Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chapter two discussion, let's gooo

What did we think? What questions do you have? Anything in particular you agree/disagree with?

Comments

Isaiah G

Freire's classic album. 10 chef's kisses. I have a question for the room and a disagreement. The question is for the other physics nerds (maybe the good Dr. herself, since she's worked in physics education specifically) - the failures of banking education are apparent when I do physics problems for fun once in a while (I know) and I'm regularly stuck because all I have in my brain are a bunch of formulas, but no idea which formula to reach for or why. My entire memory of undergrad physics was "banked", and a decade later I can withdraw so little of it. In fact, so much of it seems to depend on being UNintuitive, ignoring a bunch of real world contributions to a problem like mass + friction to arrive at surprising results. Like showing how two different masses hit the ground at the same time....if there's no air. I remember that more than the explanation of what I see every day. I might even suggest professors "prevent others from engaging in the process of inquiry" by telling students to ignore particular parts of a problem, even if we learn the concept later. Experts in the field have such a clear intuitive grasp of physical concepts, and I think that's what inspires the rest of us, but it feels like we're taught to build that intuition by being tricked first. Do other folks feel like their education in physics, or really any other science, felt like "banking" as Freire described it? Has anyone experienced or designed a "problem-posing" approach to teaching science, and what are some of the ways it's different? The disagreement is an interesting one that I think will come up again next chapter - namely Freire's dialectic between "human" and "animal", which I think more recent science might allow us to understand in a more nuanced way. He seems to suggest in this chapter (and I think the next one) that the only consciousness is human consciousness and that consciousness has a self-awareness that's also uniquely human: "Problem-posing" education, responding to the essence of consciousness—intentionality—rejects communiqués and embodies communication. It epitomizes the special characteristic of consciousness: being conscious of, not only as intent on objects but as turned in upon itself in a Jasperian "split"—consciousness as consciousness of consciousness." "Indeed, in contrast to other animals who are unfinished, but not historical, people know themselves to be unfinished; they are aware of their incompletion. In this incompletion and this awareness lie the very roots of education as an exclusively human manifestation." But we've all seen My Octopus Teacher, or Jane Goodall with the apes, and even more recent research tries to extend consciousness to even lower level organisms. I think this distinction feels important because he seems to hinge a lot of the book's argument on it, that freedom from oppression is ultimately about being "fully human". But most nonwhite, disabled, etc etc people already know what it means to be excluded from the definition of "human", and solutions to modern problems like climate change require us to consider humans as part of an ecosystem that has innumerable measures of its own agency

Jacques Vincelette

Necrophilia and the culture of control brought back to mind the 1999 movie 'Instinct' inspired by Daniel Quinn's novel 'Ishmael'. Critics dismissed to movie for its banal predictability. The dominant normalise oppressive power as a projection of so called "law of the jungle".

Christopher Garcia

I think the main goal, and maybe I'll be proven wrong as the book processes, is to establish the importance of humanity because of the usual assumption that the world exists separate from us. That if humanity is gone, the earth will simply exist as is and continue just fine. When in reality we are as part of the world as anything else. We are dependent on the material as much as it is on us, one can not observe what isn't observable. I do get the idea that there should be more value put into non human life in general, but even the intelligence of other creatures only exists because humanity has defined the concept of intelligence. I feel like the end goal is just to help people understand that nothing is concrete and that we can learn from anything and anyone just as much as they can from us, and the use of humanity is simply the broadest term to address the audience. After all as of yet we aren't attempting to teach chimps the concept of oppression.

Christopher Garcia

The part where he spoke about people seeking strong men to make up for their own inaction definitely feels more prevalent than ever. People are taught in schools that everything requires permission, and that leads into adulthood where people justify inaction on the basis of not having the authority. Not mowing your lawn, playing music too loud, random acts that should be inconsequential are locked behind artifical authority and people take that as morally true because their entire life they've been taught that any rule must be followed since you don't question authority. I just want people to give themselves permission to live more freely, I know that as the book says I can't do much just trying to live that way on my own. Lots of the things I'd love to do with my life require like minded people to also seek out similar movements and experiences. It's a good way to try and keep humble, remembering that I can be as free a thinker as I want but it only has value with community and discussion.

Isaiah G

I buy that, but if we are trying to teach humans the concept of oppression, I don't yet see how the idea that humans are not separate from the world does that. I can see how that helps us identify the limits of a model of teaching, but I'm not sure it helps us evaluate the effectiveness of that teaching in dismantling oppression. I could just be missing the connection though. I'm so glad you said "as of yet" lol it reminded me of "scientists teach a gorilla that someday it will die" https://youtu.be/CJkWS4t4l0k?si=aD9p6wCX2XJY-uCx

aliin

SORRY this got so long again... anyway The banking concept was probably the reason I dropped studying compsci this year and will start sociology. When I think back to classes I don't remember specific classes like maths or cs for example. What I remember are the days in philosophy class where eg. we did a thought experiment abt John Rawls' concept of designing a society based on ignorance (basically you don't know what role you will have in that society and are thus forced to make it just for amyone as you could be anyone). When reading ch2 it struck me that this was kind of an example of problem-posing education. While the teacher wasn't actually involved it was still a case of dialogue among students with a problem to solve for once and it was actually fruitful (at least for me) as I realized only a year later that I was basically inventing socialism on the spot without knowing what socialism is at all (other than being told it's not really good and gives the government a lot of power in the very same philosophy class before). I was sort of leading the debate as the only one who was for wealth-redistribution and against inheritance (don't remember what the exact prompt was) anyway and liked leading discussions. Everybody was asking me what I'd do if my parents were rich or if I got rich in the future, ignoring the realities that I wasn't rich and that none of us would probably ever become billionaires let alone millionaires and we'd sooner land on the streets. This was just what Freire meant when he said the oppressed will idolize the oppressor. "We want the right to oppress too!" they said basically as if there was another way of gaining that much money. They couldn't imagine any other world than the one we lived in and thus tried successing inside it rather than - in this case literally - change it. At last another classmate came up with the compromise to wealth distribution to increase taxes on the rich even more (as that was something the others could agree upon) and use that money for social good instead. And did I ever consider that before she pointed it out? No! We learned a lot from each other by dialogue that day and I wish the teacher partook in it, there was no reason for her not to as the reason for her not partaking in a way was authority-based. Her authority meant nothing in this, her experiences would have meant something! She had the opportunity to give us the word we were missing but didn't so it took me a year to understand by myself (and tbh realizimg that felt vindicating asf). As Freire put it, the banking concept would have concealed all this from us and we would never have learned to think for ourselves an alternative future. Wish we had more sessions of just that, could have been even more fruitful. Side note: others hated talking and just wanted to do the papers. Interesting how some students seem to prefer the banking concept when they are discouraged from dialogue in school.

Djoran Keil

This chapter reminded me of the film Dead Poet's Society so I rewatched it and although it's not a perfect match, I definitely wouldn't be surprised if the writer, Tom Schulman, wasn't in some way directly or even indirectly influenced by Freire's concepts on 'banking' vs. 'problem-posing' pedagogies. It also made me think of my own struggles with education and issues around rote learning. I need to do, to engage in praxis, or else the theory flits through my head like an ethereal wisp and then vanishes. I also found it pertinent to current discourse spurred by Zohran Mamdani's statement about how we shouldn't have billionaires. This part from the book stood out in regards that: "Not that it is not fundamental to have in order to be human. Precisely because it is necessary, some men's having must not be allowed to constitute an obstacle to others having, must not consolidate the power of the former to crush the latter."

