Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I’m obsessed with this book’s “Analytical Index”/table of contents–what a cool way to organize and present a book-long argument, right? I figured I’d start each of these posts with the heading summaries of each chapter we read for reference as people read/write in the comments:

Introduction - Science is an essentially anarchic enterprise: theoretical anarchism is more humanitarian and more likely to encourage progress than its law-and order alternatives.

Chapter 1 - This is shown by an examination of historical episodes and by an abstract analysis of the relation between idea and action. The only principle that does not inhibit progress is: anything goes.

Chapter 2 - For example, we may use hypotheses that contradict well-confirmed theories and/or well-established experimental results.  We may advance science by proceeding counterinductively.

Chapter 3 - The consistency condition which demands that new hypotheses agree with accepted theories is unreasonable because it preserves the older theory, and not the better theory.  Hypotheses contradicting well confirmed theories give us evidence that cannot be obtained in any other way. Proliferation of theories is beneficial for science, while uniformity impairs its critical power. Uniformity also endangers the free development of the individual.

Chapter 4 - There is no idea, however ancient and absurd, that is not capable of improving our knowledge. The whole history of thought is absorbed into science and is used for improving every single theory. Nor is political interference rejected. It may be needed to overcome the chauvinism of science that resists alternatives to the status quo.

~~~~~

Just want to start by saying that Feyerabend’s prose is definitely more dense and academic than Lockheart's was—I literally had to read Chapter 3 three times before I felt like I actually absorbed the argument (mostly) fully. so if anyone’s feeling overwhelmed by the reading so far, just know that you’re not alone. This book may be more of a challenge than the last two, but we’ll get through it together~

below are a few quotes and things they made me think of. the thoughts you share in the comments don't have to respond to these at all, but they can if you like.

~~~~~

“Just as a well trained rationalist will obey the mental image of his master, he will conform to the standards of argumentation he has learned, he will adhere to these standards no matter how great the confusion in which he finds himself, and he will be quite incapable of realizing that what he regards as ‘the voice of reason’ is but a causal after-effect of the training I received.” (Ch1, pg 9)

It’s kinda jarring to realize how true this is just from my own introspection. I’m currently working on the response to critiques of my video essays I announced in the Sokal video, and in general the experience is forcing me to contend with the way my brain automatically starts building arguments from the assumption that a given criticism is wrong. There’s been at least one place where someone basically made the case that I was insisting ‘X is true bc the scientific establishment said so’ while there can be other, non-scientific but still legitimate frameworks in which X isn’t true (this was re my pluto vid). After getting over the initial feelings of activation from confrontation, it didn’t take me long to start to concede to this commenters point, and I felt a little sheepish at how silly/ironic of a thing that was for me to do. A few days later when I read this line about scientists’ “voice of reason” sometimes being just mental programming, I immediately thought of that comment and my response to it. Like, my literal nervous system had reacted to someone telling me i'm just re-iterating astronomy dogma. And that’s as me, someone who is pretty actively trying to counter my training as a servant to scientific orthodoxy. It makes me wonder what other bits of thought i’m holding on to that I would probably let go of with a little bit of scrutiny and some breathing exercises. Also makes me grateful for an audience that’s willing to check me.

Does anyone else notice this (or something similar) in themselves? I’m curious what different kinds of circumstances have facilitated self-awareness of that reflex for people. 

~~~~~

“Theories should not be changed unless there are pressing reasons for doing so. The only pressing reason for changing a theory is disagreement with facts. Discussion of incompatible facts will therefore lead to progress. Discussion of incompatible hypotheses will not. Hence, it is sound procedure to increase the number of relevant facts. It is not sound procedure to increase the number of factually adequate, but incompatible alternatives. One might wish to add that formal improvements such as increased elegance, simplicity, generality, and coherence should not be excluded. But once these improvements have been carried out, the collection of facts for the purpose of tests seems indeed to be the only thing left to the scientist.” (Ch. 3, pg 19)

This reminds me of a rant I often go on (read: future video essay) about how boring I find a lot of contemporary exoplanet research. Basically there are tons and tons of papers being published that are just ‘hey i found another one!, with some technically unique circumstance that makes it technically warrant a publication, but has the overall effect of the field feeling like an exercise in stamp collecting. I generally attribute this to some vague financial incentive–expolanets are really popular, so there’s lots of funding available, and just kinda cataloguing objects is pretty much the lowest hanging fruit of this hip new field of research. But I hadn’t considered that the reasons driving this trend could be epistemological rather than economic. Or I suppose, in addition to? I guess the two things could also be pretty interdependent—this way of thinking rationalizes trends in research that have material, systemic origins, and the distribution of success in that system justifies that way of thinking. i tend to generally think that ideas and physical reality kinda co-create eachother, which means that either element is an opportunity to interrupt whatever feedback loop, so i’m excited to be getting this philosophical analysis to compliment what I’ve generally looked at through more of a material lens. 

I’m honestly just excited to be getting into all this philosophy in general—i’m really enjoying the book so far. are you? what's stood out to you so far?

Comments

Jim Shingleton

I did or didn't make a mistake by doing the audible book and then the written. It took me several passes to get through prefaces and introductions. But if you need to skip a bunch of material behind time or whatever Do Not blow over The Introduction To The Chinese Edition. Full disclosure, I have the attention span of a gnat. The hardcopy version and its copious detail of citations labor is a stadium where every seat is a door for me. Notwithstanding my near always leaning into the model of my assumptions. Damnit, even when I'm reading (particularly this work) it feels like I'm straightening wrought iron. Everything is philosophy and that which isn't is politics, probably. Bury that a moment, I'm intrigued of his allowance. In all things, mostly. Happy Monday

Bella Hierro

Hello! I’m a recent subscriber, a third-year/sixth-year (it’s complicated, navigating the education system with disabilities is fun) physics/astro student. After watching your video on dark matter, the scientific method as we know it seems astonishingly incompetent. I agree that this is a dense read and I feel like I’ll have to reread it a couple of times to fully grasp it, but chapter 3 resonated with me the most because it seems as though physics has lost the room for creativity that once made it thrive. From the beginning of our careers in physics, we are taught that there is a “right” and “wrong” way to do things, and that once something (whether it be a method, a hypothesis, or even us as students) fails, it should be thrown out and not revisited. While I think that in this case adjustments have to be made, it seems like the field rewards those who give up easily, which starkly contrasts the history of our craft.

Robert Herold

Hello! I am so excited that this book has finally come up for the book club, it is one of my all time favorites and while it can be a bit dense, I absolutely love Feyerabend's style. I am also glad that someone else really appreciates how he does his table of contents, I have only seen Ian Hacking do it in contemporary philosophy and its a shame because it makes the book so much easier to return to as you try to piece together different parts of the book. As someone who has read the book a few times I highly recommend that people return to chapters and sections later on because if you are confused it could be helpful to keep going and then return to the section with some more context in hand. Outside of my praise of the book I wanted to comment on the first quote because it is particularly relevant to my life and research right now. I am a political scientist, and I graduated with my masters a few years ago. I became highly disillusioned with my field during grad school, and a large part of that was this book. The quote about how scientists get caught up in their own formal programing is something that I see everywhere in political science. There is so much tacit knowledge in the field that many could tell you how to do certain research techniques, methods, and so on, but many would not be able to tell you why you are doing it, the history behind it, or anything. This has also resulted in clear dogmas being present in the field and it makes it hard to try to talk about certain ideas and concepts. Its sad because there is so much room for opportunity in the field, yet so much work goes undone because it is both not profitable and because our formal training tells us to not look at those areas. I am very excited to keep re-reading it with everyone and hear about what other people think of the book!

