Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“To teach in a manner that respects and cares for the souls of our students is essential if we are to provide the necessary conditions where learning can most deeply and intimately begin….Progressive, holistic education, “engaged pedagogy” is more demanding than conventional critical or feminist pedagogy. For, unlike these two teaching practices, it emphasizes well-being. That means that teachers must be actively committed to a process of self-actualization that promotes their own well-being if they are to teach in a manner that empowers students.”

I’ve long believed the first part of this statement to be true—I’ve probably said before somewhere in a video that I think part of developing an empathetic STEM workforce that doesn’t just serve empire is teaching in a way that treats students with empathy. But as painfully obvious as it feel when she says it, I hadn’t really taken this idea in the direction that hooks does here, where the spiritual well-being of the teacher is a necessary step of teaching in such a way. 

Another point where I already was halfway there but she added some interesting dimension to my existing thoughts was in her discussion of wholeness (or rather, the lack thereof) in the teaching profession. I was nodding my head in agreement when she talked about how the denial of academics’ wholeness works to excuse shitty behavior:

“...whether academics were drug addicts, alcoholics, batterers, or sexual abusers, the only important aspect of our identity was whether or not our minds functioned, whether we were able to do our jobs in the classroom. The self was presumably emptied our the moment the threshold was crossed, leaving in place only an objective mind—free of experiences and biases.”

However, I hadn’t really thought of the other side of this spiritual emptying—that this norm that excuses the shitty humanity of some people is the same norm that suppresses the non-shitty humanity of other people. I definitely got into this in depth in the palestine video re my experience of not liking colonization while in grad school and that just kinda not being a relevant part of my personhood at work, so I’m not gonna dwell on it here, but it was interesting to see how (like in so many other cases) a “common sense” way of doing education works simultaneously to support bad actors and diminish the efforts of potentially good actors.

There was a line that did get me into a reflective mood that I’m a little more interested in sharing about:

“Any classroom that employs a holistic model of learning will also be a place where teachers grow, and are empowered by the process.”

For any teachers here, I have a prompt I’d be curious to hear reflections on: how have your experiences teaching made you grow? And for non-teachers, can you think of an experience with an educator that resonates with this concept of teacher vulnerability as a means to student growth?

I can think of a few different instances of this for me but one stands out the most. I’ve taught ESL to young children who had recently experienced war (taught in Libya after the 2011 revolution and then a few years later in Turkey to Syrian refugees). I went into the first experience feeling pretty competent; I had already TA’d a few physics classes and figured english for kids would be easy enough. I had no idea how much the experiences of those kids were going to show up in my classrooms, or how they’d present (extremely understandable) barriers to learning. I showed up the first time probably a lot closer to a ‘banking model of education’ teacher than I’d like to admit—being very strict and disciplined and to the point, focusing on the material and trying to shut down distractions. But as time passed, things happened that interrupted the idealization of teaching I had imagined. I’d meet the parents of a struggling student and see the pressure they’re getting from home; I’d learn that a student who was acting out was dealing with the loss of loved ones; one time a kid even brought a gun to school—not in the american white guy way where he wanted to shoot up a school, but bc after the revolution everyone had guns and he wanted to show his friends he was like the brave men he’d seen defend his people. It was impossible to have these things happen and still pretend that staying within the curriculum, just drilling exercises and grading homework, sticking to the teaching script, all of these things just weren't possibly enough for what these students actually needed at this moment in their life. And don’t get me wrong, we still worked on learning English, but it turned out that they were a lot more able to do that when I took the time to engage with them on the level of their humanity first, rather than expecting them to live it outside the classroom. Needless to say, I’ve been a lot more curious to learn about the lives and experiences of my students since then and tend to be a lot more flexible/sympathetic—I really try not to assume why anyone shows up the way they do. And I think that shift had ripple effects---first it was how I saw students, then I started applying that thinking to more social interactions, and eventually I've even gotten better at extending that understanding to myself. Soooo yeah spiritual growth in teaching abound lol

