Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I think the last line of this chaptered distilled the whole thing pretty well:

“This is one of the tragedies in education today. We have a lot of people who don’t recognize that being a teacher is being with people.”

bars

When I saw that this chapter was going to be another dialogue (but this time with an actual other person with a completely distinct perspective and not just hooks’ alter egos), I anticipated that my takeaways would be on the nature of their dialogue in some way, but honestly, the way they build off each other in conversation is so seamless and they both are so insightful and experienced that I was fully caught up in the contents of the conversation and all I have to share is a list of topics they hit on that resonated with me in some way. Would be interested to hear if others had takeaways about the collaboration itself though

~~~~~~~~~~

One of the first things they talk about is their respective relationships to their profession, and the identity as educators: 

“I’ve benefited a lot from not being attached to myself as an academic or professor. It’s made me willing to be critical of my own pedagogy and to accept criticism from my students and other people without feeling that to question how I teach is somehow to question my right to exist on the planet.”

So there’s this concept in STEM ed literature of ‘science identity’, and it’s usually discussed in the context of the experiences of minoritized students in whatever STEM field and either feeling or not feeling a sense of belonging to their discipline (Carlone and Johnson 2007 is the seminal paper if you’re interested). Tldr, having strong ‘science identity’ leads to good outcomes, so our goal as educators should be to build up students’ science identity. I have a take on this idea that I will probably make a video about at sometime that’s basically: I think we should explore divesting from this idea of science identity and encourage a way of learning and doing science that doesn’t encourage making success in it the core of one’s self worth (which I don’t think this literature necessarily intends, but I do think that’s often an outcome of this stance). I think hooks’ attitude towards her professional gets at the same argument on science identity I’m still noodling on—attachment to a job is a central part of one's identity can actually get in the way of doing it well, because it’s harder to question how you’re doing it if that also means questioning your fundamental value as a human being. Idk if this is getting too far away from the actual material at hand, but i wonder if any of y’all have thoughts on this idea of attachment to career/discipline being counterproductive (or not?) How much do you identify with what you study/do for work? Do you feel like that identification (or lack thereof) serves you or hinders you?

~~~~~~~~~~

I really love the part of the conversation that was challenging mind/body dualism and drawing out the relations between the body, power, and epistemology. I’m just gonna share some notable lines without any commentary:

“The person who is the most powerful has the privilege of denying their body.”

“The traditional notion of being in the classroom is a teacher behind a desk or standing at the front, immobilized. In a weird way that recalls the firm, immobilized body of knowledge as part of the immutability of truth itself.”

“I remember in my early teaching days that when I first tried to move out beyond the desk, I felt really nervous. I remember thinking, ‘This is really about power’”

“The erasure of the body encourages us to think that we are listening to neutral, objective facts, facts that are not particular to who is sharing the information.”

“Recognition of [the conditions of one’s life, basically] must be suspended; and the rationale for this erasure is the logic which says, “What we do here is science, what we do here is objective history.”

~~~~~~~~~~

I know there's been some discussion over the weeks about how any of what we’re reading in this book translates to a STEM/physics classroom, and there were actually several points in this chapter that felt very directly transferable. Here’s one:

“Many professors who are critical of the inclusion of confessional narrative in the classroom or of digressive discussions, where students are doing a lot of the talking, are critical because they lack the skill needed to facilitate dialogue. Once the space for dialogue is open in the classroom, that moment must be orchestrated so that you don’t get bogged down with people who are unable to relate experience to the academic subject matter.”

