Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hooks' personal anecdotes in this essay resonate with me in a way that affected me viscerally—my note by the chapter’s first paragraph: “immediate shivers” (literally). and the paragraph on pg 60 that begins “Imagine then if you will, my childhood pain” had me on the brink of tears on the train to work this morning. I literally had to take a break and just like… feel and think about lingering pains, some that I’m very conscious of and some these opening passages brought to light. 

I can’t remember where I heard it (maybe a Dr. K lecture? I think?), but someone framed recovery from trauma as a process of recovery in the mind, then the body, then the voice—the idea is we first understand our pain by intellectualizing it and explaining what happened, then we attend to it’s lingering presence in the body, then we learn to speak truth to the power that harmed us or assert boundaries to what might again. When I think about my own experiences with higher education, I can easily trace this path: i had a shit experience in grad school, i learned how to make sense of why it was so bad, did some somatic therapy to exorcise it from my body, and then made a youtube channel where i’ve been able to vent my pain from that time (and now i feel marginally better!). And hooks captured exactly what that first step of intellectualizing pain felt like: 

“I came to theory because I was hurting—the pain within me was so intense that I couldn’t not go on lying. I came to theory desperate, wanting to comprehend—to grasp what was happening around and within me.” 

It’s hard to explain how intensely motivating my pain was for me to study theory; i guess i literally pivoted my career in that direction, so that much? but i sometimes worry about whether i should invest so much intellectual/professional energy in something that ultimately feels like a negative drive, you know? maybe I’m internalizing that critique of leftism that says it’s a politic that comes from resentment or something, but I do constantly question whether there aren’t better/more constructive/positive uses of my time than bitching about racism/sexism/whatever-ism. But reading this chapter, I feel so…idk, affirmed?  I can’t find the right words to explain what it did for me except maybe that i think hooks’s convinced me theory is a spiritual experience. I don’t know what else to call her stories of all the people who were touched by her work.

And speaking of all the people who were touched by her work, i really love everything she has to say about the accessibility of theory: 

“Any theory that cannot be shared in everyday conversation cannot be used to educate the public.” 

Yeah pretty much. This feels like the difference between the generative kind of theory hooks envisions and the gatekeep-y, hierarchy maintaining, theory of ivory tower bound academics. I’ve been thinking a lot in the last few years about non-traditional means of communicating research (the yt channel is a big one obvs, but even within academia I’ve been seeing increasing interest in sharing results via more accessible/less formal means than journal articles). I’d be curious to hear from folks if you’ve seen or made materials on whatever kinds of theory that is actually intended for normal people to be able to consume—what did it look like? How did it work? Does it give you any ideas?

Comments

AJ Biffl

I don't have any good examples that I myself have done, but one of my favorite instances of non-academics-only science, of investigating and communicating results publicly and having an accessible discourse around it, was the youtube saga between Steve Mould and Mehdi ElectroBOOM about the chain fountain: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcqX4UMXNKEdNBKABT3ZF6Fvu5Jkq3OxB . Basically over the course of a few months, they traded videos disagreeing about the cause of the phenomenon, and it turned into this really in-depth, organic investigation of what was going on where they would do variations on different experiments and replicate each others' setups and try to explain what they were seeing in different ways. It's legit an amazing example of scientific investigation outside of academia. Everything they did was open and carefully documented, they explained every step of their reasoning and every part of their setups, they replicated things the other person did, etc.