Lizz Valentine

The quote from page 9 is making me have a lot of thoughts as it relates to Paulo Fieri's description of the banking model of education, and how that system is instrumental to the maintenance of scientific orthodoxy. I think it is interesting to view this type of behavior as a sort of trauma response--traumatic experiences have a tendency to instill a sort of phantasmal belief in modalities, expressions, and behaviors as existentially and unquestioningly true as a protective mechanism to maintain our safety in these dangerous environments. As trauma relates to a classroom adherent to the banking model, the panoptic pressures of conformity in our modern education system create the space for such a trauma-genic adherence to educational dogma, as failure to perform in an academic field to the specificity of the institution can and often does result in ostracization and loss of opportunity for enfranchisement in that academic/social sphere. I feel like I should read this book, it seems cool.

Michael Schon

For a philosopher, Feyerabend's writing is spicy! He wasn't afraid to step on the toes of his contemporaries (Popper especially). His point about there being no "plain facts" is so important for having useful scientific discussion. Everything you observe passes through filters of theory, and entertaining alternative theories is the only remedy. I can't fully get behind his argument against consistency in practice, though. Part of science is fitting a system to your observations, but communicating a system is also essential, and humans need time to learn new systems. "Textbooks would need to be rewritten" isn't a frivolous complaint, because translation is lossy. The nuances of the old system fade out and important details fail to carry over. If you're constantly cycling theories out for new ones that aren't substantially better, then you risk the exact situation he describes in Chapter 4, where people totally dismiss older systems of knowledge because they don't understand their context. I'm all for playing around with contradiction, I think that's part of the engine of science. "Anything goes" when you're trying out new ideas, but if you aren't speaking the same language as your peers, your ideas can't travel.

bhobba

I had a friend many years ago in my early days as a programmer who was really into Astronomy, although, like me, he did a degree in math. He found a comet; it was named after him. I thought - that's nice - good on him - he must be happy. He was more than happy - it changed the direction of his life. He still worked as a programmer, but part-time got his doctorate in Astronomy. Having interacted with some of these people, it's in their makeup - they are ecstatic about discovering a comet, a planet, etc. Those not of that bent look on in wonder. As an aside, he decided to go contracting for his programming, and his card says Dr - never mentioning it is a Dr in Astronomy.

Contraryon

> my literal nervous system had reacted… Does anyone else notice this (or something similar) in themselves? You mean, the “I came up with that. It’s mine! Leave it alone!” reaction? Nevernotonce. Really, though, this sentiment certainly followed me through my reading. It got me reflecting on how we’re very insecure critters. If we weren’t, we wouldn’t need philosophy or art. Hell, we probably wouldn’t have much use for science, for that matter. Without being insecure, we just wouldn’t be very interesting. The trouble, I think, centers around being self-conscious of our insecurity and our reactions to it. What’s really fascinating to me is the idea that these kinds of bellyaches are endemic to the human condition. Like, we can look at ourselves in a particular way and become the sum of our anxieties. In a non-metaphorical way, communities can be described in the same terms. Now, when dealing with bellyaches, going to sleep is one of the more reliable ways of dealing with anxiety, even if we do invite bad dreams. (This isn’t even a metaphor: ChatGPT hurt my feelings the other day, so I had to take a nap—at some point, I’ll get around to unpacking that little mess of reality.) But we also try to squash our anxieties through action. And, at our worst, we act not out of passion but out of compulsion[1] (which is just another kind of going to sleep). ‘Even the most puritanical rationalist will be forced… to use propaganda and coercion’ because the fruits of their reason have lost the capacity to inspire; they become trivial. ‘And what is the use of an argument that leaves people unmoved?’ Of course, this is made all the worse by the fact that any interesting theory is necessarily incomplete. If there is a tendency to stasis, it’s not the settled constant that we are roused to defend but rather the assumed constants, the part of us that is bound to the theory. Or, as Feyerabend puts it, ‘doubtful points turn into slogans,’ and we are compelled to force our interlocutors to strictly play by our rules. All the better; perhaps we can defeat them before they even arrive: the young ‘must learn one particular set of views to the exclusion of everything else.’ In either case, however, we may don our laurels after the fashion of Apollo in love. [1]In this case, compulsion is seen as an automatic reflex to maintain some status quo. While passion can present as automatic and reflexive, it is defined by moving against a static state. If passion rouses the senses, compulsion tends to blunt experience.

AlexTheTutor

apologies for lateness of reply, just got settled in after airplane travel, but the traveling gave me time to do reading assignment, so... I think I have the 1992 edition, that includes a lot of history about the book and different prefaces, great context, for example, when I was realizing Feyerabend has issues with rules, I instantly thought, "I wonder if he ever met Wittgenstein", and then later one of the intros actually said something like, "yeah, he was going to study with Wittgenstein in 1952, but things didn't work out", ah big lightbulb moment, just a brief recap, Wittgenstein is major philosopher known for his many ideas about language, one of them being about rules (PI 201: no course of action could be determined by a rule, because every course of action can be made out to accord with the rule), and having read the first few chapters, I can smell the Witttgenstein influence (the chapter summaries, the tone of philosophical dialogue), it was as if Wittgenstein's paradox about rules gave Feyerabend permission to explore how this paradox could be applied to the scientific method I liked how bhobba gave some real experience perspective, so in the spirit of "anything goes" (not literally, but of course within the limits of what we are doing), I'll try to add whatever real experience I can, right now I'm teaching someone writing, she wanted help from an assignment given to her by an online class, she had to read a pro/con short essay about whether or not GMOs are good to eat or not, and then her school had her read an ESSAY SUMMARIZING the PROs-CONs of GMO FOODS, and students were asked to choose a side and write a persuasive essay using evidence from the ESSAY, we went over it, found several errors, realized the essay was outdated, also the ESSAY didn't include any evidence whatsoever, just kept making claims without explaining any of them, so her and I started talking about what it means to analyze an essay and evaluate it for substance and quality and etc (her and I will go over a more basic topic for persuasive essay, which character from The Office was the best, state 3 reasons and defend, more light hearted and can focus on having fun, rather than needing to double check the school's essay for accuracy...) anyway, the other thing I was going to do was research and write my own short essay summarizing GMO foods, to show her what a higher quality summary can look like and OMG... this topic is definitely not the first topic to start practicing writing a persuasive essay, to speedrun things, I watched about 5 YT videos from big creators, and many cited that the GMO debate is THE most contentious debates, all of them reached the same conclusion (using the same mega meta-analysis study that collected 100s of research studies), that said that GMO foods had no greater risk than non-GMO foods, and many videos made the connection that it's actually the Big Agricultural companies that people are against (using too many pesticides, legally owning seeds so farmers can't just use their own, forcing farmers to always buy more, etc) Well, 1) doesn't that mean that YT "educators" or "journalists" can have an analogous function as scientists, amplifying a particular conclusion C based on a particular theory T that relies on a set of facts F? Each big YT channel came to the same conclusion C (satisfying the CONSISTENCY CONDITION), but an alternative hypothesis may go like this, "well, sure let's say that conclusion C is true (no greater risk to health with GMO versus non-GMO foods), but... what about the conclusion of whether GMO foods provide equal or better nutritional value relative to non-GMO foods? logically, increasing crop yield and overfarming would mean that next year's harvest must necessarily have less nutrients than the previous year's harvest (it's a density issue), and there are definitely observational studies that show that nutritional content has decreased over the years for tomatoes for example (based on my own experience, store bought tomatoes just don't hit hard with flavor, neither do strawberries, but freshly picked strawberries from a friend's little farm, that hits the spot) so, here you have evidence to support an alternative conclusion based on an alternative hypothesis (it's not that GMO foods make anyone sick, it's just one side effect may be less nutrition, simply based on trying to mass produce a billion tomatoes, which doesn't even have to get genetics involved, unless the tomatoes are specifically genetically engineered to increase crop yield and etc) and what would the public's reaction be if someone used a mega phone to conclude the alternative hypothesis? (assuming it was rigorously verified and evidenced provided and etc), people may say, "well, ok, they won't make me sick, but if I had a choice, I'd prefer the food with more nutrients, so... I would prefer non-GMO just based on that", and this ACTION goes further than what Feyeraband was simply trying to outline, that we should use more than just rationality and logic to progress science, and here I am kind of presenting an extended version of "yeah yeah, we are just going to use the