Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 491497973.mp4

Downloads

Content

western rationality vs ancestral knowledge, FIGHT

References and Revisions: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1y5q1t8LL5UNNZRlwpYTwb5aIQx9aBxHunDdSJK_PPd4/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.a6nt2vm09xkq

Music: “Al Qalb Mrayef” by The Free Music

Files

Comments

Jacques Vincelette

Necromancy pushing against necrophilia, Haity shows we need to get over ourselves.

Maxwell Douglas Kinghorn

The ad in the middle convinced me to pledge a bit more. I really liked the flowers in this video 🥰

Bob van Vliet

The historical point about Western science claiming authority over physiology based on mind-body dualism while ceding authority over the soul to religion reminded me of a similar split in the history of the idea of 'objectivity' itself. In their book about that history, Lorraine Daston and Peter Galison recount how objectivity is, in essence, a Romantic idea. (https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9781890951795/objectivity) During the 19th century, scientists aimed for 'mechanical objectivity', attempting to completely remove the self from their observations. At the same time, art became defined as exactly the opposite: a willful expression of the self. Neither that view of art nor the one about proper science was in any way natural. They were new. And other scientific practices and ideas about what objectivity even *is* followed later. Fascinating history. I think you'd enjoy that book. (It includes extensive discussions of this playing out in astronomy as well!) Come to think of it, this actually relates to the discussion prompt in that Daston and Galison beautifully describe how scientists in transitional periods between the heydays of different views on 'objectivity' and on what makes scientific observations valid accuse each other of being un- or pseudoscientific. And not just in one or two claims, but dismissing whole ways of working and living 'scientific' lives. The demarcation line has run right through established Western universities and other research institutions, even through two co-receivers of the Nobel prize (i.e. Golgi and/vs Ramón y Cajal, who both thought the other was a pseudoscientific hack). The line has shifted and moved through the (Western) scientific community itself. Multiple times. So how can you ever be sure the lines are drawn correctly now?

Rado

Ngl, I love the stories, I like the conclusion, I don't like the framing. It might very much be a me problem, but from the title and intro I really expected to see some examples of blindspots of scientific methid. Instead we got three stories of science showing something cool while sourcing from nontraditional means (or at least the first two, the third one might actually have been about pseudoscience beating science, I was probably just to defensive then). And like, I love seeing how scientific orthodoxy gets things wrong, I would just enjoy it more if I wasn't already giddy about seeing the limitations of science as a method, because then I got a bit disappointed. I mean, it's probably just me, but title "stories about kniwing things" and thumbnail "best way to know things" and the contrasting with "pseudoscience" really seems to suggest that the word "science" means THE METHOD and not THE SYSTEM.

Ectrayn

discussion prompt: I don't really have an exact answer to the prompt for this video, however I think I have two tangentially relevant examples: First I remember being absolutely mind blown by the efficiency of oral tradition in preserving knowledge by a paper on how Palawa Aboriginal oral traditions were accurately reporting geological (and astronomical!) events from 12 000 years ago. I've been essentially taught that writing is the only really reliable form of knowledge transfer so of course it came as a shock that's such a thing could happen. The second is more politically grounded, but is the systematic destruction of local traditional knowledge on food crop production in favor of technocratic western ways, which have been extremely destructive on the environment they have been deployed to, while still being promoted as progress and the "good"way to do things. I believe Max Ajl talks about this in great length, but the case I'm most familiar with was the introduction of groundnut cultivation in Senegambia during the 1850s as a crash crop. Now, local subsistence farmers are seen as backwards. It's not a "pseudoscience vs science" thing, but it reminds me of the sweetgrass example in its dismissiveness.

Jake Edwards

Oooh, seeing Braiding Sweetgrass mentioned in the references reminded me of a book that, maybe, someone here might find interesting: How It Is by V.F. Cordova. Think of it like a comparative philosophical treatise concerning the spaces between American Aboriginal world-views and the world-views brought over by European ("Euroman") populations during the colonization of the Americas. An exploration of Cordova's definition of cultural matrices.

mb

I wonder how much information is ignored or lost due to it not being defined by a specific unit of measurement.

