Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Sooo pedagogy of the oppressed for a future round of book club? Yes?  probably won’t do it next cause I wanna mix it up between the radical

Sooo pedagogy of the oppressed for a future round of book club? Yes?  probably won’t do it next cause I wanna mix it up between the radical pedagogy and the science philosophy (and whatever else piques my interest let's be honest), but Freire should be the next ed reading i think.

Love the self-socratic dialogue thing hooks/Watkins is doing in this chapter. I really liked the Thich Nhat Hanh stuff about teachers creating “a certain milieu” with their presence that facilitates the state of learning—I often think of teaching (or any task of getting ppl to do/learn something) as less about imparting knowledge and more about creating the container for that doing/learning to happen in, so his words definitely resonanted. But I think the part that’s stuck with my mind most was the discussion thread that started here:

“There has never been a moment when reading Freire that I have not remained aware of not only the sexism of the language but the way he (like other progressive Third World political leaders, intellectuals, critical thinkers such as Fanon, Menmi, etc.) constructs phallocentric paradigms of liberation–wherein freedom and the experience of patriarchal manhood are the same. For me this is always a source of anguish for it represents a blind spot in the vision of men who have profound insight. And yet, I never wish to see a critique of this blind spot overshadow anyone’s (and feminists’ in particular) capacity to learn from the insights. This is why it is difficult for me to speak about sexism in Freire’s work; it is difficult to find a language that offers a way to frame critique and yet maintain the recognition of all that is valued and respected in the work. It seems to me that the binary opposition that is so much embedded in Western thought and language makes it nearly impossible to project a complex response.” 

There are sooo many things that this makes me want to talk about, but most recently, i’ve been having some similar thoughts while writing the Einstein video. Not to give too much away, but it’s going to be a deep dive into some parts of his politics and life (much of which I’m presenting as aspirational), but i’m very specifically not touching his treatment of women at all (which I’d describe as whatever the opposite of aspirational is).  There are some other ways that I’ll be getting into where I don’t agree with him entirely, but I still ultimately present him as someone who we can learn a lot from, and it’s always weird to do that knowing that they also have some problematic takes and anticipating how an internet audience in 2025 will respond to that complexity. I certainly try to give nuanced perspectives of figures I admire or critique, but I know that there’s a limit to how much like, grace i can give to ‘nuance’ before the internet suspects me of being sympathetic to ideas I shouldn’t be sympathetic to. It’s honestly really concerning sometimes—I find myself much more ready to say something that I think will set off conservatives or right wing ppl than I am something that will make “my own side” think that I support the “wrong” ideas. And it’s a shame, because I really do think there’s a lot to learn from people i don’t agree with 100% (and to be real, how many people do I even agree with 100% actually?) but I’m reticent about sharing certain perspectives sometimes because I don’t always trust internet audiences’s appreciation of complexity. The way hooks talks about the nature of like, scholarly exchange where Freire could get critiqued and then evolve from those critiques—even becoming friends with one of those critics and growing from that—feels like something of a bygone era. I don’t know if that’s in my head or the current culture is just really that different nowadays.


Also that Friere passage that she ends on, the one about how he likes to live intensely and expects to die intensely—I just really felt that whole thing. It’s a good reminder in this particular moment of political chaos and fear; the struggle is part of life but also LIFE is a part of life so go life hard when you can

Comments

Kenza

OOH ! I reframed myself from writing something about Einstein's misogyny and how much it affected his work from the beginning of this project on him haha. I'm REALLY GLAD you mentioned it right now. There are a lot of things we can learn about this people but sometimes, the cognitive dissonance I get from recognising or liking their work and their misogyny/sexism or lack of knowledge about those subject, is getting me truly crazy. I really hope you can do a video on that subject.

bhobba

One of your best. Thought-provoking. Even though I studied some of it during my math degree, I recently started delving deeper into modern monetary theory, which is interesting.

