Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

excited to finally start this book! here are the things i highlighted while reading:

“To fulfill [their] mission, my teachers made sure they “knew” us. They knew our parents, our economic status, where we worshipped, what our homes were like, and how we were treated in the family. I went to school at a historical moment where I was being taught by the same teachers who had taught my mother, her sisters, and brothers. My effort and ability to learn was always contextualized within the framework of generational family experience. Certain behaviors, gestures, habits of being were traced back. Attending school then was sheer joy.”

This is such a beautiful image of what someone's early educational experiences could be—one that feels completely unimaginable to me, to be honest. Feel free to write in your comments about everything, but if I was going to offer one prompt to everyone, it would be: what was the most beautiful educational experience you’ve had? Did learning ever feel like sheer joy? 

I’ve certainly had deeply influential teachers, but funny enough, they were never my science teachers. My favorite teacher of all time was this nihilistic vietnam vet with a fucked up sense of humor who taught my 11th and 12th grade world lit classes. Even though english was one of the few academic subjects I didn’t really care about, he got me sooo invested in his class. at one point i spent days doing an assignment—annotations for this huge collection of essays—way past the deadline, knowing fully well I would get no credit for it, but I just wanted him to read and engage with my work so much that it was worthwhile for me to do anyways. It wasn’t about grades or credit or whatever, I just genuinely had an intellectual relationship with this person that made me want to think about things and do work to show them what I learned and thought.  beautiful.

So yeah, that’s my example of the classroom being sheer joy. I have had many less joyful educational experiences, I actually marked up several lines in this intro that felt reminiscent of my time in grad school, but I don’t feel like getting into that now. Instead I’ll share one other passage I’ve been thinking on:

“For black folks teaching—educating—was fundamentally political because it was rooted in antiracist struggle. Indeed, all my black grad schools became the location where I experienced learning as revolution…Though they did not define or articulate these practices in theoretical terms, my teachers were enacting a revolutionary pedagogy of resistance that was profoundly anticolonial.”

I really appreciate her emphasis on how radical education sometimes comes from sources that aren’t presenting themselves as revolutionary in whatever way. Reminds me a lot of @badschoolbadschool, a writer on IG who talks about education and radical praxis. It also makes me think of people on the internet who tell me that I have to read theory if I want to end capitalism or whatever, and how far removed they feel from the actual real life humans I see in the place where I live who move mountains to support their communities.  It's a distinction I want to keep in my mind as I continue being a public internet person.

Comments

AJ Biffl

I can remember so many instances in high school (especially english and history classes) where I formed genuine connections with my teachers and was so excited to go to class every day. They cared so much about their students, and so clearly loved to see us grow and encounter new ideas and perspectives and beliefs and stories and traditions. They shaped so much of who I am, of how I relate to the world and express myself. It's also really interesting that you mention that it wasn't a science class where you found this joy (I don't know if I ever really had a "joyful" connection with a science teacher either, beyond the joy of learning the science itself, which is something different). The true joy I've felt in the classroom has always been reading literature and history and learning to connect with myself and others. I highlighted that passage where Hooks says in part, "devotion to learning, to a life of the mind, was a counter-hegemonic act." I think for me the radical ideas of empathy and connection that you find in literature and history, which are so beautiful and so joyful, ARE the most counter-hegemonic parts of an education, where you learn to reject the ideas of separation and domination that pervade everywhere else. I'm really excited to read the rest of this book. I'm a TA for physics 1 and physics 2 classes, and like I said there's not much radical counter-hegemony to be found in those types of classrooms, at least not at first glance, not in the curriculum. But I'm looking forward to seeing how Hooks describes the practice of education as liberation, and seeing how I can apply that to my classrooms. One last quote: "It surprised and shocked me to sit in classes where professors... did not seem to have a clue that education was about the practice of freedom." EDIT: Thinking about it, I DID have one science teacher I really connected with! She was the most energetic, enthusiastic person, and she brought this contagious giddy energy to her classrooms, and she was always so proud to see her students learning. I ended up taking two of her classes, sophomore chemistry and then a "research seminar" class my senior year where we got paired with professors and postdocs at a nearby university and worked on "real" research projects with them (seems so long ago now...). She was definitely a huge inspiration in sticking to my science path. I should also clarify that I was extremely lucky to have LOTS of amazing science teachers all through school, but she stands out as someone who absolutely cared about us as and connected with us people and constantly showed how she wanted to see us learn and grow.

Warren Shull

I'll mention 2 courses. I've always loved math, but a particular computer science course helped solidify my choice to become a math professor. In effect, I quite liked how class time was structured and I pictured myself doing something similar in math Part of each homework assignment was to ask at least one question about the material. Then, during class, a list of everyone's questions (with names removed, consolidated appropriately) was shown and the professor addressed them one by one. Students felt free to clarify what they meant or what they *thought* someone else might have meant. This usually took about half the time. For the other half, the professor put a "problem" (a block of code) on the board for us to "solve" (draw a memory diagram). He would ask us to get into groups *with people we don't know* to work on it. Everyone in the class was happy to do this, and it didn't take long until 20-25 of us all knew each other. This went especially well because of how the room was laid out: the desks were arranged in groups of students facing each other, making it easier to walk around, and *the walls were painted with whiteboard paint*. As we worked, the professor would circulate around the room, mostly *listening*, sometimes asking questions, and very rarely making statements or giving answers. This activity was not graded, but it seemed like everyone happily cooperated. (I aspire to create a similar environment in my own classrooms. Unfortunately, very few classrooms have such a favorable layout. I also do not always control what is in the curriculum, and some curricula are too tightly packed to allow much active time in class. I am currently teaching a calculus course that has those problems and an "intro to proofs" course that mostly does not.) In another course, amazingly enough, *we read Paulo Freire's book* (Pedagogy of the Oppressed). Unfortunately, I found his wording difficult to digest at the time. However, another book we read was "Punished by Rewards" by Alfie Kohn, which I strongly resonated with! (I would love to make that a future candidate for this book club.) It overall argues against the use of rewards and punishments, and against the premise that children (or workers in a workplace) need to be "controlled." The themes of resisting and questioning educational hierarchy and authority are common between both those books and this one.

