Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

so strictly speaking this question isn’t about the reading (though the first chapter’s mention of OpenAI collaborating with Sal Khan of Khan Academy did bring up related thoughts for me), but since we’ve all been reading/thinking about AI, and you’re all ostensibly viewers of science-y youtube, I'm curious to hear if anyone has thoughts on the current Hank Green AI drama. I definitely have opinions seeing it pay out as a creator, but I’m wondering how the whole thing is coming off for viewers. No need to respond to this if you’re not interested, but I welcome your takes~

~~~

On to the actual text: in trying to figure out what chapter i was on i accidentally read the last paragraph of “Gods and Demons”, and damn was it a way to start off this weeks reading:

“Then Sutskever emerged. In the pit, he had placed a wooden effigy that he’d commissioned from a local artist, and began a dramatic performance. This effigy, he explained, represented a good, Aligned AGI that OpenAI had built, only to discover it was actually lying and deceitful. OpenAI’s duty, he said, was to destroy it. Only a few yards away, several redwoods stood like ancient witnesses in the darkness. Sutskever doused the effigy in lighter fluid and lit it on fire.”

As if the chapter’s other comparisons to burning man weren’t on the nose enough…

I found the explicitly religious framing of “Gods and Demons” to be really interesting—I often feel that a certain kind of technocratic belief is just a christian worldview with some one to one swaps of where faith goes and what is the source of evil, but Hao really outlines what that looks like in the current AI landscape really explicitly. The doomer/boomer divide stuff made this feel especially literal: 

“...as much as each ideology professed to be the opposite of each other, both were in fact preaching from the same bible. Both discussed AGI as an increasingly forgone conclusion and with a religious ferocity; both fixated on the long term and asserted a moral authority to keep AI development within the control of its adherents. Where one warned of fire and brimstone, the other tantalized with visions of heaven.”

The reason I find this pseudo-religious framing of so interesting but also frustrating is because of how hypocritical it is—the average technocratically minded individual will be very quick to dismiss others’ perspectives that are influenced by “irrational” beliefs around god or people or whatever, but are totally comfortable with blind faith in the goodness/importance of their own work via a blind faith in the goodness/importance of technology.  From the circular reasoning of OpenAI leadership in earlier chapters, I don’t think the tech crowd sees this as a matter of faith, but the further we get into this book, the more obvious it seems to me.  

I think the story around the Google engineer who believed LaMDA was sentient and the comparison to Koko the gorilla illustrated this especially well. I remember when that story came out in 2022, I kept hearing about it from people who pretty much took it at face value, and I thought, well if this expert believes AI to be sentient there must be something to it. But then I looked at the transcript of his conversations with LaMDA and couldn’t wrap my head around how a person ostensibly intelligent enough to be building this kind of advanced software would also just… believe it? I didn’t have the context of his “mystic Christian priest” thing back then, but I just didn’t get where this faith was coming from. I wonder if it has something to do with being tied up in the creation of the tech—maybe Sutskever and the like have some psychological bias to believing AI is sentient/godlike because of what it would mean for them as its creator?

~~~

As for “Apex”, the only line I highlighted in that chapter was “They knew OpenAI was going downhill once it started hiring people who could look you in the eye.” Is this an autism thing?? I immediately have so many thoughts bc the depoliticization of autistic people in STEM is something I’ve thought about a lottt, especially in the context of people referencing their autism to absolve them of any kind of moral/social responsibility (see, that Google engineer that wrote that sexist memo about women in tech, or basically the entire career of Elon Musk—that sieg heil was just him stimming!). It would be very in line with that whole vibe for the og OpenAI crowd to see the hiring of “people who could look you in the eye” as the introduction of unnecessary and cumbersome social/emotional concerns to their workplace. Idk, I’ve had thoughts to do a video about this for a long while, curious to hear yalls thoughts based on this chapter/in general.