AlexTheTutor

When I teach physics, especially word problems, I break down the word problem into “Info-Question-Method-Execute”: first, gather the relevant info, second identify the question as a separate step so we don’t later say, “what am I even trying to figure out?”, third based on the info and question, select the appropriate method (or for more complex problems develop a plan), and forth then and only then do we want to begin doing anything by executing the method/plan. The goal is to break down the learning process into 4 parts: facts, concepts, process, and self. Students will naturally memorize formulas and constants (facts) after doing a dozen of the same problems. Once the students can successfully solve a problem without making a single mistake (process learning), then they can begin to understand the deeper concepts by trying to connect it with something they already know in their lives. The c in Q = mcΔT becomes a time to connect hydrogen bonding and the time it takes to boil water when cooking and etc. This is where the SELF comes into things: Everything mentioned before more applies for adults who haven’t done science in a decade and who are rusty in math and science, but for students who already come with a deep understanding of basics, c can be a way to connect the concept of slope with the specific heat capacity and a material’s ability to capture heat via intermolecular bonding and etc. The SELF is the most important part: The “banking model” of education implies that the self is not too important, since one bank account is the same as any other, and we just need to deposit knowledge into the account. But, in reality, some students will simply never grasp the concepts deeply enough before an exam, they just need to get a good grade to enter a profession, and that focuses on the PROCESS aspect of knowledge. But, not in order to ingrain the process, but only to know it for the exam. But (this is where I disagree a bit with Freire), it is still important to deposit knowledge, but we w must do so in terms of respecting the kinds of students we have, to respect their individualities, the SELF. The SELF must be integrated with the FACTS, CONCEPTS, and PROCESS. When things go well, a whole class of students who are basically in the same place in terms of their knowledge can come together and learn together, and for the most part, things can work out very well. The common myth (don’t memorize formulas) can be replaced with (obviously we want to memorize the formulas, but in the same way that we memorize words in a language, we don’t stare at a dictionary to memorize words, we use words when we speak, and that is how we memorize them, in the same way, we just need to practice some word problems, and then afterwards connect experience to the CONCEPTS, and then students (regardless of level) can perform and do well and actually enjoy what they are doing. só isso

Alfalfafield

I was a big fan of Chapter One, but the second chapter felt like a bit of a let-down. There was a lot that resonated with me – the notion that oppressive education “serves to obviate thinking” and that “no oppressive order could permit the oppressed to begin to question: why?” definitely speak to a lot of my experience of education. But the intensity of the contrast between the “banking model” and the “narrative model” felt false to me. Claiming that under the banking model “the students are not called upon to know, but to memorize the contents narrated by the teacher” – well, is that true? I memorized my times tables by rote, with seemingly endless drills and worksheets, but now I know them and I know how to use them, and I'm pretty sure that me knowing them was the purpose of all those drills and worksheets. I don’t dispute that a lot of educational practices and techniques are oppressive and serve to shut down curiosity and inquiry, but I can’t help but feel like Friere has set up a false dichotomy. The banking model that he describes sounded like a kind of straw-man worst-case-scenario model of education. I don’t know if that’s what it was like for him as a student? Another thing that struck me as idealized was his insistence on total dialogue between students and teachers (or students-teacher and teacher-student), that the process of education involves a constant exchange of learning and teaching by all participants. I’ve worked as an ESL teacher for adult immigrants and refugees for almost ten years, and I’ve certainly learned a lot from my students – about themselves, their languages, their cultures, their ways of thinking and, their countries’ histories, but also about how to teach English in terms of what works well, what’s confusing, what gets and holds people’s attention, what errors and misunderstandings are common, etc. But the longer I teach English, the less I have to learn about those things. If I’m teaching a grammar topic that I’ve taught five or ten times already, I have a very good idea of which parts will be new, difficult, challenging or confusing for students, why and how this grammar will be useful for students in their out-of-the-classroom communication, what ways they can use it to describe their opinions/experiences/thoughts/ideas, whether there are any pronunciation challenges related to this grammar for the language groups I have in the classroom, etc. I’ve likely modified my plan for this lesson several times based on how it’s gone in the past, and at this point I’m probably not going to learn much of anything from teaching it – and I think that’s okay! I feel like Friere is almost forgetting the fact that teachers should be experts in teaching, that they should know not just their material but how people who are new to this material typically react to it and methods for transmitting that material effectively and engagingly. By all means, it should involve the students narratively as subjects in their own learning, but for a lot of topics it definitely also involves making deposits of information that have to be memorized – whether it’s irregular verbs or multiplication tables or abbreviations for the names of elements or physics equations. I’m curious to see if there are any examples or anecdotes of how his methodology works in practice in the coming chapters, because I think some illustrations would be very helpful here. For my fellow educators, do you feel like you do any depositing in your classrooms, and if so, do you think it’s a bad thing or avoidable?

Robert Herold

Another movie that kind of maps well onto the ideas of the banking model of education and the problems it poses is, and this is going to sound weird but hear me out, Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure. There is a youtube channel which is no longer active called Wisecrack and they actually do a wonderful job with offering up the argument, here is a link to that video, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFD37HvGx6k. But for those who don't want to watch it I will outline it really quick, and I will mention what the movie is about. For starters the movie fallows 2 high schoolers Bill and Ted, they are dumb stoner guys and are currently on their way to failing history class which would be bad for them because it would mean that Ted will be sent off to military school and then they wouldn't be able to continue their band Wild Stallions. While studying the night before the final assignment which could stop them from failing, they meet a man from the future named Rufus who tells them they are going to be the saviors of the future with their band, but that means they need to ace their assignment. So Rufus gives them a time machine which then allows Bill and Ted to go on some time travel goofy fun and along the way they meet major historical figures like Socrates, Genghis Khan, and Joan of Arc. They brings these figures back to the modern time and with their help they put on the best presentation and end up passing history class allowing them to continue on with Wild Stallions. Now for the argument about how this movie ties back into Freire, the basic idea is rather short. We see that Bill and Ted in the begging of the movie are currently failing history, a class which is the epitome of the banking model of education. In this class they are told to learn and memorize facts about figures like Joan of Arc. Clearly this method is not working for BIll and Ted, and thus they are presented with a chance to offer up an oral presentation instead which allows for a bit more creativity then simply reciting a bunch of historical facts. Additionally, through the help of Rufus the two are able to also now go back and learn from the history from the people themselves which is a much more active form of education and participation. The Wisecrack crew even argues that their process of going through history and meeting historical figures is also a form of problem posing education. Additionally we see that Bill and Ted, while being a couple of goofball stoners, are not complete idiots like most assume, we see this when they meet Socrates and are able to use their knowledge of music to connect with him despite the clear language boundary. Now it isn't a perfect one to one between the movie and Friere's ideas but it does feel like there is a bit of a connection there to me.

Christopher Garcia

I'm not a teacher, but I do live in a community with a huge Hispanic population and my dad's first language was Spanish. I'm curious, as you've gone throughout the years have you ever been challenged by the changes in modern English that occur by the day? I know it seems silly to bring up slang, but often the biggest issue I have communicating with people who understand both English and Spanish is getting a modern phrase to make sense in either language. And of course there's phrases in Spanish that don't have a 1:1 English equivalent that they struggle with as well. I only ask cause I feel like that's an easy example in your field of how you kinda can't know everything even if you have set methods of getting the basics across, and I'm just interested how you approach those changes or if you feel like you have to.

Djoran Keil

Oh wow, I never would've thought of that movie even if I'd sat down to come up with a list but yeah, I definitely see it now. Praxis indeed!

Alfalfafield

Slang is absolutely an important part of language learning! It's part of register or level of formality, which is something that a lot of language learners struggle with, especially people coming from Romance languages. Since a lot of English's more formal vocabulary consists of loan words from French and Latin, Romance language speakers can sometimes come across as "too formal" because they're relying on familiar cognates. I don't go out of my way to incorporate the most current slang terms, though, since it's mostly teenagers who are using those and my students are largely 30+ and don't really need to know what "cheugy" means, but I try to cover the types of everyday informal expressions that they're likely to hear frequently - phrases like "my bad" or "no worries" come to mind, which are at least slang-adjacent. You're definitely right that I can't and don't know everything - there are all kinds of words that I've never heard before - but generally, if I don't know a word, my students probably don't need to know it either, unless it's specialized vocabulary for their occupation, in which case translating it 1:1 is likely a lot more straightforward. More broadly, teaching vocabulary is a skill that educators need to cultivate because it goes far beyond 1:1 dictionary translations. Your dictionary may tell you one or two literal translations for an English word, but a good teacher can also give you information about connotation, register, distinctions from similar words (today I was explaining the difference between recommend, suggest and propose), frequency, words it often gets used with or tenses it often gets used it, etc. Defining a word precisely, accurately and succinctly is a major challenge for a lot of novice English teachers. Often there are little details that get lost or added in translation, which is why the robots haven't taken my job yet.

