Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I'm interested by the tension between the university's simultaneous threat and benefit to the Shah---he seemed to have very contentious relationships with universities before AMUT, but needed them to industrialize the nation; he had these friendly meetings with students but there were also protests where students chanted "down with the Shah". And on the flip side of that same tension, it was interesting to read Mostafa Charman's refusual to work at AMUT because of his opposition to the Shah, with us already knowing that the university would eventually play a role in his overthrowing. It makes me think about the (infinitely repeated in a lot of convos I have online) tension of 'do i be in academia to change it from the inside or leave bc it's irredeemable'. Clearly, Charman thought the latter while the former was apparently going to become reality. Flipping it back to the perspective from power, I wonder if leadership that leverages universities in the US in service of empire see abstention from participating in those systems as like, making things easier for them, letting them benefit from the output they need to maintain power without having to worry about internal resistance. I don't think I've looked at this dynamic from that perspective before, but it does shift things for me somewhat.

curious what other people think on this point---would you have acted like Charman? and was his decision different than the analogous one today in US (or wherever is relevant to you) universities? there are certainly bits of context that could make the two cases very different---what the overall student/faculty body is like comest to mind. I didn't expect the part about the student body at AMUT being especially religious, like, even for Iran religious. I think the fact that in other countries the elite thing to do is to send your kids to school abroad in the west, leaving poorer students to populate even their most elite universities, makes their higher ed culture significantly different from that of the west.

the other thing that stood out to me was the bit about the changes Dr. Seyyed Hossein Nasr made during his tenure as chancellor, specifically establishing humanities electives courses and requiring (requiring!!!) sports and physical education. very here for the well-roundedness of his take on engineering ed. make nerds play sports lol (i say this as someone who as a young nerd hated sports)

respond to my prompt above in bold or literally whatever else stood out to you :)

Comments

Jacques Vincelette

On Charman's position, I did join Canadian Nuclear Laboratories 13 years ago motivated by the potential of nuclear science as technical solution to our climate/energy predicament, the challenge of waste management, and curious over the 2008 isotope crisis that exposed political entanglement. I earned my disillusionment in 2020 when our Diversity and Inclusion Pilot program was scuttled after the murder of George Floyd. I remain present as disgruntled "Wellness Ambassador" expanding the overton window with sour humour. I joined a community of clowns, still working on style.

Jacques Vincelette

After Bell Hooks and Paulo Freire, Chapter 1 enticed me. p35 the Shah was . . . against research. In 1969, he had accepted that there would be research. He thought that research would be a waste of time in 1968. At that time he wasn’t really convinced that research would be that useful . (...) Shah’s perspective on research, indicating a transition from initial doubt to eventual recognition of its value. As AMUT evolved from a teaching to a research institution, the university also took on a new global significance. There were growing concerns internationally regarding the Shah’s ambitions to transform Iran into a science and technology powerhouse in the Middle East. Praxis through research provides a learning loop.

Jacques Vincelette

I emailed my Ch.1 notes and references from the office to my home to keep security in the loop. Historic quirk, my home address is not on the Canada Post registry, all mail goes through the the town's central post office. This has prevented packages from direct delivery. My friend at the post office is professional cellist, sorting mail to make ends meet. His wife is also professional musician, violin and piano. Their children are home schooled, back to the pedagogical thread.

Jacques Vincelette

I played salah in their basement. Taboo persists on doubt over the prophets' (peace upon them) musicality. Dizzy dancing men trip. The fall of the sufi empire wrecked havoc on the music scene, making space for rock and roll appropriated from gospel.

