Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Can’t believe we’re almost done with this book—we got one more reading this week and then we’re finished!

~~~~~

Chapter 17 - Neither science nor rationality are universal measures of excellence. They are particular traditions, unaware of their historical grounding.

Chapter 18 - Yet it is possible to evaluate standards of rationality and to improve them. The principles of improvement are neither above tradition nor beyond change and it is impossible to nail them down.

~~~~~

Something I appreciated in these chapters was how silly he made strict adherents to rationalism sound framing what they see as ‘objective’ instead as things that would make them happy:

Speaking as participants we equally often use the standards without any reference to their origin or to the wishes of those using them.  We say ‘theories ought to be falisifiable and contradiction free’ and not ‘I want theories to be falsifiable and contradiction free’ or ‘scientists become very unhappy unless their theories are falsifiable and contradiction free’. (Ch 17 pg 230)

“Scientists will be unhappy for the theories have unfamiliar properties. Philosophers of science will be unhappy because they introduce standards unheard of in their profession. Being fond of surrounding their unhappiness with arias called ‘reasons’ they will go a little further.  They will say that they are not merely unhappy, but have ‘arguments’ for their unhappiness.” (Ch 18 pg 245)

On the one hand it’s just kinda funny to point out the human desire implicit in scientists attitudes about what ought to be (loled at “the retort to ‘you ought to do X’ can be ‘that’s what you think!’”, Ch 17 pg 230), but it also brings to light some of the rhetorical ways in which objectivity as an ideal is maintained. A small point i make in the video I’m editing rn is that the whole attempt to deconstruct science rather than treat it as sacrosanct isn’t to discredit it, but to draw attention to the human subjectivities involved in the process (i know, very hot take for me lol), and the comparison I make is news headlines written in the passive voice to obscure the powerful people who are responsible for some bad thing happening. It seems like Feyerabned is getting at the same verbal slights of hand re objectivity:

“The projections of these participants appear objective and statements describing them sound objective because the participants and the tradition they project are nowhere mentioned in them.” (Ch 17 pg 235)

Sooo yeah nothing exactly new here but just some more material to add to my ever-growing pile of arguments for ‘physics is actually very subjective’.

~~~~~

There was, however, one passage that got me thinking about a take that I haven’t yet shared in a video bc i’m still figuring out how to talk about it without discrediting stuff I care about:

“A rational debate is a special cause of a guided exchange.  If the participants are rationalists then all is well and the debate can start right away.  If only some participants are rationalists and if they have power (an important consideration!) then they will not take their collaborators seriously until they have also become rationalists: a society based on rationality is not entirely free; one has to play the game of the intellectuals.” (Ch 17 pg 237)

So broadly speaking this is getting at how within communities of scientists, the epistemological values that underpin the theoretical content of their field ends up being the standard for any knowledge claim within or without that domain. And it’s very silly. As an example, I do a lot of research in physics education these days, most of which centers around college-level programmatic work—stuff like how to organize a physics department to better support students or whatever. And as much as i think this work has value, there’s a part of me that feels kinda ridiculous writing peer-reviewed papers about our findings. Don’t get me wrong, qualitative research has standards of rigor and there are lots of contexts where studying education demands similar standards as studying physics… but there are also plenty of things i’ve “done research on” that I could have easily communicated in a one-page write up rather than forcing it into the conventions of a research paper, to the point that writing the research paper version of it feels extremely contrived and I'm a little embarrassed to publish it. However, as silly as I feel writing a whole ass journal article just to make the point ‘actually you should just ask students what would be helpful to them’, that IS the way you get taken seriously by physicists, and therefore a necessary part in trying to make any kind of change in their institutions. You can't just say something is valuable, you have to show that it is PROVEN with RIGOR. We very much have to “play the game of the intellectuals” in order to just respond to very obvious conditions in helpful ways, and it feels so absurd, but also I don’t know how to get around it. The master just doesn’t take you seriously unless you use his tools, and his tools are just unwieldy for some purposes. I don’t really have a resolution to this thought, it’s just something that comes up for me a lot and feels like a frustration I just have to surrender to if I want to get anything done. meh.

~~~~

Finally i’m just gonna leave this quote here without comment bc i love it:

“But let us look at [the successes of science] from a different point of view, and it becomes a ridiculous exercise in futility. It needed billions of dollars, thousands of well-trained assistants, years of hard work to enable some inarticulate and rather limited contemporaries to perform a few graceless hops in a place nobody in his right mind would think of visiting – a dried out, airless, hot stone.  But mystics, using only their minds, traveled across the celestial spheres to God himself, whom they viewed in all his splendor, receiving strength for continuing their lives and enlightenment for themselves and their fellow men.  It is only the illiteracy of the general public and of their stern trainers, the intellectuals, and their amazing lack of imagination that makes them reject such comparisons without further ado.” (Ch 17, pg 239) 

bars.

