Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 542275603.mp4

Downloads

Content

HERE IT IS!!!!! I had a lot to say...

...and just fyi, yes, I realize I misinterpreted Father Figure & I am now aware of its true meaning. Pls don't do "WELL AKSHUALLY!!!" in the comments x

I would also like to remind everyone that this is a reaction, not a review. These are my instinctive responses to the songs I heard. They are not well-thought-through opinions. I may do a little Patreon space in an hour or so to discuss the #process of making this one because it was definitely different than others.

ENJOY!!! And express your opinions freely, but please be kind to your fellow commenters x

Files

Comments

Sarah Harrison

How the heck I refreshed Patreon at the PERFECT time waiting for this video ahhhh

Emma

I’ve never clicked so fast

Rebecca Russell

Omg yess! The swiftologist lord has blessed me with this reaction as soon as I click on the app! 🙇🏻‍♀️

Lisa M

HERE

bee

best morning coffee video ever

GB999444

Your shorts titles scared me I hope we're being tay positive today...

Faith

I’ve been WAITING for this one TURN IT UPP

Claire

Yes it’s time!

Morgan

Thank godddd

Hazel

YOU LOOK SO GOOD

thalia

IM AT WORK AND THEYRE GOING TO FIRE ME BC IM TOO SAT FOR THIS VIDEO

james

the album kinda being like if lover was good

Amanda

Yasss! Was waiting for you to SHOW, girl! 🥰

Hattie

Yassss

brandon

“FINALLY” THE CROWD SAYS IN UNISON LMAO

Yarn Kay

NODAYSOFFLOGIST!

megan

been waiting for this

Tilly

MY SHOW IS ON!!

Roisin Shy

It’s here!!!! Thank you!!!

Ashley

Here we go!

maja

Second Most important Release today omg

Shannon

Can't wait!

Alina

The Life of a showologist!! Well yes!!

☆

THANK GOD!!!!!!

Léna

oh thank god

Tylerr

never have i clicked so fast

Veronika

ME TOO OMG FINALLYYY

Lauren

YESSS PATREON SPACE SOOON PLEEAK

prajith

i fear i initially took in father figure in a similar way to u so good to know im not the only one… famously also believed fresh out the summer was the actual song name for a week after ur video

sara

Everyone quiet my show is on 🗣🗣🗣

Laura Chadid

i was WAITING for your reaction

claudz

never clicked so fast

Malcolm

I’m sorry I’m a wood stan

Nicola

Yessss!!!!! No daysofffff

Sandra Maril

It took me 2 seconds to click play

Adam

Am I the only one that thinks CANCELLED! Sounds like yellow flicker beat by lorde 😭😭😭

Tha P

This right here is why i joined patreon lol

Jennie 🐍🖤

IVE BEEN WAITINGGGG. I’m sat for this reaction

Favour

omg finally, i kept checking every 3 minutes lmao

Emma Martinez

SHOWGIRL!!! The outfits are stunning omg 🥰

Rachel

WE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS #KINGOLOGIST

VROOM VROOM

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS ALL DAY THANK YOU ZACH

E ✨🩷

there's elements to it that sound like a Lady Gaga song to me but I can't pin it down !! love it though

Maria

Sabrina wishes she could write Wood lol be so fr

Saanal

OMFG THIS FIT!!!

Espritlumiere

Vibing to The Fate of Ophelia straight away is so real ❤️‍🔥

Kris

Omgsh yes!!! Let’s gooo

chappell roan

I love eldest daughter, actually romantic, honey, tfoo, elizabeth Taylor, father figure and ruin the friendship, opalite cancelled, wish list, and showgirl are kinda mid to me, wood is unforgivable lyrically but undeniably a banger unfortunately.

Autumn

The Fate of Ophelia is soooo good

sofía

so happy i joined the patreon today!!!!

Abby

Oh girls

Momo

i was the same during fate of ophelia, it starts sooo strong with the first two songs and then.....

Danielaaaa

IM AT WORK AND CANT LISTEN TILL LATER- SO EXCITED

Justus 🤍

Wood is bad. But fun! It’s such a weird song to me

Enzo Reis

Elizabeth Taylor and Opalite actually are the greatest sounds I ever heard. 🤤❤️‍🔥

V ˚˖𓍢ִ໋❀

PLSSS NOT FATHER FIGURE BEING THR ONES U WERE TALKIMG ABT ON DISCORD IM CRYINRHDBD

Gaven Guzman

No intro just straight into it OH

Enzo Reis

KING THE OUTFITS? YOU ATEEEEE

Dev

the best thing about release day is the Snakes' reactions!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Maria

I KNEW you were gonna hate Wood from the moment I heard it but that’s okay I still love it and my non swiftie bf said it was a banger so clearly the locals are gonna love

Elise

I have the swiftie zoomies !

Lizz K.

i saw the lyrics to 'wood' and wanted to call in a preemptive wellness check on zach haha

jaana

ok I just started watching so idk how EXACTLY you misinterpreted father figure but I also did on first listen... I really was just attached to the taydaughter of it all LMFAO I totally forgot scott flopchetta existed. But once I realised it immediately became crystal clear and I felt dumb AF... But anyway...

Maria

I’m on my 10,000th listen and I’m having a ball, honey

aliciaaa

your reaction to the chorus of Elizabeth Taylor im CRYING 😂😭

jaana

ophelia still remains the best song on the album for me... It's sooooo good like I am genuinely gagged everytime I hear it and I am SO glad it's the first single

Rachel

Listened to it in the gym and it suited it so well

JaneyB93

I’ve not watched your reaction yet but my initial thoughts are that some of the songs/ lyrics sound a little forced. To me it’s as if she’s trying to fit into this new tongue in cheek pop girl. Solid album will definitely listen to it but regretfully some skips and on first listen no cruel summer/ wonderland/ bops.

dumdum

Genuinely I’m so excited to see him lose it over wood hahahaha

E ✨🩷

I really like this album, like you said it is very new sounding for Taylor but with elements that we still know and love. The songs that I like I LIKEEE but there are a couple that just really aren't doing it for me but that's ok! Because it's like that on every album. And the beauty of Taylor having a broad discography is there's something for everyone. Can't wait to see the fate of ophelia MV tonight ❤️‍🔥

RJ

lmfaoooo glad we had the exact same reaction to the elizabeth taylor drop

user name

Omg just when my food is done. Punctualtologist

Emily Elser

Dare I say she actually picked a good single?????

Elena

Thank you for the reaction, Zach! Cute outfits! The album is so different. I can’t stop listening to it. Ruin the friendship is such a good track but it hits hard towards the end. I wish it was different lyrically, just because I want to listen to it more and vibe. I think it’s a solid album. Can’t wait to get my physical copies today!

Jessie Li

my show is on nobody speak

Nicole bee

Joined the membership for this!! 🧡

Alison Bell

He’s probably trying his best lol.

Nina

Nooo the video is stuck. 🙈🙈 Are we crashing the Swiftologist Patreon now, you guys?

lisa

I, too, blacked out when I heard The Fate of Ophelia 😭

James

He's the showgirl

Jane McGowan

the literal SPIT TAKE at the beat drop in elizabeth taylor is fucking killing me

Denise

There's a c@ntress afoot! I. am. gagged

Tomer

I’m so happy 😭

ducky

Nothing could have prepared me for this. Shocked in many ways but I love it. Elizabeth Taylor is that girl 💖

Cocogigi

Haven’t got there yet but I predict Zack is gonna barf at dreaming of driveways with a basketball hoop 😛

Sarah

i’m at work!!! can’t wait to watch this in a couple of hours

Jacob

Bought ur patron just for this, luv ya Zach

Molly Kavanagh

I fast forward 10 secs and then immediately rewind 10 secs and that usually fixes it :)

Emma Wells

Ruined the Friendship made some stuff on evermore stick out to me, particularly like, 'Tis the damn season and Dorothea 🤔 Maybe I'm doing meth math

rachel☁️

This album is almost tortured poetian in the lyrics .... wordy, vivid, clunky, and some are so honest it's embarrassing😭

Vanessa Vieites

Father figure is my fave 🥲 followed by actually romantic ❤️‍🔥

karen

Best album 😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️

Luise Busch

Pleassseee I need some help. What do the lyrics “Been number one but I never had two” mean? I don’t get it :( maybe it’s a play on words? English isn’t my first language so I might not get it :D

Kylee

Why am I more nervous for this than I was to listen to the actual album? Here we go boys, let’s gooooooooo 🍿🍿🍿

Foxy

I so hope that this is a visual album

Amanda

“All my friends say when you know you know, and when you don’t you don’t!” Hello, Lana, Jack, Margaret! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶 #Opalite

Vanessa Vieites

I clocked it as being about Scott on first listen but I already had that expectation. It’s my fave off the album 🥲

daniel_online

NOW WE BEEN NEEDING THIS!! Thank u 🫶

Denise

I upgraded!

Kyley

Locked in

DemiMarie🤍🖤

I am sat for your reaction 🤌🏻❤️‍🔥

sara

She suffers from being a 35 year old woman and using too many millenialisms

Madi

I LOVE IT SO DAMN MUCH!!! It's been forever since I've loved an album from the first listen

Momo

i'm a native english speaker and i don't understand either lshfldsjkfdlf someone help

McKenzie

I take it as she’s been number one on the charts but she’s never had someone to share it with so she’s never had two like she’s never felt like she’s had a real partner

Lauren

I think it’s lowkey a mix of both 🥸

Esteban García

“I’m too poor to know what that is” HAHAHA

Kirsten

Us scorpios are eating so well

Niamh

Opalite sounds so christmassy

Miss Liz

When I was laying in bed listening and she goes ….Elizabeth…🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 and then I died. I asked for reputation and a real love song and she shows up with this and the “best friend who’s hot” lyric wtaf is happening? I’ve been saying if you bang your best friend and it doesn’t get weird you need to get married for 25 years…no joke

Mia Mar

Us both claiming Elizabeth Taylor and being ABSOLUTELY FUCKING RIGHT

Elle Kaye

🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻

Mia Mar

“It’s for rich bitches only” SAY ITTT

Jomazel

EEEEK you and madeline extending showgirl celebration yay!!!

Abby

I would love for you to make a video after you have processed this album more on what you think the deeper meanings of the songs are! Also your outfits during this album are EVERYTHING!

Daniel

Sorry but people who are hating on this album are tasteless

Emma

Girl same, you're not alone

Hannah

I’m crying at Zack thinking father figure is about joe…why did he kind of cook

Ivy Fuss

i’m at a taylor swift release party club right now and there was a drag queen on stage promoting gaylor… AND PEOPLE IN THE CROWD WERE CHEERING!!!! it genuinely ruined my whole night omfg

Emjabar

Okay I know Wood is no ATW10 but it’s not trying to be. I really think the entire album has a dark, smoky, backstage, big dick energy. I think Wood fits into the vibe. It’s shocking to hear it from Taylor but I love the new feel. I absolutely love the album.

Cocogigi

I’m thinking she’s never had a partner who was with her (#2) so she’s been #1 alone 🤷‍♀️

K Scott

Ily & I’m not a charli warrior but sympathy is a knife is miles more interesting than actually romantic …

Hazel

YES THATS EXACTLY WHAT I SAID

Christiana Williams

If I’m being honest I think your interpretation of father figure is clever and fun lol

iulia

opalite x foolish one sister song episode when

Cocogigi

I think Father Figure is about Scott Borchetta not Joe 🤷‍♀️

Abbey

i love zach’s interpretation of father figure honestly… like scott borchetta is always over but i like the thought of it being joe-over coded- that is almost more showgirl to meeee

jaana

JOE??!_?$???? LOL PLEASEEEEEE this is not where I thought we were gonna go. You kill me swiftologist. Obsessed

V ˚˖𓍢ִ໋❀

okay but even if your father figure interpretation is wrong… i’m eating up the idea abt joe IDK LMAFSKDKR LIKE

farwa jawaid

i thought father figure was about scott and scooter (you made a deal with the devil but my dicks bigger)? not her lovers? am i missing the connection?

ninth_lady

She's had number one hits, but never someone willing to let her be bejewelled/enjoy her success.

Holly

Just some insight on opalite for you: "You were in it for real, she was in her phone, and you were just a pose" Travis' ex was basically an influencer and kinda was always shoving her phone in his face (there's videos of this). You could definitely describe her as a clout chaser and gold digger. The first verse explains Taylor's past, and then the second verse is his past.

Deana Whitney

Loving your sparkle here. Both in regalia and in attitude!

rachel☁️

Wait what did you get wrong about Father Figure the song is kind of in tounges

Paula C

The drop in fate of Ophelia is PERFECTION!!!!

sara

I feel like halfway through the album she lost the plot

Paula C

The bbc radio interviewer said the same!! By design I think

Vanessa Vieites

Not Father figure having more track 5 vibes than the actual track 5 lol

s

“I don’t want to hear ‘I will be your bottom’” fucking Killed me

Marky Mark

I’ve never been a true Swiftie but I do feel like I liked her albums like Folklore or Midnights so much more. I had high hopes but I’m kind of disappointed. I don’t really like any of the songs like to me they’re either bad or just decent. Add on the awful rollout and official cover and it’s just a messy project to me. I do like that she got a bit messy and tired new things with songs like Actually Romantic and Wood but that’s about it.

Joey

This was main event today thank you love it just waiting for Madelein now

Paula C

She simmers not suffers 💅

sara

Astute reply queen

BecauseBay

It’s about Scott and her masters

B

Father Figure has me stumped. on one hand I think the first part of the song is from Scott Borchetta's pov with lyrics like "my dear protege" until the bridge shifts to her pov and the lyric changes to "my dear boy" and she turns all his words back on him. she references losing her masters to scooter braun because of scott and taking back her empire with the re-recordings. But on the other hand, Joe is not off the table for me. it fits so well. especially the line about his ambition tricked him into believing he needed to get rid of her to fulfill his own dreams and make a name for himself

holly

Okay but am I crazy for actually loving your initial interpretation of father figure. Like even if it’s not officially about that…..we all know things happen in different areas…..

R

I just can’t get over all the parents who bring their kids to that listening party today and the lyrics to Wood are on the screen. 😂😅

BecauseBay

You’re exactly right. It’s from the male perspective and then switches to hers for the last third.

Yohaha

Let a girl be silly and have fun!!!

Natalee Sweet-Fabian

I blacked out my whole first listen too. I literally cried cause I convinced myself it was trash, but after some sleep it’s a masterpiece. Wi$h Li$t is probably my least favorite rn but it’s still good

Veronika

“I like the vocals..👀” reaction to Eldest Daughter killed me lmao

Emma Wells

LOL! I had the same bullet to the face reaction to "memes" in the song 😂

Abby

She’s the father figure to her lovers

Brooke

I fuck with the album but that’s the worst track 5 i think ive ever heard

Matteo

Scott Borchetta KILLED on Father Figure…

Abby

No Father Figure literally IS about Joe

Shantini Vyas

I’m about to watch this and I’m really scared

Paula C

I just got the line about crying your eyes violet in Elizabeth Taylor… Taylor has blue eyes and crying makes them RED sooo Violet… so much crying. That is brilliant!

Amal

DYING AT FATHER FIGURE HAHAHA

sara

My friend (who is not in the swiftie culture by any stretch of the imagination) said explicit use of "dickmatized" etc etc is to give pushback to gaylors and now i stand in allegiance to the cringe

Jede Král

Glad I'm not the only one who instantly connected Father Figure to Joe Alwyn :DDDD

oPaulo

Headpiece-ologist

madatmeisland

about Father Figure - i really liked your interpretation and i think it’s good that we as consumers of Taylor’s music know enough to apply variable meanings to the lyrics

Matteo

I really don’t think father figure is about Joe. It being a song sung from Scott B’s perspective until the bridge makes more sense to me. “You had to get rid of me” isn’t really something Joe did… I also can’t imagine she’s this mad at him 😭 in so long London and other songs she just seemed quite sad but very over it

Annie Turgeon

I’m on 10th listened and there is double meaning galore…can’t wait for your later takes

Kelly AF

As a 41 year old millennial woman, I disagree that she "suffers" from it

Maxi Schäfer

the way eldest daughter chorus sounds like white horse chorus 🥹

Deana Whitney

Has she ever referenced her brother in a song? A direct call out like in Opalite?

C. MARIE

This is a love album. But with the confidence of someone who is being fully loved for who they are, no reservations. There is confidence exuding from every song.

JennaEO

I’m certain that will happen

Ally ❤️

The quick changes are slaying!!!

Kirsten

To the “this isn’t showgirl allegations” I say loving Travis is the life of this particular showgirl

Janie

Insult to her, COMPLIMENT TO ME is so funny

maryna

I think father figure is about scott borchetta. The first verses are sung from his perspective and the rest of the song is sung from Taylor's perspective (just like the protegé and the predator in hands clean by alanis morissette for instance)

jaana

You reacted to eldest daughter exactly the way I thought you would lfmsjkfkd like. It kinda feels like a caricature of what a song called eldest daughter by Taylor swift would sound like????? But I do like the general sound and the second verse personally. I'll take that and leave the rest I think

laura

Track 5: TS2 > TS12 “I'm not a princess, this ain't a fairytale” > “I'm not a bad bitch, and this isn't savage” (That said, Eldest Daughter is just not good)

Satu

Honestly, I'm happy no one will ever hear my initial reactions or analysis of songs, cause I tend to be a moron until I get to cook for a while 😂. So thank you for this vurnerability! And now on to the video that I've been waiting almost as anxiously as the album! (thanks for waiting until I finished my work for the day 🙌)

boleynns

This album gagged me, and when I say that I mean I literally could not stop listening to it for 5 hours even though it was getting to be like 3am and I have a huge work event this weekend 😅

laura

First half of TLOAS > Second half of TLOAS

rachel☁️

I was not expecting forever winter pt2

Tea Terzin

My take on Father Figure is a bit different. I think she's role-playing as Scott Borchetta or Scooter Braun or any of these men who go on to blackmail and manipulate young, aspiring artists in order to gain control over them and monopolize the industry. Anyone else have a similar perspective?

Robyn

I really didn’t like Ruin the Friendship until the bridge, then it really hit me in the heart. A beautiful meaning. On the other hand… “and we looked fire” makes me feel embarrassed when I hear it

Jennifer Rivera

I’m in love with the first outfit❤️ STUNNING ✨

Hannah

Yes, in The Best Day.

Anabel

It might not be the 'right' one but I love your take on father figure!!!! It kinda works both ways

Sarah De Sousa

The intro to Fate of Ophelia is still so gaggy!!! the quiet into a big pop momenso! I also had the same "this isn't real and I don't know what I am listening to" reaction too! Its such an odd feeling hearing something youve been waiting for for sooo long!

Mara

Your joy for Elizabeth Taylor made me so happy.

Sam

I like a lot of it, but I want different lyrics to Eldest Daughter so bad! I love the music and production

Noelle Veilleux Markham

Is the behind the scenes look at what was going on that she was falling and living in love with Travis? (23:00)

Nancy P

I feel like eldest daughter isn’t a Travis song. Maybe more to her family?

KK

No I think you’re so right with Father Figure. I got Joe immediately too

speedyceviche

I love the fact that is under 50mins, I end up Life of a Showgirl and go HAHAHAHA AGAIN and start the Fate of Ophelia, and it feels better in every single one of those rounds. Can't wait for the debrief episode, thank you for the first reaction!

Bean

*sips matcha*

Abby

I don’t care what anyone says let me be delusional! Thanks!

Nefelibata

The vibe is amazing. She is the mafia boss. I was so confused during the first listen, but after the last song (which made me cry) something clicked and the whole album changed. It is a vibe first album and I love love love it. She is so cringe, so white millennium, she learned a thing or two from ms. Carpenter about bing tongue in cheek. Oh I am so pleased

Kikimora

Yeah but that would require keeping a man so

Savvy

Im sooo obsessed with Father Figure. Once i finally caught that shes talking from the point of scott brachetra... and then it turns to her perspective at the end...i started crying. I could still be wrong about that interpretation though... but thats what i think right now

Lindsay

Elizabeth Taylor is a more secure version of Cornelia Street

Miranda

While I get used to this album my most profound thought is: does Ruin the Friendship bring new insight to Bigger Than the whole sky, it’s the damn season, question, and forever winter?

Nefelibata

I don’t understand how you can react to this album during first listen. I was just confused and gagged!!! What an experience

Claire Murphy-Sewell

Zach YOUR REACTIONS WERE EXACTLY MY REACTIONS!!!!! I am OBSESSED with this album. This has been so fun to watch - your opinion is the only one I care about LMAO ILSYM

Kikimora

Eldest daughter is a snooze fest, everything else is giving

Aaron

Such a FANTASTIC album😭 I can’t choose a favourite right now. No offence to Jack, but this is EXACTLY what I was missing for yeaaaarrrrsss😩

Lisa M

I agree

Maria

Ruin the Friendship is the real track 5

Chelsea Murray

Has anyone else made the connection from Forever Winter to Ruin the Friendship? i'm pretty sure its about the same person

Aaron

This album is what Mid should have been! THANK YOU MAX AND SHELLBACK!!

Miranda

Opalite is giving I can see you 👀

Leslie M

Guys she said it's her life during the era's tour, what was happening behind the scenes... She was falling in love with Travis behind the scenes. What did you want songs about gaffers and sound guys?

Niamh

What did the fan say about the spoiler at the evolution of a snake show??

whylime21

I'm only on the first song but you look like a deer in the headlights which is SO REAL

LH

Elizabeth Taylor best song ever written and recorded

Tess

I don’t think you misread father figure?! Joe is the only way this song makes sense to me if she says otherwise she’s LYING

Alicia Martinez

Eldest daughter is the worst one unfortunately 😭 the worst offender of bad Gen Z slang lyrics. My only skip. The onlyyyyy good thing about that one is the terminal uniqueness line. The rest of the album though is perfect and I do love it

Chainey Bee

"Back to positivity, 'Ruin the Friendship.'" LOL nope

Ben Kearney

Got off TikTok to escape the leaks, logged back on after the album, and then immediately dipped once negativity showed up on my fyp.

Christina

My first impression was that Max was not playing the part of editing Taylor’s wordy tendencies, some of the songs do suffer from that (eldest daughter)

Abbie Elliott

I agree. I instantly thought of our turkey

Stephen

They said (i'm paraphrasing) "How would you react if there was allegedly a Charli XCX diss track on the new album?"

Taylor Chapiesky

The second you said this song is for Scorpios I was like fuck yeah it is bitch this album is so fucking amazing

Christina

Same here, maybe like she’s been #1 on the charts but never part of a pair, so she’s never had two? Maybe?

maryna

I'm wondering why she thought about her friend who passed away during this the European leg of the eras tour, because this is what the album is supposed to be about, right, things that happened to her backstage during the air reras tour. So, maybe this is in fact an allegory just like my tears ricochet and it is in fact about Matty Healy, someone from the past who has died now and is now dead to her... But I guess that the should have kissed you anyway part does not make sense.... But why is the song on the album? I just don't understand.

charles

wood is the best song ever I'll die on that hill alone yall haterzzzz

Grey Purtle

No you’re right he misinterpreted the song (look at the caption)

Nicola

Suddenly I feel like a fool in my headdress is my favourite thing that’s ever been uttered!!!!

Savvy

Im kind of getting eldest daughter is addressed to her younger self. Im not sure if i really like it though... maybe it will grow

Kelsey

I know you said that your interpretation of Father Figure was wrong, but it was definitely interesting! The way you described it made me think of Blank Space and using a character to play off the media's perception of you -- if she did write a song talking about her relationships as a form of profit, I would be seated!

Bernice Trapp

Ahhh not Zach not clocking that Father Figure is Scott Borschetta lashings

lumi loom

In the sea of pure taynegativity this is like water in the desert ❤️‍🔥

Bnans

no bc i also heard “turned your rags into golds” and thought joe

Brooke

Dude i physically busted out laughing at you listening to wood 😭

Emma Lowell

i come to zach & madeline for my snarky side and go to ally sheehan for the positivity of it all but lol im DEAD at some of these reactions!! agree on so much with you zach!

Showgirl

No wood is so good you just need to fathom it TRUST

Taylor Chapiesky

I do agree with you but it does actually help in some other songs (The fate of Ophelia)

aubs

???? This is like..really mean..for no reason? Like this is the shit people said about Taylor? What the hell man, the hateration is so unnecessary what did Sabrina do to do? Steal your man? Jfc

Jaki C

I think of my friends that have died on their birthdays and dates of death. Would make sense she would think of him at some point during the tour, maybe?

Payton Alijah ✧

wood made me have the ick so bad and I’m happy I’m not alone in that

Abbie Elliott

The jaw drop during father figure was exactly what i needed to see from this reaction thank you🤣❤️

FLUTTER

You genuinely make me so happy

Gaven Guzman

I was kinda getting Never Grow Up from it

Krie

Is wood graphic? Sure. Buuutt is she very clearly and graphically saying “I like Dick?” Also yes. So maybe … it’s for the gaylors 😂😂

Gaven Guzman

TASTE, this song is for the hoes

Cocogigi

Your face on Wood 😂👏

Kaitlyn MacGilvray

im so dead at the father figure interpretation but its just so much info to digest all at once

Lindsey Johnston

I think father figure it about Scott Borchetta

Holly

GAGGGGGG

Holly

I honestly see how father figure is giving Joe. If the shoe fits !!!!