Tom Cassidy

I think it's important to remember the context in which bell hooks was writing. Her liberal (white) Audience probably saw school segregation as a sin of the past. Meanwhile, the Ronald Reagan / George Bush Agenda was trying to delegitimate public schooling altogether. So here she comes saying that schooling can work when it's of the people, by the people, for the people. --and maybe that's the only way it can work? My own experiences of public school they were not as miserable as my teenage self-taught them to be, also probably not a complete success. I saw it as a way out of Ignorance and whatever I associated with my hometown. I loved learning what seemed like hidden knowledge! One of my teachers told me that the sonnet form is a perfect model of the way humans think. Is that true? I have no idea; but it certainly seemed true! Not to mention those lab classes where we got to weigh things, cut them up, and make them go pop! Also, I enjoyed the challenge of that statistics class. --And yes, in each of those classes, I felt connected to a teacher who I believed wanted me to learn.

Atallah

To your prompt, while I may not have felt sheer joy in the classroom, there have been some instances where i did feel professors approaching some of the more transgressive behaviors hooks talks about in the intro. Since most of my classes were STEM, there were was not much room for flexibility, communal critique of ideas, or recognition of differences. That said, some teachers stood out with minor acts. One that comes to mind echoes Warren's point above. I had one Computer Science professor who would always open class with him drawing on the tablet he was projecting from, while students filed into their seats. Then he would open lecture by answering any anonymous, student-submitted questions. He never acknowledged the drawings until one student anonymously asked him to start uploading them alongside lectures. I always enjoyed that part of class. Perhaps because it was at once flexible (sometimes questions would derail lecture, as they didn't have to be related to material, and the drawings themselves somehow grounded our time together) and communal (questions could be asked without the barrier of in-person interaction, leading to different kinds of questions asked) As for the content of the intro, I really enjoyed hooks' framing of teaching as an act of resistance. It's absolutely true. Apathy and disinterest directly antagonize achieving class consciousness and fighting systems of oppression. This transgression against that inoculation is completely revolutionary! Much of my thinking as a socialist tends to come back to how to engage and mobilize the masses towards a cause, as it is so easy to be come apathetic, discouraged, or complacent. Based on what I've read so far, there appears a direct relationship between the behaviors incentivized in the classroom and our ability to challenge the status quo. And of course these two concepts (pedagogy as a political, revolutionary act, and the general populous having the spirit to transgress) mutually reinforce one other.

AJ Biffl

The more I think about this CS course, the more I love the sound of it! Super student-centric, shaping class time around questions not curriculum, encouraging everyone to make new friends by mixing up the groups every day. Amazing!

Doctor Qcumber

What was the most beautiful educational experience you’ve had? Did learning ever feel like sheer joy? I’ve always felt some level of joy infused into the process of learning, but it’s mostly been small bits of joy that add up. One thing that does stand out is in senior year of high school when my English class did a unit on poetry. I had always been dismissive of poetry as flowery pretentious nonsense, but when I was forced to sit and analyze some poems, I found some that I actually really enjoyed sitting with. It ended up being the unit I was most engaged with that year. The crazy thing is, my teacher wasn’t anything special, and I didn’t really engage with poetry too much after I graduated. But that experience is still a foundational part of my worldview, because it made me realize that being interested in something is not just a natural occurrence, but is moreso a result of investing yourself in it. I was able to get myself interested in poetry, which kind of shocked me. With the more critical lens I have currently, it makes me wonder if I would have been a much more well-rounded learner had it not been for the constant societal encouragement for my aptitude in STEM. The revolutionary actions which aren’t explicitly grounded in revolutionary theory that you mentioned struck me as well. I just don’t find myself interested in theory the way I am in praxis. People really into reading theory kind of remind me of people who really care about hypocrisy in the sense that it feels like the focus is more on being right than doing right. If theory is your primary focus rather than working to see the things you value be amplified in society, you’re probably going to rub me at least slightly the wrong way. “I imagine, then, Africans first hearing English as ‘the oppressor’s language’ and then re-hearing it as a potential site of resistance. Learning English, learning to speak the alien tongue, was one way enslaved Africans began to reclaim their personal power within a context of domination. Possessing a shared language, black folks could find again a way to make community, and a means to create the political solidarity necessary to resist.” This reminded me of a lot of the ideas from A Third University is Possible, namely the natural retooling of the colonizing machine for decolonial ends. I was also struck by how I just never really considered what was lost when schools were integrated before reading this chapter. I just thought of integration as something generally good which happened despite the pushback and growing pains that comes from any social change. It kind of makes me interested in learning more about segregated black spaces and organizations in history. hooks’ perspective here is definitely adding a bit of texture to my understanding of history. “Profound commitment to engaged pedagogy is taxing to the spirit.” Yeah…I’d be curious to look into people who have ideas of how to avoid this, but it seems like a pretty fundamental aspect.