Comments

phil e the theyby

I’ll comment on the chapters when I sit down with my book, but I think the Hank Green story is fascinating. The most compelling part of it is the way the psychological pull of interacting with a chatbot had on him. Super Eyepatch Wolf made a video about it (on his Regular Eyepatch Wolf channel) and he talked about his own experiences using a chatbot as research for a video, only to find how incredibly quickly he became absolutely hooked on the really targeted, specific praise and positive feedback the chatbot was giving him. The fact that someone like Hank Green who has a lot of very plausible and sensible reasons to use a chatbot for tangible research goals can so easily get sucked into the ways the technology feeds whatever your needs and impulses are just speaks to how dangerous it really is. I think it’s important to keep that in mind; we can honor the valid practical reasons people use chatbots, while also understanding that it’s incredibly easy to get pulled into the psychologically addictive elements. Dr. Fatima’s experience with it spoke to how that can happen during moments of anxiety and emotional desperation, but I think the experiences of Hank Green and Super Eyepatch Wolf demonstrate how powerful the technology is in pulling on the emotional needs even of people who AREN’T struggling with mental health. EDIT: I’m working on putting together a presentation around chatbots, mental health, and therapy, and have been thinking that I may need to try using a chatbot at least a little bit to pull some examples and to have a more informed perspective. But even though I think I’ve kind of conditioned my brain to not see text-based communication as “real people” unless I know them IRL, these stories have me genuinely terrified to try it. I still haven’t decided yet if I’m going to for the sake of the presentation.

Jean Marrero

Ill respond to the chapter content soon (so many pages 😭) Im regards to the Hank Green reaction. In my personal opinion, its fucking ridiculous if you ask me. I get it, call out the slop and like hey, be more rigorous cuz wtf. But they are crucifying the man for using AI, Im sorry but anyone who works in industry or works in academia, is using AI on a daily basis for research and troubleshooting code. The key is AI Literacy, learning how to use it and how not to use it. Thats my opinion. If you dont like Hank Green's content, unsubscribe. If you are unsubscribing because he used AI, I got a bridge to sell you. Everyone is using AI, and not every usage is slop (low effort). We can be critical about the development of AI, we can be critical about spamming data centers left and right, but the reality is AI is useful if you know how to use it. You can even use it for good. ✨✨✨✨

phil e the theyby

I largely agree with you, but I disagree with the assertion that everyone is using AI. I do think that a lot of people are using AI and aren’t admitting it, and that it’s extremely pervasive in a lot of areas (like you said, research and academia; content creation too). But there is absolutely a group of people who are stridently anti-AI and refuse to use it entirely, and who actually believe way fewer people are using it than actually are. This essentially creates two perceived realities: one for a group who all use it and think nearly everyone uses it, and a group who don’t use it and all and think that not that many people use it. I think the reality is that most people do use it, but there’s still a decent portion of the population (maybe 20-40%, but I don’t know the actual research) who don’t really use it (like, they may have tried it before, but they don’t seek it out).

Jean Marrero

And that's perfectly fine. The issue I have is the condescension and discrimination from those who refuse to use it. Like extreme-vegans who attack those who use meat products, or religious folk who attack those who dont believe the same thing they do. Thats the main issue I see.

Dani

I am not commenting on the reading so much as your post. I am an ex-evangelical and I too have noted the increasing zealotry of AI prostelytizers. Nothing made me so uncomfortable about LLMs and the technocratic need for validation as the realization that they believe AGI is "possible" if only they have enough data centers and inputs on their LLM models. They are working toward a prophesized "singularity" and creation of a new kind of intelligence. They have no proof this is possible outside of theoretical models. They take this as an unequivocal good thing. The people funding this have no reason to want this except a sort of anti-human disgust and a desire for an unquestioning work force. And the public is primed to accept the disruption by the decades of social atomization and lack of hope for the future. It's a fertile ground for new belief systems, political and religious alike.

Jacques Vincelette

Last Saturday, Emancipation Day August 1st, I stood on a bridge signing Simon and Garfunkel's Mother and Child Reunion holding a sign stating "EMANCIPATION". Within an hour, five security guards stormed my position and asked me to put down the sign on the basis of the park's ambiguous intolerance policy over religious precept. Human rights and agency dismissed as religious tropes. Three groups of passerby thanked me for the reminder before the interruption; we still have some room for song.

