"Agnotology" Essay #3: “Challenging Knowledge: How Climate Science Became a Victim of the Cold War”, by Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway (Patreon)
Content
*NOTE: I changed the choice of essays we'll read in the coming weeks from when I first made the schedule post for this book (and may do so again!) so read ahead with caution---next week's reading is Essay 6 - “West Indian Abortifacients and the Making of Ignorance"
i think most of the comment responses last week were about what I wrote and less about the text itself so I'm gonna (try to) write less this week and encourage everyone to share their own impressions!
~~~~~
so first off, this was such a fascinating history to learn about and i immediately want to make a video titled something like 'the physicists who made up climate denial'. i haven't made a video about climate change yet (even though its kinda a big topic in the venn diagram between 'science' and 'progressive politics') because i haven't felt like I have any kind of new perspective to add to the conversation, but wow, Jastrow and his buddies are really a fantastic example of how legitimate scientists (an astrophysicist, no less!) can do nominally legitimate science in service of literally the opposite of "finding the truth". wild shit
~~~~~
In the early 1990s, underscoring uncertainty became the official strategy of the U.S. Republican Party. In a now-famous memo...Republican pollster and media advisor Frank Luntz urged candidates in the 1992 mid-term elections to use scientific uncertainty as a political tactic. "The scientific debate remains open" he wrote emphatically. "Voters believe that there is no consensus about global warming. Should the public come to believe that the scientific issues are settled, their views about global warming will change accordingly. Therefore, you need to continue to make the lack of scientific certainty a primary issue in the debate."
So this was the strategy by which a bunch of physicists manufactured ignorance on the harms of smoking, various pollutants, and greenhouse gas emissions, all in order to protect the "radical free market ideology opposing any kind of restriction on the pursuit of market capitalism". Tides have obviously turned on cigarettes and CFCs, while the climate change uncertainty they cultivated is still alive and well. But what struck me about reading this in 2026 is how I think this strategy is now leveraged in situations where scientists don't even have to generate skeptical science, and instead reactionaries can just take advantage of the dearth of information about, say, the marginalization of certain populations. some examples that come to mind are around trans people: what seem like the obvious benefits of gender-affirming care or the reasonableness of their inclusion in gendered sports are contested on the basis of outlandish worst-case scenario hypotheticals, with conservatives citing a lack of certain safety as reason enough to not move forward. combine that with the relative newness/limitedness of scientific validation of these topics for obvious historical reasons and...well i don't want to give too much of the script i'm working on away~
~~~~~
also I HAVE to mention Myanna Lahsen's proposition that envious physicists were denying cliamte change to win back their prestige---the authors of the essay don't seem keen on the theory, but idk I have a lot of faith in the ego of physicists...what'd you think? is "physics envy" just projection??