Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Vote for the Next Epic History TV Topic!

  • 3 Extra Napoleon Videos! His Marshals, ranked; his enemies, ranked; the 1813 Vitoria campaign. 139
  • Rome: Rise and Fall: 'big picture' series (like the History of Russia) charting the history of the Republic & Empire. 93
  • World War Two: a global history in 4-5 parts. 37
  • The American War of Independence: Redcoats & Rebels! 51
  • 2020-05-31
  • —2020-06-03
  • 320 votes
{'title': 'Vote for the Next Epic History TV Topic! ', 'choices': [{'text': '3 Extra Napoleon Videos! His Marshals, ranked; his enemies, ranked; the 1813 Vitoria campaign.', 'votes': 139}, {'text': "Rome: Rise and Fall: 'big picture' series (like the History of Russia) charting the history of the Republic & Empire.", 'votes': 93}, {'text': 'World War Two: a global history in 4-5 parts.', 'votes': 37}, {'text': 'The American War of Independence: Redcoats & Rebels! ', 'votes': 51}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2020, 6, 3, 9, 0, 12, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2020, 5, 31, 16, 56, 41, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 320}

Content

Thank you for all your suggestions! There were 165 posts and about as many proposed topics, and I have read them all. I've now created a shortlist for us to vote on, with a few thoughts and comments:

'More videos on Napoleon' was the most popular suggestion, whether the Egyptian, Italian or Hundred Days campaign or some other aspect. I am prepared to take these on, but I do need a bit of a breather before diving back into a major Napoleonic campaign! So I've included a Napoleonic option that I hope will appeal to many of you, and once I've had a rest from fluttering banners and small blocks of blue forming square, we can consider the early campaigns. 

Punic Wars - this was a popular idea but hasn't made the short-list, largely because HistoryMarche (my frequent collaborator on the Napoleon series) is in the middle of his own excellent and in-depth series about Hannibal's campaigns. But there is a Rome option which would cover these wars in summary. 

WW2 - I see this idea slightly splits the camp, but it has made the short-list. Just to say, WW2 is an area of particular expertise and interest to me, and was even the subject of my MA thesis. And though there are many WW2 videos out there already, I plan to cover it as a succinct, global narrative (like the WW1 series), that puts everything in context. Tbh I've not seen this done well elsewhere yet. So this is a topic I do hope to take on at some stage before the end of 2020.

The American Civil War got a lot of support but is not on the shortlist, but may well return in future. It narrowly lost out to another popular suggestion from American history, which was also a focus of my university studies and would be fun to revisit...  

Apologies if your suggestion didn't make it, but there will be more votes in future... 

Look forward to seeing what you vote for! 

Toby

Comments

Luca Schneider

Im ready for some more Napoleon tbh you do them so well ;)

Gordian III

Vote Napoleon ! ww2 has been made so many times ! American war of independence has been done by Oversimplified and Rome has been by various history channels ! but honestly I would love to see YOU do all of these : )

Marcus Cribb

Definitely Napoleonic (sorry Toby I know you want a break...) but 1813 Vittoria campaign!

EpicHistoryTV

Haha, I don't mind taking on these 3 videos, but e.g. the entire Italian campaign would seem like a very steep hill right now.

Lluis Planas

Napoleon is done! But a Rome series could be Epic!

Gordian III

Yeah, wasnt there two (episodes) of the Italian campaign. Like, he conquered Italy in 1796, then went off to Egypt, the Austrians reconquered it, and then he had to take it over again ?

Ludvig Sahlén

WW2 is super interesting, but I don't about you guys.. I've watched countless documentaries and youtube videos on the subject already at varying depths. I'm probably not exaggerating claiming that these guys have the best Napoleon videos on the entirety of youtube. I would definitely like to see more than just Napoleon, naturally, but I suspect most people, at least on patreon for epic history, has a fairly solid handle on the events of ww2 already. Then again, if you were to cover it, it would still undoubtedly be stellar content that I would happily watch and pay for.

Anna

Yes-yes-yes, Napoleon's marshals, please!

Beefcleave Beefcleave

Easily Napoleon, the other options have been done many times by Youtubers, History channel and BBC etc. Eventhough I know Toby can make it better :).