Gaven Guzman

I think she should make Wood a single just too fuck with you😂

Paula C

I have to…agree. Bridge is sweet (whether to Travis or her parents) but that’s about it for me, as an eldest daughter myself. It was touching on that idea of “I’m too soft for all of this” but never cut in

Ashley Richard

Elizabeth Taylor and Father Figure are all-timers, I said what I said

Shannon

I will never recover from seeing Zach in that feather number, reciting lyrics from Wood. 💀

Jack 's weekly music reviews

No bc actually romantic as a taycharli stan is FRYING me... yes I think tbh Charli didn't really do anything to provoke that but oh my god charli was clocked...

Paula C

Cold as you not the worse track 5 anymore.. 😩

Oleksii

obsessed with your shirt

Tha P

Your reaction to Wood was sooooooo much like mine 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Emrose

Unironically I have a friend who had the same analysis about Father Figure, but with Blake Lively being the one removed from the bank roll.

Kyle

Fortunately Wood is the greatest song ever made🙂‍↕️

Maxi Schäfer

I feel like she lost the plot with this album after Father Figure ….

Claire Murphy-Sewell

also I hear Father Figure as being about Scott Borchetta and getting her masters back. "You want a fight? You've found it. I've got the place surrounded." I SCREAMED!!!!!! It was my favorite upon first listen and I knew you'd love it!!!

Bri Renneisen

Literally same because by the second song I had texted my mom to let her know this was the best album she’s ever made for me. Obsessed.

Enzo Reis

22:09 Yes! this album it's funky and very groovy late 70s and early 80s, but with a 90s flavor. But still in this funky/groovy modern production. Everything it's right in its place vocals, background harmonies, instrumentals, like Max Martin always does.

Beeb

Don't worry Zach Wood is a grower 😉

Inés

I haven’t even thought about Father Figure being about Joe!!! I thought immediately of it being the perspective of Scott Borchetta in first person until the bridge and the last chorus when is from Taylor’s perspective. The albums being the family protected etc

Emily Sawich

She's been a number one artist but never been someone's number one, and had a number one hit at the same time! At least that's how I see it

calm98

Father Figure is giving Blank Space 2.0 lyrically

Paula C

Funny you said “one of her mysterious Frankenstein songs!! Listen to how she uses her voice in Ruin the friendship, “shooould”, it sounds like Question…? Similar topic actually. “Answer the question”

Tomer

What if she does a MV for cancelled! And it’s starring Blake lively!???????

Jasmine

I’m thinking cancelled can be about any of her friends but I did immediately think of Brittany Mahomes not Blake hdfjcj but Brittany does not have a long history with TS so I think it’s just about everyone.

calm98

The vibe I get is there's more went on behind the scenes

Megan Zemke

Underrated comment 🤣🤣

kerri Holloway

Taylor professing she loves Travis' dick... could it end the "gaylors?!?!" I gotta say, I would have died hearing WOOD for the 1st time in a movie theater!!

Satu

Yes, it all still made sense 😄.

Megan Zemke

Omg same these are the only taylor accounts I follow for the same reasons hahaha

Michelle Nolan

But at what cost? Your dignity? 🤣☠️🤣☠️🤣☠️

Dara-Lynn Buker

Third outfit change sentttt meeeeeee awayyyyyyyyyy

Michelle Nolan

I feel your embarrassment at the headdress after that. No way I can wear my sequins to the theater in 3 hours.

S B

Or... Thank you Taylor?? 😅

charles

size queens anthemmm

Espritlumiere

I thought it was "he ahmatised me" like orgasm not dick 😭

Satu

Also she said this album was about what was going on behind the scenes. This, falling in love, was what was happening behind the scenes. Many of us just took it as what was happening behind the scenes of the tour, of reflecting more about her being the show girl. I also think Taylor is not always best at describing the concepts of her albums. Perhaps she is being vague so she doesn't give away too much.

RedheadedKatie

Eldest daughter just draaaaags for me. The slow storytelling is just not doing it for me.

Leslie Eliden

Yeah Taylor get it out of your system with Wood lol but I loving the rest of the songs

Jaqi Jarboe

Wood completely appalled me. It was my worst fears come to life lol

Margaret Schinkel

You’re so wrong about Actually Romantic I think Sympathy is a way better song because of the introspection and not taking shots at Taylor. I’ve been a swiftie longer than an Angel but I still just can’t stand this song it’s giving the Lana song about Ethel Cain. But of course I respect your opinion and can see your perspective

Aline Tschopp

Why are the lyrcis never released on spotify with albums, I need to read while listening

Michelle Nolan

I love Sabrina, but Taylor channeled too Sabrina here,…

Justin Matthews

In Sex Ed growing up they used to call the wooden dildo woody so the song wood is silencing me in a big way

Kylie Johnson

I’m sorry but the slow realization of wood with the insane head dress on is OBLITERATING meeee 😂😂😂

Satu

I honestly think it was better to get the album at 7am (my timezone) than ay midnight cause then I got to slowly take it on through out the day 😄. I don't know what my brain would have done if I had time for a 1 or 2 listens and then sleep?!

Mae Osbourn

I feel like father figure is a collation of people, I know people hate nuance but I do think it is more layered and complex than ‘Scott is bad’

Hayleeeeeee

omg and awayyyy we go, no intro AHHHH

Paula C

I think the life of a showgirl, for Taylor, her behind the scenes, was all protect the family, baths, big D, and dreams of basketball hoops.

kody

Ok in the lyric booklet it says (ah!)matized me 😭 does that make it any better 😭😭

Dani

eldest daughter could have been everything to me…🥲 the bridge is beautiful, but why so many weird lyrics everywhere else? 😭 “we looked fire” 🥀

Jeremiah Nettleton

Wish List is very showgirl to me... It is the fantasy about a life you know you will never be able to access when you are under the lights. Secret gardens in my mind almost.

Kylee

It’s giving Holy Ground for me

Casees

The bridge is the only part I like & I love it 😭 this one was too millennial for me & im a gd millennial 😭

Ashley Corgelas

🤣🤣 Wood isn’t Travis favorite. He is on record saying Opalite is his favorite. Jason is the one who had a reaction to Wood when Taylor said it. Travis face was blank 🤣🤣

Satu

I think there was a release week schedule (maybe on instagram?!) for the Patreon and there were some more in depth stuff coming over the weekend. And then of course more later, I'm sure.

Maria

Damn, I wasn't hating on Sabrina just to be clear 😅

Casees

Twenty thousand percent. Taylor is too influenced lol. By both Sabrina & Travis lol

Bri Renneisen

Also I think Ruin the Friendship ripped my heart from my actual chest because my eyes still haven’t dried since last night.

eric s

It def about Scott. The first half is from his perspective “I saw potential / This love is pure profit, etc” and the second part is her reclaiming her agency by doing the TV project and buying her masters back and spoiling his and Scooter’s deal.

Miss Liz

I laughed out loud on a conference call.

Flor

Beautiful showgirl outfit!!!!

Sonja Mc

I predict Wood is going to be a major song for bachelorette parties.

sara :)

THE WOODOLOGIST

Makena

Now wait a second…I thought father figure was her writing from the pov of scott borchetta. He’s telling young Taylor all that stuff. “The empire belongs to me”, etc. etc.

Vanessa Vieites

My top 3 are father figure, actually romantic, and honey (maybe tied with Elizabeth Taylor 🤔)

Vanessa Vieites

The Sabrina feature was so mid. Can’t stand the stomp clap imagine dragons vibe lol Disappointing

Shannon

Exactly. She said it was life behind the curtain, not on stage. Behind the curtain, she was falling love and getting freaky. Tracks to me!

TheBeautyJournals

This album is just okay, nothing has gripped me yet. I’m really confused by the ‘Show Girl’ theme, as nothing really is about being a show girl or the Eras tour specifically. It seems like a bunch of really random unreleased songs put together. Ruin the Friendship seems really out of place on this album and feels like it should have been on TTPD with a different tone. I think they were more trying to wow us with how hard she’s been working, recording this album and doing the tour. This seems to be proof that not always taking on too much at once can be a good thing. This album release has felt more like a merch rollout than an album rollout. The limited time releases really felt cheap, especially without even being given a single beforehand.

Kylee

Sorry Natalie Wood but some of us needed the natural conclusion to Guilty as Sin? and of course you roll the stone away for some wood. It’s all makes sense snakes…where wood we be without her? 💀

Shannon

Exactly what I said! Love the sexy 70s energy

thebolter

Watching this after your live stream is making me lol

Sonja Mc

Wish List to me, is another version of Paper Rings.

Levi Whealey

I just went to watch the live I got a notification for and it’s gone 😭 do they not get saved?

Daisy B

Never before in my life have I felt compelled to seek out the 'clean' version of a Taylor song... Wood is too catchy for me not to listen to but "open my thighs" is the straw that broke this camels back

R

The worst part about this album is that the problem is the writing. With different lyrics it would be a good album.

Shannon

Agreed. But then they'll probably be clinging to the flirty lines on Actually Romantic

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

I hate it toooooo!!! 😭 I wish she would have kept with the superstitious theme. Other pop girls have done WAY better innuendos... I don't think she knows that WE WILL GET IT! Hide it better! 🙏

Kylee

Nothing confusing about what we just heard.

Celeste

Ophelia, Elizabeth Taylor, and Cancelled! are my favorites! Loving this album!! I like how Taylor can change her sound up.

MA

What's really worrying me is that I thought this album could save us from taynegativity however it's just gonna cause more of it 😭

amandasoul

ehhh sympathy is a knife was still mean af if it were written about you. singing about hoping you breakup with the guy who shattered you… i think taylor nailed it. charli was not being deep about it… just mean in my opinion

Susu

People were spamming Israel flags so I don't think it will be saved.... It got kinda weird in the end

Kelsey

someone I know has been calling wishlist the best song on the album all morning… I just needed a safe place to process that

Rebecca Black

Doing first reaction videos is having a heart of a lion!!!! I’ve been listening to the album all day and very slowly pulling together what all these songs are about 🙈🥰❤️

Vanessa Vieites

Coulda, WOODa, Shoulda left Wood off this album lol

Emrose

And when I said we would miss having 26 songs…. No one opened the case with me 🥸

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Dude, Sabrina would have KILLED it. She is so much better at innuendos! You need to leave space for people to fill in the blanks.

beyza

what did he say about it i missed it 😭

Jerri O'Rourke

The Prophecy and Wood sister songs 😂

Renee Darline

Zack said he was not saving this one—often they do save, but this was momentary, he’s letting it stay buried

Aya ✨

I want to erase this album from my memory and stay in TTPD era for another year or so🥲

maryna

Okay I'm saying it and everybody is allowed to throw the biggest shade of their lives... But why can Taylor produce an album like that and Halsey is not allowed to put out an album because she's not on a par with Taylor... Yes I said it.

Shannon

Exactly this. I'm not sure why people thought that Showgirl was going to be literal. It's a metaphor, and she specifically said it was about a peek behind the curtain. It was never going to be 12 versions of The Show Must Go On. She was behind the curtain falling in love with Travis and getting her freak on. 🤷🏻‍♀️ It did what it said on the tin!

Brianna Tullius

The clean version of Wood fixes it. I’m serious

Taylor

I will say that in general I felt like the writing on eldest daughter (my most anticipated) flopped, but I absolutely cried at “every eldest daughter was the first lamb to the slaughter so we all dressed up as wolves”

Bailey

Zack ilysm but please pause the music when you talk 😭😭😭

Gunjan Maji (yourstrulysavvvy)

Happy Taylor just makes me so Happy. Father Figure, Cancelled, Elisabeth Taylor and Ruin the friendships is my jam. REMEMBER SWIFTIES, it took us MONTHS to understand it, GIVE THIS ALBUM SO TIME. She has been doing GROWERS instead of ONE LISTEN HITS. And she loves to word vomit but trust me all is worth it.

Melly

I really feel like wood is just Taylor doing Sabrina That’s the show girl she is channeling

stubbs

1 min in and already loving the energy

amandasoul

cuntress afoot I’m dead

Abby Wandersee

Is anyone else having issues w the audio😖 I can barely hear:(

Enzo Reis

I'm crying with Eldest Daughter 😭😭 I don't know why but it's an old sister version of White Horse to me.

Aya ✨

In hindsight I’m glad I knew about the lyrics back in August when they were leaked cause they mentally prepared me and managed my expectations 🥲

t

Charli was going to a very vulnerable place describing a difficult, uncomfortable, ugly emotion like jealousy. Charli paints herself as the smaller person with the problem. I think if you only look at the songs, Taylor’s comes off mean. But I have to assume there’s some tea we don’t know because the song alone is just not enough to warrant that response. I love Charli to death so I’m biased lol but Actually Romantic left a bad taste in my mouth

Alex💌

Remember taynegativity sometimes comes with albums like 1989 and Rep. I'm holding out for the crowd to be okay in a year

Lisa

The Swiftologist reaction! I. Am. Seated 🔥

Lindsay

Z said that he’ll make another video with those thoughts, just a touch more processed. M is unavailable rn so he just needed a quick check in

David Bergee

I logged into your live right when you said “I just needed to come on here and process, I won’t be saving this. Bye!” LMAOOOO I’ll copy what I put on Reddit, but here’s my first thoughts y’all: For context, l've been a Swiftie since 2009. While not the album l listen to the most, Speak Now is my favorite (and I think the most important) album she has put out. I see so much of my own story in The Old Taylor (Foolish One) and new Taylor (But Daddy I Love Him... actually that's the old Taylor calling in Imao so let's go with LWYMMD). I love this album. It sounds nothing like what I thought it would (I was expecting 12 ready for its). Spiritually, this feels a bit like reputation both in the content and the way l'm seeing others react to it. Reputation was haaatttedddd back in the day. Opalite is my favorite, and I can't believe it made me cry, but Actually Romantic and Ruin The Friendship being my other favorites is... unexpected. I love Charli, but I am laughing my ass off at Taylor calling her coked out. And Ruin The Friendship has the storytelling I fell love with all those years ago. Showgirl (to me) sounds nothing like anything else in the discography, and that's a good thing. I love that there's a Taylor for every season and every mood. (Y'all, thank God that Evermore season is just around the corner!!!) I'm sure it'll grow on me more, and while not my favorite album, this isn't a fumble to me, but a palate cleanser after all the emotional throwing up she did on TTPD. Now, if you need me, I'll be shaking my ass to Opalite.

Aaron M

I think it’s about the LIFE of a showgirl, not the life of a SHOWGIRL

Aaron

BIGGEST THANKS TO THE QUEEN OF COURSE!!!

Lindsay

it’s suburban legends to me, v white picket fence focused

MA

Yeah true

Alex💌

My audio won't really play, I'm new to Patreon so maybe I'm doing something wrong though lol

stubbs

almost spitting out the matcha? so true

Anna

I was but then I did an app update and it got fixed!

Kirsten

Yes! I think people are forgetting that when the show ends, these girls go home and live normal lives.

Sacred_sunflower

I also hear turkey cooking in father figure. I think it’s both! Composite sketch babyyy

thebolter

He was very mid on the album, but in the beginning of this he’s doing hand heart 😭

Sacred_sunflower

I def see both! I think it’s composite sketch bc she is a mastermindddd

Madeleine

Wahhhhh I’m sad I missed it! Someone say what happened!

Sacred_sunflower

My FIRST instinct was 🦃 it’s giving composite sketch

Jasmine

What was the gist of the live? Did he talk about father figure’s actual meaning?

Sacred_sunflower

She mentions “youngest child” Travis is a little bro it’s a love song

e

when i first heard wood i had to pause the song because i was hysterically laughing in public. it sounds like one of those ai slop songs that people put in the fake leak tweets..... i laughed so hard watching your reaction my abs started hurting

Jenna Wells

I thought father figure was about Scott Borshetta

Jenna Wells

Same I thought Scott Borschetta

Ellie J

I can’t hear either :(

Sacred_sunflower

He said it perfect. Bad writing. It was forced. Ruin the friendship is track 5

tea with GRIFFON

ok don’t hate, but I think eldest daughter has dethroned the archer as worst track 5. I LOVE like everything else.

Sacred_sunflower

I see the resemblance and don’t think it’s an insult to Taylor either!! Zach and tay both have a face card

Sacred_sunflower

I knew wood would piss you off lyrics but I like to see you trying to vibe to the production 😂

Sacred_sunflower

It’s for the giiiirrrlllssss we like it 😉 🌲 🪵 😈 🍆

Hayleeeeeee

"THIS ISNT HAPPENING WHO IS THIS" was me the whole album

Anne

I have to admit in this safe space that I wish I could go back in time before I heard Wood and Eldest Daughter and pretend those don’t exist. 😂 The second hand embarrassment listening to those was unreal. Wood is catchy if you don’t listen to the lyrics, but it’s too late, I know what they are now. Thankfully, there are some genuine bangers on this album so it’s not a big deal skipping those.

Lisa

I love father figure so much! The idea of her taking big dick energy back from Scott and now her protecting the family(her masters) absolutely gagged me! Also, the first part being about him and then shifting to her is genius! I love that the shift happens when she whispers “I protect the family” the production of that whisper is everything to me

Zach V

Can you please post the live you just did? I really wanted to listen but I wasn’t able to join for the whole thing

Emma Gardner

Eldest daughter frustrates me so much because I love the bridge but that chorus… girl..

Bailey

TRUE! Thank you for pointing that out!!

TsukiNeko

Was hoping for more “showgirl” motifs in the production and lyrics. Brassy horns and bright lights. The dichotomy between the applause and glitter, and the grime, sweat and loneliness—like, the show must go on. Instead I got “Wood” and “Actually Romantic” 😔

Miss Liz

OMG YES I didn’t think of this. It’s like Knock Three Times which I have loved since the Now and Then movie. Now I’m hoping they bring clean to the theater when I’m there where two 12 year olds 😳 at least for this one

Syd

That’s what I did Satu and yes I wish I’d waited until morning cause I could not SLEEP haha

RedheadedKatie

Eldest daughter drags the way Robin does. If she’d cut one of the verses so it would move along, it would have been more tolerable. I know some will love it, though.

Claire

😭 I was watching this and did not get the notification

Makena

The reaction to Wood is what I was waiting for😂👏

Enzo Reis

Oh no girls Wish List and Honey are giving me Positions energy like Six Thirty or Nasty or Obvious

Shiv Patel

Zach post the live pls ❤️

Emma Gardner

I have no problem with the album being Lover (travis’s version) because it was about time we got a truly love album! But it is disappointing that the showgirl concept wasn’t fully realized because the seeds of the eras tour and fame themes on ttpd was one of my favorite parts of the album. I feel like the showgirl theme is explored way better on ttpd

Phoebe t

I had a stroke reading this, probably because I am sleep deprived

calm98

The Life Of A Showgirl is her best ever feature I fear

Jordan kuzniak

I thought oh the football talk has gotten to her😂😂

Nicole Ouimette

Wood makes me so angry. Worst writing ever.

Emma Gardner

If it makes it more enjoyable to listen to for you, I originally thought the song was about matty

amandasoul

i think she’s trynna say in eldest daughter maybe like… Travis and his friends are used to like girls with fake bodies and she’s not like that but she’ll still love him the same? Also, don’t know if that has to do with being an eldest daughter but

Emrose

To whoever said that the clean version of wood fixes it, blessing on you, your house hold, and your uber driver. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

Laurahogan

I actually really loved the Joe interpretation of father figure. The beauty of Taylor’s lyricism- it can have several different meanings

Sarah B

My face was exactly like your face when I heard the piano opening up the album. Jaw on the floor. So gagged, so beautiful, such a catchy first song! I teared up

Bacall N McElroy

I think father figure is about scooter Braun. The father figure takes the young protégé under the wing and dazzles them and makes them comfortable then feels betrayed when they want to move on without them.

kyla

the fact that you immediately connected father figure to joe alwyn is SOOOO FUNNY, he will never know peace. by verse two i said wait is this play about scott borchetta. it’s giving bitch better have my money (taylor’s version)

brandon

i feel like people are dragging it just for the sake that it’s taylor swift! there are definitely some flops, but also very very strong songs as well. overall not what i or the public was expecting but with no lead single and the “infectious pop melodies without losing the quality story-telling of ‘folklore’” comment i don’t blame people for some of the confusion. expectations were very high, and although they werent met, that doesn’t mean that it’s a total let down either.

DrEmily

Definitely more behind the scenes tea. People who feel it is only a response to Charli’s song, are being too narrowly focused. I think it’s pretty clearly about everything Charli was saying about her, on and off camera. They had mutual friends. It has to have felt vicious to Taylor - remember Brat summer was popping off when Taylor was the most recently down bad over MH.

Jill

I feel like Wi$h Li$t is a showgirl song because, for Taylor as Showgirl, a life with a couple kids and a driveway with a basketball hoop and the world leaving her alone is as much of a dream as a normal person dreaming about an Oscar on the bathroom floor

Rachel Kottkamp

Was looking for this comment! All the hate had me bummed when I woke up lol

Brianna Tullius

Lots of people hated TTPD at first give it time! Also the clean versions of a lot of the songs are better. I’m not a prude but there were a few times it ruined the song for me

Laurahogan

That’s the beauty of kids - they are so literal it’s like like why is she talking about trees? 😂

Claire Murphy-Sewell

I think CANCELLED! is definitely about riding for your friends, no matter who they are and what they've done. I can see it being about Blake, and also about the criticism she receives about her proximity to MAGA people (example, Brittany Mahomes). I am the most liberal person alive but I AM HERE FOR IT!!!! It's like you said in your unpopular opinions video: her proximity to MAGA people? I DON'T CARE. We know where Taylor stands politically. She can't be expected to do MORE than our literal elected representatives LOL

Sarah Dunsmore

My quick takes: I fucking HATE eldest daughter it is a millennial anthem if you like it I know what you are. Cancelled production is way too on the nose. I find it corny but I know it'll grow on me the way some songs on Rep did. The Fate of Ophelia is the best song ever made. Get rid of Wood and put Opalite on there twice. I dislike The Life of A Showgirl interpolating Cool by the Jonas Brothers. Actually Romantic is an Olivia Rodrigo song. This album gagged me. The first four tracks are excellent. Ruin the Friendship should have been Track Five. Some of the tracks seemed phoned in! Sorry.

Jennifer Lux

Can we take a moment for your headpieces and outfit changes. Silenced. PLUS - your dance moves are the cutest - swooning over you, showgirl-ologist

Megan Abner

Your look into the camera doing Ruin the Friendship when she said “it’s prommmm~”

amandasoul

ruin the friendship should have been track 5

Sara Macc

Loved this album!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Avery Turner

I think the album is a grower for me. A lot of the songs i'm liking more after listening a second time and being able to understand what she's actually saying not just being blinded by the bright pop production. All that to say Elizabeth Taylor has me in a choke hold the rest of album could be literal shit and I would say it's the best ever made because of that one song.

Liv

Can anyone explain why “Ruin the Friendship” is on this album? I don’t dislike it, but it feels so out of place and it really took me out of it when I listened for the first time. I’m 80% sure it’s a callback to Forever Winter’s muse? It’s not clocking to me!! Help!

Brenna

Kinda very much prefer your interpretation of Father Figure lol

tea with GRIFFON

I think the life of a showgirl might sound like that song, but if it was an interpolation she would have credited them in the writers credits. Great song tho either way.

Sophia S.

father figure is 113% about the heirloom turkey and i LOVE it. such a sick-ass take on a “break-up” song 😭

Bean

He doesn’t think any 1 song is great on first listen and had a taycrisis. Chat started arguing about Israel vs Palestine?? Was really weird, he said he had enough internet for the day after a few people said he’s not a swiftie anymore lol. Just people being stupid

Kylee

Well gays + girlies, this casual listen has truly been a journey…I just did a spit take with my iced coffee (you came back with your bellissimo headpiece 👑). Also here are all my commentary notes: — We have no idea what she just— ELIZABETH TAYLOR- did to us with the mid sentence showgirl interjection. - Opalite = Holy Ground the sequel? I think yessss - I feel personally offended as the eldest of three daughters. I’ve always considered myself more of a Guinea Pig rather than a lamb dressed like a wolf on fire, or whatever it was she said. (Also, on behalf of all millennials, and as a peer to Taylor? We’re getting old, let her cook. 😘) - The way I screamed when I heard ‘I can make deals with the devil because my dick’s bigger’ ….The Man COULD NEVER. - She must have heard my cries, ‘Style IS POP ROCK everyone’ and sprinkled in this little 90s pop/alt rocks trend we’re currently living in. She said, was that ‘so confusing’ or do I need to make it a little more clear, girl? Ok Im done….for now. 👹

Savvy

I honestly love the song Sympathy is a Knife. Ive played it as loud as possible dancing away! Actually romantic is also a great song. Sympathy is knife stood the test of time for me though... so we will have to see if Actually Romantic will. I think these woman are very different people who are not good for each other lol and im here for the teaaaa! Obviously it does seem like charlie may be doing some crazy hateration behind closed doors that we dont see but taylor does. But who knows. Im just here for the plot lol. And can still love both of them

Sarah Dunsmore

You're right, she did not credit them so I take back interpolate. But it is undeniably the same melody at times. I get ya.

kyla

as an eldest daughter i got the gist of the song. it is essentially the experience all eldest daughters have in that we have to be strong and resilient for our families whether we can be or not. i dont mind it as a track five but the writing is certainly a choice.