AJ Biffl

Another thing I've been thinking a lot about, catalyzed into its current form by Warren's comment above, is that an education can be revolutionary in two distinct ways -- in content and in form. On the one hand, an education can be revolutionary because it teaches radical ideas -- literally teaching about revolutionary ideology, or teaching about radical empathy and compassion and introduction to diverse ways of thinking and being. The education CONTAINS an element of revolution; it teaches a counter-hegemonic lesson. The second way, revolutionary in form, is like what Hooks describes her grade school years as. The mere act of education in black communities was revolutionary because it subverted the existing pattern of social domination. To empower the oppressed is to resist the systems of oppression. The act, the education itself, not necessarily the knowledge imparted, is the thing that resists hegemony. But that's not to say that an education needs to involve the empowerment of oppressed groups to be revolutionary in form. There ARE many ways that the education of privileged groups is reactionary, but any form of education that subverts the expectations of social dominance is revolutionary. In Warren's CS class, the first half of lectures was determined by the students, by the questions they chose to ask, rather than some curriculum. The rest of the class was devoted to solving problems, which is again a student-driven mode of learning. That sort of student-driven education, rather than some top-down curriculum, contains the radical idea that the classroom need not be a rigid hierarchy. The teacher and student need not be master and servant. They can exist together on the same level as peers, where education becomes an exchange of ideas like a water gun fight, not a fire hose.

Matt Fernandez

That class sounds like an awesome learning environment!

Matt Fernandez

This is my first experience with a book club, and it feels like the introduction is challenging / inspiring me to read in a far more focused manner than I often do, and the timeframe allowed is giving me space for that - to read and re-read and re-read. I really like that! My classroom experiences that stand out to me are the ones that have been more dialogue-driven. I really liked my math classes in the UK as a kid. We were introduced to trigonometry with a thought experiment: "Imagine you're looking at a building. You can assume the building wall is at a 90 deg angle to the ground. If you can measure the angle between where you're standing on the ground and a given window up the side of the building, what else can you know about the triangle of you, the window, and where the building meets the ground?" It was a very challenging class, but I loved that approach to math. It was pretty soul-crushing moving back to the US for the last three years of highschool, and math class was just solving equations over and over and over. Other classes that really stand out to me were history class in the UK (really all of my schooling in the UK), a psych class in highschool in the US, and a politics class I took at Uni in the US. In our history class, we learned about the industrial revolution and associated land reforms and the rise of factories and cities, how that affected people's living conditions and how that created a greater need for social welfare, and how socialist systems try to address those needs. In my psych class in the US, we were asked to keep a journal where we wrote out thoughts on our reading of the textbook. The freeform and open-ended nature of that was really enjoyable and made it all so much more engaging, and I ended up really challenging myself when I'd write, for example, about my thoughts on some mental-health issues from my then religious perspective and realized how.... unscientific I was. It helped me really grow a lot in terms of how I thought about the world. My politics class was a fall semester in 2001, so each class quickly became group-discussions about the 9/11 attacks and the aftermath. If nothing else, it was a place that I could practice and grow more comfortable in vocally standing against prevailing sentiments, and how often others appreciate someone giving voice to feelings they have but aren't fully understood or articulated in themselves.

Iris Foxx

Having had the same teacher as mentioned above I can fully agree that he had a way of inspiring you to learn. I feel that it was mainly because he was willing to engage with high school students as people at a time when it felt like everyone was adamant that we were not. Being able to see an adult actually listen to you when you speak or write felt revolutionary in 11th and 12th grade even though we were in advanced classes. The experience I want to share is in relation the the concept bell hooks brings up: “There must be ongoing recognition that everyone influences the classroom dynamic, that everyone contributes.”(pg 8) When I was 7 or 8 I would walk around and study an animal encyclopedia religiously. I was too shy to actually just spout animal facts at anyone and most people were not interested in talking about contextless animal facts. Then, one day I had slugs mating on my sliding glass door. (If you’ve never seen slugs mating just combine the ideas of aerial acrobatics and slime.) I summoned family, friends, and neighbors and forced them all to come see this thing that I had only ever seen in a book but could recognize before anyone else. It was gross, weird, and compelling and people listened to me express this thing I learned from a book—the best part was seeing the comprehension of what I explained to them. I’m sure this is why they (nebulous unknown “they”in this case) say you truly understand something if you can teach it to someone else. That probably stoked both my reading flame and my blabber mouth into what it is now. Excited to keep reading this one; almost inspires me enough to see what it takes to be a teacher in my county. (ALMOST, only almost ;) )

Matt Fernandez

That's awesome! I really enjoy talking to kids about things they're interested in - or rather, giving them space to talk to me about it. Same with adults too, but it feels like a different sort of space when a child hears from an adult "that's interesting, tell me more". Always feels like a great way to encourage exploration and self-education.

Justin Walker

Learning sheet music in my high and collegiate choirs is probably the closest expression I could summarize as sheer joy. The resonation of a flawless performance that echoed through the large church corridors or whatever stage we were performing on, with vibrations that could bring a tear to your eye as well a shiver up your spine.

