Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

"the historical record contradicts, or at least complicates, these images [of a hostile relationship between the US and Iran]. The Shah of Iran was a close American ally, and many have argued that before the 1979 revolution, Iran was the most important strategic partner of the US in the Middle East."

crazy to read about such a time in this the year of our lord 2026

I find that a lot of my experience reading this book so far is trying to make comparisons between the events it talks about and things happening today. for example, it was really interesting to learn about the student opposition to supporting Iran's nuclear development. i'm not suprised that there was opposition, but I was a little surprised by the scale of it: the number/size of organizations that came together, or having as high profile a representative as Noam Chomsky (though I guess he might not have been as significant a figure 50 years ago?). The description of the extent of opposition initially had me thinking, wow why can't we get our shit together like that today, but then I had to remind myself that even MIT had encampments opposing the genocide in gaza, and that was definitely not nothing. I dunno, I know of various organizations that exist in the current moment among academics/scientists, and my gut is telling me that it's not as much/strong/organized as it used to be, but maybe I'm just making some kind of nostalgia fallacy because I'm actually finding it difficult to make a clear comparison.

one bit of...not nostalgia I guess, but seeing the past repeat itself that stood out was the logic supporters of the AMUT partnership used to argue against the pushback, basically saying, 'well if we don't teach them how to make a nuclear program someone will, so we might as well do it with our (ostensibly preferable) values.' Did anyone else read that and immediately think of AI booster logic? The same theme is coming up in a different context in the research I'm doing currently for my next video (not spoiling the topic...yet), it really seems like the universal way to neutralize critiques of 'you're doing science/tech in a way that's very likely to lead to bad outcomes'. feels like something I wanna examine further at some point

Comments

Anthony Perez Eisenbarth

I'm not at all surprised by how close MIT and AMUT were. I kept thinking about the Chicago Boys in Chile and Friedman while reading it. In the mid 1950s the University of Chicago signed an agreement with the Catholic University of Chile, funded through the US aid program, and over the next fifteen years or so around a hundred Chilean economists trained under Friedman, Harberger, and Schultz. They came home, took over the economics faculty, and after the 1973 coup they were running Pinochet's economy. The timing of the events with this chapter is incredibly close too. Friedman went to Santiago in March 1975, met Pinochet, and recommended "shock treatment," the same month MIT students were fighting the Iran deal. And Friedman’s defense when his Nobel Prize was protested was basically Brown's. He was just giving technical advice, what’s a guy to do? Chomsky was already a well known figure on the American left by 1975. He was famously arrested at the Pentagon march in 1967, written “American Power and the New Mandarins,” and had that famous debate with Foucault in 1971. (I think 1975 was actually a bit past the peak at MIT too, which was probably 1969.) His reputation is in tatters nowadays. Though I'll admit I’ve never really deeply engaged with his work. The Epstein emails showed how he stayed close with Epstein for years after the 2008 conviction, even advising him on handling the press in 2019. And there's the whole Pol Pot situation where he and Herman downplayed the reports coming out of Cambodia. Hard to square all this with the guy who wrote "The Responsibility of Intellectuals." At any rate, there’s certainly no longer the same of organizational or institutional structure for the American left for that matter anymore. The left in America is not as “militant” anymore as it used to be.

Jacques Vincelette

I attended this week Anishnabek Nation Economic Development Forum in Thunder Bay, hosted by the indigenous advocacy "Union of Ontario Indians". Though drone technology featured in previous forums, they were not discussed this time around. Talks of war pointed back to the tariff war, avoiding any sympathy for the war on the homeless, displaced population, the war in Europe, the war in West Asia. The Canadian government sides with the American military adventurism, indigenous people excuse themselves from the arms race. Juggling contradiction, indigenous leaders strongly oppose fascistic laws C5 and C39 intended to bypass treaty obligations and environmental engagements. Yet industry touts C5 and C39 for indigenous communities along the Toronto-Quebec City corridor to take control of a high speed rail project. On American activism, iceinmyarea.org and justnice.us give me hope. Robin Wall Kimmerer pointed out Wednesday how our struggle calls us back to gather what wisdom we carry through the bottleneck. https://youtu.be/KZEej03M3_Q?t=2650

Jacques Vincelette

Interesting timeline. In 1974, India conducted the Smiling Buddha nuclear test... allegedly for civil demolition purposes. Before then Canada supported Indian nuclear research with the sale of heavy water moderated nuclear reactor technology. Atomic Energy Canada Limited was incorporated in 1952 to limit the liability of the Canadian government and expand its marketing base. In 2015, management of the Chalk River site was privatized in the British Go-Co model (Goverment owned - Contractor operated). We project our arms race upon Russia and Iran as smoke and mirror to our own hustle culture.

Dr. Fatima

ooh the chicago programs an interesting parallel, didnt occur to me while reading but i totally see it

Dr. Fatima

and thanks for the details on chomsky... also been trying to make sense of his work in light of the epstein reveal :/

Simon

The "if we don't do it someone else will" argument did indeed remind me of AI boosterism but I've heard it before AI many times. It has the same logic as the "Don't Create the Torment Nexus" meme, and doesn't make much sense unless you substitute the tech involved with money. One thing I found interesting about the US student's opposition to the AMUT program is that the SACC was described as being critical of "the scientific establishment's role in global politics. This critique particularly focussed on how science and technology were implicated in broader global dynamics, such as the Vietnam war" (p. 44). Obviously science plays a role in warfare and given the public nature of science in general I think it's naieve to suggest you can advance technology and also somehow prevent it from being using in war. Were they arguing that scientific advances were enabling or prolonging war somehow? Did they mean science in general, or military applications specifically? I don't think the book adresses the opposing students' motivations in much detail (I could be mistaken though).

Ryan d'Eon

About "If we don't do it someone else will": it's not a foundation anyone ever used to decide what to do. It's an after-you've-decided rationalisation. It's purpose is to be difficult to refute, while allowing you to do something either you feel guilty about or will face criticism for. On the large scale, industry-wide or institution-wide or society-wide, it is used to lower the moral floor for actions. The weakest link becomes the metric for everyone to use to decide what to do. If someone will, then everyone should. Worse than that, of course: if we can imagine a hypothetical actor who could, then we should.

Ryan d'Eon

I guess that came out of nowhere. I'm catching up on the book, and also found myself struck by the use of this particular logic, which has never sat right with me before. Wanted to get out my thoughts about it. My other reaction to this chapter was that it either flies in the face of the interpretation that western engineering students are less political, or it is setting us up to find out how they became less political over time. Because in this chapter, they seem very activist.