Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 485877583.mp4

Downloads

Content

Thanks for the questions everyone! If you have a follow up of some sort to my answers--another question, request for clarification, or elaboration of a point--comment it here and I'll add it to the list for next time

fatima

Files

Comments

Travis Thompson

Thanks for responding to my question! We do have cameras on the telescope, one deep sky camera and one planetary camera. I have spent some time using it but it’s been “under repair” for most of the time since I asked the question. I was also curious if you had any curriculum resources for my 9th grade astronomy class, especially anything that is a bit outside the box. No worries if that’s a big ask though!!

Travis Thompson

Also thanks for the suggestions! Excited to have a go at the ring nebula. Jupiter’s moons have been on my list for a long time. Still haven’t had a chance to try to image them.

Mx. Alba

I think I missed the thing where Neil DeGrasse Tyson got canceled... Anybody got a link for my education? :D

AJ Biffl

Absolutely fair answer to my question! Thanks for taking the time to address it. I did realize writing it that you had literally just had a huge part of your ability to move between the two worlds ripped from your hands, which is so shitty... I would love to hear you dig into the philosophical side still! I saw a comment somewhere else about the 'age-old question of trying to change the system from inside of it vs outside of it,' and there's also the element where it seems like maybe you can help much more tangibly and directly by interacting with up-and-coming individuals inside the system (why I had used the phrases "material support" vs "conceptual support" in the original question), even though operating inside the system can be more restrictive. How do you think about one approach vs the other?

Captain Mikee

If you're looking for astronomer takes on astronomy hype, I watch Dr. Becky for that. I'd love to know what other folks here think about Dr. Becky (Smethurst)!

Mx. Alba

Oh wow, thanks, I see now. Thanks. Unsubscribing from his podcast, then.

Djoran Keil

Like with astrology, I used to be very atheistic... and then I got into philosophy. Which is odd 'cause philosophers tend to be atheists but for me it's opened up the question: what even IS God? God isn't even what I thought religious people thought God was. The History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps podcast goes through the evolution of metaphysics and a lot of it was done by religious figures. I don't think even a lot of religious people seem to know much about this stuff as I could very much see some getting very angry if I asked them whether or not they thought God was simple, contingent, or necessary :D

Kevin Hengehold

It was a sincere question - just a bad one, I guess. After the Galileo video I was hung up on how the story we all know is so wrong, and how far could the narrative diverge from the events as recorded. I got too hung up on the vibe of the question to see that it's got a pretty trivial answer. But - I have no idea what the name of the person is who confirmed/observed stellar parallax, but I know about the debate of whether galileo said "but it still moves [italian]" - why is that? Maybe a better question would have been about the creation of the narrative & how long it took to create it. I'm thinking of how it took hundreds of years for the actual events of colonization to be romanticized into Thanksgiving, or how Columbus was essentially forgotten by history until a guy in the 19th(?) century started writing about him & he got a holiday to decrease anger in the italian-american community (I think they were getting lynched in the south - racism is a hell of a drug). Anyways - thanks for assuming good faith.

Victor Steuck

Thank you for your answer on astrology, Dr. Fatima. I bet it must be a recurring topic, so thanks for your patience. I really resonated with your response, even though I’m not from the astronomy field. When I was younger, I used to be just like that too, almost taking it as an offense if someone started talking about astrology combinations. It was only over time that I came to understand that, deep down, it’s just another form of culture and, as you mentioned, there's a lot of projection involved. The process of breaking down my biased view actually started with Tarot. My mom had a deck at home, and I began to look at it, understand the object, and read about how it can be used as an interesting narrative tool. Like, in the same way you draw three cards to “predict” your future, you can also draw three cards to think about a character’s story, their challenges, internal conflicts, etc. In other words, through projection itself, the tarot deck ends up becoming a kind of creative tool. For me, as someone who enjoys writing fiction, discovering all these functions was phenomenal. It not only gave me a new perspective on these cultural practices, but also handed me a tool that (I admit I haven’t used much) but the few times I did, I found it really fun and useful. Anyways, thanks again for your reply! And since you're a Libra, your birthday must be coming up soon, so happy birthday in advance! Now I’m off to watch the rest of the video and try to engage with the folks, because we’re here to build dialogical relationships, right? Go Paulo Freire!

Wami Ogunbi

Thanks for answering my question! Lately, I’ve been realizing that many of the big questions I’ve been wrestling with around education and mentorship come down to one core challenge: learning how to genuinely connect with people as individuals. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach. Too often, I see messaging that alienates some while affirming others in ways that feel self-congratulatory—exactly as you mentioned. That kind of dynamic shuts down growth. But when we meet people where they are and engage in real conversations—ones rooted in mutual understanding rather than lecturing or dismissing—we create space for everyone to learn and grow. And isn't that the true meaning and purpose of education?