Yara

Did she say it was about Scott? Or am I making that up?

Savvy

I feel like yes... it does

No Thoughts

Wood is haunting me ... It's a badly written Sabrina Carpenter song where instead of tongue in cheek lyrics you just get dick shoved in cheek lyrics. Not fun not cute 😂

Evie R

The thing that does kind put me off is the fact that she marketed as 1989 meets folklore 😭😭😭like this kills me after listening to wood

Tiffany

The fact that she titled it Wood and it's literally about the D 😂

Kaye Charlesworth

Ruin the friendship is about Jeff Lang. I literally wept at the end! 😭😭😭

Léa

I love you Zack, your reaction to The fate of Ophelia is hilarious. I'm having fun already

Alex💌

I think the eras tour and the success of that and her career probably brought up some feelings of back home and the friend that died, pretty sure she said she used to play her songs for him first? I think..so it's probably just something she thought about a fair amount while "backstage" in moments that she could reflect on the success of her career

Ellie J

Thank you!! Now I can watch :)

Kikimora

Why would it be

Elle Kaye

I think she feels that she’s come to the end of a (or many?) big chapter in her life, and that has her reminiscing. When I met my husband, I did something similar. Like “now that I know it’s all worked out and the past heartbreaks didn’t define me — what have I learned? What would I have done differently?” Someone else pointed out this is really the LIFE of a showgirl (not the life of a SHOWGIRL). I think she’s really looking at the entire journey that brought her here.

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

Because Gabriette has openly said much worse stuff about her. Also the "How many times has your boyfriend asked you" line makes more sense in reference to Garbiette.

Elle Kaye

🔥🔥🔥 ^This is the best take I’ve seen. Really recontextualizes the whole “they leave us the fuck alone” line — does she dare dream of that? Is it even possible?

Aya ✨

Charli is the one thats written a song about her

Kyora Wallace

WAIT WAIT WAIT, everyone chill Actually Romatic is NOT about Charli XCX. "You call me Boring Barbie when the coke's got you brave" Alot of people call Taylor barbie as an insult and ALOT of people in Hollywood do coke. "You highfived my ex and said you're glad he ghosted me." Matty is not Taylor's only ex. "You send me nasty valentines." These behavoirs sound like something A DOUCHEBAG MAN would do. (ie Scooter Braun or Scott). You say that you didn't think Taylor would take it that way why would she? Sympathy is a knife is a vulnerable song, and Taylor seemingly understands that she has this impact on people whether she means to or not (ie the monster on the hill). I picture some asshole guy bragging to his friends about how he sent her a nasty letter. DO NOT PUSH THIS NARRATIVE BEFORE YOU START A WAR lol

tomatotime

FATHER FIGURE. = SCOT !!!!

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Baby, that's showbusiness! (Srsly though you should read the book "Confessions of a record producer" it is very eye opening to the industry and how insane it is).

Tiffany

You have entertained me today beyond my wildest dreams. From your outfits to how many times I burst out laughing. 🫶

Mara

can someone defend eldest daughter? I'm trying so hard to like it but immediately I'm like this writing is so baddddd. Girl, you can't sing I'm a not a bitch to a wistful piano. I can't handle it.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

WOOD definitely needs better lyrics. Just leave space for the audience to fill in blanks...

SW

Scott B, not scooter

Abby

I love the album, it’s so different and I’m so glad she went on a totally new direction. It was the best surprise!

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

I think it could be addressed to either of them. Charli's song about her wasn't really rude so it makes more sense to me that she's talking abt Gabriette. Genius also thought the same

Faith

"New Heights of manhood" quieted me in a big way...

Enzo Reis

The Guardian is so flop to me they already said in their review that they miss The Tortured Poets diaristic writing, but they were the ones calling it too much.

Pamela F

Hear me out, I take Actually Romantic to be aimed at Charlie but the song SOUNDS like Olivia Rodrigooooo

DrEmily

Probably gonna be the clean version 🤞🤞🤞🤞

Elle Kaye

As much as it personally touched me, I see the structural issues in Eldest Daughter. But I think the whole “bad bitch/savage” mention makes more sense in the context of how a lot of sports people expect WAGs to act. When CJGJ insulted her after the Super Bowl, he didn’t use those words exactly, but he implied it. She soaks up the language around her, and right now she’s hearing a lot more of that than when she was dating the art bros.

MB98

Stoppp you looked so cute in the last outfit 😭😭😭🩷🩷🩷

Amber

Hello mirrorballologist 🪩

Taylor Chapiesky

I really didn't need to know that much about Travis kelce's dick

Veronika

I expected more from the title track. I don’t know why but It just felt like “yeah ok”. I guess as it’s the title track and has a Sabrina feature I wanted to have more of a grandiose reaction, instead it’s just an ok closer to the album

Ilina Jha

Absolutely love that the Swiftologist correctly predicted that Father Figure would be a Scott Borchetta cook (even if he initially interpreted it differently). Love this song!

A.N. Chaney

Id like to posit that she’s talking about Katy Perry at the beginning “ kitty” - Katy Perry- Katy cats etc…

Maria

Literally took off work so I could stay up as late as I wanted listening and then watch Zach’s reaction in the morning. Everything I wanted it to be.

A.N. Chaney

Do we agree that father figure is about Scott borschetta?

Enzo Reis

I love it too 🥺🫶🏻 omg twins! We said the same thing. ☺️

Tara

There are two Charli XCX roasts on this album and Father Figure is one of them.

Mira

I just can‘t get over the cringy lyrics in eldest daughter and cancelled. Normally I‘m all about embracing the cringe but these ones are too much imo

SW

I gave Halseys latest album a re listen. It’s excellent!!! So sad no one received it well

Terry B

I just woke up 🤣 — and, how about doing this video in bathtub 🤣🤣?

Katie

I think so too and then for the last verse it switches to her pov

Tara

I can't even tell you guys which song I'm hearing at the beginning of TFOO. I did it on Discord and realized the damage I could be doing to you sharing this information. I am keeping this thought to myself and locking myself away in my tower weaving nightmares.

N

stop this side by side made me laugh

April

How am I going to defend my argument that she is the best songwriter of all time to people with dickmatized

Terry B

catchy tunes a la Max Martin… too much echo 🫤 but she’s a better singer now 🤗 Ophelia “…FIRRE…” “….MEEE” Obviously our Queen rose above the fate of Ophelia (victim of manipulative patriarchal plotting in Hamlet). She’s head dive in every relationship (even when the guy doesn’t deserve it) e.g. Delicate: she saw Joe as saviour. She thought she could fix him 🐭… this time, she doesn’t care about Travis’s past, He’s Hers Now 🌟 Slay! He knows better what happens to those who wronged her 🙂‍↕️😁

Tara

She should have just called the album "CANCELLED!" sonically it's a good album, the production is great. I guess what bothers me is this project could have EASILY been a bullet proof masterpiece, lyrically and sonically. There are some GORGEOUS lyrics but also quite a lot of bad writing, that could have been easily edited out, if she had just cared enough. I don't hate this album, it just feels like an intentional waste of brilliance, that just frustrates me. So I guess what I am trying to say is, I can bop to this album if I don't listen too closely to what is being said haha. I do like TFOO, Cancelled and Elizabeth Taylor

DrEmily

Seems to be a misconception from some people that Actually Romantic is just a “too mean” clap-back to Sympathy and Charli’s “vulnerability”. I’m sure that Charli had those thoughts and wrote a great song about it, banger album. But they have mutual friends (or at least they did). Brat/Barbie summer was popping off when Taylor was most devastated by MH. Charli was on a high. There had to have been parties and behind the scenes moments, stuff happened and words were said. Do these same people think Drake and Kendrick just respond to one song? This is an amazing diss track, Taylor style.

chy

no this is a reference to a lyric in sympathy is a knife of her talking to her bf about taylor

ImogenLucy

I WAS FIST PUMPING WHEN YOU GOT RUIN THE FRIENDSHIP!!!! So profound and so so showgirl! I cried the first time. When she was describing Tennessee over that melody and prom…. The real ones got it

Evie R

I do love the album as a wholeee tbf it’s just some clunkers like wish list and wood for ME personallllyyyyyy but for sure this may changeeee with time!!!

Elise

New heights of manhood is diabolical

Elise

mom come pick me up im scared

Catherine Pier

And to the White Horse melody!! I cannot…

Elise

keep travis and his redwood tree AWAY from me

HaleyJean ASMR

and if i say i like Wood … 😗 god forbid a woman finally gets some good d

Jon Weber

That was a great reaction video! My first instinct with Father Figure is that it's about Scott Borchetta. He was a mentor of sorts in the beginning to Taylor Swift and someone who would have been all about loyalty. He certainly would have said, "My dick is bigger", while claiming that he would protect her (when in actuality the only person he cares about is himself).

HaleyJean ASMR

the clean version is less raunchy tho!!!

Terry B

She’s aware of Liz’s tumultous love life, as most successful women endured. But the lucky star 🌟shines on her — KARMA is always Better Than Revenge 🙂‍↕️ “Failure Brings You Freedom” Nothing ventured nothing lost — that’s our Fearless Queen 🥳 Max Martin really knows his rhythm 🙂‍↕️ Cruel Summer by Jack is great pop, but Max’s style is PROPELLING the beats just keep your ears on the album 🙂‍↕️ Elizabeth Taylor sounds like Don’t Blame Me 🫡🙂‍↕️🤗 If (love) doesn’t make you crazy, you ain’t doing it right — If (the album, HBIC) doesn’t slay, you’re not hearing it right 😁😁

Emma S

Your showgirl outfits are the gaggggg!!!! So awesome

Catherine Pier

This sent me into orbit 🤣🤣 I couldn’t agree more

Erin

We are one in the same Zach. But Daddy I Love Him was my fav off of TTPD too, and I was like oh Zach is gonna loooove Elizabeth Taylor! I need that chorus injected into my veins!!

Bri Renneisen

lol let the girl be horny 😅 she’s waited so long for a redwood tree

Annabel

She promised bulletproof pop, 12 bangers. And instead we got 12 Fleetwood Mac, soft rock, bleary synths, muted drums, and Billie Eilish breathy backing vocals….and flat or cringey lyrics, how am I supposed to go to the theater…?

KTotes

Something about The Fate of Ophelia reminds me of Electra Heart Marina and the Diamonds. IDK.

Christopher Marshburn

Wood could have been a vault track from “Man’s Best Friend”. If Sabrina was singing it totally different reaction.

Leslie

The bridge is beautiful but the rest of the song is atrocious. What a waste.

liz

suddenly i feel like a fool in my headdress

Miranda

These songs all end a little too cleanly. Makes me realize how much I like a Jack outro

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Ruin the Friendship is such a beautiful longing tribute 💞 It's a really simple song but the message and thought behind it is so meaningful. The story telling ❤️

Devori Kimbro

Paying to be able to watch this is literally the best money I’ve spent in a while. Watching you react to “Actually Romantic”: it me.

noicingcupcake

wait, you're thinking heirloom turkey for Father Figure? I was thinking Olivia. Or even an amalgamation of everyone who she perceives has betrayed her

olivia gemmen

i’m pretty sure father figure is about scott borchetta.

Hannah

Ok, invisible string / fate of Ophelia comparison. Tea.

Kelsey

I also thought this might be a justification? Like it’s better to take the chance on a relationship than constantly question if you should have done something (cough cough the rat man cough)

Terry B

Opalite: “Uh uh uh” backup vocals interesting call backs to 80s vocals. This is ShowGirl happy to see her fiancee visiting her in the dressing room. He’s the star player on the pitch. He knows (better than her EXs) how to cheer for her off stage.

Kylee

Ask Charlie Puth, he knows how to come back quicker than a 90’s trend. Selective hearing can be an incredible tool when you’re listening to divas such as TTPD or willow but that’s just me 😘

VictoriaReadsss

we had the same exact reaction to eldest daughter its so funny. like same EXACT reaction

Kate M

Please post the live from before I missed it because of my job :(( did anyone record it/know where I can find it I need ALL of the cONTENT

Terry B

Father Figure: Happier “Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me”, “Karma” and “The Man” for the family, f*** patriarchy, she’s the provider, decision maker 😁 Are we ready for it? I don’t think manosphere is 🤪 SLAY! AMC release bypass lame-shameless movie studios!

Rıdvan Savaş

first of all, OMG THE OUTFITS GAGGED ME ZACHHH. Especially the last one. 🧡 Ruin The Friendship was my claimed track but it always changes when the album comes out. So this is THE last time I claim a track LOL. My fav ones are Father Figure, Actually Romantic and CANCELLED! right now. But I'm pretty sure there's gonna be some changes. Happy Life of a Showgirl release day everyone 🧡

Kylee

Sometimes we need a ME! moment, just to pretend like it never happened. 💀

Laura M

"we need to keep it moving, we need to keep it light and positive... up next is ruin the friendship" yeah, about that.

Hannah

I thought that it was about olivia or an ex at first but then ppl were saying charli (which does make sense) ( am a charli and olivia fan btw lollll)

Donny

I love opalite it’s my fav

Hannah Andersen

I wish I liked this album more! I'll listen again a few times, and there are a few songs that will make it in regular rotation (Ophelia, ET, FF), but so many were really forgettable and the writing wasn't as good as I've grown to expect. I also expected more from the production. The whole thing was a lot less "showgirl" than I expected based on the marketing and commentary. A bit of a let down, but I'll let it percolate and hopefully it grows on me! ALSO your reaction to Wood was life giving and exactly what I was thinking! The headdress makes that reaction so much better!

Jonas Reich

I decided it's if White Horse was written by a TikToker. I'm not a bad bitch and this isn't savage.... I'm not a princess and this ain't a fairytale

Andrew Guthrie

The way that matcha couldn’t survive Elizabeth Taylor

Lisaboo

I love this song. It’s for all the people who had a crush in high school that never came to fruition

Jonas Reich

I decided it's if White Horse was written by a TikToker. I'm not a bad bitch and this isn't savage.... I'm not a princess and this ain't a fairytale

Katt Rowell

Did the LOASG track remind anyone else of No Air - Jordan Sparks?

Jonas Reich

It's white horse but written by Addison rae. And that's not a compliment

KAWeist

I don’t mind your interpretation of father figure here. I can see it with the lyrics. I like the album, but I do not think it really supports “The Life of a Show Girl” premise. Mind you it could be like when “reputation” came out, and everyone thought it was gonna be about her cancellation and really it was much more talking about her early love with Joe. There was also a moment earlier on with a couple of the songs like Father Figure, where I thought some of them could be the reputation vault songs just put on this album. I don’t think that now, I do think they will be their own thing later. It was an idea with all the rep stuff she was doing. I like your reaction.

laisi

I also thought of Brittany Mahomes

caroline

“Suddenly I feel like a fool in my headdress” had me LAUGH OUT LOUD

Maggie

I guess don't go to the theatre if you dont like the album?

Kate Mischka

Unless I'm being dense, but I don't hear 'dickmatized' in Wood. The lyrics I found just have '(ah!) matized' which is a bit better lol

Jonas Reich

I decided it's if White Horse was written by a TikToker. I'm not a bad bitch and this isn't savage.... I'm not a princess and this ain't a fairytale

caroline

Wood makes no sense to people who have never been dickmatized before, sorry not sorry

David Bergee

Wait hang on this worked 😂

Jonas Reich

I decided it's if White Horse was written by a TikToker. I'm not a bad bitch and this isn't savage.... I'm not a princess and this ain't a fairytale

Jessa Jayne

So it took me a few listens but I feel like this is a slumber party album or an after party this is all the stuff show girls discussing and giggle about after they take off all the feathers. The images are the show the album is the Kiki.

Annabel

I didn’t say I didn’t like it? I enjoyed 3-4 songs; I said it’s just not the music style we were promised.

Annabelle Paris

Yeah but the ah is censoring the actual word

A.N. Chaney

I feel like this album was made for new swifties because literacy is at all time low and the locals have been banging the drum loud enough to wake the dead for either “another 1989” or “another reputation” or “another lover”. So I think she really simplified her writing for them and tried to check all of those boxes. I don’t think she understood that the writing is, at a bare minimum, 75% of what makes those albums amazing. So I’m a little disappointed with the writing in a way I never have been with a Taylor album. No shade but I would venture to say that maybe Travis’s….lets say…seeming lack of an inclination towards complex literature might have been a big influence on her writing in this album- especially in songs that were about him. Because her best writing is done in the songs that aren’t about Travis (except tracks 1-3) This album is seriously front loaded with bangers and maybe that was intentional because attention spans are at all time low and she wanted people to listen to the whole thing for streaming reasons but it is also rambunctious I do think the album is well paced because just when you think it’s writing diva down (because of reasons I’ll mention in a second) she picks you right back up with either a gag or a slay or she smacks you right up side the head with some TEA As someone who has been writing poems obsessing over love and heartbreak for the past 8 years and is now in a happy relationship, in Taylor’s, and this album’s, defense: it is incredibly difficult to write about being entirely satisfied and fulfilled in love because you experience a much more steady range of emotions after the initial rush of love. This is why I think the first 3 tracks are so good, because I bet they were written during that initial rush. See: Florence and the machines “No choir” for a better explanation of this ON THE OTHER HAND: Taylor has proven before that she is capable of writing VERY well even when she is in love. Which, is why I have my suspicions that Travis is at the scene of this crime. I’m NOT saying he’s dumb I’m just saying I think simple lyrics resonate more with him and we KNOW Blondie is a pathological people pleaser. However “Wood” is heinous and it is a CRIME it was given such a STELLAR production. I’m suing for damages. I don’t hate it and parts of it are fun. But I think we can all agree the shenanigans occurring in those lyrics are not in Taylor’s wheelhouse and are borderline foolish. I do not understand wish list and the dollar signs were indeed an omen of bad things to come. Eldest daughter is indecipherable to me.

Pluvxovia

Can we talk about how Ruin The Friendship is so Debut and Fearless coded??? From a not-so good writing of track 5 to old school Taylor on track 6? oh, we're so back!!

Rachel Lobo

Some of the reactions in the comments are shockingly negative... like huh? I'm wondering what people were expecting that they didn't get somehow. For the record I've been dying for her to work with Max Martin for YEARS and was left similarly scratching my head after TTPD and I think this album is a smash back to front.

Kate Mischka

I get that. I'm just saying I don't hear 'dickmatized' regardless. I wouldn't have thought that if I hadn't been told lol

Allison

He purposefully didn’t save it! He said he needs to marinate but he’ll be releasing a review with a version of those thoughts so never fear

Monic

When Eldest Daughter started I felt like I watched you do the “me!” Reaction expression on a loop until the end of this video

Kate Mischka

I looked it up and now realize I'm just old. Dickmatize was not a part of my vernacular and it's a Gen Z thing 😂

Hannah Andersen

I agree that this does seem like the LIFE of a showgirl rather than the life of a SHOWGIRL, but I'm wondering how it's any different from what we've heard already. I was hoping that she would be offering some perspective that we haven't heard before based on the title of the album and the marketing, but I feel like I've heard all of these songs before on other albums. She talked about this being a bts look at her life during the Eras Tour and I didn't hear almost any of that on the whole album, unfortunately. I'm hoping the music videos add context whenever those come out!

Gretchen D'Antico

Oh Happy Day. I was waiting for your reaction and can’t wait for your deeper thoughts. I absolutely love the album and will be listening to nothing else. It has grown on me with every listen.

Jessa Jayne

Not there yet so excited whole reason I’m here

Amanda

The title track is giving the greatest showman

Moonbeam009

Does anyone know the details about this song? Did her school crush really die?? That's so sad. ;-;

Gretchen D'Antico

Don’t go- give the seat to someone who likes the album and will be happy.

Annabel

again I never said I didn’t like it 😅😅

Nicole Ouimette

I like dirty and raunchy like any other girl. The difference is though: the writing sucks ass. The beat is good though. I’ll give her that.

S

Or to people who have taken an introductory college writing class

Alexandria Roswick

I immediately thought Blake and then I remembered Lena and Sophie exist too! I mean, the proof is in the pudding, she really does like her friends cancelled!

Alexandria Roswick

Same but I honestly liked the interpretation! Who’s to say it doesn’t apply?

Ayla Rios

I literally just had the same thought

X

WOOD is very max martin coded. See Peacock by Katy Perry. I bet he was in the studio egging her on to say those things!

Janie

You can’t give up on a bop and half like Wood. Embrace the penis innuendos!! It is the way

Tara

Agree, also the part about writing being more challenging in a stable relationship. I just wouldn't say the writing on this album is simplified. It's just all over the place. Yes, TTPD was also messy, but that was just the result of all the turmoil and devastation she experienced. The Life of a Showgirl is messy cause...she didn't really care as much? The younger fans seem to enjoy it though. Also I just think Taylor feels really at ease and happy with Travis and very comfortable just being her dorky self. Happy taylor = dorky taylor, as her fans we might just join in on the fun and not take the writing too seriously. Still, there is a misalignment with the marketing and the actual body of work. That‘s my constructive criticism.

Abby

The question is… where is the lizard

X

well, she just said bullet proof pop. travis said bangers. now we know he's not a reliable source and really that was our fault for trusting him.

Cassandra Blalock

“Everyone’s gonna be so annoying about this album and I’m telling you it’s the best album ever made. And I won’t deviate from that” PERIOD. Y’all in the comment section who are hating 🤷‍♀️

Athena Bermudez

Favorite song is Elizabeth Taylor, followed by Fate of Ophelia, the rest just haven’t hit me yet 😭

Isabelle Goulding

eldest daughter reminds me of when i heard robin and had no FUCKING clue what was happening. it’s respectfully the only one i cannot get on board with.

mae

Need her reaction more than anything. Streets say it won’t come out until tomorrow 😭

Alex Paslawski

Madeline posting on her IG story Cancelled with “delete from library” nooo😭

James

I think ruin the friendship came about when she was doing all the surprise songs on the eras tour and she didn't sing forever winter because it's so she probably revisited that song to sing and was so devastated that this song emerged

Cassady Lynn

Father figure murdered Scott borchetta

JD IHateItHere

Is she allowed to cry in all her iterations ? She can be all these things and more.

ella

Melissa

Insult to her, compliment to me made me laugh. Love the reaction and live after

ella

I do agree that the writing isn’t great but it’s an interesting perspective ig

Syd

Dolls, if Eldest Daughter didn’t have “trolling & memes” at the beginning it would be PERFECT to me… the chorus is so gooood

JD IHateItHere

You’ve got edge kid. She never did.

ratmice

Checked Rate Your Music (big mistake, who would've thought) and WOOD has higher rating than any track from the second half. This is the highest insanement level I've seen there

Lisaboo

Wood is her version of I heard you like magic I’ve got a wand and a rabbit and it’s not as good 🤷‍♂️

Drew

I’m sure this will be lost in all the comments but I just wanna say thanks for this thoughtful and nuanced reaction! You’re the first person I’ve seen who had a very similar reaction to me on all the songs. All of the hot takes right now seem to be overwhelming black and white negativity so I appreciate it

mango

everything else I could take or leave though ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I’m just excited to hear even more of your thoughts on it edit: deleted the comment before this for my sanity because I should know better than to get this involved in the discourse oops

JD IHateItHere

In the tub, one has thoughts a la Midnights.

M'Kaegan Hall

girl it’s just a track abt a hating bitch, nothing abt this gives homophobic

thebolter

But like why are we on our moral high ground let the celebs beef it’s entertaining

parker william

I honestly don’t mind the wood lyrics.. sonically it’s a chop

Hayley

💯

soff🪽

the gaslighting into positivity after eldest daughter is frying me

Pamela F

Thank you for being as disappointed with Wood as I am… you in your headdress for it is incredible though. Probably gunna have to block it on Spotify and pretend it never happened! 😬

Brianna Tullius

Father Figure is about Scott Borchetta and she’s the protege until the end when the first person changes and she says “you mistake kindness for weakness” and “turns out my dick’s bigger”. She was young and innocent ti trust this man if the industry who was more of a Mafia boss than a father figure in the end. He promised to make her name known in the streets and “protect the family” just to get rid of her in the end. He underestimated her and he made a deal worn”this devil”

Frances Webb

I think the contrast between "not a bad bitch" and the softness of the song heightened the meaning for me. She can get up on stage and be the rep heartbreaker girl or the lavender haze I don't care girl but underneath she really fearless era idealistic romantic Taylor. The fact that it sounds weird is her point

JD IHateItHere

The second headdress is everything. Everything. I’m just thanking Zachary for the headdress. I love the album for its ABBA/Fleetwood Mac lightness. Can a girl be happy? I get the whiplash after TTPD, but people felt run over and confused after Reputation too. Old Taylor and 2025 Taylor can exist at once. She’s a showgirl.

Elle Kaye

Wow of all the songs for her to hate, I didn’t expect it to be that one? It doesn’t reinvent the wheel but it’s structurally sound

Chas

And she’s so right for that

Laura H.