scientific method meta-analysis, and amplify one friendly message, so that people can take ACTION" I thought this YT science education-journalism was akin to the BANKING MODEL OF EDUCATION that Lizz brought up (the idea of just deposit ideas into the minds of the students, have them memorize a few key ideas, instead of critical thinking), that's not to say that the YT channels are not without critical thinking, their other research did a lot of good creative exploration and provided a lot of context, nor am I saying any YT did this with intention to deposit ideas, this is just commenting on that no video actually did a deep dive on the mega meta-analysis and researched if there were any CONFLICTS OF INTEREST (i personally don't know), any HISTORY OF OTHER MAJOR REPORTS GIVING SOFT CONCLUSIONS TO EASE THE PUBLIC (this is), the mega meta-analysis was simply taken as fact without critical review, and then their videos were built around that conclusion so now, I'm like, "let me just do simple Which is your Favorite Character from The Office essay with the student" and maybe later once she developed some basic writing skills, we can come back to this idea of Banking Model of Education and even mention a bit of "Against Method" (her school just recycles the same ESSAY written in 2016 and copies and pastes it to all the other students and expects them to write a persuasive essay, this student felt the essay was something that she could have written as a high school student, and the assignment was just "performative" (her words) and so there wasn't a lot of motivation to get the assignment done, i apologize for going off topic a bit, but after writing about my own experiences, a lot of students simply don't have the time to sit down and consider alternative methods or hypotheses, they are stressed and burned out and can only simply do what they are asked to do without excitement, they are stressed to PERFORM, but rarely excited to think or become curious (I'm not the primary teaacher, these students already are enrolled in classes or universities, and come to me with help, and if there is enough time, we try our best to cultivate that curiosity), but isn't it curiosity that must be there in order for Feyeraband's vision of trying out alternative hypotheses or trying different methods, for that vision to happen, curosity seems to be a necessary condition

Matías López

This book is getting to me. It's like some kind of legitimacy over my academic trajectory. I've started in sociology, and I grew bore and displeased on the intellectual laziness that was the norm there. I studied history, and didn't fit in because I was too chaotic, not so fact-oriented (although I graduated with the best average and received a special diploma and stuff). The rigid structure of investigation just kills all the joy that I get from learning new stuff and applying it to my daily practice. And I think I would enjoy a lot more an anarchistic university haha. I'll keep on reading. It's a very pleasent book.

Matías López

"Does anyone else notice this (or something similar) in themselves? I’m curious what different kinds of circumstances have facilitated self-awareness of that reflex for people. " About this, I think that building a safe space with my partner (that is also a pedant scholar in rehabilitation) and teaching to teenagers made me self-aware of that ""rational"" reflex and how violent it is. I'll try to elaborate, though it is hard, because it's been some time since I've entered the "scholarly mood" and I've tried to remove that from my life. The mindset of rationality means there is only one rational truth, or at least that there is a hierarchy. Thus, if you start an argument, there will be a winner and a looser. And when I started trying to build equalitarian relationships (both with my partner and somehow with my students, because verticality is still there with them), I began to see how that was just a lose-lose situation. How can I win something by making my partner loose? How can I teach something to a student with whom I am debating if I make him loose the argument? It ceases to be about a common search for understanding, and it starts to be about winning a discussion. So I found myself more and more just following the thoughts of the other person (be it my partner or my students) and watching what could I learn from that, rather than seeking to demonstrate my point. I think something that helped me a lot is "Ethical Slut" from Dossie Easton and Janet Hardy. Much of our way of interacting in close relationships is also created from verticality, and being able to imagine non-hierarchycal relationships with different persons also helped me become more non-hierarchical with different theories (I bring this up in the anarchistic spirit of the book).

Amanda

Loving this book so far and Feyerabend feels kinda sassy to me... the context of originally being letters to his friend is so sweet :) Honestly, so far the ideas in these chapters brings to mind exploration of identities and learning about oneself/the world through experiences with school, community, and media. The concept of reality as a "maze of interactions" full of random/unpredictable causes and effects and varying interpretations of "facts"/ideas really resonates. The process of devleoping a sense of self with intersecting identities are formed through a lifetime of interactions and lessons (academic, social, etc) that are random and affect each other - and do not fit within a set or strict, linear steps or rules. A bit of a departure from the scientific context, but this is where my mind goes haha. The concept of counterrules also made me think of queer representation in media, the role models and examples of diverse experiences and lifestyles that make us feel like "oh, if that exists then maybe I could do that too." A novel idea and potential future is discovered and promotes a new way of thinking that might not have been explored without that alternative theory... does this make sense? Let me know!

Alex Mader

I am so excited to be back into this book. The first four chapters are especially powerful to me. With the Analytical Index being one of my favorite sections of any book ever. It inspired me to try a similar approach for my own thesis when I first read the book ~4 years ago, and now as I approach the end of my PhD it has been re-invigorating to read it again. There is so much to chew over in these 4 chapters alone, and I expect much of our future discussions will circle back to them. I remember my first reaction to the analytical index was being impressed at the bravery of placing one's arguments right up front in plain text. What a valuable tool to both the reader and critic who wants to actually understand what Feyerabend is trying to say. I wish it wasn't such a hard thing to pull off in my own writing.

Preethi Basani

Sorry for the super late response, I forgot to come respond on Monday! I had a lot of trouble following due to the denseness as well as being tired so I probably misinterpreted/misunderstood a lot and this is mostly from an American academia perspective but here are a few (unrelated?) thoughts from what I gathered: 1) I haven't read much about anarchism but I am unconvinced by the version Paul Feyerabend(PF) describes “Professional anarchists oppose any kind of restriction…laws, duties or obligations”. I think that as members of a community, we do have duties and obligations to other members in our communities. Favoring individualism over building community will leave the most vulnerable members of our communities behind. This may not be what PF is trying to say but this is how I interpreted it from reading the introduction. 2)This makes me hesitant to accept applying this version of anarchism to doing science as I am worried that “anything goes” opens up a pathway to misuse science to justify oppression. Eugenics, and anti-trans journal papers come to mind. I also wonder what would happen to the ethical standards in science that protect us from things like the stanford prison experiment from happening again. I’m curious to see how PF will tackle these questions. He does touch on "politically enforced dualism" in china. Perhaps that can prevent harmful ideas like this from taking root. Perhaps ethical standards should be a more political endeavor outside the purview of the "scientific" 3) I feel like a lot of the way Physics(I’m a physicist so I’ll stick with what I know) is done seems to be focused on making very precise and accurate precisions down to a ridiculous number of decimal points. (like you talk about in your exoplanet video and this post) This feels very in line with the line of thinking that PF critiques in these chapters. Focusing solely on predictive power seems to naturally lend to keeping the status quo protected and looking for counter examples to it while excluding any logically inconsistent alternatives. 4)I like the idea of not having one valid way to do science. My own research is about looking for parallels between condensed matter systems and gravitational systems and tends to be a lot more qualitative than quantitative, driven by trying to find cool phenomena rather than trying to make predictions. like PF suggests I feel like having many different perspectives on the same thing can be very valuable. 5) His discussion about "progress" towards the end of chapter 1 and thinking about how contemporary physics is generally done (see point 3) made me think about why people do science in the first place. It seems that a lot of Physicists I encounter seem to care most about making a model that best fits the experimental data that we have already. While others seem motivated by making things that make them most successful in a capitalist society (ex chatGPT/p much any tech thing). Others seem motivated by imperialist goals (ex: massive amounts of DoD and DoE spending in physics). I like PFs goal for this book (but can also apply to science): "I wanted to support people, not to “advance knowledge”." 5.5) I personally think I do physics because I like finding connections between seemingly unrelated things and I like discovering cool things for the sake of them being cool, but I'm not entirely sure how it would "support people" as much as I'd like for it to. One could also critique this by pointing out that a lot of people who fall into the other motivations I mentioned above could also be motivated by internal curiosity. I'm still trying to find a balance between my internal curiosity for interesting things with supporting communities and avoiding doing research that can cause harm.

