"Teaching to Transgress" - Chapter 6 : Essentialism and Experience (Patreon)
Content
“Identity politics emerges out of the struggles of oppressed or exploited groups to have a standpoint on which to critique dominant structures, a position that gives purpose and meaning to struggle…Though opposed to any essentialist practice that constructs identity in a monolithic, exclusionary way, I do not want to relinquish the power of experience as a standpoint on which to base analysis or formulate theory.”
I don’t think I have much to say about this chapter—I wholeheartedly agree with her dialectical approach to identity politics: yes, we don’t want to reduce people of any particular identity to a monolith, and also, experience based on identity is informative. To me this seems like a straightforward pair of truths to hold together, but it does feel like (in online discourse of the last years, at least) a lot of people will cling to either one or the other, with the former being more common among conservatives (think, characterizing the naming of any generalized trend in the experiences of a marginalized group as stereotyping) and the latter, more common with progressives. It always seems easier (or maybe safer?) to critique the conservative take, but ive generally been more hesitant to publicly critique “identity politics” as a progressive, despite definitely having those critiques. She captures the reason for my concern pretty well:
“I am concerned that critiques of identity politics not serve as the new, chic way to silence students from marginalized groups.”
I guess this is one instance of a broader thing I struggle with talking about political topics online—critiques of “my side” are important for advancing whatever movement, but can also provide justification for the opposing side to discredit ideas/opinions I agree with. I think most recently I’ve been thinking about this in the context of research on social inequality in education—there’s something i really hate about having made a video with the major point “some DEI work is performative bullshit that wastes time and money” only to see how today, that (almost) exact take being the justification behind the recent flood of executive orders. I feel like I’m getting off topic, but I guess what I want to say is that I really value hooks’ ability to make these nuanced critiques, and I wonder how doing that today is made difficult by like, contemporary online sensibilities (this feels similar to what I wrote about two chapters ago, hopefully I’m not being too repetitive).
I think the more interesting part of this chapter for me was the activity hooks described to orient her students to the value of experience in a classroom:
“When I teach Toni Morrison’s The Bluest Eye in introductory courses on black woman writers, I assign the students to write an autobiographical paragraph aloud to the class. Each person reads that paragraph aloud to the class. Our collective listening to one another affirms the value and uniqueness of each voice. This exercise highlights experience without privileging the voices of students from any particular group… students do not usually feel the need to compete because the concept of a privileged voice of authority is deconstructed by our collective critical practice.”
I love this for a few reasons: first, i like how this exercise challenges the assumption that identity and the experiences that it informs is something only marginalized people have. The number of times I’ve been a part of a conversation about race/sexism where the white people/men in the room act like this isn’t really about/for them, as if being white/male is the lack of “identity” rather than an identity in and of itself is…too many. Or similarly, when a white person/man speaks on behalf of PoC/women in an effort to be helpful rather than including themselves as a part of the conversation. Not about it.
And second, it’s just nice to see examples of what her pedagogy looks like in practice. I’m always curious to learn more about how things like norm setting in classrooms can be used to level power dynamics, and this is such a great example of that. Have any of you used or encountered teacher moves that challenge identity-based power dynamics in a classroom?