Currently in the theater waiting for the album/movie to start and there are multiple small children here. Like maybe 10 years old? Wondering if their parents have heard the lyrics to Wood or Actually Romantic yet.....

chappell roan

did your reaction get blocked on YouTube? I was in the middle of watching it and now I can't find it. doesn't really affect me cause I have unedited but I wanted to listen to edited first then unedited which is how I noticed.

Elle Kaye

It was mostly Zach processing his more negative opinions of the album, and then the chat devolved into chaos with odd comments and Israeli/Palestinian flags. As Zach said “[we’ve] had too much internet today” haha.

James

ETTER THAN RECENGE 2.0

Avery Turner

Are you going to post the live stream to Patreon?

Elle Kaye

I think a big part of Taylor’s more offline base is the target audience for that track

Windsor Zweifel

I can’t relate more to your blackout disassociation during fate of Ophelia. All I could process on first listen was that I like it. I loved watching your reaction!!!!

Valentin Bellegarde

‘Fate of Ophelia’ is my favourite song on the album and it is textbook Martin, that “keep it one hundred on the land, the sea, the sky…” - wow, so pretty! 🤩 🎵 Melody is the essence of music. Is this album better than eternal sunshine? ☀️ Too early to tell for me personally… but I’m leaning towards no. Great reaction!

Angelo David

I really think TLOAS is Taylor’s opportunity to “talk her shit” on an album that isn’t produced by Jack Antonoff — Jack has too many ties to the people Taylor is writing about here, I bet Jack didn’t wanna be associated with all of this drama and mess.

andre

taylor’s also holding an apple for the spotify canvas for actually romantic😭😭

daniel

He said no. I missed it all lol

JD IHateItHere

I will also say Better than Revenge walked so Actually Romantic could run Taylor’s jagged stiletto through her nemeses…..P..S. How does this not get redirected back in her face about Kimye?

Megan

Loved the first 4 song run. Ruin the friendship should've been the track 5

ryan

the vibes are very negative about the album on twitter i’ve never seen anything like it.. i enjoyed it though so

Rachel

Can we upload the preliminary thoughts live? I missed it 😭

Alessandra

Just a tip for you my dear Swiftologist: I just realized you can just listen to the Clean version of “Wood” and still enjoy the song without all the penis references

Noelia

Thanks for bringing the right showgirl energy to this Zac 👏👏👏, unlike the boring people of Twitter. Love love looove your outfits!!!!

clove

I live for the production of “Wood” but the lyrics take me out of it. I hate when she makes a good song with terrible lyrics😭

Psy

It occurred me during my belabored attempt to comprehend why those lyrics in Wood exist that at least some of her motivation may come from realllllly wanting a certain “small” man to know about the size of the D in her life now.

Vasudha R

Please upload the live y'all did today. I missed it. Would love to hear your immediate opinions 🥺

Ashley Taylor

Zack you legit JUMPED when she said dickmatized I’m deadddddd

Chas

I also went from hating ruin the friendship to crying by the end once I realized the true meaning 😭

liv

this is definitely giving reputation

Mikee Dayrit

Yeah and Max is too detached from the industry that artists won’t take it against him if he helps make diss tracks about them. Eg katy perry

Athena Bermudez

Also your reaction to Wood literally sent me 😭

Claire

K I checked her Scorpio placements… Mars, Pluto, midheaven, LILITH, and Juno

popestanleytucci💔

“I’m not feeling good. I’m scared.” Beloved, I am gagged in the best possible way ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹

Elaine

Listened to Wood once and deleted it from my library and downloads. Love, love, love the rest of the album. It’s so bloody good, and Max’s production is STELLAR (ofc). So refreshing! Yay, Showgirl, yay!

itsbritneymitch

I am so bummed about Eldest Daughter, the melody and vocals are soooooo gaggy …but those damn lyrics. I can’t get over it. Ruin the Friendship saved tho🤭

Dev

me too i keep refreshing!!

VictoriaReadsss

I think they said it would come up tomorrow

Bacall N McElroy

I have to say when Donald Trump is actively attacking you in the media and you make your clap back song about Charlie XCX it feels cowardly to me.

Erica

Can you please post the live for those of us that missed it 🙏🙏🙏

JD IHateItHere

Okay, how does I not comment on headdress number three, King? So iconic! As we know, showgirls can yearn for the simple life with a lover even if they know it’s a dream. Wishlist is opining for the bird not in hand. She is the Queen who doesn’t want projections on her. Heavy is the crown and all that although I think given her platform she is voicing a luxury the downtrodden wish to be able to reach for — “normalcy”she can fall into thanks to billions. Billions. She has the right it is a luxury many can not afford. I think we will get to the Reputation of it all, but we see the tomato thrown whilst in your glorious headdress. Diva up. Do not take off your headdress.

karen

Wood sounds like Lily allen songs ❤️

VictoriaReadsss

can someone tell me what happened on the live

the disabled mermaid

I thought u where rubbing a french fry on ur lips for a second and now i cant fucking breath 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

popestanleytucci💔

The daily mail responding to your video: swifties support taylor claiming rich bitch swag bag and stepping on these pop girlies necks, turns out they were right

liv

YASSS SILVER SERVE

Kris

Just read Taylor’s showgirl poems and they’re better than the actual album. They’re soooo well written and they actually give showgirl. Idk what’s going on

Aaron

“Suddenly I feel like a fool in my headdress” is how I’d summarize this album tbh

Elaine

Re: cancelled! Based on this, and other recent musings of mine, (what?!) I’m pretty sure Taylor and Blake are still friends behind the scenes, but they are waiting for the Baldoni stuff to be resolved.

Erica

Her rising (and therefore her mid heaven) is widely debated (between Capricorn and Sagittarius) but regardless the Scorpio mars is prominent!

Charlotte

the hatred for this album so far is genuinely baffling. i think people actually just hate her because there is objectively nothing awful about this album and they are acting like its the worst album ever released.

Valentin Bellegarde

I remember I was 20 mins into this reaction - everything positive so far - when I got the notification ‘Swiftologist is live!’ And I went into the live and it was zach expressing that he was rather underwhelmed by the album, saying we were led to believe this was a return to 1989 levels of pop mastery, bangers etc. It got me thinking… what’s the difference between now and 1989? Well, Taylor said it herself: she’s “equals” now with max Martin. And I’m thinking… 🤔 what if that’s the problem. What if that’s why we didn’t get 1989 part 2. Because the dynamic is different. Was Ariana “equals” with max on eternal sunshine? ☀️ 🤔

Róisín

Honestly you're doing the Lord's work Zach, until I watched all of this... I was in a daze the whole day.

Erin S

Okay… you enjoyed this album more than your post-recording downward spiral led me to believe! Yes, Eldest Daughter was a let-down as far as Track 5s go and there were about 3-4 clunkers overall… but upon 3rd listen, I’m enjoying it more. The initial shock and whiplash of the 1st listen is wearing off. Headed to the theater now!

Aya ✨

I know in my bones that Madeline dislikes this album more than Zach does hahaha

Kris

One Taylor swift account tweeted it. I can’t remember which one sorry

Ashley C

I feel like everyone's playing a prank on me with this one..... am I just in a bad mood? am I just on my period? is it that I got broken up with a few months ago and I'm jealous?

Wynne

Zach, this bar none is my favourite reaction video from you EVER. The drooping feathers on the headdress during Wood SENT ME INTO THE STRATOSPHERE. This is ART. THIS IS PERFORMANCE.

Megan McCoy

Realized that actually romantic is track 7 and Charli's everything is romantic is also track 7 on brat and I know it it's not the original song about Taylor (i.e. sympathy is a knife) but the song title did remind me of that title of Charli's as well so it just feels like a fun play.

Ada

Eldest daughter is written like it’s a scroll through TicTok and I can’t do it.

maryna

I love how she sings "I'm not a bad bitch" in eldest daughter but one song before that she told scott borchetta that her dick is bigger and that the empire belongs to her and two tracks after that she will tell charli xcx to basically go fuck herself...

Josieee

Zach I am screaming at the screen, begging you to realize Father Figure is COOKING SCOTT BORCHETTA…. ANYONE ELSE WITH ME???

mallorey garrett

She HAAAAATED Cancelled. It’s on her IG stories.

Mary Massed

Is it just me or does the beginning of CANCELLED! sound like a Benson Boone song???

Roisin Shy

I am glad you liked this album because the reviews have not been that positive that I saw.

Mary Massed

My first thought was definitely Joe Alwyn but now I see both ways

mallorey garrett

Oh she DESPISES this song. I can’t wait to see them go toe to toe on it

Jonathan Armswood

Me downloading patreon just to see your reaction because I love your thoughtfulness even tho I’m not a swifty. I love particularly the way you come for her when needed and give flowers when needed. You always are articulate and the right level of cunty. Ty for that.

.

Does anyone know where to watch lizard reviews?

phoenix

STOPPPPPPP THE THIRD OUTFIT WITH THE HEADRESS HAS SENTTTTTTTTT MEEEEEEEEEEEE

Angelo David

October 3rd is the perfect day for Taylor to release TLOAS because she is kinda giving mean girl... and I say this as a dedicated fan since Red. Previously (on songs like Anti-Hero) it was Taylor’s SELF AWARENESS that made it OKAY for her to discuss matters in regards to her celebrity status, wealth, interpersonal relationships with other celebs, etc. Where is the self awareness on this project? It seems like she’s just flexing on everyone and talking her shit (which I wouldn’t mind if the music was substantial). I hate to pull this card, but Taylor DID in fact build an entire brand & fanbase off of being the voice for “the girl on the bleachers,” only to become the popular “cheer captain” that bullies the other girls (smaller artists). Not to mention, she ended up with the republican football player who also would’ve bullied you in school… it doesn’t feel right. Furthermore, what does it say about the biggest pop star and (arguably) most powerful woman in the world that she needs to flex her fiancé’s penis size and come for other women to feel validated? For someone who’s talking a lot of shit on this album… this is insecure behavior. “The Man” would NEVER rely on her fiance’s dick size to feel validated. I have more to say but I don’t like being a hater. Such a disappointment.

K.C.

this is the most positive way of saying how I felt, thank you 🙏 my non -Taylor friend asked me if it's good and... I can't upload 20 years of lore into her aura so I just said to listen to it Taylor set her own bar high and she's falling on her own sword of expectation (look: I can mix metaphors, too).

Lexi

your reaction to wood….IJBOLLLLLL so perfect

April

I'm so disappointed in this album, just started listening to Style to get my fix of promised 'bulletproof pop' . I'm aways engrossed in a new album, listening to it over and over again, I hoped this would grow, and it's actually getting worse the more times I play, so I think this is 1 out of 12 I won't be returning to, still a good run!

Kris

Omg someone has posted half of the Ophelia music video on twitter! It’s on @loverlondongirl

soff🪽

madeline’ s story is TAKING ME OUT

K.C.

"that's not good writing" -why I $$ for beind the paywall truths

ZEE MACHINE

Sympathy is a knife hot take!!!!!! 😬

phoenix

Wood also silenced me but then I remembered that she's doing cabaret while dating a jock and that has made it more acceptable and almost okay lol. CANCELLED however.........cuntress. I was transported to a dark smokey corner of a billionaires' cabaret club, where she sits in the corner with a handful of scorned, designer-adorned "kicked out" a-list girls, smoking a cigarette holding a small glass of whiskey on the rocks and she motions around like a mob boss introducing the newest cancelled celebrity woman as if to say "i'm you're family now" in the cuntiest sneer ever seen. Like a Madame of the highest reverence.....I can't stop thinking about it.

Caitlyn

Watching you catch the meaning of wood in that head dress absolutely sent me

Dana Meyerson

To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ and solid grasp of theoretical physics to understand Wood

Cassidy Robbins

Is anyone else surprised by the negative reactions to this album? I LOVED it on the first listen! A few bumps with specifically the lyrics on Eldest Daughter (love the melody so its unforch) and Honey (just not my fave, maybe itll grow). But overall it was such a slay!!!

CK

soooooo glad i bought the patreon for this event

Maeva

Honestly, I loved the album on my first listen then I came here...and I got SO overwhelmed by the negative reactions that it made me change my first impression of it...idk why, I needed to log off. But so far, I love: Ophelia, Elizabeth Taylor, Opalite, Father Figure, Honey. Wood is good beat and melody but the lyrics are throwing me off. Cancelled is growing on me (not Madeline HATING on it ahah)

Emily M

couldn’t have put it better myself

Bacall N McElroy

I'm glad she is fully throatily supporting Blake Lively. She 100% was a victim of the misogyny slop ecosystem.

Juby

ILOVEELDESTDAUHHTER. Lol as an eldest daughter, it just fucken HITS

Joan Chan

I heard it too!!

Terry B

One may argue that Midnights was also a retrospect instead of exploring new POV… she’s as oversharing and least packaged as Folkmore and TTPD. I’m not disappointed. I know this album won’t be a transformation; it’d be more like fast food, and honestly, who doesn’t eat comfort / fast food 😁🙂‍↕️😅 Her visuals always help with understanding the songs 🙂‍↕️

Katy O'Brien

Why was I almost more excited for this reaction than the album itself hHahahahha

Drew

You might be the first person I’ve ever seen that is actually asking for a political song from a pop star lol

Amber

"Everything has changed" 💯 As soon as she said Abigail I SAT UP

Satu

I'm having a dance party by myself 😅 let the haters hate hate hate, I loooove this album!

K.C.

girl, so cuntfusing

Sierra Walter

Where do I find Madeline’s story?

Satu

I'm kind of surprised and not, it seems to be the default reaction since Midnights. I wonder how many just want Folklore type of stuff. But the thing with Taylor is that she never makes the same thing twice. At least not twice in a row (except Folklore & Evermore, but that was a double album).

Satu

The sad head bow when it sinks in 😂. I died.

Shondi

Agreed! I thought the same thing when I first heard it!

K.C.

it's in my notes!! it's how she draws out the vowels in that deep, hollow vocal

K.C.

Wi$h L$sT is the inverse of Lorde's Royals

Hey12345

The Wish List song is giving trad wife vibes. I study the radical right in political science and U.S.History post the Progressive Era. I am really watching what the reaction will be to that song in particular to some female MAGA influencers that are Taylor Swift fans, but peddle in anti-feminism.

Areyna Schmidt

Anyone else cry their eyes out during Ruin the Friendship??

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

I need Madeline's reaction! 🐍🐍🦎 Snakes unite! (Pweeeese) 💕

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

That was a GUT PUNCH. I was starting to put together and then I got hit... It's such a beautiful song!!!! Was not expecting that

Drew

Trust me any artist they come back with that is a “better writer” I guarantee you’ll be able to find cringy lyrics in their albums too. Ppl just jump on it when it’s Taylor

Vilde Olaussen

Team ‘Ruin the Friendship is the real track 5’ 🥲

K.C.

same critic tho?

K.C.

swiftologist 4 merch president

Léa

Totally agree with you. Except for the fact that Travis is not Republican. People gotta stop with this.

Cameron Van Sant

You really called it on Elizabeth Taylor and Cancelled!! Impressive!! Also, over here as a Charli stan......................... I'm eating popcorn lol, I'm happy

Marissa

Instagram

Kd235481

You claimed Elizabeth Taylor right!! It’s a banger

Angelo David

Well Travis certainly hasn’t stood up for Taylor when the president continuously bashes her but that’s none of my business… If he isn’t gonna speak up for his FIANCÉ, the HBIC, I can guarantee you he isn't going to speak up about progressive issues. Maybe he's not MAGA or a full-on republican but he's extremely SILENT, and that speaks volumes to me.

Ciera

“We need to keep it light and positive. UP NEXT Ruin the Friendship”

Nefelibata

I claim the interpretation (don’t care what she says in the interviews, I want to live in my bubble) that in the song “Elizabeth Taylor”, Taylor is singing TO Elizabeth Taylor, asking if she will still have fun, if she stop having different men. The song gets more interesting this way. Is like: I was living a version of you and having fun, but now I want another life, I broke the curse, will I still be famous and good at my job?

Kikki

😂😂

Jasper Murray

Girls I read father figure the same way except about matty healy when I first listened

maryna

So, after sitting with the album for a day and a half (yeah, I listened to the leaked version...), I think it could have been a great album, had there been more time. I sincerely feel that this album was recorded in a short amount of time and there was no fine-tuning. By letting it sit and then revisit it, certain things would have been a) left off, like wood or b) improved, like eldest daughter... And c) Taylor, Max and shellback would've realized that there needs to be a little bit more oomph... Oh, and d) they would have also realized that they need to kind of stick to the overall theme of the album... Ok, that's a lot of work. But technically it would have been possible... Anyone else feels like this album is kind of like a first or second draft of what the album could be technically? Sorry for being such a hater, but I just can't seem to connect with this album. There's two or three songs I genuinely enjoy, but even if I didn't have them I would still be ok, I guess... I really hope it will grow on me. I don't want to sit this era out 😭 I want to be crazy for this songs. I want to be looking at my phone and not knowing which song to listen to next of all the songs that I love. Taylor, Max and shellback: give me back my girlhood it was my first!!!

Elaine

Zack, you have to have someone send you the Target pink spritz vinyl. The interior visuals are simply *stunning*. And the giant poster. 👀 No I do not work for Target or patronize them - with this teeny tiny exception cuz it’s TS. That is all.

Nefelibata

My other tea to spill: I think ruin the friendship is a VERY showgirl song, not just because of what Zack already said, but ALSO because she centres her grief and the loss of a real person around her. Like, she makes something that has absolutely nothing to do with her, about her. That is very showgirl of her. It kind of gives me an ick, but looking throw the showgirl glasses I can see a artistic expression

Patricia Sanz Villan

Father figure??? Could also be about matty??? Because the sacandals and the younger me could be literal. I dont know it’s just the first listen

Bell

Zack thinking Father Figure is about Joe/Olivia is this album's version of "is Joe bi?" lmfaooo. The Scott Borchetta takedown is too good there. THIS EMPIRE BELONGS TO ME! -- MASTERS

Amber

"Against my better judgement, I have to bang"

Elaine

Love this theory of Taylor singing to Elizabeth. Makes perfect sense. I think they would be good friends, irl.

Jessica Maguire

Hey Zach I don’t remember where I saw it but someone suggested listening to clean version of wood and other graphic songs. it really helps if the travdick of it all, gives you the ick. 😆

Elaine

Indeed, lol

K.C.

respectfully, normal ppl aren't dreaming of that. normal ppl are dreaming of: owning a home with a basketball hoop. being able to afford kids. this song is A. hypocritical; B. lazy writing; C. tone deaf plus, there's no depth to the thought--ok you're now dreaming of a family, low key life? you can go get it. tomorrow. where's the tension? better writing in how that might be impossible for her. better case study: Are You Ready For It? the contrast be her outer life in the verses and the peace/fantasy in the chorus good writing needs tension!!

Jadz

I'm hating all the hate!! I listened to this and was immediately in love and completely gagged!! I assumed everyone would love it and was so shocked that people were hating!!

James Meyer

I don't think Cancelled is about Blake. I fear it is about Brittany Mahomes 😭

Elaine

Been thinking lately that the friendship is not, nor has it ever been, ‘over’ and this song confirms it. They are just laying low until Baldoni drama is over. These tabloid nonsense articles about TS ignoring BLs texts were BS planted by - well, I don’t even need to say it.

Amber

Definitely, I loved it right away from the first notes of Ophelia!

Bacall N McElroy

That is hysterical but I don’t think it’s true she didn’t know her back when she was cancelled. Like Blake really was with her in the trenches in the mud 😭😭😤

April

I don't know why some of these songs feel so sickly sweet when she has done sweet love songs before but they haven't felt like this. I'm not sure if it's because they have a bit of a trad wife feel/sense of I was dying and you rescued me. Tbh I feel a bit left behind and disregarded as a single person!

Shannon Mapps

Read somewhere apparently before the key change towards the end, it’s Scott’s perspective then it flips to Taylor’s

Drew

It’s definitely gonna be the clean versions of all the songs, otherwise I don’t think AMC would’ve let it stay listed as Not Rated meaning any age can buy tickets

April

There isn't 'hate' - there is a lot of valid criticism of it which is a good thing to engage with, and it is easy to put an articulate argument forward for why it isn't a good album. If people think it's good they should be able to articulate that too

Lyndsey

I'm obsessed with all the outfits you wore, Zack. The head accessories made the outfits!

Charlotte

no… there is a lot of hate lmao. everything i have seen so far is not critical of the art, it is personal jabs just how it was when TTPD was released too. i don’t care if people love or hate the album. i like it, i don’t think it’s her best but i can’t stand the complete outrage online every time taylor dares to release music nowadays. to these people her crime isn’t her music, her lyrics or even her politics. it is the sheer fact that she exists.

Emily Christine

You were vibing to wood so hard in your headdress and then she said dickmatized 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Sarah

good news is we’ll probably have part 3 of 2019 sooner than we thought

Hunter

Streets say 😭

Emily M

No bc I’m going to interpret father figure your way now it’s so much funnier that way

Drew

Listen to the clean version babes it solves this problem 🙏

Kat Doyle

It makes me so happy that Zach chose the headpiece for his Vegas outfit that I'm wearing as part of my showgirl Halloween costume this year. 🥰

darya

me every time taylor announces a new album

Bella

Cook more please

Patricia Vela

I felt this way too. I had to step away. I remember not even caring about reviews/reactions to TS albums. Caring about them almost ruined it for me today but I recognized that once upon a time all I cared about was listening to the album and making my mind up for myself. I really like this album. It's not perfect but that's okay.

Bella

He is stressed because he doesn’t like the album that much anymore

SeraRose

I love the soundscape of this album. It's giving dreamy, it's giving yacht in the Mediterranean in the 1950s. It sounds Showgirl even if not all the lyrics are

Hannah Thomas

Ok apparently I am one with swiftologist bc that was what I thought too. What is it about????

Katie

I need your reaction to balenci-shades 😭😭

Elle Lowery

I thought it started out so strong for the first 4 songs, wish that would have carried through. I suspect Wood was meant not only as a brag but also as a dig at Joe. I can’t think of any other reason for her to release a song like that unless she wanted an ex to hear it. Actually Romantic is a good song, but the question is if she cleared it with Charli or not imo. If she didn’t, I agree it’s a mean girl thing to do.

Emily M

Wood reaction while wearing the headdress I’m CRYING 😭

KRYSTAL HOWARD

After going to the theater release and hearing the album in the clean version, I have a new love for some of the songs and others that I prefer in the original state. Had so much fun though so and am so happy I did it.

Deli

I need “sniffing up the wrong tree” on a tshirt

Hey12345

Excellent point right there ☝️

Morgan Smith

I think it’s about Scott Borschetta being her father figure in the music industry and then making a deal with the devil (scooter) to sell her masters

Emily M

SENT ME TO THE MOON

Satu

But has Brittany Mahomes been cancelled? I thought people just don't like her. Like did she suddenly become conservative? I think people who are cancelled had some prominence before their down fall. What has Brittany done, be a footballer's wife that she still is? This is a genuine question because I don't know almost anything about her 😅. Blake's cancellation however has been global news and very prominent.

Emily M

He’s literally not republican come onnnnn this is well documented. Republican football fans made fun of him for being the face of the Pfizer Covid shot!! He’s a registered dem!!

Enzo Reis

As always! It's pretty boring at this time. If she does something like Ttpd = too much, if she does something direct and objective like Showgirl = weak writing/too minimal. 🥱🥱🥱

Enzo Reis

As always! It's pretty boring at this time. If she does something like Ttpd = too much, if she does something direct ande objective like Showgirl = weak writing/too minimal. 🥱🥱🥱

Morgan Smith

She hasn’t uploaded it yet. She was in the middle of uploading and then had to go to the showgirl movie

Rafael Figueroa

I've been crushing on Travis for a while so I really enjoyed "Wood"😬

Haden Williams

i think she should’ve called the album the fate of ophelia and made it more romantic and shakespearean/wistful vibes and then saved showgirl for an actual concept record. bc this is just lover 2.0

Morgan Smith

He wrote in the description he knows he misinterpreted it

Kristina

There are rallye good Songs - Father Figure, Elisabeth Taylor, Cancelled. I think I might just start forgetting tha Wood was released. Should've stayed between her and Travis, I feel like it's TMI. Love it for her, but why tell us? 😆

KattyAnn

Travis did not go crazy for Wood. He went crazy for Opalite. 😝

MK

I'm assuming it's a dig at the smallest man and measuring up to any measure of a man

April

thought it was cancelled

April

Oh I love that idea!!!!

Kenna

ZACH 😂😂😂 I cannot stop laughing. This is the best reaction ever

KattyAnn

I feel like she may have had the concept of a showgirl album banked for a while and felt she had to use it to lose it and so the songs don’t exactly fit. I do love the album, though. Taylor sounds unbothered and satisfied to me. It’s nice.

Hayley D

The clean versions really toned it down in a good way! Especially Wood! I was jamming NGL. 😂 and I must give Ms Director Swift her props for the music video 👏🏻

Stephi

Thank you for your service, Zachary. There is nothing more gratifying that witnessing the unfolding of a new Taylor era through your lens. I dissociated just as hard as you did when I hit play! Our taste is so similar and I love how you interpreted some of the themes I hadn't caught on to yet. Father Figure, Actually Romantic and Cancelled hit so much harder once you pointed out what they might be about. Can't wait for all the content ahead of us.