Black EnviroNerd

On Hank: Ah I have so many different thoughts on this but haven’t been able to form a coherent opinion so hopefully writing about it can bring some order to disjointed thoughts in my head. For reference these are the sources I’m drawing my thoughts from. Reddit thread with original tweet but Hanks reply Supereyepatchwolf reaction vid Hank’s video and apology he posted yesterday On Hank himself I’ve had mixed feelings towards him for a while now. I think when his videos hit for me I really enjoy them. At his best I think he has a skill for making me consider angles I hadn’t thought of before and I particularly enjoy how he walks us through his thought processes. I think the latter in particular is valuable in trying to promote curiosity among the public. BUT… I’ve had nagging criticisms that cause me to only watch his videos sporadically. One is I’ve become pretty disillusioned with the smart science guy archetype. I think as I’ve moved away from more linear conceptions of intelligence and developed my own knowledge base of issues I’ve personally found less value in those that market themselves as general science experts. I just find myself craving more depth and nuance than what these personalities often offer. A bit more importantly I am pretty concerned with the deference we often grant these personalities due to their presentation as down to earth, nerdy (oftentimes) white men. I think the combination of video as medium and their charisma really can (ironically) disarm some of our critical thinking if we’re not careful. Lastly, with men already so predisposed to buying into their own hype I think these figures can easily get co-opted. Tying it back to Hank I think he does an okay job of navigating this, he does encourage viewers to read the papers themselves and qualifies when he’s talking outside of his field but he does inherently still benefit and buys into elements of being the smart science guy archetype. I think one big blind spot that bothers me consistently is when he talks about a topic that really needs an intersectional framework to be done justice and he fails to do so. I’ve also in general become skeptical of science youtube channels that cover a wide range of topics without a sort of coherent “throughline of expertise” between videos. For example a geographer making a wide range of geography videos makes sense but when they start making videos about vaccines i get a bit skeptical. I think when the topics being covered become too jumpy I get very concerned about the quality of the research and content I’m consuming. This is a concern I’ve had about Hank and Scishow but isn’t unique to them. For example in his recent video he talked about how he’s researching climate change regs, 8th century organic chemistry and the history of screwdrivers all at the same time. I think these issues fuel my reaction to the AI scandal. I think he’s been very consistent in admitting that he has issues with his desire to constantly be productive. I recall over Christmas he sent out an email talking about how he struggles with holidays because he wants to keep working. I can see how with the pressures he’s under (both internal and external) to produce coupled with the broad range of 10-15 minute videos makes AI use very enticing. Seems like he’s learning that the grind culture he buys into can be at direct odds with producing quality educational content. It also seems like he lacks checks in his creative process which is a bit concerning given his rep as smart science guy. There’s a friction between the financial incentive to produce as much as possible and the responsibility to put out quality content. I think the structures he’s in really favor the former and I hope he can zoom out a bit and maybe reform his process to be more responsible. I am admittedly a bit skeptical of the explanations Hank is offering. Particularly I’m still a bit confused about what he used AI for exactly and I think that does raise concerns about transparency. I understand he uses it as a research aid but if its too the point were he can cite he’s using it too much and that his brother and wife both had hard conversations with him where “they didn’t pull their punches” it does seem plausible he’s playing down his use. To be clear I don’t know and I want to take him at his word but he does have financial and reputational reasons to downplay how much he used AI in making videos. I haven’t followed the surrounding discussion but he does appear to have a lot of defenders. I don’t think he should necessarily be crucified as he’s put out some good stuff but I also do see him getting a lot of grace that he wouldn’t be getting if he was a person of color, fem, nonbinary etc… Overall I can’t say this has made me want to watch his videos more and unfortunately it’ll probably make me more hesitant and skeptical of his future content. I finally caught back up to the book club and I just ended up writing about Hank Green this week! I guess it just is how it goes. Overall I think the chapters are hitting on similar themes as previous chapters. It's interesting seeing the AI safety clan get increasingly sidelined and disinvested from. It was also interesting hearing about Anthropics ties to Sam Bankman Fried. It really does hammer home that Anthropic and Open AI are the spidermen pointing at each other meme when it comes to ethics.

Black EnviroNerd

I saw that vid too! It reminded me of last year when I was trying to learn spanish in my free time. My tutor was pretty harsh and demoralizing but he also encouraged me to use chatgpt as an aid. Initially I used it to practice but over time I ended up using it to affirm I was making progress particularly when my tutor would go in on me. I didn't connect the dots that I was using it for affirmation until Eyepatchwolf talked about how it complimented them in ways that was really effective for them. Its trippy stuff for sure.

