Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

NOTE: next week's chapter is significantly longer than all the others, plan accordingly!

I’m going to share an embarrassing though process I had in this reading, pls don’t judge me too hard lol

By the end of the first paragraph, I thought to myself something along the lines of: “this is the third chapter in a row that’s pretty specifically about education/scholarship regarding Black women.  I don’t want to diminish the value of learning about that group, but I wanted to read this book to learn how to teach everyone, not just one demographic.  I hope she moves away from this focus soon and gets more generalized.”

This line of thinking was followed by a couple self-checks. First, I had a gut reaction of, wait, I sound kinda like the reception I’ve gotten in academic contexts talking about racism/sexism from people who don’t embody whatever marginalized identities, and in those contexts their thinking comes off as self-centered and gross. Then I thought something like, well, if I’m interested in reading bell hooks, and I think so highly of her as a scholar, I should probably trust what she thinks is valuable to spend her time writing about. Like, who tf am I to tell her what she should or should not be focused on? And then I realized, ok, somethings going on here: I don’t like how I’m thinking, why am I thinking like this? 

A few reasons come to mind—that I’m ultimately not immune to the conditioning that frames whiteness/maleness as the default and anything else as periphery, that on some level I envy hooks’ unabashed centering of her own perspective bc I’ve felt the need to decenter my own in order to be taken seriously, maybe even that I fear I’ll lose y’all as my audience by our reading focusing on something that isn’t necessarily what you were hoping to get out of it. Maybe there’s more to it, and I do intend to reflect some more, but even without a 100% clear understanding, it didn’t take long to get to a point where I could remind myself that centering the most marginalized in my conception of teaching/education is in itself ‘transgression’, and I’m reading this book not to affirm my own concept of what it means to “teach to transgress”, but to broaden my understanding.

I share all this to say, I’m still trying to learn how to non-judgmentally check my own thinking when it comes to internalized biases. I’ve heard people say something like, “you’re not responsible for your first thought in reaction to something, but you are responsible for the second”--- basically that we all carry biases bc of society that we might not actually agree with, and that’s just kind of a reality that we don’t have to beat ourselves up over, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try to notice and examine those biases and ideally, use those noticings as opportunities to grow. To tie back to my thoughts from the last chapter about how to do conflict well, I guess this is a tool I use for like…self-conflict? Sure let’s go with that.

~~~~~

To actually speak to the contents of the chapter, the last few paragraphs made me think about a constant debate I’m having with myself about the label of “feminist”. 

“Despite a burgeoning body of literary criticism by black women from a feminist standpoint, more often than not black women academics focused attention on issues of gender without specifically placing their work within a feminist context…Their work—and that of many other black female historians—has expanded and continues to expand our understanding of the gendered nature of black experience, even though it does not overtly insist on a relationship to feminist thinking…What this means is that we have an incredible work built around the issue of gender enhancing feminist scholarship without explicitly naming itself as feminist…Yet, the absence of feminist standpoint or references pointedly acts to de-legitimize and invalidate such work even as it appropriates the issues and the audience feminist movement and feminist scholarship creates… ”

So I’ve had a complicated relationship with calling myself a feminist over the years. When I was younger, I was like, yeah obviously I’m a feminist, I want women to be equal to men, that’s what it means. Then I had more exposure to people who think of ‘feminism’ like it’s a bad word, who associate it with the worst (and very real) aspects of the movement, and might call themselves ‘egalitarianist’ or something instead to signal that they’re not sexist but don’t want to align to what they see as the worst of feminism. At some point I started responding to these perspectives with something like, ‘well I understand that there are shitty interpretations of feminism, but I’m gonna call myself a feminist anyways so that my engagement with it gives those people a better impression of it’---reclaiming the label, so to speak. But most recently, the way I’ve approached it (especially in my work on youtube) is the way I’ve approached most political labels—I’m not going to explicitly call myself anything or align myself with any particular political label, I’m just gonna share my ideas and let them stand on their own.

