Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“Identity politics emerges out of the struggles of oppressed or exploited groups to have a standpoint on which to critique dominant structures, a position that gives purpose and meaning to struggle…Though opposed to any essentialist practice that constructs identity in a monolithic, exclusionary way, I do not want to relinquish the power of experience as a standpoint on which to base analysis or formulate theory.”

I don’t think I have much to say about this chapter—I wholeheartedly agree with her dialectical approach to identity politics: yes, we don’t want to reduce people of any particular identity to a monolith, and also, experience based on identity is informative. To me this seems like a straightforward pair of truths to hold together, but it does feel like (in online discourse of the last years, at least) a lot of people will cling to either one or the other, with the former being more common among conservatives (think, characterizing the naming of any generalized trend in the experiences of a marginalized group as stereotyping) and the latter, more common with progressives.  It always seems easier (or maybe safer?) to critique the conservative take, but ive generally been more hesitant to publicly critique “identity politics” as a progressive, despite definitely having those critiques. She captures the reason for my concern pretty well:

“I am concerned that critiques of identity politics not serve as the new, chic way to silence students from marginalized groups.”

I guess this is one instance of a broader thing I struggle with talking about political topics online—critiques of “my side” are important for advancing whatever movement, but can also provide justification for the opposing side to discredit ideas/opinions I agree with. I think most recently I’ve been thinking about this in the context of research on social inequality in education—there’s something i really hate about having made a video with the major point “some DEI work is performative bullshit that wastes time and money” only to see how today, that (almost) exact take being the justification behind the recent flood of executive orders. I feel like I’m getting off topic, but I guess what I want to say is that I really value hooks’ ability to make these nuanced critiques, and I wonder how doing that today is made difficult by like, contemporary online sensibilities (this feels similar to what I wrote about two chapters ago, hopefully I’m not being too repetitive).

I think the more interesting part of this chapter for me was the activity hooks described to orient her students to the value of experience in a classroom:

“When I teach Toni Morrison’s The Bluest Eye in introductory courses on black woman writers, I assign the students to write an autobiographical paragraph aloud to the class. Each person reads that paragraph aloud to the class. Our collective listening to one another affirms the value and uniqueness of each voice. This exercise highlights experience without privileging the voices of students from any particular group… students do not usually feel the need to compete because the concept of a privileged voice of authority is deconstructed by our collective critical practice.”

I love this for a few reasons: first, i like how this exercise challenges the assumption that identity and the experiences that it informs is something only marginalized people have. The number of times I’ve been a part of a conversation about race/sexism where the white people/men in the room act like this isn’t really about/for them, as if being white/male is the lack of “identity” rather than an identity in and of itself is…too many. Or similarly, when a white person/man speaks on behalf of PoC/women in an effort to be helpful rather than including themselves as a part of the conversation. Not about it.

And second,  it’s just nice to see examples of what her pedagogy looks like in practice. I’m always curious to learn more about how things like norm setting in classrooms can be used to level power dynamics, and this is such a great example of that. Have any of you used or encountered teacher moves that challenge identity-based power dynamics in a classroom?

Comments

AJ Biffl

I also really appreciated hooks' nuance in approaching the place of experience in the classroom. Nuance seems to be a major theme in the last few chapters: there's no one "correct" way of doing things, no single correct way of being, way of thinking. There's always multiple approaches or sides. In the Paulo Freire chapter, he uses sexist language but also had profound insight; in "Theory as Liberatory Practice," revering the pure-academic forms of theory excludes and divides, but rejecting theory entirely is also bad. And as you point out, it's so common for reactionary movements to pick out either or both sides of that nuance, and weaponize those criticisms to reject the movement entirely. I've loved seeing a writer attack the nuance head on and try to round out both sides. I'll also admit that I often fall into that practice of excluding myself from some discussions because, coming from a position of privilege, I feel my perspective is less interesting and I'd rather hear people with "that unique mixture of experiential and analytical ways of knowing... the passion of experience" that hooks mentions. Part of that is also knowing that coming from a privileged background, there aren't many times when my voice ISN'T heard and I want to give space for others to speak. But this chapter, and the "Bluest Eye" exercise, are good reminders that authority of experience does not hold absolute dominion over all other ways of knowing. Then nuance: there's a way to walk between both sides, not totally removing myself from those discussions because they "don't apply" (they do), and also trying to give space for other voices to have their turn. I'm not exactly sure where the balance is, but I'll leave it at two paragraphs here and sit back down.