Preethi Basani

I agree that communication is lossy, and constantly cycling out theories for new ones feels unsustainable. But, here is an example of how one of my favorite physics professors from undergrad organized it. A similar thing was talked about at some point in chapters 1-4 of this book(perhaps this could be an example of a more sustainable way to implement Feyerabend's ideas): Where possible given time and syllabus (not in his control) constrains, He would start with the historical context of the physical problem/system being studied. He would first go over initial experiments, their interpretations and the theories that went along with them. He would then talk about what theories overthrew them along with new experimental data that came along side it. Finally when he got to the status quo, he would talk about a fews alternative, logically inconsistent but equally valid theories that aren't as widely accepted. We would then discuss in discussions the various different theories and what they philosophically imply and why the status quo may have been favored over them. It was constantly stressed that the status quo was not that way due to any empirical reason, but rather aesthetic or historical reasons. The course was called history of modern physics, so it did lend itself more to this structure. But it did prepare me well to understand the many different perspectives in physics and question my assumptions when doing physics while also making me able to communicate with other physicists because we also learnt about the status quo.

David Roanleigh

Also sorry for the late reply, I've started a response several times and been distracted (new baby in the house!). I'd also like to agree with the comments about enjoying Feyerabend's sassy commentary, even through his dense prose. I think it lends a touch of humanity to an otherwise heady, academic discussion. It also, whether intentional or just his personality, puts his critique of science methodology into action be indirectly challenging the supposedly objective language in the usual "hard" science texts. That being said, I've also been reminded of how exhausting reading this kind of verbose yet precise (I assume) philosophy can be! I'd like to say that the main takeaway I have from this first section is that it reminds me of the.... dichotomy (? not sure if that's the best word to use...) that arises from his thesis, that science is an inherently anarchic enterprise. We're faced with a potential binary (though that's probably a result of my oversimplification) of "anything goes" system vs a rigid law and order system. I've run into this perceived binary in healthcare where the needs of an individual (anything goes) are pitted against the needs of the population (need for rigid rules). In the past I've more or less seen this settled by a sort of compromise that we do "basic science" by the rules until a "revolution" comes along by the super awesome rare individual (Thomas Kuhn's work) My understanding of anarchism is that it's primary (if not only) limit on individual liberty (or hypotheses in this context) is a prohibition on imposed hierarchy. Historically, much of this scientific philosophy inquiry came about as the scientific method used in chemistry and physics was applied to psychology or economics. The "hard" sciences to the "soft" sciences. In this sense, I'm 100% on board with Feyerabend rejection of this framing. I think the friction we tend to feel with his all in stance is we all recognize the strict rules and order that are required for the successful practice of science - especially as it pertains to our technology/engineering work we see in our every day. Ok, that's all I'm getting down at the moment. Thank you all! ~David

Nathaniel Bookout

edit: thanks to Emilia 22 for pointing this out, I think I got a different edition too. I'm talking about the Introduction by Ian Hacking from the 2010 edition here. I'll add the quote about Sontag below: "A postscript to the first letter says he is thinking of calling his anti-Kuhn paper 'Against Method', adding parenthetically 'this is in analogy to Susan Sontag's 'Against Interpretation'.'" I've been wanting to dig into Kuhn, so this is perfect. I didn't realize Feyerabend was in part a response to him. And I love the Sontag reference in the Introduction by Ian Hacking: "Against Interpretation" is also a fascinating read. In part because it's so nonsensically written, especially her most well-known essay from that collection, "Notes on Camp". Since I read it recently, I think it would be interesting to compare Sontag with Feyerabend a little bit. One of the main concerns in her essay on Camp is what it means to analyze a sensibility. "Taste has no system and no proofs. But there is something like a logic of taste: the consistent sensibility which underlies and gives rise to a certain taste. A sensibility is almost, but not quite, ineffable. Any sensibility which can be crammed into the mold of a system, or handled with the rough tools of proof, is no longer a sensibility at all. It has hardened into an idea..." -Sontag I wonder if one way to describe what Feyeraband is arguing here is as a sensibility, a matter of "scientific taste". There's the scientific method, as he deconstructs in his critique on the limits of methodologies. And then there's a scientific sensibility, which is what he's actually arguing for, which says that pluralism and counterinduction are as important for knowledge as empiricism. And I think one of his most important points about this scientific sensibility is its fundamental conflict with power, as institutions will take scientific ideas and turn them into rigid, orthodox traditions. That's why anarchism is consistent with a scientific sensibility, because it will never accept the de facto relationship between scientific orthodoxy, and power.

Nathaniel Bookout

I think the role of individualism in anarchist philosophy is important to consider, as you do here. Individualism absolutely has the danger of falling into the oppressive trap you describe. That's why, to me, an important component of anarchism is distinguishing pure individualism from a critique of power. Some anarchists might reject "laws, duties, or obligations" on principle, as individualists, true. But the epistemic reason to reject them, as Feyerabend argues, isn't individualism in my opinion, but a recognition of the fact that laws, duties, and obligations don't exist as a result of the rational, democratic process of a liberal community. All liberalism is based on the pretense that society is built on a foundation of freedom and equality; a freedom and equality that comes at the cost of the lives of anyone who isn't "a free citizen", in the form of global imperialism. Individualist anarchism can easily be misled by things like eugenics, but I think that an anarchist perspective that treats any structure of power--including individualism--with a critical eye is not likely to do that. Any new orthodoxy that imposes something like eugenics would simply no longer be anarchist, really. It would be some form of state power, defining what is considered orthodox and non-orthodox knowledge, which is just another form of liberalism.

Preethi Basani

Just had another thought: The way politics in the two party system is done in the US feels also in the same vain of rejecting alternate ideas until something groundbreaking shifts the status quo. Things like universal healthcare or not committing a genocide are consider radical/fringe ideas that could never be mainstream in the same way that an alternate scientific theory that is logically inconsistent is considered fringe/pseudoscience. I wonder if part of this rejection of Feyerabend's ideas in the way we do science also comes from protecting the political status quo. Perhaps admitting that science doesn't need groundbreaking revolutions to change would make them open minded to new political ideas as well. Of course there's a multitude of factors at play here but I wonder if this is one of them.

Preethi Basani

I am extremely uneducated on anarchism, so this might be a basic question. How do communities keep each other accountable and prevent things like individualism from taking root when there is a rejection of principles, laws and obligations in practice?