So idk about confessional narrative, but digressive discussion in general can be extremely fruitful things in science classes—a well guided tangent can be a fantastic learning opportunity to for example, add context to or build intuition for whatever the topic at hand is. However, I’ve also been in many a physics class where most of the digression takes the form of one guy who wastes at least a few minutes of every lecture to ‘ask a question’ that’s mostly just him rambling about some barely related obscure physics thing he’s read that contributes absolutely nothing the the conversation. I used to attribute these annoyances mostly to the students (who like, yeah part of its on them obviously), but more recently I’ve had experiences seeing physics teachers who are actually competent at facilitation enough to gracefully stop someone who wants to hear themselves talk (and even draw out engagement from students who don’t talk as much), and feel like the conversation facilitation skills hooks refers to here is actually a very straightforward tangible skillset an educator can learn to help move away from an overly authoritarian, purely lecture based teaching mode without dissolving into chaos. Personally I’ve been using the book “The Adaptive School: a Sourcebook for Developing Collaborative Groups” as a reference for some work I’m doing facilitating students recently, so that’s a thing maybe to check out if you’re interested in such things.

This post is already very long so I won’t get into the other examples I noticed of practical pedagogy things, but I’m curious if anyone else caught things that they could apply to more technical education contexts?

Comments

phil e the theyby

This chapter is FIRE, so much deep knowledge is woven into it. The impact of the mind-body dualism really stood out to me as well. This quote in particular fucked with me: “…in those private spaces where sexual harassment goes on—in offices or other kinds of spaces—one has to experience the revenge of the repressed.” (136) This idea that people in power abuse those beneath them *specifically because* they (the ones in power) have been conditioned to repress meaningful parts of themselves is fascinating, and resonates deeply with a lot of what I’ve been reflecting on lately. I think that privilege under White supremacy is deeply psychologically harmful (while providing obvious material benefits), and that harm to the privileged is a major source of a lot of the interpersonal violence they do to the marginalized. bell hooks discussed this as it pertains to masculinity in “The Will to Change,” but the idea of these specific harms coming (in part) from the mind-body duality in academia is FASCINATING. I also really enjoyed this part around “engaged” teaching (referencing Engaged Buddhism): “It invites us always to be in the present, to remember that the classroom is never the same. Traditional ways of thinking about the classroom stress the opposite paradigm—that the classroom is always the same even when students are different.” (158) I appreciate this idea that you can never fully “prepare” for a class because you need to meet the students and understand them and their unique needs. It highlights the immense amount of work needed to truly be effective as a teacher to diverse students (and all groups of students are diverse, even if they look similar on the surface). I think that personally, I feel like I don’t at all identify with my field or job title. I’m a psychologist who provides therapy and does DEI work. I don’t think of myself as a psychologist, a therapist, or someone who does DEI, and I do feel like that makes me more effective. I’m constantly looking for new ways to do things, both within and outside my field. But I also have this reaction that “they’re saying something that describes me is good, so I’m inclined to agree with them.” I want to be mindful that feeling like an “outsider” within one’s field seems like it’s just another aspect of diversity (which has very clear intersections with other aspects of diversity), and that it has ways that it facilitates our work and ways that limit it. I know that, for me, I’m less likely to advocate politically and economically for both psychologists and DEI professionals because I don’t identify with those groups, and it’s important that both of those groups have strong advocates of that sort. So I think it’s more valuable for all of us to recognize the strengths and the drawbacks that can come from not really identifying with the field. That said, I do largely agree with the benefits hooks and Scapp describe to not being attached to that identity, including greater flexibility and greater openness to criticism. But I think that people who ARE attached to their field can improve their work by weaving flexibility and openness to criticism into their idea of what it means to be a “good” physicist/writer/psychologist/whatever.

