Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Ahhh, yes. Dr. Amy Kirby is a leader in the field of... detecting epidemiological spikes via public wastewater. GENIUS. Gross. But genius. 

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/communication/responder-stories/wastewater-surveillance.html 

Can you even? I cannot even. Leave questions for her below!

Shuddering but grateful,

Your Dad

Comments

Joe Mueller

Why is it that when driving past a treatment plant there is no odor?

Timmy H.

Can I flush cat poop?

Brooke Fitchett

What’s up with the water on Native American reservations?

Alyssandra Goss

How much do microbes help clean wastewater? I’ve heard of their use, but would like to know more!

Jules Kingsland

Why is waste waste water so flipping gross 🤢

Amy Narimatsu

I work for an environmental nonprofit and water quality is a huge part of our work. We test for bacteria and other nasty stuff and publish our findings. In your experience, what's the best way to communicate this data, particularly for the general public/those that may not understand the language and results of our tests?

Christi Sullivan

Who was the person who said "hear me out, I've got a good idea" and the sentence ended with collecting and analyzing wastewater.

Diana Teeter

Can you tell from wastewater tests if the pathogen you find has human origin or animal origin? If not what further sleuthing needs to be done?

Specs Owl

The Isle of Man didn't have a sewage system until the 1970s. How come the the hundreds of thousands of people who flocked to Blackpool Beach every summer, didn't all die of E Coli or something?

Specs Owl

Is it true that seabird numbers decline when sewage becomes treated instead of just being dumped at sea raw?

Moses Cabrera

Not a question (first time commenter) but I fell in love with biology when I went on a wastewater science fieldtrip in high-school and the laboratory leader was a biochemist and showed us all the micro-organisms in our water 💖now I'm a biochemical student

Matt Thompson

What diseases can live out the longest in the wastewater?

Alexis Luxion

How did we figure out that you can test waste water for disease? How has this impacted cultures around the world? What diseases can we not currently testing for that we’re working on? What’s the scope of things we can learn from this type of testing?

jay

Why flush waste when the sawdust toilet is dry, odor-free, and generally saves the earth at every turn?

Specs Owl

There sure is an odour when you're walking past one or live downwind of one

Nicole Howley

What would happen if you ran through the sprinklers that use grey water?

Leigh

Does Dr. Amy Kirby look at diseases in animals living in the environment, other than humans?

Alia Myers

Do we regularly test waste water for disease? Is this a common practice for detecting outbreaks?

Emily Tudorache

Can you only detect pathogens spread through contact or fluids or are there ways to track something like an airborne pathogen through waste water as well?

Bonnie Flint

Do the older variants completely disappear from waste water or does there continue to be a detectable amount even as wave of new variants come through?

Specs Owl

How do SUDS work?

Ali Vessels

Wastewater testing seems to have become a really useful tool during the COVID pandemic. Is there a chance that the wastewater could be flowing in from other sources, other than the locality it's associated with? How does this data differ from standard testing data (i.e. rapid or PCR testing) in terms of evaluating community levels?

Leigh

This may be a dumb question, but what are common diseases that are caused by wastewater?

Katie Wood

First, huge thank you to yourself and all people who work in wastewater. My question is: what’s the deal with hormonal birth control and waste water? How does it affect the living things in waste water and does it affect living things in the greater aquatic ecosystem?

Specs Owl

Also how do drugs (prescribed or not) that we've taken and end up in the waterways, affect the environment?

Hannah Thorpe

How different are wastewater treatment plants in small towns compared to large cities?

Bonnie Flint

Can virus survive and be transmitted after waste water is fully treated?

RJ Doidge

I feel like there’s a joke in there somewhere related to “running water;” you can run, but you can’t hide. Let’s workshop that before the ep.

Lina Zikas

This might be a silly question but how do they pick which microorganisms they use in the treatment process? Do they have to grow them? So curious!!!

Bonnie Flint

Are plans in the works anywhere to make this a more permanent activity, testing for various pathogens like flu virus, etc?

Kristen robb

(First time question asker :) ) I study textile print, I was wondering how much textile dye run-off effects water systems. Thank you :)

Charlotte Fjelkegård

How big samples are needed for an accurate reading? (Water volume and amount of pathogens in ths water.)