Melis Ozagac

(discussion prompt perhaps and I commented this into the normal youtube video too, sorry for the length again!!!!) You are touching on a lot of different concepts of holistic thinking and transdisciplinary epistemological awareness. I think you would love to know how students who have grown up in an IB (International Baccalaeruate) international school tend to naturally come out of these schools with the very abilities you indirectly call for at the end of the video. It's one of the things that make me very optimistic about the 21st century. The main thing I want to refer you to is this class called Theory of Knowledge (TOK) but in the rest of the paragraphs I wanted to explain to you how the system of schooling that comes before this class actually prepares and allows the students to genuinely consider, appreciate and build upon the ideas of TOK. The kinds of qualities that you say in the video you want more of which could probably be described as transdisciplinary, intercultural and "glocal" thinking with an emphasis on understanding human difference and complexity through empathy. I think these are almost naturally baked into these students in varying amounts by the time they graduate. The subjects, curriculum, the weekly plan, the moderator role of the teacher, the subjects offered, the architecture and interior design, everything contributes in some shape or form to the generative and healthy value creation that happens through the exchange of hundreds of mixed, complex kids. They tend to have very interesting pasts of having lived in China, Central America, just a bunch of wildly different places and on top of that, they often come from multicultural backgrounds and therefore are usually proficient in more than 3 languages (4 was the norm in my middle school). Their normative is change and they are born world citizens. I was in such a school once where I was one of the rare non-mixed people, only Turkish lol, and one of the only ones who only knew two languages. Until the last two years of highschool, interdisciplinarity, world citizen mindset and an openness to more ways of knowing are baked into the system. I will give some examples. I remember we had constructed a reflective play over the course of around 2-3 weeks in Theatre class (somatic and emotional knowing) about Homestasis. Theatre was a serious and challenging class you had as much as Mathematics up until 10th grade btw. Homestasis was something we had very recently learned in Science. So there were mechanisms that tied together different ways of knowing in the system, in this case Theatre and Science. The teachers and school in its totality were prepared to handle, facilitate, mediate and reflect on the procedure every time. Additionally, we had an Interdisciplinary Unit called IDU which mapped out complex relations and cycles in systems of the world today and proposed alternatives like the Doughnut Economy in indirect ways. So this interdisciplinary thinking was both a direct and indirect part of the learning. These developed intuition, a gut feeling, a kind of "knowing" that comes from belief and systems thinking and stressed the kaleidoscope of human possibilities using classes like Humanities, Theatre, Design Technology, English etc., which were all required and equally given classes by the way. In Humanities holistic analysis of phenomena like Urbanisation, War, Censorship, Poverty were done etc. But the most interesting thing I think you might find, and which all this lead up to, is this class called Theory of Knowledge (TOK), which is very much informed by Epistemology. It is a required class at the end of the two years of the IB program called the IBDP, where you look into each knowledge area which the IB classifies into History, Mathematics, The Arts, Natural Sciences, Human Sciences and also recently, additionally, into ethics, indigenous and religious knowledge. So what you experienced in the way the system was designed your whole life in school is finally directly, consciously, intentionally studied to understand what the hell ACTUALLY went on as you were learning. A lot of classes were combined to create new knowledge perspectives but what DID you combine. What were we actually doing all this time and what is knowledge, and WHAT? A lot of people find this really hard, stupid, nonsensical, bullshit etc. But I think it's one of the most amazing required classes for high schoolers ever. If you have time I think you should check out the 2020 oxford textbook of TOK. You could definitely find new books to read from there. Many of the people you mentioned in your videos are given as reference within like Feyerabend. Disciplines like ethnomathematics were first given a name in this book for me and I read it in two nights. And I recognized the parallels between your content and TOK which is why I really like your videos now. It is almost like the meta manual of everything you are interested in. I think you'll like it very much! ( And just a quick note: IB international schools are another very progressive education ideal and seem to have a lot of parallels to Freire. And I say "grown up in these schools" in the beginning because many students get in and out of such schools quickly in 6 months to 3 years as their families tend to be expats, diplomats etc. I went to the international school of Düsseldorf for 2.5 years and the people who were there since 1st grade and graduated in the same school were mostly usually germans, native to Düsseldorf or the kids of teachers that taught there. Also when I talk about international school with a full IB program I assume that they do not have a deep culture of competition stemming from a disgusting system mismatch with a dehumanizing national education system that pretty much poisons the otherwise well-functioning slow and meticulous IB education. This was the case in Turkey, where I am from and seems to be the case in many other places but I still think it's better than not having IB all together and this pragmatism is what I also really respect about IB. But generally, if there are external forces compromising the "purity" of the IB system, when the kids are finally exposed to TOK they will have been so caught up in achieving, rather than engaging, speed learning rather than naturally participating and discussing, although they will usually be more open-minded than ordinary public or private school attendees, they won't be ready for TOK. It will feel like an opposition to their whole damn world view and will seem like an annoying as hell barrier in their way to get their final IB diploma as they make their way to Uni. So my assumption here is the experience of a student naturally exposed to the whole cycle of the IB program as intended, designed, self-corrected and updated regularly, with preferably a non-homogenous cultural environment, and with only minor problems through the whole 12 years. Doesn't have to be the same school, just a bunch of uncompromised IB schools throughout the world that they learn in until they graduate pretty much. My apologies for the huge chunk of text. I just thought this is very relevant to your interests and very complementary. Cheers )