Tom Cassidy

Karl Marx says somewhere "The philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways; the point, however, is to change it," and that's what I think bell hooks is up against as well. The "theory" of the 1980's was post-structuralism which, however potent its intent, was received in the US as a difficult way to reinterpret canonical literature. In terms of bringing theory home to bear on the culture we live in, I don't think there is anyone who does this as well as hooks. Her cultural criticism is brilliant; she can explain how she finds the underloved "The Bodyguard" to be transgressive, while the over praised "What's Love Got to Do With It?" is depressingly not. The only writer I can think of as informed and direct as she was might be Audre Lorde. Her essay "The Uses of the Erotic" is one of the essays that makes the connections of how women's alienation from their bodies' pleasure and pain has absolutely served the patriarchy, and the necessity of reclaiming joy! In terms of living writers that have both the breadth and the urgency of these women? Let me think about that. I'll be interested to hear what others come up with!

illthinkofanamelaterthatsnotmyrealname

Although I would say my pain/suffering is what "radicalized" me (and what was the start of a my Buddhist practice, among others). That trajectory was what led me to gravitate towards writers that focus on ways of perceiving a current historical and human context and who use theory (more or less) as a means to that end. My favorite author, Jenny Odell, describes her writing as something like "elaborating on new ways of seeing", and different writers like hooks have been tangential from that sentiment for me. From my own admittedly very privileged perspective, reading something that put me in relation to others such the way that *The Will to Change* did was monumental. It has been plain language writing like that has laid out new ways of understanding through relation and interdependence. But ironically and unironically, pain is a dangerous thing. The same pain hooks describes in herself is a similar pain that she saw in her parents in their treatment of her, in their reaction to her idealism, and to her perceived slights to their authority. I don't see leftism as something entirely defined by resentment or pain but as being more defined by its open acknowledgment and its connections to systems. It's so obvious that even fascists and right-wingers like Elon are obviously and openly suffering and in-denial of this, but this acting out of a need for approval and a sense of aversion is so strong that they would burn the village if it is in their image. From my perspective it's greed of a different stripe: not one that's stereotypically hedonistic, but one of power and world-building however vengeful. It's in this sense that pain can be double edged: pushing us towards activity or passivity, towards constructive or destructive ends, to connection or alienation. Pema Chödrön writes about pain as something that can be grounding and deepening, that suffering is a force that carves us out, and in our connection with it we might find a depth that connects us further towards to depths of others'. My childhood pain is pretty uninteresting, but that sense of isolation had also influenced my own work and my understanding of the context that I live in by deepening a fundamental desire for connection, whether that be of place or of people. I think negative experiences in others always inform how others choose to move forward in work or otherwise, sometimes for the better and sometimes not, sometimes a combination of things. This chapter is also a kick in the ass for me to try communicate the findings from my thesis work in different ways. Maybe I'll try to write some methods how-to's in a Medium article (reading one was super helpful at my last internship), or maybe an article with my advisor in The Conversation (but that's still pretty academic-ish and siloed). Environmental writing/content seems pretty lackluster in terms of reach tbh, would love to see it reach the level of urbanism or breadtube but who tf am I, yk?

Kristen

I think forms of physical practice have this same dichotomy. You have the over-coached, over-studied, professionals-everywhere physical practices like competitive sports or dance, and then you have everyday yoga practice where pose names are a suggestion or prompt to a general shape with variation and progression you only need to worry about if you want it. Heck even in my silly sword practice there's books and curriculum and passing off levels and knowing the context and material culture and all those expectations of brainy-talk-talk and then there's teachers who are deeply, deeply knowledgeable about the books and system and historical material culture and ways of thinking but class is cleverly disguised as "hey let's do this. How did that feel? Okay, try this. did you notice that felt different? Good! Does anything feel bad? Okay, let's try these things and see which one feels good in what situation."

