Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

halfway through the book, lets gooo

"Given the anti-imperialistic, revolutionary culture prevalent at AMUT, one might expect that Nasr's philosophical critiques of Western scientific paradigms would resonate with leftist students who were fundamentally protesting the US-backed autocratic regime. After all, if there is a commonality to be drawn between leftist AMUT students and Dr. Nasr, it's in their shared critiques of the West. For Nasr, this specifically entailed critical assessments of Western knowledge production and epistemic regimes of rationality and scientific objectivity. For the students, they were anti-West primarily in their opposition to the Shah and his policies. As it pertains to Nasr specifically, his epistemological critiques of Western knowledge were ultimately overshadowed by his proximity to the Shah."

This chapter was such an interesting rollercoaster between me being like 'yaaas nasr wow so based' and confusion at seemingly contradictory positions

e.g., criticizing western objectivity and imperialism, advocating for the environment, emphasizing the importance of humanities in STEM: super here for it! (particularly thought inviting artists and the whole horizontal tower concept were cool). but then, insisting he and the university were apolitical, dismissing students' "radical" perspectives, as naive, and for some reason ragging on the theory of evolution: how is this the same guy? it's honestly a useful reminder for me, i think (especially within a US context) it can be easily to fall into thinking that x y and z political perspectives always go together, and a b and c political perspectives always go together, but in real life its totally possible for people to believe both z and b, or whatever seemingly unexpected combination.

that said, i wonder if it's gonna end up being that that juxtaposition is exactly what led to the students doing what they'll eventually do? like, based on what I know about technical education and political activity of students, a whole lot of what Nasr did---require humanities classes, expose students to the arts, emphasize a national identity and spirituality as a source of purpose to drive STEM---seems like it would foster politically engaged students. but then by repressing them politically... idk it kinda feels like Nasr simultaneously gave students the tools to revolt and an enemy to revolt against. not sure if that's where this is going but that's the vibe i'm getting so far

speaking of national identity and critiques of western science, i also found the idea of modernization, but Iranian-ly, quite interesting:

"In a sense he was a modernist, but he was also very much interested in his own country. He wanted Iran to modernize. Not that the modern world to just take over Iran and change it from what it was."

I'm generalizing a lot here, but i've been exposed to a lot of perspectives in which "modernization" is necessarily at odds with "retaining X middle eastern identity"---to modernize is to become more culturally similar to the US or Europe (and i've seen this contrast both in people who embrace the modernization and want whatever middle eastern place/culture to improve by becoming more western, or a rejection of modernization for fear of becoming western). this might be the first perspective I've seen that tries to reconcile modernization and a middle eastern identity, not by confirming to the west or just moving opposite to it, but looking for an authentic evolution of one's own culture in a rapidly developing world. not sure if anyone has similar experience with the tradition/modernization conflict in other parts of the world (or even other examples in the middle east), but would be very curious to hear it so.

Comments

Jacques Vincelette

" looking for an authentic evolution of one's own culture (...) with the tradition/modernization conflict" was central to my great-grandmothers', grandmothers', aunts', mother's, and sisters' feminist struggle. I also frame the LGBTQ+ revolution as part of this struggle. (I'm still nostalgic of 2nd wave feminism as folk made way to disco and punk rock.) Anishinabek Nation on Turtle Island struggle with the trauma of genocide and cultural erasure, resilience and recognition for culture carried through, and commitment to Truth and Reconciliation beyond political theatre. The Anishinabek Nation Economic Development Forum hosted last week by Fort Williams 1st Nation carries that conundrum... giving voice to successful modern enterprise with emphasis that 'success' is measured on the impact to the most vulnerable.

Jacques Vincelette

p. 53 "Nasr conveys that what passes for scientific objectivity in the modern Western world would not bring humanity closer to the nature of existence, and to claim otherwise is an act of arrogance and ignorance. “It is as if an audience of deaf people testified together that they did not hear any music from musicians playing before them and considered the unanimity of their opinion as a proof of its objectivity.” Colleagues tell me they don't dance because they never have. What cruel childhood denies dance? Hip mobility across the gender spectrum undeniably calls for feminist doct'ring.

