Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“As backlash swells, as budgets are cut, as jobs become even more scarce, many of the few progressive interventions that were made to change the academy, to create an open climate for cultural diversity are in danger of being undermined or eliminated. These threats should not be ignored. Nor should our collective commitment to cultural diversity change because we have not yet devised and implemented perfect strategies for them. To create a culturally diverse academy we must commit ourselves fully. Learning from other movements for social change, from civil rights and feminist liberation efforts, we must accept the protracted nature of our struggle and be willing to remain both patient and vigilant. To commit ourselves to the work of transforming the academy so that it will be a place where cultural diversity informs every aspect of our learning, we must embrace struggle and sacrifice. We cannot be easily discouraged. We cannot despair when there is conflict. Our solidarity must be affirmed by shared belief in a spirit of intellectual openness that celebrates diversity, welcomes dissent, and rejoices in collective dedication to truth.”

The entire time I was reading this chapter, the only thing I could think of was the recent executive order from the new regime that aims to “end illegal DEI”. This, and other institutions eroding executive orders have been on my mind all week. I’ve been having conversations with progressive people in education, public health, trans healthcare, etc, about the drastic measures taken basically overnight that we’re all scrambling to adjust to, and it’s really, really hard to not feel hopeless. I myself work on a project funded by a grant that's about racial equity in education, and seeing how quickly Trump is cracking down on critical efforts is honestly terrifying. Not even because I’m afraid of losing my job; that’s certainly a possibility, but there are a lot of people facing way more dire futures than that (the current wave of deportations comes to mind). I’m more worried to see people who are committed to advancing whatever social causes fear their ability to continue their work.

To anyone else feeling this rn, I’ll offer what one of my colleagues told me: the chaos is the point. If anyone’s read Naomi Klein’s “Shock Doctrine” (HIGHLY recommend by the way, one of the most politically informative texts I’ve ever read), you know this game—hit the population with shock and awe, overwhelm them till their paralyzed by fear and their will to fight back is destroyed. I’m heartened to see the pushback so far—between judges blocking executive orders and federal workers choosing to resist and stay committed to their work instead of caving to the new regime, I have hope for our ability to push back on this nightmarish moment.  It will absolutely require steadfastness in our commitment to collective liberation, and it’s going to be challenging, no doubt about that. But reading hooks’ words on the importance of this commitment, even in the face of powerful efforts against it, I’m reminded to “remain both patient and vigilant” and to keep our commitment to solidarity at the forefront. 

If people have other reflections that are more specifically about the chapter, of course go ahead and share that, but if anyone else is having any kind of interaction with this recent wave of anti-social executive orders, I’d be curious to hear about your experiences and if anything in this chapter resonated with them.

Comments

Wami Ogunbi

Thank you for positing this. I haven't been participating in book club, so I do not have comments pertaining to the book. But with all that is going on, it is hard to stay silent. I am set to give a talk at my alma mater titled "Breaking Bias, Building Bots: The Intersection of DEI and Robotics" in a few weeks. I made the presentation before the inauguration. It is not lost on my how my talk is now effectively advocating for "illegal" behavior--it wasn't illegal when I started it! As an early career academic, this troubles me because I cannot afford to be controversial. And yet, the motivation of my talk is why I chose to stay in academia in the first place. So I am taking a risk and hoping that it does not come back to bite me in the butt. I've worked too dang hard for so dang long. And on another note, it is so frustrating to see all this rhetoric around "DEI hires". I loathe the implication that people of marginalized groups are inherently "unqualified" for the positions that they are in. The fact that I have worked my butt off to get to where I am, but people have the audacity to think that I am unqualified to do what I do really (pardon my French) PISSES me off. I am the first (and only) Black woman to get a PhD in Robotics at my alma mater--and I did it in 3.5 years! If I am not qualified for my degree, and I am the only Black woman to get one, are they implying that there is no Black woman capable of getting a PhD in Robotics at my alma mater? I would fiercely argue against this ridiculous notion! In fact, I would argue that there is no way that I am the only Black woman in the state of [X] capable of getting this degree. That I am the only one is a testament of how screwed up our academic system is that in the year of our lord 2025 only one Black woman in that state has earned a PhD in Robotics. We NEED more "DEI hires", not less! Because if we are not intentional about bringing in people from marginalized groups, we will continue to have a lack of diversity in academia and beyond. Heck, I would not have gotten into my program if it was not for DEI initiatives--not for lack of ability on my part, but because of lack of accessibility. I have proven that I can complete a rigorous PhD program (they do not just give them out to people! my advisor would have had no problem failing me if he did not think I earned this degree) if given the opportunity. How many more CAPABLE and QUALIFIED people of marginalized groups have we been neglecting because we continue to fail to include them? I saw one of my old Black professors add "DEI hire" in his LinkedIn bio as a silent protest against those who would use the term as a negative. His work is well known and respected in his field, as is evidenced by his very long and very impressive CV. To think him "unqualified" just because he is a "DEI hire" is laughable. And yes, he is a "DEI hire", because when he was interviewing, his department had hired only one Black professor before him--30 years before he joined. Almost certainly the department was considering that they were long overdue for another Black professor. Being a prestigious department in one of the most prestigious institutions in the world, obviously they will consider only the most highly qualified candidates. And now look at where this "DEI hire" is almost a decade later! The dude got a CAREER award among various other accolades. He is a major asset to the department! But even if he were only just great at his job (rather than extraordinary), he would have still been worth taking on because WE NEED A MORE DIVERSE ACADEMY. Thanks for coming to my TED talk.

