Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Okay... how do we track animals in the rainforest? Acoustically? Apparently! The Nature Conservancy's Dr. Eddie Game does this *as a job* and we'll sit down and lob your questions at him on Wednesday. 

Here's more on his work, too: 

https://scholar.google.com.au/citations?user=0sn9Dv4AAAAJ&hl=en

https://twitter.com/eddiegame

Fire away,

The Alie of Ward

ps: Also dropping tonight: an episode of all of your life hacks! They're so good, people.

Comments

RJ Doidge

So…if an animal shits in the rainforest…….can we hear it?

Jeffrey Bradshaw

Do most animals in a loud environment like that have better hearing than humans?

Mia Manzer

Are mammals such as dolphins, whales and bats, who use echolocation technically using acoustic ecology?

Julia Fisher

What are the measurement limitations?

Specs Owl

I would like to know this too, because I've seen conflicting info about this from really knowledgeable naturalists

Joe Mueller

How do you pick out the correct call that you’re trying to find in the cacophony that can be heard in the forests?

Mia Manzer

Do you think humans will be able to develop something like echolocation naturally?

Lene Olszeth

Does Dr. Game have a favourite forest sound?

Levi Stoyles

Can an animal of one species understand other species noises? Like I know that humans cannot understand dogs but can dogs actually understand us? Or are any other animals able to do this?

Timmy H.

How to feel less shitty about the world losing rainforests??? 😭

Specs Owl

Are you inspired by the work of Chris Watson, and will you ever make nature sounds into avant garde music? Can we ever know exactly what an animal is hearing, and if so, do they hear things exactly the same as we do?

Noel Dietz

How sensitive is the equipment you use? Like, can you hear all the insects and arachnids that are walking around near you? 😱

Chris Lipford

FTQA! 1) To what degree is AI or machine learning involved in deciphering recorded audio into useful information? 2) Has there been any thought or work done regarding air-dropped acoustic sensors to enable monitoring of extremely remote areas that would be much harder to access via ground paths? (There’s precedence for this in war to detect tanks/vehicles/soldier foot traffic. I’d love to see the technology put to a more wholesome use!)

Stacy Litwin

***First time question ask-er, long time supporter. I have a feeling this will already be covered, but I still need to ask, how do loud city environments affect calls between species, especially in terms of mating and continuing this species? Also I feel like this is going to be covered so don't feel pressured to mention me lol, but can we do anything to counteract the damage done by urban noise?

Specs Owl

I remember hearing that urban birds like blackbirds and robins have learnt to sing and call louder and clearer than their rural relatives - has this been shown to have a negative impact on their life, breeding, or survival rate?

KellyTheNatureNerd

How did this career path go for you? Did opportunities fall in your lap or did you have to seek them out? Were you sure of what you wanted to do from the beginning or was it a process of self-discovery? I was once told that most people don’t choose their specialty, it just happens to them. Also, your research seems interdisciplinary, do you find it challenging to decide what you’re interested in researching next or are your project topics provided for you? Do you feel like there are a lot of opportunities out there in your field? Asking as an anxious graduate student who’s interested in a wide range of ecology, conservation topics and likes to keep as many doors open as possible. -Kelly

Specs Owl

Oh, and which animals have been known to respond, or prefer specific types of music over others?

Joe Porfido

What are the changes in day noises vs nightly noises? Are there certain groups of animals that dominate accoutically at different times?

Batman Flight

Are you using machine learning to detect different species? I am a Chiropterologist and there have been great improvements in auto ID of bat species lately (it'll put me out of a job soon!)

Hannah Thorpe

If you set up monitoring devices in a certain location, can you tell how far away an animal is from the device by the frequency of its call?

Batman Flight

When have you been surprised by the sound that an animal makes? Like, were you recording a sugar glider and when it thought no-one was listening, it starting parping like a German Oompah band or something!?

Holly Hoag

Can the prey of animals that use echolocation ever feel the sound waves and know that they are being hunted??

Batman Flight

How far does sound travel in the rainforest? Do any of the animals use infrasound to send their message further?

Batman Flight

What is the best sound you recorded and why is it bat social calls? 😜

Alyssandra Goss

Which animal is the most difficult to track acoustically, in your experience?