Mallory Nettleton

Weirdest/most surprising thing you've seen in the water while testing?

Quincey Robisheaux

Are there any chemicals or measures that can taken to prevent disease spread through wastewater?

Madam Strange

I’m in Milwaukee and we produce Malorganite fertilizer from our waste water system. I sort of understand the process, but also not at all. What’s happening and are other cities doing something similar? Should they be? Thanks! Excited to hear the show.

Scottie

How common is wastewater monitoring? Is it just in big cities? Should we be advocating for it to happen in our hometown?

Meghan McLean

How are the, err, samples collected? Forgive the imagery but is it in one big slurry or more of a Lucile-Ball-at-the-chocolate-factory type situation?

Kelsey lore

Can you use grey water for accurate reads on these kinds of tests as well? Or exclusively black water?

Scalebar

Is anyone doing monitoring of changes in bacteriophage populations in sewage? I wonder if sudden shifts would tell us anything about population health

Mariah Buckner

Firstly, thank you Dr Kirby and everyone else taking wastewater samples. I feel it’s the only reliable metric for places that have had less than robust mitigation strategies (outside of hospitalizations). Can the particular covid variants be identified in these samples? For places with storm water joining with waste water, could there be too much dilution in a sample to have an accurate picture of viral load if the sample is taken after a period of heavy precipitation? *FTQA

Reese

1st time question asker, At one point there was a bunch of hooplah about birth control hormones and metabolites from opiates making it through water filtration and back into our drinking water. The theories ranged from crazy (the cause of the increased "fematization" of men and more gay folks) to credible (exposure to subclinical levels of opiates in drinking water during development could be a cause of rising opiate dependence/tolerance). Any credence to this? Or utter flimflammery?

Lizzy Martinez

How do they make it all work out there in Venice, Italy?

Ferf Brownoff

When I heard about monitoring COVID through waste water, my immediate fear was "Can I get COVID from smelling someone's fart?" So, uh, can you get a disease from inhaling particles after someone rips some of that trompet?

Sarah with an h

First time asker and boy howdy, do I have questions on this one: What other kinds of information can you glean from our wastewater? Do different cities/ regions/ countries have significantly different wastewater compositions? I've heard that lots of multivitamins can be found undigested in wastewater, flimflam? How many poop jokes are made daily (on average) in your lab? Do you yell "Holy shit!" When you saw a big spike in data or have a breakthrough? (Poop is always funny, but I share a sense of humor with most 13 year old boys and 40 year old men.) Does your job get real gnarly after big holidays like Thanksgiving and St. Patrick's day?

DebDoesScience

WAIT THIS IS SO COOL. I know you can detect COVID through wastewater because it's happening in my region (Boston), but what other pathogens are detected/checked for in wastewater? What other things have you gotten to look for? What does testing look like - big strainer? Small test tube? Waders and boots walking through sewers? Where does this all happen? Are there any other trends in health that can be shown in wastewater?

Ian, not Ian.

What tips do you have for me to reduce my daily wastewater production?

Nina Eve Z.

Oh! I am super intrigued by this but are there any privacy issues with going through people's poop? Or is it like those fingernail clippings in the wast bin in Law & Order, discarded so they can identify the killer... or disease in this case?

Marisa Asher

where does the waste in waste water go once it’s treated?

Laura Boer

Can we talk about cancer? My father and his sister both succumbed to different varieties even thought they were ppp

Riikka Puttonen

YES this is so interesting I can hardly wait! Apologies for my question is long but I'm absolutely dying to know the answer. Here in Finland in the city of Tampere roughly around 2010 our health and welfare institute was able to figure out that there was most likely a single person (or a family) who was shedding three (3) different types of polio virus. All this based on the waist water screening. They tried to track the person down for years and as far as I know without success, but I'd love to know whether you know of similar cases where there has been success in pinpointing an individual who was potentially spreading diseases through screening the waist water? Pronunciation: REEK-kah POOT-to-nen

Laura Boer

Not in in the gene pool…. Both lived in Western Massachusetts where there were paper mills and such…. Wondering if the water had something to do with it…

Gracie Zrain

How does wastewater and disposal effect the climate or global warming, if at all? Is it a "clean" process or what more can we do to make it more green... For a lack of a better word lol

Kristy Lowrey

Not a question: thank you for what you do looking through our poo(water)!