Anthony Perez Eisenbarth

I think the parallels between the Shah and AMUT and Trump and American universities are interesting, and while there are broad similarities, it’s clearly not the same. For one, Trump and his goons, notably Musk via DOGE, went after academic research it deemed “inefficient” or “fradulent,” whereas the Shah chartered an entire new university for the purpose of training and educating an entire generation of engineers. There’s also the fealty aspect of Trump and the loyalty questions he added to federal government job postings, and many such jobs are in technical agencies staffed by STEM graduates with master’s and doctorates. There’s no real mention of a likewise situation in chapter one for the Shah and AMUT. To be sure, a secret police to ensure compliance (SAVAK) will probably do the same thing. And furthermore, Mojtahedi secured high salaries for professors at AMUT to try and lure away top talent from foreign universities. (This is a bit like the Saudi Pro League, offering huge salaries to European and Brazilian footballers to come and play. I’m looking at you Cristiano Ronaldo, João Félix, Milinković-Savić et cetera.) Had Chamran merely turned down the position without taking further action, the Shah and his regime wouldn’t have batted an eye. What made his rejection really matter was his active involvement within a broader revolutionary movement. Nowadays, whether in America or beyond, stepping away from academia usually feels like an act of quiet resignation, as the majority simply pivot to corporate roles and abandon political action altogether. So in that it sense, it does go a certain way in “making things easier” for things to go on as they are. (Though perhaps that’s overly cynical, as the reality is undoubtedly more nuanced.) Remaining within the system or walking away each come with their own quiet compromises. I am often reminded of Adorno's famous maxim, “There is no right life in the wrong one.” And while this observation is frequently interpreted as being some form of quiet despair, I have always viewed it as a stark caution against believing our personal choices can grant us some kind of moral purity. When the surrounding society is fundamentally flawed, true individual innocence often becomes a structural impossibility. For example, our own individual choices to lessen our carbon footprint are defeated by celebrities and the ultra wealthy charting private jets while at the same time massive diesel trains, trucks, and freighters ship the things we use and buy every day (including the desktop I’m writing this on.) Chamran turning down the AMUT appointment didn't magically extract him or the AMUT students from the Shah’s regime. I don’t think this is an abstract problem. Lately, I have been thinking about my own decision to leave academia in this way quite a lot. A large part of this, perhaps, is me dealing with the passing of my dear grandmother (who liked teasing me by calling me her “absent minded professor”), the overall state of things in the US, and the recent passing of Anwar Shaikh. I remember, during my days as an undergraduate discovering his work while I was a burgeoning Marxist, devouring every book or paper I could get my hands on. Shaikh’s originality was a breath of fresh air to me. And largely influenced my own line of thought in a paper I wrote on the Marxian labor theory of value for a history of thought class. My professor passed the paper on to him, and to my great surprise Anwar personally reached out to me, asking whether I was interested in attending graduate school, possibly at the New School. (This was 2015 and I still had some optimism back then.) It was both a humbling and exhilarating moment. I was just an obscure country boy from Eastern Oregon, with some naive notions of academic grandeur, a nobody. (I still am, in many ways exactly that.) We talked for an hour by cellphone about the labor theory of value and his Capitalism book, then still only a draft. He gave me an early version of Chapter 6, which I read that very night. I write all this because book clubs like this are fundamental ways of making things less easy for the empire to continue its often brutal extraction and suppression.

Simon

> would you have acted like Charman? and was his decision different than the analogous one today in US (or wherever is relevant to you) universities? That's a hard question to answer in the context of 1960's and 70's Iran. I know very little of the country and less of how it was in that time so forgive me my speculation and any generalizations. I'm assuming that Mojtahedi invited Chamran to come teach at AMUT in the beginning of his chancellorship, so somewhere between 1966 and 1969. Chamran's fears of being paraded out in honor of the Shah proved to be true: "Zarghamee, one of the later chancellors of the university, observed that this day marked the first instance that the chant “Down with the Shah” was heard on the AMUT campus" (p. 21). That would've been embarrassing for Chamran, but it takes place in 1972 so roughly 5 years later. In his explanation for turning down Mojtahedi's offer, Chamran starts off with "Apart from danger and prison..." (p. 25) so possibly he was planning something revolutionary back then, in which case the positives of teaching at AMUT maybe wouldn't outweigh the negatives. Personally, I have declined a job offer as IT engineer for the government because civil servants are expected to implement the policies of the democratically elected government, address any concerns they have internally, and not join any public protests. I have protested against fossil fuel subsidies and was planning to do so in the future so I declined the offer (I also had the privilege of being able to decline an offer for a steady and well paying job). The crucial issue here is, I think, how much influence one can have in the position on the inside. In my current job I'm still struggling with the fact that the energy use of equipment is viewed as an externality and increasing energy efficiency is not of primary concern, but at least now I have the option of protesting in public without having to fear for my employment. It's difficult to gauge Chamran's motivations, maybe he was thinking of personal risks when he declined. On the other hand, maybe he didn't think he could exert enough influence on his students as a professor. The latter would have interesting implications for the question of "Access to what?" from the introduction.