Deacon Raid

Yes! Some of the software is getting damn impressive. Wildlife Acoustics EchoTouch is very cool.

Meghan McLean

How do you tell a real animal call from the call of an animal that mimics other animal calls?

Deacon Raid

I read a paper once about playing bird calls to sample for specific species since the birds respond to the sounds of conspecifics. In one case, the speaker had been attacked by a margay after it played a call. What sort of tampering has occurred with their equipment by the wildlife?

KellyTheNatureNerd

Any preliminary results on your current study you can spill for us?

Beth Peluse

(First time question asker) - what's the biggest surprise you've experienced when listening back to a recording?

Deacon Raid

I went to an online seminar about using AudioMoth set ups recently. Checking out some passive recording options for presence/absence surveys in structures is at the top of my list for NASBR

Alannah Wood

How much does noise pollution mess with whale and dolphin calls? Do fish communicate with noise? How far can that noise travel? How much does visiting a reef disturb it noise wise? (Also how long do I have to visit the Great barrier Reef before it's well no longer great? My trips north keep getting cancelled)

Batman Flight

Derrick, was that Nils Bouillards webinar?

KellyTheNatureNerd

What are the weirdest, coolest, cutest, or most eerie sounds you’ve heard?

Matt Thompson

Dumb question, how do you record underwater acoustics? Also, what animals sound the most like humans?

Aoife Holmes

Maybe this is off topic but I imagine that the equipment must be REALLY expensive especially for the quieter or underwater animals? How much is the equipment for the fanciest stuff? 😅

Aoife Holmes

Are your ears SUPER fine tuned now to sounds?

Jessi

I also wonder this. And related question: Are you now really good at imitating sounds?

Antonia Clark

Whales are obviously talking to each other. When will we be able to speak whale? Also, are fish using sounds to communicate?

Victoria Pfeifer

How much negative interference does noise pollution cause on wildlife, and how can we help limit it?

Leigh

Ecology in general is so cool and I can't wait to hear about this topic that I did not know existed 5 minutes ago!

Ben W

What’s with prairie dogs? Do they really have different calls for different predators?

Paulina Krasińska-Sroka

What about birds that mimic sounds of other birds or even human-made noises? How do you distinct one from the other? I live in the city and I swear I heard starlings honk like a car and bark at my dog!!

Jessi

Is there a standard way to describe sounds scientifically? Like, are there words everyone agrees on to describe what something sounds like?

Brittney Corrigan

In the rainforest, is it more advantageous for baby animals to call for their parents when in distress (and thereby give away their location to possible predators, as well?) or to remain silent?

Chris Moore

1. Please tell us about grasshopper mouse super sonic calls! 2. What is known about plants’ and other non-animals’ abilities to respond to and make sounds? 3. How much of Nature’s sounds are imperceptible and therefore not given proper praise or scientific attention? TY ☺️

Earl of Greymalkin

1) How different do various ecosystems sound like? If you had to assign a musical genre to ecosystems you know, what would they be? 2) What are the weirdest or spookiest things you've heard in your data? Ever heard any ghosts screeching in the night? 3) How much can acoustic data tell us about insects living in the area? 4) Do you ever bait animals with sound to see if they call back? 5) What kind of information do you get form acoustic data sets versus things like trail cams? How do these compliment each other? 6) Is anyone doing this kind of work in urban environments? 7) Where do you want to go gather data the most that you've not been able to yet? 8) How many mics do you set up and in what arrangement? Is it possible to track particular animals or groups across space?

Mallory Nettleton

What are the effects of noise pollution for urban area on the ecosystems within them ? What an interesting ology!!!

Jess Swann

Definitely curious about this - but also, does noise pollution create change the tone or pitch (or... melody?) of animal sounds instead of just the volume?

Jess Swann

I saw something about how a study on prairie dog sounds has been able to distinguish between the sound warning of a human in a yellow shirt vs warning of a human in a red shirt. Is that for real, and have we determined that super detailed level of understanding about any other animals?

Jess Swann

Very interested in this as well!

Jess Swann

Oh, I would LOVE to know this!

