Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Alright, we're experimenting with a different format this week (and probably also next week, which is the last chapter for this book) where I don't begin the discussion with my own perspectives, and engage with some of the comments instead.

Excited to hear y'alls thoughts, this was a very interesting chapter!

Comments

AlexTheTutor

One general principle in elementary education: children are not ready to learn until and unless love comes from home. Even if a child comes from a home of love, there can be other external issues weighing on the child (or adult). Thus, teaching can involve acts of love. If anyone has a chance to visit Brasilia, there is a wonderful bookstore in Asa Norte called Sebinho, and inside this bookstore, there are many great books, especially if you’re into Brazilian culture and literature, it even has a small café to serve coffee and desserts, anyway, it also has a room to sell merch, there is a shirt with a quote by Paulo Freire… “eu nunca poderia pensar em educação sem amor. É por isso que eu me considero um educador: acima de tudo porque eu sinto amor.” In other words… “I never could think of education without love. It is for this that I consider myself an educator: above all because I feel love.” Education is a social activity, and love is a powerful force that has the potential to connect us, so that it may transform us, in order to give meaning to life, and with this new perspective of life allows us to move forward with clarity: Education is a composition of matrices E = MTCLx

schlltchrn

I think I audibly gasped at multiple points in this chapter haha I see both things she is trying to convey, about bodies, and then about passion. Firstly, it is not possible to turn off any of those, and therefore it can not be advantageous to ignore them. But it can also be useful and beautiful and helpful to have your body and passion with you in the classroom. ~However~, considering the intensity of the feelings that arise there, and the power imbalances (!), there is an immense amount of responsibility included. I think she did not really discuss this, and I guess this is why I was shocked. Nobody is arguing anything about two students falling in love, or feeling sexual attraction, or forming a "special bond", but teachers? We live in a society silly, and classrooms are (sadly) not flat hierarchy anarchist situations, but institutions that have a very clear order of things. Now, this does not mean that there is no space for body and love and desire of any kind, but being very SUPER extra careful with it as a teacher is so very important. Resonating with some people in the class is of course normal, but also it is not just capitalism-bad, why this is something that bothers other students. I think that teachers have the responsibility to challenge these bonds and expand their love and, even more importantly, attention to others. Sure, free love for all, and also there is scarcity in the classroom. Also, it is all very public, so it is not so simple to discuss mutual feelings or lack of. Maybe my passion for the subject and the topic can be misinterpreted by the professor as our personal special bond, and like... mutual passion is a kind of bond, and a very nice thing. However, extra attention from the teacher can feel very uncomfortable. But this is because of the power imbalance and literal fear I feel in such situation. And there is no space for the student to express this, again, because of the power imbalance and how public this is, but requesting a private conversation can be even more uncomfortable (or in some cases dangerous). So... it is the teachers' responsibility to treat this bond, which only may be mutual, with care. This is all without talking about sexual attraction. There is so so so much sexual harassment in STEM, as a woman, I do NOT want to know anything about my teacher's thoughts on what a hottie I am. It is fine, we are all human, just ignore it, and make me not ever notice, ever. Back to love and passion, in high school, we had a very young choir conductor, and we were all maybe 7 years apart. My impression was always that we had a very strong and beautiful friendship too, and that he was generally a positive figure for us. Especially as a man, being openly passionate and very vulnerable, showing a huge spectrum of emotions, was valuable as a counter macho figure. All good. But this also escalated, of course. My generation, about 10 or 15 singers, was finishing high school and leaving, and the poor guy felt literally abandoned by his friends. He started being mean to us, very stroct and without much patience and we felt confused and perplexed. But because of the power imbalance and the public space situation, could not talk it through, so it all lasted much longer than it should have. In the end he figured it out himself, there were tears, there were hugs, it was all very emotional. Now, I also learned that this was a shitty and confusing situation to be in for singers who were not included, and that they did feel less than, because of the lack of attention they were getting from him through this emotional turmoil. I understand the humanity of the situation, still love the man, but I do think he was just very young and inexperienced. He really needed to treat this bond with more responsibility.