AJ Biffl

There was SO MUCH in this chapter! It legitimately got me excited to get back in the classroom and try some new things. Lots of gems about pedagogy in general (the role of privilege in the mind/body split; acknowledging the body as acknowledging its place in history; revelation that many students intrinsically perceive that "professors can be and should be dictators" and the "habit of repression" and trying to counter that; that each classroom is different and the burden of creating a learning community isn't just on the shoulders of the educator; emphasizing listening as well as speaking; that loosening the hierarchy in the classroom doesn't need to lead to lack of discipline, lack of commitment, and you can assume students can act and think responsibly as adults; that being too worried about straying from an agenda and focusing "on covering material precisely is one way to slip back into a banking system", are some big ones that I have in my notes). For technical fields specifically, I think there were a few points that apply. I really resonated with the discussion about students and other faculty being so concerned about losing "seriousness" in the classroom. I know for a fact many of my students view the physics class as sort of a different category than their other classes, that it has this reputation of being more technical and difficult and no funny business. That's also connected to students themselves actually being a source of resistance to new modes of education because they've come to expect the old forms and fear they may be losing quality in this strange new form, and may also resent being expected to become active participants in the classroom rather than passive consumers, which is definitely the expectation in most lectures I've ever attended. In a different vein but still applying to technical fields, I really resonated with the bit about how some professors will let students say something and then effectively completely ignore what was said ("We're willing to hear Suzie speak even as we then immediately turn away from her words, erasing them"). This is something I very much struggle with, being in a technical field where there CAN sometimes actually be "wrong" answers. I don't know the best way to express that someone's suggestion is valuable even if it's not an applicable way to solve a problem. Usually I'll go along with the suggestion and work it out until I hit a dead end, so we can all see together that it's a reasonable thing to try but won't get us to where we want to go. That way (I hope) it feels more like a shared process of investigation and less like "no ur wrong." Though I still worry it discourages them from speaking out again in the future. I know being told you're wrong in front of the whole class can be painful, especially when you've taken the risk of saying something in the first place. I don't know the best way to walk that line of correcting without devaluing. ~~~~~~~ In addition to all these takeaways about pedagogy, I had a lightbulb moment during this chapter (once again going to relate to Against Method) when hooks talked about resisting the pull of "feeling good" and chasing high marks in end-of-semester evaluations ("in reconceptualizing engaged pedagogy I had to realize that our purpose here isn't really to feel good"). There's this deep link between short-term motivations/instant gratification and the old forms of hegemony, vs taking a longer-term view being necessary in the pursuit of transforming that hegemony. This is found all over elsewhere too, in education, in the emphasis put on grades and test scores, but also in the climate crisis and consumerism and popular media and immigrant-phobia and on and on. How I've come to understand that link is in terms of Feyerabend's interaction of traditions. Capitalism is the most fundamental Tradition underlying the global hegemony, and its most fundamental assumption is that all things can be reduced to an appropriate amount of capital. Its language, its cosmology, is in immediate, short-term "objective" valuation, translating into an equivalent amount of dollars and cents. So everything has to act in terms of short term, tangible value, a numerical measure - any endeavor that doesn't speak in these terms is incommensurable with capitalism and is rejected by it (this also helps explain why social organisms that form under capitalism are particularly bad in contributing to existing hegemonic structures, over and above simple self-interested defense of the existing economic structure. They also have to speak the *language* of that structure, and the language of capitalism is fundamentally hegemonic - the dollar is king)

Isaiah G

RE: identifying with work I work in education, and I suspect the idea of a "math person" might be analogous to "science identity" - we all know people in our lives who emphatically identify as "NOT a math person", which is more an indictment of how math is taught (rote memorization and procedure) than of one's ability to think mathematically. I could imagine a world where lots of students don't identify as "science people", where the way the work is done drives them away from ever doing the work at all, and I could see the introduction of a new frame of identity in the work as valuable to counteract that. If one believes they can do the work, does the work, and still feels that dissatisfaction, I think it's often because we're alienated from the products and use value of our work, and we try to replace that with recognition by the system that alienates. I worked as an engineer for years but didn't identify as one because I wasn't