AJ Biffl

I read most of the human-consciousness parts as being extremely general thoughts on the nature of consciousness and education, consciousness being fundamental to the relationship between new information and action. Like you mentioned I think the revelations that many animals are conscious in some way are all fairly recent; I'd like to think he would have reframed some of his discussion if he was thinking of other species as Subjects as well. Though even so, motivated action behind the development of human society is still the the arena of humans (which is what I think he means by "historical" animals)

Robert Herold

Hey there! Thank you for sharing your thoughts it was interesting getting to read your perspective and I wanted to talk about your idea that maybe the banking model of education that Friere presents is a straw man. I want to defend Friere's point here and argue that the banking model of education is not only not a straw man, it is the basis for American Education at all levels. It is easiest to see at the K-12 level of education and the usage of standardized tests which have forced students into becoming obedient subjects who are filled with facts and 'knowledge' by the teacher. This was not only my exact experience, but all of my friends who went through American k-12 and who have read Friere all agree that what we experienced was the banking model at work. Students in the system are given a constant barrage of facts in which they must memorize or are considered to be failures, which then hurts a number of different groups of students. Students are often forced into asking for things like being able to go the bathroom and then are forced into giving into whatever the teacher says. I remember in school having to wait for 20 minutes to go to the bathroom simply because my teacher said I had to wait and didn't even give a reason. Teachers are seen as the major authority figure in the classroom and thus they in charge and students must submit to their authority. Also, in school the material being covered by teachers is decided well in advance and, almost always, without input from students, they are simply forced into learning whatever the teacher has decided is necessary. Additionally, I would argue that the American cultural view of children is that they are simply highly passive beings who don't really have, "intelligible opinions" about the world because they are young. Thus, in k-12 settings students are often not given a voice and are instead forced into accepting that they know nothing and that the teacher knows everything. Then you have the higher educational system which I would also argue is rife with the banking model, at least that has been mine and other people's experiences.

Robert Herold

Hey everyone! I missed last weeks book club but I did get a chance to look at everyone's ideas and comments and I thought it was super awesome getting to see what everyone thought about the first chapter. I am equally excited to see what kind of things people decide to talk about with this chapter. Today I wanted to touch on 2 things, the first is super short and simple, I want to point out a line from a Paul Feyerabend book which I think exemplifies part of what Friere is discussing in this chapter. The next thing I want to talk about is an idea I have had about a specific harm that comes about from the banking model of education within higher education and even more specifically, something I noticed about my field political science. To start I want to simply offer up a bit of a long quote from Paul Feyerabend's book "Science in a free society", which by the way I highly recommend it is a great book. The quote is super long so I will try to whittle it down a bit here and there. "In the years 1964. Mexicans, Blacks, Indians entered the university as a result of new education policies. There they sat, partly curious, partly disdainful, partly simply confused hoping to get an "education". What an opportunity for a prophet in search of a following! What an opportunity, my rationalist friends told me, to contribute to the spreading of reason and the improvement of mankind!... I felt very differently. For it dawned on me that the intricate arguments and the wonderful stories I had so far told to my more or less sophisticated audience might just be dreams, reflections of the conceit of a small group who had succeeded in enslaving everyone else with their ideas. Who was I to tell these people what and how to think?.... I was not familiar with their interests, their feelings, their fears thought I knew that they were eager to learn.... they wanted to know, they wanted to learn, they wanted to understand the strange world around them - did they not deserve better nourishment? Their ancestors had developed cultures of their own, colourful languages, harmonious views of the relation between man and man and man and nature whose remnants are a living criticism of the tendencies of separation, analysis, self-centredness inherent in Western thought.... Now there was much talk of liberation, of racial equality - but what did it mean? Did it mean the equality of these traditions and the traditions of the white man? It did not.... These were the thoughts that went through my head as I looked at my audience and they made me recoil in revulsion and terror from the task I was supposed to perform. For the task - this now became clear to me - was that of a very refined, very sophisticated slavedriver. And a slavedriver I did not want to be." I think that, and I say this because I don't know for sure, if Feyerabend ever read any of Friere's work but I think that the two would have had a lot of things that they would agree on. The last thing I want to talk about is a special kind of harm I have thought of that I believe arises from the banking model of education in its usage specifically in higher education and more specifically in science. Now I will limit this point even further and say that this is something I know for sure is happening in political science and I am sure it is happening in other places but I don't have experience in those other areas of science so I don't want to say it is a problem across every science. The harm is that the model helps to entrench certain norms and attitudes about science, how to do science, the methods of science, etc. which can go onto normalize ideas and behaviors which might be harmful. I want to demonstrate this point by first talking about an experience i had in a graduate class a few years ago. I was in a world politics grad class and we had been discussing a paper that offered up policy recommendations for a country, I can't remember which but it isn't relevant what matters is that it was a country the authors were neither from nor did they live there at all. For those who are unfamiliar with political science offering up policy reconsideration for countries, regardless of whether or not the researcher lives there, is quite common. This is a norm which I have found extremely little to no push back against within the field, and I decided that in my class that day I had had enough and wanted to voice my opinion. I said something akin to the idea that it might be unethical for us to offer recommendations for countries and people who we simply know the politics of and nothing else. After all, we as researchers can have a major impact on how people might come to see certain things and people might simply want to try something just because an expert said it could work. This idea was met with total shock and disdain from my classmates, one even asked what it was political scientists would do if they couldn't offer up policy recommendations. It was then that I realized that my classmates had become so ingrained into the paradigm that they were no longer questioning parts of it and simply took it as mere fact. They became as ingrained as they were because of the banking model of education they went through as undergraduates and graduates. Now they are continuing forward with possibly harmful and unethical practices simply because they were taught that it was what they should do.