I still go back and forth between those last two approaches—I do think there is value in not labeling oneself politically (at least, publicly), because there are absolutely people who will put up their ideological blinders as soon as they hear certain buzzwords like ‘feminism’, and avoiding such labels in order to reach such people feels like a strategically productive move. At the same time, I feel hooks’ point that by distancing myself from what is obviously informing my ideas does a disservice to those ideas, to their originators, and ultimately functions as a concession to reactionary backlashes. I don’t think that this chapter necessarily gave me clarity one way or another, and maybe even trying to pick between the two options is me thinking in an overly binary way. But I’d be curious to hear from y’all, either as sharers or receivers of political ideas, what do you think of this divide? What are the strengths/weaknesses of each of these approaches? Is there a middle way? 

Comments

Computers Run On Magic Smoke

I’ve experienced people forming expectations of others after hearing their labels, above and beyond creating associations you might not expect. While this isn’t a bad thing per se (consider labels that help structure teams, professional relationships or meetings, e.g. PI, editor, chair), those expectations trap just as easily. I think it’s worse in politics because part of the expectation will be formed by hostile actors; doubly so for political entertainment, because part of the expectation is “entertain me.” It’s hard to talk about my elderly neighbors losing their apartments to rent hikes with someone who’s looking for a punchline because I said I’m a feminist, or is replaying a gotcha in their head. Though since their first question was “are you a feminist,” I likely wasn’t going to convince them anyway. For people not steeped in politics I think political labels are largely uninformative, but also that uninformative labels are different from withholding labels. Someone steeped in politics is likely going to be playing the association game with your positions if they aren’t there for you. I know I do, and I definitely know that drawing a conclusion will change what I read into what they don’t say. With that in mind, I think that uninformative labels are rhetorically powerful, more so than refusing labels or using common ones. They cause people to engage more credulously—after all, you’re being honest and open about your affiliation and what you believe, right? Never you mind that no one’s heard of a ist before just now. But I think that’s disingenuous, and actively prevents people from understanding political movements. Using common labels is both honest and full of association, but plenty of those associations will be negative, and refusing labels can come off as cagey and, again, makes it harder to associate. I think there’s a different style, in which people talk about their values before their labels or positions. I value egalitarianism, merit and despise bigotry, so I’m antiracist and feminist. I value cooperation, safety, efficiency and health, so I’m for public housing, bike lanes, public transit, and single-payer healthcare. I’m a socialist, yes, because I value opportunity. I hope that invites people to discuss, discover, or at least consider how you arrived at your positions, rather than something less charitable. Unless they so strongly associate labels with values that the mere suggestion you could arrive at different positions triggers a fight; that’s definitely going to happen online.

Raphaël Royer

I have that same dilema, I'm still learning how to navigate conversations with "normal" people, these days I favor openly talking about socialist, marxist or feminist principals without explicitly naming them but that's good for random people, with people closer to me, I'm less shy about using lables to describe my thoughts. I think it's important to say people like Einstein was a socialist or that he was extremly critical of zionism. Anyway, thank you for doing these bookclubs, it's my first time participing and it's super fun!

AJ Biffl

I'm not embarrassed to say I also struggled to find direct relevance for me in this chapter. I don't think it's wrong to argue that this chapter was not meant for me in particular - I think hooks is following her own advice, and writing about the things she has the most direct experience with, the slices of progressive action that are closest to her own heart. The value I gained from this chapter wasn't in advice for my particular situation or in validating my shared experience with her - it was in exposing me to this new, foreign experience and seeing how she responds with strength and perseverance to this great struggle (as well as a bit more insight into the behavior of large social movements in general). To speak a little more about that, I'd never really encountered the specific ways that black voices were rejected in the white feminist movement before. I think I've mentioned "Amiable with Big Teeth" by George McKay before but this definitely gives me the same vibes. I've also recently been seeing it's possible a lot of the time to talk about all organizations as social organisms, entities which act in their own self interest, to procure resources and defend their methods of procurement. I think we see that sort of behavior with the alienation hooks experienced as she and others tried to walk this intersectional line between feminism and antiracism. As to the question of political labels, that actually makes me think of the last few chapters of Against Method (almost finished with it! slow going...) There's this principle of rejecting absolute traditions, but not necessarily rejecting the IDEAS of those traditions. Some of those traditional wisdoms work and are beneficial but the dominance of the tradition itself is not. So it's possible to accept the tenets of a particular tradition in some or many situations but without holding reverence to the tradition and all the baggage that may come with it. I'm not sure how relevant that is to the particular "worst points" of feminism you mention, and I'd like to hear more, but at the outset it just makes me think of the process of wrapping a whole lot of ideas and principles together under one hat, but every person might have a different picture of what the hat means and the hat changes over time and using that hat as shorthand may get less effective. If there is some reactionary impulse railing against the label, it's possible to get in there to say "the conversation is about these ideas, not the label." To what extent that actually means using or identifying with the label, I'm not sure, but it also definitely means being precise about the content and history of the ideas.

