Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The schedule for this round of book club can be found here

*Karen Hao released a correction for "Plundered Earth" a proposed data center in Chile and a paragraph about the overall projected water use of AI, you can read it here

~~~

"Plundered Earth": the whole "empire" analogy was really reinforced for me in this chapter by how often the tensions between tech companies and local communities in the latin american countries where they want to build infrastructure reminded me of the conflict between native hawaiins and american astronomers over the construction of telescopes I talked about in my colonialism video:

"Indigenous communities watching their land and their communities get ripped apart asked: A better future for whom?"

"The accelerated copper and lithium extraction to build megacampuses...is in Silicon Valley's account, also ushering in a better and brighter future. To block that extraction is thus to block fundamental progress for humanity."

"[an] art exhibition....showed the vast chasm between the reality of Latin America's rich Indigenous cultures and the woefully bereft depictions of them spit out by Midjourney and Stable Diffusion as primitive, technologically inept peoples."

"Google wasn't here to truly engage with and hear what the community wanted. 'They came to intimidate us... Think about it. They come offering us trees while drying out our Earth.'"

I got especially mad at google building that sad little "urban forest" in Quilicura while rejecting non-English resumes; like I already knew these attempts to expand abroad would be gross and extractive but goddamn, learning the details is heartbreaking. At the same time though, I found a lot of hope in the response to tech expansion, like the dedication and resilience of groups like MOSCAT. There was something weirdly poetic about them having to read massive amounts of documents to successfully argue data centers that power LLMs, like human labor prevailing or something.

I was also really moved by the students "imagining other types of relationships between data and water":

One group imagined making the data centers' water use more visible by storing it in large pools that residents could also enjoy as a public space. Another group proposed tossing out the brutalist designs of the typical data center in favor of a "fluid data territory" where data infrastructure coexists with wetland, mitigating its damaging impacts. The structures of the data center would double as suspended walkways, inviting Quilicura residents to walk through the wetland and admire the ecosystem. Plant nurseries and animal nesting stations would be interspersed among more traditional server rooms to rehabilitate the wetland's biodiversity. The data center would draw polluted water from the wetland and purify it for use before returning it. The computers themselves would collect and process data about the health of the wetlands to accelerate the local environment's restoration.

Very into the solarpunk visioning here, especially bc of how it poses a third option to the reaction to datacenters that I'm still thinking through. Generally we think of it as, well either we let them build a horrible data center in our community, or we reject it by whatever means. And that makes sense, but something that's been stuck in the back of my head whenever I advocate for resisting the construction of data centers is, even if they can't build it here (wherever here is), they're just gonna pick up and build it somewhere even more vulnerable. Now I'm not saying we should just be fine with data center construction if its aesthetic and more sustainable, but these students' (still pretty theoretical) ideas do strike me as an approach that doesn't just offset the problem to a more easily exploitable population.

~~~

"The Two Prophets": honestly don't have so much to say here but I was thrown by the mention of the 'Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality' author---did not realize he was relevant outside the world of fanfic. Got into a rabbit hole about the rest of his career as an AI researcher and it really makes me want to go back and reread HPMOR, haven't read it since i was still a v rationalism pilled teenager and I imagine it would be interesting to revist with my current perspective lol

Comments

KJ Xiao

I actually attended a local meetup party for when HPMoR ended. It was rather a small but still global phenomenon. His betting on something that is not actually quantum physics kinda pointed out how non-rational these people that later became known as RatBros turned out to be, even back then. It kinda also explains why so many of these people fell right into the cult of almighty AI and how the New Atheists pivoted sharply towards religion after Hitchens died. Not that New Atheists were nice to women before that, but as you've already discussed, RatBro worldview is rather conducive to wild swings.