phil e the theyby

Brazilian philosopher DESTROYS school!!!11!1! A few quotes that made me Think About Things: "His [the teacher's] task is to 'fill' the students with the contents of his narration--contents which are detached from reality, disconnected from the totality that engendered them and could give them significance. Words are emptied of their concreteness and become a hollow, alienated, and alienating verbosity." (71) Jordan Peterson is known for this thing of like, asking people to define what "is" or whatever means, and is widely despised for it online. The thing is, I have a tendency to ask these sorts of questions for people to clarify terms ALL THE TIME (note, people in my life who I ask these questions to don't seem to hate them nearly as much). And I think that when people hear about that tendency to ask for clarification in definition, they interpret that as people trying to box someone into exact categories, insisting that people are using the "correct" definitions. But for me, the task of clarifying what specific words mean to people (in specific contexts) isn't aimed at containing them; it's aimed at giving them real significance. I don't want to be talking about random abstract bullshit; I want to discuss how we understand tangible things that actually impact our lives. I don't want to interact with hollow principles; I want to speak in words that mean something, even if they mean something different to you than they do to me. This quote made it very clear what I'm longing for, and why I use that particular pattern to try to get at that. "They are treated as individual cases, as marginal cases who deviate from the general configuration of a 'good, organized, and just' society. The oppressed are regarded as the pathology of the healthy society, which must therefore adjust these 'incompetent and lazy' folk to its own patterns by changing their mentality." (74) As a psychologist, my field is (often justly) accused of being the agent of "changing mentalities" to adhere to "healthy society." There are almost assuredly therapists who do that. My goal is instead to help folks recognize the PROCESS of oppression described here, and learn how to mobilize and become empowered towards dismantling oppressive systems. I think enough people are recognizing that society is sick that it's easier to get folks to recognize that their "laziness" or "incompetence" are a result of a sick society rather than their individual defects. "Implicit in the banking concept is the dichotomy between human beings and the world: a person is merely in the world, not with the world or with others; the individual is spectator, not re-creator." (75) See Dr. Fatima's new video. Well-timed indeed. "Whereas the banking education anesthetizes and inhibits creative power, problem-posing education involves a constant unveiling of reality. The former attempts to maintain the submersion of consciousness; the latter strives for the emergence of consciousness and critical intervention in reality." (81) I love the use of the term "creative power" here, because I think recognizing that creativity (and not just criticism) is a massive part of what's inhibited. My notes in the margin: "How to be generative instead of just critical?" That is, how do we engender the emergence of consciousness with the creative energy needed to build new systems, rather than a channeling of rage that simply burns the old systems down? Freire speaks to love, which I think is absolutely an element of it. I also think that finding the spirit of joy, passion, and curiosity in our critiques is super important. I think music in Black resistance movements have done a really good job of this. To bring an example closer to home (and it's kind of awkward because this is on her page and she will read this, so it feels a bit too "stan," but it's genuinely the best example I can think of), Dr. Fatima's videos do a really fucking good job of this. Between the humor, the energy of the music, the lively set designs, the cool outfits, and the general joy and fun that seems to go into making them, her videos embody that our critical consciousness, while it puts us in contact with things that are incredibly painful, doesn't prevent us from being in touch with our joy. And I think using creative media when the topic gets harder and more painful can ironically get us in contact with our joy and generative energy as well. The road to liberation is long (longer than any of our lifetimes), and we need to honor whatever feelings that come up in that process. Art that creates room for that and allows us to move through it, that gives voice to feelings that are denied and that creates room for feelings (especially hope and joy) that feel impossible, are critical for survival and healthy resistance. On to Chapter 3!

AJ Biffl

This is something that came up while we were reading Teaching to Transgress, and Isaiah G and Alfalfafield brought up some of these issues, but I've mainly been thinking about how much I have trouble trying to apply these dialogical ideas to physics education, which at first blush is an extremely top-down field of knowledge (in previous discussions we'd used the phrase "technical"). I have I think sort of two distinct neighborhoods of thought about it. First are just the major takeaways I had from the chapter about actual strategies to use in the classroom to better embody "problem-posing" education. One is literally just posing more problems: spending less time at the board working problems myself and more time walking around and talking with them about how they're approaching them - "acts of cognition, not transferrals of information" (pg 79). Since it's summer the class sizes are smaller so I'm able to spend more time at each table, but I hope to continue this balance in the fall. Another thing I've been trying is emphasizing how the material relates to their lives directly, how their intuition and experience relates to the abstract equations, and then also in how realism meets simplification in the material (this is related to Isaiah's comment). Not presenting the world as "motionless, static, compartmentalized, and predictable" (pg 71) in like the most simplistic physics 1 way, instead talking about which approximations in a problem are most likely to be false and how each of them could be included in our treatment if we wanted (so like today we talked about how "elastic collisions" are made up and where to include the lost energy in the equations). But then the second neighborhood my thought wanders into is that none of the material I teach actually contributes to understanding structures of oppression. Like there's some aspects of empowerment in learning to use this stuff, and like we talked about during Teaching to Transgress there's a lot of importance in what we frame the material as being useful FOR (so writing problems about snowballs and baseballs not bullets and bombs). But on the other hand I don't know of any way I can shade the material to put emphasis on "unveiling of reality" and "critical intervention in reality" (pg 81). To some extent I guess learning to "perceive critically the way they exist in the world" (pg 83) is a philosophical position that can be learned in any classroom, but I don't know. Maybe others have ideas.

Christopher Garcia

That definitely makes sense. I recently applied for a position where I'd be doing social media and coordination for programs like ESL classes, after school activities, and youth outreach so I'm curious how that'll take into account knowing how to bridge age/language gaps. I think ultimately you are doing what the book aspires educators to do, you did learn as you went instead of just reading definitions and stopping there. That's definitely how English (and really most of school) curriculum felt for me. Only a good teacher would make the class worthwhile, so regardless I think we can all appreciate one when they come across.

Robert Herold

Hey AJ thank you so much for your input I loved reading your ideas and your unique perspective. I definitely can understand how it could be hard to apply some of the ideas brought forward by Friere to the world of physics education. I think that in your first takeaway you point out some really good ways of trying to bring these ideas over into your realm. I especially like that you mentioned how you go about trying to invite more dialogue with your students I think that this is a big thing that is often missing from a lot of physics education. While my current focus is on political science, when I was an undergrad I initially wanted to go into astrophysics so I took a few physics classes and honestly each one was both fun in the sense that I love physics so just learning about it was fun, but it was also boring because the teachers never really engaged with students outside of labs. Each class was just a big lecture full of material that I was expected to memorize. So I think that by inviting more dialogue and trying to tie the material you are teaching into the lives of your students you are trying to do something more in line with what Friere talks about. I also wanted to talk about your second idea as well because I think that there is an interesting discussion here. To start I want to say that this thought has never really come across my mind in the multiple readings I have done and I think this is because I have always approached it from the lens of a social scientist. Because of that I have never really asked myself if the content I work with and the material I teach relates to structures of oppression and what that would mean for applying Friere's ideas. I think that this is a good point to raise because in a lot of ways you are right, like sure it is possible to relate some of the history of physics and stuff to things like oppression of women, but that really is more about the history and culture of physics and not the content itself. However, having now thought of this I find myself wondering if the content is the only thing that matters. If you focus less on the material and more on attempting to disrupt things like the banking model of education and the current teacher-student dynamic which is common throughout a lot of educational institutions than you are doing important work for students. Now this is obviously still hard in some sense because disrupting the banking model in physics is a little tough as you have pointed out, but going back to the first point you made I would say you are doing things that do disrupt that model and the student-teacher dynamic.

Robert Herold

Hey Aliin, thank you for comment, I really enjoyed reading what you have to say, also don't worry about being long look at how long my post is haha. I really liked your story about your philosophy class and I think it is rather funny because I experienced something extremely similar in both a philosophy and political science class back when I was an undergrad. I remember when I first read the book and thought back on my own moments and I found myself coming to the same conclusion as you, that a lot of people are willing to idolize the oppressor because they hope to one day become them. Reminds of the quote from Ronald Wright, “John Steinbeck once said that socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires.” I also think its interesting that you have a comp sci background because I honestly would have guessed that comp sci, physics, and math are the three fields where I imagine the banking model is used very heavily. I am curious if this is something you experienced in your comp sci classes.

Robert Herold

Hey Isaiah thank you for your awesome post and question I really enjoyed reading your perspective! I wanted to tackle two things in this response, one was to offer an answer to your question and the other was to talk about some consciousness stuff. To start with the question I would answer the first part of it with a simple yes, I would say that my education in both physics and political science were heavily based on the banking model of education. I would also say that this was true for political science at both the undergrad and graduate level. I still remember one grad class where I had to read 7 books in a single semester while also keeping up with weekly academic papers as well, it was so much content that was I was just supposed to absorb that I only ever ended up retaining the information for just the class and I missed out on a lot of important details that I only discovered after rereading some of the books later on. For the second part of the question I would say that I have seen some professors that I took classes with who tried to engage in a more problem-posing approach. One class I took was a seminar class but was entirely student run, the professor offered insights, questions, opinions, but he let us do a lot of the work. We were not told to read a specific book or article but were given like 10 articles to pick from and each one talked about different topics and it was very interesting. I think that there are some people out there who are building their own approaches to problem-posing education and I doubt there will be one way in which we should try to do it. Now I want to talk about your second point about consciousness. I want to start by saying that I don't think a lot of Friere's argument rests on an assumption that humans are the only conscious being. I think that Friere's language is used to help build a sort of metaphysical solidarity with all humanity. We are conscious beings who, as the quote you use says, know we are unfinished and this is something that unites us all. Additionally, I don't think that freedom from oppression is itself the path to becoming fully human. Also when he talks about "becoming more fully human" I once again don't think he means in a literal sense or anything like that, what he means is that by working to free ourselves of oppression we are more able to engage in activities which we usually think of that make us human. Things like art and so on. That being said I could be misunderstanding Friere slightly but that is how I see it at least.