AlexTheTutor

Yes, I’ve had the same feeling for a while about this book. In a previous chapter when she was in a position of power, she “had to exclude students” in being part of a discussion. I thought, “there is no way Hooks would be ok being left out of a discussion if she were a student”. And then, the NEXT chapter she wrote about how as a student she was initially left out of a seminar, but she fought until she got in and was able to discuss ideas with Freire, her hero who shaped the ideas of this very book. Other parts of the book made me question: if someone’s self-esteem is always being challenged (lack of recognition, achievement, and respect from others), to what extend is it possible to advance to Maslow’s next hierarchical level and become a self-actualized educator? Other parts suggest that Hooks prefers talking about theory than providing a robust detailed how-to guide on teaching everyone. That being said, Hooks has presented a general theory of pedagogy: teachers are to engage students in critical thinking and self-reflection within an environment of active participation, mutual respect, and care. Also, rethink traditional classroom dynamics if necessary. The core of her theory is 100% valid by experience, for me at least. Just today I was teaching chemistry for 3 straight hours to a black woman, making her critically think on how to approach questions and self-reflect on mistakes within a safe environment full of active participation and etc. She has a big lack of self-esteem with chemistry, so it takes a lot of courage for her to try. I’m proud of her. There is a male organic chem professor who is a bit too harsh when speaking to students. Due to the lack of mutual respect, a lot of his female students find me, and we get through the course. So, although gender is important to consider, mutual respect simplifies a lot. Instead of providing my own detailed how-to, it honestly just boils down to, “do not assume anything, just make direct observations of student in the present moment, think about how to approach, and then approach”. It’s more improv than anything, but this improv allows for trust building. Example: female students openly talk with me about hormones and menstrual cycles and how it affects their learning. If there’s an Indonesian student, I speak a little Indonesian, and etc. These small things excite students, and they embrace more of a growth exploratory mindset. Consequently, for me I don’t put labels on myself for anything. Beyond self-actualization is transcendence. I’ve been able to blend in with any ethnicity and teach anyone just fine: war veterans, refugees, etc. A right-leaning taxi driver in South America asked me if I was a leftist or rightist, and I replied neither, because if everyone is moving left and right, no one is moving forward. Make direct observations, critically think, and move forward, self-reflect when needed.

AJ Biffl

After ruminating a bit, I wanted to clarify what I meant in the first paragraph because I think it reads quite differently than I intended. First, I did NOT mean that because I'm white I couldn't benefit from her account of racialized alienation - I think it gave a hugely illuminating description of how white people can contribute to that alienation within feminism and parallel social movements. My main point was that her focus seems to be about education and discussions about feminism and other progressive social theories, and the importance of people who feel alienated within those movements to continue to be vocal about their intersectional experience. I don't educate about progressive social theory, I seek to emply progressive theory in education in another field, so I don't directly interface with the need to support an intersectional perspective. Her calls to action are not calls I can answer.

Hari Sood

> But I’d be curious to hear from y’all, either as sharers or receivers of political ideas, what do you think of this divide? What are the strengths/weaknesses of each of these approaches? Is there a middle way? I was having similar thoughts through this chapter! I feel like the chapter reads like a lament, showing the pain of trying to take intersectional approaches in spaces where the injustice of power is both suffered and exercised, which requires nuanced understanding that it is easy to dismiss. This followed by the tragic final point of the lack of collective support meaning there continues to be an issue of understanding 'black life from a feminist standpoint', from a place of hermeneutical injustice or something. It's pretty bleak. It also makes me thing of these labels - between friends (primarily friends of colour), we've found the term 'white feminist' and 'white socialist' helpful (and kind of like comedic iygm), to describe the person (most often white) or space (most often white) that basically reduces social issues to these things (binary gender and class respectively), almost in a conversation ending way. An example is the statement 'everything is because of the patriarchy' or 'it all comes down to class'. Like yes these things are really significant things to address but they are not ground truths. Saying it like this means there is no room for additional discussion, or to dissect those things more intricately - how is the patriarchy experienced by different demographics of people? how is class? It makes me wonder whether these terms need to be seen as starting points, rather than end points - you are not a feminist by conclusion (I say I am and no further questions), you are feminist by idk...direction? orientation? it is not a label that describes but a lens that can be used to bring understanding to a whole myriad of issues. Practically speaking, I find it still helpful to use these terms, not least because like they still represent naming solidarity against oppressive systems. Mb it's where I've found the terms white feminism/socialist to be helpful, to then categorise the exclusive nature of this thinking as a subset of the term, and open up spaces for alternative formulations within the umbrella of feminism/socialism.