David Ruscalleda Gómez

What's the impact of noisy infrastructure (airports, busy roads) in animals that depend on sound for mating? Do they somehow addapt to those noisy surroundings? Do they just reproduce less?

Jessica Arend

What is the best way for a layperson like me to look up the sound of an animal I’m hearing? Is there an app for that?!

Jessica Arend

First time question asker. Last name is pronounced “errand”!

Jessica Arend

I’m interested to hear, along these lines but more generally, how sounds or calls of animals have evolved across time/different contexts

Jessica Arend

Are there any non-animal species that make communicative, interpretable sounds? Like… plant calls?

Sh4rkH4ts

Are there any animal calls that are better produced by human mouths than by technology or tools? How do we tell what sounds Dinosaur vocal chords produced?

Meryl

Tell me more about what happened when shipping was shut down in the North Atlantic during COVID and everything went quiet.

Kim Hamlin

Let's say, hypothetically, you and some buds were walking around lookin' for salamanders in the middle of the night and after 30 minutes of walking in the desolate woods, you finally see a bat acoustic recorder strapped to a tree you've passed five times. Did you and your buds ruin that evening's recording or did you give the researcher a good chuckle once they got the data back? And if you ruined the data, how would you go about paying amends and clearing your soul of the guilt?

Joy Kotheimer

Are you able to tell distinct individuals vocalizing vs variation of one individual vocalizing? Also how much does mimicry blow your mind!! (I mean, Birds don’t even have lips!)

Zoe!

Am I allowed to tell people to shut up in the name of acoustic ecological protection?

Kelly Shaver

Ok what is the deal with plant sounds? Like, do trees really “talk” to each other or is it just resonating with the occasional random noise?

Anna Zimmer

Are there any human-made sounds that help other animals? Like do guitars make dolphins happy? Do high heels make endangered species mate?

Rachel Murdock

how much of a roll does machine learning have in identifying animal sounds? i'm thinking of the sound ID feature on the merlin app for laypeople and the work of Denise Herzing & Thad Starner with spotted dolphin communication

Super_Sara

Can different sounds affect plant growth? One of my students showed me a video from Ikea. They did a study about how plants that were bullied grew less than plants that were spoken kindly to. We felt like this was flim flam to sell furniture.

Celeste Rousseau

Have you ever listened to or studied the sound of a creature who is on brink of extinction or whose since become extinct? I find this notion to be incredibly depressing and yet it is the question I have.

Kate Halloran

Does it annoy you as much as it does me that films will use an Australian kookaburra noise by default for tropical sounding birds regardless of which continent the film is based?

Reuben Clamzo

Are there animals we ONLY know by their calls? Like rare whales or toads or something?

Emily Krieger

what about sonic mimics? like lyrebirds. or barred owls, which sounded just like monkeys or gibbons to me when i was treated to their midnight courtship once in Seattle. how do you acoustically track a trickster if it can imitate other species in the area? or do scientists just not in such cases?

Emily Krieger

lol that's a line from The Shawshank Redemption: "If I so much as hear a mouse fart in here...."

Shelby Reardon

What is the worst sound an animal makes? Is there a deeply irritating, ear-splitting, bone-chilling or just down right awful noise that some poor animal produces?

Rich Pasenow

I would love to hear more about how sound recordings are measuring the recovery of coral reefs.

Robin Kuehn

We know human-made sounds are a huge problem for critters in the ocean. Is it a big issue on land too?

Rachel Kendrick

Does industrialization interfere with data collection? Like if you’re near a road or a more populated area does it effect your data or even how other animals interpret the sounds?

Caitlyn Powell

Is community or volunteer based monitoring an under-utilized strategy in management? What are the major benefits or drawbacks to engaging citizen science in wildlife monitoring?

Caitlyn Powell

What are some of the most surprising things you can learn from acoustic monitoring?

Lizzy Martinez

Baby sloths seem much more vocal than adults. Is that true? And do you have any fun sloth facts?!

Derek Peloquin

I'd love to hear about subsonic and supersonic vocalizations or other animal sounds!

Tom Elias

What types of sounds are out there that we as humans can not hear?