AJ Biffl

I had a lot of feelings about the Hank Green drama. I think my initial gut reaction was some form of disappointment, like when I watch Hank Green I want to hear from Hank Green and not whatever AI he uses, though hearing more details it seems like that's not really an issue and his scripts have still been written by him, and he just used AI to curate research (at least that's what he's said, I think). Info curation is an interesting case study, because realistically all internet research is algorithmically curated, even before modern LLMs. Another thought was basically that he should not be operating under any incentive that requires him to use AI to keep up. To some extent you can view AI adoption as coerced, particularly for not-high-level employees at big companies etc, where the expectation of adopting AI is universal and basically required, and in situations where there legitimately is competition that would otherwise wipe you out if you didn't pay obeisance to the arms race and start using AI yourself. But none of those apply to Hank Green because, well, he's Hank Green. He does not need to play that game. But then of course I saw a ton of stuff online that was absolutely unfairly flaming him. I'll agree there is moral significance to using AI and that the significance grows when you have a large platform, but also 1) that moral character is not one-dimensional and 2) public whippings are not helpful for anyone (basically just the AI Literacy video). I saw another good take online that was like, if he needs help with research he can hire a researcher to help him.

AJ Biffl

There were some really interesting things in these two chapters! I was fascinated at the phenomenon of "normal" tech people having friction coming into the OpenAI system, not understanding the lingo and the assumptions and so on. I think that illustrates 1) the depth and significance of AI, being capable of cultivating entire networks of ideas based on the biggest issues in the field, and 2) how centralized that development is being carried out: (basically) a single company: a few board members, a CEO, a handful of department heads, are leading this undeniably world-changing development and the rest of the world, even the rest of the tech world right outside the door, is completely out of the loop. I was also, unsurprisingly, horrified hearing more about the into-to-statistics approach to morality of effective altruism. It's like a more technocratic utilitarianism from the most annoying person in your philosophy class. And let's not pretend it's any more objective or reasonable than purely going on vibes just because you named a variable that you can neither measure nor estimate. What's p(you're full of it)? Like if it was possible to rigorously calculate the odds of disastrous events every state in history would have been doing it all the time. This marginal distribution is called "from my ass"?? It was also really terrifying in "Ascent" how powerfully the profit incentive took over. That quote from a former employee, "You could no longer make a case for being an idealistic research lab. There were customers looking to be served here and now." As if giving the customers what they want is anywhere comparable to their founding principles. I don't know if that's genuinely what the sentiment was at the time, that giving customers a thing they'd pay for is on the same level as the duty-to-humanity they claimed to be founded for, or if that's the former employee's spin. And then at the very end of the chapter, Nadella paraphrasing Altman, "I need more, I need more, I need more." Haunting. Next chapter is gonna be sunshine and rainbows, I'm sure.

AJ Biffl

Also, that story about the Google engineer is wild, and I'm definitely on the same page that a lot of time people (often self-diagnosed) will form an opinion in a position of privilege, spend zero time introspecting, and then when they get pushback throw away any responsibility because they're "on the spectrum." My stepmom is a brain injury rehab doc and has worked/does work with brain injured and developmentally disabled children and adults for a couple decades now, and I asked her about this and she had some really good takes. One was basically that "autism spectrum" is quickly becoming meaningless because it's kind of just applied blanket to anyone who is socialized a little differently along with, like, kids who actually can't sit on a bus. And she was also basically like, if you have the ability to recognize that you are not good at something, like you know you need practice recognizing social cues or facial expressions or something, you're also responsible for getting that practice. She said, "that's just Timmy being Timmy, but Timmy is still responsible for being Timmy."

AJ Biffl

I'd hesitate to even say they have theoretical models! Excepting of course Sutskever's effigy

