Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

So this book was first published in 1994–over 30 years ago—and this chapter’s opening sentence about the state of inclusion in teaching feel

So this book was first published in 1994–over 30 years ago—and this chapter’s opening sentence about the state of inclusion in teaching feels annoyingly still relevant.

I really appreciated her discussion of the needs of educators in the process of learning to teach multicultural classrooms. A few lines I highlighted:

“...any effort to transform institutions so that they reflect a multi-cultural standpoint must take into consideration the fears teachers have when asked to shift their paradigms.”

“Since our seminar was to educate for critical consciousness, we did not want the seminar setting to be a space where anyone would feel attacked or their reputation as a teacher sullied.”

When I think about most of the DEI efforts I’ve seen in some physics departments, I see the critical need for this kind of support. I remember feeling frustrated trying to argue for whatever interventions logically with faculty, only to eventually realize that logic is not a particularly helpful tool when their reluctance to change is coming from an emotional place (whether they realize it or not). I remember faculty being too scared about saying or doing the wrong thing to feel comfortable/motivated to do anything at all—which, as much as I want to be mad at, I begrudgingly understand the reasoning behind. In hindsight, I feel kinda naive about the extent to which I just didn’t consider the humanity of the professors I was trying to solicit help/action from, and I wonder if I would have been more effective If I spent more time trying to understand their needs of people. I’m not beating myself up about it too bad though bc it’s really hard to be empathetic to ppl who have power over you and are making your life difficult, but I do think I’ve started value skills like—idk what to call it, diplomacy? Strategically being kind to power?—since that time. Recognizing the difference between my beliefs about how people should behave and realistic expectations about how people can/will behave, I guess.

Besides that, I really liked the stuff about not seeking validation as a teachers:

“The presence of tension—and at times, even conflict—often meant that students did not enjoy my classes or love me, their professor, as I secretly wanted to.”

“...many of my students who bitch endlessly while they are taking my classes contact me at a later date to talk about how much that experience meant to them, how much they learned.”

“Moving away from the need for immediate affirmation was crucial to my growth as a teacher"

This one resonates sooo much, especially as a woman teaching physics to predominantly male students, plenty of whom will inevitably not respect me (at least, at the start) on the basis of my appearance/identity alone.  It’s a weird thing to be in what is supposedly an authority position in a classroom (or a public lecture even) and have people basically heckle you as you’re trying to teach. Over time I got used to standing my ground and kind of just dismissing anything that I felt was obviously disrespectful and continuing to do what I was actually there to do. Surprisingly, that would often get a good result—on more than a few occasions, I’ve had a student or audience member start the semester/evening from a very hostile place, but by the end of the experience, they’d significantly change how they engaged with me, sometimes even offering a sheepish apology for how they behaved to start. Sooo yeah lesson here is be ok with students disliking you lol

Very last thing and you don’t have to humor me on this but I’m curious if anyone has thoughts—towards the end of the chapter she talks about the way some of hooks’ students, once learning the things she has to offer, would tell her that “[they] can’t enjoy life anymore” (bc now they understand all these horrible social dynamics that exist like racism sexism etc). I feel like I often see the feedback on the vague category of leftist video essays that they just make people sad and add to viewers’ sense of doom. I don’t want to pull a lot of y’alls discussion energy into this, but I am wondering if people think this is the vibe they get from my videos. There is inherently a lot of doom and gloom in discussing issues that you want to change in some way, and I try to approach them in as productive ways as possible, but idk how things land for viewers. I’d think it’s slightly more positive bc i do think i have a pretty positive outlook on life, but who knows if that actually reads. So yeah feedback on this point welcome lol


Comments

Justin Walker

Honestly I think that it becomes increasingly difficult to talk about things objectively because of the emotional nature of positive reinforcement from learning. Ie: it becomes harder to not feel good about learning specific material because learning is what people pride their emotions on, Ie such as the happiness someone has from being happy to explain something because they know the subject matter. I personally think you do a great job of elaborating on your points I am usually surrounded by people who don't have the attention span to delve into the topics and conversations covered in your videos so the fact that you can even generate such matter always piques my interest and make me what to watch or comment interact with your material in some manner hopefully that gave you some feedback ☺️

