"Agnotology" Essay #1: “Agnotology: A Missing Term to Describe the Cultural Production of Ignorance (and Its Study)”, by Robert N. Proctor (Patreon)
Content
*NOTE: I changed the choice of essays we'll read in the coming weeks from when I first made the schedule post for this book (and may do so again!) so read ahead with caution---next week's reading is Essay 3 - “Challenging Knowledge: how Climate Science Became a Victim of the Cold War"
~~~~~
"Ignorance can be made or unmade, and science can be complicit in either process."
I'm gonna share a couple of passages/thoughts/questions that struck me, but don't take that as a boundary for the discussion; please share comments/questions on whatever you found interesting!
~~~~~
Of the three categories of ignorance Proctor introduces in this essay, the one I'm most interested in at the moment is the second: "Ignorance as Lost Realm, or Selective Choice (Or Passive Construct)". If you've seen my video on gravity/dark matter, this passage probably feels familiar:
"...inquiry is always selective. We look here rather than there...the decision to focus on this is therefore invariably a choice to ignore that. Ignorance is a product of inattention, and since we cannot study all things, some by necessity—almost all, in fact—must be left out. "A way of seeing is also a way of not seeing—a focus upon object A involves a neglect of object B."
Proctor goes on to ponder "how [we should] regard...knowledge not yet known?", and describes an attitude towards the progression of knowledge that I'm hoping to challenge in a video I'm working on:
"Selectivity is often conceived as transient, evanescent, a kind of "noise" in the system or scatter about the line, with bias slowly being rectified. Science is like mowing your lawn: you can choose any place to start, but things end up looking pretty much the same.
The context I see this idea play out in is in a counterargument to constructivist takes on science: yes, we can't study everything everywhere all at once, but we'll eventually get to validating everything that needs validating and disproving everything that needs disproving, so it hardly matters that there's more investment in (to put it in terms of my gravity example) dark matter than MOND---even given non-scientific reasons for why might be focused on investigating one over the other currently, the scientific process will get to truth of the matter eventually.
The question I'm interested in is, what consequences might arise from our choices of what we aren't currently prioritizing? What are the outcomes of choosing to 'mow the lawn' in this pattern instead of that one? Even if we take the position that science is more like "the progressive illumination of a well-defined box" instead of the position that "darkness grows as fast as the light" (which I don't buy for a second, but just for the sake of argument let's go with it), what happens as a result of the choice to progress through our construction of all the knowledge along this path rather than that path?
I'm curious as to a) whether this even makes sense as a question to people and b) if any examples of such selectivity based consequences come to mind for anyone? I have a few key examples in mind that I'm exploring for the video, but it's always nice to have a range of examples.
~~~~~
Another passage I found relevant to a completely different video I'm working on was towards the end, under the passage "Virtuous Ignorance? 'Not Knowing' as Resistance or Moral Caution":
"If knowledge is power (which it sometimes is but not always), then to dismantle certain kinds of power may require the reintroduction of bodies of ignorance--hence importance--in that realm. History is full of such undoings, the deliberate abandonment of skills to improve some way of life...Refusals of technology are often of this sort. We often hear that you can't turn the clock back, an idea as absurd as the notion that thieves cannot be brought to justice. It is not only for foolishness that technologies have been avoided, refused, or abandoned.
In Ireland, the eel fishermen of Lough Neagh no longer fish with power-driven nets; a decision was made in the 1960s to restrict all fishing in the lake to hand-drawn nets, to sustain the diminishing stocks. Leaf blowers are being banned in many communities, and many of us look forward to the day when doctored monocrop lawns will be seen as pathology. The Japanese lived for more than a hundred years without the gun. Protests against novel technologies are often lumped under the ridiculous rubric of "luddism," a term too often forgotten to have sprung from moral complaints with good reasons...the breaking of looms in the early decades of the nineteenth century gave rise to the modern industrial strike (for better working conditions); protests against technologies and knowledge practices are rarely the result of people fearing modernity in the abstract."
So I immediately thought of the conversation around AI when I read this, particularly the divide between the pragmatic take of "well it's here, let's deal with it" and the divester take of "we still have time to reject it". I lean more towards the former because I think the latter misses the potential in contending with harms that are already happening in the present moment, but this passage had me wondering whether it is actually possible to put the genie back in the bottle, so to speak. If I'm honest I don't find Proctor's argument here very compelling--fishing nets and leaf blowers are pretty niche technologies that were only rejected on small scales, the Japanese definitely have guns at this point, and the comparison to luddites falls flat to me considering the machines they destroyed (not on the basis of existing at all btw, but only in contexts where employers were using them to undermine standard labor practices) were definitely still used and even further developed.
I don't want to be defeatist about harmful technologies, and I don't love calling people's idealism naive, but I have yet to see an actually compelling case for the potential of un-introducing harmful technologies (except maybe idk chlorofluorocarbons? again, pretty niche). Any thoughts, AI or otherwise? Can the genie ever really be put back in the bottle?