"Teaching to Transgress" - Chapter 5: Theory as Liberatory Practice (Patreon)
Content
Hooks' personal anecdotes in this essay resonate with me in a way that affected me viscerally—my note by the chapter’s first paragraph: “immediate shivers” (literally). and the paragraph on pg 60 that begins “Imagine then if you will, my childhood pain” had me on the brink of tears on the train to work this morning. I literally had to take a break and just like… feel and think about lingering pains, some that I’m very conscious of and some these opening passages brought to light.
I can’t remember where I heard it (maybe a Dr. K lecture? I think?), but someone framed recovery from trauma as a process of recovery in the mind, then the body, then the voice—the idea is we first understand our pain by intellectualizing it and explaining what happened, then we attend to it’s lingering presence in the body, then we learn to speak truth to the power that harmed us or assert boundaries to what might again. When I think about my own experiences with higher education, I can easily trace this path: i had a shit experience in grad school, i learned how to make sense of why it was so bad, did some somatic therapy to exorcise it from my body, and then made a youtube channel where i’ve been able to vent my pain from that time (and now i feel marginally better!). And hooks captured exactly what that first step of intellectualizing pain felt like:
“I came to theory because I was hurting—the pain within me was so intense that I couldn’t not go on lying. I came to theory desperate, wanting to comprehend—to grasp what was happening around and within me.”
It’s hard to explain how intensely motivating my pain was for me to study theory; i guess i literally pivoted my career in that direction, so that much? but i sometimes worry about whether i should invest so much intellectual/professional energy in something that ultimately feels like a negative drive, you know? maybe I’m internalizing that critique of leftism that says it’s a politic that comes from resentment or something, but I do constantly question whether there aren’t better/more constructive/positive uses of my time than bitching about racism/sexism/whatever-ism. But reading this chapter, I feel so…idk, affirmed? I can’t find the right words to explain what it did for me except maybe that i think hooks’s convinced me theory is a spiritual experience. I don’t know what else to call her stories of all the people who were touched by her work.
And speaking of all the people who were touched by her work, i really love everything she has to say about the accessibility of theory:
“Any theory that cannot be shared in everyday conversation cannot be used to educate the public.”
Yeah pretty much. This feels like the difference between the generative kind of theory hooks envisions and the gatekeep-y, hierarchy maintaining, theory of ivory tower bound academics. I’ve been thinking a lot in the last few years about non-traditional means of communicating research (the yt channel is a big one obvs, but even within academia I’ve been seeing increasing interest in sharing results via more accessible/less formal means than journal articles). I’d be curious to hear from folks if you’ve seen or made materials on whatever kinds of theory that is actually intended for normal people to be able to consume—what did it look like? How did it work? Does it give you any ideas?