Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

*NOTE: I changed the choice of essays we'll read in the coming weeks from when I first made the schedule post for this book (and may do so again!) so read ahead with caution---next week's reading is Essay 6 - “West Indian Abortifacients and the Making of Ignorance"

i think most of the comment responses last week were about what I wrote and less about the text itself so I'm gonna (try to) write less this week and encourage everyone to share their own impressions!

~~~~~

so first off, this was such a fascinating history to learn about and i immediately want to make a video titled something like 'the physicists who made up climate denial'. i haven't made a video about climate change yet (even though its kinda a big topic in the venn diagram between 'science' and 'progressive politics') because i haven't felt like I have any kind of new perspective to add to the conversation, but wow, Jastrow and his buddies are really a fantastic example of how legitimate scientists (an astrophysicist, no less!) can do nominally legitimate science in service of literally the opposite of "finding the truth". wild shit

~~~~~

In the early 1990s, underscoring uncertainty became the official strategy of the U.S. Republican Party. In a now-famous memo...Republican pollster and media advisor Frank Luntz urged candidates in the 1992 mid-term elections to use scientific uncertainty as a political tactic. "The scientific debate remains open" he wrote emphatically. "Voters believe that there is no consensus about global warming. Should the public come to believe that the scientific issues are settled, their views about global warming will change accordingly. Therefore, you need to continue to make the lack of scientific certainty a primary issue in the debate."

