Against Method: Introduction-Chapter 4 (Patreon)
Content
I’m obsessed with this book’s “Analytical Index”/table of contents–what a cool way to organize and present a book-long argument, right? I figured I’d start each of these posts with the heading summaries of each chapter we read for reference as people read/write in the comments:
Introduction - Science is an essentially anarchic enterprise: theoretical anarchism is more humanitarian and more likely to encourage progress than its law-and order alternatives.
Chapter 1 - This is shown by an examination of historical episodes and by an abstract analysis of the relation between idea and action. The only principle that does not inhibit progress is: anything goes.
Chapter 2 - For example, we may use hypotheses that contradict well-confirmed theories and/or well-established experimental results. We may advance science by proceeding counterinductively.
Chapter 3 - The consistency condition which demands that new hypotheses agree with accepted theories is unreasonable because it preserves the older theory, and not the better theory. Hypotheses contradicting well confirmed theories give us evidence that cannot be obtained in any other way. Proliferation of theories is beneficial for science, while uniformity impairs its critical power. Uniformity also endangers the free development of the individual.
Chapter 4 - There is no idea, however ancient and absurd, that is not capable of improving our knowledge. The whole history of thought is absorbed into science and is used for improving every single theory. Nor is political interference rejected. It may be needed to overcome the chauvinism of science that resists alternatives to the status quo.
~~~~~
Just want to start by saying that Feyerabend’s prose is definitely more dense and academic than Lockheart's was—I literally had to read Chapter 3 three times before I felt like I actually absorbed the argument (mostly) fully. so if anyone’s feeling overwhelmed by the reading so far, just know that you’re not alone. This book may be more of a challenge than the last two, but we’ll get through it together~
below are a few quotes and things they made me think of. the thoughts you share in the comments don't have to respond to these at all, but they can if you like.
~~~~~
“Just as a well trained rationalist will obey the mental image of his master, he will conform to the standards of argumentation he has learned, he will adhere to these standards no matter how great the confusion in which he finds himself, and he will be quite incapable of realizing that what he regards as ‘the voice of reason’ is but a causal after-effect of the training I received.” (Ch1, pg 9)
It’s kinda jarring to realize how true this is just from my own introspection. I’m currently working on the response to critiques of my video essays I announced in the Sokal video, and in general the experience is forcing me to contend with the way my brain automatically starts building arguments from the assumption that a given criticism is wrong. There’s been at least one place where someone basically made the case that I was insisting ‘X is true bc the scientific establishment said so’ while there can be other, non-scientific but still legitimate frameworks in which X isn’t true (this was re my pluto vid). After getting over the initial feelings of activation from confrontation, it didn’t take me long to start to concede to this commenters point, and I felt a little sheepish at how silly/ironic of a thing that was for me to do. A few days later when I read this line about scientists’ “voice of reason” sometimes being just mental programming, I immediately thought of that comment and my response to it. Like, my literal nervous system had reacted to someone telling me i'm just re-iterating astronomy dogma. And that’s as me, someone who is pretty actively trying to counter my training as a servant to scientific orthodoxy. It makes me wonder what other bits of thought i’m holding on to that I would probably let go of with a little bit of scrutiny and some breathing exercises. Also makes me grateful for an audience that’s willing to check me.
Does anyone else notice this (or something similar) in themselves? I’m curious what different kinds of circumstances have facilitated self-awareness of that reflex for people.
~~~~~
“Theories should not be changed unless there are pressing reasons for doing so. The only pressing reason for changing a theory is disagreement with facts. Discussion of incompatible facts will therefore lead to progress. Discussion of incompatible hypotheses will not. Hence, it is sound procedure to increase the number of relevant facts. It is not sound procedure to increase the number of factually adequate, but incompatible alternatives. One might wish to add that formal improvements such as increased elegance, simplicity, generality, and coherence should not be excluded. But once these improvements have been carried out, the collection of facts for the purpose of tests seems indeed to be the only thing left to the scientist.” (Ch. 3, pg 19)
This reminds me of a rant I often go on (read: future video essay) about how boring I find a lot of contemporary exoplanet research. Basically there are tons and tons of papers being published that are just ‘hey i found another one!, with some technically unique circumstance that makes it technically warrant a publication, but has the overall effect of the field feeling like an exercise in stamp collecting. I generally attribute this to some vague financial incentive–expolanets are really popular, so there’s lots of funding available, and just kinda cataloguing objects is pretty much the lowest hanging fruit of this hip new field of research. But I hadn’t considered that the reasons driving this trend could be epistemological rather than economic. Or I suppose, in addition to? I guess the two things could also be pretty interdependent—this way of thinking rationalizes trends in research that have material, systemic origins, and the distribution of success in that system justifies that way of thinking. i tend to generally think that ideas and physical reality kinda co-create eachother, which means that either element is an opportunity to interrupt whatever feedback loop, so i’m excited to be getting this philosophical analysis to compliment what I’ve generally looked at through more of a material lens.
I’m honestly just excited to be getting into all this philosophy in general—i’m really enjoying the book so far. are you? what's stood out to you so far?