Djoran Keil

I think part of the problem might be that the very word 'science' has colloquially come to mean a very specific, very Western, THING. It's become a signifier not signifying the signified. Like how "begs the question" has come to mean something other than actually begging the question. So when the term science is used by at lot of people it generally, whether intentionally or not, tends to mean anything in the Western methodology of scientific inquiry which exists in opposition to... well... everything else.

Nick Molina

The comment about the people in East Palestine, OH (and many many more communities abroad, for that matter) needing to *prove* their lived experience of harm by pollution through such onerous means as the western scientific method made me think about how difficult it is for women to successfully *prove* their experiences with sexual/domestic/intimate partner violence in our justice system. In these circumstances and your examples of traditional knowledge bearing very real advancements in multiple fields, so much progress can be made from jump if we begin from a place of humility and simply trust when people tell us about their lives. The west's broader culture seems to have a very strong tendency to REALLY need to *prove* something beyond a reasonable doubt if the ideas offered in any way make us uncomfortable; people are suffering from a chemical spill, women are unsafe within our society, and people from way back in the day might have known about their environment.

Djoran Keil

It occurs to me that there's a relation back to the Pedagogy of Oppression here in the dichotomy of with/for when it comes to scientific endeavour and cultural knowledge. It seems to rise from a paternalistic and patriarchal conceptualisation of reality. One thing I keep seeing in Indigenous land practices across continents is this notion of working WITH the land. People being an intrinsic part of the land instead of apart, and standing in dominance over, it. That theme of dominance carries through a lot of the Western philosophical history of science which separates and elevates people (and in many cases this is very literally spelled out as only men being even defined as people) above animals and plants. So many people seem to have forgotten that we and the world are the same thing.

Quentin C

This is a really thoughtful piece. I’m an aerospace engineer, and I also did an astrophysics minor in college. I’m really left wondering if/how space science still has blind spots that could be filled by “non-traditional” schools of thought. Astronomy has already benefited greatly from being such an old realm of study. It’s incredible how modern scientists worldwide have benefited from data recorded MILLENNIA prior in places like China. (P.S. — this was the first video of yours I’ve watched, and it was so good that I rushed here to support you. Glad to chip in what I can and stick around for more!)

AJ Biffl

Thinking about ancestral knowledge anticipating modern western knowledge makes me think of a post from a substacker named Kaimataara about how communal social organization was super prevalent in indigenous cultures and then was wiped out by western imperialism, and marxists and european anarchists were basically trying to put together scraps without any cultural depth to develop communal ideas. It's a great read and I highly recommend the stack: https://substack.com/@kaimataara/p-161177232

AJ Biffl

In a lot of ways only sourcing knowledge from traditional scientific places IS scientific "method"

Michael Morgan-Giles

This is such a great article! The "relational infrastructure" Kaimatarra mentions has become so transaction in the west that it's hard to find solidarity and build coalitions. After reading that article, I even notice how I lean on theory as a way to feel like I'm doing something radical - even when I'm not. Thank you for sharing!

Michael Morgan-Giles

Indeed! I might be accidently attributing this to Einstein, but i've heard the quote; "Whether you can observe a thing or not depends on the theory which you use. It is theory which decides what can be observed." And if the hegemony of science excludes all non-scientific perspectives that don't have units of measurement, well we'll miss all the information from those perspectives.