Bryan McIntosh

The short answer, at least based on Canada's experience: Reservations were chosen because they weren't terribly desirable places to live, and those undesirable places often have poor quality water supplies. Add in decades of underfunding for maintenance and training of staff for places that do have water treatment plants, and it's a recipe for unsafe drinking water.

Bryan McIntosh

How does the size of the population served by a sewage treatment area affect the results? Is there a maximum or minimum where the statistical analysis starts to break fown, or where the sheer amount of effluent (or lack of flow in the case of a small population) overwhelms your ability to get good representative samples?

Casey Newcomb

As someone in the food safety industry, this is something that is utilized for foodborne illness tracing. Is there any hope of using this to trace less detectable bacteria, virus, and parasitic contaminants? For example, actually detecting the Campylobacter pathogen for tracing since it is often under reported in food safety cases.

Karly KW

How much does mold come into play in your work? Mold makes people sick and can also originate in bathrooms. Thanks!

Silvia Triverio

Oh, Alie, first of all, I hope things are better for your dad - all the best vibes to him! Then… thanks so much for finding such great ologies, seriously, I am already obsessed. Now, to the question: I heard somewhere (Freakonomics?)that you can check drug abuse among the population via sewage testing, is it true? If so, is it because of what remains in poop and per or because people dump in the toilet like in the movies? And, about septic tanks, does their content ever gets out or are they closed system?

Robin Kuehn

How did our species survive with all of the disease-causing bacteria that lives in our (healthy?) gut? If we're so susceptible to illness from our own poop, how did we ever make it this far?

Elena Horne

This. I really want to hear the answer to this. Also, how would they even go about identifying someone from their waste?

Samantha Reyes

Have you ever found any new /unidentified diseases? How is wastewater treated so that it becomes safe in bodies of water?

Sydonie S.

What are the issues with flushing pet poop and are there ways to monitor animal based disease vs human diseases?

Rachel Hamilton

Just some general talk about COVID and wastewater testing? Did people get immediately more interested in what you do when COVID hit lol

Lauren Cooper

What kinds of diseases are most commonly tracked in waste water?

Melissa Berger

If COVID is detectable in wastewater, what does that say about its transmissibility through waste? (Aka how concerned should I be when using a busy rest stop bathroom?)

Yuri

Um, wow. No question, just need to say she's is a freaking hero of public health

Talela Manson

How has the increased monitoring of water contamination improved the livelihood of todays public health?

David Ruscalleda Gómez

Given that waste water shares the infrastructure with rain water drainage (it's like that in Spain at least), do heavy rains influence the rate at which diseases spread? (i.e. by overloading water treatment plants and thus forcing them to let pass the contaminated water)

wendy curtis

I’d love to hear about the future of using wastewater to pinpoint DNA and find criminals in hiding. Info vs privacy

sarah

How does the monitoring and testing of it for things like covid work?

Robin Stumbo

Do you know of any prominent/exciting research on bacteriophages in wastewater?? I'm super interested in phage therapy and from what I remember sewage/wastewater is a great place to look for them.

Margaret Downs

As I imagine is the case for a lot of people, I became more aware of this as a way to track COVID spread. In that context especially, I keep seeing wastewater being referred to as a "leading indicator" of disease spread, and I've seen it happen, most notably with Omicron, where the levels of virus in the wastewater spiked a couple of weeks before cases did. Why is that? I'd think it would correlate more closely time-wise with positive tests (because if you're sick and getting tested, you're also shedding virus. My understanding as a biochemist for whom virology/immunology/etc. is really far outside my wheelhouse is that you wouldn't start shedding virus much before your viral load is high enough to test positive). Is it just because people take a few days to go get tested, then maybe a few more to get results? Follow-up: are pathogen levels in wastewater leading indicators for any other diseases?

Archietedeli

i'm curious where the data goes and how it's used? also, how specific does it get? like citywide, neighborhood, or a specific household?