Djoran Keil

Robert, if you haven't already then I highly recommend looking into the history of the philosophy of science and social studies as these disciplines showcase the evolution of the concepts we accept as true today but in knowing their origins you can see reflected in them so many things which have been obfuscated by normalisation or altered terminology or reframing, etc. A lot of colonialism, sexism, racism is built into these structures so much so that I think they're almost invisible to most people. I should be clear that I'm saying this as a non-academic with zero qualifications. I just love all this stuff so am a keen participant :)

Djoran Keil

In regards Peterson I'd argue he does it in bad faith so as to 'win' arguments and bully what he sees as opponents into submission rather than any attempt at genuine dialectic. Clarifying terms is good when dealing with people who are interested in good faith argumentation. Otherwise, it's just a rhetorical tactic.

Alfalfafield

Re: the non-radical content of physics instruction - I'm reminded of The Dispossessed by Ursula K Le Guin - if you've never read it, it's a sci-fi novel about a society of anarchists living on the moon of their species' home planet. (They got exiled there hundreds of years earlier by the capitalists when their revolutionary activity became too much of a threat to business.) The main character is a physicist and physics teacher, and the book follows his education and work in a radically egalitarian society. Highly recommended!

Alfalfafield

Hi Robert Herold, I absolutely agree that a lot of education follows the model you describe, and it can be horribly dehumanizing for the children who are forced to endure it! Teaching which engages students as full subjects and encourages a dialogic and problem-posing approach is definitely going to be superior in most contexts. I just question whether there's a true dichotomy between these two models. I feel like there are some kinds of knowledge that unavoidably have to be "banked", that can't really emerge through a process of conversation and dialogue. The best example from my field is probably irregular past verbs - most English verbs end with -ed in the past, like walked or talked or learned, but there's about 200 verbs, most of them very common, that have different past forms (and sometimes different past participle forms), like taught, had, made, wrote/written, rang/rung, was/were/been, etc. There's no consistent pattern or logic to these verbs, and nothing intuitive about which ones are irregular and which ones aren't. For someone learning English, you just have to memorize them. The best way to do that is probably through a mixture of some rote repetition (worksheets, flashcards, drills, etc.) and some personalization - using them to describe your own life, experiences, opinions, and feelings, or to discuss meaningful real-world contexts. But that second part can't really happen until the knowledge has been (at least partially) "banked". So at least for me, what this looks like in practice is a blend of the banking and conversational models. As the instructor, and as someone who's taught this topic before multiple times, I (a) have knowledge that my students don't have and can't possibly work out on their own, and (b) have some expertise in how to transfer this knowledge effectively, and I feel like at least in this chapter, Friere doesn't really account for those two circumstances very well.

phil e the theyby

Thanks for sharing this! God, Feyerabend is so fucking good. As I was reading “Against Method,” it didn’t feel like a philosophy that was developed abstractly; it felt like it was meaningfully informed by witnessing cross-cultural interactions within the field. Obviously, the end of the book confirmed that suspicion, and what you’ve shared here further deepens my understanding of how his personal experience informed his philosophy. I think it’s really cool that you spoke up in that way and challenged that norm. I’ve been thinking a lot lately about how much of our lives are centered around roles. We naturally gravitate towards the behaviors and expectations of the social roles assigned to us. Regardless of our beliefs, our behaviors tend to adhere to those norms. For people who are able to “succeed” in their roles and who feel relatively comfortable doing so, it’s rare to question the norms of your role, because doing so is basically undermining your perceived value to society. But those of us who aren’t able to succeed in our roles, or for whom doing so is deeply uncomfortable, are a lot more likely to question the foundational assumptions of those roles., and try to change what the role itself is/does. In your example, your fellow students hadn’t connected enough with their discomfort around political science and what it does (maybe they didn’t even know enough to FEEL that discomfort), so your questioning got totally shut down. I think part of critical education is awakening that discomfort in students, and I think that’s a lot of what Freire’s referring to.

phil e the theyby

@Alfalfafield I really appreciate your thoughts here! I think I read Freire’s work as focused on the development of conscientização, particularly in the context of revolutionary movements. In this chapter he discusses education generally, but I still see the focus as building one’s awareness of their own oppression. Obviously, his ideas can be applied in helpful ways across educational contexts, but I don’t think they’re INTENDED for all educational contexts. So I don’t think he’d necessarily disagree that there are educational settings where certain things need to banked; I just don’t think those are the types of education he’s really focused on or thinking about.

Isaiah G

SO appreciative of all these thoughts! @Alex I used your method today doing one of my daily problems - gathering the facts and deciding the process before executing - and it already made me feel more confident in completing the problem. I especially appreciate how your response highlights that how we get to the outcomes ("deposit" the knowledge, remember the formulas) makes a greater difference from banking than the outcomes themselves. @AJ "consciousness [is] fundamental to the relationship between new information and action" is brilliant, and extremely clarifying, I want to reread the chapter with that lens and see what comes up @Robert your analysis of the "consciousness" bit resonates with something else I've been reading by Erich Fromm, who Freire has cited a few times thus far - Fromm says that a common misconception of Marx's materialist arguments is that the material abundance itself is the ultimate human goal; he argues that it's more about removing the material constraint so we can engage in the activities that make us human, like you say. All this to say I don't think you're misunderstanding, and I think you've helped me discover a deeper throughline. Also thanks so much for sharing your experience in this and your other comment; it's definitely clear when you're working with someone who has learned by "banking", even if the harm that does is not as clear as it should be

aliin

Yeah the banking concept is used really heavily, we basically did no research on our own, just went and listened to lectures and lectures only and did homework, that was basically how my first two semesters went. Looking back a big factor for dropping out was exactly that, I was missing the part where I had to do more than memorize, where I could speak or research and you really do feel the dryness of it. And since there are soooo many students in a lecture, weirdly enough the more people there are the more anonymous everyone becomes so you don't interact with them much and don't build up a sense of unity/community until later when most (including me) drop out and classes become smaller. I still like programming and stuff but it didn't feel worth it, it just felt dulling. There were a handful of ethics lectures for later semesters but that was the extent on that side of things, and at this point I'm thankful I realized soon enough what it was that was bothering me!

Quezacoatl

Yes! His insistence on the significance of the difference between human and animal irked me to no end. I think I regularly muttered "why is that relevant" or "you cannot know that". As Freire is indebted to european Phenemonology, as can be seen in this chapter, it makes sense to me, that he would try to ground his ontology in the special position of the human ability to transform (Scheler does that a lot for example). I think it limites his scope and he should have put more emphasis on the connection to the world than its transformation, even though both are relevant for his ontological approach

Quezacoatl

What I find most interesting in this chapter, is that Freire tries to make quite academic and hard to read philosophy (Husserl is quite difficult even if german is your native language) usable for education. This kind of philosophy asks us to see the world as radically malleable in human conciousness, while still being grounded in a material reality. It is, as Freire points out, against the way we teach especially in school, to see the world in this way. I therefore sometimes joke that if you're studying philosophy and don't have a crisis regularly, you're doing it wrong, because the subject regularly asks you to question your own preconception of the world, often given through a "banking education" in school. That said, there are a lot of people studying humanities, that are unfazed by this constant questioning. They are learning these concepts as if they were taught in the banking education, and sometimes they actually are. Freire frames this as an instrument of opression, but it is also an instrument of measurment and sometimes of self protection. Learning that the world is different than you thought is scary and sometimes cataclysmic and for a lot of privileged people its much easier to just ignore that and dissosiate. This is in my opinion why its so hard to liberate people in privileged positions, they are just happy in ignorance and I don't think Freire has a good answer to that problem.

