"Teaching to Transgress" - Chapter 1: Engaged Pedagogy (Patreon)
Content
“To teach in a manner that respects and cares for the souls of our students is essential if we are to provide the necessary conditions where learning can most deeply and intimately begin….Progressive, holistic education, “engaged pedagogy” is more demanding than conventional critical or feminist pedagogy. For, unlike these two teaching practices, it emphasizes well-being. That means that teachers must be actively committed to a process of self-actualization that promotes their own well-being if they are to teach in a manner that empowers students.”
I’ve long believed the first part of this statement to be true—I’ve probably said before somewhere in a video that I think part of developing an empathetic STEM workforce that doesn’t just serve empire is teaching in a way that treats students with empathy. But as painfully obvious as it feel when she says it, I hadn’t really taken this idea in the direction that hooks does here, where the spiritual well-being of the teacher is a necessary step of teaching in such a way.
Another point where I already was halfway there but she added some interesting dimension to my existing thoughts was in her discussion of wholeness (or rather, the lack thereof) in the teaching profession. I was nodding my head in agreement when she talked about how the denial of academics’ wholeness works to excuse shitty behavior:
“...whether academics were drug addicts, alcoholics, batterers, or sexual abusers, the only important aspect of our identity was whether or not our minds functioned, whether we were able to do our jobs in the classroom. The self was presumably emptied our the moment the threshold was crossed, leaving in place only an objective mind—free of experiences and biases.”
However, I hadn’t really thought of the other side of this spiritual emptying—that this norm that excuses the shitty humanity of some people is the same norm that suppresses the non-shitty humanity of other people. I definitely got into this in depth in the palestine video re my experience of not liking colonization while in grad school and that just kinda not being a relevant part of my personhood at work, so I’m not gonna dwell on it here, but it was interesting to see how (like in so many other cases) a “common sense” way of doing education works simultaneously to support bad actors and diminish the efforts of potentially good actors.
There was a line that did get me into a reflective mood that I’m a little more interested in sharing about:
“Any classroom that employs a holistic model of learning will also be a place where teachers grow, and are empowered by the process.”
For any teachers here, I have a prompt I’d be curious to hear reflections on: how have your experiences teaching made you grow? And for non-teachers, can you think of an experience with an educator that resonates with this concept of teacher vulnerability as a means to student growth?
I can think of a few different instances of this for me but one stands out the most. I’ve taught ESL to young children who had recently experienced war (taught in Libya after the 2011 revolution and then a few years later in Turkey to Syrian refugees). I went into the first experience feeling pretty competent; I had already TA’d a few physics classes and figured english for kids would be easy enough. I had no idea how much the experiences of those kids were going to show up in my classrooms, or how they’d present (extremely understandable) barriers to learning. I showed up the first time probably a lot closer to a ‘banking model of education’ teacher than I’d like to admit—being very strict and disciplined and to the point, focusing on the material and trying to shut down distractions. But as time passed, things happened that interrupted the idealization of teaching I had imagined. I’d meet the parents of a struggling student and see the pressure they’re getting from home; I’d learn that a student who was acting out was dealing with the loss of loved ones; one time a kid even brought a gun to school—not in the american white guy way where he wanted to shoot up a school, but bc after the revolution everyone had guns and he wanted to show his friends he was like the brave men he’d seen defend his people. It was impossible to have these things happen and still pretend that staying within the curriculum, just drilling exercises and grading homework, sticking to the teaching script, all of these things just weren't possibly enough for what these students actually needed at this moment in their life. And don’t get me wrong, we still worked on learning English, but it turned out that they were a lot more able to do that when I took the time to engage with them on the level of their humanity first, rather than expecting them to live it outside the classroom. Needless to say, I’ve been a lot more curious to learn about the lives and experiences of my students since then and tend to be a lot more flexible/sympathetic—I really try not to assume why anyone shows up the way they do. And I think that shift had ripple effects---first it was how I saw students, then I started applying that thinking to more social interactions, and eventually I've even gotten better at extending that understanding to myself. Soooo yeah spiritual growth in teaching abound lol