Ninett

Can all diseased be tracked in wastewater? If not which can’t and why and which ones are easiest to detect/ track?

Jojo

Who is your best mentor or person you go to for advice in your career?

Jessica Kleist

I grew up in wastewater. My family business builds lift stations and my dad has worked in wastewater treatment on and off. Does a wastewater surveillance system exist in the US? If not, would it be plausible to install one going forward in all treatment centers?

Desiree Mott

I work in a lab that does testing on waste sludges for things like heavy metals and mercury. Aside from the gloves and safety glasses I already wear, should I be wearing other protective equipment? A mask? How far into the waste treatment process are you taking samples from? This is absolutely fascinating, and exciting, to have a guest that is semi related to the field of work I'm in!

Kai Kishimoto

What new things have you learned applying this method to COVID-19? How might you do things differently for the next pandemic?

Donald Hodges

Is there a set of demographic data available that take waste water measurements and translates into categories and characteristics by geography?

Stephanie Leské

Hello!! First of all thank you for doing a job that a lot of people wouldn't do! My 1st question is I read that caffeine intake in a community can be measured? First of all, what purpose does this serve? And secondly how do you even do that!? From a fascinated coffee addict. My second question is perhaps the most stupid... when I use toilet paper to take off my nail polish should I not be flushing that down the toilet? And putting it in the general waste?? I genuinely think about this & worry everytime I do it.. Sorry neither of these are epidemiology questions, but now I need to know! ♡♡♡

Marianne Thomas

Ooh yes, this! Are there any diseases that are a pain in the ass 😜 to find using this system? And what's the dream, beyond COVID? Is there a disease you fantasize about developing a test for?

Marianne Thomas

I mean they could both be interesting microbiology questions as in- are there substances (like nail polish remover) that can screw with testing? I second Stephanie's thank you because I got so excited when I heard this science was a thing!

Laura Boer

Sorry, me again but it’s Cape Cod water and breast cancer that keeps popping up… wondering if it may be a demographic issue , or if my father was right, there is something nasty I.

Micah Delman-Allen

are there ways to detect pathogens via wastewater that aren’t transmitted via water? like if you can’t catch it from drinking the water are there other indicators of something being in a population?

Euan Munro

This is a great TOPIC! Can we detect viruses, bacteria and parasites in wastewater?

Kasey Carrick

Although this question may be outside of the epidemiology scope, is there any indication that the virus found in the waste water can contribute to spreading Covid?? In Detroit and Dearborn, Michigan, flooding is a huuuggeee issue. Although the flood water is not supposed to contain waste water, the old and poorly built system allows waste water to back flow during heavy flooding. During the last flood, my coworkers basement toilet turned into a back flow volcano 🤢🥴 Aside from the general nastiness and stank, my concern is if this waste water flooding can spread the Covid-19 virus??

Constance McRobert-Smith

Covid dies if its not inside a human within like 72 hours at most I'm pretty sure, so I would think this is a no

Jessica Kleist

I rescind my previous questions. Per my real dad, not the pod one, he wants to ask: Do you know of any permits of Dosmetic Waterwater Plants (WWTP) in the USA, have compliance limits for epidemiology compounds? Or Do you see this in the future? Since Pharmaceutical waste compounds are being found in waterways across the country. I'm sure that the economic cost to remove them would be extremely high....

Earl of Greymalkin

1) At what point in the wastewater treatment protocol are samples taken? How is wastewater generally processed, and how is this different across the US and it's territories? Do current methods sufficiently remove biohazard risks from the water? 2) How do you handle samples safely with biohazard risk? 3) What is the limit of detection both of the assays you do and with respect to how big an epidemic must be to detect it? 4) What other information about a community is detectable in wastewater? 5) Whose idea was it first to do epidemiology with sewage? How has is been used to full effect? 6) If you compared a curve of the epidemic's confirmed cases over time with when the virus is detectable in the wastewater, how do they line up? 7) What's your favorite poo joke? Do you own anything with the poo emoji on it? 8) Do you have any pets whose poo you've sampled for fun? 9) Is there a word for the city-wide microbiota?

