Teaching to Transgress - Chapter 10: Building a Teaching Community (A Dialogue) (Patreon)
Content
I think the last line of this chaptered distilled the whole thing pretty well:
“This is one of the tragedies in education today. We have a lot of people who don’t recognize that being a teacher is being with people.”
bars
When I saw that this chapter was going to be another dialogue (but this time with an actual other person with a completely distinct perspective and not just hooks’ alter egos), I anticipated that my takeaways would be on the nature of their dialogue in some way, but honestly, the way they build off each other in conversation is so seamless and they both are so insightful and experienced that I was fully caught up in the contents of the conversation and all I have to share is a list of topics they hit on that resonated with me in some way. Would be interested to hear if others had takeaways about the collaboration itself though
~~~~~~~~~~
One of the first things they talk about is their respective relationships to their profession, and the identity as educators:
“I’ve benefited a lot from not being attached to myself as an academic or professor. It’s made me willing to be critical of my own pedagogy and to accept criticism from my students and other people without feeling that to question how I teach is somehow to question my right to exist on the planet.”
So there’s this concept in STEM ed literature of ‘science identity’, and it’s usually discussed in the context of the experiences of minoritized students in whatever STEM field and either feeling or not feeling a sense of belonging to their discipline (Carlone and Johnson 2007 is the seminal paper if you’re interested). Tldr, having strong ‘science identity’ leads to good outcomes, so our goal as educators should be to build up students’ science identity. I have a take on this idea that I will probably make a video about at sometime that’s basically: I think we should explore divesting from this idea of science identity and encourage a way of learning and doing science that doesn’t encourage making success in it the core of one’s self worth (which I don’t think this literature necessarily intends, but I do think that’s often an outcome of this stance). I think hooks’ attitude towards her professional gets at the same argument on science identity I’m still noodling on—attachment to a job is a central part of one's identity can actually get in the way of doing it well, because it’s harder to question how you’re doing it if that also means questioning your fundamental value as a human being. Idk if this is getting too far away from the actual material at hand, but i wonder if any of y’all have thoughts on this idea of attachment to career/discipline being counterproductive (or not?) How much do you identify with what you study/do for work? Do you feel like that identification (or lack thereof) serves you or hinders you?
~~~~~~~~~~
I really love the part of the conversation that was challenging mind/body dualism and drawing out the relations between the body, power, and epistemology. I’m just gonna share some notable lines without any commentary:
“The person who is the most powerful has the privilege of denying their body.”
“The traditional notion of being in the classroom is a teacher behind a desk or standing at the front, immobilized. In a weird way that recalls the firm, immobilized body of knowledge as part of the immutability of truth itself.”
“I remember in my early teaching days that when I first tried to move out beyond the desk, I felt really nervous. I remember thinking, ‘This is really about power’”
“The erasure of the body encourages us to think that we are listening to neutral, objective facts, facts that are not particular to who is sharing the information.”
“Recognition of [the conditions of one’s life, basically] must be suspended; and the rationale for this erasure is the logic which says, “What we do here is science, what we do here is objective history.”
~~~~~~~~~~
I know there's been some discussion over the weeks about how any of what we’re reading in this book translates to a STEM/physics classroom, and there were actually several points in this chapter that felt very directly transferable. Here’s one:
“Many professors who are critical of the inclusion of confessional narrative in the classroom or of digressive discussions, where students are doing a lot of the talking, are critical because they lack the skill needed to facilitate dialogue. Once the space for dialogue is open in the classroom, that moment must be orchestrated so that you don’t get bogged down with people who are unable to relate experience to the academic subject matter.”
So idk about confessional narrative, but digressive discussion in general can be extremely fruitful things in science classes—a well guided tangent can be a fantastic learning opportunity to for example, add context to or build intuition for whatever the topic at hand is. However, I’ve also been in many a physics class where most of the digression takes the form of one guy who wastes at least a few minutes of every lecture to ‘ask a question’ that’s mostly just him rambling about some barely related obscure physics thing he’s read that contributes absolutely nothing the the conversation. I used to attribute these annoyances mostly to the students (who like, yeah part of its on them obviously), but more recently I’ve had experiences seeing physics teachers who are actually competent at facilitation enough to gracefully stop someone who wants to hear themselves talk (and even draw out engagement from students who don’t talk as much), and feel like the conversation facilitation skills hooks refers to here is actually a very straightforward tangible skillset an educator can learn to help move away from an overly authoritarian, purely lecture based teaching mode without dissolving into chaos. Personally I’ve been using the book “The Adaptive School: a Sourcebook for Developing Collaborative Groups” as a reference for some work I’m doing facilitating students recently, so that’s a thing maybe to check out if you’re interested in such things.
This post is already very long so I won’t get into the other examples I noticed of practical pedagogy things, but I’m curious if anyone else caught things that they could apply to more technical education contexts?