So this was the strategy by which a bunch of physicists manufactured ignorance on the harms of smoking, various pollutants, and greenhouse gas emissions, all in order to protect the "radical free market ideology opposing any kind of restriction on the pursuit of market capitalism". Tides have obviously turned on cigarettes and CFCs, while the climate change uncertainty they cultivated is still alive and well. But what struck me about reading this in 2026 is how I think this strategy is now leveraged in situations where scientists don't even have to generate skeptical science, and instead reactionaries can just take advantage of the dearth of information about, say, the marginalization of certain populations. some examples that come to mind are around trans people: what seem like the obvious benefits of gender-affirming care or the reasonableness of their inclusion in gendered sports are contested on the basis of outlandish worst-case scenario hypotheticals, with conservatives citing a lack of certain safety as reason enough to not move forward. combine that with the relative newness/limitedness of scientific validation of these topics for obvious historical reasons and...well i don't want to give too much of the script i'm working on away~

~~~~~

also I HAVE to mention Myanna Lahsen's proposition that envious physicists were denying cliamte change to win back their prestige---the authors of the essay don't seem keen on the theory, but idk I have a lot of faith in the ego of physicists...what'd you think? is "physics envy" just projection??

Comments

AlexTheTutor

World War 2 changed a lot: countries changed, institutions changed, and the people changed. Everything changed as a response to the events of World War 2. So, during the Cold War, not only were there mechanisms already in place for those in-the-know to reshape a new world order post-WW2, but the most important thing was the mentality: The motivation was there for change to happen. That changed was driven out of a continual sense of needing to survive, perhaps a bit out of fear. Hence, if those in power feared the spread of communism and did what it took to make sure it never spread, then those in power would have the experience and the perspective to identify other dangerous beliefs: Climate change. They would apply similar tactics in preventing the spread of communism to preventing the spread of the belief in climate change. Also, military industrial complex --> monetary incentive to maintain status quo of eliminating communism and or any other bad belief (after all, we all need a clear purpose, what more clear purpose does one need than the belief that the work you do can save the country) Also also, smoking cigarettes is visceral: eventually within a generation or so, we can see with our own eyes the effects that a lifetime of smoking can cause. But, the climate? The weather is so… chaotic and requires an understanding in math and science. “Just look at the chart, it’s obvious”, no it is not, reading a chart requires math and science skills. Reading written words in any language is not an obvious skill that one learns by osmosis; how would understanding what is being written be somehow assumed as obvious? It is not. There is a lot of information within the system in 2026. There is too much information. The rate of growth of this information is also quite big. There is too much entropy. There is too much entropic flux. And yet, here is the crux of the issue: If the rate of collective learning is far less than the rate of generated information and far less than what is required to understand relevant prior truthful information, what grand movement does one expect to happen without ordering such information and its rate beforehand? Particularly when the will to do so does not exist within enough of the members within said system? The system as a whole will not be able to predict or prevent any disaster, the only option the system has is to adapt in real-time to any changes to itself.

Rafael Matos

This chapter just made me think about the future of my country. I am from Portugal and this week Portugal legalized lobbying. It was already legal at the European Union level, so it already affected us, but it wasn't legal inside the country. And in this chapter there are many examples of how a small group of people with a lot of money from investors can create doubts about scientific knowledge. With lobbying I fear that instead of regulating influences, as this new law intended, this policy only ends up legitimizing those same influences that will always create this type of desinformation. And I say that they will always create desinformation exactly because of what is showed in the chapter: The ones with more money will have more influence and they will always defend the free market even if that involves lying about scientific evidence

Jacques Vincelette

As an active member of the Environmentalists’ Club in high school at the tail end of the 1980s, I witnessed the tragic flop of the Toronto goal, in the wake of the Montreal accord. Dow Chemical supported the phase out of CFCs given their formula for HCFC substitutes. Industry had no substitute for fossil fuels. In 1989, the international community agreed in Toronto to reduce carbon emissions by 20% by 2005. However, the accord to be signed in Noordwijk was torpedoed by US Science Advisor Allan Bromley. In 1993, Allan Bromley gave a talk at Chalk River Laboratories about ‘Science, Technology, and Government for a Changing World’. The Carnagie Corporation released a report by this title earlier that year. Andrew Carnagie led the expansion of the steel industry and wrote the “Gospel of Wealth” in 1889. This dogma proclaims that surplus wealth is put to best use when it is administered carefully by the wealthy. In 1889, trans people were Molly Maguires shot down by Pinkertons. Today, trans humans are agentic avatars requesting server space on the next flight to Mars.

Iris Purpurea