Contraryon

For political anarchism, I don’t think that Feyerabend’s characterization is solid; it lacks a lot of consequential nuances. Now, to be fair, this isn’t because he’s ignorant of those nuances—I just think he’s being a bit abrasive—the idea of having responsibilities towards one another does not contradict most anarchist thought. In any case, it seems to me that Feyerabend’s relationship with political anarchism is somewhat complicated. My read on his intent is that he wants to point out a perceived contradiction between the positions taken by anarchism as a political movement and the mentality of some anarchists when it comes to the primacy of science. Anarchists, like Marxists, take a kind of Hegelian view of social order, but a positivist approach to science and technology. Basically, Feyerabend is saying “I don’t like anarchism as politics, but it definitely is good for science” and he imagines the anarchist to say the inverse. Of course, I should be clear that I don’t think he’s making any political argument at all. Regarding whether to favor the individual over community, the question I would pose would be this: is anyone more vulnerable than solitary person in a room with ninety-nine others who are debating whether they even count as a person? More to the point: what is the relative value of that person’s welfare compared to the other ninety-nine? This is why it sucks to be a utilitarian—you must tabulate and code human experience. It becomes, sooner or later, an exercise in comparative suffering. For my part, I think it's a false dichotomy: any theory that trades one person’s welfare for another’s, whether it’s one person or ninety-nine, is bad theory no matter how much unimpeachable data has been gathered. I would argue that it is substantially a desire to protect a community that has driven our greatest tragedies, especially if we start seeing our collective group identities as zero sum conflicts. Eugenics, transphobia, and misogyny are all attempts by communities to maintain particular identity—to maintain cohesion. Now, as far as “anything goes” is concerned, I really think Feyerabend would have done better to just go straight to the source. Aleister Crowley said, “Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the Law,” but this was to be in the pursuit harmony with the universe, which includes other people. I think there is a quality of ethical framework that can come out of the idea that I have individual responsibilities towards individuals rather than to any particular group—a kind of diffuse parasocialism, as opposed to contingent group memberships. Although, I will say this: the individual engenders the very idea of ‘consternation.’

32 Emilia 32

ok im really late because i accidentally got the edition with a foreword and 3 prefaces, so I had to read 64 pages in total. I just have a few quick disconnected thoughts: 1) I really resonate with with what he's saying about science and its history being inseparable. It's a logical conclusion of the general idea that empiric facts and theories aren't objective truths, but I never thought about it in this way. I did catch myself being slightly annoyed by this too, just because it cements the people that were important in science history into science itself. That includes people who, I would argue, don't deserve remembering and also it highlights the many biases of science. There was comfort in the idea that science is this transcendental truth that is built by scientists but will long outlive them, because it's not connected to their values and ideas, it's just facts they happened to discover! But i do agree with Feyerabend that that comfort is false and after all it's better to critically engage with something (like the people who have shaped scientific theories, but this applies to any field) than to ignore half the picture. 2) It's sad that he outright dismisses (and in my opinion mischaracterizes) anarchism in political theory :( 3) but I liked that he conceded how important politics are in science (in ch.4 esp.) 4) And also also here are my two favorite quotes so far: "To make the weaker case the stronger and thereby to sustain the motion of the whole" (p.14) This reminded me of the movie Challengers hahaha "We need a dream-world in order to discover the features of the real world we think we inhabit (and which may actually be just another dream-world)." (p.15) I think that is not just a great argument for pluralism, but also a compelling take on fiction as a whole. I'm currently writing on an essay on Escapism in art (videogames especially) and I will probably quote the dream-world section in there :)) PS: does anybody know what he means when he says "chimera"? I imagine it means something specific in the context of philosophy maybe? o.O

32 Emilia 32

wow that sounds like a great teacher !

Nathaniel Bookout

I think I got the same edition, lol I agree about anarchism, but I sort of get the impression he's talking about a specific brand of white, European anarchism maybe? Which has very different roots than the queer/feminist/civil rights anarchism that sprang up in the US in the 60s and 70s.

Nathaniel Bookout

I agree with Contraryon that it seems like Feyerabend's issue with anarchism would be anarchist positivism, and their false use of science, though I wouldn't call Marx an anarchist. For anarchism to truly work it must be decolonized, alongside science. Crowley is a good example of anarchist philosophy at work. The feminist revival of witchcraft is another. The civil rights movement had anarchist roots and ideals, in part (the Black Panthers most specifically). As did the gay liberation movement. All of these are examples of uniting against hierarchy, through solidarity. I think the easiest way to summarize what I meant by individualism is that feels like a certain version of white, Enlightenment philosophy, that stands opposed to what is a much older form of anarchist politics built on individuals in community.

Preethi Basani

Your comment about having to let go of the comfort of science being a set of facts that are disconnected from the discoverer made me think about how if at all we should be engaging with theories from awful people? A big example that comes to mind is Heisenberg who was a nazi. Do we engage with it as an idea on its own? Do we critically examine the idea in the context from which it came from and how would that look like? Or do we not engage and abandon it for an alternate idea (which would most likely also require abandoning the contemporary interpretation of quantum mechanics)? In other words in the world of anything goes is there any ideas worth not engaging with or considering regardless of there utility?

Saoirse

I haven't had a chance to start this one yet, but reading the thoughtful comments here is so inspiring! Makes me want to have an in-person philosophy salon with y'all haha

Zachery Sanders

Yes this resonates with me. The rationality I grew up with was one of conflict and refinement through that conflict. But that worldview was severely challenged by kind of parallax view (so to speak) of living in a foreign country and being schooled by a loved one that "sometimes it isn't about right and wrong, it about how people feel". I left the teaching life, but what you describe is something I really miss about it, exploring together with minds that are awkward, tentative, unsure, but usually pretty open to explore the possibilities.

Zachery Sanders

My early ideas of science were shaped by my father, “a biological psychologist” who didn’t do “touchy feely psychology”. Science was something firm, certain, rigid, refined, and ordered. That never sat well with me (or the other way around). So I found myself in literature, the arts, and philosophy. It wasn’t until much later I discovered intense beautiful uncertainties in Stephan Jay Gould and Francois Jacob. With the publication of Logocomix I discovered a similar take on mathematics and logic. From there I read Popper, Kuhn, and Dennett. Reading Feyerabend brought a lot of this to mind. Especially Gould’s piece on Kirkpatrick: “I respect Kirkpatrick both for his sponges and for his numinous nummulosphere. It is easy to dismiss a crazy theory with laughter that debars any attempt to understand a man's motivation—and the nummulosphere is a crazy theory. I find that few men of imagination are not worth my attention. Their ideas may be wrong, even foolish, but their methods often repay a close study. […] The different drummer often beats a fruitful tempo.” That method, results, facts, and interpretations are aligned and limit or focus the way one can look at and question reality made me think of the first chapter of The Dao. I like how Roger Ames and David Hall’s translate "dao" as “way-making”, but there’s an astonishing 175 translation of the first part here: https://www.bopsecrets.org/gateway/passages/tao-te-ching.htm The general idea that any description of reality remains just that, and while a description is part of reality, it is only a part (Jorge Luis Borges points absurdly to the possibility of descriptive power with a 1 to 1 scale map in “On Exactitude in Science” - https://kwarc.info/teaching/TDM/Borges.pdf Both and Not at the same time is a concept I didn’t ever see in science until much later in life, and I wished I’d seen it sooner. I kept wondering through this reading (and in my life as a teacher) that while outright dismissal is usually not productive, what approach to take with conspiracy theorists, ancient civilization alien believers, and general science deniers. How do they fit into all of this? I too liked the Analytical Index, but was also terrified and overwhelmed by it. I liked it a lot more in the context of floating text above the chapter rather than collected as a list/table of contents. Also it reminded me of Mo Yan’s Life and Death are Wearing Me Out- Each chapter title serves as a kind of Chinese Communist Propaganda, a summary of what will happen, and an interpretive key. Keys are a kind of emblem, and like the explanation of “anything goes” (in the many introductions!), they make the most sense in the larger context of what is being said. For this book, ‘anything goes” is important not just in the content of what’s said in the chapter, but also in the context of his friendship with Lakatos. And it is this context that I find relevant and important in ways that science is done and in why it is done. Italo Calvino’s Invisible Cities relates that in the first conversations between Marco Polo and Kublai Khan, Polo uses props, sounds, or gestures/actions to describe the cities of Khan’s empire. In later conversations these become emblems and build in complexity. Each “new fact received a meaning from that emblem and also added to the emblem a new meaning”. All of this leads to Kublai Khan asking, “On the day when I know all the emblems… shall I be able to posses my empire, at last?’ And the Venetian answered” ‘Sire, do not believe it. On that day you will be an emblem among emblems.” Feyerabend similarly writes; “Knowledge so conceived is not a series of self-consistent theories that converges towards an ideal view; it is not a gradual approach to the truth. It is rather an ever increasing ocean of mutually incompatible alternatives, each single theory, each fairy-tale, each myth that is part of the collection forcing the others into greater articulation and all of them contributing, via this process of competition, to the development of our consciousness.”

