Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“When I first entered university settings I felt estranged from this new environment. Like most of my peers and professors, I initially believed those feelings were there because of differences in racial and cultural background. However, as time passed it was more evident that this estrangement was in part a reflection of class difference. At Stanford, I was often asked if I was there on scholarship. Underlying this question was the implication that receiving financial aid “diminished” one in some way.”

I don’t think I ever really felt othered on the basis of class until graduate school—astronomy runs extremely bougie and my school was very prestigious, so it was really the first time in my life I had been around people with such a clearly distinct class background and culture. I was honestly shocked by the obvious expectation that we all came from money—it wasn’t just cultural, (though that was certainly a jarring part of it) there was also really egregious material assumptions like faculty expecting their students to not work a second job, or asking students to front thousands of dollars for required things that would be reimbursed eventually. I didn’t really have the language to articulate this dynamic at the time, so for me this chapter was very much one of those times hooks described where theory can be healing.


This chapter also got me thinking in a kind of meta-way about this book club. It’s not exactly the same as class, but there is a distinct financial asymmetry to my vs y’alls participation in this learning space, on top of the fact that I’m very much the one calling the shots. I’m considering switching up the format a bit, but i want to ask ppl who are participating what would be more valuable to them. Basically, I’m wondering if I should decenter my own voice in a big way by not starting each reading with my own thoughts, and instead providing a more neutral space for you all to start conversations, and then I engage with comments the way you do with eachother instead of being like, the top down opinion haver. I think I defaulted to what I’m doing now partly because of a central lecturer being an automatic model for teaching in my head on some level, but also because I feel the need to ‘give value’ to people who participate here, I guess in the form of writing out my thoughts and opinions on each chapter. But maybe the value I’m giving is the container for discussion and not my take, you know? And also I don’t always have an insightful take on every single reading we do, so it can feel contrived at times. I don’t know, let me know what you think if you have an opinion, not making any promises but I’m curious how you would like this format (meaning, this context and not shifting to discord or zoom or something) of book club organized.

Comments

Justin Wells

I’m not part of the book club but enjoy reading what you have to think on things as well as the quoted passages. I’ve sometimes read the comments others have put but frequently I’ve come past these posts before others have written. That said, I’m clearly gleaning understanding from others and not putting in the time myself and perhaps that’s not what is necessary for what you’re trying to achieve. I’m existing as the bank that the knowledge is deposited in (as Freire would put it) and perhaps forcing me to engage in a different way would change my view on books that you’re reading in book club. That said, I don’t have the time to read all the books in book club and would still be reading the thoughts of others to come to my conclusions. It’s a tricky thing either direction but I won’t say no to what you’re doing now. For my part my thought might be for you to post the discussion first then come in afterwards with a new post about your thoughts on the chapter and a second discussion would be able to form, but that might be a lot of work and I’m not sure if that’s going to function like I’m thinking it will

Jacques Vincelette

I appreciate your lead; and your vulnerability when you pull back to recuperate.