Kristen

Inside every hot take there is a baby, and the bathwater the baby just pooped in...

phil e the theyby

OK, I'm gonna try to stop saying how great every single chapter is, because clearly they're all great. But I DEEPLY appreciated this one on many levels: for highlighting the need for praxis (a synthesis of theory and action in which your day-to-day actions meaningfully embody your political ideology); for speaking to that almost spiritual feeling you get in the presence of great teachers; for highlighting how essential it is that we understand meaningful critique. I think where a lot of online discourse falters is that it doesn't seem to really take the time to try to understand what someone is saying, and the potential VALUE of what they're saying, before critiquing it. Even people who are sharing the worst possible takes are doing so because they believe it will make the world better in some way, either through gratifying their own needs (which is a lot of what happens in online arguments), or because they've thought about what's going on and genuinely believe that what they're sharing has some value. If you want to critique someone's work, it's really important to actually try to listen for what they were trying to share and where they were coming from, and make sure that your critiques hold onto that while also challenging that person to expand their thinking. It's worth noting that a lot of what happens online isn't "critique"; it's people voicing that they were hurt, upset, or offended by something that someone said or did. They might PHRASE it in the form of critique ("you said this about race in the academy because you want to get rid of White people"), but they're actually talking about their own emotional reaction to what you said ("you said this about race in the academy and I felt uncomfortable because I don't know how to manage interactions with people who are different from me, so I got angry at you"). You may or may not find their emotional reaction to be something you need to honor. Some people in the online video essay space feel that their audience's discomfort with them (the creator) publicly interacting with people or institutions that have "problematic" views or actions is an emotional reaction they want to honor, so they avoid having those interactions. CJ The X has said that they explicitly don't want to honor that reaction, and they don't want to cultivate an audience who polices who they can interact with, so clearly, creators can also choose not to honor that reaction. That doesn't mean that CJ feels the reaction people have is bad or irrelevant; they just don't take that reaction as their responsibility. I very much fall on the side of believing that we should learn what we can learn from anyone. The goal isn't to ignore or disregard their biases or harmful actions; if anything, it's important for us to recognize how the biases that informed their harmful actions may have influenced their work. But all of us were raised in some variation of White supremacist capitalist patriarchy (even those of us raised in areas with few or no White people are still impacted by the broader effects of those systems), and it affects all of our thinking and actions to some extent. If we're not able to learn from people who were or are problematic in some way, we're gonna have a hard time learning anything at all. Related to that, I've heard some people take issue with bell hooks because she was a landlord. Being a landlord is a problematic, bad thing that we should not be doing (although obviously, there are more and less problematic ways to go about it, the same way there are more or less problematic ways to go about being a police officer; it's always problematic to some extent). I agree with those folks that being a landlord isn't a thing we should be doing, and that it runs contrary to the stated aims of bell hooks's work. I can still find the value in what she's saying, learn a tremendous amount from it, apply it to my own life, and choose not to be a landlord myself.

Mingo

I'm thinking about why there isn't much people added in the comments, concerning the amount of comments and I think it might have something to do with the style of this chapter as a Socratic dialogue of sorts, that might be an issue. But that's me writing this after I just finished this chapter by Wednesday, so maybe people just fell behind with the whole book club thing? Anyway, I felt inspired by the whole not being 100% on board with everything the man spoke about and how my man jordan Peterson made the same comment and when he said it, I had the urge to object...

AlexTheTutor

“authentic help means that all who are involved help each other mutually… …only through such praxis… can the act of helping can become free from the distortion in which the helper dominates the helped” this is SUCH a fundamentally important concept, I’m happy Hooks writes this in her book, it’s akin to the relationship between victimhood and creativity: within distortion, a helper (or rescuer) always depends on someone to be rescued, it creates a codependent toxic victimhood relationship (the rescuer says “you can’t do this without me, you need me” and the rescued says “I can’t do anything, I always fail, you need to help me”), the opposite of this is instead being a coach and allowing others to create, only by our creative efforts can we rise above the endless cycle of victimhood and create a better positive future, and going back to this book: it is ALL TOO EASY to fall into this trap, especially when someone who has been oppressed tries to “help” others far away from the oppression, often the “helper” has no sense of objectivity and only feels their oppression as they try to “help” others understand how it feels to be a victim of oppression or prejudice, as if the helper needs to “rescue” everyone from their outdated perspectives of the world, that is why those people are turned off, as Hooks wrote about how students question why are they learning about oppression “I thought this was English class”, yes exactly, because there was a miscommunication of expectations, many students know nothing about grammar, syntax, or how to write, the best way to make sure they themselves don’t fall under any oppression is to first teach them what a preposition is, then the student gains trust with the teacher, only then can student and teach help one another mutually (authentic help): teacher becomes coach, and student creates, but no student can create without knowing the basics “when you are privileged… you can waste resources… look at what most people do with water” I remember during a skit a famous talk show host wasting water and joking about it, it was so tasteless and thoughtless, I remember my grandfather born in 1900 how he scolded me for ordering a $2 soda at a restaurant when I was a child, “no! you don’t waste money! Water is free!”, I remember being happy that he yelled at me, it meant he cared, I remember one of my students who lived in poverty and as a child had parasites grow from her stomach due to dirty water, she only received her first book at the age of 13 (Harry Potter) and it meant everything to her, it allowed her to dream far beyond her condition, she created so many opportunities that today she is a medical doctor who on occasion teaches children about water sanitation, she is one of my most treasured students

