"Teaching to Transgress" - Chapter 4: Paulo Freire (Patreon)
Content
Sooo pedagogy of the oppressed for a future round of book club? Yes? probably won’t do it next cause I wanna mix it up between the radical
Sooo pedagogy of the oppressed for a future round of book club? Yes? probably won’t do it next cause I wanna mix it up between the radical pedagogy and the science philosophy (and whatever else piques my interest let's be honest), but Freire should be the next ed reading i think.
Love the self-socratic dialogue thing hooks/Watkins is doing in this chapter. I really liked the Thich Nhat Hanh stuff about teachers creating “a certain milieu” with their presence that facilitates the state of learning—I often think of teaching (or any task of getting ppl to do/learn something) as less about imparting knowledge and more about creating the container for that doing/learning to happen in, so his words definitely resonanted. But I think the part that’s stuck with my mind most was the discussion thread that started here:
“There has never been a moment when reading Freire that I have not remained aware of not only the sexism of the language but the way he (like other progressive Third World political leaders, intellectuals, critical thinkers such as Fanon, Menmi, etc.) constructs phallocentric paradigms of liberation–wherein freedom and the experience of patriarchal manhood are the same. For me this is always a source of anguish for it represents a blind spot in the vision of men who have profound insight. And yet, I never wish to see a critique of this blind spot overshadow anyone’s (and feminists’ in particular) capacity to learn from the insights. This is why it is difficult for me to speak about sexism in Freire’s work; it is difficult to find a language that offers a way to frame critique and yet maintain the recognition of all that is valued and respected in the work. It seems to me that the binary opposition that is so much embedded in Western thought and language makes it nearly impossible to project a complex response.”
There are sooo many things that this makes me want to talk about, but most recently, i’ve been having some similar thoughts while writing the Einstein video. Not to give too much away, but it’s going to be a deep dive into some parts of his politics and life (much of which I’m presenting as aspirational), but i’m very specifically not touching his treatment of women at all (which I’d describe as whatever the opposite of aspirational is). There are some other ways that I’ll be getting into where I don’t agree with him entirely, but I still ultimately present him as someone who we can learn a lot from, and it’s always weird to do that knowing that they also have some problematic takes and anticipating how an internet audience in 2025 will respond to that complexity. I certainly try to give nuanced perspectives of figures I admire or critique, but I know that there’s a limit to how much like, grace i can give to ‘nuance’ before the internet suspects me of being sympathetic to ideas I shouldn’t be sympathetic to. It’s honestly really concerning sometimes—I find myself much more ready to say something that I think will set off conservatives or right wing ppl than I am something that will make “my own side” think that I support the “wrong” ideas. And it’s a shame, because I really do think there’s a lot to learn from people i don’t agree with 100% (and to be real, how many people do I even agree with 100% actually?) but I’m reticent about sharing certain perspectives sometimes because I don’t always trust internet audiences’s appreciation of complexity. The way hooks talks about the nature of like, scholarly exchange where Freire could get critiqued and then evolve from those critiques—even becoming friends with one of those critics and growing from that—feels like something of a bygone era. I don’t know if that’s in my head or the current culture is just really that different nowadays.
Also that Friere passage that she ends on, the one about how he likes to live intensely and expects to die intensely—I just really felt that whole thing. It’s a good reminder in this particular moment of political chaos and fear; the struggle is part of life but also LIFE is a part of life so go life hard when you can