Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Which Disastrous British Defeat shall we do?

  • Raid on the Medway 1667 140
  • Battle of Cartagena 1741 61
  • Battle of Isandlwana 1879 125
  • Sinking of Prince of Wales and Repulse 1941 63
  • 2026-06-08
  • —2026-06-10
  • 389 votes
{'title': 'Which Disastrous British Defeat shall we do?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Raid on the Medway 1667', 'votes': 140}, {'text': 'Battle of Cartagena 1741', 'votes': 61}, {'text': 'Battle of Isandlwana 1879', 'votes': 125}, {'text': 'Sinking of Prince of Wales and Repulse 1941', 'votes': 63}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 6, 10, 13, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 6, 8, 15, 54, 28, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 389}

Content

Thank you to everyone who voted in the first poll. We have a decisive winner, which is Disastrous British Defeats! We've created a shortlist featuring 4 of the most interesting and dramatic...

Raid on the Medway 1667 - a Dutch fleet sails brazenly up the River Thames, breaches naval defences, and burns or captures the pride of the Royal Navy right at its home docks.

Battle of Cartagena 1741 - the War of Jenkins' Ear is largely forgotten, but the British attempt to seize Cartagena in modern Colombia led to a spectacular disaster, with disease wiping out half the expedition.

Battle of Isandlwana 1879 - British troops are overwhelmed and annihilated by Zulu warriors armed mostly with spears and shields, in one of the most shocking defeats in colonial history.

Sinking of Prince of Wales and Repulse 1941 - two powerful British warships are sent around the world to Asia as a show of force, only to be sunk within days by an enemy they had severely underestimated.

Poll closes Wednesday 2pm UK time, so get voting!

Files

Comments

Victor Deleon

Hahaa let’s do all of them 🤭

Kevin Xu

It would be great to get a full scope or professor guided description of the Zulu front. Even as a yank I learned things about Wabash and the overall American-Indian conflicts that were not well described in primary school history

Shaun Scandrett

they're all great choices. sounds like mini-series in the making!

SCL

I would love to see a video on all these defeats but since I suggested Isandlwana in the prior poll it has my vote :P

Dane McAfee

All good choices… but I went with Medway, since it essentially was the catalyst for a general rethink of English grand strategy in a larger sense, and had deep political ramifications visavie Charles II and Privy Council and the bubbling cauldron of relations with Parliament. The next decade or so over the 1670s had the real possibility of exploding into another English Civil War, which would have shifted the course of Western Civilization and modernity itself. The disaster at the Medway pointed to the faction lines of what might have happened.

TKG Moff Hallas

Do all, but please do the Anglo-Zulu War

Hunter Cihal

I'm hopeful people vote for something not already talked about in history. I didn't even know about Medway until this post for instance. Cartagena is interesting as well, and not much talked about.

Jack Huston

All of them would be fire, though I'm a chump for some good ol 1700s content so I'm going Cartagena. Medway would be good too

luc

Kaboul disaster…

Eli Khanam

The Battle of Rorke's Drift is already somewhat known among history buffs, so I feel the battle it happens as a knock-on effect off, should get some more coverage.

Caleb Hathaway

It won't win probably, but the siege of cartagena is a personal favorite. Such a fascinating story and horribly disastrous result

Ludwik Patyra

I love Zulu movie and Welsh Soldiers singing Men of Harlech, so the choice is simple :)

CP

I think a series of histories biggest f*ck ups would be great. It will make me feel better when I forget to attach a document to an email

Robert Sawers

I choose the Medway. I haven’t seen any recent videos or podcasts on this embarrassing defeat. So important, so interesting, so ironic. In just over 23 years William of Orange would become William the 3 of Great Britain. Would many have thought this would happen in the 1660’s? So for me it’s the “Raid on the Medway”. The Zulu war is probably going to win but it’s been done so many times before on so many military history channels, time for a change of pace the Anglo- Dutch War is such a change. 📚📕⚔️💀

Zoldy

As a Dutchman I am obviously very biased, but making one on the Medway would make the most sense as it's pretty much completely uncovered on Youtube. Isandlwana is possibly one of the most known battles of the 1800s (outside of the Napoleonic Wars of course) and has plenty of coverage. Same with the death of Force Z, it's mentioned in every WW2 doc covering the front. Cartagena should be the only real contender to Medway.

Marcos

Well, you changed my mind sir

shrubby1989

Lets have Vietnam, the phillipines, battle of badensberg, and operation eagle claw if we're gonna play this game

thisss guy

I’d say all the above. But I also think a deep dive into the Franklin Expedition could be interesting. It’s not really a defeat, but can kind of fit in the category.

Mingyuan Chen

It would be great to see all of them in the future🤩⭐️🤓

Marcus Cribb

We all know Zulus will win, because there's a film about it... but for that exact reason, the first two would be the most interesting, as it has had the keast amount of coverage.

Just Some Random Guy

I want to see Medway too, but the movie "Zulu" holds a special place in my heart

Melodroman

It’s Medway, for me. I’ve barely seen anything more then toe-depth discussion about the Dutch Republic and it’s (militart) history. Especially from one of the top-tier history creators. The Dutch are always treated like a side-piece, and addition to one war or another. They’re almost never in the spotlight.

Discorules

I vote Isandlwana but only if Rorke's Drift gets a nice section.

Tristan Blackshaw

Oh not Isandalwana again please I beg of you… it’s been done so many times.

Mohammed Alsaadoon

All excellent choices. I really want to see a video on Force Z's sinking because of Churchill's dreadful thoughts after hearing about the sinking would make a great end cap to the video " As I turned over and twisted in bed the full horror of the news sank in upon me[...] Across this vast expanse of waters, Japan was supreme, and we everywhere were weak and naked." But I have to give it to Medway cause its the only battle I truly haven't heard about.

Stuart Carver

All of them of course let’s make it a series at some point

TankerBricks

Medway! Or just do all of them!!!