Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

"[A] peer of our time was such a talented person coming from a small town from Kerman. In the second or third year, we noticed he is not coming to the campus, after a while we heard he was also killed... Nobody wanted to make their political orientation public, we would not know anything about their orientation before these people going underground [secretly joining militant orgs], the political suffocation at the time is not comparable to what we are experiencing these days, these days everyone at least talks, but at the time you would not even dare to reveal your criticism to yourself. When someone was killed, others would not do something [i.e., mourn, or protest] which could make their orientation clear."

I think my biggest takeaway from this chapter was that, as much repression as it feels like there is in the US right now, as hard as it feels like it is to be say, a leftist academic or engineer, as much fear mongering as there is about communists or whatever tf---it's really aren't that bad yet. Like it's bad, don't get me wrong, (i mean i literally lost my academic job because my research was too woke, clearly it's bad), but it's hard for me to even imagine a level of suppression like the one this chapter described. Like, really imagine living in it, having to make decisions about how (or if??) I engage with politics in it. The stats alone are horrifying---a third of the student population kicked out over protesting, 2-3% of that same population killed for their political activity. I wanna say I'd have my principles in any context, but how would I actually feel about presenting them to the world the way I did in school if a hundred of my classmates had been killed for theirs?

I was particularly struck by the danger of just having political content. Like the story of the student that had his home searched by SAVAK, where they found incriminating things such as leftist fiction books or a tape with a song by a Soviet singer...can you imagine? I understand that to a degree modern suppression of political dissent functions through overwhelm of content rather than the criminalization of certain content, but it still feels wild in retrospect how easy it is for us to share and access political books, ideas, art, whatever. like yes, they're taking the woke books out of libraries, but a critical analysis of that phenomenon is probably online right now and won't get you arrested, and that's significant.

A lot of time is spent discussing the damage technology and the internet is doing to our society---which, valid, obviously i think that's worth discussing---but i increasingly find myself thinking, shit there's still so much potential here. Not to get too off topic but i'm thinking of the recent left wing win in brazil's presidential election; I've been seeing so much discussion of the digital strategies people used to combat Meta's support for the Trump knockoff candidate, and it's really renewing my optimism for the potential of the internet as a site of radical activity. Haven't felt like this since they organized the arab spring over facebook (lol really come full circle with meta and popular uprisings huh)