AlexTheTutor

Mike from PBS Ideas Channel did such an amazing job breaking down a wide range of theories through the lens of media and pop culture. His videos slowly developed ideas and posed questions allowing you to think about theories while learning about them, and since the ideas were framed within media/pop culture, it became easier to understand. Also, there was a book club and a sub-reddit and other ways for others to create an ongoing conversation. He was the GOAT. Yes, he had a team to help him out, so he didn’t do it alone. There are so many other channels to recommend, but for now… “I came to theory because I was hurting” Hook’s family did not want to connect with her. Theory became part of her family, her home “there is no place like home” “Even though such an arrangement meant that economically they would always be living with less”: My default is to play devil’s advocate to get deep into things. So… economics isn’t everything. I work with many poor families. Many adults raise the children, and the kids grow up having a great character. Compared to the many “affluenza” families in which both parents are busy professionals, their kids fail school and have behavioral issues. How will those abandoned kids function in 15 years? But, suppose economics IS everything. Then, one year’s salary is enough to have housing and have one parent stay at home to raise 7 kids. But, today in Australia, a house is 12 years of salary, after getting the house at 40 years old, there may not be a chance to even think about having one child. Hypothesis: Monetary inflation exacerbates all other forms of oppression. “She was more interested in action, in DOING something… this woman’s response disturbed me”: One model I developed when teaching is “First see, then think, and lastly do”. Especially in physics, many students will rush to DO something and answer the question without thinking about concepts or seeing what the question is. It’s natural for students to want to DO something before thinking. If needed, before starting any session, consider addressing this dynamic, and ask for everyone’s patience, no need to be disturbed. Actually, my first girlfriend is black. When we were dating, I was super theoretical, she was 100% NOT. She eventually started her own business and is a millionaire in a sector that 0.1% of business owners are black women. She would say herself that her brain simply doesn’t work to understand theory. She has experienced racism, but she was also raised by a loving family who empowered her. It’s great Hooks has theory to process her trauma, but there is a great danger, a danger that Hooks seems to be aware of: (as she mentioned in the previous chapter), will she become the helper who dominates the helped with theory, the victim who wants to rescue everyone when no one was looking to be rescued, instead of empowering them? Modern Western philosophy often has this “moral desire to change the world” (as Tom mentioned Marx, but there’s also Ayn Rand). It’s dangerous to use philosophy to change the world into one’s “ideal” image. Reading this chapter was sad. Sad vibes: The wound created by not being accepted by one’s own tribe, by one’s family… that can hurt more than 1000 slurs. I feel like the author needs a hug.

phil e the theyby

The key points of this chapter all felt super critical. Holding on to the necessity of both theory and practice; the potential for theory to heal; the need to communicate theory in a way that people outside of academia can understand and resonate with, particularly by connecting it to their everyday lived experience. In my work providing therapy, I feel like a lot of what I do is actually taking theory and explaining it in a way that makes sense to people in the context of their exact, unique life experience, in order for them to name it, make sense of it, and heal. I love Dr. Fatima's breakdown (source lost) of that progression of recovery from the mind to the body to the voice. Given that I often work with folks on a shorter-term basis in a university counseling setting, I'm typically mostly involved with the mind and a bit of that embodied work, but with the hope that some of that work and especially students' development of their voice will either happen in later therapy or within their communities. I don't have specific sources to point to (other than, you know, Dr. Fatima), but I feel like so much of the video essay genre is specifically about taking theory and making it inclusive and accessible. I also think the "Powerpoint party" can be a really cool way of doing this, having each individual person engage with some element of theory and then present it to the group in a way that's human, relatable, and tangible. At the end of the day, I think the foundation of any social change is understanding the world around us and acting based on that understanding and our collective wisdom to identify and follow through with the steps we need to take. I think the main way we understand the world is through stories. Those stories can be abstract, multi-part grand narratives (as theories often are), or they can be as simple as someone telling you what they've been through in their lives. I think the folks who focus strictly on "action" tend to just be more informed by those individual narratives than "theory" itself, but that's no less valid as a way of knowing. I absolutely believe that connecting with theory is a spiritual experience. It is the act of feeling known and understood not just as an individual, but that your experiences make sense in the broader context of the entire world. One example of a powerful religious experience is connecting with a deep feeling that "God has a plan and I am a part of it." I see that as VERY parallel to our experience of "There's a narrative that makes sense of our world, and it maps on exactly to my lived experience AND gives voice to that experience." For those who aren't religious, I think connecting with a theory is ultimately a form of connecting on a deep level with something bigger than yourself (the theory is about much bigger systems than you, yet it perfectly encapsulates a core experience you have). And to me, that's the heart of what spirituality is.