Savvy

I felt the same way. I listened at midnight in the dark with good headphones and i loved it. All the hate i see around is honestly shocking me! Love that zach's reaction is positive and pretty much my first listen roller coaster as well

April

It's pretty surface level, not great writing - which is okay if the melodies really take you somewhere - this album does neither for the majority - so that can impact connecting emotionally to it

Michelle Forge

pissing laughing at your reaction to the first beat drop in Elizabeth Taylor - you almost fell off your chair hahaha

Savvy

Ooo i love this picture

Savvy

Im a bit confused by it lol

Elle Lowery

I was expecting more songs about the eras tour specifically, like in I can do it with a broken heart. I’m here for the “I love Travis” and “my dick is bigger” vibes but I feel like in the promotion it was promised that she’d dish on the tour specifically and I don’t see that in the album. But, when Reputation came out I was also really confused so I’m not sure how I’ll feel about the album in a few weeks or years time. Pretty sure Rep is going to stand as my favorite album still tho

Aimee

Someone tell me who Father Figure is actually about 🙏

Hanna Cannon Colm

What are our thoughts on Father Figure being about mentees or Taysisters?

Stephi

OMG, SAME. I'm still recovering.

Elle Lowery

I like Eldest Daughter (of course I’m biased as an eldest daughter lol) but I think it would have fit in better on TTPD. Ruin the Friendship moved up to track 5 would have been my suggestion. I also think there’s a couple of songs from TTPD she could have saved and revamped the production that would have fit better on this album (clara bow, I can do it with a broken heart, and/or so high school). But I think this album wasn’t planned in advance. If she’d know the concept for TS12 before she released TTPD I think she could have edited it better to stay on the theme of The Life of a Showgirl.

Katie

So happy I watched this after the YouTube it is great to see your unedited reaction

Stephi

Agreed, Tiff. Made my whole week.

Aya ✨

she literally says “boy”, that theory makes no sense to me

maryna

It's hard to put into words. I'll try: 1. I think many songs don't take off in a way that I would like them to and that makes them kind of mellow, for instance Ophelia, it sounds very background music to me, like you switch on the radio and the song is on and you're like moving a leg along to it and but you don't go crazy for it, you're not like desperately waiting for the pre-chorus or the chorus or the bridge. The song sounds very much like she's playing it safe and not taking any risks, many other songs on this album if not all of them. (I'm talking about the sonic landscape.) 2. Generally I'm fine with songs not fully taking off because jack does that too, but most Jack songs that don't take off have other interesting things going on sonically (e.g. fresh out the slammer, or the ending of my boy only breaks his favorite toys). Again this makes it seem like she's playing it very safe. There is nothing funny or weird or super original sonically, it's just all very uneventful. 3. I seriously feel like a lot of the bridges aren't that great and usually taylor is great at delivering bridges. I like yearning for the bridge to start and then scream it back at her. 4. the tonal shifts confuse me (e.g. Ophelia includes some old-fashioned language, wood is very playful and uses sexual language, eldest daughter uses internet verbiage). I like it when there is an overall feel to an album. It allows me to dive into the world that the album creates. But there is no one world on this album, it's all a bit all over the place. No? Ophelia's lyrics are folk-more, wood is a horny journal entry that should not see the light of day... 5. Some songs are not well written imo because there is no clear conceit or idea that they focus on, e.g. eldest daughter or wish list. With cancelled too, you don't _really_ know what or who she's talking about, you just have a vague idea. Again that's okay if certain other things work. And father figure too is actually not very clear. again you need to know of the lore to actually understand this song. This is fine for me and I had to do it on ttpd and midnights too and it's okay. But if you create an album for the masses, I feel like the message of each song should be clear, just like 1989. But a song like father figure is gibberish to the general public. Is it not? People might catch the overall sentiment of the song but I don't think they will fully understand. Some songs are much better in this respect, though, e.g. ruin the friendship, ophelia, honey. 6. Lastly, i feel that some of the songs lack authenticity. In wishlist she lists a lot of material things she claims she doesn't need, but she's a fucking billionaire... At the end of the day it's hard to say why you connect with something or why you don't. Ophelia is the type of song that should work for me. I like it melodically, lyrically, vocally and sonically but still it does not fully hit home for me and that is really weird and just tells me that something is missing for me. maybe in the end I'm just not a Max Martin person? (I do like 1989 and rep, though...). Sorry, this is the longest answer in the history of answers... 😬 It's also full of negativity, I know that. I don't want to spoil the party for anyone... I'm just really sad that I don't like it, because the last albums were just so great for me.

Hanna Cannon Colm

I think it could make sense because she calls herself father figure. Kinda like how Nicki calls people her “sons.” 😆

Bri Renneisen

I felt honored to be a part of the nasty girl chat 😅 That was nothing compared to the way the girls talk when the boys aren’t around lol

Sheridan S

I'm just about to watch the movie! So exciting!

Ivan Cervera

Now imma say im here for the tea and shade but sympathy is a knife is definitely the better and more interesting song of the two. Like one is “lemme examine my own insecurities” and the other is “ f u and kys u coke head mess” 😭😭

HaleyJean ASMR

Scott B, her old record label manager

Elle Lowery

I like some of it but I’m confused because she spends a good portion of the album being cvnty but then sings “I’m not a bad bitch”?

Lauren Markland

I loooove it way more than I thought I would. Came online and was smacked in the face with the negativity 😂 same thing happened with rep tbh

Erin S

I think the first couple versus are her singing what men (Scott Borchetta) said to her the first half of her career when she was being managed and controlled and then she flips it on the last verse to say she’s the father figure now… she’s the one driving this train and she calls her own shots about what she sings and does to promote her work and she does the damage control when it’s needed and she protects the work and the people her work for her. I remember her saying she saw potential in Borchetta when she chose to sign with him and his new label rather than some bigger established one, but then he didn’t take care of her in the end… he made a deal with the devil (Scooter) instead. At least that’s how I see it.

Kaitlyn

I ride at dawn for father figure. Who's coming? Bring your torches and pitchforks were headed to Scott’s

Elle Lowery

I wish it was on TTPD instead of TLOAS. I could see it fitting in on the anthology

Alexa

No lol he's the same age.

tomatotime

Yes yes yes some one tell him

tomatotime

Oooooooooo INTERESTING many composite sketch between Scott and Charlie

alice

I fear the melody of white horse will be perennially bastardised in my head by the visceral cringe of "i'm not a bad bitch this isn't savage" 😭

Hanna Cannon Colm

Ppl are saying Scott B but I feel like it could be sooo many diff people

VictoriaReadsss

Okay tea is I felt the same way, I’ve gone through ups and downs the last 18 hours w the album🤣🤣

Kylee

I’m currently in the theater, dancing on my own because no one likes to have fun anymore. Do people understand how bad this woman wants her Rocky Horror Moment? Can we just pretend a little bit to give that to her? Anyways, haven’t gotten to the music video yet, but do you remember a few days ago when I said Ive been preparing myself for Taylor Swift the musical because I’m shocked we haven’t done it yet? Well…….? 🍿🍿🍿 Also, Wood goes off in surround sound, you can actually hear someone knocking on the walls. Besides me, that is.

Alexa

Made me think of a guy I had the biggest crush on in high school and almost pursued multiple times. He was so sweet. But then I met my husband and started a family etc and never heard from him after graduation... He took his own life a couple Christmases ago. RTF really makes me think of him.

Erin S

Just saw the movie… I think the clean version of wood that she uses in the release movie is more tolerable.

Erin S

With a picture of a redwood tree, perhaps? 🤣

Deli

STOP haha

Erin S

I had the same reaction! I usually find the clean lyric substitutions kinda dumb, but in this case they make some of the songs more poetic.

Elle Lowery

“I have been afflicted by a terminal uniqueness/and I have been dying from trying to seem cool” is so heartbreaking and definitely resonates with me. Trying to look like you know what you’re doing and getting praised for any successes but feeling alone and easily hurt behind closed doors. I definitely see peoples criticisms of the song though. There’s a lot going on at once in it

jasmine

the headpiece is taking me out ijbolll

KRYSTAL HOWARD

Once you hear the clean version with the lyric videos you might change your mind

Erin S

Maybe verse 2 could be. I’ve been ruminating that verse 1 is her singing from Borchetta’s viewpoint at the start of her career. Verse 2 could be her midway in her career… around 1989… being a mentor to someone who then was disloyal to her (maybe Matty, maybe Justin Bieber?)… and then verse 3 is of course Taylor’s Version-era Taylor.

Katie

I’m legit shocked at your explanation of father figure. I can’t unsee it now, but it’s not how I interpreted it at all the first time

Kylee

This might be the most magnificent red wig we’ve seen yet, allegedly. Ohhhhhh bitches? She’s baaaaaaaack. 💋

Erin S

I think it’s probably about multiple people that fit the narrative… yes, Blake and agree, Britt and there are probably a ton of others that come to mind for her. People are too easily cancelled anymore… none of us are perfect. My own cousin “cancelled” me from her life and I still don’t know why.

Dane

I went to the party release in cinema and they played the clean versions of the explicit songs and I gotta say, as someone who usually never listen to the clean versions, Wood clean version is better. The smexshual innuendos are more subtle, and clever and I can enjoy the boppy chorus without having to hear the word dickmatized, unlike the explicit version that is just cringe... Also, Opalite's chorus sounds like a Christmas song to mr

Val D'Villain

at some point I even suspected turkey slander but like.....surely not............

Aimee

I really wanted turkey slander

Rachel Bullock

Wood is a cricket song for SURE because the beat slaps but the lyrics are...shocking...

Tara

ok I can't take it no more I have to say it and I might get blocked from the patreon. Why am I hearing Karma by Jojo Siwa in the beginning of TFOO help

Becca Gilgan

Yes!! Thank you!! I liked several of the songs better as “clean” versions. No dicks! No thighs! No bitch!

Elise Cooper

I feel so satisfied that I was calling Father Figure a song that Taylor is actually the one mentoring someone. I think this is the first time I have ever claimed a track and it actually be my favourite track on first listen

hew619

I CACKLED when you showed us the Vegas shirt onggg

Kyora Wallace

WAIT WAIT WAIT, everyone chill Actually Romatic is NOT about Charli XCX. "You call me Boring Barbie when the coke's got you brave" Alot of people call Taylor barbie as an insult and ALOT of people in Hollywood do coke. "You highfived my ex and said you're glad he ghosted me." Matty is not Taylor's only ex. "You send me nasty valentines." These behavoirs sound like something A DOUCHEBAG MAN would do. (ie Scooter Braun or Scott). You say that you didn't think Taylor would take it that way why would she? Sympathy is a knife is a vulnerable song, and Taylor seemingly understands that she has this impact on people whether she means to or not (ie the monster on the hill). I picture some asshole guy bragging to his friends about how he sent her a nasty letter. DO NOT PUSH THIS NARRATIVE BEFORE YOU START A WAR lol

Elle Lowery

Although she’s done diss tracks in the past. I’m just not used to her writing one about another woman. The only one I can think of off the top of my head is bad blood

Magenta

I literally had THE SAME EXACT reaction to Wood. I was loving the song and production and beat, and Jackson 5, grooving and then…. And THEN… dickmatized by Travis Kelce’s redwood tree opening her thighs, stopped me in my tracks and we are listening to a song about Travis Kelces junk!? The lyrics have to be ignored to enjoy. At what cost!?!? Say it again Zach!

Dan

I feel like the use of “father” and flipping the gender roles and subverting the expectations is pretty intentional, meaning I think it’s definitely referring to a man in her life, most likely in a professional sense. I could see it being also about a previous romantic relationship but it feels very directed towards a long standing professional relationship aka Scott borchetta? I can’t imagine this being about a taydaughter

Koreyn Wight

i think it's a bit more the LIFE of a showgirl than the life of a SHOWGIRL if that makes sense

Jh

Hard disagree, I don’t think she has to stick to a visual theme. She should have maybe not made the visuals about showgirls. I also think this actually is her best album with very good productions I was prepared red to dislike it. I really think wood is hilarious also, I have no attachment to Taylor being a fairy princess who doesn’t sing about dicks. Anyway it just has me wondering why she didn’t put much effort into midnights production when she still was capable of greatness. These songs are so good; I don’t think you need to know much lore for father figure. there’s so much great music that doesn’t paint an exact picture of a situation and I don’t think it has to. I think that’s just what people are used to from Taylor. I also feel like some of her best bridges musically and I’m happy to get a key change from her finally. This album is the first one of hers that has made me sob actually. I was on the edge of hateration just prior to this album but now I’m… swiftie

Pooja R

Same here...i am going to speak my truth and say i do not give a single shit about Travis, much less his manhood. The secondhand embarassment i had listening was intense. Its like she lost a bet with him and had to add this song in. Awful.... in general i much prefer the first half of the album lyrically and sonically.

Peggy Darling

I def interpreted it as a cautionary tale. Like learn from my mistakes and regrets

shelby

Zach! Father Figure is giving the Scott B interview with Larry King in 2016. “I saw potential…”

chappell roan

Please upload the live Zach!! I missed it but I would gag to watch it

chappell roan

I’m PMO cause I LOVE wood in every aspect, except for the lyrics which are ABYSMAL! But it’s so catchy and sounds amazing productionslly

Griffin

"The Empire is Belongs to Me" Absolutely about Scott Deal with the Devil/Scooter

Griffin

Ok so I think after a few listens, relistening to The Heights' podcast how she described it, I'm fathoming the concept finally. Showgirl is about holding-back/playing it cool outwardly while real and vulnerable change is happening off stage

Griffin

Explanation: When Taylor said this album is about what happens offstage, etc, she meant what was going through her mind that she wasn't sharing. She was feeling empowered and invigorated by the Eras Tour and her rerecords, and also completely changed by this unexpected relationship that was everything she ever wanted, and she couldn't fully express that outwardly at the time. (Though we all noticed a change). She is feeling fulfilled and in control and supported and untouchable -- and wonder at those feelings, after a life of so many outside influences pulling her every which way. There's a lot of Travis-saved-me-(with-his-dick), but also I-control-my-career, I-control-who-my-friends-are and-who-i-let-in, I-control-how-i-feel-about-others-hating-me, I-control-how-i-act and i-am-allowed-to-be-vulnerable-if-i-want and its-ok-to-want-because-im-safe. This is why she chose the bathtub image for the main cover among all the gorgeous photos. At the end of the night she's exhilarated and exhausted and feeling complete and fulfilled in all aspects of her life, and that's so novel to her.

Dan

Am I the only one who thinks ruin the friendship is about something more recent and not the same person as forever winter? She makes it sound so recent and she did say this album is referring to the last few years of her life? Unless she was just really thinking about jeff again during a very intense period of her life (eras tour). Idk anyone have thoughts about this? The song really touched me so I’m just thinking about it a lot

Allie C

this is why i love your reactions and reviews, i was soooo on the fence about ruin the friendship. like why tf is it on the album but you breaking it down made so much sense.

Bella

Same, I showed some songs to my boyfriend and he asked if it was really a song because it sounded unfinished 💀

Makayla Smith

Some of these comments make me feel crazy because I really like the album 🥲 Like damn guess I have no taste lmao

ducky

Glad I'm not the only one who immediately thought Father Figure was Joe shade 💀

Czarina

I have the same thoughts! It feels like these songs are from the vault songs and I was left trying to find where the main album songs are. It’s a weird feeling… I just thought it would be more - I’m looking for a Style or Blank Space but the songs are very mellow and not hard hitting. I think she may have oversold this a bit if I’m being honest.

Deli

What does “youre only as hot as your last hit baby, been number one but never had two” mean? I feel so dumb lol

Vikki

I think Scott Borchetta and him mentoring her then selling the music out from under her, and her eventually buying the music back.

Elise Cooper

I think Father Figure, Ruin the Friendship and Actually Romantic are so look behind the curtain/true feelings and retrospect once the lights go down and I love it, I wish we had more songs like this that reveal just a bit of how Taylor really feels behind the scenes - lots of this album is I love Travis and that's fine but is it really showgirl? I guess it's what she wants after the performance is over

Natalie Topalian

FWIW Popcast released an excellent podcast about the album today that is worth the listen for anyone interested in a thoughtful discussion on TLOAS 🫶

Natalie Topalian

Cannot wait for Swiftologist/EOAS review as well and I loved this reaction video!! And curious how your opinion evolves with more days/listens after hearing the livestream earlier today.

Griffin

I gotta say the amount of things that scream Charli on this is hard to ignore. I would assume that if it is about Charli (which I kind of think it is), then there's more going on behind the scenes in the beef than just Sympathy is a Knife. The way she delivers "no man has ever loved me like you do" really implies woman. That said, I think the song is to all the haters. Like think of how much time snark groups spend on her

Jh

I fear it is about Blake because…. I’m sorry I can’t unsee what I see about that legal drama. I don’t think she actually loves Blake anymore, I think she’s sort of neutral about Blake, but doesn’t think she deserves to be cancelled. But I also don’t want it to be about someone who supports the things going on with this government……. The song itself is whatever to me.

Jh

I’m sorry but I love the wood lyrics

Griffin

It's def Scott B. She starts from his perspective, speaking to her, but then in the Bridge and final verse she's taking control and using his words back at him because she came out of the fight on top "turns out, my Dicks bigger". Scott is Italian. Half this song is mob boss references. "I protect the family", "sleeping with the fishes", etc. Scott said in interviews early on that he saw potential in her. Deal with the devil => selling to scooter This love is pure profit => betrayed her for money, what she thought was family was actually greed All I ask is loyalty => he expected her to say with Big Machine despite giving her zero compromise in negotiations I'll draw your tears with my sleeve => taylor has mentioned that the worst part of Scott's betrayal was he had comdorted her when she was crying over stuff scooter had done to her before "You had to get rid of me" => he tried to ruin her career after she spoke up Who's pictures on the mantle => her picture all over Big Machine offices The Empire Belongs to Me => rerecords, taking back ownership of all her work And even more but this is already a novel

Ada

She says you live me better than any man could and talks about writing a song about her so I think it really is about Charlie or at least another female musician

Courtney Camden

I think it implies she’s never been in a couple where they’re both at the top of their games at the same time? Not totally sure, either

Jh

I love this album. I think some of the negative critiques spewed out like we all agree and that their perspective is objective truth is just crazy. This is album has touched me more than any previous ones. I just sobbed to wishlist in my car. Also, Wood makes me LOL and want to dance. I need to see more support for Wood from the grown ass women tbh

Inés

Yess!! I love to see other people's opinions <3

Natalie Topalian

For what it’s worth 😊 in case anyone is interested in a solid discussion!

Megan

I think wood is interesting because it seems to be indulgent for her to embrace this kind of exhibitionist kink they both must have? I can't help but think that she wants us to think about them having sex.

Jasmine

I feel better already with this and only through song #1, thank you 🙏🫶

Jess Angus

I had the same thought, sounded like Abigail called while she was on tour and then she flew home? I think I thought that because I associated TLOAS with the last two years on the Era’s Tour, but it’s not just the last two years, it’s her whole life, and now (and especially on tour when the boisterous crowd is gone and she’s left in the bath in the silence) she ruminates about the what ifs and the regrets, so that’s why I now do think this is fully Forever Winter for the story and the feelings about it a Forever unresolved. She’s stuck in Forever Winter and she doesn’t want anyone else to be.

Jess Angus

What does she replace thighs with in the clean version?

Bacall N McElroy

I know that’s not true 😭 but for real though punching up is brave punching down is cowardly. I don’t think it was called for to respond to this if she’s not brave enough to clap back at her actual biggest hater

RiskBat

The vibe of this album to me: This is Taylor's 1st rage bait album Father Figure gets you excited for camaraderie, turns out it's a 'put you in your place' gag Wood is satirical not really sexy Ruin the Friendship cute highschool song turns into pro-cheating sad you're dead lil diddy Cancel pro bad behavior as long as you're good at it Even just convincing us it was a showgirl album was A TROLL She got happy. Realized we've been feeding off her misery. Now she wants to feed on ours. She's intentionally not giving us the complex female character.

Roisin Shy

You may prefer the clean version of wood

Magenta

It’s like she’s massively overcompensating for all the comments saying that Travis must be upset for only “getting” So High School and (possibly/partially) Alchemy on TTPD.

Bacall N McElroy

Regardless of if you think that Blake lively is a talented actress or you think that she has a good sense of style or you think that she’s rude. The fact of the case are her boss add sex scenes into the movie that weren’t in the script, added topless scenes that weren’t in the script, asked her about her sex life etc. her being cancelled was outrageous 😔

S M S B

Fourth listen today. And it's clicking more. I had to drop the entire image of a showgirl and let that go. And just listen. Isn't music crazy? Taking it all in is a process. Being invested in someone so deeply that you've loved since before it was cool to love her is so exhausting. A roller coaster! And I love the roller coaster!

phoenix

That was my initial (still kinda) impression -- like she's talking as if she's a Madame (respectfully!!) and so it's not just for the "new girls" but also her mans, like boss bitch dominatrix mob wife vibes, I feel like even though it's much different, it exists from the same kind of place Cancelled is

Griffin

Two lines in particular make it undeniably about Blake to me. 1) tone-deaf and hot, let's off her. That clearly references the lawsuit and the exact criticism Baldoni used to try to take her down with the planted stories. 2) Poison thorny flowers. The role in It Ends With Us that is involved in the cancellation and lawsuit is a florist named Lily Bloom, and flowers are a huge aesthetic and theme of the movie. Every video people use of Blake in her cancellation are of her surrounded by or covered in flowers.

phoenix

Actually Romantic is also funny if you hypothesize it being to the rat 🐀 (it could be both, either way it's one of the wildest things I ever heard ---- til I heard Wood and Cancelled, that is lol)

Mary

I really like it too, it’s ok for people to have different takes on it, maybe they had different expectations too

Zoe Cane

Opalite & Ruin The Friendship & Honey are my top 3 so far. Ruin The Friendship feels like a better track 5.

Griffin

People do this every single taylor album. They'll change their mind in a few weeks

phoenix

I thought of this whole album in such a strange world; kind of like Burlesque -- on and off stage. Played out like a movie.. that's another reason why Wood, while as crude and off putting and jarring -- it's like a Cabernet!

Ada

Thank god

lindsey koetze

Am I the only one who feels so sad about the hate already! Like I loved actually romantic but the amount of hate comments I've seen in literally a day have gotten me so down. I freaking love this album and usually the POP albums are my least favourite. Will be avoiding social media for now.. Snakes, I applaud you guys for being so brave to post this because the amount of hate you guys recieve would do me in. Ly<3

Amanda

I like listening to the first four songs and then it falls off for me….🥲

Griffin

Girl publish a book. This description is perfect

splendidvie

You know it's bad, if some of the "clean" versions are better than the explicit ones. Also, i thought we all agreed on not calling women "bitches" anymore. WHY?

phoenix

All in all though, I think the thing that makes me most fulfilled about this album is the fact that Taylor is a theatre kid and has been begging for her theatre moment probably for her whole life; but as the reigning pop star of all time, she's never quite been able to do that - and when she does, people are like "wow, weird, Taylor you're just not Broadway you're 4 on the floor or ballads; stay in your lane"... And so throughout this whole thing you can TELL when she's just grinning ear to ear, saying audacious shit and almost feel her go like 😲🤭.. she knows she is talking and singing some wild shit but even if you aren't vibing with it, you can't deny that her fun and enjoyment is TANGIBLE

Griffin

It's basically a fun sex song like Sabrina makes. Let the girl have fun

phoenix

Thank you 😭😭😭 that's such a compliment. I'm glad I wasn't the only one with that little movie scene playing out!!!

Laura E

Sabrina’s vocal is so goood

Archie

The life leaving your eyes when you realized what wood was 😂😂😂😩

Griffin

I did this almost every song and restarted each halfway through 🤣

Artenchanted

I laughed so hard at your reaction of Wood... You started bopping happily and I knew what was coming and the sudden change of your face and stop in your tracks movement did not disappoint ;D Thanks for the reaction. I missed the live stream you did after so I am hoping you'll upload it at some stage.

Griffin

I think in two weeks we will all change our minds on this one

Griffin

This song will age worse than any other song of hers ever, and that's sad because the sentiment is powerful

Griffin

And I screamed and applauded and played it again.

Griffin

Give everyone two weeks, they'll come around.

Archie

Everybody was effing boring at my cinema too. This new generation is so scared of being cringe they could never know fun

Michelle Smith

What is your thought about eldest daughter being Taylor talking to a younger part of herself from the perspective of the protector who has had to be “bad bitch and savage” ??

Griffin

How are we having completely opposite thoughts on the levels of writing

Griffin

Please, you applauded Sabrina for making a dozen of these songs

Valentin Bellegarde

The lukewarm reception to this album made me realise a glaring contradiction in the run-up to its release. Taylor said she went into it wanting to make “bulletproof pop.” But she also said that she and max martin (and shellback) went into it as “equals.” But the gag is that you’re not an “equal” to max martin when it comes to “bulletproof pop.” He has no equal in that regard. So what did that equality look like in the studio?