Zachery Sanders

I love the Sontag quote! Thanks. As a sourdough bread making enthusiast, the metaphor of natural sourdough - it's fermentation/culturing, it's proofing to grow, how it can be molded with some but arguably never as intended, the hardening, and the resulting taste--- is so ripe. Natural sourdough is more interesting in it's tastes. Baker's yeast more consistent in it's output....

Zachery Sanders

5.5 is a doozy. I'm not sure there's an out. While teaching in US public schools I kept telling myself I'm doing this for my students of color and for students whose identities are often marginalized and oppressed. The issue I kept coming up against and could find a good answer to was how much I was helping and how much I was harming by upholding the white supremacist systems still firmly in place in the US public schools. Feyerabend's take though at least feels a little hopeful to me.

Contraryon

@Nathaniel Bookout > though I wouldn't call Marx an anarchist In the interest of protecting my honor, I meant "like Marx" in the sense of drawing on some of the same source material, not that Marx himself was an anarchist.

Matías López

Hello Zachery! In what level of education are you a teacher? I also face that dilemma! Here it's common that, in the context of ESI (Integral Sexual Education) students spring to question "what about biology" in a very transphobic way. There was this really talented student that uphel that view. My trigger reaction was to say that she had biologicist and transphobic views (such thing is true) but, by virtue of naming that, and using my power as teacher to dismiss her view, that attitudr could've cemented not only in views, but in identity (like, it would be rebel to dismiss the "woke" teacher and deep dive into right wing discourse). So I just answered the question of "what about biology" with "I don't know a single bit about biology. I am a history teacher. Shall we learn what biology says?" and started searching medic or biology papers and thesis on the topic (unsurprisingly, there were a lot), and we studied and discussed that together. It took quite some time, but by the end ot it, both my student and me had a deeper understanding of both biology and society, and the anti-science horrors of those pundits that speak about biology and trans people without knowing a fuck about anything.

Matías López

So, in syntesis: 1. I take my students seriously. 1.a) If I don't know about a topic, we research it together. 1.b) If I do know, I offer a practical work in which the student contrasts its own source of information with writings I offer on the topic, and we discuss honestly. Simple, though it requires some time. If the student is dishonest and only wants to troll, you've dissarmed him! Next time he brings the question, its easy to ask "I don't know, did you study it? What do you think now? Why?

Matías López

I think that Chimera is just in the loose sense of a mitical creature/someting ilusional that deviates from truth. He is quite ambiguous on purpose so I don't think he was thinking the therm in a tecnical way

Matías López

Yes, it does make sense! That's why interaction between society and academia brings what the author is searching for: new perspectives that clash against the current dogma

Nathaniel Bookout

This was a really interesting post. I especially love your reference to the Tao Te Ching and other Chinese thought. Personally, I think the Tao is one of the most interesting examples of "ancient science" we can look back on, in the way Feyerabend is advocating. And I really need to read Invisible Cities now. Also, I really loved the story about Matias's student. "What about biology?" is a reflection of a shift in scientific paradigms, as Thomas Kuhn would say. It's just the old paradigm asserting itself, completely ignorant of the empirical context of the new. Just like the Catholic Church did with Galileo. So I think one of the most interesting things to get from Feyerabend is the question: "how do we deal with paradigm shifts?" Do we just try to justify them rationally? But that doesn't work, because holding a paradigm to be true is a normative decision, not one you make rationally. It's a judgement call. So do we make moral judgements instead? Pressuring people by calling them transphobes if they don't agree with us? But that doesn't work entirely, either. What I think Feyerabend is advocating, and what you demonstrate well, is something in between. He doesn't favor using either rationalism or relativism, exclusively; he explicitly advocates for using both. There are a few important epistemic questions at the heart of TERF ideology. The issue many people fail to recognize is that they're rooted in the same philosophy as trans and queer identities themselves are, queer and feminist thought of the 60s and 70s. "What about biology?" is just the other side of the coin of "What about gender?", and its logical extension, "What about hierarchy?" some of the original questions of the feminist movement. "Gender is a social construct" can be interpreted many ways. Some radical feminists would say that any performance of gender reinforces patriarchal norms, a common TERF reasoning. Many other feminists would say we might not be able to *not* perform gender; we're all performing something. It's just a question of what you perform, and whether it's consistent with the label you're supposed to have. I think this is more like what Judith Butler would say.

Matías López

"I'm all for playing around with contradiction, I think that's part of the engine of science. "Anything goes" when you're trying out new ideas, but if you aren't speaking the same language as your peers, your ideas can't travel." I think that part of the point of the author is trying to convince people to be more open to new ideas, putting the responsibility of the comprehension of new theories also in other scientists, not only in the one that publishes the new idea. It's a call to not dismiss something just because it doesn't fit in the dogma, and when something doesn't fit in the dogma, it doesn't matter how well communicated it is, if the people upholding the traditional view on science don't want to listen.

Matías López

I was just going to comment on the ideas of the author in relationship to Freire's, so I'll put it in here :D. The author says "The answer is clear: we cannot discover it (the world we presuppose) from the inside. We need an external standard of criticism, we need a set of alternative assumptions or, as these assumptions will be quite general, constituting, as it were, an entire alternative world, we need a dream-world in order to discover the features of the real world we think we inhabit". The dream world, the external standard of criticism that Feyerabend seeks already exists, and is the society surrounding academia. I just started my semester in a new career, and inscribed myself in “Taller de Aprendizaje y participación Comunitaria” (workshop of learning and community participation). The whole purpose of that subject es to know the “territorio” (territory, the concept has other weight that I cannot explain) of the university, and work with some of the social actors that try to enact a social change here in José C. Paz. It’s prerequisite to an annual subject that invites the students to investigate and work with social actors of José C Paz. It’s in line with the current “learning in movement”, and with the Freirean critique of bancary education, and I think that this nails what the author was looking for: it’s the external standard of criticism from which we can learn, interact and question our own assumptions, formulate new theories and keep the science in movement. Just imagine that each and every university career has that: mandatory participation in the social movements of near the campus. That can give the life Feyerabend seeks. (P.S: Here there are quite some bit of political/social/scholarly currents that take Freire's proposals as point of start for a new way to create knowledge, that's why in my English career I have one year and a half of community participation). (P.S2: I know people from Bangladesh, and now that the government fell, the universities are giving credits to students that help the community to maintain order and function amidst the power vacuum (there is no longer police for now in Bangladesh))

Zachery Sanders

While in the world of education Pedagogy of the Oppressed came up so many times, and I haven't had a chance yet to read it yet. I'm interested in the idea of trauma as a basis for stunting or stifling. I agree that kinds of trauma as experienced by certain intersections of identity do lead to this security blanket of stagnation. I also think though, for other intersections, at least in my experience, that trauma has also been an impetus to challenge, confront, and seek change. Looking at trauma and impact on science is very interesting and I'll be looking more towards things with this frame.

C S

I have been apprehensive about this book for years because I loved Kuhn's book. Kuhn spent the rest of his days trying to clarify the appropriate limits of his insights as Feyerabend went wild with them. Feyerabend complicates the neat paradigm cycle and forces us to see that the knowledge game is a messy one. The author doesn't disappoint, I think the book will continue destabilizing my sense of epistemic authority.