Is this egg still good? It smells like Teen Spirit

I'd really like to see a dual concept to this too: what kinds of obvious nonsense are we forced to spend our time worrying about because it conforms to some formal scientific trappings. People are constantly p-hacking their way in to absurd results, bending hypotheses or just straight up misrepresenting what actually happened, and exploiting the scientific aesthetic to saddle all of us with the problem. In 2008, Science published a paper purporting to show that children could predict election outcomes by looking at faces. (They couldn't 'predict' the outcomes, of course, they identified the faces of politicians who won their elections.) In a certain sense this paper is one of the more respectable ones; it's not an obvious an overt fraud like a lot of behavioral economics papers have recently proven to be, but it's nonetheless advancing a theory about reality that's so implausible it demands expansive followup... which has not come. This is a pretty benign example but there are plenty of extremely sinister ways you can abuse these things. The attacks on gender affirming care and vaccine medicine in the U.S. (and U.K.) for instance are directly weaponizing the idea that the double-blind trial is the most privileged way of producing knowledge about medical care, and everything else is implicitly inadequate, as well as the notion that statistical evidence is necessary and relies on threshold populations that are simply larger than the whole potential body of trans people who could be study subjects, rendering it in a certain sense _impossible_ to know if gender affirming care is helpful to them according to the standards of mass medicine

Mx. Alba

Speaking of pseudoscience... What are your thoughts on homeopathy? It's a thoroughly unscientific method... You take something that *causes* the symptoms you want to combat, dilute it so there isn't even a trace of that compound left, and then it "magically" works as a cure for those symptoms. I will concede that for someone who believes that it works, it would have a beneficial placebo effect. I don't think it could be anything beyond that, though... Right?

Dr Jennifer Burgess

So to the last YouTube comment, requiring Patient and Public Involvement (PPI) in medical research proposals is now standard in the UK if you want to get your project a) funded and b) past ethics. This usually involves the researcher presenting their ideas and proposal and receiving feedback, unlike "co-production" where patients are involved from the very beginning i.e. conception of the idea, developing the proposal (which is not compulsory). However, patients and carers who get involved in PPI are not representative of the population and can get things wrong. I was recently working on a clinical trial that got high praise in the PPI stage, patients/carers saying that they thought it was really important, that they definitely would have taken part if they had been offered the trial. However, these were patients looking back years after their diagnosis, who had had problems that they now wished they could prevent, who are more interested in research. Large clinical trial gets approved, lots of funding, I am employed, I spent months approaching people asking them to take part in the trial, and >95% of people said no, they were not interested. In this case, a pilot study approaching the actual patients we needed to recruit would have done a better job at predicting whether just-diagnosed patients were actually interested than the PPI panel did (and I know the obvious suggestion is to try and make the PPI panel more representative, but for various practical reasons trying to get a panel of people who have just been diagnosed with something is obviously problematic).

Lipwig

If the non-scientific knowledge that scientists used to go in the right direction in those examples had not been there, those discoveries might have looked something like the discovery of the cure to scurvy ? I read about it in "Reality is Very Weird and You Need to be Prepared for That" by SlimeMoldTimeMold, and the gist of it seems to be : centuries of repeatedly discovering and losing the cure, because of the surprisingly complex nature of scurvy, and reality. So as a counter-argument to the "science could not have gone in the right direction by itself" could be : it could have, it juste needed a few more centuries of random exploration and luck ? It's a great and very fun read ! More generally, I feel like the work of SlimeMoldTimeMold, and also Adam Mastroianni on criticizing modern science, and science being a strong-link problem (another great article is actually titled "Science is a strong-link problem"), while approaching the subject from a very "non-political" angle, echoes with the lastest videos very strongly. If it has not been discussed before around here (I couldn't read everything, sorry) I think it could be a very valuable addition ! About the video itself, it feels like a great argument for Feyerabend's "anything goes" viewpoint more than a list of examples where pseudoscience "beat" science, as another commenter pointed out, which made me even more eager to find out about areas where other methods can reach knowledge that science is completely unable to touch. This might mean having to completely let go of science as a way to validate this knowledge though. And in the same vein, I'm very curious about seeing how pseudosciences such as traditional non-western practices would actually go about producing new knowledge today ! I imagine they are not completely static bodies of knowledge, so what do their methods and epistemologies look like ? Anyways I hope some of that made sense, loved the video (and the music), as well as reading everyone's walls of text here, thanks !