Karlie V

Weirdest sound you’ve ever heard? Coolest? Scariest?

Brittany Green

Can you explain how acoustic ecology is used in the arts?

Brittany Green

How do human noises affect how animals make noises?

Brittany Green

What is the most important piece of technology used in your field?

Cynthia Cinnabar

I just read an article about how orangutans have developed rapidly-evolving forms of slang! Would shifts in what animals are saying have an impact on their acoustics?

Nick Thayer

How has human acoustic ecology changed over the last 100,000 years? Do we know whether/how that impacts human neural development, functioning, etc?

weedyinvasive

How does one get into a career like acoustic ecology? Asking as an audio engineering student with a love for biology

Shannon Ball

Have you tried tracking bats acoustically before? If so, how easy or hard is it to distinguish different species? I've heard visual identification can sometimes be pretty difficult

Christopher Go

Why does the ambient and quiet sounds of nature, like the serene bird chirps or raindrops splashing on our windows, makes us feel so at peace with ourself?

Alice Rubin

What's the difference between the sounds on the ground versus the sound in the canopy in the same place in the rain forest?

Alice Rubin

When you watch movies, do you identify the animal sounds that are out of place for the ecosystem where the scene is located? I. E. kookaburra in the opening of Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Arc when they are supposed to be in S. America.

Stephanie Coombes

Do animals change their vocalizations/sounds in different temperatures? Sound seems so much louder in the cold (like the real deep freeze your snot and eyelashes cold). Do the little critters have to be extra quiet?

Between Dumplings

What do you think of Forest Bathing? Part of its appeal must be immersion in an acoustic memory of ancient times?

Erin Crone

How do animal's calls adapt with urbanization, logging noises, and other human-made ruckus? Are there some species or groups of species that are better at adapting to these things than others?

Kleargle

What do people mean when they say birds (and humans) "throw their voice", and does this make ur job harder?

Kleargle

Noise pollution - what's the deal? How harmful is it//what can possibly done about it?

Alexandre Catulle

Do you have perfect pitch but applied to animal noises?

Alex

This honestly sounds like my dream job! I've been studying auditory neuroscience for a few years but have lately been thinking of pivoting to conservation. Any advice for getting involved in the field?

Alex

Also, are there any open access banks of endangered soundscapes that one should check out?

Willow Hall

How are you able to separate all the different calls in a given environment? I just started birding and I struggle to differentiate two bird calls in relative silence. Is there a certain trick or method you use to accomplish this when in a chaotic environment?? Ps so excited to learn about this ology!

Nikki DeMarco

Does human expansion of residential areas impact your work? Like, hearing cars or city/suburb type noise.

Nancy Anderson

Question (above) came from mutual friend of Dr. Game who has since retired.

Hannah Boyd

First time question asker! How much of rainforest chatter is actually occurring ultrasonically or at frequencies that the human ear can't detect?

Kent Durvin

Many common birds have several common calls. Has anyone figured out what they mean?

Cerulia Avila Red

We know there are lots of mimics in the visual world between different animals, insects and plants but does this hold true for sounds across species or types of life forms?

Miranda Panda

Are there animals you have heard but never seen before?

Stephanie Leské

Oh!!!! Very excited to heat this interview. I would like to think that I can come up with a sensible question but I'm gonna come clean..on more than one occasion I've been at a local farm park which have tapirs...but everytime I would go they would be in their beds. So through my frustration the next time I went I played videos of tapirs to coax them out. I've done this several times with Highland cows in nearby fields with varying degrees of success... so my stupid question is this.. can animals tell you're playing a recording & are just standing there thinking what a dumbass you are. I have also used this technique to try teach my greyhound to roo. He responds to some and not others so I'm worried since I don't speak greyhound what if I'm playing him harmful content?

Megan Cook

Animal calls are great and all … but have you ever been out in the field and you hear Big Foot coming at you and it turns out it was actually just a robin rustlin’ leaves? Put differently, why are some innocuous sounds amplified in the woods ?

Garvey’s

First time question asker! What is your favourite animal sound

Nathalie Jones

I wonder about this kind of thing pretty regularly... How often ecologists/biologists discover something and hear back from Indigenous peoples that they've known about this for millennia. I feel like this is 100% applicable to animal tracking in particular. (1st time question asker!)