Hari Sood

also look at me responding the actual week of the book club like someone who has their life in order 😎

Hari Sood

> because I'm white I couldn't benefit from her account of racialized alienation Not that I know you as a person in real life but it would've been a crazy shift in your book club personality if you had said/meant this 😂

Hari Sood

And love how you tied this back to AM!

Hari Sood

Love your thoughts Eric, especially around communicating values before labels/positions! It reminds me of a reel I saw where the person talking was like 'I believe everyone deserves a home. Now how we do that (social housing, more jobs so people can afford homes, investment in infrastructure businesses) is a political question that can be discussed. But saying something along the lines of 'If you are homeless, there may be a reason as to why you don't deserve a home', that's not politics, that's just being a dick.

Hari Sood

> with people closer to me, I'm less shy about using lables to describe my thoughts This is a cool thought Raphaël! It's like when people are familiar with you, what you stand for, the language you use etc, they know what you mean when you use the term, but stragers won't and will default to mb their understanding, or like the generally socialised understanding or smth

Hari Sood

I like the idea of prioritising interpersonal interactions over prescribed ways of interacting based on labels Alex! Also (and hopefully not to open a can of worms) my understanding is that terms like man and woman would be talking about gender, and male and female about sex - for consistency and clarity! Though that is just my understanding and others may understand differently 🙏🏽

AJ Biffl

I love that way of thinking that labels are starting points, not end-all ways of defining people! Like you start in the fertile soil of all the philosophers and writers before (what Fatima mentioned about doing service to the ideas and originators of those ideas), and you react and grow into and use the ideas yourself. I also really like this pointing out of "spaces where the injustice of power is both suffered and exercised." I think it's probably a safe bet that almost ALL large-scale organized movements have at least some axes of internal oppression, either because of history or internal biases or just emergent material hierarchy. So even fresh new movements aren't immune to alienating and putting down in this way

phil e the theyby

OK, so I LOVE that Dr. Fatima brought the discussion explicitly to labels, because I think I've had a lot of thoughts about this under the surface. Broadly, I avoid labeling myself and my ideology, in large part because I don't want to limit myself. I care about all people and their well-being. If an ideology has things that benefit that pursuit, I'll draw from it those parts that are useful. But I will readily and happily reject any parts of any ideology that I find is getting in the way of that goal (and largely, where most ideologies fall short is the "all people" part; they often state that in theory but struggle to actually hold onto it in practice). When I talk about my beliefs, I tend to say that I'm "informed by" different traditions. How I think about the world is broadly influenced by a lot of feminist (and particularly Black feminist), anarchist, and Marxist thought. I also draw a lot from the philosophical traditions of existentialism and pragmatism, along with various aspects of Christianity and Buddhism (and some of the more prominent tenets of Judaism and Islam are also pretty core to how I think about the world, although I'm somewhat less educated on those religions). But I don't say I'M a feminist, an anarchist, a Marxist, an existentialist, a pragmatist, a Christian, a Buddhist, Jewish, or a Muslim. For the religious identities, those are things people tend to label themselves either based on their beliefs (and again, I kind of believe all sorts of different things) or based on being a part of a community, but I'm not really part of a faith community. If I were a philosophy professor, labeling myself as an existentialist or a pragmatist would be useful in delineating my work, but I'm not a philosophy professor. So generally, I just don't see labeling myself ideologically as useful to what I want to do, nor do I see it useful in terms of self-concept. I honor and respect different traditions, but who I am and what I believe is much broader than any one of them, and I want the freedom to distance myself from those traditions whenever it is useful to do so. This doesn't mean distancing myself from the PEOPLE who align themselves with those traditions; I have no problem with others labeling themselves, and I value the opportunity to hear what those particular labels mean for them. I just don't find it that helpful for me personally.