Rafael Andrade

I think I agree with you in both points. Unfortunately education in general, but specially physics is very based on the banking model. That been said, there is a lot of research and practice that try to change it. As a graduate student in physics' teaching, half my research was around this problem. I particularly like inquiry-based learning, it tries to bring some os scientists' practices to students, so they can be more active in their own learning and learn scientific ideas while learn it's process too. If any teacher would like to take a look, I recomend Margus Pedaste's article Phases of inquiry-based learning: Definitions and the inquiry cycle (DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2015.02.003). I'd really like to suggest some of my own publications they are all in portuguese, so let's pretend I'm just being humble. About the separation between humans and animals it also bothers me, and I would say it's a fatal flaw from humanism. I really like some critics Ailton Krenak, a brazilian indigenous thinker, makes about humanism, because it depends so much in drawing a line between what is human and what is not. So while Freire would praise all humans in their different manners, Krenak asks what a human in the first place, and points how this line was always used to say what/who is a non-human, and therefore wouldn't have the same rights. This distinction and also the alignment with humanism can also be related to him being really catholic and the influence the catholic left (that fought against the many USA funded dictatorships in latino-america) had in his works. All being said, I believe Freire himself would agree with this critics. In some interviews he talks about his experience, as an exiled, in many countries. He said that when he was in Tanzânia another teacher would show him the university campus and he grabbed his hand and hold her while they walked in the campus. He was really uncomfortable because he thought it was unmanly to hold another man's hand, and it was weird to him a culture in which it was normal. But later in his life he thought (and said) it must have something wrong with his (and my) own culture, for not being able to recognize and accept a gesture of affection.

Rafael Andrade

I get your point but I disagree in two ways: The first is that I don't see it as a literal dichotomy, as if you teach in a way or another, but more of an artificial dichotomy for analysis and discussion. He uses a lot of dialectics in his works, so it would make sense (to me) to define two poles that can be build up in a synthesis for your praxis. Clearly there is a good pole and bad pole in this analysis, but more in the sense of something that is invasive to the student versus that either grew within or has been invited in. So memorizing something doesn't need to be 100% in the banking model, if this memorization has meaning to the student and is greeted by him. Similarly you can make a non-expository class that can still be oppressive, by doing an activity that reinforces oppression (an extreme example is the movie The Wave). The second reason comes from the chapter 1, Freire believed that the tools of the oppressor can't be used to end oppression. In this sense education, even when the student learn, can be more of a tool for domestication and less for empowerment. This has a lot to do with the idea of epistemicide, when you kill a people not by killing the individuals but their culture. Keeping in the example of literacy, Brazil has more than 200 indigenous languages still in use, but they shrink every year, and so do the number of speakers because most indigenous communities doesn't have a bilingual school, therefore most of their vocabulary is in Portuguese. That being said, this book is more academic so it can get a bit far from reality in some points. Maybe you would like to give a look in Pedagogy of Freedom. He wrote it 30 years after Pedagogy of the Oppressed and it written for teachers, so it is a bit lighter and talks more about the practice of teaching, bringing points similar to what you said, like that teachers shouldn't be authoritarian, but they are authorities, and that has to do to the responsibility you have as a professional. Most undergraduate teaching courses in Brazil use more Pedagogy of Freedom than Pedagogy of the Oppressed because of this (Not saying that's the right choice, but that's how it goes). Some of his teaching methodology could be interesting for you too, since he worked majorly giving literacy classes to illiterate adult peasants.

Rafael Andrade

As a fellow physics teacher I understand the frustration. Sometimes it can be really hard to distance ourselves from more traditional classes, but there is a lot we can do! The most direct approach to talk about the relation of Science and Social problems is through STS. Some examples I like to bring up in my classes is to talk about urban planning while teaching kinematics (I recommend the channel 'Not Just Bikes' to get some ideas) as well as the cold war and military uses of rockets. Or even going through the history of Industrial Revolution to talk about thermodynamics. Another approach I really like is the Inquiry-based teaching (I talked about it in another comment but I'm linking it here as well), you can give a look in Margus Pedaste's article 'Phases of inquiry-based learning: Definitions and the inquiry cycle' (DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2015.02.003).

Rafael Andrade

I guess I got a little late this week so most of my points got dispersed responding other comments, but I still want to leave here my favorite quote from this chapter: "Indeed, the interests of the oppressors lie in 'changing the consciousness of the oppressed, not the situation which oppresses them'; for the more the oppressed can be led to adapt to that situation, the more easily they can be dominated." (p. 74) Also, the necrophiliac comment was brutal. That's a savage way to critic gamefication in education and other behavioristic approachs to teaching and learning.

Alfalfafield

Thanks for this insightful reply Rafael! I thought it was very clarifying. I'll definitely check out the Pedagogy of Freedom after I finish this one.

AJ Biffl

I really like those suggestions Rafael, thank you! I'll definitely have to try them. I also want to say that actually following through with this stuff is difficult enough on its own, even after you ideate a plan to do it. I still find myself falling into "banking-style" comments when answering questions, like "this part is wrong," or "this is how you do this, this is what you're supposed to do." I think part of it is because of how the class I TA is structured, but some of it is also habit.

Warren Shull

The second paragraph of the chapter remind me of the quote "The mind is not a vessel to be filled, but a fire to be kindled." Shortly after that, a sentence on the second page of the chapter reminded me of something that happened in my job recently (I'm a math professor): "In the banking concept of education, knowledge is a gift bestowed by those who consider themselves knowledgeable upon those whom they consider to know nothing." This past spring, I was proctoring an exam for another professor who was out of town. I thought I saw a typo in one of the questions, and I emailed the professor (who I knew was actively watching his email). He responded with an explanation of why two particular ways of writing the question were equivalent, and said that what he wrote was consistent with what he had done in the past. It was clear to me why those two ways were equivalent, but neither actually matched what was on the page. (For those wondering, it had to do with diagonalization of matrices. He described how A=P^{-1}DP or A=QDQ^{-1} are equivalent, but the page said D=P^{-1}DA. I could be mistaken, but I don't know how that can be correct with P^{-1} being included but no P anywhere.) I wrote again to ask if he was sure, and tried to explain why I found this phrasing strange. He simply responded "Yes I'm sure" and offered no further explanation. None of the students ever asked me about it, and if he did find it had been a typo later he never told me. I'm not sure how much, if any, it affected how the students answered the question. But I have to wonder a few things: 1) Was his response partly informed by how he perceived my background/status relative to his own? For context, he was recently promoted to "full Professor" while I am a recently hired "Teaching Assistant Professor." He specializes in an area of math that would use matrices a lot (Algebra), while I specialize elsewhere. So it had been a while since I took this course as a student, but he could have reasonably assumed I had taken it at some point. I wonder, if the person proctoring had been someone else with similar status and expertise, whether he would have taken a second look. 2) Was this partly driven by an inflated ego? I can imagine how a promotion to the highest available rank would feed someone's ego. 3) Is this something that underrepresented populations in STEM experience on a regular basis? I'm a white man (as is the other professor), and it's not common for me to *knowingly* witness any form of implicit bias directly. I have heard it talked about in certain circles, but I don't usually learn the details of what happens. When I teach, I try very hard to appeal to what is mutually observable and understandable, rather than to any person's authority/status including my own. I'm wondering if underrepresented populations regularly experience the opposite, and if this is a good (relatively mild) example of that.