actually designing or building the parts I "owned"; even my IP like patents was owned by the company. I felt more like an engineer when I built robot kits at home than when I was actually working as an engineer. In lieu of "owning" the products of my work I felt fulfilled in my job when I got recognized by the company, and companies recognize the way the work is done as much as, or more than, the quality of actual work products—"the way the work is done" includes work done loudly regardless of quality, work performed by someone with a certain title, work performed particularly urgently (my current company shouts out people for fighting fires constantly, but never good work that prevents the fire), etc etc. I haven't been in academia for years but I remember exactly two classes fondly from my entire undergrad career, and they were the ones where I actually got to have an idea and build it myself. I think the problem in identifying with our work is when we skip over the more pragmatic definition of that identity—CJ would say "the difference between someone who does something and someone who doesn't do something is whether they do that thing"—toward the capitalist definition of that identity, where you only are someone if the institutions that profit from your work recognize you for doing it. If you can actually witness the use of the thing you work on, and use your own thoughts to do that work, I suspect it becomes much less cognitively dissonant to identify with that work

AlexTheTutor

The “Adaptive School” book is great! On chapter 7, it explains the “5Cs for Being a Good Facilitator”: Clarity, Consciousness, Competence, Confidence, Credibility. I always recommend anyone getting into education to make their own outline/flowchart of it (or any other pedagogical framework). I’ll quickly share some other books/models I’ve borrowed when teaching physics/science at the university level. 1) 5E Model: Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate, Evaluate. This is a classic model and sets a strong tone for the teaching/learning experience. I’m sure there are books/videos to explain more. The model can be adapted when teaching science in a group or one-on-one. 2) “What The Best College Teachers Do” (2004) by Ken Bain. This is a great place to start to get general ideas about what works and what doesn’t. It’s based on research. Even if you’re not a college teacher, you can still get a lot out of it. Some advice may seem basic, but it’s honestly the basics that many professors get so-very wrong. It often applies the 5E Model too. 3) “Chicago Guide to College Science Teaching” (2020) by Terry McGlynn. This is more geared towards actual professors/adjuncts who teach actual science courses. It goes over how to make a syllabus and etc. For me, it’s still good so I when I ask students to see their syllabi, I can look at it with a more technical eye. 4) “Ambitious Science Teaching” (2018). This is more for teaching grade school science. Why even read it for teaching college? Too many professors have NO IDEA about how science is taught at the grade school level. It’s nice to have a global educational Consciousness, (one of the Cs in the 5C model) Anyway, moving on: How attached should one’s identity be towards their career? There was a time in my life that people simply called me “Tutor”, like that was the name everyone gave to me. But, I think how attached one can be has to do with Ego and Balance. When I was learning science, math, and logic, I learned the skill of ‘assume whatever you want, but always try to prove yourself wrong’, and by doing that you will figure out the truth. So, for me in order to achieve and maintain Balance, remove the Ego, otherwise I would have wasted a lot of time being like, “wait, I thought I was right, I’m right, so what’s going on? Now I’m upset, ugh.” Michael Jordan: Stop it, Get some Help. Next question: Anything to apply to more technical education context? Well… this is where I may lose everyone, maybe, let’s see. “Teaching to Transgress” was published in 1994 when “Different World” (historically black college sitcom) was still on TV and very popular. I bet in 1994 a lot of people of color were inspired to go to college because of that sitcom, and once there some read this book, and they felt heard and understood. That’s cool, yay. Today, It’s 2025. Story 1: a few teachers I know have quit teaching due to Admin telling teachers to let kids lead the class and speak about experiences, instead of the expert to guide discussion, effectively taking autonomy away from teacher (disrespectful according to those teachers). In theory, it sounds nice to let everyone have a voice, but in practice, it rarely works, and should only be used at special times. It works here because we all take our own time to read and reply, and me replying now doesn’t take away from anyone else replying. So, this bookclub is wonderful, but… Story 2: Having a bookclub requires reading books, I never thought I would be asked to work with medical students, and create flow charts, just because some medical students literally have never developed the habit of reading any books. Ever. Yes, it is a thing. A new thing. Not all, but maybe a few out of 100 med students will fail an exam and have to redo, they’ll find a tutor, and figure out how to study. One day, I recited cardiology concepts as if I were a cardiologist (student’s words, not mine), the med student was like, “how are you doing this??”, to which I was just like, “if everyone actually read and studied from textbooks, I wouldn’t have any students” (paraphrasing), anyway the med student is obviously