Aimee

🤣

m

siak is deeeefinitely more nuanced. taylor took it at face value lol

Linde Deckers

I’m literally CRYINGGG with laughter at Zack in his headdress being quieted by the Wood lyrics

m

the first verse of title track immediately made me think of britney. there’s that olllld picture of taylor as a child with britney from the early 2000s, not to mention britney kinda rhymes with kitty. i mean it’s obviously more about the experience than anyone in particular, but yk

Becca Gilgan

I agree!! I instantly liked it more! Much less forced with the adjusted lyric.

Kd235481

Actually romantic to everything is romantic is crazy

Morgen Clay

I'd genuinely love to see Madeline explain Eldest Daughter to you. It really hits the wounds of being a b*tch when you're younger and growing into a nurturing/maternal role within your family. Like yes I am that bitch but you and I know I'm really thoughtful and loyal beyond reason and sometimes even unwillingly. Never gonna let you down, never gonna leave you out. It isn't savage it's just love.

m

"When you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras”

Roisin Shy

Will check that out thanks!

V

Oh this is such a good take. I hadn’t even thought of that but it’s so true. And I’m a Swede! So yessss max Martin is like the only one who can do his whole max martin thing.. Also Taylor is so young compared to max, like she was a child when he wrote Britney’s hits etc and defined an era of music, so someone as young as Taylor obviously can’t be his equal etc bc he’s an older master of his craft

Kylee

Ok but quick notes- HOT TAKE (actually fuck that, I knew the assignment as soon as I saw the first cover), we have a visual album of the highest order: Wildest Dreams Taylor, who was really just Taylor doing Elizabeth in the stage ropes? I’m surprised I made it out of there alive. I witnessed what was behind the stone once they rolled it away, you don’t come back from that shit, everything has changed. The Eldest Daughter bodysuit? Stop it. She knew she had to do something to distract us from that one, such showgirl behavior. Oh ya, forget dickmitized because ohhhh girls, does she come for Charli. Hard. Can’t forget to throw some scraps at Aimee with the who wore Marilyn better behavior. Kim could NEVER, obviously.

Miss_Lippy

“Normal people will think this is fun” Well, yes! But lately the Patreon feels like it has been invaded by Swiftly Neutral 😫

Juby

I LOVE eldest daughter lol heals something in me

diya

what else did he say on the patreon space? can’t believe I was too busy working to catch it. never doing that again. (also you’re cooking)

ryan

this might be the first time my claimed song is my favorite 😭 father figure was so fucking great

nevo

the feather headdress is giving napoleon

Sheridan S

Wi$h List and Actually Romantic might be my favourites 🙈

VictoriaReadsss

Yall the music video was perfect in my eye I gear

Vikki

Skies

diya

at least in my feed all the hate has been about the bad writing, embarrassing diss track and travis penis mentions (which are all valid)

Charlotte

the writing isn’t her best, the travis penis mentions are so completely gross and unnecessary but the charli diss.. idc about that, she could’ve said worse tbh. most hate ive been seeing isn’t even about the lyrics it’s about the charli ‘shade’ and how she’s an evil billionaire which, to me, is not valid criticism for an album.

diya

send him a pic and get it over with. why do we have to deal with it

OneRainyWish_Again

I’m really looking forward to hearing your full analysis of this album. I agree with you that it has some good songs but I’m not hearing a great 24 karat Taylor Swift song here, not yet. Opalite is my favorite so far, I love the 60s sound in the melody. Ruin the Friendship gave me chills a little bit, but I need to listen to it some more Edit: Does Taylor just not have much to say about Travis?? And that’s why Ruin the Friendship is standing out lyrically, bc it’s not about him? Not a Travis hater btw, he’s cute and fun afaik. But, it seems like all Taylor says about him is “He’s hot and nice”… and I love happy love songs, like “hey Stephen” and “fearless”, those have incredible lyrics and melodies! So I know she can create amazing happy love songs, but these are lowkey not it

diya

TTPD was the same (maybe worse?)

Jose Dominguez

I just came back from watching the film and I do have to say that the music video it’s one of her best of all time ITS SO GOOD SHE ATEE and also the songs for some reasons are clicking and now I’m definitely thinking more positive abt the album and I’m so happy I got to really understand her vision, so I’d recommend if you have the opportunity to watch the film cause for me it kinda helped me to fully get a big grasp into the album!! It’s not 1989 pt2 but it’s such A GOOD album, I love it even more with every listen!

diya

that is one of the greatest lines ever written and. taylor’s is one of the worst. taylor’s went to wattpad school of sex description

Ally ❤️

For Wood and Father Figure, for the first time in my life, I subbed the clean versions… I cannot with dicks and dick-matizing around every corner.

Ally ❤️

My fondest desire is that she works with Max on her next project.

diya

zach said that 2 songs in and has since changed his mind

Maya Reads

Im sure its been said but she is not saying dickmatized. 😂 close enough

Ally ❤️

It was opposite for me first listen… but it’s a grower. I think it’s no skips with a few clean version subs. I made a playlist, so I’m happy 🤷‍♀️

Griffin

To me it's so bad that it's camp. It's Travis's london boy.

diya

I was hoping for less penis and more introspection

diya

may that kind of dickmatizism never find me

Abby

I think it could also be her ruminating post-Matty on if she still wanted (at her big age) to be the girl who asks and answers the questions she has about love. She worked through it a bit on TTPD “should’ve let it stay buried” and I think this song is her decision that she regrets not answering these questions and the not knowing more than the pain and heartbreak and embarrassment.

Aaron

Not to sound like a joe widow dog whistler but this album made me miss a certain taylor in a way i havent missed her in a long time :(

Maya Reads

Not me being a travis defender xD he said Cancelled was a banger no reaction to wood. And the week after said his favorite was Opalite ;)

OneRainyWish_Again

Same, the “we’ll never know why” lyric got me 💔

JD IHateItHere

You read my deranged, desperate, serpentine mind. The Bone Collector and Lizard must feed us.

diya

I’m trying to imagine it and Sabrina would definitely use a more humorous/mocking tone and also probably do less dick jokes (crazy)

Funky3079

idk if anyone else has brought this up,,,, but i’m seeing a vision of ‘Ruin the Friendship’ and ‘Question…?’ being sister songs,,,,,,, 👁️👁️

JD IHateItHere

Showgirl in the tub with tea and her vibrator.

diya

ok but to the Kendrick and Drake analogy, Kendrick was cooking on WHY he didn’t fuck w Drake. Maybe there was BTS stuff between Taylor and Charli but taylor didn’t really mention that outside ‘boring barbie’. If sympathy and ‘boring Barbie’ is the fuel this seems like overly cruel and punching down. Even when charli was up with Brat summmer let’s not forget Taylor was on Eras. She will always be punching down

Drew Rosen

Ur right and u should say that

Deli

This is so interesting because the last undeniably good album was folklore(maybe evermore too). She’s disappointed me with every album since. I don’t know where the writing has gone. She has impeccable moments on each record but what happened to the days where almost every song was good? 1989? I thought this album would be great and the writing would be perfect.

Gigi

noooo

diya

to me it’s a less powerful clara bow

Deli

It’s interesting to think that endgame is kind of where she lost the plot. Her first truly inauthentic and bad song. Since then we’ve had so many misses. I don’t know if she can return to the writing of red or speak now ever.

Bell

I’ve been a Taylor fan since 2008. That being said, despite her appearance of self awarness in the New Heights podcast when she said actually I’m not the center of the world, her world view is still terribly miopic. You were cancelled we get it. Doesnt mean you have to die on the sword of everyone who’s been called out blindly (lena dunham, brittnay mahomes). And as I remember she didn’t love being called “that bitch” in 2016. I get it’s 9 years later, but fuck, the amount of calling people bitches in this album leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Music does not exist in a vacuum and she has to know about the wave of conservatism, trad wives, right? Or maybe she doesn’t. “I want the whole block looking like you.” Come on. SELF. AWARNESS. I hope she takes a long break, reads a book, gets someone to do a cringe test on her new music. Some lyrics were just really aggregous. “I’m not a bad bitch, this isn’t savage,” “we looked fire.” Oh God. THAT BEING SAID. Opalite? Going #1 in my house.

JD IHateItHere

I felt the same about n the aftermath of Reputation and Tortured Poets. You’re not crazy. There is awkward. There is leaning into deranged. There is Yes, and????

Deli

I had this EXACT thought. She used the word bitch wayyy too much, it was lazy writing. And yes calling women “bitches” is lowkey a mild slur. It’s also not very tasteful or glamorous. I wish she could expand her vocabulary lol

diya

this made me spit out my diet coke thanks

Kayla

Tomorrow I think! (JK NOW!)

Deli

The clean version of eldest daughter is so much better bc it says baddest instead of bad bitch. And ditto, bitch was being thrown around everywhere. Swear words need to be used tastefully… and YES yhe misogyny was off putting

Deli

This is genius

diya

agree on almost everything. FOO forever

Myra

The main commentary I keep seeing about this album is, “It isn’t showgirl,” but it was never supposed to be. The problem is that the visuals contradicted the album’s thesis. It was supposed to be a peek behind the curtain/after the show, but all the visuals gave us showgirl. As a longtime fan and student of her work/psyche, I understand that the visuals were a projection of the confidence and sexiness she has gained by being with Travis. To me, it comes off as a private boudoir shoot made public, and unfortunately, that set up certain expectations for the sound associated with this album. People feel let down because the songs don’t match the imagery. I get it, but I also get Taylor, so I don’t feel let down. I really love this album and all the love and joy that emanate from it! ❤️‍🔥

Rachel Kottkamp

Yes wish she would have kept it on the shelf til she could have done a full showgirl genre but oh well lol

Moonbeam009

Yours and Madeline's opinions are the only ones I care to hear from. 🫶

Hilde

30000%

Hilde

You’re the real showgirl for pulling back after that massive pause that wood gave you and coming back to us and delivering. You showgirled through.

Jaspreet Kaur

I actually can't stop listening to it!!

Laura Harvey

It’s really not what I expected based on the imagery and the podcast but I do like it. But I got caught off guard and it took a second to regroup

Abby

I think the SIAK of it all is is not the reason we got Actually Romantic but between the two the production on AR is miles above SIAK. Not saying both songs aren’t good, they are not the same kind of song so hard to compare.

Taylor Chapiesky

I still cannot comprehend the fact that that song exists like even after hearing it played in the theater I still just can't

Neeni M

im sorry but having a bunch of kids is not an inherently conservative thing, and it's not a trad wife thing either taylor will never ever be a trad wife, she simply cannot be. i don't like this discourse that conflates getting married or having a family with conservatism. it is a very normal thing to want and do

X

in cancelled, taylor is talking very specifically about blake lively. every line in the chorus is a blake lively reference. maga didn't stand by her when she was being cancelled, they were literally perpetrators of her cancellation.

cj johnson

the disappointed look at the camera in the showgirl headdress is meme material

Neeni M

god i can't stand that sub, they like to pretend they're not just a snark sub in sheep's clothing

Kalyn

I felt that a bit, too

Kalyn

Was gonna comment this!

clove

“People don’t need to bubble wrap me in their minds as much as they do… I’m a pretty tough broad” -Taylor Swift, 2025. No one having opinions on the music she released is preventing her from having fun.

Sparkles

The clean version of wood is perfect. It takes out all the cringe and it’s just the right amount of dirty

Tiffany

Next time I'm having a really bad day or feeling depressed, I'm just gonna come back and watch you listening to Wood. 😂😂

karen

I know it's supposed to remind me of Jackson 5, but the chorus has a very similar tone to Lily's "Fuck You" haha

Cassandra Blalock

Well, Wood is an egregious crime against humanity so 🤷‍♀️…that’s my only skip tho

Bell

cancelled is def about Blake, I agree, but it’s the underlying belief of anyone who’s been publicly chastised is a friend of mine because of what happened to me. It’s back to that me, me, me, I, I, I.

Bell

“they want that complex female character, I just want you, have a couple kids have the whole block looking like you.” Cmon now. “playing house.” And you’re right. Taylor could never actually be a trad wife. That’s the point. It’s like the tiktokers who are getting paid bank to be promoting that lifestyle who are financially empowered and independent telling other women not to be. It’s irresponsible and just shows that this glass tower she’s built where she doesnmt hear anything negitive creates an echo chamber where she’s surrounded by yes men.

Bell

completely agree. After folklore, everything’s been a derivitive of what she’s done before. Mifnights being a 1989xreputation, Tortured Poets being like a folklorexRED, I just don’t quite understand what happened. Like she’s been replaced by a podperson.

X

max martin snuck crack in this album because why does it sound better tonight than it did this morning?

X

maybe i'm crazy but i think this might be reputation tv

No Thoughts

God bless you, I don't think I will ever get there with that song.

Neeni M

"you're only as hot as your last hit, baby" is her mimicking the way the music industry treats people based on their relevance

Neeni M

i can't seem to find it on Spotify. is on YouTube or anything like that?

Natalie Topalian

Yes just YT for now! It will probably be uploaded to podcast platforms tomorrow

karen

actually the song is called Him

Rose Lebeau

Father figure felt like brochetta tea to me

Paul Espinal

zach are you uploading your last live? i missed it😔

Amber

Zach I'll totally send you my crappy phone recording of the music video because it GOES HARD

John Butler

I really liked it. Comparing albums to 1989, Folkerlore and TTPD is always going to leave you disappointed. She hit a double off the wall, and not a home run, but its still solid contact. Maybe I'm crazy reading some of the other comments, but it'll be on in the car for a long time. I wish she had left wood off the album.

A.N. Chaney

“Wood” is the meanest thing Taylor’s ever said about any of her exes

peri

With the damn headdress on too 😂😂

peri

Yessss plsss I was showgirling at work and couldn’t tune in live

Ry

He said he wouldn’t. He was just talking about some of his mixed feelings about the album. Biggest takeaway was there is now “great” Taylor Swift song on the album.

Ry

It definitely has gotten better after every listen for me.

ccynthesyzer

After watching the film… your takes on FF are not off 👀 FYI

Kim

Yes!!! Laughing though father figure reaction, We love the turkey roasting though lol

Kim

THANK YOU!!!!

Anna E

100% agree with you, I feel exactly the same!

Anna E

It just keeps getting worse for me with every listen too 😭

Brittany Hogue

all i could think was "thank God they got engaged before this album dropped" because otherwise I would have been like girl, you've lost your damn mind. AGAIN. Lol. Now that he feels more "end game" then just "another random boyfriend she has gone cookoo over" it helped with the overall vibe 🙃 lol

Karen Valentino

My own personal weirdness is that first listens are kind of jarring, second listens I’m already recognizing the music and some of the lyrics and have settled into the experience. I love the album. I love that not all of the lyrics are obvious. I love that I feel little hints of music from now and from decades ago. I think Wood is hilarious and that Taylor must’ve had so much fun coming up with euphemisms.

Teresa Johnston

Ok. I just thought of something and I think it might be insane, but it does feel weird to me that so many songs reference other artists pretty obviously: Father Figure is a George Michael reference, Wood sounds like the Jackson Five, Life of a Showgirl sounds like the Jonas Brothers song...is she saying that George Michael, Michael Jackson, The Jonas Brothers = showgirls. Like in a complimentary way. Are there other references that I am missing?

Alyssa (originalparafan)

Dude she seems so in love, taken care of and safe in her current relationship. Really sweet things said in this album about the football dude. Hey, I’m super happy if football dude is taking care of our girl! We just want to see the Queen happy and safe!

Britanii

Showgirlologist slaying as per usual. LMAOOOO on Wood.

PandoraNicole

That's a hilarious way to look at it

Emily Vocatura

the interesting part of that is none of them are showgirls they are show boys/men So hmmmm

PandoraNicole

Right when he said he feels like a damn fool in the headdress I was laughing so hard and then my elderly neighbor called me to ask me a question about Facebook. I'm basically her tech support, and she asked me what I was laughing so hard about as I answered the phone and I said I couldn't possibly explain it to her LOL

PandoraNicole

Yeah I never heard him say anything about Wood. I've heard him say several times that Opalite was his favorite song and that Cancelled was a banger that's it

Chas

Love this story!

Chas

This!!

Britanii

Also Elizabeth Taylor is SO good! It might be my favorite on the album.

Chas

💯 worth the price of admission

Chas

I would die 🫶

Brittany Hogue

Actually Romantic might be my favorite track. It is Speak Now/Rep, cunty Taylor at her absolute best 😅😅😅

Chas

Honey is what Lover wanted to be SILENCED me because yes

Pearl Dennis

The "complex female character" is in the same section with all of the other film references. She's taking about actresses wanting to play complex female characters as a goal. She's listing off things through this song that people want and specifically says that it's great that that's what they want and that they should get what they want, but all she wants at this point is him and a life together. There's no "trad wife" or misogyny in this concept. Being in love, getting married, and having kids is not just for conservatives and doesn't equal trad wife.

Anna

I watched the film and I thought what she said made it clear it was Scott? Minor spoiler: She talks about how she can see herself being both the protege and mentor and how the song is about power

Lizel

They showed a clean version of the film though. It was insane! People caught on and they were screaming the curse words and dirty words out loud 😳😂

Chas

💯

Nancy P

That is such a good way to put it! It’s actually very showgirl to create stunning visuals but really there’s all these contradicting feelings and events going on once the curtain comes down. Like that feeling after you take a picture and smile starts to fade.

X

on first listen i was most surprised that i couldn't here max martin's melodic math anywhere. i was like "did he even show up for work?" but listening again tonight, it's there. hiding in plain sight. this album is addictive.

Nancy P

Right?! It changed me too 😅

Alyssa (originalparafan)

Zach you’re so gorgeous as per usual. Wear the black feathery black swan head piece regularly, thank youuuuuuu!

Lynn

I gotta admit. I'm loving this album so far...

Lynn

Although not really sure I like the calab with sabrina 🤔

Courtney Adams

Am I the only one who thought “Cancelled” was about Ariana Grande?

Miss_Lippy

Pearl, THANK YOU!!! I feel like I’m going insane with some of these knee jerk bizarre reactions to this album and song in particular that feel almost hyperbolic. Equating this with MAGA/trad wife type stuff is so laughable to me because I’m like “Have y’all met any actual MAGA types?? Or do you just not have the misfortune of having trumper relatives??” These people unanimously HATE Taylor lmao The same Taylor who endorsed Harris and gets regularly targeted by their orange idol online?? Make it make sense! And misogynistic?? What?! Where?! 🙄 And yes, let’s equate a grown MAN who publicly humiliated a teenager on the world stage and then put “her” naked in bed with him in a mv while also calling her a bitch who needed him to get famous in a song, under the guise of extending her an olive branch, only to turn around, say “Psych!” & then further humiliate her because sure, that is the *exact* same thing as a woman referring to people who said they hope she dies and fucked with her “bitches” 🙄. Well done I guess because that leap took some serious mental gymnastics -either that or a whole lot of personal projection 😆

Lynn

So true. I did this too.

VK

The chorus of CANCELLED is a lot like the chorus of YELLOW FLICKER BEAT by LORDE

VK

The Fate of Ophela is good but it sounds a lot like something that might have come up on random in my Spotify. A lot of the melody of most of the songs is a little generic and is missing the Taylor stamp

Leslie

I would really like to know this

Luiza Lodder

agreed 100%. Also, AR sounds incredibly like Where is my mind by pixies, which is a great song to interpolate (even if uncredited lol) bc the chord progression is just so good, but it also makes me think sonically AR is a bit derivative.

Leslie

I thought the same thing. People are assuming the Forever Winter guy because he's the only high school friend we know of that died, but that was years ago, plus I think they were still close and not fallen out of touch like the song says. I think it's likely something happened while she was on tour that we don't know about (nor should we ofc)

Leslie

I need "I feel like a fool in my headdress"

Erin

Thank you for your reaction to Wood. I was silenced in the SAME way, but my friends love it and I was really questioning reality for a second there 😭

EN

Shook that Zack actually liked this....

Laura Harvey

“Against my better judgment I have to bang”

Maeva

If you like the melody, beat & sound of "wood" try listening to the clean version, someone mentioned it and it's pretty good, without the weird words

Miss_Lippy

“You’re only as hot as your last hit, baby” -the music industry, general public speaking to the artist. It kinda implies that they are viewed in a way where their value as a person is tied to the reception of their art by the industry or the masses & that they’re ultimately deemed irrelevant or expendable. “Been number one but never had a number two” = I’ve had lots of number one hits in my career but I’ve never had a true companion in my love life who wanted an actual real partnership with me before.

Kris Knutson

Listen to the clean version. Still some innuendo, but his redwood tree takes her to new heights by opening up [the] skies.

Mae Osbourn

I adore how in father figure the refrain ‘leave it with me’ shifts from a comforting, supportive statement to an assertion of dominance

Lynn

How sad I disnt like track 5 *sad face*

Lynn

If Taylor is a boring barbie I be one any day of the week. Boring barbie my arse 😆

DrEmily

Wait wait wait… is Jeff Lang the guy in You Belong With Me? Is that what Ruin the Friendship is saying?!?! Is that just me?

Hannah Ramirez

The moment you’re bopping to Wood and then you hear the word dickmatize 💀💀💀 SAME

DrEmily

Try the “clean” version. Heard it in the movie. Much better. Makes it cute and tongue in cheek. Should have been the only version for this song. Actually, all the clean versions were solid and didn’t detract (except maybe lessen the gag of Father Figure). Some were marked improvements.

Hannah Ramirez

Hearing wood for a second time now. It might be the worst song she’s written. It’s so clunky. And saying New Heights. Umm okay lol. PMO 😂😂😂

DrEmily

Could be, just didn’t think they were more than friendly

Lynn

Omg... wood all about Travd dick... jeez Louise lmfao 0 Knock on wood haha.

Riya

I joined the patreon just to watch this reaction video and you did not disappoint!

Miss_Lippy

I can’t take him seriously when he's saying Taylor is to music what McDonalds is to food ffs. Or if he doesn’t see the irony in saying he hasn’t been a fan of Taylor since Rep era -while he’s doing a whole ass deep dive pontification on TikTok solely about a Taylor album that literally just dropped less than 24 hours ago 😆 Sure, Jan. If that’s not a fan then it’s a professional hater lol

DrEmily

There must have been some CXCX behaviors going on I didn’t even know. My friend showed me some tasteless photo with her mimicking being a casualty victim with bloody friendship bracelet on a severed hand from August 2024. It caused outrage since it was released around the time of UK stabbings in Southport at the Taylor-themed kids dance class and the cancelled Vienna dates from terror threat. At the time, fans had defended it as a clue they were doing a collab. All this in the middle of writing TLOAS. Probably the straw that broke the camel’s back.

Miss_Lippy

This is an interesting take and now I want to relisten to the podcast too

Flavia Mancini

i actually love your interpretation of father figure! i know its not technically the "correct" one but its really fun to think of it in that way

Aly

I do like the majority of this album, but I will say that the overall problem I'm seeing is that the album rollout and promotion being JUST the NH Podcast interview and album variant releases led to the fanbase really blowing the idea of a 'Showgirl' theme out of proportion. The interview made it abundantly clear MULTIPLE TIMES that the theme was the life of Taylor Swift after the show ends and it being mostly "I love Travis" is, in fact, on the theme of after the Showgirl closes the curtain. But the photoshoot that we got drip-fed led heavily into the aesthetic of the Showgirl (because I think Taylor really just liked the aesthetic) and that muddied the waters. I also don't think Taylor ever actually marketed the album as 'bulletproof pop' or 'like 1989' (unless there was other marketing besides the NH podcast that I don't remember) but she did shoutout that the lyrics would be of Folklore quality and be vivid, crisp, focused, and intentional. And on most of the songs, I would agree with that (Eldest Daughter is not in that category).

rachel☁️

Actually romantic is egregious

rachel☁️

So many humiliating songs omfg I can't believe she thinks she ate. AR and Wood need to be scrubbed from existence entirely. The people are HATING IT on TikTok. AR looks so embarrassing. The writing on this album is just plain bad, I cannot believe the general public is consuming this

rachel☁️

True I disagree with the McDonald's comment

rachel☁️

Worst ever, if literally rather listen to thank you Aimee

Meli

I really liked his interpretation too! I thought it was cool because it actually lowkey fits haha

rachel☁️

Help someone said the album is giving Katy Perry BYE

Vikki

I felt like that too. I wondered if she'd mixed a few different situations into Ruin the Friendship to conceal the presence of 🐀

stfu.liamb

I’m from planet swiftie, and with Travis on this one; absolute bangers.

trelew1972

Ruin the friendship is about Jeff Lang, her high school friend who died from an overdose at age 21. She also wrote the painfully beautiful Forever winter about him. In 2010 when she won the BMI country award she dedicated it to him bc he had died that same week. The fact she's writing another song about him 15 years after he died, imo, it means his life and death had a big impact in her life.

