Against Method: Chapters 19-20 (Patreon)
Content
wow it’s been a while coming but we finally made it to the end of this book! i for one am feeling very accomplished bc this was the longest and most academic thing i’ve read in a while so kudos to anyone who made it through the whole thing. This week will be our final post/comment discussion, and next week will be our live collaborative writing session to close out this book (critical mass of participants permitting). If you’re interested in participating, indicate your availability on this when2meet by this Friday, and I’ll announce the date/time within the weekend.
~~~~~
Chapter 19 - Science is neither a single tradition, nor the best tradition there is, except for people who have become accustomed to its presence, its benefits and its disadvantages. In a democracy it should be separated from the state just as churches are now separated from the state.
Chapter 20 - The point of view underlying this book is not the result of a well-planned train of thought but of arguments prompted by accidental encounters. Anger at the wanton destruction of cultural achievements from which we all could have learned, at the conceited assurance with which some intellectuals interfere with the lives of people, and contempt for the treacly phrases they use to embellish their misdeeds was, and still is the motive force behind my work.
~~~~~
I thought Chapter 20’s outline of how Feyerabend came to the philosophical positions he presents in this book was a really interesting way to end it. For one, just because I saw a lot of myself in it—both in his/my early days (“They talked to those of us who used science to ridicule the rest - which was then my favorite occupation” pg 270) and where we landed later (“Enriching and changing knowledge, emotions, attitudes through the arts now seems to me a much more fruitful enterprise and also much more humane than the attempt to influence minds (and nothing else) by words (and nothing else)” pg 273). I talk about this in the responding to feedback video (that’s basically done, I’m just fighting with some copyright stuff to get it posted) but i had a similar arc from rationality bro to scientist who wants to talk about politics and feelings. But the ways we’ve gotten there seem really different–for one, a lot of this chapter gives ‘part of the boys club’ in a way I didn’t really feel like I had access to in my more science bro-ey days. But also how he had this big revelation that white supremacy exists in science when schools integrated racially and he was teaching non-white people for the first time:
Now there was much talk of racial equality - but what did it mean? Did it mean the equality of these traditions and the traditions of the white man? It did not. Equality meant that the members of different races and cultures now had the wonderful chance to participate in the white man’s manias, they had the chance to participate in his science, his technology, his medicine, his politics. These were the thoughts that went through my head as I looked at my audience and they made me recoil in revulsion and terror from the task I was supposed to perform. For the task – this now became clear to me — was that of a very refined, very sophisticated slavedriver. And a slavedriver I did not want to be. (Ch 20 pg 278)
this stuck out to me bc i’ve moved in a similar direction philosophically/politically as feyerabend, but i think we both got there in very different ways. Coming at it from a model minority ish position, i at some point realized how going along with whatever hegemonic norms was kind of participating in my own oppression, so i've often wondered how that change happens for like, white guys? I usually assume it’s just the fact that the norms of white supremacy/patriarchy are ultimately harmful to white people and men also, and that can be kinda an analogous realization to the one i experienced, but Feyerabend’s realization of being the oppressor of others is interesting. I think in hindsight I can see this positionality informing the insights he’s able to have about the machinations of Science™ in a really valuable way. To use the Audre Lorde metaphor, it’s like the master defected, so he can point out all the flaws in his tools and his house to the rest of us. That’s what this book feels like to me, having now finished it, and I already know I’m going to be coming back to it soon/often.