phil e the theyby

I'm making a separate post for the actual chapter analysis don't judge me I'm really grateful to Dr. Fatima's vulnerability around unpacking her reactions to things; the fact that this is an environment for noticing what comes up for us without judgment is a huge part of why I love it so much. Kudos for moving away from the purity posturing bullshit that can become so pervasive in online spaces. I really appreciate bell hooks' diagnosis of some of the roots of fundamental disconnects between (White) feminism and Black communities. That said, I feel like the direction she proposes (in this chapter, anyway) is somewhat shallow, and I think that's because it's only a partial diagnosis of the problems. I think that a lot of the fear and resistance to dismantling patriarchy and adopting intersectional feminist lenses on the world comes specifically from *the fear of what happens when patriarchy's gone*. Particularly within many marginalized communities that are organized around patriarchy, the structure of the community as it is (including its patriarchy) is one of the only resources available in a White supremacist society. I think there can be a fear that dismantling the patriarchy will dismantle the community itself. While the work of Black feminist writers like bell hooks can correctly point out how the patriarchal aspects of Black communities are harmful (to both men and women; read "The Will to Change," it's a great book), this awareness itself doesn't guarantee that dismantling patriarchy will actually be better for Black people as a whole. It can be hard to instill a vision of a world beyond patriarchy, particularly when such an image seems to evoke the White liberal "utopian" vision where "everyone is equal" but what really happens is that all BIPOC communities and values are just erased. The White liberal utopia has everyone regardless of race living together in harmony, except they all have to only say and believe things that make White people comfortable. So naturally, the image that's evoked when saying "we can dismantle this system of gender oppression" is an "egalitarian" world that doesn't actually serve or care about Black people unless they align to White interests and White values. I think this same fear (not being able to envision a positive future after the dismantling of racism) exists in White people, but in more subtle ways. A lot of White folks just don't feel equipped to manage those conversations about difference, especially when discussing that difference involves hearing the harm BIPOC folks have experienced at the hands of White people or in the name of White interests. So it can be hard for them to invest in dismantling racism, because they feel unprepared for what would happen if racism were actually dismantled (although the next chapter of this book does seem like it would help with that a bit!). I do think we need really solid visions of the change that's possible for the future (maybe the fiction world does a better job of this; idk, I don't really read fiction), and we need to equip people with the skills to actually navigate cross-group interactions in a (hypothetical, "maybe we'll never get there") decolonized world. On to the long chapter! :)

AJ Biffl

I like your description of that fear of losing the structure of patriarchy, but I don't think that that element is missing from hooks' perspective. I'm thinking of like in the previous chapter where she mentions the black male student who expresses difficulty in developing feminist awareness, or the group of female students who expressed fears of isolation or changes to their heterosexual relationships if they openly committed to feminist politics. I think that type of fear is one of the very common reactionary impulses against feminism all over the place, that patriarchy as a scaffolding of power is where a lot of people are used to standing on, and they fear losing. In this chapter I think hooks is talking to black scholars about the ways other factors prevent them from coming under the feminist umbrella to speak against patriarchy, but these are people already focusing on "issues of gender without specifically placing their work within a feminist context," so their confrontation of that fear is already happening, and so isn't her focus

schlltchrn

I think I agree with this idea that there is this fear to deconstruct the system that the community is holding on to. I also think that firstly, if one first tries to bring feminism into a new community, there is going to be some conflict. If feminism was only connected to white feminism, starting a chapter of black feminism, would for sure cause some push back. But something I can associate to my own experience, as long there is this association with feminism=whiteness, or feminism=oppressor of course there is going to be much suspicion from both man and women. I have been observing something similar in the country where I come from, Serbia, where we have a lot of memories of NATO bombing in the 90s, and anti-imperialism is crucial for both left and right. Now, leftist men, almost surgically avoid topics like feminism or LBTQ+ rights, because this might associate them with the neoliberal capitalist "west", and as people who identify as anti-imperialist, this is the worst nightmare. While in the back of their heads they'd be like "sure that is obvious, women are ~equal~ to men" they would never criticise their own misogyny because, again, LGBTQ and feminism=west=NATO=imperialism. Which is, of course, ridiculous, but that's what we're working with.