Qamar Radmi

I think what struck me most is the idea that a "radical pedagogy [would] insist that everyone's presence acknowledged". It feels a priori a bit alien to me, as I feel in science class (and in my case, maths class), the teaching session is one of abstraction, of transportation into another world where our mortal worries shall not disturb. I sadly felt this way a long time in my mathematical journey, where I shut myself off whenever I had a question thinking that it's trivial and must be worked out in isolation. Today, I'm a bit more hopeful. I have learnt to ask questions and engage productively in the classroom, many classmates tell me that they're happy to hear me because I voice their similar questions, I constantly worry about being annoying, but I deeply enjoy this part of human interactions in this world we pretend is so abstract and so inhumane. I enjoy when teachers show their fallibilities, their biases and their ways of thought. A recent experience where I felt true joy was in my first algebra 2 course of the semester where the teacher felt like he was interacting with us, he was getting sometimes closer to the audience, and making us feeling as if he was waiting a response, it felt so interactive, and it felt natural for me to ask my questions when they occured. I think this is the part of classroom that I enjoy the most. I think it occured to me, at this same course, that I may love being a teacher. I feel that maths courses feel the best when their approach becomes close to humanities, when we have history sections, and remember the human aspect of "hard" science, because it reminds us of our own subjectivity, and what our future can look like in such a field. I sometimes felt sad reading the introduction feeling that I wouldn't be able to transpose bell's approach in humanities to science, but the more I think about it, the more it feels possible.

illthinkofanamelaterthatsnotmyrealname

Although I'm in grad school now for ecology, the first time that I actually *loved* a class was a literature class in the 11th grade. We had read and discussed novels and poems together, split into in groups, and then by ourselves in readings that we could choose from. That was a sort of creative freedom and a feeling of community and dialogue that I have never had replicated in that kind of setting. Learning has almost always been a solitary thing for me otherwise, even in classrooms. I really have enjoyed the work that I've done in environmental fields, but in some cases it can be antisocial. STEM for me had never really incorporated broader scales of thought, and has mostly engaged with the "banking" model that hooks mentions, where facts are regurgitated in a conformist and uncritical way. There is a lot of respect for scientists like Robin Kimmerer who can blend social and scientific analyses, but it seems like a lot of academics are afraid or are discouraged from placing science in the context of social analyses for fear of being labeled "squishy", or an "activist", or being outcasted to a Political Science department. This was mentioned multiple times by academics in a seminar at a neighboring university, where their paleoecology department discussed a paper called "Scientist Engagement and the Knowledge Gap" by L DuPont. Reading that paper and listening to that discussion, it felt like none of us seemed to have the vocabulary to talk meaningfully about larger environmental issues outside of our immediate expertise (at least not as a group). Many of us probably didn't have training to do so; I certainly don't think I did. But I'm very much looking forward to this book club, especially since I now TA. I'm leading the lab of a course I've never taken, so hopefully these essays can make it a little more worthwhile for both me and my students.

Warren Shull

That downside of integration is certainly an interesting point, but I wonder if any of the reverse happened for white kids exposed to black teachers for the first time. If those teachers brought any of their revolutionary practices with them, even a little bit, white kids being exposed to them may have been a very good thing. If that did not happen much, it's likely due to the constraints placed on teachers. I would guess that principals and superintendents at those integrated white schools were less tolerant of a liberation approach to teaching when it crossed their radar. If what were previously "black/colored schools" could have continued existing, while opening their doors to white children, I wonder how that would have played out.

Warren Shull

Do you think privileged groups usually receive *more* reactionary education than marginalized groups? Or is it the other way around? Or does it depend on what choices the privileged people make? In my example, the whiteboard paint on the walls was likely made possible by the college's wealth.

Warren Shull

It sounds like you are still in high school, or recently graduated? I'm curious how close you think my CS course that I describe comes to "transposing her approach." A few other people in this thread seemed to like what I described there, and it did play a role in motivating me to become a professor!

bhobba

Primary school was, for me, a blur. But for some reason, I became interested in math and electronics in secondary school (year 8). I went through the math textbook in about a week, kept on a roll, and taught myself calculus the following year at 13 (we started a year earlier than most other countries here in Australia in those days). It just so happened my math teacher in years 9 and 10 was a fantastic teacher who I liked a lot, although he was a bit exasperated I just went my own way in class. He got me on one question - Bill tell us how imaginary numbers are used in electronics. I didn't know about Euler's relation then and was stumped. He didn't rub it in, but I soon learnt about it and the connection. It helped a lot with my electronics. Ideologies were not much of a thing at our school. Although one person who was into it thought I was 'retarded' because I had no interest.

AJ Biffl

I think any education can be reactionary in content (and almost everyone probably sees at least a little bit of that), BUT I think an education is reactionary in form if it reinforces the social hierarchy. The education of privileged groups, which serves to "empower" people who already have substantial power, is an action that reinforces that hierarchy. Then, once members of the privileged class have been given that increased power, they're more likely to use that power to support and defend the social hierarchy as well.

Kayla McDonogh

I can also relate to the transformative reading of Freire. Last year I was first introduced to the Pedagogy of the Oppressed, and I've seen the themes he writes about in multiple places! Dehumanization of people, the banking system within education, and education as liberation. It's sent me on a much different path, and I am grateful for the awareness. I want to bring awareness to this call to action from the introduction. "More than ever before in the recent history of this nation, educators are compelled to confront the biases that have shaped teaching practices in our society and to create new ways of knowing, different strategies for sharing of knowledge." I don't see this request being filled or even acknowledged, at least in the k12 public school system I work in. I see more investment in the educational industrial complex rather than in teachers and instruction, only furthering the problem. Solutions are always to empower the most oppressed to identify failures of liberation. As a singular teacher, this is not possible for me to safely reach for in my current employment. Without intentional changes to instruction, systems, and mindsets we are damaging our students and further isolating the community. I'm worried that without intentional action to create a more inclusive classroom setting, we will force student populations back into segregation.