Black EnviroNerd

Side note not directly tied to this weeks reading: I watched “The Drama” yesterday as well as olay’s analysis of the film (Why Everyone Missed The Point of The Drama if anyone's curious) . The character Rachel really reminded me of the discourse surrounding AI use that Dr. Fatima discussed in her “How to (Anti) AI Better” video. Particularly the liberal instinct to condemn actions and virtue signals as opposed to taking a people centered approach where we hold space for the multiple contradictions we all have. I know I’m late to this but would definitely recommend giving it a watch. TW for sexual harassment. Scattered thoughts on the reading: The doomers and boomers divide feels very reminiscent of the divide between Democrats and Republicans. Lots of friction and political maneuvering but ultimately neither of the groups allow for challenges to the status quo. The doomers are only willing to delay at the end of the day. Their existential concerns about AI don’t include concerns about labor conditions to train the models or climate change. Their main drive feels less about ensuring AI is beneficial for humanity and more about assuaging the moral discomfort they feel in their work. Plundering the earth was a good chapter and a familiar one. I work on environmental justice policy so it was a bit exhausting reading about data centers in my off time. I did enjoy the global perspective the book offered and it was useful to hear about how activists are pushing back in South America. Critical minerals in general are always a sticking point for us as the default is to plunder in our system even when talking about renewable deployment. I also enjoyed the solar punk ideas that were being thrown around in the chapter. Often there's a lot of friction between people who want to block vs people who want safeguards in environmental justice circles. I personally lean more towards blocking these facilities but am sympathetic to those who are simply trying to get some sort of concession or benefit. I would love to see more solar punk ideas. I think we just need ways to get resources behind these projects! It's interesting seeing Altman's celebrity phase during the Biden Admin especially in contrast with today where I think he’s seen as more of a villain. Big tech really had a lot of good will and PR behind it that I think they’ve pretty much squandered at this point. Something I think about often is how a lot of us really want a sort of evil mastermind or hyper competent shadowy organization behind our oppression to give us a sort of comfort that the opposition is ultra formidable. The more mundane reality is however that we’re really just pushing back against a collection of ultra rich, ego driven, oftentimes incompetent and loosely aligned elites. I think this book really just hammers that home for me.

Dr Jennifer Burgess

Just leaving a comment to say I'm stil here and reading/listening, but I've got a bit behind and haven't quite managed to catch up. Hopefully will be back on track by next Friday!

Jean Marrero

Profit over all, even humanity, is truly a death cult mentality. The hyperfocusing on the wealth and prosperity of a far away country to the detriment of the colonized will always be a sad, but also an evolutionary reflection. Humans would like be pretend being high and mighty with conscious and morals to the masses, while reigning an empire of blood, human trafficking, and displacements on the background, only ever evident if some decide to lift their own veil of the costs of their ignorance and how it breaks every notion of human altruism through money. At the end of the day, survival of the fittest suppresses the vulnerable to this day. And its the truth for all animals, ALL animals...

Jacques Vincelette

Life remains multifaceted for all animals. Through alpha male depravity, sad how we reduced "survival of the fittest" to the biggest dick.

Jean Marrero

yup, at least animals do it for survival, but I guess the more intelligence, the more sadistic acts the animal engages in for gratification. Dolphins are a great example of doing sadistic shit for fun, so it seems that "the fittest gets to be a dick" is seen in nature.

Jacques Vincelette

p278 "Chile would become a global hub for digital infrastructure." p286 In his victory speech, Boric repeated a slogan of the protests that slammed the legacy of the Chicago Boys during Pinochet’s rule: “If Chile was neoliberalism’s cradle, it will also be its grave.” My uncle Roger was programmer in the 1970's-80's with interest in cybernetics and Quebec sovereignty. In 1971 Stafford Beer worked with the Chilean Production Development Corporation (CORFO) in the newly elected socialist government of Salvador Allende, to apply cybernetic theories to the management of the state-run sector of Chile. Lessons learned on running telecommunications on low power simple phone lines. In 1973, US supported to military coup for Pinochet's dictatorship. In the context of the cold war, the coup came in response to genuine international collaboration. Solarpunk utopias branch off in response to Cyberpunk dystopias of 1970's-80's extending social critical sci-fi of the 1950's. The dystopias inspired alpha males in their quest for "survival of the fittest". Hippies still have a chance if we grow up to transcend tantric orgies. I still suspect those synthetic mushrooms were planted by the CIA.

AJ Biffl

I really liked the solarpunk bits, as a reminder that it may even be possible to construct infrastructure for a version of this technology that isn't some dead, purgatory wasteland that stretches for miles ("megacampuses" is horrifying). It reminds me of something I think they talked about in AI Snake Oil, I can't remember whether it was specifically about parallels with the internet boom or telephone lines or the electrical grid, but it was basically that you can guarantee at least some democratized access, to ensure that benefits are at least a *little* bit spread out, when the infrastructure required to access a technology is publicly owned, even if the online domains and virtual spaces are corporate-owned techno-feudal. You could turn that to data centers and say, we the government here are going to build our own sustainable, non-necrophilic data centers (or some substantial compute capacity) that these tech giants then have to pay us to use. A slightly better alternative than letting them build the monstrosities and then nationalize them by force, and even better than letting them just build the monstrosities and then sit there, extracting.

Stentor Danielson

It really is striking, and depressing, how closely all of the AI development in Chile parallels centuries of extractive resource development in the global south. Geographers have been writing about this under the rubric of "political ecology" since the 80s, and at times the Plundered Earth chapter felt like I was reading something out of Antipode or the Journal of Political Ecology (albeit a little lighter on the citations to Gramsci or Harvey).