Comments

Justin Walker

I've had a lot of teachers being vulnerable to me in my educational journey but I find myself coming back to a few specific professors that I would like to get into more detail about who they were in the philosophies in which they taught but by myself in a crossroad or people are actively after pursuit of negating my education that being said I always enjoyed the arts and sciences and those that taught those subjects always seem to be emotionally ready to answer my questions is we dive deeper into different realms of thought

AlexTheTutor

"how have your experiences teaching made you grow?" I am a teacher, but I do not teach at a school, I teach privately (think of a tutor), I teach math and science and English, I teach students from elementary, middle, high school, college, and sometimes graduate level. I have been teaching for 24 years. I want to write an entire book answering this question, but I won't. I will try my best to be brief. Chapter 1: I remember the high school kid who did drugs but then after we spoke enough times, he stopped drugs, he started to study, he started to take care of his younger siblings, he started to care; and that college student whose parents never told her she could be anything, but I said she could at least try and she owes it to herself to go medical school; and insert 100 other stories... I always taught by first principles in the sense that if a child or student comes to me without receiving love at home or elsewhere, there is really no point in me teaching them anything, until and unless they have a sense of direction and purpose, a sense of self, a sense of security. Most likely all those students couldn't tell me how to solve for x or whatever, but they were able to begin to resolve deeper issues and gain confidence, gain determination, gain all those intangible qualities that no academic test could ever begin to quantify. Yes, there are other students who remember all the little tricks I told them to solve problems, and they got their 100's on their exams. But, even still. Years from now, people will never forget how well you treated them when you had nothing. Chapter 2: but, there are other students who instead of trying to improve, all they want to do is complain and act like victims, they are like vampires that drain your energy, in my experience many adult students who want to be nurses but will say they don't need to know math or how to write with so much confidence, and "lucky" for them a lot of programs (trying to survive financially) have done away with a lot of standards in order to retain more students and maintain tuition revenue, these adult students can't be told what to do, they are adults, they are anxious and afraid, and so their fear will perceive you as not good enough, all the collective wisdom and experience will mean nothing to them, they will not listen to anything you have to say, but that is why i am a private teacher, i can choose who to teach based on who is willing to listen, the poor teachers who quit every year, they tried their best to teach when no one cared to listen.. i remember the first Rocky movie, Rocky saw a teen girl on the streets at night smoking, so Rocky took her home, the teen girl hated Rocky and thought he was a loser for trying to tell her what to do, Rocky wasn't a hero at that point, he did not self-actualize, he was still just a bum, but when Rocky trained and won his boxing match, the whole world wanted to listen to him, so yes it's true, maintaing a process of self-actualization is essential for the great teacher, but if someone self-actualizes and no one is around to see it happen, at least to the everyone else, did any self-actualization ever happen? Chapter 3: so, it's important to reflect on your life, to reflect on your growth, and so when a student challenges you with a question, that you have an immediate answer, "why should I listen to you? you don't know what it's like", well i didn't learn how to read until i was 17, i was neglected before then, i didn't have any money when i was in college because i decided to date a black girl and my parents cut me off because of that, but that 10 years later i was still there for my parents before and when they died, and when the rest of my family died too, and who else was there? the students who never gave up on themselves, even when all they had to eat was flour and sugar for dinner due to "complicated family dynamics", but that they still worked hard and made a better life for themselves, the students i was able to connect with on a deeper level, despite that the fact that we never shared any of our past with one another, but that our past resonated even in the present moment, and those qualities of resiliency and perseverence reflect back from me to them and from them to me.. teaching the same students for years is like planting trees in your garden, never knowing if the seeds will germinate, it takes years of patience and care to see if they will grow, and yes there will be bad days (storms and snow), but things in life pass, and time after time, miracles happen (exams aced, courses passed after the 4th try, entrance exams passed after the 10th try, graduations, etc), and thoses miracles allow you grow your own roots of faith, everything allows one to self-actualize until (regardless of weather or etc) you feel yourself in a paradise of gratitude and fullfillment... so how have experiences being a teacher has made me grow? Chapter 4: yes