Aidan

This reminds me of non-western logic systems like Jainism logic, where instead of evaluating statements as just true or false they have seven different evaluations. What you said about science as a tradition also makes me think that language about research, observation, reasoning etc. is limited to western tradition. Terms like science, health, and treatment illicit ideas and structures rooted in western history. But, I think there’s a more amorphous sense of science that every culture participates in. Like indigenous ancestral practice and western science are both systematic ways of participating and learning about the world. It does make wanna see more sources that touch on that in a similar way to Robin Wall Kimmerer. I also wonder how discussing these topics in English or western terminology limits the exploration of other traditions. I’m not super well read in this so I apologize in advance for my nonsensical rambling.

Robert Herold

You bring up a very good point! It is actually something I struggle a lot with in the world of political science which is currently hung up on the idea of trying to engage in the process of operationalizing ever single concept possible. I have read papers where the researchers claim to find the "objective measure" of things like good and bad news, democracy, etc. The problem that the field fails to recognize, and that I try to point out in my research, is that the idea that there has be a unit of measurement for every concept is simply hurting us a lot more than it is helping us. It is blinding us as a field to other concepts and ideas which can't be easily reduced down in a way that allows for easy measurement.

Robert Herold

To start I would say that if you want to see a video about the limitations of the scientific method I would recommend watching Dr. Fatima's last video about Feyerabend who was a major critic of the scientific method. That being said I want to both extend a point made by Djoran Keil and I want to add my own point. Starting with what Djoran says, I want to simply say that I agree with them that the word science means something very specific in the western world. Science is not just a collection of fields and researchers in the western view, science and what makes something science is the method it employees. This is why I think that you might have been expecting a discussion about the method itself. Now I want to make a point that I think the video is talking about both the system of science and the method. The reason I say that the video is about the method is that the stories mentioned would not have existed had people not chosen to go outside of the scientific method and look for alternatives. In each story the scientific method does indeed fail, it is just not a direct failure, it is more a systemic failure to account for non empirical things or ideas.

Dr Jennifer Burgess

Jainism logic sounds very cool - have you got anything good you could link me to?

Aidan

I haven’t come across too many resources. There’s always the Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. There’s also this http://fitelson.org/piksi/burch.pdf they get into the seven-valued logic of Jainism on page 80 (shown on the page not the pdf page count)

mb

I'm currently getting an accounting degree and I see similar issues with the economics curriculum that I've taken. Everything is reduced down to the dollar as a unit of measurement, and as long as it's in the positive then anything on the other side of the equation is acceptable. There may be descriptive economics out there that attempt to merely describe how people allocate resources, but the prescriptive neo-liberal economics that has been presented to me (as natural laws in most cases) so far doesn't seem much more than an abusive use of the scientific process.

Green

your comment reminded me of an interview I watched this week of Latoya Nugent, someone who had to go through the process of 'proving' her queerness to the government of so-called Canada to get refugee status. She is now involved in a project called Rainbow Railroad, which helps LGBTQ+ people who are persecuted and want to move elsewhere and also publishes some of their findings about the sorts of patterns that emerge while the organisation does its work. For instance, how the so-called USA is one of the top destinations people hope to move to while also, in the past five years, also showing the most growth in numbers of people seeking RR's support, due to factors like states' anti-LGBTQ+ states'. This is a specific example of how the absurd notion that a type of harm being experienced can only be considered legitimate once it has been 'proven' - that I wanted to append to your comment because her experience and actions stuck with me. I watched the video on a youtube channel called 'Queer Collective' and recommend it. To end on another, unrelated but activating note, she mentions how the best thing we can do is support queer refugees in our communities because being new to a place with little help to rely on is made so much easier by having a support network, when (typical?) spaces of communion in diaspora might also not be safe. I looked up orgs and groups near me ASAP when I heard this and I'm sharing this because I want to urge others, especially if queer in places that are relatively safe to be so and not refugees, to reflect on how they can integrate the queer refugee experience in their paths to liberation too, since it's an experience that I've only become aware of so recently.