Miriam

1) What infrastructure or public health investments do you think we need in order to expand wastewater surveillance? 2) How do you think the usefulness of wastewater surveillance changes when we start to look at more rural areas, where septic tanks might be more the norm? Is there a known tipping point in population density at which it is no longer a representative sample of the community?

Cassafrass

First timer here: how often do you get self conscious about (or think about) what others might discover in your excrement?

Elizabeth Fensin

How did she wander into this particular job? Who had the idea to look for Covid in sewage? It sounds cool and gross at the same time. Thanks!

Gabrielle Shimp

How does it apply to the vast amount of areas across the country without centralized wastewater collection and treatment systems?

Brandon Meredith

Did shitty DC water kill Wilbur Wright? I think I read that Wilbur caught typhoid fever after a trip to DC… twice! And the second time killed him. And this was only a few years after he had invented the airplane with his brother. So sad! Was this a thing with DC and other parts of America back then?

BeckytheSassySeagrassScientist

So we’ve been hearing about a giant wastewater treatment plant in Dundalk MD, near Baltimore having issues threatening “catastrophic failures”. Silver lining of lots of data? Or just lots of poop in the river? I know a lot about environmental impacts of added nutrients etc. but are there unexpected human or animal health threats of a ‘catastrophic failure’? Or cool poop data stories to be told?

Brandon Meredith

Here’s another: I heard that hookworm is on the rise in America. Does that mean that there are hidden droves of Americans without anywhere to go but the woods?

BeckytheSassySeagrassScientist

I’m morbidly fascinated by micro plastics making their way into animals and humans. There’s a famous fairly recent study finding micro plastics in human poop specifically, but is poop plastic like EVERYWHERE? Is that something you’ve looked at in poop flood water?

Charléne du Toit

From my plumber husband: What are the risks with viruses such as hepatitis and others when dealing with wastewater? As a plumber (in Australia) we are told to get vaccinated to protect ourselves from hepatitis specifically, are there other viruses to be aware of? What are some other protection methods I can take to minimise the risks?

Dawn Smolczyk (pronounced small-check)

Can the taste of tap water taste different depending on the microbes in it, or is it more likely due to the difference in minerals in the different locations?

Leanna Shuster

How much can scientists narrow down the source of contaminants detected in water? Like do you only know it came from a metro area or can it be pinpointed to a single neighborhood or even closer?

William Andrews

It depends on the plant. A common thing is to have the air that is drawn in to be infused into the second stage come from over the first stage. The second stage of many plants is a "activated sludge" system. Huge amounts of air is bubbled into the tanks and the bugs in the activated sludge feed on the waste. The air from the primary and from the headworks sections are used to supply that process.

William Andrews

Can vs. should. As an ex worker at a treatment plant, I have seen intact cat droppings make it all the way intact into a sample. It would get to the digestors. Toxoplasmosis might still be viable after going through the treatment process. So, given the option, trash it.

William Andrews

Nearly every wastewater treatment (that have anything beyond primary treatment, letting stuff settle) or water reclamation plant uses them. Activated sludge systems, rotation biological contactors, trickling filters, pond systems, and membrane bioreactors all use microbes. That accounts for most of the treatment options.

William Andrews

People's urine already contains a large amount of unabsorbed medications. Dumping other things like hormones, antibiotics, and other classes of drugs only make the problem worse. This is a known issue. That is why there are drug take back programs. I spoke with the EPA about this in 2005.

William Andrews

It has been going on for over 2 decades. So, it ain't a new thing for COVID.

Amy Narimatsu

***edit: we publish our results on social media and a website with whether or not an area is safe for water contact (like swimming) and try our best to avoid jargon, but I don't think ifs reaching all of our communities, particularly low-income communities of color

William Andrews

The density of people and other factors may make a waterborne waste system a more reasonable option. Also, water is any easier option to transport than sawdust.

William Andrews

Most wastewater plants have to check for the presence of either E. Coli or "fecal coliform" and do so on a daily basis.