Edison Hauptman

Sadly not keeping up with the book because I have an exam soon, but I enjoy reading everyone’s thoughts! To briefly answer the prompt: encouraging my students to find the parts of the course that matter *to them* and to build their knowledge from that basis has resulted in some awesome projects—some which make me more enthusiastic to share the parts of the course that interest me (even if it’s “off-topic”), and some of which simply give me opportunities to learn more about the world. I teach math, and many of my students build from interesting topics I haven’t seen before, so there’s a nice exchange of knowledge taking place in my classroom environment—one, on reflection, that I want to be more intentional about sharing with the *entire* class rather than my current one-on-one model.

Kayla McDonogh

Thank you Dr. Fatima for asking the question of personal growth as an educator. In my perspective, working as an educator is agreeing to continual education and personal growth. Teaching has allowed me to experience advocating for students with disabilities in the public school system. The experience of designing their education through a collaborative process of identifying the correct individualizing education based on a collaborative team has given me more experience and led me to disability justice advocacy. I’ve had to confront some of my own ableism and been confronted with the assimilation of public schools. I’ve gone from blaming individuals to blaming systems, which is a better fight; but I’ve been able to see how thoughts around me shape my own behavior. The success of inclusive education truly depends on the community understanding deeply the meaning of, how to, and support of inclusive education. What I love is to continue learning more about disability justice and education liberation, I hope that we can grow local support for public education; because inclusive education is the perfect step in the door for liberation education. A real push towards accepting diversity as a strength, and how that manifests in instructional design moves us more towards liberation and inclusion for all students. I love gaining a more clear vision of what inclusive education is and feels like. Here are a few quotes that stood out to me. “A classroom was diminished if students and professors regarded one another as “whole” human beings, striving not just for knowledge in books, but knowledge about how to live in the world.” “Progressive, holistic education, “engaged pedagogy” is more demanding than conventional critical or feminist pedagogy.” “teacher or any helping professional should be directed toward his or herself first because if the helper is unhappy he or she cannot help many people.” Keywords: joy, freedom, student expression,

Anne Vermeyden

I can't wait to talk about how our current models of employment in higher-ed actively work to prevent this self-actualization. Like. How can a sessional teaching at 3 different institutions and commuting their life away to have the energy or even institutional safety to do this kind of work? The additional emotional labour profs and educators are doing as they implement this vulnerability in the classroom for meaningful education is honestly so exploited by our institutions :(.

phil e the theyby

So I'm a clinical supervisor to psychology interns at a university counseling system (so basically, supervising the therapy they provide to university students), which is a sort of "practical education." Each semester (well, Spring and Summer are combined), I supervise a different person, and we meet for two hours a week for individual supervision. As I've continued to do this job, it feels like and less like "lecturing" or even "talking about clients," and more and more like fostering a spiritual journey. When hooks references Thich Nhat Hanh's idea of "teacher as healer," that feels DEEPLY resonant to me, as I'm always prioritizing supervisees' well-being and wholeness as people over anything else. And this isn't just because "it's fun to talk about our real human experiences" or "it feels good to connect with another human"; I feel like all of the times when my supervisees have been ineffective with their therapy clients, it's come from a place of being disconnected from themselves. No amount of technical knowledge can even replace the benefit a therapist can provide by just being a fully present, empathic, and caring human to the person sitting in front of them. For me, I feel like I'm always being transformed by what I learn from supervisees. I see how themes that emerge in my life parallel themes in their lives, in spite of completely different social positioning. I get to witness how immense joy can emerge from incredible hardship. I get to see who they are as unique individuals start to emerge from behind the facade of "professionalism," and how transformative their unique selves can be for their clients. And I find that a big part of what allows that to happen is just by me being who I am, not as a stoic professional, but as a full, embodied human trying to make sense of the world. By honoring and embracing the parts of myself that make my job difficult for me (AND the parts that make me good at it), I help supervisees move from a "competence"-based, fixed mindset ("either I'm good at this or I'm not") to a more holistic, growth mindset ("I'm a complete person, and some things will be harder for me and some will be easier, but I can always learn and grow"). One thing bell hook said REALLY get at the heart of what I've experienced: "There are times when I walk into classrooms overflowing with students who feel terribly wounded in their psyches... yet I do not think that they want therapy from me. They do want an education that is healing to the uninformed, unknowing spirit. They do want knowledge that is meaningful" (19). It sometimes takes a lot of work to get supervisees out of the very intellectualized ways of knowing and being. As hooks notes: "Most professors were often deeply antagonistic toward, even scornful of, any approach to learning emerging from a philosophical standpoint emphasizing the union of mind, body, and spirit, rather than the separation of those elements" (18). But when they really start to get there, it gets a WHOLE lot more fun. We laugh all the time in supervision. But that laughter also creates room for tears, for genuine curiosity, for grieving and for hope. Honestly, it's a blast.