phil e the theyby

Ok, finally got to read this! Yeah, this book is DENSE to read after a full day of work/childcare and putting the kids to bed. But when I actually process what it’s saying, this feels like both a gut punch and a breath of fresh air. Obviously these chapters focus on scientific inquiry, but I feel like it really echoes a lot of what I’ve been thinking about regarding…inquiry in general? Especially into humans. I’ve started to really look for the kernel of truth or validity in everything I hear people say or do, and I’ve gotta say, that shit opens my eyes. Even when, say, a politician I hate makes a statement that is completely factually wrong and harmful, I know they’re saying it because it resonates with SOMEONE’S perspective and experience. And rather than writing those people off as stupid (because “stupid” is a concept I genuinely don’t believe in), I try to really imagine: what are conditions that would make me think the same things? I feel like this has drastically expanded my empathy and my patience. My main issue with it is that I know my perspectives, ideas, and interpretations are deeply limited. I’m able to continuously find this common ground, but there’s still always this sense that I’m missing something. Also, what is my process ITSELF missing? I feel like these are questions I can only answer in the context of interactions with other people. But I think everyone I talk to is so starved for any possibility of unity and empathy that they take my way of doing things as super awesome and amazing in all ways. To me, all of this sounds super intellectualizing as I type it out. I try to actually engage with this process in an emotional, embodied way, rather than something that’s purely intellectual. But honestly, I would LOVE to be challenged on my process and just bring in more lenses and perspectives to how I look at things. So yeah, this book club definitely needs to just start a philosophy cafe or something 😂

phil e the theyby

Matías, this is SUCH an amazing story, and I love both your introspection and the way you responded to the student. We BADLY need to take people’s questions and curiosity seriously (especially children’s), and to honor and foster them. And I not only agree that it can be disarming to folks who are intentionally trolling; I’ll take it farther and say I think it might actually be MORE important with them. People troll because they feel like they’re wrapped up in some kind of culture war. If you show them that you’re not interested in a war, and that you actually care about what they think and want to honor their questions and uncertainty, it can break down the pain and confusion that’s leading them to troll in the first place. It won’t happen every time (the person needs to open their heart to the invitation you give), but it can, and it’s absolutely worth trying whenever we have the opportunity.

phil e the theyby

Preethi, I think his argument is to engage with all theories not only by awful people, but with theories that are in themselves awful. I’m talking phrenology and eugenics kind of shit. But rather than how traditional science has engaged with them (that is, “is this true as a complete theory explaining the nature of humanity”) and more, “what is the truth that exists within this theory and where is it useful?” (though I don’t know how much he cares about that “useful” part; that’s more what I take away from it). How I’m thinking about this in a not-particularly-scientific theory is something like when a politician says, “immigrants are making our country unsafe, stealing our jobs, and poisoning the blood of our country” (I’m in the U.S., so yeah…this kind of “theory” is definitely prevalent here). This is horribly offensive and factually inaccurate on so, SO many levels. But to me, it seems like it tells us some things that ARE meaningful: 1) White (and some BIPOC) Americans don’t understand cultural differences or know how to honor or effectively communicate with people from different cultures. 2) A lot of Americans feel really insecure about their jobs and, as a consequence, their ability to ensure that their basic needs for food, shelter, and medical care are met. I guess I’m reading “anything goes” as being about stopping the search for “what is the one objective truth,” to focus on “what value does any given theory have to help us make sense of the world around us, especially in ways our existing theories can’t?” It’s about finding the nugget of truth in ANYTHING, even things that are super offensive and awful. But I may be completely misinterpreting what Feyerabend means; we’ll see as the chapters go on 🙃

phil e the theyby

I feel like both are a manifestation of the same problem: global Western imperialism has formed the foundations of how we think, both scientifically and politically. I think resistance to both political challenge and Feyerabend’s approach serve the same purpose, which is that both of these challenges are fundamentally threatening to the entire fabric of the status quo. If you allow a process that gives anyone’s voice power, the people in power reflexively reject it because it would challenge their power. And I don’t think they do that because they’re uniquely evil, power-hungry people; I think they do it because having the entire framework of your ideology collapse is existentially terrifying.

phil e the theyby

I have such mixed feelings around what you’re saying about the scholarly life! I absolutely agree with you that a lot of the ways “rationality” functions in traditional education operates from a hierarchical, “one right way” pattern of thought. But I also feel like I have this image of a “scholar” as someone who’s supposed to break down their preconceived assumptions and really look at what’s happening in front of them, to question where things come from, and to think critically about the world. Is that what actually happens? Not very often, no. But when I try to think, “what’s the closest ‘stereotype’ I have to the kind of person who would engage with knowledge the way Feyerabend is talking about?”, the image that comes to mind is a “curious scientist.” Or like, a mathematician who’s laying out their fundamental axioms and assumptions. The second image that comes to mind is some sort of wanderer or traveler who’s seeking the truth…the problem I have with that stereotype is that there’s always this image of them essentially FINDING the truth, which clearly isn’t happening in any absolute sense. All that to say, I think your criticism of scholars and the academic realm are 100% valid, and I also feel there’s something in the stated (but not always practiced) values of academia that is actually super important and helpful, and is rare to find in other places in society.

Preethi Basani

As someone who wants to do this but has been struggling to do this for a while now, what do we do from there(after empathizing)? For example, as a trans woman, I can see what upbringing/circumstances might lead to someone being a terf and understand their perspective. But how can I find common ground with them when they deny my existence and humanity and I will not compromise that? What happens after i empathize? How do we proceed in community if we can’t find common ground?

Zachery Sanders

@Matías - I left the teaching world (although does one ever?) I taught for about 15 years in private and public. Private mostly high school and public mostly middle school. Your story and those wonderful, time consuming, difficult moments are the main thing I miss from teaching. I could go on about that for some time, but as this relates to Feyerabend, the idea of “anything goes” is tongue in cheek rather than literal. There needs to be a method to the “madness” (I really hope this doesn’t make me a Polonius….). The last school I taught for a variety of socio-economic, race, and trauma reasons students were disengaged and the main challenge was reconnecting any kind of joy for exploring and learning. And it was a constant game of pin the tail on the donkey- each new student and situation seemed like it needed entirely new ways of approaching it. And Wow, was that all exhausting. @Nathaniel Thanks for the kind words! Invisible Cities is worth a read, although like many of his other works, it can be a little difficult to get through if you’re not into alternative and fragmented narrative styles. I’m still not sure about paradigm shifts, sometimes I believe were so enmeshed that we can’t see beyond and to me the alternatives in the “aboutisms” might be contained within the current paradigms of gender (or any other issue). Other times, I think maybe alternatives are the thinking on the edge of a paradigm about to breakout and reshape the ways we think. And ya, an interplay of rationality, relativism seems very Dao.

Zachery Sanders

I’m sorry to hear you struggle. My mind on this issue changes a lot. Right now, I feel there are acts for individuals, acts for systems, and acts for those with power. The impetus for change should be with systems and those with power. For others people and their identities, especially those whose existence and ways of life are threatened, I think they are less obligated to carry that burden. Of course it usually falls to marginalized and oppressed folk to challenge the threat. But asking marginalized folk to be calm, not angry, to understand, and be compassionate is huge ask and does a lot to divert the conversation away from the harm being committed by those with systemic power. For my part I try and adopt a position of loving the humanity in a person and still being able to tell them I hate your idea and #U@(* that. I may remember wrong, but Adorno writes somewhere that any system set up to try Nazis would have similar totalitarian and fascist elements, but never the less trials must be done. Thing continually fall out of theory, and so “anything goes” but of course with qualifications and reformulations.