Christi Sullivan

I have a degree in public health so I know it’s been going on for a while but I am always curious to learn more about how a method was started. I work on deep brain stimulation for my job and it fascinates me that someone said let’s stick some electric paddles in your brain so I was curious what train of thought lead to this ☺️

William Andrews

I have worked at a very large wastewater treatment plant, 100s of millions of gallons a day. It involved many stages and things like cryogenic oxygen, sludge drying and burning, gas turbine engines to generate power and heat. And then I visited a small town that a relative lives in. Their treatment plant was a pond system. They pumped the ww into a pond on one end and it flowed slowly to the other (some places use a second pond after the first). It takes a couple of months or more to flow through the pond. If you have a lot of land and not much water, it works well.

William Andrews

Think of it like sourdough. You start with what you can get and keep feeding it. Plants that are starting new or have had a major problem will often get tanker trucks with starter from a nearby plant.

William Andrews

At the plant that I worked at we saw blue and red coming in from a local textile dyer. If the COD (chemical oxygen demand) loading is not bad, it is not too bad. But it can make it hard to read the chlorine residual, as the chemistry used for that turns red/pink when to show the residual.

William Andrews

Oh the stories that workers can tell. Wads of $100. (Money is way too common). Jewelry.

William Andrews

If the treatment plant has tertiary or advanced treatment, they usually have a disinfection set-up. It can be chemicals (normally a chlorine or ozone based system) or UV.

William Andrews

Yes, 100% others are. Typically the sludge is first digested in tanks for around a month. It is then thickened and might be dried. Then it is composted (usually with vegetative matter added.)

William Andrews

For virology samples are usually pumped from the stream of wastewater (often after the second stage) and forced through a filter to collect the various viruses, etc. in the filter.

William Andrews

The FDA is concerned about a variety of drugs in wastewater. It is not just about people downstream getting dosed. It is also about what happens to animals, especially aquatic and amphibian animals.

William Andrews

Are you staying less than 2 meters away from the source and for 15 minutes or greater of continuous emissions?

William Andrews

I worked in a wastewater lab. "Shit" was a technical term there. It was a synonym to a turd. Whereas sludge was a collection of the stuff at the bottom of the process. Scum floats to the top. Biosolids are sludge that have been treated in a digestor, then thickened. The better the water conservation in an area, the more stuff in the water. In the past 30+ years Los Angeles has had less and less water going to its biggest wastewater plant over time.

William Andrews

Cannabis use is one interesting thing that can be tracked.

William Andrews

If you use a dishwasher, do full load, don't "prewash" them in the sink. If there is a huge amount of material on a plate, scrape it off. Run only full loads of laundry. Don't have the water running while brushing your teeth. Shave at the sink, not in the shower, and only have the basin 1/4 full or less. Use low flow showerheads, low flow toilets, and aerators on most sinks. Shorter showers. When bathing kids, only enough water to cover their legs. Follow the old mantra: "If its yellow let it mellow, if its brown flush it down."

William Andrews

This will depend a bit on where you live and the type of treatment used. But, here are some things that may happen: it might put in a landfill, turned into fertilizer (and possibly sold at home and garden centers), injected below the surface in farmland, applied to the surface of farmland and plowed in, burned (possibly for power), injected deep underground into old oil or gas wells, and in some places discharged to the ocean.

William Andrews

For Elena, start at the wastewater plant, then move back upstream to a branch and check there. If it is not there, go to the other branch. Repeat as you mover further back upstream. Taking some educated guesses to jump further upstream might speed up the search. It is the same way that the workers find people putting things in the sewer that they shouldn't.

William Andrews

Yes, drug use can be detected in sewage. Your body does fully absorb all of the drugs you put into it. So the drug can be detected as can be the metabolites. Other things like money does get flushed and has been found by wastewater workers at the treatment plants. Septic tanks can either be closed holding tanks (that need to get pumped out). Or they can be attached to a 'leach field', the water (the septic tank does provide some treatment) that flows out from the tank into the field and goes into the environment.

William Andrews

General steps: Screen out the big things like sticks, rags, and 'personal items', then slow the sewage down to a flow of about 0.5 feet per second (this drops out most of the solids and most of the floaty stuff gets scraped off), then a step with aeration and biological activity (some places will stop at this step), a filtration step, a disinfection step.