Nathalie Jones

Ooooh I like this. Especially since I listened to the spider dancing episode recently!

Patricia Brewster

So many birds mimic other birds and animals. How do we really know what we are hearing is correct?

Patricia Brewster

I can never find where to give you ideas for shows, so I'm just gonna put it out there. You would be the first for sure. No-see-ums! What are they? Why do they leave volcanos on your head? Why do they itch like HELL? Why do they go for your ears and around your eyes? Why do they seem to live in gravel? These little bastards no bigger than a pin head can send you right over the edge!! I have never been able to get answers to these questions.

Kate Purple

Second time asker question, but I didn't know to say "first time" last time. Plus you didn't read my comment, so it's essentially my first comment. Here's a question.. or like 5? 1. How do you keep recording equipment dry in the rainforest? 2. Is it difficult to subtract all the insect buzz from the background (not that insects aren't important to listen to as well)? 3. Is there a lot of anthropogenic interference in your location? Does the story of US air force planes disrupting frog breeding translate to any of your work? (I can't remember if that work was upheld.) 4. How much do you listen and how much of it is the computer extracting the data and spitting out a species list? 5. Can you ID individual animals? And track their movements? That would be so cool. "Oh hey, Sally the ape is on the move again. And ooo, she's mad at Phil again." Non-human primate drama, good times.

Average_pi

How do they not confuse the sounds of animals I mean I confuse the sounds in my backyard 🙃

Molly Lynch

First time question asker here! With song-learning birds, does anthropogenic noise (like road noise, construction, etc) cause changes in the adult's song? Are there any differences seen in urban vs non-urban populations of the same species?

Avren Keating

Yes! What is the best app for us to use? My husband Digby wants to know (he uses he/him pronouns).

Barbara

Sending you love and best wishes for your father and family. Keep smoking the bees, Alie.

Natalie Gertz -Young

What is your relationship to music? Did a love of music early on lead you to this field? Also look into Dr. Lisa Rainsong. She is a music theory professor and natural history educator that studies the songs of birds, amphibians and insects. She is so cool.

Specs Owl

I have an example of this, although its not a full answer of course! Many species of birds will respond to the alarm call of a blue tit! they'll fly away in a panic of they hear it, even if they're a completely different species!

Ellen Fierer

Hi! First time question asker. I teach high school environmental science. More and more, I have students who are trying to figure out what they can do in the biz so to speak. So I’m curious about what your journey was to becoming an acoustic ecologist in the rainforest?? Want to share with mi kiddos. Also, I’m curious about how you go about isolating the sounds to determine exactly who you are hearing. What specific tools are used? What about organisms that don’t make sounds? How do we keep track of them? Lastly, do you take enthusiastic, passionate citizen scientists along in your field work (asking for a friend-who are we kidding, it’s me! Pick me!).

Megan Westervelt & Josue (Yoshi) Arteaga-Torres

I just discovered a new idol in Science of my area of study!!! As a Conservation Scientist, what has been your greatest challenge at the moment of translating the science to practice?

Carrie Cimo

Hi Alie! You're amazing, and I love you! Question(s): Where is the quietest place in the world? What impact are human inventions like planes and cars having on wildlife communication? Have animals begun evolving their calls to mitigate other sound interference? Do significant changes in noise level (louder or quieter) in an environment (human caused or not) affect an animals fecundity? What was the most confusing / amazing / perplexing sound you've heard in the jungle? Thank you for all you do!

Matt Glenn

Hey Alie! First time asker, but I’ve been loving your work for months now 😊. Field recording has been a huge passion of mine for the past decade and has made me keenly aware of just how much anthropogenic noise can disturb natural sonic ecosystems. I know that so much of that noise is created by transportation, infrastructure, and large industrial sources that are beyond our control, but how can we do our part as individuals to minimize disturbance of the sounds of natural ecosystems?

Patrick W

Long-time listener, first time questioner: in the early months of the pandemic, what did we learn about the sudden quietness and how it affected ecosystems?