arcie m

the student body being made up of regular people (not the elites who studied abroad in the West) who leaned religious seems to me like the thing that imbued AMUT with revolutionary potential so I don't think there's anything to assess about Charman's decision. Even if he had joined, it's not clear to me that he would have had much to contribute to the student organizing. Maybe he could have done some critical consciousness raising or shielded some students from some of the consequences, but they clearly did what needed to be done without him i think what happened is very different from the aspirations of academics who "want to change academia from within." first, those aims (or least the possibilities under discussion) basically stop at diversity and inclusivity - it never amounts to using universities to like overthrow the government. second, i think there's something different about who US academics end up in community with as their students: someone choosing to go to an influential US research university to "change academia from within" will not end up in community with the people

Jacques Vincelette

p19 "According to Zarghamee, the fifth chancellor of AMUT, the establishment of AMUT coincided with significant educational transformations occurring in France and widespread student protests against the Vietnam War in the United States. Majid Rahnama (1924–2015), the minister of science and higher education at the time, urged the Shah to prevent these protests from spreading to institutions of higher education." Instead of addressing grievances, protests are suppressed. Protests in France, Albania, Italy, Portugal and Belgium this week-end again are lead by students. And calls for peace are violently quelled as antisemitic or unpatriotic. p30 "While we were unable to locate definitive archival records, it is important to note that AMUT students largely came from lower-middle-class and moderately religious families. (…) the wealthier the society was getting the upper class strata of the society that did not have strong religious beliefs anymore was sending their kids abroad for education.(…) In terms of economic class and background, approximately 5 percent of students came from a “professional” background, with 30 percent from families of “white-collar employees,” and the rest (65 percent) from “blue-collar”" (So happens I picked up a blue collar on clearance at the petstore this afternoon to strap the harp on my shoulders in order to play on the road. I adapted the Irish traditional tune: The minstrel girl to the war is gone, In the ranks of blood you'll find her. Her father's sword she has girded on, And her wild harp slung behind her.)

Jacques Vincelette

On September 9, closet violinist, friend, colleague, was stabbed 400m from my home, half way on my path to masdjid, at the corner of the church where a tenor lends me a harp. She recovers slowly in hospital, still too painful to hear me sing. Last Wednesday, community rallied for a supportive walk. I did not carry the harp; not about me; hadn't practiced standing; makeshift blue braided harness was missing a strap. We were gifted orange whistles and invited to be loud. Only youth whistled as we marched solemnly.

across-overalls

I just caught up and what struck me most was the demographics concerning women (roughly 10% with outliers). I had read they were much higher but had not connected that was probably a post revolutionary stat. As for Charman, I initially thought “well you chose wisely” but your point on the eventually overthrow occurrence got me. Another reader commented that he probably couldn’t have done much ultimately, and I’m still wrestling with that. Ultimately I think this has the perspective of an individual’s contribution as an autonomous actor, and this may be a thoroughly Western stance. But that is how I see academics typically: Struggling on their own. The Anti Imperialist Scholars Collective has caught my eye though, which is just a truncated thought as I need to end this comment eventually 😬