Qamar Radmi

I think the part that stood out to me was the quote : "being smart meant that one was inherently emotionally unstable and that the best in oneself emerged in one's academic work" I think this rings so true within the students I met, we joked around saying that us and our classmates were all socially inept, which I took first as a half-joke, but it becomes less funny when I start noticing how ill-equipped these people really are with interacting with minorities and exhibiting racist rhetoric but in a non-necessarily malicious way, and it feels like there is no real space to discuss these things, especially since we don't have our english class anymore this semester, so we're just doing maths continuously, and sometimes I worry about how disconnected we become from the real world and society, and how easy it is to live in our academic bubble, where all that matters is how smart you are. I will be honest, I too indulge in this in a rather interesting way. Being trans, I feel almost always rejected by society, family, etc., and in academia, a space where I can have whatever "emotional unstability" (in this case, transness as seen by society), as long as I show my best in academic work, I can stay in this rather friendlier place than outside. I always think about if I get really great in academia and get a good position, I could be trans but at least I would also be great so people couldn't disregard me for the former in the benefit for the latter. I want to talk a bit about some of my teachers, one of them was really inspiring to me, but it lately started feeling that students are just an afterthought for her. Not willingly I think, but just for the fact that she has so much obligations in academia (research, teaching, pedagogical organising,...), it's sad to see engaged teachers become drowned in responsibilities so much that they cannot really engage meaningfully anymore.

Moz in Oz

That was my thought. The whole industrial education model is opposed to that kind of connection. Impose the curriculum, grind the standardised tests, extrude obedient wage slaves. Repeat until retirement. Which is why some of my friends are very involved in Steiner schools despite the woo behind them, the holistic approach is much more survivable for kids that might not cope with being hammered into shape.

phil e the theyby

You bring up such a good point about how academia can be a safe haven for folks who struggle in other areas! And just as the “solution” in academia involves honoring and uplifting diverse human experiences and teaching academic concepts in ways that actually resonate with people’s human experiences, I think it’s super important that, in our personal relationships, we honor the range of people’s emotional experience and “social skills.” I think those of us who are “skilled” socially (which I…sort of am? I’ve come a long way from my youth when I definitely wasn’t, anyway) need to be patient and compassionate with those who aren’t, and work to understand them and help them communicate more effectively without shaming them. As someone who REALLY struggled with my emotions and with social relationships, I would have LOVED if someone would have said “hey, I really care about you and want to know more about you. But when you talk about your interests in this way, I find it really hard to follow you and be interested in what you’re talking about. Here are ways you can share your interests with others while still engaging them in the conversation.” But just like how schools don’t put any effort into helping anyone who isn’t seen as “smart,” anyone who’s seen as “awkward” is completely rejected in our social worlds. I think we need to do a lot better in supporting people in learning to connect and engage with each other.