Michael Roberson

I was like voodoo ewww spooky. frfr though 😳

Tom Cassidy

This isn't really a case of pseudoscience over science, but it is a case of the "view from nowhere" attempt at scientific neutrality was brought up short. I live in stroke alley (the South East), which is also the Black belt, which is also Kidney Failure alley. Until VERY recently, black patients were treated differently than white patients. Not as an act of accidental bias; as best medical practice. What was called "race adjustment" was used to interpret kidney data, to portray black patients' kidneys as functioning better than they are. (Read about it here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_adjustment and here https://apnews.com/article/kidney-transplant-race-black-inequity-bias-d4fabf2f3a47aab2fe8e18b2a5432135) It was small group of medical students and Dr. Amaka Eneanya (https://www.linkedin.com/in/amakaeneanya/) who were responsible for changing this. In a larger context, this calls attention to the systemic devaluation of BIPOC women's experience specifically in a medical context. Donna Harraway has long argued that scientific knowledge should be critically aware, ethically grounded, and socially responsive, and this is an example of that!

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

This is a great video, thought-provoking, initially easy to digest but dealing with some profound ideas that require a lot of mental gymnastics to fully grasp (if we even ever do, limited as we are by having had our psyches formed by 'western culture' from the start). And yet. I have a criticism this time, and it is that I think it's detrimental to refer to the knowledge systems discussed in the video as 'pseudoscience'. Dr. Fatima did give us operational definitions at the start, but it just feels deeply unfair to me to equate what could be called "traditional knowledge" (the knowledge historically ingrained in living non-white communities) with things that claim to be scientific but actually fall short (my operational definition os pseudoscience). I'm finding I feel almost attacked/offended by this framing, I realize this because I listen to the video and feel an intense urge to get defensive -- even if the essay is actually very much aligned with my own views. Scientists listening to voices outside of science is a good thing! And you know what, actually taking both traditional knowledge and also what I'm calling "actual pseudoscience" seriously might be part of that. I'm not discouting taking "things that fall short as far as science goes" into consideration as well. And yet. I cringe and haunch my back and feel my stomach escaping me when someone calls chinese medicine or psychoanalyses or my religion (yorubá traditional practices) pseudosciences. It feels like someone is judging our truths we the measurements tools of science and finding us coming short. Well yeah, I never intended to even be in that race. In my view of the cases presented in the video, forces outside science didn't "beat" science, they strengthened it. And... Somethings are not cognizable to science. And that's fine. Science benefits from being in contact with such things, a diversity is a value, a more diverse world is simply better than a less diverse one, and science can find inspiration in many places. That is all true. Science becomes richer and can is some instances only progress with nudges from outside-in. But science will not prove all traditional knowledge to be right, nor should it be concerned with that at all (and I find that many times it unfortunately is, and we all lose some with that).

Kristen

I'm, like, a lurker, because young kids and a 9 month old. So, I see this, and then PBS Kids shows that do champion science* and nature and generally, as educational kids content, are about knowing and how we get to knowing. That asterisk is just that the version of science they present is pretty benign and through being simple for kids actually is more universal than capital S "Science," y'know? It would be easy to get all "bad actually" and do that thing where left gets so purity-focused it ends up agreeing with the right that says kids educational tv is useless/misinformation/bad. I try to instead appreciate it as what it is -- an educational children's show. Kids aren't so indoctrinated they need the deconstruction, and investigating non-Science-gained knowledge and finding it sound is a common theme because, surprise, just about everything adults tell kids is ancestral knowledge.

Tobias Ziemke

Great work. The voodoo death section is fascinating!

Tobias Ziemke

Re: that one comment about indigenous fire management efficacy: this is the slipperiness of Western rationalism. The ideology claims that objective truth must come from logical deduction of experimentally-verified premises. Given the results of this or that fire management experiment, the best strategy must be the one that optimizes each variable in accordance with the existing research. That is, until that strategy is demonstrated to be inferior to indigenous practice-based strategies. Then, such demonstration is incorporated as another experimentally-verified premise to argue that the superior indigenous practice is also the logical, rationalist answer. Western rationalism prevails, they proclaim. Western rational inquiry yields the best results because the best results are definitionally the rationalist's choice. Its a tautological nightmare. But its one that reaffirms Western chauvinism, so naturally it persists without anyone realizing its contradiction.