"Teaching to Transgress" - Chapter 3: Embracing Change (Patreon)
Content
So this book was first published in 1994–over 30 years ago—and this chapter’s opening sentence about the state of inclusion in teaching feel
So this book was first published in 1994–over 30 years ago—and this chapter’s opening sentence about the state of inclusion in teaching feels annoyingly still relevant.
I really appreciated her discussion of the needs of educators in the process of learning to teach multicultural classrooms. A few lines I highlighted:
“...any effort to transform institutions so that they reflect a multi-cultural standpoint must take into consideration the fears teachers have when asked to shift their paradigms.”
“Since our seminar was to educate for critical consciousness, we did not want the seminar setting to be a space where anyone would feel attacked or their reputation as a teacher sullied.”
When I think about most of the DEI efforts I’ve seen in some physics departments, I see the critical need for this kind of support. I remember feeling frustrated trying to argue for whatever interventions logically with faculty, only to eventually realize that logic is not a particularly helpful tool when their reluctance to change is coming from an emotional place (whether they realize it or not). I remember faculty being too scared about saying or doing the wrong thing to feel comfortable/motivated to do anything at all—which, as much as I want to be mad at, I begrudgingly understand the reasoning behind. In hindsight, I feel kinda naive about the extent to which I just didn’t consider the humanity of the professors I was trying to solicit help/action from, and I wonder if I would have been more effective If I spent more time trying to understand their needs of people. I’m not beating myself up about it too bad though bc it’s really hard to be empathetic to ppl who have power over you and are making your life difficult, but I do think I’ve started value skills like—idk what to call it, diplomacy? Strategically being kind to power?—since that time. Recognizing the difference between my beliefs about how people should behave and realistic expectations about how people can/will behave, I guess.
Besides that, I really liked the stuff about not seeking validation as a teachers:
“The presence of tension—and at times, even conflict—often meant that students did not enjoy my classes or love me, their professor, as I secretly wanted to.”
“...many of my students who bitch endlessly while they are taking my classes contact me at a later date to talk about how much that experience meant to them, how much they learned.”
“Moving away from the need for immediate affirmation was crucial to my growth as a teacher"
This one resonates sooo much, especially as a woman teaching physics to predominantly male students, plenty of whom will inevitably not respect me (at least, at the start) on the basis of my appearance/identity alone. It’s a weird thing to be in what is supposedly an authority position in a classroom (or a public lecture even) and have people basically heckle you as you’re trying to teach. Over time I got used to standing my ground and kind of just dismissing anything that I felt was obviously disrespectful and continuing to do what I was actually there to do. Surprisingly, that would often get a good result—on more than a few occasions, I’ve had a student or audience member start the semester/evening from a very hostile place, but by the end of the experience, they’d significantly change how they engaged with me, sometimes even offering a sheepish apology for how they behaved to start. Sooo yeah lesson here is be ok with students disliking you lol
Very last thing and you don’t have to humor me on this but I’m curious if anyone has thoughts—towards the end of the chapter she talks about the way some of hooks’ students, once learning the things she has to offer, would tell her that “[they] can’t enjoy life anymore” (bc now they understand all these horrible social dynamics that exist like racism sexism etc). I feel like I often see the feedback on the vague category of leftist video essays that they just make people sad and add to viewers’ sense of doom. I don’t want to pull a lot of y’alls discussion energy into this, but I am wondering if people think this is the vibe they get from my videos. There is inherently a lot of doom and gloom in discussing issues that you want to change in some way, and I try to approach them in as productive ways as possible, but idk how things land for viewers. I’d think it’s slightly more positive bc i do think i have a pretty positive outlook on life, but who knows if that actually reads. So yeah feedback on this point welcome lol