Donna Schakelaar

WSPs have been a vital tool in managing Covid outbreaks in Australia with samplers being places in remote Aboriginal communities as well as metro areas. But they are not used in a majority of countries including developed nations. What have been the main barriers? How much does it cost for the most basic sampler vs fancy automatic samplers? What training is required?

Donna Schakelaar

Similarly, what about Strongyloides? It is endemic in Northern Australia and during the Wet Season.

William Andrews

The rule of thumb about what is ok to put into a toilet: If it didn't come out of you and isn't toilet paper, don't put it in the toilet. (Flushable wipes aren't).

William Andrews

Unfortunately microplastics are a big issue. This includes glitter. People are even selling capsule of glitter to swallow so that your poop will shimmer. About 6 months before COVID hit, I had to take a sample of compost made with human waste to a lab. When we were sampling, we saw shimmering and wanted to make sure that there was no broken glass in it. I borrowed the microscope in the biology section at the wastewater plant lab. It was glitter and not glass. The biologist there said that the see glitter in the sediment samples they take miles off shore in the ocean.

William Andrews

In most places in the USA you are fine. Your water utility is required to provide you with an a routine report about the quality of your water. Most of them post it on their websites.

William Andrews

Generally the samples are taken at the wastewater treatment plant. That serves a specific area. Larger wastewater systems have routine sampling at strategic locations upstream and for every trunk line that comes into the plant. They can trace things upstream by placing samplers in the system upstream. Also, knowing which businesses are in which areas can help narrow the search.

Average_pi

HOW … how DO THEY FIND TEENY TINY VIRUSES IN THE WATER. Does washing your hands wash the germs into the water? ARE THERE GERMS IN MY POOP?!!!!!’ 💩

E-Veh-Lease Sanchez

Might be totally unrelated BUT....I live in Chicago where we get our drinking water from Laker Michigan. I never understood why the lake water can go through a filtration plant to provide us drinking water but we can't do that same process with ocean water. Is it the salt? More bacteria? Also....probably the stupidest of questions! [Insert embarrassed monkey emoji] Ivelisse (E Veh Lease)

Mel

Hey y'all! Why does hard water wreck so many things and why is this such a common issue?

Krystyna Dallaire

Was wastewater testing for viruses being done prior to the pandemic or is it a thing that popped up because of it? Are there broader public health uses of viral wastewater testing that communities should be looking into?

Sarah with an h

Fascinating! Apparently I should've gone into shit instead of sales for a living.

eHawk

Do people use wastewater epidemiology to look beyond human issues? For example, do farming regions use this to consider herd health for pig farm runoff, or could we consider this a way to look at health metrics for other organisms? There are so many disease issues in other interesting target species where this might be useful, farms come to mind since it's a lot of one type of organism locked in one place (much like people in a city).

Krista Jones

(Long-time listener, first-time patron and question asker!) Number one: While analyzing samples for COVID-19, have you unexpectedly discovered influxes of other viruses in certain regions? Number two: (jk that's just a poop joke)

Kairsti

Are water bears your favorite animal?? They are mine ;)

Nikki DeMarco

How much time is in the lab vs in the "field" (enter green face emoji)?

anthony willis

when something is found in the wastewater, what’s the process behind trying to identify where it came from and how to stop it?

Christopher Go

So for example I have COVID, does that mean the food that we eat and the fluids that we drink has already been contaminated by particles of the virus? And if these excretions such as feces or urine floods through sewage systems does that mean animals such as sewage rats can possibly be a carrier for stronger variants of COVID since they always travel in the sewers?

Jarred Abrahams

Hi Alie, huge fan and new to Patreon (first question)! I'm also interested to know about wastewater epidemiology for other diseases. More specifically, how/who first came up with the idea?

Liv Bruce

When reading about this technique, it's specified that the virus pieces are in our feces. Do pieces of the virus end up in our urine as well and why/why not? Does this have any implications for what type of pathogens we're able to detect in wastewater?

Ali Mac

Oh Hi! ~It's my first time here~ I worked on a project last semester looking at PFAS in the water cycle, specifically drinking water treatment options in Baltimore **today's pee is tomorrow's tea**(iykyk, TY John Oliver: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9W74aeuqsiU) 1. Superrr excited to learn more about wastewater & 2. Do PFAS and other potential immunosuppressing contaminants work alongside viral contaminated water for ultimate destruction?