Simon

Nasr certainly seems to be in a difficult position: in between the Shah and everything he represents, his own vision of modernisation and the student's criticisms and protests. It seems that Nasr was aligned with the Shah on the aims of the university: "the prime minister Amir-Abbas Hoveyda told him (Nasr) that the Shah had chosen him because he was the only one who offered a serious critique of the challenges of modernization" (p. 61). I'm struggling to find a description of what the student's positions actually were but, viewing this whole thing in the frame of the cold war, I'm assuming they were trying to prevent leftists from staging some kind of communist revolution. The tension between Nasr's vision for modernisation and the student's (perceived?) revolutionary ideas seem to come to expression in the Center For Humanities. Nasr "beleived that to produce ethical scientists and engineers who were responsive to cultural, environmental, and spiritual matters, engineering students needed a specific technical education rooted in the social and cultural history of the nation" (p. 64). Some of the students viewed the Center as having a "hidden political agenda" and "was established to depoliticize the student body"(p. 66) so I suppose they viewed Nasr as a kind of puppet of the Shah and didn't believe the primary goal of the university was to train Persianized engineers. I think the students were politically engaged independant of their activities at the university and that Nasr simply got caught in their fight with the Shah, or more broadly between the US and Russia in the cold war. Nasr "feared a generation of Iranian scientists and engineers who would be wholly incapable of adressing the real needs and actual concerns of their own country". Maybe a good example of this in current times can be found in AI; it's being stuffed into every piece of software imaginable and being presented as the solution for any kind of problem a professional could have. The gains in productivity of using AI outside of computer technology seem to be few to none, however: https://www.apollo.com/wealth/insights-news/insights/daily-spark/no-signs-of-ai-payoff-outside-the-tech-sector. AI looks to be a software engineer's solution for software engineering problems, extrapolated to the rest of the world. Maybe they should have taken more courses in a Center For Humanities of their own.

arcie m

I found it interesting that from SHN's perspective, humanities students in Iran were less inclined towards leftist thought than STEM students were, due to their humanities training. on a superficial level, that's the opposite of what we have here. part of it i imagine is what we mean by humanities education in the first place. the humanities education that SHN was talking about may have been more like studying greek philosophy, the roman empire, and the enlightenment here, rather than like gramsci or foucault. but i also wonder if part of it is that islam and marx lead to competing political projects it was also noteworthy to me that the students at AMUT were aggrieved by the wealth inequality they were seeing, coming from modest means to the city. that factor, combined with giving them a good education, is a recipe for creating future revolutionaries. i wonder if on some level that the function of humanities education, in pre-revolutionary Iran as well as here, is to "domesticate" such future revolutionaries by training them to become part of the existing political system instead. that's something that fred moten and stefano harney say about professional academics, at least

Jacques Vincelette

p.69 "In addition to their alleged naivete, he noted that during his presidency, almost all AMUT professors were younger than thirty years old. Furthermore, he also attributed their politics to the material conditions many faced in their home villages. He said that most professors and students were from lower socioeconomic backgrounds and were deeply pained by the deep economic discrepancies they observed between their home villages and affluent parts of Tehran. (...) they seemed like villagers, it was overly visible and painful for them." The berating terms "naivete", "villagers", "overly" overwhelmed by pain, project a class divide that resonates with my own family history in Canada with the repression of French Canadian, indigenous populations, and immigrant refugees. Elitism in stratified academy offered liberal mobility up the social ladder: as one sheds lower class upbringing, one's village must be left behind in order to commit to serious study.