AlexTheTutor

Have any of you used or encountered teacher moves that challenge identity-based power dynamics in a classroom? 1) Be physically present in the moment (no online class, no cell phone, make eye contact) 2) Set the proper tone at the very beginning (listen before you think and think before you speak, make eye contact, be the example and lead with patience, honesty, integrity, and empathy, everyone will practice gratitude (gratitude journal), emphasize group harmony, always encourage and promote positive growth mindsets, but quickly address any negativity or victim mentalities) 3) Share a snack / share a meal … to build trust, to build relationships, during snack or meal, have people share what they are grateful for, share your own stories that emphasize that the time we have to live our lives truly is short, have people share what motivates them what gets them up in the morning, and etc 4) For each gathering, let’s take turns sharing our favorite songs and briefly say why it’s your favorite, one person shares one song for each gathering, compile these songs into a playlist 5) Have everyone meet to volunteer at a soup kitchen on an early Saturday morning (something neutral yet meaningful), during next snack / meal, share experiences, the goal is to promote the idea of transcending beyond ourselves, instead of fearing not being good enough, free ourselves to realize that we are good enough to grow 6) Instead of being angry and blaming others, forgive, if we get a 50 on an exam, do not be angry for too long, forgive ourselves, and instead, identify what went wrong, identify what went right, what you can do better, and make a plan to improve, then simply execute the plan and have faith 7) Have everyone be in search for the awe-inspiring, for medicine the story of Emily Whitehead (a child who had zero chance of surviving her cancer, but somehow is today at university studying English 10 plus years later), and etc for whatever field of study you want to focus on “uh ok, first thing, it’s not practical to do those things in a classroom, and also there’s nothing about challenging any identity-based power dynamics” these suggestions all aim to elevate our spirits, to let go of the ego and rise above it, identity-based power dynamics is like a fire, and removing an unhealthy overinflated ego is like removing oxygen, the fire will simply extinguish itself, this is not about changing people, people may still be corrosive outside the class, it’s about creating an environment that is an oasis to anyone's corrosive natures As for the classroom, I challenge you to rethink what a classroom is, even the first point about no cell phones in theclassroom, too many K-12 schools passively accept cell phones in schools, “you fight the battles you can win” as one administrator told me, well if you can’t get cell phones with brainwashing algorithms that promote tribalism away from kids with developing prefrontal brains, you’ve already lost the war before it began. But that’s ok, because eventually students will always want to be found, you just have to listen when they're looking to be found and speak with authenticity. I’ve had classes outside in the rubble of a favela, when people don’t always have food or water, finding food, sharing a meal, and washing it down with water, all of those things are awe-inspiring enough, and people are just grateful to be together

Raphaël Royer

"for there is a particular knowledge that comes from suffering. It is a way of knowing that is often expressed through the body, what it knows, what has been deeply inscribed on it through experience." This part particularly spoke to me. Being severely disabled (essentially quadriplegic) definitely helped shape my world view, pain is a such a universal human experience yet, there is so many different kinds of pain. Having lived (and still living) through a wide array of physical and emotional pains, I feel equipped to better empathize with people. That said, being a white guy, I favor the approche of "sitting my white ass down and listening." Anyway, I'm really good at sittting down so... 🤣

Hari Sood

I'm not sure I have many cool examples of teacher moves that challenge identity-based power dynamics... though one that comes to mind is the few timesit's been like class projects to prepare a talk/presentation on anything you like - sometimes in this freedom you get to hear alternative/different viewpoints, approaches and thoughts that, unlike most things, can sit firmly outside the taught curriculum. Also (a bit dead but) things that allow classes to contribute anonymously to discussions that then get shared with everyone (e.g. word clouds or answer submissions on smth like Menti that get shared on the screen) can be great ways to share ideas equally, outside of who they are coming from, and start discussing them collectively. Some other thoughts (or one main thought) from the chapter: - I'm starting to understand the view that EVERYONE is traumatised and somewhat disembodied by things like capitalism and colonialism, and all this wild talk from Fuss about the limitations of experience feels reflective of that. Someone convinced that "experience rarely advances discussion and frequently provokes confusion" and so should be avoided, and that 'truth clearly does not equate with experience' (like honestly WTF is this I disagree so hard with this) for me is just reflective of someone who hasn't, doesn't, doesn't know how to, and fears, engaging with experience - as this requires understanding ourselves, and each other, in a very embodied way - and doing this in a traumatised body is terrifying. So all this appeal to theory and science and like objectivity etc. without consideration for the power of experience is j mass dissociation and disembodiment, and to move past it everyone first needs a hug and a cry. I think this is also nicely captured when hooks talks about how the phrase 'passion of experience' encompasses particularly 'suffering' - I wonder if there is something in like as suffering becomes more acute and unavoidable, we must confront and address it, not from a place of theory but from our direct experience. And for privileged people, their trauma from systems is real but not like invasive enough to require attention, and so they can just exist in a mildly dissociated state forever - which allows conceptual systems and theories to fluorish over subjective and interpersonal experience

Hari Sood

Were you stood up to write this??