schlltchrn

Ahhh labels are so tricky and useful in so many ways. I have always avoided labels for different reasons. One of them is that I feel more comfortable saying that I "believe" something, or I am "doing" something, than the big scary I AM something. It feels way stricter. I am scarred, I will associate myself with things I don't believe, but the other person perceives as a part of this particular identity. And also scarred to be called a hypocrite for not 120% committing to this identity. Like "are you really a feminist if you don't __fill in the blank__". Also, I never wanted to make connections with people only based on this one label we both share, and would rather roam around the world and see who I meet on the way. For example, I always saw my sexuality as something I do, or that happens to me, or something I experience, than something I AM. So I would never identify as _a bisexual_ or _a pansexual_ I'm like... a person going around feeling attracted to other people. And I see how this is a super privileged way to see things, since people have identified before me, and used these labels as an important tool to fight for the rights of queer people, so that I can, at least in my bubble, just be a blob floating around vibing. When other people do identify with ideas, sometimes, I feel seen through that. I feel like I relax differently if people put up the labels I feel adjacent with. So labels can be useful to me, even if I don't use them confidently myself. But is that fair, could I make other, maybe more vulnerable, people more comfortable if I declared my alliance with their movement in a more pragmatic way...? Probably...? One thing that does put me on guard, however, is mostly leftist men identifying with a philosophy of one dude like 100%, fully committed. You know, a bunch of dudes calling themselves a Marxist, Leninists or Maoists or Trotskyist or Titoist or whatever... I mean... sure your favourite guy from history got many things right, and you find him clever, and I can go on and agree with a bunch of things somebody had to say, but uhm... the world is changing and everybody is up for debate. Or saying things like "As a leftist, I do feel for x group of people for suffering through a thing" I mean... as a compassionate human you can also feel for people. It seems like how people chose a random sports club as kids or teenagers to cheer for their whole life. And it often has a leftist flavour of "facts don't care about your feelings" kind of debate. It doesn't seem like a fully rounded belief that includes both a more specific personal and a more abstract spiritual component to it.

Kristen

I remember in a class on Liberation Theology the radical idea was that the marginalized, old/young, poor, weak, meek, foreign, imprisoned, enslaved, etc. -- you know, the "losers" of society -- were not only worth listening to, but the only perspective that could lead to liberation because the dominators would never be driven to liberate the dominated. I think universal design -- accessibility -- is kind of praxis of this idea of liberation in the most mundane, everyday kind of way: by designing things for everyone, not the "average" or "median" or "able" but really everyone and every "special need" you end up designing better things in every way -- including for the able and average. It's usually so obvious it would feel silly to change it to serve "the majority" because it would make it objectively worse of a design. (Curb cutouts, colorblind high contrast palletes or text/font sizing, and even "cheats" and difficulty levels built into video games are all examples of universal design.)

Jacques Vincelette

Sadly, under the corporate research/academic framework, values have been coopted as "wishful thinking" pie in the sky dreamy objectives we are eventually striving towards. At least labels offer practical archetypal references as any reliable tarot deck. Labels acknowlege position, story, and associated biases and privileges. I can identify as 2nd wave feminist from the women who taught me, admitting my struggle to catch up, and the no-nonsense righteousness to trample political correctness.

Hari Sood

I have a book you may be interested in phil! I did some volunteering with the author of this book, who used to be Buddhist (having been raised by Christian missionaries), then decided to drop the label as he found some Buddhist teachings too dogmatic, and then has started a society called the 'Middle Way Society' for a more pragmatic approach to primarily Buddhist teachings. He has many books but whilst volunteering with him I read this intro and it has really stuck with me! https://www.robertmellis.net/lesson/migglism/

Hari Sood

Really interesting Lidija! It makes me think about the nuance of social understanding of terms as more powerful than their underlying definitions, , or whether they are just used as an excuse to hide more entrenched beliefs - e.g. in the case of LGBTQ, is it that people are so fearful of being socially associated with imperalism that they avoid it, or is it just a justifiable excuse to be queerphobic? phil - on your thoughts on fiction - it reminds of of in gainst Method when PF talks about art being as legitimate a way to understand the world as science, just through a different medium. I think this is where fiction isn't just storytelling, it's the very real presentation of alternate realities that can help us understand what our current one is missing. I used to not read much fiction but have been getting back into it to make sure my very real imagination is not limited by what is materially/experientially in front of me!