Ella Shively

How does acoustic monitoring work in areas with a lot of echo? Also, what's the weirdest sound you've heard in the rainforest?

Charlotte Fjelkegård

Ooooh, this is a great question and now I simply must know the answer!

Kelsey lore

Hey Alie! First time questioner here! Are there any animals who have had to change the way they communicate because of urbanization or any other circumstances?

Kaitlyn Gahl

Resources and advice for people trying to go into the conservation technology field? Technology for conservation and ecology is advancing quickly, but it is still so difficult to find tech specific degrees, funding, and professionals. Any hot tips? (asking for an engineer turned ecologist)

Kaitlyn Gahl

First time question asker! <3

Reiley Allison

Howdy, this topic is pretty cool. First heard about it a few years ago on another Podcast. Glad you are doing an episode now! My question: Have you heard bigfoot? Is there a range of sounds? ALso second question, impacts of human activities on ecological sound? ALso, as a sensory sensitive autistic individual, why is it that loud noises from cars, music, people, etc. creates great anxiety, while "natural" sounds of the same pitch are quite soothing and can calm me?

Trinaty

Long time listener but I just joined Patreon! yay! can you PLEASE talk about how scary birds are that can mimic our voices and stuff? it’s horrifyingly cool!

Jules Kingsland

I need to know is it flimflam that billy apes are a mixture of chimpanzees and gorillas and how do you track them if they are so hard to find and one more is climate change affecting the tools you use to track these rainforest animals.

Hayley Aronson

Are there more challenges in placing acoustic receivers in a rainforest versus an aquatic environment or do you have a mobile form of receiver? I think I've seen a backpack form, but are they able to use drones these days?

Hayley Aronson

Not really about tracking, but I've read playing recorded sounds of a productive coral reef can attract larval creatures to settle in an area. Is this something that can be utilized in replanted forests?

Jerald Pratt

I've heard about projects that use old cell phones to record audio in the wilderness. Is that still happening? How does the phone recording get turned on/off to perserve the battery?

Jeanette-o-saur

How often do you recommend Kitten Mittens to people who are tired of listening to their cat stomp around the house?! (Sorry not sorry)

Jeanette-o-saur

"That bird stole my identity!" - Brian Fellows

Jeanette-o-saur

ok, real question. I listened to a podcast a while back on endangered butterflies that were thriving in a missile test zone, so I'm curious if there are any cases where anthropogenic sounds have actually had a positive effect on an ecosystem or species.

Carrie Leigh

First time questioner. 🥰 How does human noise affect the study of acoustics in the wild? Are there any places that are truly still "quiet" or without noise pollution?

Isaac Raabe

I have a bunch of starlings that are the constant chatter in my yard. I also notice they have taken a liking to my gutters with gutter guards over them and hear them scurrying inside it now and then. Their chattering sounds are peppered with computer/ cell phone noises and are amazingly similar to those. During my morning walk I also hear woodpeckers all over the neighborhood getting their days started. I have seen a couple banging on metal lids and that just makes me laugh, but I wonder if it is their communication going on

anthony willis

how can someone as an adult or even as an activity for children get to participate in acoustic ecology experiments?

Some Random Frog

First time question asker here! What exactly is noise pollution?

Popita

Is there any animal that cannot be tracked through sound. Certain animais don’t make noises, like butterflies. Do you have special equipment to detect wing flaps or footsteps?

Kelsey Shaner

first time question asker ! :) i like talking and singing to my plants for fun, but i've always wondered: is there any definitive correlation between plant growth and noise/music?

rhianna leigh

FINALLY i’ve been waiting for this episode for forever and ever. i hope i’m not too late to ask because this one is so important to me :’) i have been so interested in acoustic ecology through Bernie Krause and Gordon Hempton for many years and it’s what drove me to make the music i am making (and will be releasing in 2022 hopefully) that incorporates biofeedback, my field recordings, and collected sounds. i have wondered for many years HOW do you get into the field of acoustic ecology / bio acoustics? where and what do you study, how do you find mentors, how do you know what gear to get. it’s so niche that it seems very hard to get to and i also haven’t seen many people my age or women as leaders in the field. i would love love to work under someone and learn the ropes more than anything 🤍🤍🤍