Kristen

I don't think your videos are gloomy, especially compared to a lot of other lefty analyses out there. I think you come from a very human place of "this is what we're told, and it kinda makes sense, but look here's this wrinkle what happens if we pull on it -- oops all bullshit! But it okay now we know."

schlltchrn

I think that a large part of the gloom comes from understanding some discouraging information intellectually, but then not being able to allow the natural emotional response, be it sadness or anger or disappointment, to exist fully. We end up kind of "stuck" in this in between space. I am at the very beginning of trying to embrace the emotional side in such situations, and your video on telescopes, Hawaii and Palestine was something that truly pushed me to examine it deeper, so thanks! At some other times I am not energised enough to engage with some critical materials with all the emotions that come, and that is okay, we all should find our balance I think. Having the offering to engage with it however is for sure very valuable. Regarding the empathetic approach to the people who perpetuate power, there is another layer that can be scary, I believe. The one arguing against oppression also has to present as more vulnerable in such conversation. I often fear speaking up on a topic because I am afraid to be so disappointed by the opinion that the other side holds dear, that I'll get in the fight or flight mode. Either shut down, or start a heated argument that will lead nowhere. But going at it with patience and compassion really needs this soft strength. Which, again, I don't have all the time and I understand that people don't have all the time. But trying to practice and strengthen that muscle, it's a huge challenge for sure.

bhobba

Very true. I find her very balanced.

AJ Biffl

I also highlighted bits about "diplomacy" toward educators, but I'd thought about it in terms of the connection between progressive thinking and acknowledging there are no inherent or absolute authorities. Then this position of needing to be empathetic toward people who are expected to lose their authority... I guess the ruling classes are people too... "it is difficult for individuals to shift paradigms and... there must be a setting for folks to voice fears, to talk about what they are doing, how they are doing it, and why." Which is great praxis honestly and a reminder that respect and openness, the tools at our disposal, can and should be employed everywhere, even where we might rather use pitchforks (obviously dealing with elderly professors with pitchforks is extreme, but I mean all ruling-class-types). I also spent some time trying to unpack "no education is politically neutral" as it pertains to teaching physics, because there's no explicit political content in the topics we talk about. I think I identified three sort of political bents to it, and I'm curious if others can think of more. First is just this open attitude as an educator, to treat students as people or treat them as servants, is a political act (goes back to some of the comments in the intro discussion about education as liberation/empowerment or as indoctrination). The second political shading I think is in the history of science - presenting any history is a political act, depending on what stories you tell or leave out, especially as an educator where you can totally shape people's view of a thing, it being the first time they've seen it. The third political shading I think is in how educators emphasize the USES for the science they teach. I had this horrifying moment going over old exams from previous years to collect practice problems for my students, when several old exams had problems where you're trying to do the calculations to drop a bomb on a bunch of "terrorists." After getting over the initial shock, it made me think how much emphasis teachers put in how you USE this knowledge is super important - if people only ever see physics problems applied to weapons and violence, of course they'll all become bomb builders. Obviously, I didn't choose any of those problems for the practice sheet. As far as the question of doom and gloom, I find your videos have the opposite effect, probably because I'm coming from a doom and gloom perspective already. You generally paint issues with a very tangible, actionable lens, which is the first time I've seen any creator or writer do that. And I've spent so long looking at these things from a hypothetical, intellectual viewpoint (and getting more and more despondent over the years) that finally finding someone who talks about these issues in a concrete, relatable way as it applies to my own field directly is hugely valuable and hugely inspiring.

AJ Biffl

Another question for others here: Hooks mentions that during one of her meetings with faculty they invited professors to talk about concrete strategies they'd used to make their classrooms more inclusive. Does anyone here have any strategies or stories about things they'e done in the past?

schlltchrn

Regarding the uses for the science that is thought, first of all, LOL what??? That problem is outrageous just... what!? I don't.. I... what? Second thing, I think that it is politically important in STEM education to emphasise that we DO have responsibilities in what we do and who we do it with. There are sooo many people who just too easily convince themselves that they are not responsible for what is being done with the technology they are developing. Just two days ago, I had a conversation with some uni people, a master and a PhD student, where I told them that our university has projects with gun manufacturers. They were like "hm, but it's not the fault of people producing the guns, it's the responsibility of the ones who use the guns" which I could not believe. I think they felt uncomfortable about what they said as the discussion continued, but it goes to show that is super important to make this responsibility clear to students early on.