Comments

bhobba

Before discussing rationalism, I think a definition of what reason is, is needed. That, I suspect, may be far from trivial. Personally, I am a proponent of the Socratic method, which, for me, is synonymous with rationality. As a proponent of the Enlightenment, I think this is a better way to proceed rather than cast doubt on its principles.

Kristen

Is the next video "how to criticize the moon landing (without sounding like a conspiracy theorist or tech illiterate troll)?"

Nathaniel Bookout

I think I understand his anarchism as a sorta framework--the "iron rails" that guide a pluralistic worldview--which is why it's not inherently a functional system on its own (as he describes it). It needs to encompass every other "tradition", and consider the use of any one of them accordingly. The point is to ensure that no single tradition ever rises above the others to define its domain of knowledge as the only valid one. Because, from an empirical point of view, scientific theories are strengthened by their counter-points, which makes the "open exchange" of free ideas integral to a free, scientific society. Though I also think we should remember why the master's tools don't work. Sorta like what Feyerabend is saying, there's something I've stolen from biochemistry: "Form follows Function." Specifically, the structure of a complex biomolecule (usually talking about a protein) in turn defines its biochemical function. I like the idea on a larger level, with systems in general, too. Where and how you articulate something defines its shape and function, and probably also its power, how likely it is to take hold. Of course, this all depends on the relativistic considerations Feyerabend brings up, depending on what you're articulating. If you're talking about physics, for instance, you'll have a lot more power with institutional support. But you’ll also be limited by those very institutions. If you're talking about social justice, it might be that other courses of action are better. I guess what I'm trying to say is: consider what is being gained, and what is being lost, by not writing a one page letter just saying to "ask students what would be helpful to them."

Gnome Choomsky

THE RELIGION OF "SCIENTISM" IS BASED ON PHOBIA OF "IRRATIONALITY"! PHOBIA IS NOT THE CORRECT RESPONSE! Once you base your response to something on phobia, it starts to look ridiculous from the outside! I have trypophobia! It would be just as silly to base my life and my politics on my subconscious terror of clusters of holes as basing one's life on phobia of the irrational! You, on the other hand, need to make sure you're doing the correct dialectical analysis! It's not DIALECTICAL to say that everything is "subjective"! The objective comes from the dialectical synthesis of all the subjectivity! For that, you need to do the NxN diagram! The objective is simply (i.e., nothing other than) the map/mapping of all the "points" of subjectivity! The dialectical synthesis of the map and the territory is MEMORY! But, yes, you're right! THEY need to listen to US! THEY don't know WTF is going on in our heads! THEY THINK THEY CAN BYPASS OUR EGOS AND GET INTO OUR HEADS DIRECTLY! FUCK THAT SHIT! IF ANYONE WANTS TO KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON IN MY HEAD, THEY'LL HAVE TO ASK ME DIRECTLY! AND YOU CAN'T ALWAYS GET WHAT YOU WANT! NOT EVEN THE FALSE GODDESS OF BOURGEOIS LIBERTY CAN ALWAYS GET WHAT SHE WANTS!

Gnome Choomsky

Nothing is "relativistic"! It's dialectic! There's a difference! Einstein never read Hegel! If he had, quantum shit wouldn't have been so "spooky" to him!

Gnome Choomsky

Did you ever read Hegel after reading Socrates? Ever heard of dialectics? We don't have to worship white dudes who died 300 years ago! I certainly don't worship Hegel, but you don't need any opinions about him to learn from his dialectical "method"! Oh no! I said the "m" word! Arrest me! 🙄🤣🤪

Nathaniel Bookout

Feyerabend talks about the Hegelian triad: position, negation, and synthesis (225). His argument is that the Hegelian tradition of "rationality" is not inherently objective, or pragmatic. Rationality, like science, is simply a tradition that's "neither good nor bad". (235) "Rationality is not an arbiter of traditions; it itself is a tradition or an aspect of a tradition." (235) So I'm defining his anarchism as "a free society in which all traditions are given equal rights, equal access to education and other positions of power." (236) This is where relativism comes in. You have to consider what he's saying about being a "observer" vs. "participant". If your goal is only to talk about what is and isn't considered accepted physics, for instance, being an "observer" and operating rationally as such might be sufficient. But if your goal is any form of political change, or social justice, then it's necessary to start thinking like a "participant", and thinking about what outcomes your actions can lead to, as you decide how to act.

