Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Happy Friday everyone~

It’s time to start the next book club! As I’ve mentioned, we’ll be reading a subset of the essay from Karl Popper’s “Conjecture and Refutations” (available in a bunch of digital formats for free here). I picked a set of three that I think show a range of his work from the straight science philosophy to his commentary on politics. Here’s the plan:

  • Monday Sept 1: Chapter 11 - The Demarcation Between Science and Metaphysics

  • Monday Sept 8: Chapter 16 - Prediction and Prophecy in the Social Sciences

  • Monday Sept 15: Chapter 17 - Public Opinion and Liberal Principles 

So on each of these Mondays, I will make a post here on Patreon and the discussion of the relevant chapter will take place in the comments over the following week. I’m going to continue what I did last round and insert my thoughts as participant comments like everyone else rather than putting my top level commentary in the post itself. 

For the last week of September, we’ll either do another collaborative live writing session or I was thinking maybe if people get into Popper and want to read another essay or two, we could potentially do that instead. We’ll see how things shake out in the first weeks and figure it out then. But for now, if you wanna participate, I’d recommend starting the first reading soon bc it’s much longer than the other (40 pgs vs ~10 pages). 

Excited to start reading this with you all!

fatima

Comments

AJ Biffl

I feel more rational already

Jacques Vincelette

Sorry, I started reading on August 6, distracting from the 80th anniversary of Little Boy on Hiroshima. The Einstein-Russel manifesto suggested a decade later “Shall we put an end to the human race; or shall mankind renounce war?” Proof built answer ulfalsifiable under current economics.

john melesky

I note that the first essay discussion is scheduled for Labor Day. Coincidence?

Ryan Messina

I am going to try and commit to this one!

Ryan Messina

Oh no, I have only just starting reading it and oh boy is this going to be hard. My quick take of Karl in a nut shell: -Constant flattening of complexity and talks in absolutes. -Obsessed with authority, truth and law. So far I believe he thinks epistemology is these things. -His knowledge extends as far as ancient philosophy and religion. And it appears he believes these are the true sources... -He speaks in ways were the stakes are high, in absolutes or nothing at all. There is no nuance. Its his way or no way. Then says stuff like “Its simple, its A or B (and from his crazy logic line you wouldn't want to appear in B.)” -Assigns morality to objectivity and claims its an optimistic view, not like those pessimist. So are I don't even think this is going to get to any interesting conversation like linear and nonlinear systems, emergence or feedback. What I have seen so far would reject the existence of such fields of control theory, information theory and game theory as they cant exist in this world. The question I do want to know from reading this is, what is Karl afraid of? Like, I see no consequence if you just ignore what he is saying.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

I have very very vague recollections of reading Popper's "The Open Society and Its Enemies" for a philosophy class I took in 2011 or 2012. I'm actually excited to come into contact with his writing again now from a very different perspective.