AlexTheTutor

I like Nasr’s analogy: if a group of deaf people reported not to hear music from a guitar, then objectivity permits science to conclude (logically) that guitars do not produce music (p < 0.05). Also, Nasr’s use of the ‘amnesia’ as a metaphor most likely comes from his education in the history of science. I’m going to try to tie Nasr’s metaphor to the first question about tradition and modernity: In February of 1922, Rio de Janeiro hosted Modern Art Week. Before this week, artists in Brasil focused on copying the great writers of Europe: poetry must be crafted with rhyme schemes and precise control of rhythm. As a result, art was for the elite: if you know how to read, you can enjoy this art; if you know how to write like Europeans, then you can enter the arts. But, one day, many young artists a little over a century ago said, “No, we are Brazilians! We want modernity. But, we want it to be Brazilian Modernity. We want to express what we are and who we are.” And so, after this one week in February of 1922… Brazilians began to create their own cultural identity, separate from Europe and Portugal. Before 1922, poets such as Olavo Bilac wrote traditional academic poetry such as “In the Middle of the Road” that referenced Dante’s Inferno and other European classics. After, poets such as Carlos Drummond wrote “In the middle of the road…”, a poem rooted in his own experiences from Brasil, and well… there is a video on YouTube that translates this short poem in 10 different languages, and today there is a statue of Carlos Drummond on the Copacabana beach. This one week in February: Brazilians took European paintings and created the paintings of Tarsila do Amaral, took jazz and created Bossa Nova. It is a beautiful thing when a culture embraces its own identify and says, “This is us, this is how WE see the world”. This ability to express one’s own culture, it is a language beyond written language. To think how many languages-beyond-language never happen, just because of the great influence of one dominant culture, imposing its will on other cultures. Just as some languages can become endangered as just a handful of people speak its words, so too can cultures become endangered by a super-majority of its people embracing one dominant culture over their own culture until just a handful of grandparents remember the days when kids used to trick-or-treat or do some other particular thing. Perhaps in the future, one monoculture consuming the same social media will think the same and feel the same and do the same: whatever is trending that week is modern, and the tradition is to never to repeat the same trend again on purpose. It is almost as if people within a monoculture of logic and feeling, people will disconnect from their past. They will have amnesia. But, I don’t want amnesia. I want to feel the music and poetry of Iran (and other places), art that isn’t influenced from the outside, but comes from within. Also, to comment on political perspectives and how a person can embrace a,b,c and x,y,z: The US has a long and strong cultural tradition of comedy. To be a comedian, when you do stand up, you must stand out. And, what stands out is shock. In the 1980’s, a comedian may start with how airplane food is horrible, while a comedian post 9-11 wanting to stand out will push things and say, “so, airplanes… wait… too soon?”, until (and I kid you not), when you explain what ‘burning a CD’ is to gen-alpha by saying that it was common in the 2000’s and without skipping a beat, a gen-alpha kid saying “oh yeah, they got that expressing on 9-11 after the burning of…”, well you can fill in the rest, edgy comedy, never forget? oh such amnesia. Meanwhile, there are other countries and other cultures out there: kids in other cultures who don’t even like The Office because Michael Scott is a jerk, and nothing is funny, at all, not a single moment, inappropriate, and shameful that any adult acts like this, now let’s be serious, real people are starving, our neighbors are starving, heck, we’re starving! Kids are saying this, not adults. In these same cultures: “of course you can be religious and apply concepts in genetics and evolution to treat patients in a clinical setting, what does one thing have to do with the other? God is good”. (Contrast this to Nasr’s opinion about evolution). These cultures had video rental stores on every block, well… now everyone embraces monoculture of Netflix… hm… Big tech with its social media can make sure that millions (billions) of people who used to have various opinions now only have 2 opinions, that everyone will be categorized as believing a,b,c or x,y,z, and everyone will be too emotional to remember a time before this, amnesia… But, remember the words from the past: Public opinion happens when no one has any ideas, the stronger the public opinion, the less likely anyone has any original ideas. Don’t you see the propaganda, it’s just like air, it’s right in front of your face, you breathe it in, but you never feel it, but it does in fact press on every inch of the body and mind: a,b,c vs x,y,z

Jacques Vincelette

To quote our fearless leader: "So glad I shared I couldn’t pirate “Revolutionary Engineers”"

Ryan d'Eon

I'm so confused about the random anti-evolution comment. Maybe there is an Iranian or Islamic context the reader is assumed to have that makes it obvious? To me, however, the phrase "scientific Illusion" is not enough to explain it, but it suggests a critique based in some read Nasr has of the evidence? I wonder if the interviewers didn't want to touch it, because it's out of scope. I also found myself having to reorient my intuition about politics. I think i got that in the cold war, the US was right and USSR was left, and Nasr is trying to plot an unrelated Iranian course. Kind of leviathan style, just a little country stuck in the middle and he's trying to prevent his own students from being sucked towards one political pole or the other. Some of him comments comments about leftists seemed alarmist, almost funny in their exaggeration, until I remembered there was a huge, belligerent country that proclaimed to be leftist.