Anna

PS and if you need any additional info about Poniatowski (images, bio details; whatever - please, do not hesitate to ask me! ;) I would be delighted to share this )))

Kevin Xu

I personally feel arzamas covers Rome summary quite well already, though I totally dig the whole subject fatigue you feel for Napoleon

Ron Rozen

Rome sounds great!

PapaZoulou

World War Two has already been done multiple times by everyone. The American War of Independence could be nice but I doubt it'll work well outside of the US and England. Rome is also a subject that has been already (and currently still is) massively treated by Historia Civilis, History Marche, Kings and Generals, and even Unbiased History. I personally mainly voted for Napoléon due to the Vitoria campaign, due to the fact that while I think talking about Napoléon's marshals and his opponents is a good idea, I really, really despise vids that tend to rank people as those tend to make people go nuts in the comments. Also, unless they are about basic history figures across history and very simplified (like those top 100 vids about famous kings, presidents, and best generals evuuh), I think it's also a risky move concerning the channel to make a subject around generals of a specific time period.

Darko

WW2 and rome have a lot of coverage on yt imo. So I voted Napoleon. Still hoped to see 18th century Europe wars.

Seamus Hamrin

A! W! I! Sssssoooooooo undercovered. I love, love, love me some Napoleon but heavens to Betsy I’d be head over heels to see the AWI get some Epic History treatment.

Rio Rifqi Syah Akbar

I understand everyone’s reasoning for not really wanting WW2 as much. Personally, even though WW2 has been covered in depth across youtube I just love how Toby does his videos!

Abraham Ash

Revolutionary War, all the way!

Marcus Cribb

Maybe Vittoria & Pyrenees (sorry I keep on the 🏔️⛰️🏔️⛰️ but it's never been done and personally, as someone who enjoys researching the Peninsular War, it's 1814 I struggle to picture. I think you'd do a really good job at it too...

MorningStarr

Napoleon's Italian Campaign. Arguably one of his most brilliant campaigns and I'm sure Epic History could capture its complexity.

luc

Yes for Napoleon ! Rome or Independence War are also very interesent more like WW2, which is too documented. Maybe Rome is less well studied than Independence War and can be more popular for that. Thank for your job on Napoleon !

Philip Öhrberg

Personally i whould suggest wait with ww2 series. Its been covered by other YT channels , series, movies, etc. I really want a ww2 series here but not right now

Gavin Anand Saint Just Brown

Hi Toby. I'm torn between 'WW2' and '3 extra', but its got to be the latter. While I would love to see a WW2 series some day, preferably with an Eastern Front focus, I think the subject has been done to death in all media formats and I'm more intrigued to see you focus on more obscure history. Congratulations again!

Stuart Carver

Vitoria would fit perfectly chronologically between the retreat from Russia and road to Leipzig so I’m all in as I’d like continuity when you make the rest of the napoleonic series in the long form format. Love the fact you’d rank his enemies too but do you mean generals or monarchs too? If you do early Napoleon you should do the entire war of the 1st and 2nd coalition so you have the big picture not just what Napoleon was doing. Maybe WW2 sandwiched the 2? Yes it’s been done to death but your videos are so good that it could still be fun plus let’s be honest it would be a huge boast to the channel as it has such mass appeal. Still excited about the space race there was a great series on the bbc like 15 years ago but can’t remember what it was called. Are there any area you wouldn’t want to cover at some point in the future?

Wade Eckert

Wow that’s a tough one all great choices but I would love WW2 to get the epic history tv treatment as your WW1 series was fantastic. Also great job on the Napoleonic series Toby endgame was amazing!

Dan Jaggers

I'm voting Rome, even though I am aware that the Napoleon option will likely win considering how popular the series has been on here. xD I am a little disappointed that my choice of the History of the Ottoman Empire didn't get the shortlist, but then again it was pretty much buried under all the big popular options. xD I do hope it gets covered someday though, certainly in my opinion one of the most interesting empires in history.

Jerry Johnston

I probably should have taken part in the nomination process but I'd rather see some much more interesting things like the English Civil War, Thirty Years War, War of 1812, Great Northern War, the Teutonic Crusades, etc things that have had far less good coverage and treatments by other channels.