phil e the theyby

This chapter, along with the previous one (which I'll go back and comment on shortly) absolutely SANG to me. What they have to say is so fucking important that I think we should be looking at them in EVERY area of our lives where we want to hear from diverse voices, not just school. Hot quotes time! "Professors cannot empower students to embrace diversities of experience, standpoint, behavior, or style if our training has disempowered us, socialized us to cope effectively only with a single mode of interaction based on middle-class values." (187) We silence the parts of ourselves that speak from any voice other than the White middle class. Anyone who struggles to speak in that voice (which can obviously come down to social class as discussed here, or language, ethnicity, and race as discussed in chapter 11, but it can also include neurodivergence) is effectively silenced. Even a voice that's too "feminine-coded" can be devalued. I remember my initial reaction to watching Kathrin's videos on YouTube being the difficulty I had with her speaking with a soft, feminine voice, feeling that it wasn't "captivating" enough. But she does that intentionally to highlight how vocal qualities of softness are devalued. I had to train myself to recognize that I was deeply invested in what she was saying and it was indeed compelling, but I had to undo the socialization that told me that type of voice isn't interesting or engaging enough. "Fearful that I might abuse power, I falsely pretended that no power difference existed between students and myself." (also 187) This is SUCH an easy trap to fall into. It's critically important to use any position of power and authority to name and highlight how that power is operating, and to intentionally disrupt it. I initially tried to do this by just speaking in a much more natural but "unprofessional" way (swearing is a big part of that), hoping it would invite others to speak from their more authentic voices. But I think it did the opposite, because my position of power (especially when combined with my Whiteness) could have come across as me essentially flaunting that I didn't have to play by the rules of professionalism that other people do. So now I'm much more mindful of the specific ways I disrupt norms of communication, and I'm explicit about my power and positionality. When I'm meeting with trainees as their individual supervisor, I absolutely curse all the time, take my shoes off, and sit sprawled across the chair. But I tell them WHY I'm doing that and am consistently supporting them in drawing out their own voice. Because of my own positions of privilege I don't want to speak to this too much in general cases, but I did want to highlight this: "Sometimes students who want professors to grapple with class differences often simply desire that individuals from less materially privileged backgrounds be given center stage so that an inversion of hierarchical structures takes place, not a disruption." (188) I can't speak to how this process operates for marginalized identities I don't hold. But in speaking to the area I can speak from (as a queer person) I can say that, when it comes to queer identity and discussions about it, I don't want to only be hearing queer voices. I want to hear from cishet people who are grappling with the impact of patriarchy and the gender binary on their OWN lives and experiences. I think all angles of the discussion are critically important, because privilege and oppression are intimately connected, and I think privilege does its own psychic harm that needs to be really reckoned with if we want to dismantle oppressive systems. I host a supportive space for queer students at the university I work at. It's very popular and well-attended. When some of the executive orders came down, we needed to change some of the marketing around it to make sure that it was clear that any students could attend. I discussed it with my colleagues, and we all agreed that, while we don't want hecklers, the space is ABSOLUTELY open to students regardless of sexuality and gender identity. Not only because often "straight people who are curious about queer things" often just end up being queer people a few years later, but because learning, understanding, and solidarity across difference is the only way to change anything for the better. Again, to me, this was one of the most pivotal chapters in the book. It speaks to the critical importance of us really examining the ways we're inviting and discouraging different voices, and shaping our spaces to uplift everyone.

phil e the theyby

Separate post for Dr. Fatima's questions about book club! First off, these are really fucking good questions that I haven't thought of. I know that, for myself, I'm very comfortable speaking from my own perspective, and I appreciate Dr. Fatima's thoughts (and a lot of her discussion questions are SUPER good, which can help me go somewhere when I'm not sure what to say (some of these chapters aren't super long, for example, or are a little narrow in what they talk about compared to some other books). But I think for people who are less confident in their voice and perspective, it may feel intimidating to post. I think that a small part of that pie chart may be Dr. Fatima's posts, but I think that some of it might be what a typical book club post looks like here. The posts here tend to be VERY long and detailed (and thoughtful as well; I thoroughly enjoy them!) in ways that I imagine could feel quite daunting to someone who isn't sure if what they have to say is of much value. I think this is something that can sometimes just change organically over time if more people join the space and have the courage to make comments, especially if those are responded to positively (through comment replies from other people posting or, as much as I hate to say it, likes...yes, my brain does still feel reinforced by the little hearts, thank you very much). If anything, I think Dr. Fatima's posts probably help with people feeling more confident engaging, if only because she connects the book chapters to real life experiences which people can at least relate to their own life experiences. But that could also be seen as a negative if the goal is for the book club posts to have a dialogue between the text and life experience, rather than the text only being a jumping off point for talking about life experience. I think there are pros and cons to each. I like the current structure and approach, but am also totally open to experimenting with other formats and seeing how it feels. I will say that CJ started their book club with the format Dr. Fatima's describing here (their book club posts were just "I liked these quotes") and they engaged with the comments a fair amount, and now they mostly share their thoughts in the post itself and very rarely reply to the comments (similar to Dr. Fatima's current approach). So Dr. Fatima may want to run the "book club thoughts" by CJ if she hasn't. But personally, I only joined CJ's Patreon after they stepped back from so much engagement in the comments, so I can't compare the two experiences. I'm wondering if the old format of CJ replying to comments served as a sort of "reinforcement" that got some people more engaged with book club (although I KNOW that wouldn't have been CJ's intent because that's not their approach to parasociality at all) and, once there was a critical mass of more different kinds of voices/posts, the book club more naturally brought in different voices and wasn't as centered around CJ's thoughts even when they shared them at the start of each post. Basically, all of this is really hard to figure out! But I hope these thoughts have been helpful in some capacity.