motivated, that’s not the issue, the modern school system too often no longer teaches, anything, period: Class behavior too poor, parents siding with their kids, Admin pressuring teachers. Example: Many English teachers in grade school are asked NOT to read novels with students, instead focus on reading excerpts to prep for standardized exams. Luckily, this med student was someone I’ve worked with for a few years, so going back to the 5Cs, when I said, “just read”, I earned Credibility, and the med student listened. I don’t have a medical degree or even teaching degree, and there are definitely 1000s of undergraduate freshman who I DON’T have credibility with. I bring this up, because the med student was only UNWILLING to read. It is common now for undergraduates to be both UNWILLING and UNABLE to read for comprehension (sounding out words and letters is not reading). Stories 3 to 100: Before pandemic, this would never happen, but now many undergraduates who I just met NEVER listen to the same advice, instead they cite apps, social media knows more than educators, right? Credibility speaks to prestige, and when students being on apps for 6 hours plus each day, “you don’t have prestige”. Most undergraduates I work with now are 25 plus and moms, they are a reason to study, and they will listen to you. But, for the everyone else, it is common for students to band together, complain, victim blame, give adjuncts low ratings, and make them change the exam format, lowering standards. Adjunct teachers being over with it all will sometimes submit HW questions for students, just ask, or you can just research answers during an exam, and get an A, and etc The point being: “Teaching to Transgress” nice book, but in terms of "technical" application... the educational environment is still wonderful in some places, but in many other places, it’s barren due to a different kind of climate change. Students develop habits “can I go to the bathroom” “we’ll never use math” “my parents are too busy to actively care, so I’m just going to wait to graduate HS to change anything about myself” and so on, often when I work with academically neglected middle school or HS students, it’s about breaking bad habits, and developing positive ones, one habit to break is actually get them to a place where instead of them always complaining and sharing opinions, that they are eager to ask questions and eager to listen to those answers, and that requires building trust. So, to close this long response (apologies for that), I would like to add one more C: Care… Hooks definitely writes as someone who cares, it's not a technical skill, just a human skill, students are human beings, and school systems are often dehumanizing them, but if you care when no one else seems to care, that can mean everything to them, and that can be enough for them to figure out the rest

Mingo

I was entranced by this conversation. But one thing that kept me wondering was the part about what to do when things don't go according to plan. I know I have to struggle with that whenever I get the chance to teach because then I have to stop myself from Falling down an imposter syndrome spiral. And I was curious if that is a thing that gets better when you're regularly teaching and have to deal with this on a regular basis or if that's just me...? And another thing I was confused about was how applicable all of this is for different age groups. To me, it really seems like that approach is tailored not only to the humanities but also to late teens and twenty-somethings

Raphaël Royer

"There has to be a recognition of the way the failing economy is taking jobs. There has to be more of an emphasis on job-sharing and job-switching in the interest of creating an environment where engaged teaching can be sustained." we could add to the emphasis on job-sharing and job-switching, an emphasis on of good paying part time jobs, as well as programs to encourage disabled people who wants to work. As a personal example, I cannot work full time, but would like to still work, thing is, I can't make more then 100$/month, anything over that will be taken out of my disability check... Anyway, not on topic but kind of. 😅

Jacques Vincelette

Attachment to career/discipline, engineers Vs scientists, remains fundamental drama in the Canadian nuclear research indusrty. 2025-2026 coporate objectives define 'Leadership' as 'fostering a culture of compliance'. This sets engineers squarely on top. We invite scientists to submit lucrative ideas and engineers run the options study for funding in line with project protocols. I have been silenced as signing and dancing token métis, never explicitly as engineer. Calling out streaking nudity engenders discomfort (Bill C-65 in reaction to the me-too movement). We maintain modesty by adjusting camera angles. When everything settles, we sink neck deep into post-modernism, with the odd winking eye or strawberry tongue sticking out.

schlltchrn

A late reply, but, that is SUCH an interesting point, about ownership of your work. I recently had a paper published, and I mean it has my name on it, and I worked on it, and it is a paper that I published. But because of the stress and pressure from the university, and the whole academia really, that I HAVE TO PUBLISH NOW, and it needs to be a certain way, it feels less mine and more like something I performed for "the boss". On the other hand that same week I managed to fix my coffee machine which included changing some piping and rewiring some stuff, and I was so proud, that for a week I could identify more with being a coffee machine service person than with being a scientist.