Hari Sood

Some thoughts on the chapter: Teachers growing too - this is a really cool and important point, I know from so many of my teachers at school, and also having met a lot of teachers as an adult, how many of them are just there to regurgitate a curriculum to get their kids grades. The most frustrating are the ones that are fully checked out of connecting, but even those who want to be teachers, often there is this aspect missing of like 'you are a person who is learning from the classroom too'. But tbf I do wonder in such a high stress job where the curriculum is already too long to be teachable and you have like 30 students a class, how easy it is to actually practice this truly. The system is set up to fail teachers! The university as a haven for book knowledge - OMG so I used to work at a research Institute and the senior people there were SUCH BAD LEADERS. Sure they knew a lot about their subject areas, and could give really deep insight, but jeeez when it came to like team decisions, organisational decisions, human interactions, they were AWFUL. And it was so sad cos there were all these like excited, engaged junior staff members who were just squeezed and drained and spending like ALL their time dealing with the internal politics of emotionally immature senior staff. We kept reflecting how seniority and promotion seemed to be based just on academic ability as opposed to ability to lead a team etc and it is just such a shame - this place in particular, with good leadership it could've been world-changing with some of the junior staff I knew. Intellectual as someone whole - love this idea! It reminds me of when I see articles/people talking about how 'the smartest minds' do XYZ, and they are pretty much referring to people that work in big tech. I'm j a bit like, yeah these people are clearly good at maths/computing but what about moral intelligence, social intelligence, creative intelligence, spiritual intelligence any other intelligence? Surely the 'smartest minds' wouldn't devote their life blindly to hegemonic institutions, or would e.g. have an opinion about genocide? Time to end intelligence as a one measure thing (or a thing in general tbh). The thoughts on teachers needing to work on themselves and being healers - this is really cool and makes me think about e.g. how therapists can do so much damage to people when they haven't worked through their own neuroses yet. This makes sense to a lot of people but I guess we never really extend it to teachers, even though teachers likely have the most active interactions with young people outside immediate systems of care than anyone else. Hurt people hurt people, and hurt people traumatise young people over whom they hold power! Student expectations in the classroom - so cool and just like a direct way of sharing how the current education system and power-hungry educators are failing students. This book is really helping me understand education as a journey that everyone takes together, and in which everyone is learning something new. Cool stuff! In answer to Fatima's question - and it will be way less beautiful and rich - I spent summers at University working as a camp counsellor in the US. This was a really formative experience for me (although I know how bad the camp scene is, this one was hella expensive so all the kids were from very wealthy backgrounds), as it showed me what alternative education spaces could look like - adults engaged in teaching kids so many different skills, ideas, hobbies, topics, adults not necessarily that much older than the oldest campers meaning the relationships were much more like older sibling-y and equal than really authoritative, and also how the whole experience was also firmly discussed as a growth and development opportunity for the counsellors, with campers/counsellors sharing spaces in e.g. camp-wide meetings to discuss personal and vulnerable stories (e.g., open contribution all camp meetings discussing friendship, or change, or loss). I feel the space did really well to balance ensuring safeguarding (adults/counsellors there to care for the campers) but also humble the counsellors to learn and grow alongside the campers. And in this space you would often see campers who really struggle at school (academically, socially) really come alive and thrive. Shame it is j so exclusive and temporary!

Hari Sood

Love these thoughts both! Makes me think of two things - one is that in academia I wonder if there's more room to separate the research side from the education side if that makes sense - lots of people will go into academia primarily to carry out research and explore complex ideas, others will go in primarily to teach. Whilst people can obviously do both, I wonder if having more variety of roles within academic spaces can be a way to practice supporting some of the diversity you're talking about. Also (kind of side thought), I recently came across a thought about social anxiety - that actually no-one is in ESSENCE socially anxious, but that the normative ways of socialising can make people anxious if it's not the way they want to socialise. Socialising for me is just connecting with others, and that can be in literally any form - even just silently sharing the same space, or online communities or smth. I really feel like everyone has ways they like to connect with others, but we're forced to do this like robotic 'how are you?' 'what have you been doing recently?' 'how about them taxes eh?' (my friend calls this 'beep booping' cos everyone is being a robot) which makes a lot of people (including me) anxious. E.g. I would say we're all socialising in a form here - and it is beautiful!