DrEmily

My friend showed me a NY Magazine cover feature of Charli where Taylor was obviously asked to comment in middle of Sympathy “speculation”. She provides a quote, heaping praise on CXCX talent, but there is no corresponding positivity, just a vague statement that people are going to think what they want. The same magazine has some tasteless photo with CXCX posing as a casualty victim with a severed hand wearing a bloody friendship bracelet. This was August 2024 and caused outrage in Europe (probably farther) since it was released around the time of UK stabbings in Southport at the Taylor-themed kids dance class and the cancelled Vienna dates from terror threat. There was an attempt to downplay it as a sign that it foreshadowed a peace/collab like what happened with Lorde, but obviously not. It was one of several articles from that summer and Charli never said a positive word about Taylor. Charli was someone Taylor had admired and promoted, and thought of as a friend, but she dissed her practically everywhere. And Brat was riding high. All while TLOAS was being written and recorded. It probably felt less like punching down at the time. Sympathy implies Taylor as the bully, and AR says Taylor thinks Charli’s “obsession” with her is cute. Sounds like a kind of diss war to me. I agree that it’s going to stir up the stans, which is unfortunate. Especially if all they know is Sympathy…

DrEmily

Yes! Rocks as a sly tongue in cheek allusion

DrEmily

Elizabeth Taylor also had a habit of dating and marrying lots of men. Tragic loss of early love (which now we have Ruin the Friendship parallel). Even habit of returning to try again with someone - I wanna say Ratty, but the Burton may very well be Turkey since we now know they had at least one big break before the end- Jack revealing You’re Losing Me as first song recorded for Midnights, a year before official breakup, is actually insane.

Lynn

Same. Thanks. Gonna try the clean version x

DrEmily

Movie helped me with ones I was still processing. I thoroughly enjoyed it

DrEmily

I agree with diya - the clean version sounds more subtle and sly, more Sabrina Which is wild

Swiftologist

Girl I know this I talked about it in the video

DrEmily

Makes me realize Jeff Lang was the guy in You Belong With Me. Unrequited first love. No wonder his death hit her so hard. Sad And Tayhaters are trying to say she is telling girls to be home wreckers or sluts and just kiss every guy in high school so you don’t live with regrets. Hope sanity finds them someday (or stops Fantano from talking)

DrEmily

Taylor says in movie that it’s about power dynamics with someone who helped her in beginning, and how that changed and the POV changes in the song. I wish she was clearer on that - or even had some sort of signal in lyric video.

Emma

Initial thoughts - I listened and felt like I’d heard a few of the songs before. It drove me mad. So I figured it out lol Ruin the friendship - Bill Withers “lovely day” Opalite - Post Malone “Circles” Wood - Jackson 5 “I want you back”

DrEmily

I thought the family were the original masters

DrEmily

I realized after it started that it was showgirl who is off duty- really should be called Midnights part 2. Definitely improved with repeat listen. And Wood is much more sly and fun if you listen to the clean version - explicit was too startling

DrEmily

I’m calling it Midnight part 2: TLOAS

Aly

I really want to know what part of the Eras Tour European Leg made her reflect on this 15-years-past moment. Everything else on the album was current-timeline inspired (Travis/Scott/Charli/Eras Tour Showgirl Fiction) so what led to this song while making the album.

DrEmily

She may have even planned to sing it at Vienna. It would have been written/recorded around then. She may have even hid that cancelled weekend I Sweden with Max. I now wonder if she didn’t sing those songs, the way she didn’t wear the infamously missing 1989 green green and green yellow costumes…

DrEmily

You ok? Hope uou didn’t feel too terrorized for your opinion. Sorry you felt something was homophobic. Maybe repeat listen or other’s interpretation will ring truer for you. I’d be happy to share my take. But i could easily be way off. Or you can skip it. Whatever works for you.

DrEmily

Clean version

DrEmily

Just wait for the video

Ash

I love how the song life of a showgirl starts with the humble beginnings of the narrator and mimics that with both lyrics and production, then slowly gets more lyrically complex and sonically sounds more showgirl-y. The production is telling the same story of building into a showgirl as the lyrics. This one is definitely growing on me!

Aif

10000%

Ash

I love this take! I wish the visuals had been Taylor dressed as a showgirl doing mundane things or the kind of dorky vibe like in the Target ad instead of just I’m a hot, sexy showgirl. It was misleading.

Sara

I have a theory that Taylor is very deliberately adding these raunchier lyrics (including full Wood) as the first stage to a more adult era coming. Say the younger fans who came on board were ~10 when the re-recordings started in 2020. So now they are 15. In a few years they are young adults, and I bet Taylor is not counting on getting one more generation on board in a few years but rather catering to these fans and us "adult nostalgics" in the upcoming eras. I'm calling a Miley Bangerz type era coming as one of the two next eras with a lead single equivalent of something like WAP from Cardi B 👀

Ashley C

idk probably an anniversary of death

Ashley C

thank god. I felt like I was going insane for almost a full 24 hrs until I saw Madeline's reaction

Jose Dominguez

Same 😅 I’m hoping zach can experience the film

Anuradha Srinivasan

Same! I enjoyed it in the movie, actually I like all the clean versions better.

Maya

The production is very showgirl-y 80s/90s vibes but most of the lyrics not so much... its confusing to me. The music and production is so good though

Anuradha Srinivasan

Can you feel the comments being invaded as we speak? Just pretending to agree to Zach and Madeline but spewing hate in the process?

D.D.

I was wondering about this because of the Wicked references in the lyrics!! Something wicked, popular, poison flowers, etc. But it also confused me because why would it be about Ariana?

SwiftieMoonie

Omgggg thank you! I couldn’t figure it out.

Maya

Wait what is the real meaning of father figure, I thought his interpretation made sense? At first I thought it was Olivia (before I noticed the pronoun he) but now I'm really confused, what other male has she mentored?

Miss_Lippy

Now that’s it’s percolated a bit and I’ve seen so much backlash, here specifically, I have some thoughts: 1) If TTPD was “Am I allowed to cry?” then TLOASG is “Am I allowed to laugh?” 2) Taylor really can’t win because with TTPD they said it’s too wordy, it’s too intellectual, it’s too sad/dark, it’s too long, it’s too serious, no more Jack. So then she releases this more light playful album and it’s “Too short, bad writing, boo to happy goofy Taylor, we hate confident cheeky Taylor, she’s tone deaf and even the more bizarre and unhinged takes of Taylor MAGA, Taylor right wing zealot, Taylor racist, Taylor trad wife. I can’t help but think that some of them are just angry or sad individuals who truly prefer an insecure depressed lonely tortured Taylor because misery loves company. Either that or they are bitter Gaylors lol And finally 3) I keep thinking about how Zach has said in many NMFs that he would rather an artist take risks & do weird or experimental things than just put out the boring standard stuff. Taylor played with some new sounds, used her vocals in new ways, switched up her typical self-serious verbose songwriting style and changed up her usual producers, she did some satire/campy writing, took some risks and not all of them landed, but at least she took some risks and experimented. Not liking the album because of the vibe or actual content is fine but enough with the misunderstanding lyrical meaning and then declaring it evidence of Fascist Taylor or whatever tf it is y’all try to cook up next.

Maya

can you tell me the correct one, I am confused

Megan Zegveldt

The reaction to Wood had me howling 🤣😭 It feels like she was trying to pull a Sabrina but it didn’t quite happen lol

Brittany Hogue

I dont remember that photo! Ugh, never been a huge cxcx fan though. Sounds like just from from the few things fans know, there was probably a lot of other things too. Did you see one of the Taylor photos released yesterday there was a plate of spaghetti, wine glass and spilled water cup? The exact set up from the now infamous Gabriettee video?

Irxuu

My first reaction to the album was exactlz like Madeline's (except I do really like cancelled) and my second reaction was literaly like yours. Time will tell but for me this is a grower. That being said I am never listening to Wood or Eldest Daughter ever again.

Miss_Lippy

Sure can. Zach and Madeline had pretty different initial reactions to it and I expect there to be people who agree more with one of them or the other, ppl who fall somewhere in between them or even land somewhere else entirely. The primary difference tho is that Zach and Madeline are fans first and haters second. I cannot say the same for many of the ppl commenting here lately. It’s like some rode here on a hate train specifically to roast Taylor or to mine for Taynegativity. I also trust that Z&M ultimately want Taylor to be successful and happy and would set out to engage with her content in good faith, which again I cannot say for a lot of these people responding. I’m not sure what is happening with this latest influx of people either -it seems to have attracted a lot of haters and trolls but it used to be mostly Taypositivity from actual fans with occasional snark or valid criticisms. As it’s grown, the space has become increasingly Taynegative and it’s made the vibes much soggier than they used to be.

Damon

Honestly I love wood 🪵. It’s a bop! She’s head over heels in love and getting some 🙌🏻

Flavia Mancini

i believe the scott borchetta one is the correct one

Kelly Hartley

We need to keep it light and positive *moves on to ruin the friendship*

Claire

I really like the album, it’s bright and fun and catty at times. My least favourite are Eldest Daughter, Wood and Honey. I’m not a huge fan of the title track either… it’s ok but not the grandiose showgirl moment I was expecting. I really see Opalite as a beautiful dance song you can play at graduations or weddings or at a karaoke with friends. Its lovely. My absolute favourite is The Fate of Ophelia ❤️‍🔥

Miss_Lippy

It’s about Scott Borcheta and from his perspective to Taylor as a young artist and then at the end she flips the script and switches it to her own perspective, sort of in the style like she has done in the past with a song like “Last Great American Dynasty”

Deb

I think Taylor used words above people's understanding. According to slangsphere, “ah-matized” means "something has been done with a ridiculous, over-the-top energy, almost as if by an unpredictable, chaotic force. " People just put the dic in front of the term with their own imagination. The slang nailed that perfect balance of sounding like a legit term but being totally goofy — which is prime meme fuel.

Luke Alexander

Loved the outfits omg thank u! I died at the last one so iconic

Deb

Well said. I am new to this site, but it seems to be a forum for hate and bullying. Madeline's reaction video was an embarrassment. The hosts last kiki as they call it was a complaint fest, often without them even knowing if what they were complaining about was real. At least Zack, in his reaction video, attempted to be professional. If they are going to have a forum as "professionals" that means they have to adhere to professional conduct. It is a trade off all professionals have to make. Also, Zack may find some comfort in the fact that the dic lyric was never used. I think Taylor used words above people's understanding. According to slangsphere, “ah-matized” means "something has been done with a ridiculous, over-the-top energy, almost as if by an unpredictable, chaotic force. " People just put the dic in front of the term with their own imagination. The slang nailed that perfect balance of sounding like a legit term but being totally goofy — which is prime meme fuel. And I think you are right...Taylor was trying to be goofy .

Maya

thanks!

Lexi

the headpiece is literally too iconic to me … and the song reactions you had to do in it are the best too💀💀💀

Lexi

also the Father Figure “misinterpretation” is INTERESTING thank you for the Joe perspective

Lexi

I at least thought the reference to stealing husbands was!!

Lexi

I showed it to my boyfriend we were cackling she took it so SERIOUS

Alexandra Jung

Someone needs to overlay cool by Jonas brothers and life of a showgirl to that tune change visual

Brittany Hogue

I never would say a clean version is better than the og one (the way Taylor intended), but Wood is one that I think makes it more palatable of a song because the lyrics are much less jarring and overt. lol

VK

I didn't get it right away, had to reeeeeeely think 😬

adnw

best reactions hahaha but what really gagged me is the random insha’Allah in there - obsessed

Annie

The LOL from your reaction when the beat dropped in Elizabeth Taylor

Caroline James

I love you Zach!!! I had so much fun reacting and bopping with you to this album!! Yes.. I didn't fall in love with every song right away, but I really love the majority! I didnt get a chance to go to the AMC, but now I want to! Father Figure was my favorite reaction.. GAGGED LOL. The song I had claimed was "Honey" and it actually it the one most like me in love ❤️ so I'm thrilled!

SP

I’m right before you listed to Father Figure and just wanted to say two things - one this is pure joy watching you react to this! And two- my perspective is that it is truly the *life* of the showgirl. Not BTS of the show (the tour) but truly the life that was happening to and around the girl while she still had to be the showgirl every night. And her *life* was falling in love, getting her music, finding out about friends, fueding, drama, etc which is lyrically where we are at I think. Idk I love this album!!!!!

Liv

honey feels like a dig at matty. the song itself sounds like it could be a 1975 song, and it reminds me of glitch with the vocal slide. and then the whole thing about calling and being too high to remember

Miranda

For sure that part

Maxine Carter

I definitely heard circles immediately! Now you’ve said it I can hear bill withers and I remember just muttering “disco funk” to my cat at the beginning of wood

Maxine Carter

That was where my mind went immediately, maybe a composite?

chrystalnyan -

what if taylors showgirl is brittney

Tara

Fair points, I guess the main issue for me is, this album doesn't feel intentional. You can feel the intention and purpose behind TTPD while listening to it: a cathartic release of emotions of turmoil and devastation. The writing on this album however just feels... negligent. There are some beautiful lyrics, the production is ok. You can really feel how close she was to creating something really, really good and then simply decided not to. Which is her choice, it is her art. But I can't help but feel a bit frustrated that she didn't care enough to really tend to her writing. It's not about her being sad and broken all the time. Of course she is allowed to laugh. Honestly Father Figure and Actually Romantic are well written! But so much of the rest... idk. In the end she can do whatever she wants and I just wish her happiness. But as someone who really appreciates good writing, effort and thought put into art, I am disappointed. Which is fine, as her fans we are not entitled to her music. At the same time it's okay to be bummed that the album didn't meet expectations, especially by how it was marketed. I'm confident so many more swifties would enjoy these songs if they were just marketed differently.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Eldest Daughter - ok I think I get the connection now... This is her first time being vulnerable with Travis. She is a sheep in wolf's clothing (the costume) - the gloves are coming off. It's a bit surface for Taylor, but oh well. I hate the term "fire" used where it is, but maybe it's he explaining it to him so she is using his vocab to describe it... But it is a jolt in a really great story that I personally didn't like, it sounds off.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Exactly. People making their full opinion on a first listen is insane. They should know better 😂

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

AR is meant to be cheesy and bad. She is taking Boring Barbie and running with it ❤️ Wood is horrible though, it's WAY too on the nose... Taylor is better than this. She is so good at lyrics when she lets her audience fill in the blanks.

rachel☁️

@Jackie: While I think Taylor absolutely has the right to respond to Charli, this response doesn’t land for me. Charli showed real depth and vulnerability on SIAK, while Taylor’s track on AR feels more like she’s just makng fun of her to embaress her—and the lyrics come off clunky. The song would’ve been stronger if Taylor focused less on Charli specifically and more on her own cultural position: the monolith people love to tear down because they feel threatened. Being the most famous person in the world inevitably shapes the way her responses read; as the “monster on the hill,” she’s always going to look like she’s punching down. A song exploring what it’s like to live under that much attention—rather than taking direct digs at Charli—would’ve been far more compelling. AR is one of her most immature songs to date. (IMO)

Megan Zemke

I think you’re on to something, but recently I saw more eldest daughters (including me) saying that Father Figure is the tough girl eldest daughter anthem and Eldest daughter is the inner monologue of trying and failing to be cool and collected.

Abby Fortune

I have never felt more disconnected from Taylor. Not only from the way that she completely misjudged the quality of this album, but the actually romantic punching down stuff is giving mean girl in a way that I just cannot relate to.

Hannah H

I really appreciate your reaction!

sleepy bubbles

I felt very confused listening to this album especially the first 3 tracks 😭 I did listen to it on a CD player so hopefully it’ll click better on speakers lol

Dorene

Midnights and TTPD were much much better than this.

Dorene

I was so looking forward to listening to this album on repeat, but I’m struggling to hit play for a 3rd time

Laura Berger

I can't get over that one guy from phone a snake one time who said this album would be horny Taylor and an album to party and shake your ass to... he called it. That's exactly what this is.

Hannah Andersen

I agree with you that there is an issue with the marketing/rollout not really reflecting the actual album. I went back and listened to that section of the NH podcast and she did mention "bangers" and "infectious anthems", and then Jason said that it looks like it's "full of energy" and Travis agreed. Possibly because of that commentary, my brain filled in the expectation that it would be cover to cover bulletproof pop music. Also worth noting that I don't hate this album. There is a lot that I like, but it missed the mark for me thematically. She did say that it's about what was happening in her life outside of the Eras Tour, but I guess I'm wondering - why do the showgirl theme at all? All of her albums are about her personal life, and they aren't really themed like this one. The rollout almost seemed like it would be a concept album, but there wasn't anything new here thematically (in my opinion). I think it would have been cool to hear some kind of call back to the tour and how that impacted her life. I imagine there are a lot of different ways that a person would be impacted by a world tour that went on as long as the Eras Tour did. The title track with Sabrina does this well, and I think I just hoped for more new themes related to her life as a showgirl since she does have a really unique perspective.

Hannah Andersen

Ophelia reminds me of Foster the People!

Veyda

I was confused on the first listen ngl. It wasn’t what I expected and that kind of threw me off at first, but after a few listens I can say that I enjoy most of the songs and they grew on me. I even had a stim song moment with Opalite and The Life of a Showgirl. I usually never gravitate towards collabs on a Taylor Swift album but Sabrina is a highlight on TLOAS. However there’s one thing I simply cannot forgive … Wood. I’m way too asexual for this (and I listen to Sabrina on a regular basis). Wood just makes me cringe and uncomfortable. She didn’t even had to say a lot about it in the release film. I listened to the clean version today in the theatre and I never thought that I would ever consider listening to a clean version of anything but here I am. Does it make sense all the time? No. I mean skies instead of thighs? I guess ... But do I get to enjoy the song sonically and without immense cringe? Well yes and I will continue to do so. I also enjoyed the music video for The Fate of Ophelia especially visually, but no spoilers :)

Hammie

Couldn’t agree more that Ruin the Friendship should’ve been Track 5. I’m around Taylor’s age so I was meh on the high school theme too but when the reveal in the bridge happened it made me tear up. It’s not just about the loss of a friend but regret and the loss of time too. It’s very introspective but still an earworm which is my favorite kind of Taylor song 🥲

Terry B

Saw the official release movie in cinema: She asked for George Michael’s estate’s blessing before using the FF title as she knows how important songwriting is 🙂‍↕️— I knew it! She likes George’s music 🎵 😭 RIP — he passed on Xmas 🎄 day too

Sulacycle

I've heard people talk about it having a 70s sound. It got me thinking David Bowie's plastic soul era, with slight R&B peppered in. I hear echoes of that now that I'm many, many listenings in.

Sulacycle

I love that perspective. She's dragging some folks in the negative spaces.

Hannah Andersen

Exactly - she really does set her own bar high, and the way she talked about how proud she is of this album on NH really solidified that expectation for me. Midnights has been a lasting favorite of mine! I do see the connection between the two, and there were quite a few moments that sounded really similar. I'm not sure why this one isn't hitting the same way for me, unfortunately. Good call on the clean version of Wood!

Anna

Eldest daughter here… I bawled my eyes out at this. I know this didn’t hit for you like it did for me, so I’ll explain how I took it… 1. I don’t think she’s saying she’s the “eldest” daughter in her family. I feel like she’s attributing the eldest daughter feel to the industry. Maybe being Scott’s first signed artist? Having to navigate it all from that perspective? 2. The line about “lambs to the slaughter dressing up as wolves and we looked fire” is so on point and to me this is incredible writing and I’ll tell you why. She’s basically saying fake it til you make it but in a very dark way. We were all the practice kid, we had more strict rules, we had to be perfect, we had to be patient with the younger ones, we had to be the “adult” when the others were being assholes to us (I‘m looking at critics of Actually Romantic), lots of responsibility was laid on us, and for some of us STILL IS (bc now our parents are old and need help), we had to pick up ALL of the “how tos” very quickly, and above all, we had to seem cool or unbothered or else we were “complaining”. So we all dressed up as that person to make it happen. We all just put our heads down, did our job, and did our “bad bitch” persons so good that ppl wouldn’t take shits on our younger siblings. And while that worked for most of us, it took a toll on our mental health. And she said ALL OF THAT in that one line. THAT is good writing. To be really honest, anyone who’s seen any episode of Shameless where Fiona goes from crazy big sister wolf to absolute break down in tears (that she only ever seems to do in private) will get this song. 3. The fact that she also knew how to articulate how youngest felt (prolly cuz she talked to Travis and her bro but you know neither of them put it that way) is impressive to me.

ccynthesyzer

I can’t see my original comments but see via my email that people have asked. I think that Zach’s reaction to father is not totally of base because —————— SPOILER TO MOVIE ———————————————————————————————————— Taylor says she sees herself in both positions at times. The mentor and the mentee and the idea of power dynamics. Z was seeing those layers on first listen. The AMC “movie” was wonderful and hope it becomes accessible in some way in the near future 💗

Rachael ♥️

Wood is crazy but I still love this album

Federico

"I need my spirits lifted up" *CANCELLED! starts playing*

JD IHateItHere

George was so talented and an amazing producer. So magnetic too.

SatelliteSnail

This will clip will live in my brain rent free: 4:09 "Dear God...🙏 Thank you 🤩*giggle*🥰 thank you! and fuck you Scott Borchetta and Scooter Braun 😠 just as an aside, just to get that in there *makes the cross with bejewelled headpiece* AMEN🙌"

reckless mermaid

YES! THANK YOU!! 🫶💕 As an eldest daughter I resonate so much with every thing you said here. You summed up my understanding of the song perfectly. I do agree with Zach that the writing is muddy and incongruous; there are a lot of ideas that she’s trying to weave together but doesn’t quite get at the crux of what she’s trying to say

DrEmily

Maybe she played You Belong With Me and was telling someone the original inspiration or was talking about high school with someone or met up with Abigail. Who knows. Probably perfectly normal. At least she didn’t have to invent a fictional song origin so 85’s feelings weren’t hurt. Pretty sure she was signaling all was good by number tagging Trav in the song

DrEmily

Yep. Gabriette apparently reposted some meme at the time calling 365 “Bad Blood for people who do coke”

DrEmily

Some songs are brilliant but definitely not all. They are improving with re-listen but a bit of a hard left after 18 volumes of poetry on TTPD. Think it suffers a bit from being rushed. She didn’t have to pump it out to completion before the end of Eras European vacation. But I really think she wanted to power completely down after the tour.

Draxxlie

I also cried my eyes out to Eldest Daughter. To me it’s a song about having to be the one to find out all on your own how dark and cruel and cold the world is and then wanting to protect your youngest sibling from that. It’s extremely personal to me so I just skipped over that part of the reaction entirely but I’m glad to see I’m not the only one who was hit so hard by this song

🌷Elle🌷

Title track - Cool by Jonas Brothers Actually Romantic - Beverly Hills by Weezer so many are using sounds that are already popular from others songs, not sure how to feel about it LOL

🌷Elle🌷

Definitely not the only one!!! Me and a friend immediately went "this sounds like it's for Ariana/Demi" since they have made peace and the song felt very general in the sense that she's extending her hand to those who she sympathizes with

🌷Elle🌷

im going to need you to take this back LMAO

🌷Elle🌷

You're not the only one diva

🌷Elle🌷

I've been in Taylor circles literally since the Tumblr times. I think this is normal, the only difference is that the Eras Tour scaled it to new numbers. Taylor has been polarizing in small ways and fans feel what they feel about such things. To some it means nothing, to others it means everything. Objectively I understand why there is a wave of negativity. I don't think it's out of pocket.

Ivan Cervera

Can i just say that there are ZERO bangers on this album 😭😭 like i love some of the songs on here but there’s no new romantics, no ayhtdws, so im a little disappointed

🌷Elle🌷

Diva I don't know where you got any of that but none of that has been proven to have happened. Blake got backlash for being tonedeaf and terrible at marketing, and it snowballed from there, to where she can't prove a single thing. What did get proven was that she exaggerated "harassment" because we literally got video and audio proof. Please LMAO

Victoria

I need merch that says "suddenly I feel like a fool in my headdress" stat.

Jaysun

ironically i think this is the thinking that got us this song in the first place 😂

Terry B

if only she'd spared 3 of the 6 years spent with Joel with the friend who passed i.e. sliding doors 🚪 the film 🎞️... would've could've should've... I just lament 😢 > half decade lost in a relationship... wouldn't 3 years been enough to notice it's not working out? hmm 🤔 maybe This was Her Trying (too hard for too long)? but she reflected in Happiness: "There'll be happiness after you But there was happiness because of you Both of these things can be true" 🙂‍↕️ I guess there's no definite timeline to decide on pursuing or ending a relationship 🤔💭... See?! And ppl dismissed her love songs as stupid -- human emotions are complex! She's blonde, pretty and smart -- BOTH things can be true 🙂‍↕️

Terry B

Though the track's a bit off the album theme, I'm glad she gets to include tracks that she wants spontaneously without MENtors' interference 🙂‍↕️

Terry B

I'm the youngest in the family tree 🌳 so cannot relate to #5... I've always felt a chip on my shoulder having to prove myself not needing help... with my recent broken shoulder, I literally have a chip on my shoulder... 🤣...