elke

Bit late to the party but my two cents on the second chapter... The concept of banking and teaching by requiring rote repetition without understanding of context or learning to think critically reminds me of a chapter in Sand Talk by Tyson Yunkaporta where he talks about the Prussian model of education in chapter 'Advanced and Fair'. He says that the Prussian model was developed from wild animal domestication techniques to slow down social emotional and intellectual development so it would take years rather than months to move from childhood to adulthood (months as in indigenous rites of passage for example). The strategy adopted was 1. Separate the young from their parents in daylight hours 2. Confine them in an enclosed space with limited stimulation or access to natural habitat 3. Use rewards and punishments to force them to comply with purposeless tasks And then as in Freire treat them as an empty vessel to be filled with lessons from the teacher. It's also that bit about not being taught to be critical and not being taught in a way that places/shows knowledge within spatial, relational, temporal/ historical contexts. They're just pieces of information to be rote learned without any understanding of the where the why the how etc. I think a lot about how the English language is very noun based and focuses on categorising everything (English was a lingua franca/ trade language so it's roots are capitalistic and colonial). There's a chapter in Braiding Sweetgrass that compares the noun based English language and it's categorising of things without relationship to each other with verb based indigenous languages like Ojibwe. Kimmerer talks of how resistant she felt to Saturday as a verb that it was ridiculous (what we are taught is that Saturday can't be in relationship it can only be a thing) . And then discovering the word wiikwegamaa "to be a bay". That the water can be a bay for a time and then be an ocean for a time and how understanding the world as alive and moving started to break apart the oppressive methods of teaching and learning: "This is the language I hear in the woods; this is the language that let's us speak of what wells up all around us. And the vestiages of boarding schools, the soap-welding missionary wraiths, hang their heads in defeat." Anyway I'm really enjoying the book. The constant 'men and women' thing is weird and clunky af though - just say people 😅

Dr. Fatima

wow that's such an upsetting but also apt comparison... I feel like usually when I've thought of the banking model of education, I think of it as just not as effective as other models, or maybe like, politically placating , but this makes me really see it as being actually intellectually damaging. curious to see if there ed research on this---thanks for sharing the connection!

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Much like last week, reading everyone’s contributions to the discussion is really exciting and inspiring. First of all, I want to share that reading what you all said about chapter one contributed a lot to my understanding of it. Dr. Fatima answered to my comment asking if perhaps the content felt stale to me because it was indeed old, and since its publication Freire’s book has become such a staple in discussions about education, and she couldn’t be more right. Not only the book has been hugely influential in the last half century, but it has had a profound impact in the specific educational settings I was immersed in most of my life, which might have contributed to my ‘desensitization’ to it. Reading how all of you responded to the text was actually very informative and really renewed my hope in the power of Freire’s work. To see how reflective chapter one made our bunch of reader was heartening.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Now for chapter two, I wanna say thank grandpa, your work has made me possible. I grew up in a big brazilian metropolis, inside a left-wing progressive household, and from the age of two I was enrolled in a small private-owned school that took Freire’s work as seriously as Piaget’s and Vygotsky’s. All of my education was in that same school, until I took my university entry exams at 17. Schools are always schools, full of flaws and problems and biases, but as far as schools go, I had a lot of freedom as a pupil, and most of my teachers actively engaged with us in problem-posing education. When I started university I enrolled for a social sciences degree, and I immediately realized I’d been taught to interact with new knowledge in a radically different way when compared with most my peers. Problem-posing is the way I was first learned *think* in a structured way. And yet, reading this chapter still felt new to me. I found myself questioning what exactly is baking education beyond its aesthetics. The thing is, for a long time I’ve thought “I know baking education is crap, but it actually works for me” (because I find it easy to “memorize” pieces of information I’ve been exposed to and because I feel I’m able to “pose problems” by myself when presented with new knowledge). And reading this chapter I realized that actually – no. Not at all. Baking education doesn’t work for anyone and it never worked for me. The fact that I actually enjoy long lectures has nothing to do with baking education, because baking education is a philosophical and epistemological stance, not a method per se. A lecture (or a youtube video!) can be problem-posing, while a very interactive *gamified* “PBL” lesson can be baking, depending on what they are servicing.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

the "men and women" thing is a translator's choice, in portuguese Freire often opts for "men" when meaning "people", which is uncomfortable but understandable for his historical time =/

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

"Not just bikes" is a great chanel!! I'm Brazilian and I lived in the Netherlands for a year as a teen and the difference in urban planing was one of the biggest cultural shocks to me xD

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Overall, I enjoyed Chapter 2 much much more than the Chapter 1, mostly because I actually felt challenged by the text. It made me stop and think and reevaluate past experiences and current convictions. One of the things I found most profound from this chapter is how Freire articulates what it is to be “in and with the world”. This struck me as truly beautiful, to be “in and with”. And this passage feel very, very relevant and impossible to ignore to anyone inside a classroom: “The teacher cannot think for her students, nor can she impose her thought on them. Authentic thinking, thinking that is concerned about reality, does not take place in ivory tower isolation, but only in communication.” It urges: listen to students. Listen to them profoundly, take them seriously in your effort to really answer and stablish a dialogue. Soliloquies can’t teach, they can only expose. I also mourned some inevitabilities – and some choices – in translation. “Problem-posing education” seems pale in comparison with “educação problematizadora” and that’s because “problematizadora” does not derive from “problem” per se, but from “problematization”. Freire wants teachers and students to “problematize” together: not only to “pose” problems, as one would pose questions, but to create problems, to see problems where one once saw normalcy. Another note on translations there is a particular passage: “no one teaches another, nor is anyone self-taught. People teach each other, mediated by the world”. “Teach” in portuguese is “ensinar”, “learn” is “aprender” and “educate” is “educar”. In this passage, Freire does not use “ensinar” but “educar”. My translation of this sentence into english would be: “no one educates anyone, no one educates themselves. People educate each other, mediated by the world”. This feels deeper than just “teaching”. Ofcourse in many contexts the teacher possess knowledge the students don’t have. Of course some people are self-taught in some subjects. This is not what this passage pertains to. He is talking about the profound social nature of education itself, not only about “teaching”. I feel like the translation opens doors to misinterpretation, as I’ve seen someone highlighted this particular quote to “disagree” with, but taking the more literal meaning of ‘teaching’ instead of ‘educating’. And yet still. The whole thing is beautiful, so I’ll leave it here so you can read it again: “Through dialogue, the teacher-of-the-students and the students-of-the-teacher cease to exist and a new term emerges: teacher-student with students-teachers. The teacher is no longer merely the-one-who-teaches, but one who is himself taught in dialogue with the students, who in turn while being taught also teach. They become jointly responsible for a process in which all grow. In this process, arguments based on "authority" are no longer valid; in order to function, authority must be on the side of freedom, not against it. Here, no one teaches another, nor is anyone self-taught. People teach each other, mediated by the world, by the cognizable objects which in banking education are "owned" by the teacher.”

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Thanks for sharing all of this! I wanna read Feyerabend so bad now. The passage you brought up made me think of my own experience when I worked in a clinic that catared mostly to black people living is slums, me being a white (in my cultural context) middle-class professional in health care. Of course I had a lot of technical knowledge that could objectively make any *human body* 'healthier'. But what did I really have to offer to the people I interacted daily with? I felt very out of my depth, but also very motivated to learn. And what I did was listen to them. Let them teach me what 'health' meant to each person I saw, and try to put my backgroud in their service. How to best achieve the goals they set for themselves. I always told every patient they were the specialists in their own bodies and in the symptoms they'd lived with. What had they tried before? Had it worked? For how long? What would they be willing to try? I didn't work with everyone -- a few people insisted I was the 'doctor' and I should therefore 'prescribe'. But mostly, it really worked, because the changes people made in their lives had been decided by them and not by me. I was there to support, not command. And somethings are out of my depth completely, and I have to learn to live with that. My own limitations are enourmous and some are insurmountable. That has to be fine. There are other people around with qualities to fill the gaps. And now I'm a TA in a class for people studing medicine, and it's so great to see such diverse faces who will be doctors in the next years...