but bringing it back to the suppression of leftist media from the chapter: it makes sense that we, ppl on the online left, constantly remind ourselves that making/watching stuff about politics isn't the same as doing politics and that platforms like youtube are compromised in whatever ways, but the perspective this chapter gave me is definitely making me feel like we should take seriously our ability to share such content, knowing that in another context, people in power would try to take it away.

~~~

A last thing that I found interesting was this description of why students at AMUT were ideal members:

"According to OIPFG, Marxism-Leninsm, as a science that deals with social formation and phenomena, is one of the most complex and layered subjects in nature and, therefore, requires a highly developed mind to understand. Due to their social background, academic studies, and psychological training, students were deemed capable of grasping and applying this theory. OIPFG urged active participation by students to mobilize against imperialism and dictatorship, as they were considered the most knowledgeable and dynamic group of people within Iran. Therefore, the organization aimed to mobilize and coordinate student forces.

so like i don't disagree that students make good political actors, is anyone else getting 'only nerds are smart enough to run society' from this? idk maybe i'm projecting, but my read is yes, and it's interesting how STEM culture can vary internationally but also retain some of the same obnoxious pretentiousness bc numbers are sooo rational* or whatever



*not counting the irrational ones ofc

Comments

Jacques Vincelette

p86 According to Pouyan, the only way to get beyond this absolute weakness—to politicize and organize the working class—was for the revolutionary intellectuals to connect with the masses through “revolutionary might” (qudrat ʼinqilābī). He contended that such revolutionary might would establish emotional bonds between revolutionary intellectuals and the proletariat, eventually extending into building organizational relations. Revolutionary might sparks emotion into relations and organization. The nerds "propagandistic nature, informing the proletariat of a force of its own". I recognize that emotion carries an embodied perception and understanding of relationships intersecting the web of life. The humble intellectual sparks fires in faith that community will tend them, that life remains resilient.

Jacques Vincelette

p81 Maryam, a female alumni of AMUT who had participated in such mountain climbing, recounts: In the mountains, everyone would sing epic songs. This was a result of youth excitement. We would wake up at 4 in the morning, somewhere in the middle of the mountain, packing our equipment, singing, this all created an atmosphere of seriousness, excitement. (Mountain climbing bring us back to Moses and the Ark of the Covenant, the ultimate sermon from Martin Luther King Jr, the sunrise atop Mauna Kea)

Dr. Fatima

i thought this part about going to the mountains was so cool! they really knew how to touch grass lol

across-overalls

I flagged your last point too because i disagree with the book here. ML is absolutely a bear to grapple with however, when you’re brought up in a society fueled by its eradication. I agree to that extent. However, in talks with Chinese and Vietnamese comrades, it’s just laughable that it would be a difficult concept as dialectics etc are taught in abstract ways from basic schooling, progressing to formal study later on. I’m finding a lot of side eye with this book but I’m glad we’re digging in. Another thing is the Maoist violence is always presented in isolation like oh there was this assassination attempt, or this thing was blown up. The context isn’t presented alongside these points, but maybe it’s a few paragraphs or a section back. So way back here: “there’s some students murdered oh my!” And later: “Soandso blew up a building. Crazy!” It’s giving whiplash with the timeline. I read a page ahead and we’re about to get a 2024 report from a foreign radio broadcasting *into* Iran, so I’m trying to hold in my mind that this book is a product of MIT

across-overalls

That said, this is my fav chapter so far. This book is really helping me organize one of my local events screening Still Minab. Student Day falls on a Monday but we might shoot for that rather than waiting to commemorate the 1yr. It’s a slight stretch, but we’re dealing with a pro imperialist domestic force in Iran, so there is some ideological alignment with the 2026 events

Jacques Vincelette

Thank-you for the lead on 'Still Minab' p91 The close relation between the leftists and Islamic leftists have also been discussed by one of our female interviewees: “The two groups were not enemies to each other, would cooperate with each other and had many similarities with each other. The leftist girls also wore simple clothes, so were respected by the religious”. The imperialist/sovereigntist SDF Kurdish forces lost ground and gas wells to Damascus' interim government. Imperial counterfeit rials and Starlink terminals don't go as far as they did a year ago. Simple modesty trends in fashion.

AlexTheTutor

The cartoon movie PERSEPOLIS by Marjane Satrapi portrays Iran at a time when even listening to rock and roll led to imprisonment or worse, plenty of trigger warnings, but great movie and really puts liberty into perspective. Another work to recommend is a comic called BANNED BOOK CLUB by Kim Hyun Sook and Ryan Estrada; it’s about student protests in 1980’s but in South Korea, in which Kim herself just wanted to study literature, but was threated prison time for the crime of discussing Shakespeare and etc, Ryan and Kim are married, and I actually met Ryan once, great guy, he illustrates the comic. It’s interesting to compare-contrast different student protest movements globally Now, about chapter 4: when I was reading this, the first thought was, “Patty Cake, Patty Cake, Baker’s Man, bake me a cake as fast as you can”, it’s one of those hand clapping games that 5 year olds play during preschool, and it’s a game that outside of preschool, no one ever plays or ever thinks about, and it shows how much environment can shape our actions, and so… how interesting it is that Iran has decades of experience with student activism, almost as if inside the school, students play the game of activism and protest, but once outside of this environment, eh… the game loses much of its momentum, (yes, of course there are many factors that lead to activism-protest, I’m just including this as one significant factor), after all, December 7th is Student Day in Iran (1953), it’s baked within their culture to recall student protests, “bake me a revolution as fast as you can” Also, having taught-spoken with many international students, I want to share this perspective: imagine being from a country in which the only way to become a doctor (or someone super important in society) is to pass an impossibly difficult entrance exam, an exam that only 1 out of 10,000 may pass, and if you are poor, the odds are even more against you, but despite all odds, you pass, and you enter the best university in your country, naturally… you feel important, you feel as if you are the chosen one, “wait, chosen one…? Isn’t that a bit much?” No, in Iran, if you are a medical student who did the impossible to enter the best medical school, you can remind yourself of the great Ibn Sina, Iran’s great physician from Islamic Golden Age, maybe you see yourself as the next great physician, and now you enter a special group of other students who are just as intelligent and motivated and feel just as important, no one in this group has ever accepted mediocrity, there’s no time to waste, no time to be nerdy, everyone in this group demands excellence, not only from themselves but from their society, and the best way to demand excellence is… activism-protest

Dr. Fatima

@ across-overalls, it's so interesting you say that, I can't remember where but within just the last few days I saw someone explaining how in say, china, ocncepts like dialectic materialism or whatever other marxist ideas are just...commonly understood, not some obscure academic idea that only nerds who read a lot of theory understand. it makes sense that in a society ideologically antithetical to those perspectives, that wouldn't be the case, but I don't think I could really appreciate how significant that distinction is until hearing this also, are you in iran??

Jacques Vincelette

To be fair, repetitive slapping around ties adults into repressive policing. Youthfull curiosity holds space for contrationtion. p.77 The book begins with his confession of love to Azadeh, a former classmate, made decades after the events that irrevocably altered the course of Farahmand Rad’s life. In his second year at AMUT, Farahmand Rad was transformed from a starry-eyed romantic to a fearless activist Yousouf Islam's Tea for the Tillerman opens on "Where do the Children Play" and wraps up with "Father and Son" and title song. Bell Hooks "Will to Change" came through thrice this Wednesday November 4, with my wife, with a medicine woman, and with a friend and mentor coming out of parental leave.

Matthew

Yeah, it absolutely felt like the OIPFG was saying that only nerds could properly run society. I wonder what causes this because I think that it not only applies to those in STEM, but to anyone who feels superior to everyone else (the rich, the Europeans over the rest of the world, etc.) I think part of why it can be so pervasive in STEM has to do with what AlexTheTutor was saying, that you pull off what others deem extremely difficult or impossible and then the people you interact with pulled off the same feat and so you have the sense that now you are the next great physician/scientist/etc. and that you are better than everyone else. Uh, this might be a terrible take, but I was also getting some Harry Potter vibes, mostly the later books when the Ministry of Magic was trying to crack down on what was happening at Hogwarts. Obviously, these were two vastly different scenarios, but I think the combination of students who were somewhat stuck to the school they were attending, assuming most AMUT students lived on or near campus, the fact that there was an underground student network, and the government was trying to suppress the students. I’m sure that there are better examples out there, but this was one theme in HP that has always stuck with me and I think it felt similar when the students were saying that they didn’t know who they could trust.

Matthew

Hi AlexTheTutor, I liked what you said about activism-protest, how it is shaped by the environment that people are in. For me, it feels like it is less about loosing momentum and more that the momentum gets diluted. At university, most people are similar ages and at similar stages of life as well as the environment most universities try to cultivate is trying to create as much interactions between people as they can. These interactions are where ideas come together to clash, interact, build on each other, and create new ideas. This is also done in a relatively small area. Once you get outside of the university, now you are interacting with people who are in more diverse stages of life and life outside of school tends to be more dispersed and harder/less likely for various different human interactions.