"Teaching to Transgress" - Chapter 12: Confronting Class in the Classroom (Patreon)
Content
“When I first entered university settings I felt estranged from this new environment. Like most of my peers and professors, I initially believed those feelings were there because of differences in racial and cultural background. However, as time passed it was more evident that this estrangement was in part a reflection of class difference. At Stanford, I was often asked if I was there on scholarship. Underlying this question was the implication that receiving financial aid “diminished” one in some way.”
I don’t think I ever really felt othered on the basis of class until graduate school—astronomy runs extremely bougie and my school was very prestigious, so it was really the first time in my life I had been around people with such a clearly distinct class background and culture. I was honestly shocked by the obvious expectation that we all came from money—it wasn’t just cultural, (though that was certainly a jarring part of it) there was also really egregious material assumptions like faculty expecting their students to not work a second job, or asking students to front thousands of dollars for required things that would be reimbursed eventually. I didn’t really have the language to articulate this dynamic at the time, so for me this chapter was very much one of those times hooks described where theory can be healing.
This chapter also got me thinking in a kind of meta-way about this book club. It’s not exactly the same as class, but there is a distinct financial asymmetry to my vs y’alls participation in this learning space, on top of the fact that I’m very much the one calling the shots. I’m considering switching up the format a bit, but i want to ask ppl who are participating what would be more valuable to them. Basically, I’m wondering if I should decenter my own voice in a big way by not starting each reading with my own thoughts, and instead providing a more neutral space for you all to start conversations, and then I engage with comments the way you do with eachother instead of being like, the top down opinion haver. I think I defaulted to what I’m doing now partly because of a central lecturer being an automatic model for teaching in my head on some level, but also because I feel the need to ‘give value’ to people who participate here, I guess in the form of writing out my thoughts and opinions on each chapter. But maybe the value I’m giving is the container for discussion and not my take, you know? And also I don’t always have an insightful take on every single reading we do, so it can feel contrived at times. I don’t know, let me know what you think if you have an opinion, not making any promises but I’m curious how you would like this format (meaning, this context and not shifting to discord or zoom or something) of book club organized.