Hari Sood

Love this Lidija! Your final thought also resonates with me - a big one for me is if you are truly leftist you believe in collective intelligence and community over individuals, to the extent that you should recognise that even if these individual men had great thoughts, they are just an amalagamation of everyone and everything around them, and its misinformed/dangerous/not resilient/hierarchichal or truly collective to put individual people up on a pedestal. If you believe in the idea of 'individual genius' you kind of believe in the idea of eugenics or smth

Hari Sood

Would love to hear more of your thoughts on universal design Kristen! It reminds me of that book The Design of Everyday Things, where the argument is 'if you can't use it, you're not an idiot, the thing is poorly designed'

Kristen

Yeah, well, as a software engineer I also see the "feature/bug" perspective everywhere. It's easy to see these systemic issues as "bugs" and think drawing attention to them and solutions is enough, but then analysing the forces that be the bug starts to look like a feature for someone else or power itself, and sometimes more looking it becomes a bug again as it becomes clear it doesn't actually serve anyone at all. To me, universal design is something that is a feature for everyone, not a bug to some. The fear a lot of people have with accessibility is that the thing that works for them will be tailored to someone else (a dreaded "minority") and stop working for them. That's not good design though, so it's a phantasm created by noticing how the "losers" (meek, poor, tired, etc.) are excluded and only knowing the methods of violence, exclusion, coercion means the only imagined outcome hurts the ones benefiting from the current system and chooses new "winners" and "losers." Tl;Dr: universal design, liberation, is scary to the mind that only knows a system that pits winners/losers against each other, so any bug fix is stealing a feature away from them.

phil e the theyby

Thank you! This seems really interesting; I’ll check it out 🙂

phil e the theyby

I don’t think I articulated that point super well, AJ. I definitely agree that hooks highlights the specific things you mentioned. I think the specific fears that I haven’t seen noted as explicitly are 1) not feeling EQUIPPED to handle the changes (i.e. when the bad things you mentioned happen, not having the tools to manage it), and 2) believing that the future on the other side of patriarchy is actually better (i.e. they on some level know things are bad, but don’t think taking action will actually change things for the better). But other people may feel that’s more present (or implicit) than I do :) Lidija, thank you for sharing that example; it’s been sticking in my head for DAYS since you mentioned it. Those reactions folks in Serbia have are completely valid, and it’s also fucking tragic because it prevents…you know, actually taking care of women and LGBTQ+ people. This is why I tend to value personal relationships as a supplement to “movements” in changing beliefs. Folks need people who they trust are on THEIR side (or in this case, anti-NATO/anti-imperialist) who can talk about these things from a place of compassion for why it may be hard for them to understand at first. But these conversations are really hard to have, especially for folks who are harmed by the way things are (in this case, women and queer people). Ideally, it’s cishet men having these conversations, simply because they’re (inaccurately) seen as the most “credible,” and because they have less personal trauma around the topics to deal with when trying to have these conversations. Hari, thanks for reminding me of the fiction point a few days later. It made me think about how my bias towards non-fiction tends to center around trying to “equip myself” for the work I’m doing and helping me learn things to support the people I care about. But I think this attitude probably has some pretty strong White supremacist, imperialist undertones to it, in that it only treats non-fiction texts as valid sources of knowledge. Your comment has me a lot more committed to weaving more fiction into what I read, both to imagine what else is possible and to start to take in other sources of knowledge, even if fiction isn’t the “language” I’m most comfortable reading. Because I’m pretty confident fiction books have a lot of unique and valuable insights to offer that I wouldn’t find elsewhere.

Moz in Oz

I think labels are useful for things we can't not be. I'm vegetarian even when I'm not eating and that is often useful for others to know. But it's not really important to know that I'm more anarchist than authoritarian most of the time. This also ties into which prejudices I'm willing to hear expressed, and which people should hide to be polite. That doesn't always work, but it does reduce the frequency. Most people, most of the time, won't tell you directly that they'd murder you if they thought they could get away with it (my coworker who dislikes cyclists being a notable exception)