Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

wow it’s been a while coming but we finally made it to the end of this book! i for one am feeling very accomplished bc this was the longest and most academic thing i’ve read in a while so kudos to anyone who made it through the whole thing. This week will be our final post/comment discussion, and next week will be our live collaborative writing session to close out this book (critical mass of participants permitting). If you’re interested in participating, indicate your availability on this when2meet by this Friday, and I’ll announce the date/time within the weekend.

~~~~~

Chapter 19 - Science is neither a single tradition, nor the best tradition there is, except for people who have become accustomed to its presence, its benefits and its disadvantages. In a democracy it should be separated from the state just as churches are now separated from the state.

Chapter 20 - The point of view underlying this book is not the result of a well-planned train of thought but of arguments prompted by accidental encounters. Anger at the wanton destruction of cultural achievements from which we all could have learned, at the conceited assurance with which some intellectuals interfere with the lives of people, and contempt for the treacly phrases they use to embellish their misdeeds was, and still is the motive force behind my work.

~~~~~

I thought Chapter 20’s outline of how Feyerabend came to the philosophical positions he presents in this book was a really interesting way to end it. For one, just because I saw a lot of myself in it—both in his/my early days (“They talked to those of us who used science to ridicule the rest - which was then my favorite occupation” pg 270) and where we landed later (“Enriching and changing knowledge, emotions, attitudes through the arts now seems to me a much more fruitful enterprise and also much more humane than the attempt to influence minds (and nothing else) by words (and nothing else)” pg 273). I talk about this in the responding to feedback video (that’s basically done, I’m just fighting with some copyright stuff to get it posted) but i had a similar arc from rationality bro to scientist who wants to talk about politics and feelings. But the ways we’ve gotten there seem really different–for one, a lot of this chapter gives ‘part of the boys club’ in a way I didn’t really feel like I had access to in my more science bro-ey days. But also how he had this big revelation that white supremacy exists in science when schools integrated racially and he was teaching non-white people for the first time:

Now there was much talk of racial equality - but what did it mean? Did it mean the equality of these traditions and the traditions of the white man? It did not. Equality meant that the members of different races and cultures now had the wonderful chance to participate in the white man’s manias, they had the chance to participate in his science, his technology, his medicine, his politics.  These were the thoughts that went through my head as I looked at my audience and they made me recoil in revulsion and terror from the task I was supposed to perform. For the task – this now became clear to me — was that of a very refined, very sophisticated slavedriver. And a slavedriver I did not want to be. (Ch 20 pg 278)

this stuck out to me bc i’ve moved in a similar direction philosophically/politically as feyerabend, but i think we both got there in very different ways. Coming at it from a model minority ish position, i at some point realized how going along with whatever hegemonic norms was kind of participating in my own oppression, so i've often wondered how that change happens for like, white guys? I usually assume it’s just the fact that the norms of white supremacy/patriarchy are ultimately harmful to white people and men also, and that can be kinda an analogous realization to the one i experienced, but Feyerabend’s realization of being the oppressor of others is interesting. I think in hindsight I can see this positionality informing the insights he’s able to have about the machinations of Science™ in a really valuable way. To use the Audre Lorde metaphor, it’s like the master defected, so he can point out all the flaws in his tools and his house to the rest of us. That’s what this book feels like to me, having now finished it, and I already know I’m going to be coming back to it soon/often. 

Comments

Gnome Choomsky

I'm reminded of "Invisible Man" by Ralph Ellison and "1984" by Eric (🤪)! Those were both books where the protagonist slowly realized they were in the society of Plato's cave and had to use their wits to escape! But you also need love! You need solidarity! You need POSITIVE-SUM LOGIC! YOU NEED MATERIAL DIALECTICS! THAT'S HOW WE WORK TOGETHER TO DEFEAT PHOBIA! THAT'S HOW WE WORK TOGETHER TO DEFEAT THE MASTERS! DIALECTICAL MATERIALISM MEANS DIALECTICAL MATERIAL-ISM! WE HAVE TO RECOGNIZE THAT WE'RE ALL MADE OF THE SAME STUFF! DIALECTICAL MATERIAL! 👀

AlexTheTutor

To be honest, my book only has 15 chapters, so I haven't been able to respond directly to the text since then, but I just wanted to say thank you for running this book club and allowing us to converse with one another about these big ideas, much appreciation <3

Preethi Basani

Big agree with Alex, I got way too busy with life stuff and don’t have the capacity to parse through the often highly dense book. At one point I think I signed up for a Google doc discussion session to motivate myself to catch up but I didn’t, sorry! But I’ve been reading the discussions every week and have been enjoying that a lot so thank you for providing this space!!