Nicole George

First timer here! So… can you drink urine? What’s going on in that stuff 😅 also is it true you can see drugs in the wastewater?

Nathalie Jones

I just listened to the taphology episode and can't stop thinking about the pressure cooker warm bath cremation scenario and like......does that actually happen and are people just flushed down the drain with poop and blood, etc. and does that just go into our waterways and beautiful ocean? Who decided this was a good idea?

Megan jamnicky

I’m interested in if there is a connection to diseases found in wastewater and antibiotics found in the water as well?

Paul Hossfield

This is so cool! I knew about it because I'm such a COVID geek. My question is, how is the reception from state and local governments? Are they generally supportive of your efforts?

gg

I got a water distiller at the start of COVID because I was at our local grocer and a customer needed some distilled water but they ran out. In these times you shouldn't rely on running out of essentials. I see from a wastewater report that BA.2 is in our valley.

Marita

Hiiii, I know that this is not entirely on topic, but I have heard some crazy things about drugs in London sewage and how this can be damaging to the environment. Would love to know a bit more about that, if the oologist has a clue,

Emma

Neti pots! What's the deal with having to boil tap water to make it safe for nasal rinses? Will I really get a brain parasite if I don't?

Angelica Lagasca

I wouldn't say I'm a germaphobe but I certainly do not take germs lightly. I hate anything to do with bodily fluids. How do you mentally approach working constantly with various pathogens, some of them even infectious, and bodily fluids in general? (And the smells!)

The Squirrel Queen

Hey! I’m curious about ways that fungi can be incorporated into the wastewater treatment process. I’ve heard that turkey tail fungi can effectively filter out some pharmacological compounds. Are there any other potential applications for fungi in water purification?

Some Random Frog

Are there ways to make waste water less gross?

Popita

Why is it that some viruses/bacteria can infect humans and animals through water and others cannot? What sets a waterborne contaminate apart?

Marissa Laws

My friend studies wastewater treatment in Minnesota so this question is for her. Does the temperature/weather (e.g. freezing temps) affect the ability to detect pathogens in the wastewater? What is the optimal time/location to sample? Are there any other factors or barriers or resistance (from the public/ companies) to this work?

Curious

If you have a septic tank and it leaks on to the soil is that soil useful for a vegetable garden? I ask because we bought a house from an elderly woman who was supposed to be hooked up to the city’s plumbing but had a septic tank. It was very old and started to leak. We had to have the city come out and hook up the sewer. We collapsed the tank and the soil in that area of the yard is SUPER fertile (the grass grows crazy fast there). I have a vegetable garden in another area of the yard and wanted to see if I could plant a garden on top of the old septic tank. My partner thinks that the veggies would absorb traces of medication that the elderly couple were on along with any other goodies from the human waste.

Curious

I would also like to add my parters father works in waste water in fl. When Covid hit everyone who worked at the plant contracted Covid… is that a someone came to work and spread it thing or a airborn waste water thing.

Reiley Allison

How do temperatures of the external environment impact the waste water? Is there an optimal time to grab samples?

Holly G

1st time question asker. Are there any diseases that are exclusively obtained through waste water contamination? Also, have you ever uncovered illegal dumping?

Jillian Langford

What's the deal with Fluoride in water? Are you really getting the poop out and putting fluoride in to fix my chompers?

William Andrews

Certain microbes can produce 'off' smells. An experienced wastewater treatment plant worker can tell things are not going right if the smell is off. Ideally there are never enough of the wrong ones to produce a dominate smell.

William Andrews

Yep, salt is the reason that sea water is not just treated cheaply to make drinking water. Salt content plays an important role in what uses reclaimed water might have. Removing salt is vastly more energy intensive than treating waste water to ok standards. Reclaimed water is less salty than the ocean.

William Andrews

It does happen ad it goes right into the sewer.

William Andrews

This generally got covered in the episode. Yep, drugs, legal and illegal are found (when looked for in wastewater.) Many aquatic and amphibious species have shown problems near some locations because of some drugs.