Hari Sood

This is so beautiful phil! > the benefit a therapist can provide by just being a fully present, empathic, and caring human to the person sitting in front of them. This really resonates with me, in tough times in my life when I've gone to people close to me they often fret and worry so much about whether they are providing the right care, and I am always j like 'literally you just being here and seeing me is enough'. It also saddens me to realise in these situations how little we teach people about effective care, and so how unprepared and unconfident they feel when they need to provide it

Hari Sood

ooo what are Steiner schools??

Hari Sood

Love this idea of going from blaming individuals to blaming systems, I always feel like the former is easier, but the latter is right 🙏🏽

AJ Biffl

I've been thinking about the prompt all week. It's difficult for me to pin down one thing that I've learned or grown from as a teacher, since I'm still very new to it (this is now my second semester as a TA). I'm still very much learning the mechanics of teaching, trying to pick up the strategies of the more experienced TA's, tips from the professors, things like that. One thing I really *look forward* to learning as I teach more is seeing how many ways there are to learn something, how few one-size-fits-all boxes to present new information in. I've spent so long understanding these topics in one particular way, and I'm really looking forward to encountering new ways of understanding and packaging this information that works for other people. I also really resonated with the points about the partitioning of teachers ("the self was presumably emptied out the moment the threshold was crossed, leaving in place only an objective mind -- free of experiences and biases"). It reminded me of scientism, this idea that Objective Truth can somehow pour out of someone's face and be independent of the person doing the teaching. Crazy that it's infested every department of the academy. I have in my notes -- "The One True Religion of the military, the investment bros, and big tech - nothing succeeds like success."

AJ Biffl

I also highlighted the sentence, "our work is not merely to share information but to share in the intellectual and spiritual growth of our students," which I thought was really powerful. Again this idea of actually viewing students as people

Hari Sood

looks so interesting thanks Moz! Will have an explore, though sad to learn on a quick glance that Steiner was a massive racist 😭

Moz in Oz

A whole lot of progressive thought in the early 1900's was disturbing in various ways. It pays to be aware of it but try to focus on the positive parts. There's good in just about everything, although the proportion varies!

sentient

I am just starting the reading today. I am at page 6 transparently. I reflected on my experience, I didn't make it as far as others here when I was younger. Growing up in the US South, education institutions elevated "well behaved" white folks and particularly white boys that predominantly white female teachers found cute -- ew!, there was no relationship to intellectual interest or creativity. BIPOC people were non entities and invisible at best, not gendered or relevant unless they could be ridiculed by the teachers. It wasn't that long ago. I learned one had to do drugs to be checked out enough to understand the level of mind dulling insanity and also just not speak. Everyone was threatened by BIPOC people making sense. White girls learned to raise their hands after we would talk and repeat a fragment of what we said and get praised by the teacher. They'd make snarky faces at us to emphasize we were put in our places. My first teaching experience was at age 12 as a substitute teacher of dance; I had learned to be stern, disciplinarian and had been taught with physical assault and verbal battering included. When I was a substitute teacher, I was told I was outdoing the teacher as a stern authoritarian, thankfully minus the physical and verbal assault. That made me ease up. The 1491s singing lesson sketch reminded me of that experience. I had loved Montessori and Freire as a five and six year old kid and would write treatise on education at that age, and was moved by the muckrakers. I was more of academic then, and in short order it was blunted out of me. I was in my own world, except for a few who would listen to my thoughts and take notes. My teaching experiences as an adult were rooted in student directed learning that integrated trauma care. I enjoyed offering support for learners with needs that were often unaddressed by other institutes. I loved it, and of course the institute became popular and that meant that care for students went out the window. I experienced this again in post grad continuing education settings, where they literally conscript progressives to author education and have neolibs deliver a militaristic style education with POC masks -- it's the pinnacle of perfected covert hegemonic education takeover. Of course, they didn't want teachers that taught and inspired confidence and creative self actualization in their learners, that's the dreaded A word, "activism." This reading makes the burnout feel less confusing. Thank you for sharing this. Sorry for any typos.