AJ Biffl

I love this! A follow-up question about your experiences hosting this support space, have you found that there is disparity between the voices of marginalized vs "not" marginalized attendees? Aka, have you had to navigate what hooks mentioned about "distinction must be made between a shallow emphasis on coming to voice, which wrongly suggests there can be some democratization of voice wherein everyone's words will be given equal time and be seen as equally valuable... and the more complex recognition of the uniqueness of each voice" (pg 186)? If you have, how do you balance privileged voices being louder with letting others speak?

AJ Biffl

I wrote down so many quotes from this chapter. I think learning to subvert this ever-present bourgeois white culture is hugely important, but at the same time hugely difficult because it's SO ubiquitous. I recently had the thought that one of the jobs that "culture" has is that it's the thing that teaches people the rules of navigating the dominant power structures in their society. So people born in white/western cultures are taught the social expectations of entering white hegemonic spaces, and people who aren't have a literal culture shock when they get to higher levels of academia, business, whatever, where that culture is almost literally everywhere. This perception of "vulgar disruptions" hooks mentions (pg 178) is coming from people of different cultures literally never having been taught these unspoken expectations of conduct. I realize this may be super obvious to other people, but it's an aspect to privilege I'd never thought about before teaching.

AJ Biffl

As far as the book club format, I do like having the well-thought out discussion questions, and of course I think we're all here because we respect your voice and want to hear from you. That said, I also know sometimes I just sort of ignore the discussion questions entirely because I have thoughts and wanna puke them somewhere. Maybe you could have one discussion post where you share a specific discussion question/prompt, and then another more free-for-all post to share more general, unstructured stuff? The detriment of that is that it diverts attention and effort into keeping track of comments/threads on two different posts and frankly this format effectively does both those jobs (prompt and free-for-all) at once already

AlexTheTutor

HOOKS: “class is more than just a question of money” Yes true. In my experiences, it is very common for everyone to believe that money is the ONLY factor that determines social class and success and happiness: False. I consider 4 factors that determine “health”: Financial, Social, Emotional, Physical. Each are necessary, but none of them are sufficient by themselves. For example, we need physical health to enjoy life. But, if all we have is physical health, we will not enjoy that life (poor mental health). Another example: yes of course not having money can put stress on life, but (insert 100s of examples) wealthy parents “raising” emotionally neglected children who end up on drugs isn’t great for anyone. Yes, wealthy families have more resources to help drug addiction within the family, but (insert 100s of examples), there are many happy professional adults who came from poverty. There can be dozens of examples for 4 factors, but in general, I think of it as a math function: Let LS be a Life Success function whose inputs are f (finance), s (social), e (emotional), p (physical), and map onto a field of LS values. Then LS(f,s,e,p) has the property such that LS = 0 iff any of its inputs are zero, but then there is something to be said about acceptance, accepting our limitations in itself gives a great sense of peace (consider accepting poor physical health but finding peace by strengthening the emotions and growing the spirit). All of this is just to say: class and the success derived from it are so much more than just having money or material wealth.

AlexTheTutor

BOOK CLUB: For me, this is a great book club. I have tried many in-person book clubs, and it almost always devolves into 1) host talks most of the time, 2) talks about politics and feelings, turns into sharing egos instead of ideas, 3) no discussion of book, and 4) even on rare times when book is discussed, most have lack of basic understanding of text. So, that is not fun at all. I have run book clubs (especially during pandemic). It was always nice, and each group was a bit different: go around and share opinions with elementary school students, ask probing questions to middle school students, try to construct theories or arguments with HS students. I haven’t done book clubs with college students. But, for adult book clubs, most of them weren’t my students, so we would just summarize what happened and what we thought about it. I was a part of a book club with a lot of moms, and they are super chill: 2 to 5 sentence comments, smiles, enjoying the book, sharing recipes. For this book club: This is really great. You are doing great. We can all write mutually exclusive ideas (one person’s writing isn’t taking away time from others to share), while also engaging with one another. In terms of the options you were thinking about: Option A (only write opinion); Option B (only reply to comments); Option C (write opinion and reply to comments). Options A, B, C seem great. Whatever feels good for the book and chapter. I am guessing you are a lecturer of physics maybe? If the group discussion was about time symmetry implying energy conservation, I would stay quiet and listen. I would only want to hear from you and other PhD people at first. But, understanding, applying, and discussing sociology/pedagogy/etc (in my opinion) is far more difficult than astrophysics. It is wonderful and enrichening to share thoughtful opinions. Another option: Option D, just pose questions (especially if the text doesn’t resonate one week).

phil e the theyby

Great question! I think that really, within the spaces I (co)host, the main form of marginalization within the space (which somewhat but not entirely overlaps with broader social marginalization) involves people who just don’t feel comfortable talking in large groups. We generally have 15-30 people, and some folks are VERY comfortable speaking and being perceived, whereas it’s much harder for others. We actually started breaking up into four smaller groups specifically for this purpose, to create an environment where it’s more comfortable and natural for people who are more reserved to speak. It seems to help, but we don’t have a ton of data (we’ve only met four times in the current arrangement, and only once with small groups), so I’ll have to track and see how it develops! I think the topics, environment, and physical space all impact what steps you try to take to uplift typically marginalized voices.