Warren Shull

That makes sense for the most part. I was more getting at the question of what *kind* of education each group is more likely to receive. Pre-integration, it sounded like Hooks' education was more radical than that of her white peers. On the other hand, here's an article claiming that low-income schools tend to be more authoritarian in their approach (the complete opposite of what tended to happen at my college): https://www.alfiekohn.org/article/poor/

Mingo

I didn't have any educators that really inspired me. There were a couple of teachers throughout school who tried, but I had a whole lot of stuff going on. I guess I had a very long "problem child" phase. But in university, when everyone was less and less interested in being inspiring or about pedagogy or whatever you may call it, there was one man who only had a teaching position and not a real research position (apart from some teaching related research). And he was just a blessing! I'm sure, if it weren't for him and his tireless efforts to explain basic university level physics, so many more people would have dropped out in the first two semesters than did that already. He deserved so much more props than all of those highly decorated professors we had at the institute, which makes it so much worse that he ended up having a very traumatic accident that left him a shadow of his former self and he died a few years after at a way too young age😢

Moz in Oz

for me there was a moment in a university feminist studies tutorial where I made a critique that coming from a white male engineering student some people were not comfortable with. A "mature student" who was also a lesbian stepped up and said "he's got a good point" then a woman who later became a close friend absolutely ran off with my critique and had a field day. I never managed to find out whether she agreed with it, but she had "no time for that ad hominem bullshit". It was a moment of feeling accepted and validated, and I don't have a lot of those.

Moz in Oz

Also, the sociology lecturer in a class of 50-100 who was collecting essays as people left a lecture, stopped me and when I said I wasn't enrolled said "I'd really like to read your essay". So I ended up getting a third year sociology credit despite the engineering school rules not permitted it to be awarded at the time I did the coursework. The course itself was great and I enjoyed the lectures, and writing the essays was both challenging and fun. Partly because there's a certain liberation in not caring about the mark you get, and not feeling especially obliged to work out what the marking criteria are and carefully structure around them. Here's the points I want to make, here's the academic justification for them, and here's some other stuff I found that seems relevant :) Or as my "Philosophy of Computing" tutor put it "I'm giving you an A+ for the first half, and a what the heck did I just read for the second half". I did a BA following the engineering degrees. Backwards compared to the US, but in Aotearoa doing one non-engineering paper in a four year degree is permitted but unusual.

Moz in Oz

Aotearoa is about 30 years into a revolution in the presentation of the indigenous population. There's pushback, but it's almost always pushback against what's already been accepted. Kohanga Reo (Maori immersion preschool https://nzhistory.govt.nz/women-together/te-kohanga-reo ) is inside the establishment now, and The Treaty is seen as bedrock to most people (US funded fash are agitating against it though). Even from Australia where I am now it's hard to describe to people in other British colonies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ng%C4%81_Tamatoa is another useful place to start. That is to say that it can be done, it has been done, and it should be done. Kia kaha! (stand strong).

AJ Biffl

Wow that's a really interesting article! That's another important distinction - education which empowers and education which ABSOLUTELY DOES NOT. And I guess it makes sense that that evolution has happened in poor classrooms over the past six decades, from the "learning as revolution" in Hooks' time to the "pedagogy of poverty" today, as emphasis was put on standardized test scores. Like the article mentions, that authoritarian banking-system education style improves standardized test scores while expending minimal resources, and at the expense of genuine learning. So schools with minimal funding and in areas with the highest population density, already under the most strain, had to turn to those draconic methods to avoid being shut down altogether. That comparison between the steel-fist reward-and-punishment classroom organization and the test-score reward-and-punishment dance for funding is tragic and hilarious ("Interestingly, their carrot-and-stick methods mirror those used by policy makers to control educators"). I'm not sure whether to blame the fascistic obsession with efficiency and quantitative performance, or the right-wing desire to destroy all public services in the pursuit of profit-seeking alternatives (actually turns out "No Child Left Behind" in 2002 had bipartisan support so probably both)

schlltchrn

The introduction was already a wonderful read. And something I appreciate is a kind of sense of warmth - painting different vivid pictures of personal experiences while pointing at systemic problems that are also very relatable. My most formative educational experience was probably singing in the school choir, which, of course, has nothing to do with the programme of the science high school I went to. However, it was one space where feeling feelings together was encouraged, and it made everything else we did in school make more sense, because we had this deeper knowledge about each other. I understand how teaching physics and maths does not accommodate this as easily, but I still find a striking difference between studying science and doing science. Maybe it is because as a foreigner in the university, not speaking the language very well during my studies, it was more difficult to break barriers and connect. But I still have an impression that in my research work, I have been lucky to experience the collective. To experience communal exploration to some extent. This has never happened while sitting in classrooms or libraries studying, repeating the same problems, taking tests, passing exams. What a missed opportunity! Looking forward to reading the rest of the book!

schlltchrn

I relate to this lack of vocabulary to talk about critical context of STEM and not having a training for it. It is a very frustrating experience. I got "tricked" into nuclear fusion research with environmental promises, but most scientists can't discuss it further than "clean infinite energy good" and get in the nuance, and often, I feel like I can't either. In reality, by the time people realised that fusion may not be the most effective idea, most have already checked out of the whole thing and just keep doing it for the puzzle. I guess ecology is different, since it is... ecology obviously, but is there a similar experience to an extent? Like gamification of ones own specific topic?