AJ Biffl

It's astonishing how prescient she was - all the discussion of trying to return to an idealized past, that "part of our contemporary crisis is created by a lack of meaningful access to truth." So many of the strategies of reaction are the same as they've ever been, and it seems like we're still very much on the losing side. I'm comforted by the fact that, as she points out, working in education is one of the first handholds in resisting misinformation and cultivating liberation. I also really resonated with this idea of "the necessity of dissent, challenge, and change" in multicultural environments ("social antagonisms" in the quote from Peter McLaren), that the ideal multicultural world is explicitly NOT homogeneous, but that it's diverse and in that diversity, in there being so many unique ways of being, that people will constantly be challenged. The "conflict" of coexisting contradictions - it seems so far away, but how beautiful.

AlexTheTutor

“Education is not politically neutral”, that reminds me of “To Kill a Mockingbird”… but probably more directly, Bel Hookes has been influenced by the Brazilian educator and philosopher Paulo Freire. Freire: No hope implies no dreams, and no dreams implies no change. If you want change, you must dream, but to dream is to have hope. So, have hope. But, (something I first learned by staring at the painting “Hope” by the British artist George Watts), hope is not a passive thing to have, hope is an active force. Loosely applying Newton’s 2nd law, if hope is the only force applied within a system, I as the object would fail to go anywhere; Freire called this naïve optimism. But, in the absence of hope, even if other forces are present, even if I go somewhere, I will still be and feel lost; Freire called this cynical fatalism. Thus, for Freire, hope is necessary but not sufficient, that one must believe in our capacity to become agents of change: that is his pedagogy of hope. For me as a teacher, I practice a pedagogy of faith. If hope is that force that overcomes static friction, faith is the force that holds the world together. Faith is gravity. Thus, without faith, there can be no hope. Also, without faith, there can be no love. In Bel Hookes’ other book (All Above Love), she writes how love manifests in different ways (romance, friendship, spiritual). Probably inspired by Freire again, I wouldn’t be surprised if Hookes believes that to teach is an act of love and therefore an act of courage. And, courage requires faith: to not only believe in an uncertain future, but to take action to try to the best of your abilities to make the future you want to manifest. So, have faith. Having traveled and lived in different countries, I am convinced that within each country, there is at least one grandmother or grandfather who lives the most simple and happy of lives. I wish I could transport the reader to the homes of these people with 80 plus years of age. In an instant, any worries and doubts you may have disappear, and you feel the tranquility radiating from these people, from the gardens they have taken care for decades: the fruit trees, the colorful flowers, the herbs, the shade, the pathways. And, these people live in countries that in their lifetimes had great political instability and violence. They told me their stories full of poverty and death. Yet, they have nonetheless cultivated beauty from the Earth, independent of headlines and history. It reminds me of the YA novel “The Girl Who Drank the Moon” and the character Ethyne who despite living in a village stunted by a cultural victimhood mentality perpetrated by an evil gov power dynamic, she embraced a life of creativity and growth within her home, her sanctuary… which reminds me of Aerith from Final Fantasy 7 and her home garden within the Sector 5 slums. These people (the real or fictional) always practice a life of faith. And, as Hookes wrote about the importance of educators to continue the progress of self-actualization, and as Hookes quoted Romans 12:2 (“Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind”), for me practicing a life of faith is a great pathway to progress with self-actualization. So, that is what I will continue to focus on. Good book so far. Happy garden.