Terry B

in the theatre release, her baby finger 👋🏼 was bandaged 🤕 due to some glass bowls breaking 😱 😭 but she kept rehearsing "she's one tough kid she can handle her s***" 🙂‍↕️ speaking of the word s***... Apple 🍎 Music 🎵 filter is SOOO dumb: it bleeps the Japanese word "shite" to "s***e" in J-pop songs 🤣 ~ "shite" is the te-form of verb conjugation for present progressive i.e. "do-ING", connecting verbs or asking permission 🤣 at first I was like, 🤔 how come the J-song titles're censored?!... 💡Oh-- 😳 English-centric cultural blind-spot interpretation -- duh 🙄

Brooke Guido

No this cracked me up I couldn't stop thinking about it 😂

caroline

Elizabeth Taylor should have been the opening track!

🌷Elle🌷

Actually Romantic is Beverly Hills by Weezer more than that Pixies song, I listened to both and BH sounded exactly like AR

Aly

I think Zach (or other TS creators) started to use the term 'bulletproof pop' to describe the album and it caught on, but that was never a TS marketing term. TS didn't even use the term 'bangers' first, one of the Kelce Brothers did and she echoed the term after they did. I think the visual concept (and title) of the album came to be because she made the record WHILE being a Showgirl on the Eras Tour. Maybe more so because of the ICDIWABH part of the TTPD set choreography and theming specifically. And I suspect that the timing is also why there isn't a lot of reflection on the tour itself. She made the album while touring, so she hadn't fully processed the beast that was the Eras Tour until after the album had been made because she was too busy living it in order to make it to the next city and the next show. Maybe TS13 will reflect more on that?

🌷Elle🌷

Music is super subjective at the core, so just because lots of us don’t like it, it doesn’t mean you have bad taste. It just means you vibe with the music! There is nothing wrong with anyone who likes this album, nothing at all. It can be amazing to you, but terrible to me, and both things can be true🩷

Riya

We apparently share some brain cells because my reaction to every song was almost identical to yours. No wonder I like your videos! 💀

Tova Benson-Tilsen

"Ruin the Friendship" kinda frames her mindset when Matty happened. She chose to carpe the diem and answer the question

Emily

Although Father Figure is predominately about the Scott Borchetta masters drama and power struggle, I don’t think it’s off base to also read it as Taylor toying with her power/role in the music industry as top dog and the public’s perception of her. Of course this is a secondary reading imo; the masters drama is what’s on the surface and I think is almost certainly the main focal point. The Olivia credits debacle comes to mind with this secondary reading. This only really occurred to me after hearing her explanation of the song in the movie (I won’t spoil). I think what’s so interesting about Taylor’s songwriting is that there’s so much to explore and many different interpretations. Would be curious to hear everyone else’s thoughts (preferably those who know what comments I’m alluding to haha). I’ve seen a lack of nuance when it comes to this song, and I think it’s perhaps the most interesting on the album. Multiple interpretations can exist at once!!

Miss_Lippy

I have been a longtime fan as well and I agree with you that waves of negative reactions from fans over certain songs or albums, especially right after a drop, is not out of the norm. But the keyword there is “fan” and you can tell when a fan reacts poorly it usually contains feelings of disappointment or frustration, let down etc. However, these “snarkers” are glorified cyberbullies who form snark pages specifically designed for sad chronically online losers to weirdly and obsessively insult and pick apart celebs/artists they obsessively cyberstalk and hate on like it’s their job. Reddit is full of them and they're almost always invasive, creepy, hyperbolic, cruel and fucking weird to boot. The sentiment that I’ve seen from some people who’ve joined here really mirrors that snarker attitude where its evident their criticisms aren’t coming from a place of normal fan frustration because they want Taylor to do better or disappointment because an album wasn’t what they’d hoped for, etc. but instead they will comment things that just feel vitriolic, nasty and lack the depth of understanding that one would expect an actual fan to have. I’m all for criticizing Taylor. I have LOLd at some of Zach’s fashion roasts of her, I’ve criticized her for doing cringe behaviors or talk about her total flop songs, etc. I even think it can be fun and interesting to have good faith debates and discuss her music with other fans because it’s often broadening my understanding of the material. What I’m not interested in are the comments & contributions to discussions being made by freaks who hate her so much that they get off on dragging Taylor online for sport and attribute world strife, destruction, wars and horrors to her mere existence.

Valtteri Iivarinen

Interesting, but the fact that she changed it in the clean version to ”hypnotized” kinda says something though

Mia Aiyana Cardenas

Ivan I thought the exact thing at first, but I SWEAR they grow on you-- just wait

Trudi

I agree, I read it as being about "managers" and other powerful people in the industry taking advantage whilst pretending to have your best interests. And now she is in the position to do it to others if she wants to...

Rachael Evansco

Agree with all of this! Eldest daughter here too. Love the Fiona reference because it's so true to the analogy of the Eldest Daughter.

Alves

Title track sounds like a song from the zootopia soundtrack

Juna

The Life of a Showgirl kind of reminds me of MARINA’s new album.

Hammie

I was wondering why this was included too but Joe Caramanica a critic for the NYTimes Zach has mentioned before suggested on his podcast that the Fearless/Speak Now portions of the Eras tour may have had her thinking about this again

Lauren S.

the only song I have issue with is "Eldest Daughter", the rest I LOVE! hard to believe how much negativity I'm seeing honestly. Can't people just enjoy and have fun? Whatever, it's a win to me!

Lauren B

I feel like this the problem with her writing on this song and album. I like the song but all the things she lists other people are just random, it makes what she's saying easy to misconstrue. Like why is she singing about actresses wanting to play complex female characters if that has nothing to do with what she wants or is not meant to be a foil to her desires?

Brooke Guido

SUDDENLY I FEEL LIKE I FEEL LIKE A FOOL IN MY HEADDRESS MERCH PLEASE!!!!!!!!

emily

A cuntress afoot!! 😭😭😭

Marsha

I think you're way off on Father Figure, Zach. I think it's from Scott Borchetta's POV, as he was a "second father" to her, in her words. Or I'm wrong! Or Matty! Her dick's bigger b/c he was the smallest man who ever lived! rofl! I don't know, it's just great no matter what.

Hayleeeeeee

'that wasn't good" re: eldest duughter... yeah. its not-- youre right about that!!! hahahaha

Hayleeeeeee

the highschool trope is soooooo old omgggggI thhohgt the same when I heard ruin the friendship!!!

Marsha

I think we all know Taylor well enough to know she wouldn't write a song like Wood unless she was clapping back at someone -- maybe people saying their love wasn't real, he just has a big d*ck or words to that effect. Just thinking out loud, wondering what other people are thinking. It has to be a clap back, IMO.

reincarnation of helen keller (avery)

I agree father figure is a joe alwyn cook because i would expect nothing less from her, id be shading him on my wedding album to another guy if i was her

Hayleeeeeee

the "oh no" during wood was so real lol

Hayleeeeeee

the redwood tree line is also where she lost me 100%

Zoë Peterson

Just got broken up with and this album is so catchy but rough to listen to rn

Sophie Middleton

Father figure has multiple meanings. Olivia, Borchetta, Scooter etc etc

karen

I'm better now... it's not the best album, but I really like it sonically 😂

splendidvie

I might be delulu, but sometimes I think she still harbors some sort of resentment toward Matty, which drives her to talk about the big D extensively — oversharing the amount of joy and great sex so that the smallest man can’t escape hearing about it.

splendidvie

not saying she wants him back, she's just being a petty queen.

JesspressoShot

"Okay, back to positivity! - Ruin The Friendship." Oh, little did we know...

Kat

Did anyone else also feel like the Fate of Ophelia wasn't real when they first listened and had to restart? 😂 I loved it immediately but it felt so surreal

Ashley

I thought so too at first listen but it’s not a trope it’s about her actual high school friend who died

Taylor Rae

I have watched this like 5 times. Zach in his fancy head dress hearing Wood for the first time goes down as my favorite Swiftologist moment of all time. I keep laughing.

Marilyn

I really think everyone is misinterpreting eldest daughter - I think it’s addressed to her family, she’s saying in showbiz you’re supposed to be a bad bitch, but she’s saying she’s not, she’s loyal to her family even though that’s not cool

Marilyn

Wood might be a counterpoint to The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived and a specific message for a specific person - Matty Healy

Chelsea Rose Riggs

Has anyone thought of “Every eldest daughter Was the first lamb to the slaughter So we all dressed up as wolves and we looked fire” being about the bad blood music video?

KRYSTAL HOWARD

I see it as Taylor expressing how she felt growing up and having her family doing everything they could to help her reach her dreams and she feels responsible for protecting them from all of this and all of us.

Terry B

re: #5 Father Figure: George Michael lost his masters in court vs Sony 😡 90s… He would’ve could’ve should’ve won if it’s now with fandom online backing 🙂‍↕️ Taylor might have identified with the struggle — she has indirectly TAY-VENGED George 🫡 😢

ioana

Literally the only skip for me

Terry B

#5 is it hidden messages to her own family (none of our biz 🙂‍↕️) maybe she's reassuring fans (esp. OG fans) she won't leave them -- we're her longest relationship after all 🙂‍↕️ #6 🤣 she just said she's not a bad bee 🐝 not savage, then her advice is play dirty, steal someone's BF, better to find out answers than keeping her side of streets clean 😳🐍 instead of moral high ground "Girl At Home"...

Terry B

Zach, just cabaret feather 🪶 headpiece? where's your swimsuit costume 🤣? #7 I suspect it's covert dig at 🐭 and his fiancée (💍🖕) like in snooker 🎱 you hit the white ball which isn't really your target 🎯 I'm sure there're other beef she could've write about, why Charli? 🤔 provoking another fanbase also freebie PR... I feel like since Rep 💿 new Taylor writes with double meaning, the external motive protects her private feelings. This album is marketed as Life of A Showgirl who's found happiness + success so any references to her ex's and young self #6 cannot come across as cold feet bride-to-be... 🤔 #7 punkness would've been a song sung by Avril...? 🤔

Terry B

Thanks for the head pieces Zach! 🤗 You seem happy 😃 Her vibes feel like epilogue to ERAs tour, pop tunes satisfaction guaranteed by Max Martin 🙂‍↕️ On second listen it's grown on me... clean version lyrics are tolerable 😅 Real Showgirl: #2, #4, #10, #11 = Slaughtered but Come-Back Immortal Girl Boss HBIC The MAN with biggest checks ✍🏼 who vows she will not leave her loyal cancelled friends 🙂‍↕️

George

after a few days I have rlly grown towards this album

gund simp

the first 4 tracks were a red herring..

MwanaLesa

For each song I asked myself… Could this song exist if there was no Eras Tour? Nine times out of 12 I thought “yes”. That is disappointing. I wanted more behind-the-scenes musings and evaluation of this particular tour spotlight.

MwanaLesa

😂😂 Facts on facts!!!

MwanaLesa

I love the “just kidding” line following “I would trade the Cartier for someone to trust”. When I saw that in the lyric video it made me laugh.

MwanaLesa

It feels like a trope because she refers to it so often. We didn’t need that here. We are supposed to be showgirls! I was annoyed when in the movie she said she hadn’t talked about high school in a while when it was literally the name of a whole song in the last album. 🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️

MwanaLesa

I was with you until “it’s great no matter what”. lol…. I agree that it’s from Borchetta’s point of view.

MwanaLesa

Yes!! The punching down on Actually Romantic AND on Opalite. The reference to the ex always on her phone was nasty and unnecessary. Lots of people talk shit about Taylor. So what. Leave that nobody little girl alone. It was beneath Taylor.

PandoraNicole

The thing about Jack too is everyone was begging her to get rid of him or at least take a break from him for the next album. She did exactly that now people are saying they miss him and I've even seen people apologize to Jack after this album. And the thing that's so stupid though is that if she would have done another album with him no matter how good it was people would still be saying I still want her to not work with Jack for the next album even if it's good and they're happy with the album they would still want her to work with another producer for the next one. She had to do it.

Alaina

The lip gloss was a paid actor.

Mar

Still can’t get over you gagging on your matcha at Elizabeth Taylor drop

Mar

Opalite - Luis Miguel “1+1=2 enamorados”

L

She said in an interview that she wondered about moving one song on the tracklist, but decided against it because it would fuck up the eras stage symbolism. I firmly believe it has to be ruin the friendship and that she wanted to put in on 5. Am i meth mathing or am i onto something here? 😅

Mar

Opalite is suspiciously similar to 1+1=2 enamorados by Luis Miguel

MwanaLesa

You are definitely on to something!! That song is the black sheep of the record!!

Cassady Lynn

Okay im dumb someone explain ‘been number one but i never had two’ to me

Joyce Smith

She’s had #1 songs, been #1 in the industry, #1 tour etc. but she’s never had a partner (been a part of a pair, or 2) that was truly her match. She had not met “the one,” Travis, yet, so she was still searching for her #2, her other half.

pricila

Eldest daughter reminded me of hello kitty lol. The songs sound so serious but the lyrics …

Alysha

“I heard you calling on the megaphone” is pretty easily explained, lol.

tiamat

Oh wait where did she say this?

L

Ahh, i can't remember what interview it was right now, but it was one of the recent ones where she does the "my fans are so smart they figured out the track list looks like the eras stage"- talking point and then she mentions it from there.

Mikee Dayrit

Man, she really doesn’t think about sequencing at all in an artistic way. It only matters through numerology or easter egging

Alexis

So High School was about being in the beginning of a relationship as an adult but feeling like you’re in high school because you’re all awkward and shy and suddenly 16 again Ruin the Friendship is actually set in her high school years in the front half

Alexis

I didn’t think anything could top the emotion in “ I regret you all the tiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiime”

Alexis

She thinks it’s Taylor supporting alt right people who have been cancelled 🤷🏻‍♀️

Alexis

Funny I heard the oh oh oh as a 50s callback!

Alexis

Do you want her to let us in or not? I’m here for all the talk!

Alexis

It’s called range!! 😂 💕

Alexis

Truly! The woman can’t win with some critics

Alexis

I actually prefer his approach to Madeline’s because he gets to really vibe with the song as it’s meant to be heard

Alexis

💯

Alexis

I don’t recall Britney Mahones being “cancelled” though? Especially not for “making a joke only a man could” or being “too much” or “smug” or “tone deaf and hot”

Alexis

At least it would silence the maga “reading”

Alexis

Yes! A range of pop music influences - I love it!

Alexis

Haha Did the interpretation change once the friend got to cancelled?

Alexis

Plus I think the references to some people wanting a Palme De Or at the Cannes Film Festival and an Oscar on the bathroom floor in wish list made me think of Joe’s “ambitions”

Anna

Actually prefer your interpretation of Father Figure.

Chloie 😝

I feel like it doesn’t give Scott at all??? It’s confusing me that Madelines take is the general consensus bc the song is like obviously addressing an ex and romance coded…. Idk

Bailey

Taylor herself says it’s about a protege and mentor relationship

Dijon🌺

“Conversations with Friends will tank” continues to take me the fuck out I can’thsjslaksksksk

Katherine Russell

Your eyes kept getting bigger and bigger on Father Figure! Love this reaction. 🫶🏻

Karisa

Wait wait wait… when she said her best advice is to answer the question… could that be who the song Question was actually about? I’m blacking out the lyrics to Question at the moment… 🤣Gotta go listen and revisit this idea. Oh, I’m remembering we thought that was about Harry… but was it? Be right back lol.

Karisa

Could the second verse of Actually Romantic be about Kim K? She sent her haters Valentine’s gifts along with her family and friends. There is an image I saw awhile back that has all the names on post-it notes… and Taylor’s name was included… just a thought… lol she is unhinged in this song and I love to.

Karisa

Ok yeah, I’m mental… that song is definitely not about that guy… pretty sure it is about Harry. 😂 Man, I haven’t listened to midnights in awhile I’ve been on a Reputation Kiki for awhile and damn… I love this record. It’s so good… I love the production on it actually. It has a lot of interesting sounds and beats happening. I’m sorry but I love Jack… I hope he comes back on the next one.

Cassandra Blalock

Zach’s first listen of Fate of Ophelia is like seeing a sunrise for the first time. 🌅

Cassandra Blalock

Also, Zach, Imma let you finish but you got Wood soooooo wrong.

Kerri S

Question is probably about Matty Healy, who she'd been wondering about for 10 years.

Lo, the Apprentice

Oh honey watching your reaction to the first two songs, knowing what’s to come, is so sad lol

Lo, the Apprentice

My final verdict is that if this would have been a Katy Perry album from 2019 I would have loved it. KP could have pulled off singing Wood about Orlando Bloom!

Srhgrotz

I think you were spot on with your Father Figure interpretation

Dorene

I want to see the first draft of Father Figure that was clearly pointed at Joe 😅 I think there were then some convoluting layers added to it, but I can still feel that Taylor is the father at the beginning.

Dorene

In seriousness though, what makes the song so perfect is her elegant feminine voice singing words that are usually grumbled in a basement by a greasy old man surrounded by smoke. It redefines power, which she has done in real life. Muah!

Cassandra Blalock

Actually Romantic is my fav every day that ends in y

Sydney

The reactions to Eldest Daugbter have been so interesting to me because I have never understand the thru line of a song so clearly on fist listen! And I’m the youngest by 15 years lmao.

katie

I literally keep coming back to watch this lol

Lisa M

Me today lol

Lisa M

React to Demi’s new album plz 😭🫶 and yes it’s produced by zhone 😭

mango

you’re too kind thanks for checking in on me :,) it did make me upset I’m ngl but I’m ok now promise I got accidentally logged out of patreon and just didn’t bother coming back till now lol and I also deleted tik tok and twitter (which I’d been meaning to do for a while anyway so in a weird twisted way it’s actually a good thing the Discourse™ got so bad) I think I’m just gonna sit this one out for now cause I still have my own thoughts and feelings but I know the internet and it’s just not really worth it atm (esp since I don’t even really care about the album itself all that much. haven’t even listened to it since the day it came out)

TheChanter

I believe Father Figure is a warning to Travis Kelce. And I will be vindicated eventually. Like how we found all the Ratty clues in songs years later. I promise you. Zach was onto something thinking it was about Joe. Scott didn't have any scandals to cover. But Travis' old tweets... remember those being dug up and now we can't find them anywhere? ZACH was right when it's Taylor talking about a boyfriend, it just wasn't the boring Turkey who didn't like fame. It was Travis who LOVES fame and his team leaked the contract in 2024 and Taylor said, "I'll cancel your card." And he changed his mind.

TheChanter

Eldest Daughter was Travis asking "Honey where's my Track five?" and it's false venerability she put into a song for a guy who wouldn't notice it's not that deep of a song. Because he'd never even listened to "Red" and wouldn't know the likes of Taylor's true love songs or Track 5's because "It wasn't on the set list." -Taylor to Travis on his podcast. And Taylor played the piano and put pretty vocals to try and fool the world. Didn't work on the real true fans like Zach who need quality and soul. Which it has NEITHER of those.

Stamkitty

This was a gem. Loved rewatching.

VictoriaReadsss

Sometimes I just need to come back and rewatch the fate of Ophelia and Elizabeth Taylor reactions

VictoriaReadsss

“I’m telling you it’s the best album ever made and I won’t deviate from that” -swiftologist and me 2 songs in We indeed both deviate from that statement 😭 I love how we all had the same canon event

katiecrow

Revisiting your reaction to Wood made my day thank you! x

Joan Rood

I watched this reaction when it first came out - as well as Madeline’s - and all the subsequent videos both have done about the album - and I just re-listened to this reaction. I’ve also listened to the album a lot. Initially, I put 6 songs on a playlist (1 - 4, 6, and 12). Then I added 11 (Honey). Now I’m thinking of adding all the others except eldest daughter and wood because I actually do like these other songs a lot even if they aren’t my favs. Also I know on a subsequent video, Honey was criticized for attacking other women - but let’s be real - a certain percentage of women are exactly the way Taylor portrayed them (at least when they are younger).

Alex

not me finding out you also use my signature perfume

Olivia G

I’m mostly curious when we became totally cool with calling woman bitches? And saying that all her bitching didn’t get her what she wanted? Like…. Miss Americana is aging so poorly.

Luke

your too woke

No Its Becky

Meh, I kinda think it’s valid. I actually don’t mind the language personally BUT it is a bit hypocritical on Taylor’s part since she herself had rants about calling women bitches… just an observation but I’m not hating either way

Carnelian

I can’t count how many times I’ve watched this. Excellence.

Teaplease

What contract? Don't tell me we are feeding the PR stunt narrative here

Teaplease

I've rewatched that part and cackled so many times. My exact reaction

Teaplease

That's a great litmus test and explains why so many of us felt confused and let down!

Teaplease

I just can't square the "we all dressed up as wolves and we looked fire" line. It's so dense with metaphors that just don't make sense together

Teaplease

Ahhh never saw that meme!! I also heard Bowen Yang describe being next to Taylor and Travis on SNL as standing in the Redwood Forest

Teaplease

I'm nodding along to a lot of what you said here, except the "bad bitch" persona. As an eldest (and only) daughter, I've never experienced a pressure to seem tough or hardcore, just to be GOOD. And I think if Taylor had written this song 12-15 years ago, she would have said the same ("careless man's careful daughter"...)

Teaplease

Skies is so much better. Not just because it's less vulgar, it's just a more surprising metaphor

Teaplease

I immediately thought of Joe too..."I founded the club she's heard great things about" right

Teaplease

6 more months of letting it marinate, and maybe getting Aaron in the room for some lyrical editing would have been helpful to this album. That's just not Max Martin's forte

Teaplease

She was married EIGHT times!!! On the Speak Now tour, Taylor invited James Taylor on stage at MSG for a duet of Fire and Rain and said her parents named her for him. This song feels like an admission that she has a lot in common with Elizabeth Taylor too. Lest we forget she believed her love life was cursed in The Prophesy

Teaplease

YES YES YES!!! She finally answered the "what ifs"

Teaplease

Oh oh oh!!! I'm just re-listening to Father Figure and Eldest Daughter after hearing Zach talk about Father Figure having a Joe subtext. When she revealed the track list on New Heights, I did think it was weird there are kinship terms on back to back songs (father and daughter). What if Father Figure is saying (to Joe, Matty, or any industry protégé) you're only welcome here on my invitation ("little did you know your home's really only a town you're just a guest in") and Eldest Daughter is saying that Travis has earned the privilege of being family to her ("I'm never gonna break that vow / I'm never gonna leave you out"..."and now you're home")?

Teaplease

The bridge would seem to make it about Blake or others who have known her since 2016 ("they stood by me before my exoneration, they believed I was innocent"

TheChanter

The one from Travis' PR team at Scope. It was leaked in the end of 2024. A contract between him and Swift saying when they would break up. But they remained together because it was leaked. You really think Taylor wouldn't protect herself and her brand after the stuff with the rat? Travis was a safe option and he gets the fame and money that comes with being with her. They may have real feelings for each other. But this is just as much business for them as it is personal. Maybe even more so. I've never in all my life seen an engagement announcement showing up unprompted on my Amazon Fire Stick homepage.

splendidvie

Regardig the B* word thing. That's not the point. The point is, Taylor herself said: "There is no such thing as a bitch" (in Miss Americana), vehemently calling Kanye out for calling her B* in his lyrics etc. She's not helping the cause by actively repeating a stereotypical portrayal of women. And she does it multiple times on Showgirl. It's like she all of a sudden forgot everything she once claimed she "believed" in. Switching agenda and feminist tone really isn't a good look for her. just my two cents.

K.C.

he never should've switched outfits

musicsf

I just love the moment when you hear "dickmatized" and immediately snap out of the zone XD

Chas

I come back and watch this moment when I need to feel less alone

folklevermoretpd

Who's back to watch the Wood reaction for the 100th time?

Lyla

if you stop watching after father figure you can pretend like there’s a happy ending,

Stephi

So good to revisit this after listening for a few months. <3

Liv

🥱

Liv

Lmao that was made up by some weirdo jeez you people need help badly 😭

Finley

had to come back to this after listening to elizabeth taylor lmao. just felt the urge to resee the insanity of this reaction

Jose Zelaya

No Zach don’t change the outfit nooo noooo it goes down hill after the first change

Chas

Watching this again and Zach’s reaction to Wish List is pretty much how I felt like listening to the album from moment one

ARYA

you need to have a "WELL YESS" sign on ur wall atp..

Tori Tallman

I would like to submit “suddenly I feel like a fool in my headdress” as a nominee for fav swiftologist quote of all time

Jake Deason

it's time to rewatch this reaction again. it's just chefs kiss

Mia Mar

Watching this after your daughter from hell reaction to feel something because that album makes showgirl sound like lemonade dead serious This is genuinely one of the best videos on the internet

Hunter

rewatching to feel something :'/

Savannah Sloan

“I’m two songs in and this is the best album I’ve ever heard and I will not deviate from that”….. hahahaha

cat

I love rewatching this and getting to the part where you say THANK YOU after the first track and I’m like… you won’t be saying thank you in a bit😭

dylan Nehila

I fully agree with wish list like you’ve said it’s kinda hard to rly decipher what she actually likes about this person bc supposedly he like embraces her fame and glitz and glam and the fact that she does enjoy being a star despite the bad things about it but wish list kinda goes back on all that so it’s like okay? 😭

dylan Nehila

And ironically “scratches down your back” feels more intimate and intense than any lyric on that song

dylan Nehila

I feel like it’s trying to play into the “trying to seem cool” theme but it just doesn’t land for me 😭