Victor Steuck

The point you brought up was really good, precisely because, as you said, mentorship is something that can truly shape your academic future. Having an advisor who isn’t able to connect with you must make the already stressful academic journey even more overwhelming. No wonder there are so many videos online of people talking about their experiences leaving their PhD programs, etc. I don’t have the background to speak from experience (I’m someone who never got to that stage in college), but I think you might enjoy Pedagogy of the Oppressed if you’re not already familiar with it. I mean, not just in that work, but in others as well (I’m thinking here of Extension or Communication), Freire speaks directly to the point you raised: that is, learning to genuinely connect with people as individuals. Freire contrasts "extension" with "communication." In the "extension" model, knowledge is treated as a thing that one person (the expert) gives to another (the learner), in a one-way, top-down process. It assumes that the educator knows everything and the student knows nothing. But in the "communication" model, education is a mutual exchange, a dialogical process where both sides are open to listening, questioning, and learning from each other. That’s exactly what you're talking about: real connection, built on mutual respect and understanding. A successful educational process involves communication instead of extension, which means creating space for dialogue, not just transmission. And that’s how we genuinely connect.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

I loved listening to your answer to AJ regarding how you decided on your video topics and how much you value YouTube vs. academic carrier. You mentioned that people might not like to hear about their favorite 'content creators' being pragmatic, so I wanted to share that I really enjoyed it. Your communication is so honest and self-aware and I find that delightful.

Faye K

Hi Dr. Fatima! I love your work. I was wondering what your thoughts are on the hierarchy of sciences where math/physics is seen as a "superior" science followed by chemistry, biology and the social sciences (see xkcd comic here for a funny depiction of this: https://xkcd.com/435/). As a science educator, how do you feel about students' decisions about which science to study sometimes being informed by this hierarchy? Also more theoretically, why and how do you think this hierarchy originated and has it always been seen like this?

Alex Brezina

As a follow up to the question about the value of astrology, would the value of it be the same if the framing is different? My own issues with astrology generally stem from evoking the vibe of astronomy, but then using that as an aesthetic for the mental practices. This feels like it muddies the waters on both astrology and astronomy as a result. Like, being a specific sign doesn't need to evoke astronomy to still get the gist of it. I can be X sign because of planetary alignment, or it could just be due to the month I was born. If you want to keep some space vibes, you could just tie it to our orbit of the sun and it'd at least seem more tangible.

Alex Brezina

I also bring it up because I've long had issues with crystal healing folks. I think there is value in a series of meditation practices that helps to ground people and process they're emotions, but after studying geology for so long, I lose it when these metaphysical properties start getting assigned to rocks and minerals. It's also extra annoying as a collector that the crystal healing folks often inflate the costs of minerals on the whole, and then grind them all down to the same geometric shapes. Lapidary work is really cool and takes skill to do well, and I don't like the finite amount of materials being churned into shapes that don't work to highlight or accentuate the existing crystal forms of the minerals that get used. Maybe it's just a matter of aesthetics at that point, but I certainly feel frustrated that so many stories of a sample's formation are constantly being lost to form the same polished spheres, pyramids, and obelisks. If it's just a difference of tastes, then sure, no problem, but the crystal healing stuff has become a cottage industry that keeps pushing out low-grade lapidary work that simultaneously inflates the cost of anything short of industrial mining.

Michael Roberson

I’m thinking of becoming Star Talk Patreon member so that he prioritizes my inquiries and that way I can bug them about it until his curiosity leads him to research who you are. If it comes to fruition I would definitely tune in. Love you Dr. Fatima keep up the good work!

Jacques Vincelette

On the premise that we humbly gather in reverence to life and beauty (thanks FA), I have consulted the Tarot twice these past 10 years. Ahead of Truth and Reconciliation day, September 30 2023 in Canada, I pondered whether It was worth signing Bob Marley's 'War', Allison Russel's '4th Day Prayer', Brell's 'Voir un ami peurer' and Beethoven's 'Ich liebe dich', at a meeting with the IAEA. The response suggested two dark men had my back. I was cut off after Shuhada' Sadaqat's line "Until the ignoble and unhappy regime which holds each and every one of us through child abuse, exploitation, subhuman bondage, is toppled and utterly destroyed...". I had the chance to wrap up the meeting with Beetoven and the event was forgotten. On December 4 2024, I consuted for a friend over a job offer in private health insurance. The cards indicated a business of death and violence. ("delay", "deny", "depose")

Michael Morgan-Giles

Really appreciate your response to the AJ's question about the philosophy behind your role as a youtuber. I think I also struggle with the individualism of making myself feel "okay", whilst also trying to build a more collectivist community that aligns more with my values. I find it really challenging to balance "starting with me" and also trying to meet the broader needs of the community at the same time. so I appreciate your take on this. Solidarity forever <3

Hari Sood

Popping back up again for a question for the next office hours if it fits! One day I will be on time and we will all see the light of God Short version: I was wondering how you go about researching your videos? Longer version: In your Galileo video, you referenced Indigenous controlled burning practices as an example of where the non-Westernised 'scientific' approach is actually the right one. To ask the general question in reference to this example (which was so spot on and cool) - do you like write your script, and your arguments, then search for examples to back up the arguments (like here, prepare the 'scientific method approach won't always work' line then find an example that works. I know purists say this would be confirmation bias or whatever but idk the world is confirmation bias nothing is pure, all arguments are vibes which hold on the strength they resonate etc. who cares how they were formulated)? Or do you do a lot of reading around the topic and allow the script to emerge from that? When referencing examples, how did you come across them? E.g. here, the example fits so well, was it something you knew already or came across while researching? If the latter, how do you then manage/work through the possible needle-in-the-haystack of ALL the things you could spend time researching to find the relevant and punchy ones? If the former, how do you remember/rediscover what is relevant? Do you like tag/store things as you read them for future reference? I'm personally like a concept person, I can hold concepts more easily in my mind but struggle with holding like concrete examples/facts to reference, and then when I have to find them I get overwhelmed I don't know where to look. Would love to know your process!