illthinkofanamelaterthatsnotmyrealname

So at least in my (limited) experience, different branches of ecology seem to have fairly different personalities. It's hard to say because I'm pretty new to the field. Right now I'm on the fisheries/marine side of things, and probably around half who do fisheries biology got into it because they avidly fish. I'm not necessarily one of those, but I do think finding ways to relate to our subject matter, the land, and those who have relations with it is a good habit. Some who do more tech-adjacent things (GIS, remote sensing, etc.) are more similar to ComSci personalities who just want a dignified desk job. Some of ecology types want to "make a difference" but also really want to just work outside the field. I wouldn't say there is as much gamification of the subject matter, but there's certainly some romanticization of it. I think the limited job opportunities, lower pay, and emotional cost attract certain types of personalities and weed out others.

phil e the theyby

In this introduction, bell hooks does a really beautiful job of painting the picture of the revolutionary spirit behind Black education in the time of segregation. When you've spent your entire life having your intellect devalued by a White supremacist society, only to learn that not only could you USE your mind, but that you could see many things clearer and that there was serious revolutionary potential in that, is incredibly liberating. Integration brought Black education back into the reason education existed in America; to uphold the White supremacist hegemony. Two quotes I highlighted were (both on page 7): "Neither Freire's work nor feminist pedagogy examined the notion of pleasure in the classroom." "Excitement in higher education was viewed as potentially disruptive of the atmosphere of seriousness assumed to be essential to the learning process." The absurdity of this is that, in the time of our lives when we learn the MOST (childhood), there's an INTENSE pleasure and curiosity kids have, that makes learning genuinely joyful for them...before school gets progressively more awful and pointless and makes them feel like learning is fucking lame and they should probably play more Minecraft. Being "serious" isn't supportive to the learning process; if anything, it VASTLY inhibits it. I love bell hooks' emphasis on the collaborative process of building excitement in a classroom, and of adjusting that process based on who you are teaching. It really paints this picture that, while you can learn better ways of teaching, you'll always have to adjust, grow, and adapt because your students will always be changing. I actually experienced a ton of joy in learning. As someone who struggled terribly in social relationships and didn't feel valued at home, school was the one place where I felt good at things. I was placed in all of these "accelerated" classes or moved ahead a grade in certain subjects (which are bad things for a lot of reasons, but were the only safe haven I had) where I could learn ravenously. That said, by about middle school, I really stopped caring about a lot of school for a while. My mental illness was getting pretty bad, and "getting good grades" just didn't feel as valuable as it used to. Things did get better in high school, because I was able to select a lot of classes that really excited me and I had mostly really good teachers who both made the classroom interesting and seemed to actually care about me as a person. I had a few pretty amazing educational experiences that really brought joy to learning. One was my tenth grade English teacher, who was ACUTELY aware of how much bullshit the education system is riddled with. He intentionally made it really easy to get an A in his class so that "trying to get the grade" wasn't a motivator for people, so that they could focus on actually learning. He insisted that students just get up and go to the bathroom whenever they wanted (without raising their hands) because he didn't want to be trying to connect with a student and get them to engage all year, and be excited to have them raise their hand, only to find that they needed to take a crap. He had us read books that he was genuinely excited about, and that challenged how we thought about the world ("Stranger in a Strange Land" is one that still sticks with me to this day). By explicitly challenging the bullshit norms of our education system and by sharing his excitement and enthusiasm (and by giving a lot of autonomy for our projects, so that we could learn about things WE actually cared about), he created an environment that really brought a lot of the fun back into learning. I also build some of my best friendships in that class, because I think that environment just encouraged us to explore and express ourselves in ways that made it easier to connect with other people. That teacher almost made it really clear that he cared about us as people and wanted to stay in touch after the class ended. I still remember him sharing his email address and saying something along the lines of, "Now does that mean that I want to stay in touch with all of my students forever?" (obviously a leading question where the implied answer is "no of course not, that's so impractical"). And then he answers his question by saying, "Yes, I do." Another thing that really brought joy to learning was the handful of my college math classes (with one professor in particular) where the homework assignments were designed to be hard as fuck so that you would really struggle to solve them on your own, with the idea that you'd come to these evening sessions to do the homework with other students. We'd sit around tables and talk with 6-8 other students, trying to figure out how to do these proofs. It created such an environment of curiosity and enthusiasm, where we were all excited when someone had a breakthrough in figuring out how to do something. Then we would need to be able to explain it to each other so it made sense to all of us (we were allowed to work with other people to come up with the answer, but we had to write up the answer ourselves). For anyone who's done an escape room and has been stuck on something for a little while, you'll know that it's exciting for the whole group when someone figures out a next step. This was what doing math homework was like for us. When Lockhart was talking about the potential for real joy and thrill in learning math, my experience with those classes really made me certain that such a thing is possible. Also, I just want to highlight the fuck out of Dr. Fatima's last point. You don't need to know any theory at all to make a massive difference in people's lives, and to fight back against oppressive systems; you just need to care about people, and to listen to them. If anything, theory is important for people like me who grew up in the suburbs with a ton of privilege and could get away with not doing anything. Theory serves to 1) get our asses out the door and actually start challenging these systems, and 2) makes sure that we're not trying to steamroll the amazing work that real activists and organizers have been doing for decades by poisoning it with the White supremacist bullshit we were raised on. That's not to say that theory can't play other important roles (it can help a lot of folks who are marginalized by society see that the problem is the systems they live in, not them as individuals), but I think that a lot of really crucial activism and organizing happens outside of the kind of formal education that produces theory. I'm super excited for the rest of this book!