Nathaniel Bookout

As a white (cis gay) man, I think I can trace my "awakening" to a few particular moments, maybe. 1) Being introduced to feminism by a good friend my Freshman year of college. Being queer helped make me open to the discussion in the first place, I think. I was reading "The Red Queen: Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature", by Matt Ridley, an evolutionary psychologist (I'm sure you can imagine what sort of issues they had with him). So, at that point, I saw there was obvious patriarchal and transphobic bias in many of the sciences, especially biology, which was my main interest. 2) My one and only philosophy course as an undergrad, "Pragmatism, Progressivism, and Feminism: The Turn of the 20th Century", where I got to visit the Newberry Library in Chicago (I went to school in C. Springs) and read a lot of William James, which influenced me away from deciding to major in Neuroscience, and going the purely positivist route in psychology/biology. 3) My mother's death, which is the first time I'd thought about spirituality since I became an atheist (and started being interested in science). That's when I started taking interest in things like Zen Buddhism, Taoism and the I Ching, and Tarot and Astrology. I would say that, while I was aware of it intellectually, I didn't really fully recognize the impact of my white privilege until this point, too. 4) I went fully off-kilter when I joined a "personal and professional development organization" that's based in a patchwork of psychology and economics, mixed with just a bit of spicy pseudoscience (about the "positive phenomenon called integrity"). 5) It's been a few years since I left and I've been recuperating control of my own mind, it feels like. Lately, I find I'm more secure in my values and self-understanding than before, with two major things coming out on top: 1) an emphasis on open exchange and intersectionality, and trying to pay more attention to other perspectives than my own, and 2) grounding in integrity (I stole it and made it not a positive phenomenon anymore), specifically intellectual integrity, which involves that open exchange, and also the general bending over backwards on behalf of the truth. I think Fatima's most recent video is a great example of intellectual integrity. The reason I would say intellectual integrity is not a positive phenomenon is because of what Feyerabend says about open exchange "traditions": "The tradition adopted by the parties is unspecified in the beginning and develops as the exchange proceeds." (237) To say it's a positive phenomenon is to say it's a fixed point that somehow exists in reality, exactly as you define it. But that's giving one person the power of definition at all. It must be "normative", as in relativistic and perhaps even prone to bias, if it's to be flexible enough for open exchange. Perhaps the role of anarchism is to keep the open exchange as egalitarian as possible, due to that role of bias. Reading Feyerabend's book has been really helpful, even crucial, for my reconciling everything I "learned" from my time with "evangelical integrity". Especially considering that's where I first learned about Wittgenstein, and the stuff they say about him is some of the only work they taught me that I still use. Something like: "There are no such words as 'me' or 'mine'. Words of this nature were introduced into society as a control mechanism which systematically divided the subjects first individually, then as a collective." (That's a Prince quote btw, in the context of an organization it sounds like culty shit, and it is, but he's really just talking abut sex.) Following up on that is something I'm super curious about (especially having read Feyerabend). For more about "integrity" you can check out: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2963274. McCloskey's paper is super Feyerabendy.

Emiel

I only discovered the channel when the book club was already halfway done so I only read the later chapters. I did really enjoy going through the earlier discussions too though, they were more than enough food for thought even without reading the text itself! Regarding the change in philosophy and how it happens for white guys: I was definitely also one of the scientists who would look down on non-scientists and who wanted to use that powerful position to influence the world around him (in a well-intentioned way, but still). I wouldn't say there was one moment of realisation, but rather an unconscious change in perspective and way of working that happened gradually as I got more real-life experience working in my field. Only after that change had already happened, I would start to notice all the assumptions I still held from my old way of thinking and how they didn't match my day-to-day experience (often actually triggered by researchers coming around to ask us to describe our methodology). Part of that is still happening, like through this book club and watching Dr Fatima. I'm not sure if this change in philosophy even could have happened to me in a conscious way - I think I would have held on too tightly to my old ways of thinking if I had noticed myself getting pulled away from them.

