Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

As is being widely reported, Willie Collum lied, and surely cannot continue as a referee. He must be removed.

A Rangers spokesperson said: “Rangers FC today met with Scottish FA officials to discuss the VAR handball call and subsequent miscommunications from Saturday’s Old Firm match.

“From the meeting, there was an overriding consensus the VAR decision of no handball was incorrect.

“Having listened to the audio, there is no mention of a potential offside at the time of the handball decision. Rangers is also deeply concerned at the haste at which the erroneous no handball call was made.

“Rangers has appealed to the Scottish FA to release the audio and explain this decision, and future contentious decisions involving all clubs, to the public, as would be common practice in England for such a decision."

Comments

Robert Deavy

There 2 reasons only that Collum never made the correct decision 1) he cheated pure and simple 2) He was scared of the backlash of awarding Rangers a penalty at the piggery. He suffered abuse before back in 2010:2011 (Broadfoot foul) The hostile intimidation THAT CLUB create from the boardroom may have been on his mind He is only human and was concerned for his family If its number 2 then he need to step forward and tell the truth otherwise it can only be the first one in which case he should resign from refereeing

James duncan

Club have to ask for collum to be removed as a referee

Cal macleod

Collum has to resign , surely !

Ally Cliff

If this was the other way round, collum wouldn’t have any windows left. Every cheerleader would be demanding his sacking

dotty 84

If that prick isn't sacked or resigned then the Club have failed to act accordingly. Cheating bastards.

John Smith

Collum should be sacked if he doesn’t resign. Massive win for the club this 👏

Latimer

It's a blatant case of 'we're not giving them a penalty'. Half time comes, everyone including Lennon says it's a pen, cue panic and rummaging through the footage for another reason not to give it.

Stuart McNiven

This all seems completely above board and normal.

James Mcgill

Totally incompetent at best and a cheat at worst. The rest of that officiating team also need to take a good look at there performances. Especially two 2nd yellows that should have been issued

Stuart cunningham

They will ride it out for few weeks as usual and all will be forgotten about

David whyte

This is disgusting, Collum must be sacked

chris smith

In either case, he didnt apply the laws equally. He made a conscious decision to act for the benefit of one team. Using the word ‘cheating’ is unnecessary.

G Calder

In my opinion - Its number 2 Too much inTIMidation . That doesn’t justify his actions - it means he’s not suitable to be a ref .

Kris

Collum surely must get his jotters now!?

Mike Black

What Celtic have to realise is that their constant intimidation of referees by both the club and it's support is effectively match fixing

Chris M

Time to see it through and ensure he's gone. A cheat with a long history of ropey decisions.

Gordon Millar

No profession, even as a sideline profession, can tolerate dishonesty, mistakes are human, dishonesty is a calculated act. let's see how this plays out, over to you SFA.

Douglas Gilligan

Been saying it for years, Willie Collum is a terrible incompetent referee, he makes the game all about him, even when not refereeing. I also genuinely believe he is a cheat and deliberately and wrongly gives decisions against Rangers.

Gary Shaw

It’s human nature that he’s shit himself….the thought of giving us a penalty and in turn,sending off Johnson,has absolutely petrified him….plain and simple….I actually don’t think he’s cheated because it’s too clear to cheat if that makes sense..

Ron

DONT let this drop Rangers!!!

Graham johnston

He was just scared of the consequences of giving a penalty against Celtic. If it was at the other end of the pitch it was going to be given all day long

Bill’s truth

Rangers cannot let this happen. This needs to be the start of the fight back, we press against them every time we are subjected to this type of behaviour.

Craig

Refereeing the occasion and not the match! He’s not even in the stadium yet he shat it! Who would want their house and work called then the windows smashed right enough!

Scott jamieson

Get him binned this is just cheating the game at its finest! Wee rat bastard

Steven L

I’m neither surprised or shocked.

Paul Kerr

Refereed to a different standard by these chumps for years, it's time they paid the price. Should have been given his jotters already.

Craig Armstrong

Would anyone be really surprised to see Collum in the mide for the Hibs or Dumbarton game? I certainly wouldn't. He should be resigning by the weekend as he's really screwed up here whether a conscious decision not to give a penalty and then panicking about how to cover up or if he had realised what a mistake he's made and then gone looking for a reason ot to have given the penalty breathed a sigh of relief at a possible offside and that's then been leaked to Sky. Whatever it is he has no authority to referee anymore

David Fleming

We now need to be strong and carry on until Collum is removed

RfcBazza

The board better be planning more than this.