First of all I loved the drama of this essay 😂 and idk about the accuracy of Lahsen’s argument but I am fully willing to believe it based on vibes. The vast majority of physicists and engineers I know are truly Like That. I see an adjacent phenomenon to what Oreskes and Conway describe unfolding within “big data”. Social scientists argue that calculating polygenic risk scores (the genetic likelihood for having a certain trait) for traits like educational attainment, parenting style, life satisfaction, success, intelligence etc. will help them do more robust empirical research. Medical researchers argue that finding the genomic basis of every disease will help prevent everything from cancer to depression. On that note “computational psychiatrists” argue that brain data, voice data, and other biometrics can make psychiatric diagnosis more “objective.” None of these people are flat-out denialists of anything, they agree that educational achievement gaps and high rates of chronic illness and mental illness are real problems. But there’s this fixation on “knowing” that I find fascinating that they seem to use to justify not taking action. Like, we could fix our broken education and healthcare systems and society at large in so many ways that would go a long way towards alleviating these problems. But there’s no will to do that — instead there’s endless calls for “more data” because we can’t act until we “really know” or we have to be “objective.” Another paper I read talked about these kinds of precise “techno-fixes” as “non-disruptive disruptions” and that seems akin to what Jastrow and co wanted. No massive societal upheaval, no real change.

AJ Biffl

I cackled out loud at the "physics envy" bit. I definitely buy it. Part of Lahsen's reasoning was that physicists saw these other sciences' methods as "less rigorous" which reminds me of the technocracy video and the Sokal hoax video. Also, shoutout to Naomi Oreskes and Eric Conway. Absolute badasses. Around the same time as "Merchants of Doubt" they also wrote a really cool little mini-book called "The Collapse of Western Civilization: A View From the Future" which is written from the perspective of a historian in 2393 looking back at what the climate collapse looked like. It's a really neat little read, less than 90 pages including an interview with the authors.

Anthony Perez Eisenbarth

I’m new to this whole thing, and I probably wrote too much, but go easy on me. This was a very interesting chapter. And I can’t help myself but think of how there are many parallels with Antonio Gramsci’s (among other’s) ideas about how public consent is produced through the cultural hegemony. We all live in the dying days of capitalism (I think we all know this) and I’m not really surprised that Jastrow and colleagues behaved in this way. Gramsci and Hegemonic Knowledge Production From a Gramscian perspective, the Marshall Institute functions as precisely the kind of institution that manufactures consent. These weren’t marginal cranks but credentialed elites: former NAS presidents, NASA directors, physicists with security clearances. They operated in what Gramsci called “civil society,” the realm where hegemony is constructed through seemingly neutral institutions: think tanks, universities, media et cetera. Jastrow and company’s genius (if one can call it that) was recognizing that in liberal democracies, coercion alone cannot sustain capitalist relations. You need what appears to be freely arrived-at consensus. We have all sorts of terms for this: the “marketplace of ideas,” and so on. By demanding “balance” in media coverage, they exploited liberalism’s own procedural commitments against substantive scientific findings. The form of democratic debate was weaponized against its content. Foucault’s Power/Knowledge Conjecture For Foucault, power doesn’t simply repress truth; it produces it. Every society has its “regime of truth”. The Marshall Institute wasn’t merely suppressing climate science it was actively producing an alternative epistemic framework, complete with its own experts, publications, citations, and institutional legitimacy. They deployed the very apparatus of scientific credibility—the credentials, the institutional affiliations, the language of “sound science”—to undermine scientific consensus. Power here operates not by silencing science but by proliferating competing “sciences.” The Ideology Question The classical Marxist reading would position the Marshall Institute as superstructure—ideas serving material base interests (fossil fuel capital). And indeed, the funding trails support this: tobacco money to Seitz, industry connections throughout. But a more sophisticated post-Marxian reading—drawing on Althusser, and compatible with Foucault—would note that ideology doesn’t merely mask reality; it constitutes subjects and their understanding of reality. Jastrow, Seitz, and Nierenberg weren’t cynical mercenaries. They appear to have genuinely believed that communism was an existential threat, that free markets were civilization’s salvation, that environmentalism was crypto-socialism. This is ideology operating at its most fundamental level not as conscious deception but as the very structure of perception. They “knew very well” what the science said, but nonetheless acted as if it were uncertain. The cynical distance from truth didn’t impede ideological functioning; it was its functioning. The Production of Ignorance as Capitalist Strategy What Oreskes and Conway document—and what the concept of “agnotology” captures—is something the Frankfurt School anticipated: the industrialization of unreason. Just as capitalism industrialized material production, it has industrialized the production of doubt, uncertainty, and strategic ignorance. Just as the culture industry produces standardized pseudo-individuality, the “scientific doubt” industry produces standardized pseudo-expertise: manufactured dissent that simulates scientific debate while foreclosing genuine inquiry. The Cold War Perhaps what’s most striking in the Oreskes and Conway account is how the Cold War functions as a kind of structuring absence: an ideological unconscious that persists even after its ostensible object (Soviet communism) disappeared. The Berlin Wall fell in 1989; that same year, the Marshall Institute pivoted to climate denial. What they called, "a critical examination of the scientific basis for global climate change policy." The enemy shifted from Soviet tanks to environmental regulation, but the psychic structure remained almost entirely intact: existential threat, civilizational stakes, heroic resistance by a clear-eyed minority against naïve masses seduced by the enemy.

Jacques Vincelette

I teased our Director Human Resources Governance on this matter, her place in the Meloche & Monnex dynasty and her formal pedigree in legal ambiguity (Incongruous friendship). The 1993 Carnagie report highlights "Given the indeterminacy of science, how can the judicial system make the best use of scientific "fact"". Mark Carney spoke in Davos on 2026/01/20 in the context of UN report A/HRC/59/23: "You cannot live within the lie of mutual benefit through integration when integration becomes the source of your subordination."