arcie m

I've been thinking a lot about the banking model, and ways to reject it, in my teaching for the past year. I really want to get beyond just having students do problems in class, even in groups. Even though the alternative to the banking model is called "problem posing," just giving students math problems to work on, even hard ones, doesn't provide the occasion to "develop their power to perceive critically the way they exist in the world." Last summer, I had students keep "math journals" in which they recorded observations that lead to math (algebraic relationships or function/derivative concepts) from their everyday lives. This past semester, I had my stats students do secondary research, including finding and analyzing datasets, that they would share in-class regularly; I also had my Math for Trades students find stuff to measure for themselves and calculate with, that they could then write up as their own word problems as conclusions. The throughline here is that I want to create opportunities for students to be experts in their own right, to utilize their authorities over their own experience, to cultivate their own ways of knowing math, instead of me "depositing" math knowledge or even math problem solving knowledge. I still need students to learn how to solve math problems. On one hand, that is at least an "act of cognition" so it's better than depositing something like, "2 times 2 is 4." On the other hand, the method to solve a math problem is still something that I'm depositing in a student's head, whether I show them how I do it or do some scaffolding until they can figure out how to do it themselves. We're not teaching each other. So I wonder, is it oppressive to teach that? Given that it is, how do we navigate the contradictions of harm reduction and liberatory pedagogy?

elke

Hi yeah thanks i realise the reason it's just clunky and distracting is all :)

elke

It's very upsetting isn't it. I really felt like school felt like this for me. There's def stuff out there but Tyson used an indigenous method of inquiry which meant he went deeper than most would. I believe he went through the earliest Prussian syllabuses and old federation documents to build up the history. The chapter (and book) is well worth a read

Koshika Yadava

A student perspective here. I was not enthusiatic about physics in school for a number of reasons. But one textbook that drew me into into physics was Resnik and halliday because each chapter started with a problem i felt invited to ponder upon..reading your comment made me think of it rhough this was a very very long time ago

AJ Biffl

Love hearing your thoughts on the translation! I'm always curious when I read translated works if nuances or implications of phrases got lost because there's no direct parallel in english. That's an insightful distinction, "teaching" vs "educating" in that passage

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Hi there. The work you've been doing sounds amazing! bet the pay off is very rewarding even if coming up with the lectures is not the simplest thing. I learned maths in a similar context as the one you are trying to provide to your students, and I’m really grateful for that. I wanted to comment on this thing you said: “On the other hand, the method to solve a math problem is still something that I'm depositing in a student's head, whether I show them how I do it or do some scaffolding until they can figure out how to do it themselves. We're not teaching each other.” I must say I disagree. For all you are telling me, you are not depositing anything “in the students head”. Freire says in the chapter “the teacher cannot think for the students”. No true knowledge is ever deposited, I think (and Freire says). Knowledge is not a thing that ever *can* be “transferred”. Knowledge is gained in educative social interacions throught acts of cognition. Good teachers, problem-posing teachers, help students gain awereness of solvable and unsolvable problems. When we talk about “learning by rote memorization” we are not talking about teaching, actually. The fact that some people are able to learn for real even though all they had was baking education is due to them being able to think for themselves on the basis of what was offered to them. They had to perform their own acts of cognition, almost alone. Some people memorize but don’t learn, so they can’t properly apply those things they memorized. Context changes a bit and they find they don’t understand how to proceed. People who actually learned can adapt and apply what they learned in different contexts. What Freire is saying is that the teacher, if he wants his students to actually learn, can’t rely on just “showing how it’s done”. I think it’s important to recognize that in this particular book Freire is talking about education in general, and using examples from the classroom, but his main interest is in discussing how progressive political leaderships approach their interactions with the “masses”. His “target audience” is the brazilian would-be revolutionaries who wanted to convince the population to join in the struggle for a more democratic or even socialist future. Freire worked close with people fought mainly for agrarian reform and land expropriation and redistribution. He is an educator, but this particular work is not aimed most most specially at teachers inside regular schools. For that, I recommend his later book "Pedagogy of Freedom”. Now back to the thing you are struggling with: from what I’ve read from Freire’s other work, it becomes pretty clear that he doesn’t see the classroom as a space that is 100% horizontal where teachers and students learn together the exact same thing. In the Pedagogy of Freedom he talks about how some people read his work and interpreted it as if he as proposing a classroom where the teacher has no authority, and he is quick to disabuse this notion. The teacher does posses knowledge the students don’t yet have, and this is important. The fact people “educate each other” does not mean that they teach the same thing to each other or that they learn the same things at the same time. The teacher has a duty to help his students perform acts of cognition that will lead them to learning things that the teacher already knows – such as how to solve a math problem. That is not “depositing”. The fact that students leave you class knowing how to solve math problems is not a testament to the fact you’ve deposited it in their heads (because knowledge is not depositable). If students left you class having memorized a few formulas and algorithms, that could be a deposit, but it doesn’t seem to be the case. Similarly, the teachers should be leaning new things with their students and from their students, and should be also open to revise things they already think they know when confronted with students’ reasoning – but that does not mean you have to learn how to solve the same math problem you already learned how to solve. You and your students should educate each other, dialogically, as in: you can learn, for example, new ways to teach, or how to overcome specific limitations your methods carried…

Dr. Fatima

i'm so glad the conversations between everyone are helpful 🥹

Dr. Fatima

It's really cool to see how someone teaching math might apply non-banking pedagogy, thanks for sharing! The things you're trying remind me of a book we read here last year called "A Mathematician's Lament" by Paul Lockhart and the second part of it was his attempt at showing how we might teach math in less cookie-cutter ways than what is standard currently. I'd recommend it if you haven't seen it, the book is extremely short (actually it was just an essay first, and he somewhat expanded it to publish as a book), the only issue I think it has is his methods work best with small class sizes that allow a lot of teacher-student interaction (which i suppose is the difficulty with a lot of non-banking pedagogic methods)

Dr. Fatima

Also thanks for the context around who he wrote this book for Maria--I imagine we'll make our way to "Pedagogy of Freedom" in a later book club

Koshika Yadava

This is my favorite bit too and reminded me of a more something from david graeber about how we are acts of mutual cocreation (paraphrasing here , dont remember the exact words)

cyphrsphyr

Page 79. "Liberating education,...and students on the other. [cont'd] ...the teacher student contradiction needs to be resolved." This is an example of good oracle. A second thought: continuation beyond banking, or thwarting the depositor? (the whole/student-v-teacher) Page 85. Molding an object for bank. Bad oracle. Page 86. Problem-posing education,...in their humanization. The actions of good oracles, over the deceit of bad oracles.

Travis

Themes that resonated with me: everything is relational, to be human is to be curious, curiosity is creativity, thought transforms us Things i was thinking about while reading this chapter: common core, Intergroup Dialogue Project (IDP), and a 2018 article about Orthodox Jewish schools. Common core: these curricular standards and top-down directives about what kids learn creates even further alienation of the teacher from their students. And in this we can see clearly the difference bw a reactionary educator and a liberatory one. The reactionary, aware of their own limited agency, is acutely aware of students being lower on the hierarchy and demands they “know their place”. The liberatory educator realizes that they and the students share a common enemy- the state- and works to foster a sense of humanity and agency in the classroom. IDP: During my university orientation, everyone had to attend an IDP session so they could learn to not be racist, homophobic, etc. of course many people saw it as a joke and didnt engage with the process genuinely. One of the memes that still lives in my head is the phrase “we are all teachers and learners”. 2018 article: “What Yeshiva kids are actually studying all day” by Moshe Krakowski. Personally i am minimally familiar with this branch of Judaism and the discourse about the extent to which it is inherently oppressive, but i know there ARE a lot of feelings about it. So i take this article with a grain of salt. But what it argues is that Yeshivas actually specialize in nourishing critical thinking and awareness of subjectivity.

Quezacoatl

There is a similar discussion of language in Carl Mika's "Indigenous Education and the Metaphysics of Presence" where he compares english with Maori language. He combines a similar analysis of the noun centred english language with what Derrida calls the "metaphysics of presence", a view of the world that prefers static and present object to processes and movements

elke

Ohh ty this sounds ace will read ❤️