Kayla McDonogh

This chapter reminds me that progress is never a linear progression forward. There will always be steps forward and backward. Just like this chapter said many times fear, misinformation and liars are the reasons for distrusting progress and education justice. We must have hope and community to remain hopeful, and continue to learn and grow. Memorable quotes - "exposing certain truths and biases in the classroom often creates chaos and confusion" (30). "require of us willingness to see the classroom change, to allow for shifts in relationships between students." Some notes about systemic changes for education justice: Imperfect progress commit ourselves fully remain both patient and vigilant embrace struggle and sacrifice not easily discouraged cannot despite when there is conflict solidarity shared belief Celebrate diversity, welcome dissent, and rejoice in collective dedication to truth (too good to not restate again). Also Noteded: "If we fear mistakes, doing things wrongly, constantly evaluating ourselves, we will never make the academy a culturally diverse place." Everything has consequences- good and bad, and this chapter reminds me of the courage to try and fail and remain hopeful. When met with your mistakes, address them but do not let it stop you in this work. Or even, mistakes should be expected for progress, its a sign of progress rather than stagnation.

Hari Sood

A lot of this chapter reminds me of the conversations from the intro around the life of a mind being a counter-hegemonic act, how regardless of how political systems are practiced, they cannot eradicate the WILL and BELIEF in '...a spirit of intellectual openness...' I almost read it as her saying 'even though these systems have been in place throughtout my journey and are so destructive, I am STILL able to stand here with my faith unshaken and able to communicate the truth I believe in', which I guess also pairs nicely with the Bible quote ('be not conformed to this world but ye transformed by the renewal of your minds') - feels like there's something in here on like the indestructability of faith on the level of religious conviction... In answer to Fatima's bold - also for context I write this as not a US citizen so watching from slightly more afar. I am completely aghast at what is happening in the US, and terrified by how easy it seems to be. Like some dudes can just unilaterally decide shit for hundreds of millions of people and carry it out based on fear and military threats. It's so wild and disheartening to have it reaffirmed how easy destruction and violence is. I also find myself, maybe as a means of survival, thinking of what can be picked up from the remnants. THIS MIGHT NOT READ HOW I'M THINKING ABOUT IT AS IT'S NOT YET FULLY FORMED IN MY MIND 😬 BUT something like I've been doing a lot of ruminating on how immaterial and made-up power structures are - like the new administration is just a bunch of people who are making decisions, in a manner basically no different to how anyone does it - the issue is the consequences of the decisions they make. This helps me a) feel like I understand the world better and can engage better than maybe I previously thought (there is no secret to e.g. the skills and knowledge needed in order to govern, it's just people) and b) almost view all these human systems as like tragically farce - a completely artificial nothingness that we've somehow managed to design in such a way to materially destroy peoples' lives. It maybe makes me think of what IS real - me, my soul, you, people, my love and care for others and my feelings of their love and care for me... and then makes me think how almost laughably ridiculously detached the systems we have are. That then ignites something in me which is like 'you think you have power over me, and you do within these systems, and that is scary and horrible, but in essence I don't give a shit about your systems, or you, and whatever systems you try to crush me with I will always find a way to denounce them, practice outside of them and continue to practice the things that are actually real to me'. Which brings it back to the idea of the un-colonisability of the soul, the idea that we can all in some ways practice a 'person oriented' society even if the way society is set up makes it almost impossible. That real things don't and can never die, and however much oppressive regimes try to destroy them, they are still alive and living - perhaps having to adapt, possible temporarily shrink and hide for safety, perhaps having to take time to grieve for what has been lost. But they will never die, and there will always be some time when they can strengthen and thrive. Or smth Couple of other thoughts that came to mind: - "I felt humbled by the knowledge of what we give up when we are young, believing that we will find something just as good or better someday, only to discover that not to be so' 😭 damn bell - "They teach us to believe that domination is 'natural' that it is right for the strong to rule over the weak, the powerful over the powerless' - this reminds me of a comment I think either previously on this page or one of Fatima's videos about how Darwin's theory of evolution (adaptability and cooperation) has been maliciously adopted by industrial capitalism to mean competition and hierarchies - why don't we talkk about this more!! - '...conventional ways of critically approaching a novel could not coexist in classrooms that also offered new perspectives' I will always be annoyed at people who claim to love critical thinking/innovation/new paths but never think about oppression/politics - it's like surely if you love critical thinking you would be open to critical race theory, or critical gender studies? Or like someone I know who was like 'if you want to ask a question and people say 'yes let's find out' go to Silicon Valley' i'm like what if that question is how to end capitalism or create greater community?? What is that question doesn't have a profit motive? If you are a genuinely open person you would be open to de-growth, challenging paths to equity and non-profit motivations??