AlexTheTutor

Also, since this chapter is about class circa 1994, some observations I need to share circa 2025: a few days ago, a trader bought 5854 contracts for the $5.00 Hertz call option at $1.18 per share, expiring on the 25th of April. Yesterday, HTZ rose by 56%, and today it’s already up 30%. Basically, some lucky trader bet $6 million that HTZ would go up to $5.00 when it hasn’t done that in a year, and there’s no reason to suspect any sudden jump. Who bets $6 million unless they knew for certain the price would jump? This lucky trader mysteriously won 10s of millions of $$$ overnight. Anyway, other observation: best friend who spent a decade to get PhD and took out loans, those loans are in forbearance due to DoE issues, but the interest on the loan will continue to grow, and best friend will need to pay more in the end. Also, the first students I worked with today, one of them had to work a 12-hour night shift and still came to see me early in the morning, the other had to wait for a family member to babysit her baby. They are hardworking honest people who try their best to calculate grams and moles in chemistry. All they want to do is have dignity with a respectable healthcare job. Talking about class: we live in 2 polar opposite worlds, and neither could possibly understand the other.

schlltchrn

It's also interesting what happens on the other side, from the perspective of the more financially privileged, or already assimilated people. The more "vulgar" person is sometimes ridiculed, but sometimes not, they just become the kind of endearing class clown, however still not taken seriously. There's kind of an infantilisation happening, as if the ~higher~ economical class is a development step that they need to ~grow up~ into through assimilation. It is also kind of a culture shock, because people who know how to embody the bougie academic code of conduct, don't know how to meaningfully interact with somebody of different class and dismiss them as childish in a way. Love your observation!

schlltchrn

I really appreciated hooks' approach to resist this class divide by making all students feel seen. During my time at undergraduate studies, I lived with half the money to what is considered poverty line where I live, and came from a generally less financially privileged culture. I think most of the time I felt truly invisible and isolated. Now that I'm moving in the direction of being in some kind of teaching role myself, I have literal daydreams about making marginalised students feel seen and respected by me, but also facilitating a space where it is hopefully more possible for them to feel seen and respected by the other students. It is so important! In my experience, which really was the opposite, I built up so much resentment towards the more privileged students and the lecturers and the whole institution, that I pulled away from the university as a whole and really finished 6 years of studies isolated from other physics students. I am still very insecure about the knowledge gaps that I have, just because I would never discuss the material with anyone else, and really just learn from the books. Now this is for another reason, and that is that universities as institutions and buildings, and not just teachers, really need to have this responsibility to facilitate spaces. Comfortable places for people to exchange their ideas and experiences, informally socialise, and can create a community in the framework of their studies. If the building itself does not have such spaces where one does not need to consume anything, students will resort to... coffee shops, where attendance costs "just a coffee" for most students but completely excludes more marginalised people, to whom one coffee may be their whole food budget for the day. I think this disparity and isolation for me personally was much harder than the financial hardship itself, and there are so many ways in which educational institutions fail people by assuming no responsibility.

schlltchrn

To Dr. Fatima: Regarding the format, I really like the prompts, especially because it is kind of clear that one can also have a tangent to any other topic or thought they've had, but also share experiences to the posed question, which makes it kind of more discussion-y than confessional-y - both are great, but it's a direction that the book club takes, if there are some overreaching questions. I am thoroughly enjoying this as it is, but maybe an idea is for you to give some main ideas, prompts or questions in the post, to kind of facilitate the discussion and give this value, and then take off the lecturer hat, and write your personal thoughts experiences etc., in the comment section? If you have any you want to share, of course. And interact with other comments however you feel like. The only difference is formatting, but then your thoughts on the chapter are at least not in a larger font then the other ones, and also you maybe feel less pressure to push for something *extra* insightful, if that is just not your vibe that week? I imagine it would be exhausting for me to feel like I need to excuse myself if I don't have something super smart to say each week.