AlexTheTutor

Tuition is casino-high-roller-table expensive, the idea that only my friends from other countries naturally expect that PUBLIC higher education is always by definition FREE, that’s gloomy, watching high-quality educational video lectures and participating in book clubs for a price of a coffee… that is the opposite of gloom, that’s cloudy apples without the clouds (esoteric reference), anyway moving on… I could write an entire essay about the many many experiences people have told me about the times multicultural initiatives did nothing but upset the very people they tried to influence, but unless people want to hear that, I want to keep things positive, also I just want to focus on ideas from the book, except to quickly say... several retired professors I know use their platforms to host podcasts or tv programs to have others share poetry from their cultures in a more informal setting, so there are teachers who want to do this, the most obvious solution is to just create a new university department and hire experts from other cultures to teach courses, but my guess is that it's not possible (MONEY) “eager to include Toni Morrison… but then teach that work without ever making reference to race”, not necessary, I often teach “Lord of the Flies” to private school boys (they need to read it anyway for school), they learn about crowd psychology, how crowds can go insane and hurt others, how outsiders will be the first to get hurt (Piggy), how this is especially true for crowds who once had high status (rich choir boys) but now feel like poor losers who wish to be winners again (stranded on island without food or shelter), students see themselves as the rich boys and wonder if they or their friends would go crazy too, and then I remind them of the time that no one defended that teacher whose cat died and how all the boys made fun of the teacher and made her cry (the students trusted me enough to tell me this story, and no I never taught any boy who did any of the bullying), I never needed to mention anything specific about race, they deeply understood from their own lived experiences, that others saw the teacher as weak and that when a crowd sees anyone as weak or lower status, the crowd can attack, (they mentioned other marginalized groups for and by themselves and shared their own stories), that in general we are all on a stranded island called Earth, and in the future WE have the power to use our voice to stand up for ourselves and for others, I did NOT plan to discuss any of this with them, the only plan was "let's just read and discuss the book", this isn't the only experience, there are others that include other works, but they always feel organic and natural, never forced and contrived, but in general it often can be more effective to teach about race without ever first mentioning it, but true education only occurs when goes off into the real world and applies lessons, so who knows if students learn anything, just need to have faith Also, Ru by Kim Thuy, Parable of the Sower by Octavia Butler, and Blindness by Jose Saramago have been great novels to teach students about gaining different perspectives, maybe others can suggest other books?