Hari Sood

I have somethimes thought that the way we should be living is in harmonious disharmony - which feels like the 'conflict of coexisting contradictions' you're talking about AJ!

Hari Sood

You should add this to the end of your presentation Wami!! (as long as it won't have too fucked up consequences)

AJ Biffl

I love that! That idea that we can all work together and help each other, but there isn't just one right way of being, there's a multitude, so you're constantly surrounded by this mishmash of different, conflicting ideas - not material conflict but philosophical and cultural. And considering all these perspectives you can see all the sides to a thing and come out the other end with a much stronger view overall

Wami Ogunbi

Absolutely! I will have to be more subtle, but I do intend to incorporate some of the messaging from my post--just enough to (hopefully) not get me fire.

Atallah

I loved how this chapter emphasized the relationship between transgression and change, by placing it alongside Dr. King's theories of social revolution. So much of this still applies today. The notions of a "culture of lying and denial" and "lack of meaningful access to the truth" are rampant in today's society, but I do see teaching to transgress as a bulwark against that. By way of "a revolution in how and what we teach", we can undo biases in our institutions and grant significant resistance to the rise of fascist ideologies. I was also particularly struck by how hooks outlined the misconception of cultural diversity as trying to "replace one dictatorship of knowing with another". This is unfortunately all too present with the critical race theory backlash in years past and the DEI response currently. There is a white fear of being replaced, or having the oppressed classes do to their oppressors what the oppressors did unto them. hooks makes it clear that it is not about changing content, it's about changing form. I also couldn't help but think of Palestine, where so many Zionist sympathizers will frame Palestinian liberation as a barbaric outcome, leaning on orientalist tropes of savagery. Or how two-state supporters will not realize that the entire form needs to change, not just the content. They fail to see that because of this misconception of what diversity/liberation truly means. True liberation and autonomy includes the ability to make mistakes, critique yourself, and grow. Transgression is a struggle, like so many others. Everything is connected!!

phil e the theyby

Beautiful chapter; eventually I stopped underlining basically everything and just drew stars next to big sections that stood out. I feel that we’re in a time of deep spiritual loss combined with serious material hardships. Those in positions of power, groomed from childhood to disavow their connection to human life in favor of profit and “progress,” work tirelessly to accrue the best boats as they drown the world. Those who support the oligarchs of our society live lives that are materially and spiritually lacking, and turn to the image of the glorious return of a safe, homogenized world, free from everything that feels unknown and terrifying. The rest of us scramble to build not only the material supports and infrastructure to support each other through the ecological and political crises, but a cohesive enough cultural ethos that feels like it makes sense of the world and makes life worth living. The words “revolution of values” feel deeply accurate for what’s needed, and what we long for. Education isn’t mental, and it isn’t just for those who are deemed “smart.” Education is intellectual, embodied, spiritual, communal. It requires us to break down every boundary that keeps us from connecting to others, and it requires rebuilding boundaries that protect us while also allowing ourselves and others the transformation necessary to live in a world so interconnected and so complex. Education is, at its core, learning to live in the world, WITH the world, and with other humans. And it is the fundamental task of our time.

Raphaël Royer

"They teach us to believe that domination is "natural," that it is right for the strong to rule over the weak, the powerful over the powerless. What amazes me is that so many people claim not to embrace these values and yet our collective rejection of them cannot be complete since they prevail in our daily lives." I think there's more normal people than there are bigots but bigotry will always be elevated because it does not threatened hierarchies, on the contrary. Education and interacting with people from a wide array of backgrounds (I'm thinking of her white boy, friend. that story was so sweet) are really the best ways to fight against these basic instincts. I just don't know what to do when the ruling class completly destroys the education system...