phil e the theyby

I think a lot of the miserable parts of studying science come from the individualistic, competitive nature of a lot of educational environments. In spaces where there's less focus on "doing your own work," and instead focus learning in collaborative ways (that "collective" you describe), I think studying science can be INCREDIBLY fun. That said, I do think some of studying science IS actually "doing science," so maybe I'm just fully agreeing with you :P

phil e the theyby

That's incredibly sad; I'm so sorry for that loss you and the whole university experienced! I think it's such a crucial starting point for any educator to just...make the student feel like you actually care about them and what they're going through. It's the only way to create a calm and safe environment that actually allows for learning, especially for people who are going through hard times outside of the classroom.

phil e the theyby

I'd say that a lot of that segregation is currently happening. In terms of neurodiversity, academic tracking is basically a form of segregation, and it often fills the role of racial segregation as well due to biases in the selection process. Working as a teacher within those systems is incredibly hard, and so much of the most important work you do feels like it's totally drowned out by the mountain of bullshit within the systems you work in, and you see DAILY the ways those systems harm kids. If you can find allies and solidarity among other teachers, that can go a really long way. And please don't ever forget that just making one kid feel like you genuinely care about them can be life-changing. I have teachers I remember and cherish from over 20 years ago, because they just showed day-to-day that they cared about my humanity in ways that other people didn't. What you do is so important; my heart goes out to you!

Mingo

Yeah, you're absolutely right about that! There have been some reforms in European academia that incorporated so much more hurdles, be they monetary or performance based. Many "educators" who were not professors felt like some sort of enforcer. It was nice to have this devoted man on our side. I don't know how the vibe changed through these reforms though. Would be neat of someone had a study about that.

Dr. Fatima

lmaooo i forgot you'd be here Iris... I almost shared the story of when we were reading that play aloud as a class and he had me and Wagas read for the terrorist characters to show how weird/cute/personal our rapport was. good times lol

schlltchrn

Oh for sure. As an absolute minimum: teachers asking questions as they are explaining something. Even though that can be competitive in its own way, at least it stirs the room. At least makes us feel like we are moving toward the same goal.

Lola

agreed, my sister just started a fairly competitive research-focused master's program and the way they drill the students to be competitive and the whole program is designed to be as hard as possibl, it's so far from what actually doing science can be like. and unnecessarily cruel, esp to chronically ill and neurodivergent students

Lola

i am curious to see how much hooks focuses on university-level teaching in this book vs all different sectors of education. it'll be interesting to see i think. i was also wondering how her critique holds up re today's educational industrial complex, as you call it

Lola

i vibe so hard with your experience that being interested in something is not a natural state, but a result of investing yourself in it. the notion that there's stuff people are by nature inclined towards some things and not others boxes you in and so many times i have found myself instinctively rejecting engaging with / doing a thing bc "that's not something i do", only to catch myself later, "wait why do i not do that, and what if i did?"

Zenón

I think my favorite educational experience was in my physics program when my professors introduced “two part exams”. The first part would just be a normal exam but after that we’d start the second part where we got another copy of the exact same exam and were told to freely talk to each other. A year after we started doing exams this way they decided to just give us a take home final and encouraged the whole class to work together. We ended up taking an empty classroom and writing the solutions to all the problems on the chalk boards so people could admire them like an art gallery. We’d walk around and talk about each problem and edit them whenever someone saw something wrong. All of this was done without any teacher involvement. The class just got so used to collaborating that we were able to organize this all on our own. ( well tbh there were a few especially organized student who put it together but everyone was happy to help!)

Qamar Radmi

Hello ! So I'm replying a bit late sorry, but no I am not recently graduated, I'm more in my last year of undergrad. I really love the example you gave, but as you said, in my uni, the curiccula are always too packed, and so it's hard to have such an approach laid out by a professor.

Qamar Radmi

What happens mostly is in classes where we work on exercices, there is a certain liberty in how we shall approach (and I like that, sometimes I just put earphones to concentrate because I am easily distracted) and when I rest I can check on my classmate and see if we can help each other, and I find it to be really fulfilling when I help someone understand something, and vice versa

Kayla McDonogh

I really love this example of community led learning. Isn’t this how learning happens outside of the education system? Collaboratively with many minds working together to solve common goals. Why don’t we use more of this in our classrooms? I can tell you, from being a high school teacher the students feel and internalize the hierarchy of individualism competition achievement. Those who do not learn the banking system well do not feel the community belonging from public schools, or look to other means.