William Ross

We know the sfa have been sharing the var audio with broadcasters in real time - they have absolutely no justification in not sharing the audio with rangers or indeed allowing it to be released to the paying public

MARK DRIVER

Needs to be sacked, totally unacceptable behaviour

Angus Mackay

Statement is so weak. We never seem to learn.

Craig

Did Collum lie? Or was it someone at the SFA that said it wasnt given for offside, Boyd alludes to that the other day. Collum should be finished for is incompetence.

James Little

I think this is round 1 more to follow

Tom

Isn't this pretty much what we all thought would be the case? How tinpot is this stupid, shitey wee league!

Luke

That good old Masonic conspiracy coming up trumps again? On a serious note; it looks so much worse trying to cover it up 20 minutes later with the offside image. Willie Collum is a cheating cunt and should not be considered a top referee in this country. I agree that the audio should be released but my, oh my, I will not be listening to it. My hatred for that man is already at fucking boiling point and think that would probably tip it over the edge.

douglas easton

Can’t say this has come as a surprise. He is a terrible ref and has either cheated or allowed himself to pressured into not giving it by their intimidation towards refs. Either way he should resign or be sacked

Colin

What a pathetic response from our club we should be going for the lots of them and demanding heads and going down the legal route to get rid of them and calling it out as cheating

George Higgins

Saying he lied is quite a jump. Got it wrong yes. Rest not so clear.

Niall MacKay

Wow, so what we've been told is enough for us to be confident in releasing that statement. If the SFA can't even defend their guy as a 'yeah, he made an error' then I can only assume that makes the audio even worse than you can imagine. We've got signed and sealed proof of conspiracy against us in these games. It's incredible how these things always come out eventually. Let's be hearing the VAR from September's game now, please.

Ronnie Mora

Explosive, but not surprising. SFA are bent as bananas. We all know it

Brian Rae

What about the performance of the ref? Do you think the club has brought that to their attention? Allowing a player to play on with a bloody nose, 2-3 2nd yellows that were ignored etc. The whole thing stinks and Collum has now lost any credibility he ever had but, I bet they allow him to resign rather than drawing attention and sacking him.

Sandy Fraser

This is too weak again from the board. No wonder this shit keeps happening. This is a chance to get collum sacked and at the very least cause another ref strike. The last time they got a ref sacked and everyone scared to make a decision against them for years to come. Bitterly disappointed in the board.

Heart and Hand

He changed his story. He said no penalty then 30 minutes later sent Sky the still and told them it was denied for offside, when it hadn’t been. That’s a lie.

Jim Milne

It's also cheating. He willfully cheated the integrity of the game by lying to cover up his clear bias.

Latimer

Collum is taking the focus off Walsh performance, he's every bit as culpable. Hope the board are pushing this also.

Jim Milne

I get our board has to be careful in the wording of every statement from a legality standpoint, however we will likely never have a better opportunity to go for the jugular on a clear matter of bias refereeing towards an opponent of ours. I would hope privately they have told the SFA that Collum should resign with immediate effect. This is worse than the Dougie McDonald incident IMO.

Graham Jones

This puts every decision he’s ever made into question, and it casts a shadow over the rest of them. We now have to ask real questions about why Celtic didn’t;t get reduced to ten men. If he can blatantly lie about the handball incident, then his other decisions have to be questioned. That was not a game we should’ve lost all things being considered. 5this is a side who went and beat areal Betis in their own backyard, when Real Madrid couldn’t do it. That was involving foreign referees who are free from being told there’s a Masonic conspiracy, so maybe we need to look at employing good foreign referees if ours don’t match up.

David Millar

Do we have confirmation that it was Collum himself, rather than some other SFA VAR liaison type functionary for example, that sent Sky the still? In a way I hope it was the latter as that points to and proves a conspiracy, there being more than one SFA contracted person involved.

Alex M

And thats probably where it ends with the SFA. Id love to know who was doing VAR when the actual VAR was busy looking for the offside. I wonder if any other decisions were "missed"

KennyY

And that hits the nail on the head and precisely the reason why refs don’t rule against them. How many other clubs petrol bomb their CEOs house with his family inside.

Conor Brown

Still wonder how the fuck he survived sending Lundstrum off for a professional foul last year. Conveniently the game before VAR came in.

Ian Milne

The SFA have apparently already refuted the contents of the Rangers statement saying that was not the version of events as the saw it 🤦‍♂️

David Scott

Its out and out corruption he directly changed the potential outcome of the game.

