"Teaching to Transgress" - Chapter 9: Feminist Scholarship (Black Scholars) (Patreon)
Content
NOTE: next week's chapter is significantly longer than all the others, plan accordingly!
I’m going to share an embarrassing though process I had in this reading, pls don’t judge me too hard lol
By the end of the first paragraph, I thought to myself something along the lines of: “this is the third chapter in a row that’s pretty specifically about education/scholarship regarding Black women. I don’t want to diminish the value of learning about that group, but I wanted to read this book to learn how to teach everyone, not just one demographic. I hope she moves away from this focus soon and gets more generalized.”
This line of thinking was followed by a couple self-checks. First, I had a gut reaction of, wait, I sound kinda like the reception I’ve gotten in academic contexts talking about racism/sexism from people who don’t embody whatever marginalized identities, and in those contexts their thinking comes off as self-centered and gross. Then I thought something like, well, if I’m interested in reading bell hooks, and I think so highly of her as a scholar, I should probably trust what she thinks is valuable to spend her time writing about. Like, who tf am I to tell her what she should or should not be focused on? And then I realized, ok, somethings going on here: I don’t like how I’m thinking, why am I thinking like this?
A few reasons come to mind—that I’m ultimately not immune to the conditioning that frames whiteness/maleness as the default and anything else as periphery, that on some level I envy hooks’ unabashed centering of her own perspective bc I’ve felt the need to decenter my own in order to be taken seriously, maybe even that I fear I’ll lose y’all as my audience by our reading focusing on something that isn’t necessarily what you were hoping to get out of it. Maybe there’s more to it, and I do intend to reflect some more, but even without a 100% clear understanding, it didn’t take long to get to a point where I could remind myself that centering the most marginalized in my conception of teaching/education is in itself ‘transgression’, and I’m reading this book not to affirm my own concept of what it means to “teach to transgress”, but to broaden my understanding.
I share all this to say, I’m still trying to learn how to non-judgmentally check my own thinking when it comes to internalized biases. I’ve heard people say something like, “you’re not responsible for your first thought in reaction to something, but you are responsible for the second”--- basically that we all carry biases bc of society that we might not actually agree with, and that’s just kind of a reality that we don’t have to beat ourselves up over, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try to notice and examine those biases and ideally, use those noticings as opportunities to grow. To tie back to my thoughts from the last chapter about how to do conflict well, I guess this is a tool I use for like…self-conflict? Sure let’s go with that.
~~~~~
To actually speak to the contents of the chapter, the last few paragraphs made me think about a constant debate I’m having with myself about the label of “feminist”.
“Despite a burgeoning body of literary criticism by black women from a feminist standpoint, more often than not black women academics focused attention on issues of gender without specifically placing their work within a feminist context…Their work—and that of many other black female historians—has expanded and continues to expand our understanding of the gendered nature of black experience, even though it does not overtly insist on a relationship to feminist thinking…What this means is that we have an incredible work built around the issue of gender enhancing feminist scholarship without explicitly naming itself as feminist…Yet, the absence of feminist standpoint or references pointedly acts to de-legitimize and invalidate such work even as it appropriates the issues and the audience feminist movement and feminist scholarship creates… ”
So I’ve had a complicated relationship with calling myself a feminist over the years. When I was younger, I was like, yeah obviously I’m a feminist, I want women to be equal to men, that’s what it means. Then I had more exposure to people who think of ‘feminism’ like it’s a bad word, who associate it with the worst (and very real) aspects of the movement, and might call themselves ‘egalitarianist’ or something instead to signal that they’re not sexist but don’t want to align to what they see as the worst of feminism. At some point I started responding to these perspectives with something like, ‘well I understand that there are shitty interpretations of feminism, but I’m gonna call myself a feminist anyways so that my engagement with it gives those people a better impression of it’---reclaiming the label, so to speak. But most recently, the way I’ve approached it (especially in my work on youtube) is the way I’ve approached most political labels—I’m not going to explicitly call myself anything or align myself with any particular political label, I’m just gonna share my ideas and let them stand on their own.
I still go back and forth between those last two approaches—I do think there is value in not labeling oneself politically (at least, publicly), because there are absolutely people who will put up their ideological blinders as soon as they hear certain buzzwords like ‘feminism’, and avoiding such labels in order to reach such people feels like a strategically productive move. At the same time, I feel hooks’ point that by distancing myself from what is obviously informing my ideas does a disservice to those ideas, to their originators, and ultimately functions as a concession to reactionary backlashes. I don’t think that this chapter necessarily gave me clarity one way or another, and maybe even trying to pick between the two options is me thinking in an overly binary way. But I’d be curious to hear from y’all, either as sharers or receivers of political ideas, what do you think of this divide? What are the strengths/weaknesses of each of these approaches? Is there a middle way?