AJ Biffl

This chapter made me feel things! The student "who would discover the ground of their being," and "the mysterious force that moves birds to migrate or dandelions to spring" all strummed some heart strings. I've recently been trying to get a better understanding of my non-rational side (Feyerabend has been rubbing off on me), all those aspects of human experience that don't follow deliberate reasoning or justification but just happen naturally like how your eyes wander when you look at a landscape or how you take a deep breath when you walk into fresh air. The description of eros as sort of this seat of passion, this natural force that churns up sublime purpose, something wailing, singing, burning deep inside, I love this. There are some things we do not because of careful reasoning or social pressures but because somewhere deep in our bodies there is a force propelling us toward it. "Where did we learn it, that talent for insatiability?" (Margaret Atwood, Handmaid's Tale) ~~~~ As far as applying this to pedagogy, I resonated a lot with what hooks talks about towards the end, about how bringing passion into the classroom is related to self-actualization, that showing or demonstrating or opening the door to the connections your students can have with the world, you have to know those connections are there yourself, you have to be ready to dive in to those pools.

AJ Biffl

I think that's a SUPER important point about the power disparity in the classroom! Professors need to be really careful because they're not only responding to the relationships they're forming with students, but they control how those relationships are shaped purely by virtue of being in a position of power in the classroom. And like, the entire reason it's almost universally banned to have romantic relationships between teacher/student is because of how implicitly coercive the power disparity can be. I wonder how hooks would respond to concerns about abuse of power in trying to bring passion and eros into the classroom. Because usually you need to be careful and deliberate about your actions to make sure there is no abuse of power, but that's specifically NOT how eros/passion works, which is more flying by the seat of your pants. So how do you balance the sort of untethered, natural force that is passion with the care and thoughtfulness needed to avoid abusing power? Are thoughtfulness and passion mutually exclusive?

Jacques Vincelette

Chapter 13 resonates well with Audre Lorde's: 'Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power'. I shared her perspective at work on valentined's day 2024, Reprimand was harhs and I lost the privilege of mass-email; but I have since noticed poets propping up.

Tom Cassidy

I also thought of Audre Lorde! As I recall, she talks about the erotic as a force which can fill ones being , not simply something that is focused on the sexual. But I think we need to talk about how erotic often enters the classroom. In college and later in grad school, certain male professors simply took it as a given that relations with their female students were somehow a professional perk, Young women who were receptive were granted access to professional opportunities,and even though I don't believe any such couplings were simple quid pro quo, its and abuse of power, and the effect on the teaching environment was corrosive. I don't see this as an embrace of the spirit of the erotic; I think it happens (happened?) exactly because the erotic is constrained. It becomes a perk of privilege! Don't get me wrong. I am all for student/faculty collaboration and friendship, but the widespread abuse of the power imbalance is (or was) a real problem. I THINK federal title IX policies have changed this somewhat.

schlltchrn

Great question ! My impression, reading the essays, is that a lot she has to say is idealist, and this is one of the main reasons I am enjoying the book so much! It really isn't a negative critique. I strongly believe that having a lively and firm idealist side is radical and necessary, and letting it turn to cynicism is what is actually naive. And I think this is why she was, and is, such a huge literary figure, and that I want to learn from her. She also at moments in the book kind of reminds herself, "but of course... we live in an imperfect society, so this is what we do", which I also found endearing. And that didn't really happen in this chapter. Maybe because it was written with so much passion :) Of course, this is all just my personal impression. I don't think that thoughtfulness is exclusive to passion, that it is not either/or and not even a dance of the two, but that it is possible they could be one. But also I have no idea how to practically move toward seamless integration of the both.

schlltchrn

I'd just add to confirm that it _is_ very much a thing of the present that does not seem to leave. Also, I love your thoughts on it, it tickles the imagination to think how true embracing of the erotic can constrain the power abuse.

AlexTheTutor

Your view is interesting, I didn't even think of the obvious sexual attraction and etc. For me as an educator, I function as a "tutor", so I have no power to give anyone a grade. Even though I don't have any institutional rules placed on me, I follow a moral guideline of for example "dating students can jeopodize their future, so, NO, no exceptions" and that's honestly enough for me. I always tell students that THEY are the ones with the power. I am just here to be a little catalysts and guide them. BUT... (deleting "juicy" but real shocking stories of other professors and students)... yeah... I wish there were more cool role models to show others proper ethical behavior, so it would be a naturally thing NOT to... you know (XX + XY + Power Dynamic yields bad consequences), like... well I know this professor who hosts wholesome board game nights, he's very nice

Jacques Vincelette

The commodification of beauty flips it to insatiable porn. Hence Erykah Badu's "Don't feed me yours for your food does not endure". More to beauty than canabalism.

