Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone,

Excited to start reading this book with you all! (If you're like me and still waiting on your copy, here’s a digital version)

Here’s how things will work: we’ll read one chapter per week, starting with Chapter 1 this week. On the following Monday, I’ll post a discussion thread here where we can talk about the reading in the comments (the full schedule is below)

Unlike past rounds, I won’t be writing up my initial thoughts in those posts. Instead, I’ll offer a few broad prompts and respond to some comments (not all of them though bc I want to be less “the teacher” and more just one voice in a space I’m facilitating, so please don’t take it too personally if I don’t reply to you directly)

At the end of the book, we’ll do a collaborative writing session: we’ll all get on a google doc at the same time and write reflections, questions, and responses to each other in real time (pending a critical mass of ppl being available)

Reading Schedule

  • 6/23 – Chapter 1: The justification for a pedagogy of the oppressed (28 pages)

  • 6/30 – Chapter 2: The “banking” concept of education as an instrument of oppression (16 pages)

  • 7/7 – Chapter 3: Dialogics (38 pages)

  • 7/14 – Chapter 4: Antidialogics and dialogics as matrices of opposing theories of cultural actions (58 pages)

Tentatively, we’ll do the group writing wrap-up sometime during the last week of July, and I'll send out a when2meet to plan it the week before (though if Chapter 4 ends up feeling like too much to tackle in one week, I’m open to stretching that part over two)

In the meantime, feel free to use the comments on this post to share your initial impressions, expectations, or questions you’re bringing to the book---i'm curious where everyone's coming to this from!

fatima

Comments

phil e the theyby

I think this plan sounds great! I’m excited to see how your approach to the space works out. I think you being “just another participant” has worked great for the collaborative writing sessions, but obviously this is different because it’s asynchronous. But I’m hopeful it should be a good time! I’ve read this book before and I personally found Chapter 3 to be much harder to get through than the rest. I was on an airplane for part of that so that probably didn’t help, but I also read part of Chapter 4 on the same flight and found it much easier. Idk if other folks feel similarly, but just wanted to put that out there in case others are reading it for the first time and want to be a bit more intentional with planning their time to read that chapter. I’m excited to revisit this book, and I’m especially excited to dive into it with y’all!

hunebe

I'm new to the patron/book club and I'm really excited about this book. Along with “Pedagogy of the Oppressed”, I'll be reading "Why Civil Resistance Works" by Erica Chenoweth and Maria J. Stephan. I'm sure the philosophy and theory of Freire will pair beautifully with the stats, charts and historic accounts of the civil resistance book. I'm looking forward to learning with you all!

Green

I’m also new to the patreon/book club! And I’m also hoping to frame Pedagogy of the Oppressed within a larger conversation with other modes of thought. And am replying to your comment bc starting my own seems like too out-there of a task lol. I read Freire’s book a few years ago, when I was much less conscious of things that I am now. And I can’t say that I got everything but a lot resonated with regards to disassembling the student-teacher dynamic and other paradigms for how we do things that maintain oppressive structures/thinking. I then read Yang and Tuck’s ‘Decolonisation is not a metaphor’ upon my arrival at uni and saw that they had critiques of Freire’s abstract approach. I am now hoping to partake in the book club. I anticipate that from this re-read I will glean things that I missed the first time around. I also anticipate that I’ll have to hold multiple views about pedagogy at once, while I figure out what is useful in what situations and where different approaches can be taken, and why they might be preferred. I anticipate that my views will be expanded by people in the book club’s input. I know that I don’t even know how much I don’t know about this topic, but I am glad that this opportunity is here because I’ve toyed on and off with the idea of working as a teacher in a school after I leave uni. Even if I don’t pursue that path, I want to be equipped to better engage in the endeavour of knowledge-sharing and knowledge-expanding as this can happen in any area of life.!

Joseph

I've been a patron for awhile and never got around to any of the previous book clubs, but I'm doing a research internship in higher education and my boss just happened to recommend me this quite recently, so timing worked out. I'm really excited to participate in this one!

Astro_Madden

I just read Create Dangerously by Albert Camus together with a group of scientists. We read while asking what the difference is between the responsibilities of a scientist and an artist. Great conversation.

Victor Steuck

Hey Phil! Pedagogy of the Oppressed is a book I’ve known for a long time. It’s pretty much a classic here in Brasil, especially in education and social movements. This is my first time going through it in English, and it’s been really interesting to revisit it from that angle. I totally agree with you. The whole book is intellectually intense, but Chapter 3 and on definitely get more abstract and philosophical. From that point on, Freire really leans into the idea of praxis. In Portuguese, he often uses the word “quefazer”, which is tough to translate and trickier to fully grasp (even in Portuguese). But I think it points to a deep sense of committed, transformative action, that is, of acting, reflecting, and feeling all at once. A kind of PensAção, maybe? Thinking–feeling–acting all together, not one or the other. One of my favorite parts of Chapter 3: “To exist, humanly, is to name the world, to change it. Once named, the world in its turn reappears to the namers as a problem and requires of them a new naming. Human beings are not built in silence, but in word, in work, in action-reflection.” I’m also excited to go through this again, especially with a group like this that’s reading it with care and intention. It’s a tough read, but such a powerful one.

phil e the theyby

Thanks for sharing! I’m excited to hear your thoughts on if anything reads or feels different in English compared to the Portuguese version 🙂

Karina KN

A classic in Brasil but unfortunately not commonly read in licentiate degrees in the Sciences...Excited to do this now, better late than never!