Billy McCormack

That's a sacking surely, he cannot continue after this we could've got something out of that game on Saturday, so this also has to bring into question why the media, ceptic board and their pedo fans are allowed to put pressure on the refs, they're too scared to make the right decisions and they're getting away with it.

William Ross

Some of the things they are doing directly and at their behest got juventus in serious trouble

Jimmy Price

He lied and tried to cover it up! He has to go! If not it’s corruption!

Danny

And now the SFA say we’re talking shite. We can’t just let this one go, unless we’re happy with the status quo forever. The cabal needs outed and destroyed. All we want is fairness and an even playing field. (The scum being turned into an Asda would be a bonus though)

Alexander Laird

We now simply HAVE to demand that he either resigns or is sacked. We should not stop there tho'. Walsh has to be demoted as clearly he is at best incompetent - either that or he never again is involved in any match involving Rangers FC.

Calum Robertson

Sacking Collum doesn't fix the problem. If a mistake was made in your workplace I would expect manager's to provide extra training, clearer instructions and monitor future performance. That's what will probably happen here. Rangers should be thanked by other teams for forcing this issue. Others might now request or demand listening to audio of dodgy VAR calls The bigger question is why have referees doing VAR duties. Referees have a clear role in football but VAR is new. You need the best people for the job - employ them!

Gregg

The guys who do var are referees assisting the on field referee via video. They have to be referees no? Maybe working the tech or what not the get help but no sure this is the issue. Could be wrong

LD

As with all things, it's the coverup that'll get you

Mr J K Murray

this in his 40s deceitful saville of a ref, could not believe my eyes, vatican assisted ref position is unatainable, the audio has been listen too and this seems to be the case, are they giving grace to the two refs to make announcements concerning this, as both invoved in this visually manured situation, in taking the orginal art and putting a forgery in its place, quality' heist, der vault, slight of whisles' , both cohorts needed their bottoms smacked, one birched,

Buff Richardson

It’s not the mistake in not awarding a penalty, it’s the trying to manufacture an offside decision that wasn’t checked , it’s the lies that get you in the end ..

Angus Mackay

I thought earlier that Rangers statement was weak. I now actually believe they’ve played this very well tonight.

David Clapperton

In all honesty I don’t want to think refs are cheats. In this case i believe Collum is an arrogant wee prick that in his own mind can never be wrong so felt he had to find a way, any way no matter what, to prove he didn’t get it dramatically wrong. As soon as that goal kick was awarded it was never about the correct outcome, it was always about how to prove he wasn’t wrong. To him the game in that moment and right up until the second they found the offside, didn’t matter. I would bet any money that when that offside was found he celebrated as if he’d scored the winner in the World Cup final.

Tamus

Rangers Board grow some f**king balls please, stop being toothless tigers. Call him a liar and demand him sacked

William Hughes

Did anyone really expect to get an even crack with Walsh, Clancy and Collum involved in the game v them? These individuals are incapable of refereeing Rangers fairly. Does any Rangers fan think if that penalty incident happens at the other end we're discussing this? Time and again we're on the wrong end of these decisions v them - the last 3 meetings tells you that. Time Rangers pushed for a change. It's long overdue.

Calum Robertson

Football could learn from Rugby Union where referees and VAR officials are miked up. TV viewers by hear referees direction to players and full discussion between VAR and referees. The idea of VAR is to improve decision making, so why only give the discussions to Sky. Football needs to do better

John Palmer

Football refereeing acts like it's above the Law. In a Court of Law, the defedant and plaintiff are allowed to request all transcripts of their case, this is also the same if you are involved in a workplace dispute, you're entitled to see everything that has been recorded either via tape or written word. Football continues to be corrupt.

Robert White

David. He's been a professional referee, at least paid as such, for many years. He watched, as we all did, as the Celtic fullback punched the ball out to stop Sima bearing in on goal from 6 yards. It was a penalty. It was a booking and red card. Collum knew this. His only job was to refer this to the referee. He cheated instead. Knowingly. FIFA needs to investigate the rancid smell from Hampden.

KennyY

It’s a very strange response from the SFA. What’s in it for Rangers to report incorrect details of the meeting. Are we to assume that the hatred against us in Scotland isn’t just contained to newspapers, journalists, television commentators and the SPFL but also to the SFA. If they were to hold their hands up and say yes it was a genuine error by the referee then it’s broadly acceptable but to say that it wasn’t a handball and wasn’t a penalty is blatantly untrue. It looks as though the cartel runs much deeper than any of us thought. These are the type of decisions that cost league titles. Playing against 9 or possibly 8 men on Saturday makes it a completely different game. It can’t just be Rangers fans that see this week in week out.