Tom Cassidy

I remember first reading this essay years ago; I was attracted to the GW/bh dialogue, which I thought was clever (it is), but it really helped to shape my thinking about Friere. My problem with Friere's concept of the Banking Model of Education is not only that this is what the school system enforces, but it's what students expect. Universities are places where students come to get intellectual capital; we use the metaphor of "investing" in education, and we even make students take out huge loans they may will spend years repaying. The Banking model of education goes way beyond the idea of the student as blank slate; they come to college to earn money, status, and privilege. bell hooks knows all this, which is why she tells us about students who ask "Isn't this class supposed to be about English"? Critical pedagogy doesn't always mean aligning yourself easily with what the student thinks he/she wants. I think the form of the socratic dialogue is kind of perfect, because the role of the teacher is to be the engaged questioner. --I love the image she paints of Friere acknowledging the feminist critique of his rhetoric and implicitly empowering them to carry it foward.

Hari Sood

I have some mixed thoughts about this like appreciating the thoughts somebody has and lessons we can learn from them even if they have problematic thoughts elsewhere. On the one hand I firmly believe everyone is worth listening to, is inherently good, and is trying their best, and it's a dangerous path to dismiss and not engage absolutely with someone - it suggests you believe there is something inherently wrong with them that is not even worth your time trying to understand. And so the complex view of hearing what everyone has to say and then evaluating each bit on their merit to you makes sense. Mb this is my philosophical view. On the other hand, pragmatically there may be other things to consider. One is just that as a person in an oppressive society, is it my job to make room for the nuanced understanding of people with oppressive views, or is it THEIR job to be self-critical of their views and more careful of what they share in public, and be more accountable for what they do share and the possible consequences of it. Secondly, even if we recognise that people are complex, each time we don't explicitly discuss this whilst referencing someone, we tacitly promote the norm. So e.g. for Freire and Einstein, in a world that is actively sexist, unless we mention their sexism EVERY TIME we mention them, we promote the tacit, socialised and normalised world view of both these people, i.e. that they were geniuses in some holistic sense. And so we tacitly normalise and socialise their sexism as part of their genius. In this way, whilst I don't believe it enough to actively advocate for it, I am interested in the argument of 'if you currently hold oppressive views and communicate them, or have done in the past and have not apologised and held yourself accountable for them, I refuse to promote anything you say'. Practically speaking, I can see how this leads to more non-oppressive knowledge being shared, and requiring more accountability for saying problematic things. Though that is a controversial and unfinished thought so would love to hear what others think! Couple of other thoughts: - I live the idea of authentic help and removing the power dynamic. Makes me think of family abolitionism and removing accepted hierarchies in this space - The quest of moving from object to subject makes me think a lot about the transformative journey of addressing trauma, and resolving dissociation - The idea of growing more open as we age feels really important, as the socialised message is that people in general become more conservative as they age. Inspiring to be reminded that isn't just a track! - The final thoughts on her meeting with Paulo are a nice reminder that love is not a resource that can be measured but a feeling - you don't qualify for love after e.g. X amount of time, you can experience love with anyone at any moment, for any length of time!

Nick P

Got to love when you're finally reading an author you've wanted to read and they say "oh yeah so most of this argument is heavily influenced by this other important person" 😆. Getting a chance to meet him, publicly critique, then discuss with Friere sounded like an amazing experience for Hooks! Getting to address your thoughts on expanding previous works directly with the writer who is open to that must have been fulfilling.