Robert Herold

I am so excited that this book is going to be the newest one for the book club because I love this book so much. I have read it I think 3 or 4 times already and every time I return to it I find more things to think about and it is just a truly amazing piece of literature. I can't wait to explore it with everyone!

Travis

Lately I have noticed that several of my fellow organizers are pulling me towards their own ideology. This has been difficult in some ways, but it has been helpful in providing me with more clarity about who I am, what my values and principles are, etc. One of the topics I like to obsess over is how to make sense of my own whiteness, my own settlerness, and what it would mean to be a “good White person”. This has created its own obsession, about how we know something is correct/true/real. In other words, what is knowledge? I have heard this Freire title many times, but never actually read it, so I look forward to cracking it open for myself!

RA

Damn...You. Really. Like. This. Book. 😅 ...I actually covet this experience. To have read a book cover to cover and grow with it over the years. Many of the books I read in my youth no longer relevant in this, near, "upside down" world.

Robert Herold

Yeah I love it a lot lol. But I also have read it multiple times over like 6-7 years and so the reason I get new things out of it is because I have read it at different stages of my own life. I first read it as an undergrad as I was getting more into critical theory and things of that nature. Then I read it again in grad school and at the time I had been asking more questions about education and stuff so the book hit me hard in different ways. Then one of the last, if not the last time I can't remember 100%, times I read it was when I graduated and it provided a lot more things for me to reflect on such as my own teaching philosophy and things of that nature.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

I'm very curious about how Freire's peculiar neologisms were translated. There are so many words he bends or subverts. One of my favourites (from memory) is 'boniteza', something akin to "beautyfulness" which he often uses in place of 'beleza' (beauty).

Kevin Hengehold

can you talk more about what your fellow organizers' own ideology is, and how it differs from your own?

Kevin Hengehold

Love this book. I've read it a few times now - it helped a lot as I transitioned from a policy wonk behind a laptop to an organizer talking to people about fighting their vampire-ass landlords. Excited to discuss!

Quezacoatl

I'm really exited for this being my first active book club. I just read the book two month ago and only bought it because the penguin cover looks amazing. I can't stop talking about it since I read it so I'm really looking forward to talking about it more.

Rafael Andrade

I'm really excited to be finally participating with the club's reading and even more to be my fellow recifense book, Paulo Freire. Pedagogy of the Oppressed is not exactly an easy read, most courses start by reading Pedagogia da Autonomia (I think it was translated as "Pedagogy of Freedom", but I'm not sure it's the one), but hey we already gone deep in Feyerabend, right? I will be reading the pt-br version but I decided to get a look on the english forewords and preface to get an idea of how his ideas and context is introduced to you and I was very glad by it. It's very common to talk about Paulo Freire as someone that came from poverty and give those meritocratic ideas of how "genius" he was. When instead he came from a middle class origin and had the opportunities to develop his ideas. What truly made Paulo Freire special wasn't some sort genius insight, but his solidarity and humbleness to listen those who where not listened, and invite others to do the same. I do also like how in the preface he question the so-called left that keeps a dogmatic view of reality, unaware of it's own elitism and fanaticism, a great discussion that reminds me the Feyerabend's reading.

Arjun Rai Gupta

Joined as a Patron for this! My partner and I love this book, though I still need to read it through. While we are at this, another book I want to read but cannot find is 'Critical Pedagogy Under Siege in Palestine: Critical Perspectives from Paulo Freire, Khalil Sakakini, Edward Said and Antonio Gramsci' by Nur Masalha, Peter Mayo and Najwa Silwadi (Bloomsbury Academic, 2020)

Dr. Fatima

thanks! i replaced my link with this one

Dr. Fatima

It’s funny, I’ve heard of Pedagogy of the Oppressed a million times, but I don’t think I heard of Pedagogy of Freedom before at all. I’m certainly curious to check it out now, but I’m curious why there’s such a difference in their impact (at least, as I perceive it)

Dr. Fatima

I love having a book that I revisit over the years and receive differently as I change. I’ve mostly done it with fiction though, I don’t really re-read nonfiction often. But this makes me want to go back and re-read some to see how it hits now 🤔

Dr. Fatima

That sounds like a super interesting conversation—I love Camus but wasn’t aware of this essay, definitely inspired to go check it out now!

Dr. Fatima

Ooh this thing about the made up words and their translations sounds really interesting (I’m a bit of a linguistics nerd on the side lol), very grateful we have so many Brazilians here to help us with those interpretations!

Rafael Andrade

Probably because Pedagogy of the Oppressed is much more academic then Pedagogy of Freedom. The first is very dense so he could establish all his theory. The other were published 30 years later and was intended so teachers could read and easily understand his points (But in a refreshed manner, he didn't like to recap his old ideas)

Travis

Are you my therapist, bc that’s exactly what I’ve been waiting for someone to say /jk I have libertarian anarchists, marxist-leninists, and “pragmatists” all seeming to be fighting over me. Personally I am allergic to dogma of any kind. What matters most to me is dialogue, reflection, principles, and relationship. I am currently in leadership in my local DSA chapter. I am a transplant, so meeting other organizers through DSA projects has been my main exposure to the varied characters that make up The Left in my city. My anarchist comrades hate that I am in DSA and think its a waste of my time. I have plenty of critiques of DSA, but i feel like most anarchists i know are horribly lacking in critical thinking and self-reflection. I am against dogma— but i know so many anarchists who fetishize autonomy into its own dogma!

Craig

I'm late to the party, but re-reading this very important book. Looking forward to reading what others think of it. I think it's what the world needs.