Kayla McDonogh

The Māori are often referenced in west for their liberation education! We are very far behind, many years in mindset and skill set. Now we’re even more and more behind with elimination of DEI in education. I admire those who has done this work before, thank you for sharing their stories. I would love to learn more. Washington state has also ahead by systemically investing in inclusive education, which usually lends to more liberation of education. If you put student’s with disabilities into the individual hierarchy classrooms, they often feel worse. Instruction for inclusive education does not make since without liberation of education, and instructional strategies that intentionally use collective wisdom rather than competition. https://ospi.k12.wa.us/student-success/support-programs/inclusionary-practices-technical-assistance-network-iptn

Hari Sood

Going to add some thoughts before going through comments above! I accidenally read the intro before going to bed and then couldn't sleep for ages cos I got excited and my mind was racing with thoughts on revolutionising education lol. I really enjoyed the overall messaging and found a lot of validation in her approach. Some thoughts: - Educating as fundamentally political: This is one of those things that is like seemingly so obviously true but not practiced much at all across the board! The way she discusses the difference between being in a predominantly black school (political education was a given) vs a predominantly white school (information acquisition and memorisation focus) made me think a lot about my education - I got good grades throughout school, but only first engaged in political education through philosophy units at Uni. I went to a very priveleged high school, and one thing I am always furious about is how not once in this school was I ever taught about my position of privelege, how lucky I was to be there, how scarce this was and how the world is set up in such a way that only an exclusive few get access. Nah was j about 'remember this, get good grades, report back to parents'. Everything human is political, so if education is about sharing lessons of the world with people, surely it has to start political!! Why does it matter that I know what colour copper sulphate is if I don't understand what oppression means!! - "...learning, a life of the mind, was a counter-hegemonic act" I have often felt that, however possessive and dominating a person or group is, they can never control another person's soul - you can control their bodies, and even brutally shape how they think, but you can never control the fundamental human essence that is them. And also how education can liberate, as it can help you communicate your soul. I came across a really cool term recently, 'hermeneutical injustice', which is the injustice you face when you don't have the language to describe your experiece and oppression - for instance, how many people, especially women, may not have had the language to describe their oppressive home lives until concepts around domestic abuse and assault became more available and discussed. Knowledge IS power, not least when used to UNDERSTAND power. - "That everyone influences the classroom dymanic, that everyone contributes" Yes!! I've always thought that teaching is going on a journey with your students, rather than like a many-to-one hierarchical relationship, so totally vibe with this. It reminds me of Actor Network Theory, where everyone and everything involved is an actor, which then influences the interactions in the space - in this case not only is every student an equal actor with the teacher, but so is the room, every desk, the whiteboard, everything! This helps me conceptualise the breaking down of hierarchies into equal, active interactions, which feels critical for liberatory education (I did also write a blog post on some of these ideas recently hmu if u r interested 👀) In terms of learning being sheer joy... not really. I had some good teachers at school but none that ever really captured my imagination, or spoke to me on an individual level. I always wonder what specific curious hobbies/interests I would've developed had I had teachers who had guided me in this way but I guess 🤷🏽at University I had a bit more fun, especially when going to see my philosophy professors and having intense discussions about what I was writing about. I'm now thinking there MUST be something I enjoyed more than I can recall atm, so will revisit this...

Hari Sood

Your English teacher sounds so phenomenal phil, and such a rarity in the education system 😭 the theme I see in your comment is 'I got super engaged and excited when given the freedom and space to explore' - isn't it wild that this feels so obvious when written down, but then becomes a standout/exceptional experience in all of our educations?? What has gone so wrong?? Also small thought, I recently learned that 'lame' is probs an ablist term - I've started replacing it with stuff like 'dead' and 'wet'

Hari Sood

Love your thoughts Kayla! I find it particularly telling how you mention how you are limited as a singular teacher, and how this allows the education system to keep itself propped up - if you as a teacher are already rammed trying to cram information into your students' brains, because that is how your performance is measured and how you keep your job, who is able to be the educator who slows things down, and empowers the most oppressed? Can it be teachers in schools, or does it currently need to be educators outside the school system?

Hari Sood

Your thoughts remind me of what she wrote about teaching being a 'performative act...meant to serve as a catalyst that calls everyone to become more an dmore engaged, to become active participants in learning' - seeing teaching as a performance is such a cool thought and makes it much more freeing and creative thatn just 'get people to remember information'

Hari Sood

Your the second (or third?) to say this Justin, and it's so sad as in the UK arts education funding has been deteriorating for YEARS. I have friends who are really musical but have never had the chance to learn music in an organised setting as it wasn't available to them in their school journeys. We need more opportunities for people to experience the magic of things like choirs!

Hari Sood

Where was your school Matt?? All I remember from UK history classes is the World Wars and like Henry VIII lol

Hari Sood

Same! Would love to explore anything you find if you look into this Warren :)

Hari Sood

I love the phrasing of finding joy in flexible and communal teaching Atallah!

Matt Fernandez

I was in Reading. I think it was years 8, 9, and 10? But it's been a while so I might be off on that, lol.

Hari Sood

Great train station, great schools 😎

ASDF

I know I'm a bit late to the party, but I wanted to comment on some aspects of the intro before moving on to chapter 1. My first time reading this book, I was optimistic and using its lessons about freedom, joy, empathy, and challengimg the status quo to inform my own teaching and learning process as a young graduate student. For this readthrough, I am in a depressed funk after getting chewed up and spit out by entrenched systems of domination that denied me a degree for daring to think differently. > The feminist classroom was the one place where students could raise critical questions about pedagogical process. These critiques were not always encouraged or well received, but they were allowed. That small acceptance of critical interrogation was a crucial challenge inviting us to think seriously about pedagogy in relation to the practice of freedom. This passage elicits the most emotion from me, mostly because of how directly it contradicts with my experience. Indeed, it has been in feminist spaces where the worship of domination and the rejection of diversity have been the most pronounced during my extended and failed attempt to earn a PhD. I wish that there was a way to revive the anti-hierarchical and pro-freedom practices of feminism that we appear to have lost between the time of bell hooks and the current day.