Empire of AI: "Plundered Earth" and "The Two Prophets" (Patreon)
Content
The schedule for this round of book club can be found here
*Karen Hao released a correction for "Plundered Earth" a proposed data center in Chile and a paragraph about the overall projected water use of AI, you can read it here
~~~
"Plundered Earth": the whole "empire" analogy was really reinforced for me in this chapter by how often the tensions between tech companies and local communities in the latin american countries where they want to build infrastructure reminded me of the conflict between native hawaiins and american astronomers over the construction of telescopes I talked about in my colonialism video:
"Indigenous communities watching their land and their communities get ripped apart asked: A better future for whom?"
"The accelerated copper and lithium extraction to build megacampuses...is in Silicon Valley's account, also ushering in a better and brighter future. To block that extraction is thus to block fundamental progress for humanity."
"[an] art exhibition....showed the vast chasm between the reality of Latin America's rich Indigenous cultures and the woefully bereft depictions of them spit out by Midjourney and Stable Diffusion as primitive, technologically inept peoples."
"Google wasn't here to truly engage with and hear what the community wanted. 'They came to intimidate us... Think about it. They come offering us trees while drying out our Earth.'"
I got especially mad at google building that sad little "urban forest" in Quilicura while rejecting non-English resumes; like I already knew these attempts to expand abroad would be gross and extractive but goddamn, learning the details is heartbreaking. At the same time though, I found a lot of hope in the response to tech expansion, like the dedication and resilience of groups like MOSCAT. There was something weirdly poetic about them having to read massive amounts of documents to successfully argue data centers that power LLMs, like human labor prevailing or something.
I was also really moved by the students "imagining other types of relationships between data and water":
One group imagined making the data centers' water use more visible by storing it in large pools that residents could also enjoy as a public space. Another group proposed tossing out the brutalist designs of the typical data center in favor of a "fluid data territory" where data infrastructure coexists with wetland, mitigating its damaging impacts. The structures of the data center would double as suspended walkways, inviting Quilicura residents to walk through the wetland and admire the ecosystem. Plant nurseries and animal nesting stations would be interspersed among more traditional server rooms to rehabilitate the wetland's biodiversity. The data center would draw polluted water from the wetland and purify it for use before returning it. The computers themselves would collect and process data about the health of the wetlands to accelerate the local environment's restoration.
Very into the solarpunk visioning here, especially bc of how it poses a third option to the reaction to datacenters that I'm still thinking through. Generally we think of it as, well either we let them build a horrible data center in our community, or we reject it by whatever means. And that makes sense, but something that's been stuck in the back of my head whenever I advocate for resisting the construction of data centers is, even if they can't build it here (wherever here is), they're just gonna pick up and build it somewhere even more vulnerable. Now I'm not saying we should just be fine with data center construction if its aesthetic and more sustainable, but these students' (still pretty theoretical) ideas do strike me as an approach that doesn't just offset the problem to a more easily exploitable population.
~~~
"The Two Prophets": honestly don't have so much to say here but I was thrown by the mention of the 'Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality' author---did not realize he was relevant outside the world of fanfic. Got into a rabbit hole about the rest of his career as an AI researcher and it really makes me want to go back and reread HPMOR, haven't read it since i was still a v rationalism pilled teenager and I imagine it would be interesting to revist with my current perspective lol