phil e the theyby

Wow, Karen Hao did a REALLY good job of making me angry in "Gods and Demons." She highlighted the central contradictions of the Silicon Valley mindset very efficiently: "...never fully acknowledging the utter contradiction of declaring the problem of creating and managing beneficial AGI possible, but San Francisco's housing crisis too tough to tackle." (228) EA is gross as fuck, as AJ already pointed out. I think there's a kernel of a reasonable thought in the movement (that sometimes it's helpful to think about positive steps you can take towards social change that have large but unsexy impacts, as well as problems outside of your immediate field of vision) and turned it into a completely batshit philosophy. Something like John Green's work on tuberculosis takes that kernel of truth and does actually meaningful shit; EA just creates a bunch of brainrot and pointless philosophical math problems. The point about needing to include porn in the dataset for DALL-E 3 because otherwise the performance was notably worse for women and people of color (238) was one of the most repulsive things I've ever heard. Only in a field overwhelming dominated by White men would that fact not prompt the thought, "hey, maybe the thing we're doing is bad, and we should stop and think for a minute." Overall, "Gods and Demons" was just BLEAK, laying bare all of the most miserable shortcomings of AI development: the blatant disregard for human suffering, human dignity, sensible scientific analysis (see the discussion on page 253 of how they never check if the answers to "tests" AI are given are just found within its training data), and the utter unwillingness to engage with anything outside of "the task we've put in front of ourselves" (in this case, "build AGI"). One thing that really stood out in both chapters is how the Doomers and the Boomers both ultimately end up in the same place: "we need to build the AGI god ASAP"; the Doomers just think THEY need to build it first and be the ones controlling it and holding the reins, while the Boomers ALSO think they need to build it first but just put less emphasis on the "controlling" part. I truly, genuinely believe that the Doomers are Not Our Friends; I think they focus pretty exclusively on "existential" AI risks, entirely to the detriment of the majority of the real, tangible harms done by AI. I think the policies they want will only ever focus on the power of the LLM, never on the processes of its development. The really interesting part about "Apex" is that within OpenAI, on a technologically, ChatGPT didn't change anything, but structurally, it changed everything. The culture changed, the priorities changed, the possibility of doing anything that wasn't just "ChatGPT but more" evaporated; even the relationship with Microsoft changed massively. I did read the "They knew OpenAI was going downhill once it started hiring people who could look you in the eye" (264) as an autism thing. Essentially, this project was only every By and For one very specific type of person: not just men or men in tech, but a very narrow set of focus, interests, priorities, and beliefs. As with much of the world of startups, the goal is to build something "of value" while staying within the narrow realm of what you like and carry about and what interests you. You're supposed to be able to change the world without ever having to learn how to engage with anything outside of the capitalist class. This isn't super related to these two chapters, but there was a recent article about an OpenAI AI agent that breached its closed environment, accessed, the internet, and retrieved information from a different AI startup's servers. Sam Altman was quoted as basically saying that AI has entered the "singularity." It was nice to have read these two books to analyze these sorts of articles a bit more critically; basically, these are AI agents that are essentially trained to identify software vulnerabilities. So it's less "we told the robot to make as many paperclips as possible and it murdered all the humans because it decided that humans got in the way of making more paperclips," and more "we trained the robot how to make paperclips and how to murder humans, and then we told it to go make as many paperclips as possible no matter what, and it used our training on how to murder humans to do that."

phil e the theyby

Great thoughts on the chapters as a whole. Yeah, these were some of the hardest chapters just because the problems highlighted here seem so intractable. Things like data centers, content filtering, etc. were absolutely horrific but at least felt like they were relatively external and therefore more possible to change (with regulation, for example). But the problems highlighted in these two chapters are like, the heart of the industry as a whole. It's bleak. I think I agree with the idea that people are responsible for their actions regardless of neurotype, but I think the idea of the category of autism being "too broad" is generally a problematic one. The truth is, it's simply impossible to tell from the outside whether someone is autistic or not (my previous boss was/is a psychologist who's worked with a ton of other psychologists and has known a lot of autistic people, and when I first told her I thought I might be autistic she said she thought I wasn't; I got tested several months later and it turns out that yeah I'm definitely autistic). A lot of autistic people look way more OK than we actually are, because being able to socially present in ways that make other people comfortable is an essential survival skill. The reason it's a relevant and valuable category is that it affirms the genuine realities of certain limitations to what some people's brain and body can handle while still feeling safe and comfortable, for reasons that *aren't* about how they were socialized. It reminds people that some problems can only be resolved in a sustainable way by changing the environment or limiting exposure to certain challenging stimuli, not just learning more coping strategies. I don't think this is exclusive to autism (there's tons of variation in neurotype, and some of them are caused by life experience such as PTSD, and some variations are more malleable over time and some are less so), and autism isn't the reason the AI crowd are unable to talk to people or see other people as humans (that happens because they weren't taught how to do that and their social environment doesn't require them to learn). And there is a part of me that wishes the diagnosis didn't matter: that we just accepted that different people have different brains, and we're able to trust people when they say what their limitations are. But unfortunately, we live in a world where we don't know how to navigate differences between ourselves and others. I think that simple fact explains both the autistic tech bros who say shitty things (they aren't able to navigate "I feel uncomfortable with these people who think/act differently than me; I should learn to unpack that and see it differently rather than just blaming or judging those people") AND the fact that so many people have to use up so much energy and burn themselves out trying "look normal" instead of being able to say what works for them, listening to and honoring what other people need, and finding a healthy balance.