Mingo

That's an interesting point. Made me think of the same dichotomy I experienced in music. Sometimes the whole class isn't divide and heady theory yet also this idea of "genius" or "talent" can create so many exclusions.

Raphaël Royer

Thank you for sharing this with us, it's really profound the way people can connect with their shared experiences of pain and being lost. We realize that we all have something in common and that we are all connected by our shared humanity. Anyway as a dumb guy who very much admires academics, I appreciate people who can explain complicated subjects in a way that you don't feel you are, I don't know how to say this other than, inferior... I need to work on that, the feeling that I don't matter and have nothing to offer haha 😅 So, all of that to say, thank you, you have been and continu to be truly influencial in my life!

Hari Sood

I imagine noone will see this now as I am a week late 😭 but thoughts nevertheless! The points she makes in this essay are really cool and really valuable - my parents were business people so growing up I heard (and kinda internalised) so much of the 'talking does nothing you have to DO something' stuff, and have been on a bit of a journey recently of realising that actually words and ideas and communication are STILL doing stuff, it is still like changing and affecting the world and connecting people and showing what is possible, so this was really affirming! I especially enjoyed the idea of discussion leading someone to being able to then describe and understand their experience better - hermeneutical justice FTW! It reminds me of that part in Against Method where PF explains how art is not like abstract and imaginary, it is a very real way of understanding the world - and so is theory. Like the theories I have are held based on my understanding of the world and who I am, and my actions just reflect that. I also enjoyed the callout on denying liberatory power when splitting things into valuable/not valuable - feels like there is a more general lesson of anything rule-bound is always going to be anti-liberatory, and it's important to remember that. I maybe am a bit unsure of theory 'that speaks to the widest audience of people' - this feels like the same 'scale' language of capitalism, which risks, through universalising, homogenising messaging and watering it down to the stage of being meaningless. Obvs I hate like academic exclusivity, but I think the messaging needs to empower like plurality, and the need for people/roles with different knowledge and realities to adapt and translate theories for themselves and their communities. I think I in general agree with making theories as accessible and inclusive as possible, but maybe that wording is a bit different than 'widest audience' that j gives me some minor heebies To answer Fatima's questions - two thoughts come to mind. One is over lockdown I was building a social justice learning platform, with volunteer instructors trying to translate lessons from social justice (race/gender/immgration/climate change and more) into pedagogically sound online learning (link if interested: https://app.pyxium.co/courses). I trialled it at a few schools and got really good feedback (both from students who were excited to learn about these topics and teachers who liked how engaged the students were), but ultimately I didn't want to/know how to commercialise it ethically so didn't take it further. But learned a lot about making complex issues accessible! The second is my last job was as a Research Application Manager, my role being to translate research outputs for end users who may not be technical/academic, but may be interested in the outputs. I have many thoughts on this, but for now the overall is: I learned a lot, great idea, terribly executed at the org (caught up massively in academic politics). Link here: https://www.turing.ac.uk/research/research-programmes/tools-practices-and-systems/research-application-management

Hari Sood

Love this phil - therapy provision is totally an example of translating theory and making it practicable/relevant to people!!

Hari Sood

This is really cool Kristen! It almost makes me think of like which theories are strongest, and I guess it's those that kinda naturally emerge without having to be forced - so like in your sword practice the open questions the teachers are asking will, if the theory is legit, lead you naturally towards the explanatory power of the theory without much effort. Theory that takes aaaages to just try to understand and doesn't really show itself/emerge is mb weaker theory, and the kind that just needs to be taught as theory in and of itself, and not through practice! Cool thoughts!

Hari Sood

The way you write is beautiful friend! And adding Pema Chödrön to my reading list!!