AlexTheTutor

"So broadly speaking this is getting at how within communities of scientists, the epistemological values that underpin the theoretical content of their field ends up being the standard for any knowledge claim within or without that domain." Dr Fatima Yes exactly, at least within my own experience, my career has been built by teaching outside the system (freelance teaching), just seeing what works and applying it directly and automatically without need of asking anyone's permission (except the parents and students of course), literally 5 mins ago, I was working with a student who skipped their college physics class to learn with me, why? "well, my professor just goes so fast, I don't have time to ask any questions or understand anything, so I feel like class is a waste of time" of course, if on the first day of learning a new language a native speaker talks to you, you won't understand anything, you may get discouraged and want to give up, thinking (incorrectly) that you just can't learn another language, OR... or... we can realize that a learning environment is essential for learning, for example it must always be like pre-school: fun, engaging, building curiosity, learning one concept at a time at our own pace, and plenty of snacks and naps.. so the pros are obvious, real adults working 2 jobs and paying for college need real help today, not tomorrow, so if you are able to provide that need, you will always have students to teach the CONS are... if you try to bring any obvious suggestions to the real professors as someone with absolutely no official credentials, you will never be taken seriously, you are not a doctor or a lawyer or really anything, there is absolutely no way that you know anything, and definitely not more than those with degrees (interestingly, in 2022 I learned about this thing "imposter syndrome" by attending an educational seminar ran by educators with Master degrees or higher, my first reaction was utter repulsion, these students are already so overwhelmed as it is, they need guidance, reassurance, experience, and wisdom, all of which everyone in the seminar had more than enough of, being outside the system, I never thought to doubt myself, I already do enough of that if a student doesn't get an A on an exam we were preparing for, but with time, we figure out better ways to prep, and the students get A's and share strategies with other students, the professors hear about it, and THEN they say "oh hey, that's a good idea, I think I will use that", it's happened several times, so the rare times I engage directly with the system (and not the students), it is a genuine culture shock, i've learned to mind my business and focus on working directly with students so I can only help a few dozen students at a time, which is great, but anyone working within the system to improve it, that work has the potential to improve the lives of thousands if not millions, it's tiring with all the institutional inertia one must deal with, but I salute you and anyone else who has the patience and diligence to pursue that goal, honestly it is work that should be valued above anything else

bhobba

Relativity is not a good name for special relativity these days. It is really a theory about the symmetries of an inertial frame. See https://physics.umd.edu/yakovenk/teaching/Lorentz.pdf. I am unfamiliar with Hegal, but despite many differing views on QM, once I discovered Gleason's Theorem, it never was that strange to me.

Nathaniel Bookout

I'm talking about relativism as in holding different philosophical views without declaring any one of them objective, not special relativity.

phil e the theyby

I appreciate the delay in the next book club because it’s given me time to actually go through and finish this one (which has taken me a LONG time; life gets messy and this book is DENSE). I haven’t read all the comments here yet, but I just want to share how fucking STUNNED I was by Chapter 17. It spoke to a core fundamental tension in LITERALLY ALL HUMAN INTERACTION that I didn’t have the right words to describe. The “open exchange” idea Feyerabend is how I aim to approach interacting with, and even thinking about, other people generally. It feels VERY different to how other people tend to approach people. This isn’t to say I’m some sort of superior human; I OFTEN fall short of this ideal when under stress, but I do take it seriously in how I engage with people, even those who others see as “bad” people. I also think I just have a brain disease where I HAVE to understand the dynamics that are happening when I interact with people, so the idea of trying to understand their frame of reference, share my own, and co-create something that feels mutually valuable is something I aim to do to fend off the crushing anxiety of groundlessness. I’m excited for the rest of the book because I think this becomes complicated when approaching societies as a whole (although I see it as just as important). But I know that pages 234-239 of this book will be critical references I will point to when highlighting other people articulating thoughts that form the basis of my personal philosophy.

AJ Biffl

This claim of the "dialectic" as being a solution to organizing subjective truths in an objective way, but then the way you organize is you have to map out every individual's subjective perspective is giving me the same vibes as "Now critical rationalism is either a meaningful idea or it is a collection of slogans that can be adapted to any situation" (pg 151).

AJ Biffl

I imagine PF would respond that only allowing discussion within the confines of these "principles" is restrictive at best and is a tangible lever of censure and oppression at worst. That's the point of "casting doubt" - that fence you put up is not the only field where we can talk

Gnome Choomsky

The meaning of the zen koan isn't so much to be found in the words themselves, but in how we can identify them as meaningful in our own lives. When Lana says, "when the world was at war before, we kept on dancing... and we'll do it again..." what she means by that is up for interpretation, but we can all bring our own meaning to it if we identify it as true in our own lives. And certainly, as long as we keep finding joy in simple, everyday moments, especially with loved ones, while the world is falling apart all around us, then we can say that we "kept on dancing." It's precisely as deep as you want it to be!