AJ Biffl

I think the trouble in "autism" as a blanket category is that it doesn't give much info about what types of support people actually need, because there's such a wide range. There's a tradeoff there - on one hand, people in general being more familiar with the concept of autism is good because people are aware of its existence, and I think the hope is that in understanding this general phenomenon they are more prepared to interact with people with those differences. "Autism" sort of functioning as a shorthand for, 'hey you need to realize there's a difference here and to navigate that difference with care,' which like you said is what is missing a lot of the time. But I think in practice the word "autism" gets substituted as a fixed shorthand for a single specific category of person with a specific set of implications (which is especially not helpful because the most visible autism-spectrum people are more high functioning, and need less support). This is especially true of how the state interacts with these concepts, because legalese-speaking suits require fixed, objective points to put into official documentation. And if that's the environment maybe it's better for the state not to say that there are exactly two kinds of people, autistic or non-autistic. I mean it's also bad if the state says there are exactly seven kinds of people, type one type two type three, etc., but may be slightly better for understanding exactly what kind of support people need? Well ideally the state doesn't get involved at all but...

KJ Xiao

Sorry for not joining the book reading, but this seemingly unrelated video https://youtu.be/872JcpP3FEM has a surprising twist early on that makes it relevant, in a way that I think will thoroughly entertain you and your audience. Much more relevant is this superbly long video https://youtu.be/SmhLAaEi6xo

phil e the theyby

Oh for sure. The autistic vs. allistic duality (or the neurodivergent vs. neurotypical duality) absolutely feels like a false dichotomy, and way too many people take a very uniform view of what it means to be “autistic” (and a lot of neurodivergent people take a way too uniform view of what it means to be “neurotypical”). When it comes to accommodations, ideally we wouldn’t have categories and everyone would get what they need without having to prove they “really deserve it” with a diagnosis first. Given that we don’t live in that world though, I’d rather the category of “who gets accommodations” be as broad and vague as possible to allow as many people to receive as wide a range of accommodations as possible. As much as I’m “anti-state,” I will say that I would MUCH rather have the state be involved in the decision-making process than who actually gets to make the decisions without state involvement: corporations. Because at the end of the day, states are essentially corporations with at least a semblance of public accountability, and corporations are essentially private states with almost no public accountability. I can think of no stronger example of this fact than OpenAI itself.

wandfigur

Regarding Hank Green: It's crazy how mad everyone is about the AI thing but no one bats an eye about the things he actually says or fails to say. This clearly shows people's priorities and makes their demand for authenticity of thought ring hollow.

Justice Quinn Hertzman

Hello everyone and sorry if this is the wrong place for this comment, but I just joined the Patreon and I'd like to know how the book club works; it seems like we're in the middle of a text now yeah? Is there an estimate as to when the next book would begin?

Nanibgal

Hi! I'm pretty new here too, I think this current book will end on the 28th of August, but IDK what's up next or how long after that.

Nanibgal

I was really looking forward to trying to say what I thought about these chapters but I feel super nervous and stressed every time I try to write a comment. I feel afraid to engage with the work as intended here even though I've really been enjoying the book and thinking about the points it brings up... I'm posting this instead because I feel like maybe if I post about my feelings of fear, it'll make it easier to write out my actual thoughts instead of tearing up and deleting everything. IDK if anyone else is struggling to comment, but if you are then I hope we can lift each other up.

phil e the theyby

You’re definitely not alone; it can feel really weird and different to share your thoughts in this sort of setting! But I’d personally love to hear what you have to say. Often we hear the most from people who feel the most comfortable and confident (and often privilege can play a big part in that, though it’s not the only factor), but I find it super valuable to hear as many perspectives as possible. Try not to worry about whether your thoughts are “good” or “right”; just worry about whether they’re YOURS, because that’s what’s most valuable here, imo. I’m glad you’re here!

AJ Biffl

what phil said!

eari359

I feel similarly, everyone here seems so smart and good at writing. And i struggle to write anything meaningful. It probably just takes practice and to just do it. I wanna start with the next book because i procrastinated and am still behind with this one. Also i'm thinking about just doing something small, like writing about just one thought for each chapter and not overthinking it.