Patrick wilcher

My top 5 marshalls 1.Dovout, 2. Ney, 3. Lannes, 4. Murat, 5. Soult

Gordian III

Murat at 4th !?! He betrayed Napoleon !!! I would put SaintCyr or Oudinout instead.

MMDT

I voted Napoleon but a Rome video like the Russian one would also be absolutely great so that is my second choice . But I'd also love to see an indepth WW2 video in the future, especially after your remarks here.

Wenwei Jiang

How is Ney at second place though? His bravery and loyalty are beyond question, but seems to be lacking in tactical judgment... Maybe Suchet should be somewhere on the list instead, and Massena too.

Wenwei Jiang

I voted for Rome because anything Rome-related is automatically a no-brainer for me, but I do strongly believe that your coverage on WW2 would bring something new and refreshing to the existing contents out there. I've seen very excellent documentaries on WW2 (e.g. World War II in HD Colour), I've seen short videos that deal with very specific topics (or in Eastory's case, from a very specific dimension) very well, and I've seen many many many other poorer-quality videos that are inadequate in either succinctness, or detail, or accuracy, or any combination of these. A WW2 series done by you would easily blow these numerous poorer-quality videos out of the water :D

Alex Lower

Ranking of the marshals would be great, even if it's the only further Napoleon video. Your introductions of them and their stories have inspired further learning. You've earned a break from the battles and maneuvers!

Patrick wilcher

His trustworthiness alone is what makes him 2nd in my personal opinion. To be one of Napoleon's top Marshalls you do not have to be a skilled strategist or decision maker. That is the emperor's job, your job as a marshal is to carry out the emperor's orders to your fullest of your ability and I feel that Ney did that very well. I'd maybe consider putting Suchet in the top five but Massena was a Pillager and a looter that got disgraced in Spain so he is nowhere near the top five in my personal opinion.

Patrick wilcher

Overall he'd led the calvary of the grande armee better then anyone else could have done. Betrayal?? Oh stop it he came around to his senses during the hundred days campaign:D

Alfonso Frias

Your videos on The Napoleonic Wars are great. I would not have any problem if you continue with the topic for the time being and then maybe go into World War 2. I’m sure you could do a great job and go into great detail on a topic like that.

Babatunwa Aderinokun

Please do a WW2 video. I think it's about time for us all to have a break from Napoleon and the WW1 video is begging for a follow up. WW2 please!

Alberto Barreto

Yes More Napoleon!!! Make Epic history TV the defacto Encyclopedia on Napoleon. Please do the Egyptian Campaign!! You must introduce Sir Sidney Smith into the story.

Speakdino

I figured people are too invested in Napoleon right now to give it up. I hope after these Napoleon videos are done, you'll go further East with your videos.

Seth Cox

If it's Napoleon, I'd prefer his earlier campaigns, Egypt, etc. Eventually, I'd like to see videos along the lines of Blackbeard and other Discovery Age explorers.

Alex D

The first Italian campaign of Bonaparte would be the best !

Wesley Barley

Toby, I just want to say that you if you feel like making a video on WW2 - go for it. You have certainly earned the right to make something for yourself in my book. I promise I will still watch it. And probably love it! Just please come back to some of these other ideas when you're done :)

EpicHistoryTV

Thanks Wesley! There might be an executive decision about the WW2 series this autumn, but we'll see..

EpicHistoryTV

I don't think it's going to win this time, but I'm not giving up on it!

Gordian III

agree with him. you making ww2 would be awesome : )

Blase Tilling

Please do Rome I need a quick breather from Napoleon

Gordian III

Ask Eugene, who faced Murat with 30.000 men in Italy : )

Stuart Carver

You have to bite the bullet and do it at some point ww2 is almost mandatory and it’s what you like so....

Game Caesar

Napoleon's early campaigns would make your channel probably the absolute undisputed king when it comes to Nspoleonic content on Youtube if it isn't already.

Gordian III

Napoleon won ! I think you should do Vitoria first, and then do the rankings. You can then do a Part 7 to part 13 (like you did with you Napoleon part 1 to 6) you can then add Vitoria into those parts.

EpicHistoryTV

Haha, I'm sure you do! I'm afraid I need a bit of a break from animating the battles though, so I'll do the Marshals and enemies rankings first. But we will get to Vitoria.