phil e the theyby

I love this chapter and how conflicted it made me feel. I’m a big advocate for the more expansive view of the erotic, and the quote on page 195 does a really nice job expressing why. And I find the idea that professors oversexualize their students specifically BECAUSE of how the erotic is repressed super compelling. At the same time, I think there is a very real phenomenon of people (particularly men) who are in touch with the erotic longing but are radically unaware of the power dynamics that operate in their interactions. I think any project to liberate the erotic (which I do think is important) has to be REALLY fucking grounded in recognizing and honoring how power operates. I don’t think avoidance of the topic of erotic drive OR power is the right solution, but I don’t think I came away from this chapter having a very clear sense of what the right solution might be, or even what elements it would HAVE that would facilitate the process. I Did Not Like this quote: “I asked students once, ‘Why do you feel that the regard I extend to a particular student cannot also be extended to each of you? Why do you think there is not enough love or care to go around?’ To answer these questions they had to think deeply about the society we live in, how we are taught to compete with one another.” (198-199) While I absolutely agree that capitalism promotes viewing other humans as competition, this is FAR from the only factor that would influence students’ reaction. Looking from a particular student’s lens, if they haven’t experienced being really loved and valued by others, and they see how you love and value another student, it doesn’t particularly matter to them that you could hypothetically show that love and care. If they’ve only experienced that love and care in a general sense (i.e. the way you convey it to other students), and then they see how you show UNIQUE, particular care for another student, it makes sense that they’d wonder why that student has unique value. I usually don’t have such strong critical reactions, and I know it’s because this taps into my personal hurt. As someone who’s frequently seen as having good ideas and a lot to contribute but is rarely treated as someone people want to have close personal relationships with, I’ve spent a lot of time trying to sort out how I’m viewed relative to other people. I think more critically-focused classrooms are one of the easier areas for me to “earn affection,” because I can engage critically with ideas from an open and compassionate perspective. But I know that people who struggle with these kinds of dialogues would find it much harder to elicit that “love and care” response from the professor, and those students would have very valid reasons to feel that they’re not as valuable, especially if they haven’t felt loved and valued in their personal lives.

Hari Sood

Dropping in a month late with 2 thoughts: 1) "I am a black woman...' quote from her student -> so beautiful, and such a lesson for life on not being able to change the past but changing the future! 2) love as competitive -> NO SPOILERS (Artist's Way focus area coming up) but one of the lessons I've really trying to be working on is thinking abundantly rather than scarcely as much as possible - especially in terms of love, intimacy and connection. Trying not to think 'I have some good things around me, I should SECURE THEM and MAKE THEM MINE while I have the chance', rather 'man I'm so grateful for the connections I have, and am excited by how many more I will be able to form in many different and wonderful ways across my life, living harmoniously with them whilst allowing the agency of others to also flow with them' or smth

Hari Sood

> I think any project to liberate the erotic (which I do think is important) has to be REALLY fucking grounded in recognizing and honoring how power operates Totally agree phil, and makes me think about how entangled the erotic has become with power in our current systems. Power as a way to self actualise has to be one of the worst lessons tacitly taught today! Also interested in your take on that para, mb there is something in like if the classroom is a shared, collective space, then the love in there, even if directed TOWARDS a particular student, is still shared and be collectively held (amongst other things)

Hari Sood

I read a book last year with an essay that talks specifically about the issue of sex in teaching settings, covering a lot of similar points that you're bringing up Lidija! The big takewaway I remember is basically what you are saying - the power dynamic is there (at least in the education systems we have now), and when it is so stark, there can be massive problem with 'normalising' these kind of things. I guess on the flip side, if we create this truly equal classroom, where teachers/students are equal participants in the education journey, as hooks is idealising, these issues become less problematic, as there is less power difference? (Although I would say not none, so still need to be careful...) Book is here: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/56347680-the-right-to-sex :)

phil e the theyby

I imagine that’s probably the ideal that bell hooks is working towards, which I personally really like as an ideal. For me, it just read as “show your love openly and freely and that ideal will come to life,” which I don’t think is necessarily true. I think you’ll always have people who you and most people in the group aren’t as drawn to because of elements of their presentation outside of their control (including things like restricted affect, which you often see in autistic folks and often makes neurotypical folks feel uncomfortable), and the fact that other people get particular recognition while they do not will lead them to feel like that love towards a particular student is certainly NOT for them.