phil e the theyby

These are super important questions, and my wholly unsatisfying answer is that it depends on context. Sometimes all empathizing does is helps us find a better path towards survival (whether that be by avoiding the person or having a specific plan of action for how to respond to someone in a way that maintains boundaries and understands the ways they might react to us). Other times, people may use really bigoted or ignorant language, but can be more open to other perspectives than we give them credit for. A lot of this comes down to whether someone’s biology can get to a place of openness. As a nonbinary AMAB person who is read as a cis man, I have the privilege of being able to talk with people about gender without their socially conditioned defenses coming up, whereas they might have those defenses up as soon as they look at me if I were more visibly queer. So I have the privilege to engage in those conversations and know how to avoid or mitigate their “triggers” in a way that can foster a sense of shared humanity. Other people don’t have that privilege. I think the single most important thing is to have your own spaces of community and safety with people who really get you and where you’re coming from. Also, never try to have those conversations online. We can only get through to people when they’re open to us, and so much of how we do that is through tone and body language. Everyone’s defenses are up in any online interaction; it’s just the nature of text-based communication. And the biggest thing I want to emphasize is that it’s not your responsibility to educate anyone. I think empathy is, first and foremost, and effective method of self-preservation. If you understand someone, you’re most informed on how to interact with them in ways that mitigate harm to yourself (which includes both harm from their actions and harm from denying or silencing yourself). This kind of empathy can take a lot of emotional labor. Having people and community where you don’t need to put in that sort of labor feels like a really important prerequisite. And I’m well aware that finding/building that isn’t always easy (I’m in my own process of trying to build that now). Sending lots of love your way; this is a really hard position to be in ❤️

River

I am so far enjoying the book, even though I can only understand about half of it. I found Chapter 4 especially relevant with my personal experience with medical science. My father passed away two years ago. He was an engineer and a staunch believer of modern science. He fell ill suddenly and passed away in the span of 4 days. Doctors couldn't figure out what was wrong with him and the all the tests came out clean. Even after he passed away suddenly, they couldn't tell what exactly caused his death. It was the moment which made my sister completely lose faith in modern science. She has been into new age stuff since then and looking more into ayurveda. I work as a scientific writer and recently noticed some fringe efforts to marry modern medicine with ancient practices such as Ayurveda, Sunnah medicine, traditional chinese medicine, greek medicine, etc. I have known a few doctors who have studied these ancient disciplines alongside their formal medical education. I have also seen a fertility service which combines modern medicine with ancient practices like Yoga and Ayurveda. I feel like, since doctors are closer to regular people, they have a more practical and intuitive understanding of science and can move past the chauvinism which is mentioned in the book. Its harder for people in material or purely theoretical field like physics and mathematics to see their own knowledge blocks, due to isolation from the regular population. I wonder, if there was a way to remove this barrier and make these sciences more interactive with daily life.

Rafael Andrade

I also felt like he was being sassy! It really made the reading funnier and lighter to imagine him writing a letter about the mean girl (aka Popper).

Hari Sood

Physics is artistic expression within a framework!

Hari Sood

I am so late but "How can I win something by making my partner loose? " has unlocked something for me - love the thoughts Matías!

Hari Sood

Not sure if you will see this phil but your comment is a lightbulb moment for me around the idea of something like 'there is truth in everything - where is it' - thank you for writing and sharing!

AJ Biffl

Yeah this is a really interesting connection! I think you're spot on about rejecting alternatives being rooted in defending the status quo, in both science and politics. In a hegemonic society, the standpoint of almost all institutions is constant competition for resources, and that perspective of fighting over every drop makes you extremely unlikely to stop to hear out alternatives or outsiders. As phil said, these outsiders are threats to the fabric of the institution, and any threats are unacceptable and must be rejected or wiped out. Any accession to those outside voices is a chink in the armor, is weakness

AJ Biffl

These first few chapters are such a gut punch. I definitely felt myself getting rocked to the core reading through it, and then sort of through the shock going, "this... is absolutely right." I love the rejection of a puritannical core "scientific method" and that anything goes is a much more fundamental way of approaching science. I remember during my masters (I was in an "Integrated Sciences" program where we selected two or more different fields to combine and do work in), we had a "Methods of Science" course and one assignment was to try to map out the pieces of scientific method (hypothesis, lit search, observation, etc) in our particular fields, and part of the result was seeing that every field had so many different ways of navigating those pieces, and even different studies in the same field would have completely different approaches. The whole course was more about seeing a survey of different approaches than trying to define a particular "scientific method." One thing that especially jumped out at me in these first few chapters is a consequence of the need to proceed counter-inductively. You need to test counterinductive hypotheses to get around the limitations of a current theory - each foundational assumption of a theory has to be unpacked and hypotheses tested that subvert that assumption. But if you keep doing this, you run into the problem that eventually, underlying EVERY scientific outlook or theory is the assumption that "the universe follows consistent rules." If you set up the same experiment, you get the same results (within reason) - that's a fundamental assumption of all empiricism. But if you throw that assumption out you can't even DO science - without that assumption, every experiment is essentially meaningless. Your results might just be coincidence, or maybe the gods decided on that day to give you those results and on another day they'll give you different results. So the process of science is fundamentally limited to existing within that one underlying assumption. But then any epistemological system, any approach seeking to reveal knowledge, HAS TO HAVE COMPONENTS THAT GO BEYOND SCIENCE - there needs to be some other aspects to the collection of knowledge that don't require that consistency. If we are to seek knowledge then we have to seek everywhere, including places where science can't look - individuals NEED some spirituality, some religion, etc., where this other sort of information can be sought. I think Feyerabend gets at this in later chapters when he mentions how there are traditions other than science that we can learn from. But, the other aspect is that I don't think science is an epistemological system *at all*: I think science is a practical art, like engineering or painting. "Anything goes" works in the manner of trying everything in your toolbox to get something to *function*. It's not about revealing knowledge, it's about trying to make pieces fit together in a useful way. Feyerabend does shed some doubt on whether a tradition being "successful" is a desirable standard, but I think that's one of the main pulls of science and one of the reasons 'the church of science' is one of the dominant ideologies on earth - science WORKS. It built the internal combustion engine and the atom bomb and the wireless telephone. "Nothing succeeds like success," (Ch 3) and people revere and follow that success. The decision to keep or throw out a particular assumption, to keep or throw out a particular method, is a personal decision, and since the consistency assumption is an eminently useful one, most keep it.

AJ Biffl

Some other general thoughts: Re: "stamp collecting" model of science, "the collection of facts for the purpose of tests seems indeed to be the only thing left to the scientist." I think similar things happen in high energy physics, with dark matter searches and accelerator physics. There's a lot of extending the same methods with slightly better performance and then not really seeing anything new, just slightly better limits and slightly lower error bars (that's not to say there's no innovation happening, but the biggest-ticket experiments are usually the tried-and-true old guard stuff). In "Evolutionary Socialism" Bernstein (chapter 1c) mentions ways that production is cheapened under capitalism - "better organisation of work, inter-unification of work and perfecting of machinery" - and it strikes me that these mechanisms are facilitated by science. At a certain point, once the "revolution" has left a revolutionary idea, science is left to just serving the hegemonic order, to either improve the efficiency of hegemony or do meaningless stuff in theory (see Angela Collier's video about "theory as resistance"). There's no meaningful transformation from science, just contribution to the established order. I liked what Feyerabend mentioned about this formation of 'old fossils' from revolutionary theories, and about how focusing on the full historical story, "a historical account of each stage of knowledge" can help preserve the nuance and power of the new and old ideas. ~~~~ There was one last thing I saw that stuck with me, a quote from the introduction: "the inbred and always rather nasty kind of jocularity one finds in specialized professions." I definitely have experience with this sort of self-superior humor, people joking about students that are struggling, etc., and it makes me sick. It feels like a really important call out. In any specialized field, under the development of any form of hierarchy, you can get this nastiness. I confess I'm guilty of this too. In the moment it's so easy to have a giggle here and there about the silly mistakes, but it builds this larger culture of laughing at everything that's done wrong, about laughing AT the people who are trying and struggling.