"Revolutionary Engineers" - Chapter 3: "Dr. Seyyed Hossein Nasr at AMUT: Bridging Science, Philosophy, and Controversy (1972-1975)" (Patreon)
Content
halfway through the book, lets gooo
"Given the anti-imperialistic, revolutionary culture prevalent at AMUT, one might expect that Nasr's philosophical critiques of Western scientific paradigms would resonate with leftist students who were fundamentally protesting the US-backed autocratic regime. After all, if there is a commonality to be drawn between leftist AMUT students and Dr. Nasr, it's in their shared critiques of the West. For Nasr, this specifically entailed critical assessments of Western knowledge production and epistemic regimes of rationality and scientific objectivity. For the students, they were anti-West primarily in their opposition to the Shah and his policies. As it pertains to Nasr specifically, his epistemological critiques of Western knowledge were ultimately overshadowed by his proximity to the Shah."
This chapter was such an interesting rollercoaster between me being like 'yaaas nasr wow so based' and confusion at seemingly contradictory positions
e.g., criticizing western objectivity and imperialism, advocating for the environment, emphasizing the importance of humanities in STEM: super here for it! (particularly thought inviting artists and the whole horizontal tower concept were cool). but then, insisting he and the university were apolitical, dismissing students' "radical" perspectives, as naive, and for some reason ragging on the theory of evolution: how is this the same guy? it's honestly a useful reminder for me, i think (especially within a US context) it can be easily to fall into thinking that x y and z political perspectives always go together, and a b and c political perspectives always go together, but in real life its totally possible for people to believe both z and b, or whatever seemingly unexpected combination.
that said, i wonder if it's gonna end up being that that juxtaposition is exactly what led to the students doing what they'll eventually do? like, based on what I know about technical education and political activity of students, a whole lot of what Nasr did---require humanities classes, expose students to the arts, emphasize a national identity and spirituality as a source of purpose to drive STEM---seems like it would foster politically engaged students. but then by repressing them politically... idk it kinda feels like Nasr simultaneously gave students the tools to revolt and an enemy to revolt against. not sure if that's where this is going but that's the vibe i'm getting so far
speaking of national identity and critiques of western science, i also found the idea of modernization, but Iranian-ly, quite interesting:
"In a sense he was a modernist, but he was also very much interested in his own country. He wanted Iran to modernize. Not that the modern world to just take over Iran and change it from what it was."
I'm generalizing a lot here, but i've been exposed to a lot of perspectives in which "modernization" is necessarily at odds with "retaining X middle eastern identity"---to modernize is to become more culturally similar to the US or Europe (and i've seen this contrast both in people who embrace the modernization and want whatever middle eastern place/culture to improve by becoming more western, or a rejection of modernization for fear of becoming western). this might be the first perspective I've seen that tries to reconcile modernization and a middle eastern identity, not by confirming to the west or just moving opposite to it, but looking for an authentic evolution of one's own culture in a rapidly developing world. not sure if anyone has similar experience with the tradition/modernization conflict in other parts of the world (or even other examples in the middle east), but would be very curious to hear it so.