Hari Sood

I am a month late (after busting a gut to be on time for chapter 9 😭) so won't go too long but some quick thoughts! > i wonder if any of y’all have thoughts on this idea of attachment to career/discipline being counterproductive (or not?) I have worked with people who it feels really associate their identity with their work, and I have only ever found it counterproductive - once your ideas, outputs and ways of working become your identity, it is very hard to separate the operational from the personal - ideas can't easily be discussed or explored on merit, because there is personal value associated to them. Small issues can flare up into giant problems because of the safety associated to them. I personally think capitalism and professionalism is inherently impersonal and disembodying, and so it NECESSITATES a separation. I don't deny that a lot of people do work they are passionate about, but I doubt anyone's personal identity incorporates employment law, tax deductions, postage and packaging, Zoom... the working world is set up at its core to be impersonal, whilst you can find meaning in it, for me a job should always have its limitations for self expression - how can we challenge capitalism if we actually find our identity within it? Also all the embodiment stuff was really cool and makes me think about the issues of values from a personal point of view vs through a societal gaze - a lot of this embodiment work feels really critical for education, but if the societal gaze doesn't value it, and the gaze is always looking over your shoulder, it takes a hell of a lot of courage to pursue it - which makes these folk so inspirational!

Hari Sood

Love your thoughts as always AJ! > I don't know the best way to walk that line of correcting without devaluing. I wonder if this is just a limitation of classroom settings as they currently are - many peers, one teacher - public speaking when offering an answer. I imagine if we had e.g. many students, many teachers, small groups exploring different things, if you as a student wanted to suggest something very different, it would become a safer space to suggest it and explore together. Also j things like time limitations, if education was truly about exploring with no end goal in mind it would be easier to make space for all kinds of pathways. But at the end of the day atm a teacher needs to prepare their students to get grades as per the mark scheme, and so can't allow too much space to stray from the tracks The more I read, the more I feel we need a school abolition movement!

Hari Sood

Love both your thoughts! It makes me think about how impersonal commodification is, as opposed to idk functional/purpose driven work - for it be to personal to me, I want to be able to see the purpose/meaning of what I am doing, and identify with it, as an end. However under capitalism this isn't the end, the end if commodification, i.e. creating or shaping of this meaning in such as way as to be able to sell it later. This step is ALWAYS depersonalising, and I guess true of EVERY paid job under capitalism (even public sector jobs are 'selling' the service as worth the cost of employing the person). So I guess no job that is paid can ever be inherently personal, unless I guess capitalism literally runs through your veins??

Hari Sood

> it really seems like that approach is tailored not only to the humanities but also to late teens and twenty-somethings I guess in converging both of these to think about science education for primary students - if I have a very young student who is struggling with some scientific concepts, perhaps just expressing 'it just doesn't make sense to me', a really good education system would allow space for them to express what doesn't make sense, what makes more sense, and why - perhaps through this fundamentally different basic understandings of scientific concepts would emerge, which would definitely teach me something as a teacher! So I think it can be applied wherever, if the world would just allow it to be!

Hari Sood

This is mb where UBI needs to replace conditional welfare systems!!

AJ Biffl

Yeah I think you're right! I hadn't made that connection between the pressure of public speaking and the tensions I mentioned. And in my experience it has ABSOLUTELY been the case that when the pressure is off and I'm walking around to different tables while they're all working on their own things, ideas and questions flow much more freely.

AJ Biffl

I really like this idea of capitalism as impersonal, as like you are supposed to generate value and then ship it off to someone else and your only return is whatever wage (very much akin to Marx's idea of alienation). But this new framing as "impersonal" has a very practical, tangible aspect that I like a lot - you need to look outside of class society for the personal: for identity, for connection, for community. Also for sure resonate with the point about valuation, and about how absolutely yes inspirational hooks and Scapp are