer happening, as it would help with our home grown quota as well. We are very short on that front, and having another player who would play more often than not is a step in the right direction. I think between him and McCausland it would help ease those pressures. The Shankland move will depend on what Hearts are looking for. There are other options out there. I changed my mind on him over the past month because he’s been the reason Hearts are third in the league. I don’t know if he can play in the higher level games or not, but the only way we’ll know is if we buy him and play him. I hear some people saying we should move on, but we simply can’t until we get some answers from the Old Firm game. My trust in the referees has evaporated. I always thought they were simply poor, but the fact they’re hiding the audio just makes it all look suspicious. Conspiracy theorists will be having a field day and the referees only have themselves and their bosses to blame. Release the audio, apologise for a mistake and move on was simple to do. This has become a situation now where public trust is at stake for them, especially with us.

Alan Hendry

Doig is Scottish, marginally younger and more robust. If both are interested put me in the maybe camp. Rather have players here who want to be here. Full faith in our big Belgian magician to do the right thing

Billy Forrester

Doubt we are mortgaging the clubs security on a 3.5 million striker which we desperately require and Shankland is gauranteed to score goals in SPL, something which I’m convinced will win us the title.

Billy Forrester

Sign Shankland you are guaranteed goals in the SPL, it’s a no brainer and will win us the title as that’s all this team lacks is goals from a striker. We will all be on here screaming and moaning come May if the club don’t spend some cash on a striker and we lose the league, I’d say Shankland is a safe bet and worth the spend, not everyone needs a resale value and his goals would pay for themselves

Heart and Hand

There’s been no indication from the club that they’re even interested in Shankland. They will be aware of him obviously but where he is on the list, nobody outwith RFC knows.

Jim Milne

I don't think he is a player that fits into Clements style. Yes he's a poacher, and scores goals.....but he's a Kris Boyd style player for me, and not sure he holds the ball up and tracks back on and off the ball enough for Clement to want him. I could be totally wrong though.

Jim Milne

The sheep add millions to Miovski's price the minute we enquire. We need to start finding the Miovski's of this world ourselves.

Jim Milne

I would keep Ridvan. It's obvious from what Clement and some players have said that Beale had a terrible physical conditioning plan that almost assisted in players becoming injured. That, and his love for Barasic never allowed for Ridvan to get a proper run. Obviously Ridvan has had a few injuries, but he needs a settled run. I thought he snuffed Maeda out at Parkhead. We paid £5m for him, and there is a player there. Bassey was shocking in his first few games until he found his feet and got settled games. We finally have a manager who can give players a chance and confidence, we need to give Ridvan that LB slot for the rest of the season IMO.

Alan Ryder

Am I alone in not wanting Ridvan to leave? Showed how good he is last 2 games. Tries things which don’t always come off but I’d rather that than check back and pass to Goldson

Rona Bluebell

Dear lord, do you ever go on holiday? Was expecting you to be away for a bit.

Callum Dinnen

I like Ridvan lots and I think he has so many positive attributes. He's got far more dimensions to his attacking play than Barisic.

Craig

I went to Tynecastle to watch Hearts v St Johnstone and I can’t see him in a PC team. I also saw him at Firhill a few years ago when he was with Utd and destroyed Thistle - but again - it’s not a Rangers yardstick. Just to clarify - marrying one of them (now divorced) results in Thistle and Hearts supporting kids. But, if they had to choose… No doubts there.

Gary Shaw

Shankland reminds me of the time we were always linked with Lewis Ferguson…I never truly believed that Gerrard wanted Ferguson and I feel Clement isn’t interested in Shankland either….2 Rangers supporting Scottish boys and people are putting 2 and 2 together.