Hari Sood

Some thoughts: - On the humanising/patience with esp white educators: I think there's some balance to be had here, on the one hand I fully believe that everyone is a human trying their best in their specific context, who is j trying to be understood, and so landing first on their context and slowly shifting it will always be more effective than pummeling them with a very different view. That being said, I feel like any significant learning/shifts require risk, fear, and some faith that even though the new land is uncertain, there are lessons to be learned. And senior/powerful people are able to risk more. I think I land on gentle firmness - I am going to be firm in communicating what I think is right, but gentle to allow all the objections/worries to arise. Like taking someone to the new unknown land but still holding their hand. Ideas of threshold of liminality come to mind here - take someone to the edge of their reality, and gently lead them through it! Also Fatima on your strategising with power point, fuck me I struggle so much with this. Whenever someone senior to me at work is a dick I am like 'YOU ARE MORE SENIOR THAT ME AND HOLD POWER OVER ME I NEED YOU TO BE MORE MATURE'. So I def have lessons to learn on like 'managing upwards' - Safe spaces: this feels soooo critical to me, mb even the most critical thing - almost like a hierarchy of needs thing (tho ofc hierarchies aren't reality and everything is mushy). I want to take people at their word, and they won't feel they can express their true word if they don't feel safe. Start with safety for everyone and go from there! Rock on! - Growth as a teacher moving from affirmation: Nice! - 'Native informant' points: Omg 🙄 so out of uni the first place I worked was a mega-capitalist consultancy (young me having internalised like rUnNiNg A bUsInEsS iS tHe UlTiMaTe GoTtA lEaRn) and when I once challenged a director (ex army general) on how the company doesn't think about diversity properly he was j like 'that's why we have young people like you to show us and tell us how' i was j like SORRY you earn like 10x times more than me, have significant institutitional influence and also can get me fired with one email, I am not able to nor am I going to try to challenge your views and make you uncomfortable. Offloading this kind of work to junior employees is basically a way of saying 'idgaf and I'll make it your problem'. Comes back to like the risk thing - if you care, you gotta be able to take the risk of diving into smth uncertain! On Fatima's videos point: Not at all! I think there is a difference between like sorrow and doom. I recently read Trauma and Recovery by Judith Herman and one really nice idea is (along the lines of) once you process and understand your own trauma, you learn how much sorrow there can be in the world, then you look around you and see how much sorrow there IS in the world, but it no longer crushes you, but fills you with compassion and an energy to want to RESOLVE it. I feel like struggling with justice talk and catastrophising it to doom is a way to kind of not hold the real, messy sadness of reality but extend it to its essential end, and thus abstract it and not feel the weight of right now (not that this is something I don't do lol, must be a human thing). I think there is a lot of power to be found in exposing/sharing sadness, grief and difficulty, but also show that it doesn't break us - that it is a place we exist in, can learn from, hold and move from. And I think you do this really well!! The optimism, humour, and light in the face of crushing forces really comes across in all your videos, as well as the ability to say 'look we're here now but here's how we can move forwards' - and that tone and framing is beautiful and needed!

Hari Sood

"oops all bullshit" really encapsuates the like tragically funny exposure tone of a lot of fatima's videos

Hari Sood

Your second point leans into the idea of it not being minorities' job to teach those with power about oppression, partly because it is a highly emotive, very real topic that requires a lot of capacity to explore and discuss, which is what those in power have in abundance. Also when it becomes something that CAN be responded to with direct, explicit violence and hate, it becomes not only difficult but a very real risk to explore as a minority. This is mb where genuine allyship can be so powerful!

Hari Sood

Agree wholeheartedly with both of you about how these topics are communicated in terms of their use cases, and where they apply - I honestly cannot believe that bomb example either 😭 Another thought that came to mind - the way I understand every word I use and know is unique to me, and based in my reality. This is potentially obvious with words like 'justice', but also applies to things like 'science', 'maths', 'numbers', even 'logic', 'fact', etc. trauma survivors are likely to have a different understanding of 'cause and effect' than others. So I guess this leans into the 'everything is political' arg, cos if you teach a Physics lesson, the same words and concepts will be understood ever so slightly differently by everyone, and the patterns of those different understandings on a mass scale is just the current political reality

Hari Sood

I remember hearing that Lord of the Flies is much more just the reflections of a specific, troubled man and his thoughts on human nature, than anything more like expansive and real. And then when a Lord of the Flies situation actually happened in real life it was the complete opposite - cooperation, survival, hope, trust... found this article which is a nice summary https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-of-the-flies-what-happened-when-six-boys-were-shipwrecked-for-15-months So any lessons from Lord of the Flies become 'what could happen based on the characters/personalities/beliefs of those involved, based on the authors interpretation of likely characters' rather than 'what happens due to human nature'. Which is far less compelling!

Raphaël Royer

"Emphasizing that a white male professor in an English department who teaches only work by "great white men” is making a political decision, we had to work consistently against and through the overwhelming will on the part of folks to deny the politics of racism, sexism, heterosexism, and so forth that inform how and what we teach." I get to easely "triggered" Everytime I hear an overly sexist or racist comment, I feel attacked! Recently, I started to be more cool headed and use my awesome white guy power. Everytime I hear any kind of bigotry, I take a breath, let them cook a little bit and then throw feminist or anti-racist concept, usualy in the form of questions. The look on some dudes faces 😂 almost like I betrayed my kind. 🤣Sometimes it works but I see so much of what she describes "the overwhelming will on the part of folks to deny the politics of racism, sexism, heterosexism, and so forth" Also, it was one thing that drew me to you, tackling issues with a lot of doom in them but with a non "EVERYTHING SUCKS" vibe. You are fundamently funny with awesome vibes (I might be biased, smart women is kind of my favorite kind of persons) Anyway, I feel blessed that my yt algo showed me, I think it was your 2nd video like what 2 - 3 years ago? Keep being awesome! leftisbest ✊

