Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

I said recently that I would announce the book club for a book I’ve been very excited to read with the release of an upcoming video, and this is not that. I’m doing something very unlike myself right now and that is, rather than working on solely one video at a time and releasing it before I start researching the next one, I’m simultaneously researching/writing/conducting interviews for three different videos at once. I don’t know why, it’s just kind of happening like this, but we’re rolling with it. As such, it might be a second before I put out a video (though I imagine that once I put out one, the next two will drop shortly thereafter).  Point is, I didn't want to keep book club on hold till I release a video so here we goooo

Our next reading is a selection of essays from the book "Agnotology: The Making and Unmaking of Ignorance”, Edited by Robert N. Proctor and Londa Schiebinger. I started reading it today as part of my research for a video on whatever you’d call the opposite of scientific knowledge’s constructedness, and so far it’s super interesting and quite accessibly written, so I figure it’d make a great book club choice.

You can find an online version here and I’ll additionally attach a pdf of the full text to this post for anyone who wants to read it virtually/is waiting on a physical copy.

Our weekly discussion posts will go up each Wednesday, starting next Wednesday 1/21, reading one essay per week. As usual, I’ll put up the weekly post for the given text, we’ll have discussions in the comments section, and then if there’s interest we’ll do something at the end to conclude the book. I have a selection of four essays to start with below, but if we feel like it we can add a few more after (or maybe do something like some people read one each of the other essays and we share to each other about it? Instead of the collaborative live writing session? In addition? Idk we’ll see, feel free to offer thoughts). Anyways here’s the schedule*:

  • 1/21: Essay 1 - “Anotology: A Missing Term to Describe the Cultural Production of Ignorance (and Its Study)” (36 pages)

  • 1/28: Essay 3 - “Challenging Knowledge: how Climate Science Became a Victim of the Cold War" (18 pages)

  • 2/4: Essay 6 - “West Indian Abortifacients and the Making of Ignorance" (14 pages)

  • 2/11: Essay 10 - “White Ignorance” (20 pages)

Looking forward to reading together, as well as the video this is going into!

*i changed the selection of essays from when I first made this post, may change the last one again

Comments

Kurt Mendez

Seems interesting enough. But there's an obvious gaping hole in all of this and it's the superstition of religion. Are these essays intentionally light-handed? And intentionally non-controversial? Or are these incomplete thoughts painting an incomplete picture? It appears that way, at least to me. Given the usual human despotism behind the psychology in this series of essays. And I'm actually astounded that no one in that book seems to be concerned about the danger and slippery darkness that is: willfully embracing logical fallacies, as well as, the personal accountability behind such thoughts that lead to actions, subconscious or otherwise. And please excuse my pointed thoughts. As I assure you that my tone is not one of ungraciousness or challenge. I'm merely an eternally obtrusive student. And furthermore, I apologize if my freewheeling candor struck you as the unpleasantness known as contradiction. As I admire you greatly, and my conscience enjoys supporting you. ❤️

Doug Greer

I read this book when I saw it referenced in Philip Mirowski's research article: Hell is Truth Seen Too Late. Here is a video about the research article: https://youtu.be/QBB4POvcH18?si=A5yKYFpeo_AwSgk3 . The research article has been posted to read for free... Hell Is Truth Seen Too Late by Philip Mirowski; boundary 2 (2019) 46 (1): 1–53 https://read.dukeupress.edu/boundary-2/article/46/1/1/137342/Hell-Is-Truth-Seen-Too-Late Have you read Mirowski's work on the NTC and their crusade to dominate science?

Jacques Vincelette

Stanford University Press might not address the gaping hole of the superstition of science as religious devotion, but tiptoes at the edge of the well with research reduced to strategic marketing tool.