phil e the theyby

Ok, so it felt like most of the rest of the book was trying to talk to people who aren’t me and make them understand a position I broadly agree with. And I could sort of follow it (but sometimes struggled to with my lack of background on things). In contrast, it felt like Chapter 20 was for ME, telling the story of why Paul Feyerabend thinks like ME, and I felt DEEPLY seen. The third to last paragraph (Feyerabend recognizing his own conceit) especially stood out to me. It sounds like he hit this point of deconstruction where he thought, “we need to actually do something or build something that fixes this.” Which is good! That is a GOOD impulse. But how do you do that in a way that’s actually collaborative and honors the people you’re trying to build WITH, and avoid recreating colonial dynamics? I think his intuition in the second-to-last paragraph of focusing on people or spaces where he actually knows them and has meaningful relationships is solid. Ultimately, decolonizing to build something new is always a communal project, not an individual one. Fatima, I also thought about the internalized White Western standards and values many BIPOC folks carry; it’s something I see INCREDIBLY often as both a therapist and a supervisor of therapists-in-training. I feel like the majority of my work is trying to connect folks to themselves and their own sense of values, and it can be hard to do that in ways that aren’t just saying, “here are my norms and values and they’re great and you should adopt them.” I have both educators from the academic elite and charismatic pastors in my family history; I have a genetic lineage of talent in convincing people towards my ideology or way of looking at the world. I’m trying to navigate how to use that to guide people towards themselves, their own values, and their own questions, rather than getting them to think/engage with the world exactly how I do. It’s a complicated process. This book was a tough read, but it was INCREDIBLY worth it. Thanks for the pick! I’m looking forward to a more straightforward type of prose in bell hooks with the next one, though; my brain needs it 😅

AJ Biffl

What a book! Has been hugely influential for me, so I have to say how grateful I am this book club happened, and how glad I am I decided to give it a read even though I became part of this community too late to see the discussion in real time. This book has really transformed the way I think about politics and ideology. More thoughts in the replies. ~~~~~ To answer the question directed toward us white guys, how the "change" happened for me was that I started out pretty nerdy as a kid and read a ton of non-fiction, especially about nature and biology (think sharks and dinosaurs and the rainforest), and when you read about those topics you can't really escape learning about climate change and deforestation and poaching and all these terrible things that people do (the big three from School of Rock: tore a hole in the ozone, burning down the Amazon, and kidnapped Shamoo and put him in a chlorine tank!) Then in freshman year of high school someone pointed out to me that all those awful things aren't because humans are inherently bad, all those things are corporations trying to make a profit. Capitalism causes those things, not human nature. I joined my high school's socialist club and was extremely active there all 4 years. As I learned more about the history of especially the USSR I turned more anti-authoritarian (especially Gulag Archipelago by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn). Then for many years I disengaged with politics entirely (the depressing Trump years and the turgid Biden years), and only recently have become engaged in politics again and have seen some evolution in my views (thanks in no small part to this channel, which uniquely combined politics in a practical way and academia, the environment I am now in)

AJ Biffl

I'm just going to post the full blurb I wrote in my notes document at the end of this book. Putting it in the next reply so it can be collapsed/expanded for scrollability

AJ Biffl

Rejection of all methodological standards extends quite neatly to politics. Political methodology can be seen to refer to ideological alignments. These methodologies, these guides to approach the distribution of power in society, are understood to carry an accompanying grab-bag of specific policy positions (the authoritarian right is also pro-gun, etc). We then immediately run into one of the problems of reducing a set of ideas to a specific named tradition, which is that each person may carry within them a different sense of the policies and beliefs underlying a political methodology. Employing or appealing to or referencing a particular methodology is at best a fuzzy endeavor and most often is effectively meaningless. At worst, the naming of a political tradition can be used as a tool to indoctrinate and divide, particularly as employed by the dominant members of a social hierarchy. Education as to the particulars of a political methodology can distort, misrepresent, villify, deify, etc., with no recourse to the specific content of the policy positions. As itself a political tool, comparmentalization and encapsulation of political ideology can be employed to (extremely effectively) reinforce the existing social hierarchy, or to overthrow it. Lastly, whether or not the framing of a political methodology is done disingenuously, whether or not the expressed implication of a political methodology is true to the underlying policy positions, the adoption of a particular political methodology as an absolute standard of political conduct is highly damaging in that a specific political methodology is restrictive, precisely in the manner of Feyerabend's understanding of methodology of reason. The coherent and humanitarian management of a political structure requires a large amount of flexibility, much more so than is afforded by any general methodological rules. The analogy to an anarchistic approach to science is as follows: in science, we see that a particular school of scientific methodology is restrictive in how it cuts off avenues of investigation or the collection of experimental facts that lie outside of the possible hypothesis-space of the methodology. The better course of action is to proceed as "anything goes," to collect experimental information in any and every way to continually build up a working process of understanding. In politics, we see that a particular school of political methodology is restrictive in how it cuts off avenues of political action or the implementation of transformative policy that endanger the political priorities or value system of the methodology. The better course of action is to proceed as "anything goes," to respond to the evolving social environment and tailor political responses in the way as befits each particular development. In particular in the process of politics this means an understanding of possibly having to abandon both a particular standard of valuative expectations and abandoning consistent loyalty to the well-being of the status quo. Ironically, adopting this "anarchistic" framework back into politics does not lead one to anarchism. Rather we arrive at an ideology-agnostic position, something we may term "radical disloyalty" or "anti-ideology," where the only permanent rule in the rulebook is, "there is no rulebook."