phil e the theyby

This was one of the most validating and impactful chapters of any book I’ve ever read. Unfortunately, most of my reactions are EXACTLY the same things Dr. Fatima shared. I think it’s crucially important to recognize the deep insecurities people have when trying to change (because they literally lack the skills, both emotionally and behaviorally, to manage the tensions that WILL come up), and to make supporting people with those difficulties a core part of the work. I think it’s critically important to recognize that, even as teachers/professors hold tremendous power, they are also pawns in the system at the end of the day. Their decision to teach, while hopefully at least somewhat driven by the desire to do so, is almost never a free choice; they’re required to have some form of employment to maintain access to food, housing, and (in the U.S.) healthcare, and teaching is the form of employment they thought would crush their soul the least. So the fear of messing up includes that fear of being uncomfortable, but it also includes underneath it the fear of homelessness, starvation, lack of access to medical care, loss of a feeling of contributing to society in a meaningful way, and/or being forced into work that is completely soul-crushing. The fact that we lack the skills to manage these transitions to a more holistic form of education is harmful to everyone; the educators just suffer less material harm and are seen as doing “OK” because they’re able to hold onto a form of comfort. But that comfort is increasingly fleeting in a world that’s more and more reliant on cross-cultural communication, and where the problems people face are more global than local. Like Dr. Fatima, I also really appreciated bell hooks’ emphasis on how people won’t necessarily like you or feel good when you create a truly transformative educational environment. A lot of my most direct teaching happens in one-on-one environments where I can build a lot of trust and safety, so that kind of liberatory education often has had that “kumbaya” feeling that I long for. But in educational spaces where time is more limited and interactions happen in groups, it makes a TON of sense that some of that change would happen without people feeling particularly good about it. And it’s good for me to remind myself that this doesn’t mean I’m doing anything wrong necessarily; that’s just part of the change process. I don’t think I’ve ever had the experience of feeling like I can’t enjoy life anymore because of Dr. Fatima’s videos, but I honestly don’t remember ever having that experience. I think that I historically just haven’t enjoyed life in general, and have struggled to find much joy in things that have mainstream popularity (with some exceptions). So when I learn about the world and start to see oppressive systems in EVERYTHING, I don’t feel like I’m losing my ability to enjoy things; I feel like I’m understanding why I didn’t enjoy them to begin with. And oddly enough, for mainstream things that I did enjoy, I don’t feel like I’m losing something by seeing the problems with them. If I don’t like them anymore, I can usually move on from that just fine (“Ignition (Remix)” is a great song, but when I learned about R. Kelly, I didn’t feel comfortable leaning into that song anymore, and that doesn’t feel like a huge loss to me). And for things I still do enjoy that are “problematic” in some way, I feel like I can enjoy them with more integrity when I recognize them for what they are (for instance, a cool song with a catchy beat that also has some regressive or problematic lyrics) rather than treating them as wholly good or wholly bad. That’s just me, though. Maybe people who were happier or more satisfied with their lives before struggle with “not being able to enjoy anything” after watching too many Dr. Fatima videos. But for me, I just appreciate having a better understanding and feeling more equipped to face the world as it is, and that makes me feel better about my life and the world.

phil e the theyby

Your first point about the stunted emotional response is SPOT ON. Most of us really have no idea what to do with those feelings, so it can leave us really stuck. I TOTALLY feel what you’re saying in your second paragraph too. My first thought is that it’s critically important to have other people in your corner who can back you up, either during those conversations or before and after them. I think the strength to kindly and compassionately challenge people who view the world differently comes from having people on your life who you don’t have to challenge, who you know are there for you and will back you up and care for you, even if those discussions go horribly wrong.

phil e the theyby

Great posts from everyone here. AJ, I really appreciate your reflection on how politics is interwoven into physics education. It’s so valuable for all of us to take the time to reflect on how politics are acting in our spaces, even when it’s not immediately obvious.