Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 542554772.mp4

Downloads

Content

Please remember this is a REACTION, not a review, and none of my thoughts are fully considered or weighed and everything is knee-jerk. Not everything I'll say in this is perfectly worded or perfectly said! It's just a kiki at this point!! Plleeasseeee don't take this so seriously or think anything I say means I hated this record or hated x or y or z.

There is one song and one song alone that I'd say at this point I HATE....and you all know what that is....everything else is either nebulous, confusing, or something I really like. I AM A SWIFTIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Even if after a few listens I decide it really isn't my favorite hey mannn it's no big deal. We're all just here on the big floating rock....something to remember!

(for the record, I don't think Cancelled is "about" Brittany, OR Blake. Neither of them are the issue I have with the song...seen lots of discussion about that already. Idgaf who she's specifically referring to if anyone, she could be talking about Tony the Tiger and I wouldn't care, it's a mess either way. But, the optics of releasing this song when she's being criticized for palling around with MAGA friends is pretty bad, I think we can ALL agree on that.)

Files

Comments

Eddy

The wayyyy I have been waiting for this

erin

the way i EXPEDITIOUSLY CLICKED ON THE NOTIF

Drew Rosen

oh we are in for some good food

☆

IM SAT

Saime

i’m sat after seeing those stories 😭

Mary Massed

The Swiftilogist Patreon winning the quick turnaround game. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 thanks for working your asses off for us!

Shondi

Never clicked so fast

Tayllor

The ways in which I SCREAMED at this notification, Lizard, deliver the truth unto us

James M

this intro….. you kill me…

Omar

I’m so ready for this! ❤️‍🔥

Mavi💖

I've been waiting for this queen!!, the intro killed me lol I love your outfit

Sarah B

Bahahaha the intro!!! LOVE THE BSB!!! And the color changing microphone!

Saime

ok production 💥💥💥

Sarah B

I’m getting so hyped with anticipation!!!

Landon🗿

everyone stfu my shows on.

Kelsey

well hello everyone!

Alexa

My thoughts on cancelled exactly😭😭

bubblegumrebel

this intro fucking PLEEEEEEEEEEEK 😭

Kelsey

the dress!!!

Alejandro

QUEEN DIVA WIG BOOT YOU LOOK AMAZING!!!

em

SAT

chappell roan

It’s sad that you have to defend your opinion so heavily… personally i LOVED the record but if you hated it I WOULDNT GIVE A SHIT!!!! If internet people give you shit about whatever you have to say (I don’t even know if they will I haven’t heard this yet) just know they’re demented. But we love you over here, and that’s unconditionally, no matter if you love or hate the album. That’s irrelevant. 🥰

Iana Mergen

Not me currently in the TLOAS movie and now have something else watch afterward!!!

nish 🍓

before i even get to the reaction. this outfit. madeleine the diva that you are. the absolute showgirl

Shantini Vyas

Queen I am so scared to watch this reaction

Lauren

Love u Lizard thank you!!!

sara

The intro is fryingggg me Madeline you are incredible

nina

The caption…. I too am feeling your feelings, Madeline. May us dubious Swifties hang in there during these next few days of discourse.

Ry

The way this gets posted the moment I got home from work for the weekend. Thats Showgirl.

Melinda

The intro music is killing me

Mavi💖

Don't feel like you have to defend your opinion, everyone is entitled to have one, it's ok to like it or not like it, it doesn't make you less of a fan and it's not a crime, people need to chill

R

What annoys me most about this album is that the problem is 100% the writing. If the lyrics were different I would have loved it and that’s upsetting. Also where are the showgirls?? Because according to this the life of a showgirl is getting dicked down and getting in fights with other showgirls….which I guess fair enough 😂

Noni

I'm just gonna say it, Travis is a terrible muse. There's no depth in the songs for about him.

Heather Hexem

And just because you don’t like something that Taylor does, says or makes doesn’t make you any less of a Swiftie…I’m tired of people being shitty when anyone has some sort of opinion on anything. I’m mixed on this album there’s some bangers and some misses in my opinion. My faves are Father Figure and Cancelled!

Dev

MY SHOW IS ON

Amanda M

That’s right you start with pure pop gold!

Meli

You do not have to explain yourself to us!! We know at the end of the day you are a swiftie who believes in nuance and doesn’t clap and cheer like a Seal every time she does something

Ally ❤️

I actually loved this album, after subbing in clean versions for the dick songs. 🤷‍♀️ I just can’t be meditating on dicks swinging every time I turn around…

Maisie

You look soooo good!! Love this showgirl look.

Dev

Madeline you look GORGEOUS 🫶🏽

Olivia

Oh my god HOW I WISH IT SOUNDED LIKE SO IT GOESSSSS

Hannah

diva im cackling at the whole thing you’re so real

Gail

QUEEN 👸 so excited to watch your reaction 😩

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Imo Canceled! is Blank Space 2.0 - it's satire. She is poking fun of people's perceptions of her friends.

Maya Reads

Lol I JUST FINISHED ZACK. Perfect timing. But also i slept 3h last might i cant. (But i will and i am)

Emma Lowell

im ashamed to admit that i didnt even consider the maga of it all with cancelled... oh no i hope she speaks on this or SOMETHING bc people will be so mad

Forty2times

I think it's world timing too. Bc the amt of Maga moms on Facebook that are gonna be using that song...

briar

the second plane … i’m ready

Nora

You didn’t like Ophelia?! Omg haha

Nefelibata

Girl is hard to see you go through this. I feel you

calm98

This!

Klarisa Loft

I’ve been waiting the whole day! YES. The makeup, the whole look is serving.

Laura E

You are right about cancelled and you should say it!!!!!

Tanvi

you look gorgeous omg

Jeremy

THIS IS TEWWW GOOD

grace, esq.

so nice to see a reaction from someone who genuinely is a swiftie and also genuinely struggling with this album like i feel crazy

Nicole

the intro was everything to me

Tha P

LOL i had to go check if my youtube music wasnt playing in the background LOL BSB girlie here! 🙋‍♀️

Nora

(Totally fine btw I’m just shook)

erin

playing ready for it immediately after hearing the first song off the album sent me into the stratosphere

Holly

Dang I hope this grows on you!! Totally fair reaction but I am personally obsessed

kRiStAvAnG

The album is definitely a different vibe. I’ve listened to it 5x through today and so far only 2 songs has really stuck to me. People are saying it’s a grower….so imma let it grow.…and if it never does, I’m okay with just the few songs that will.

Hannah

Yess max martin intro !!! Backstreet Boys. Lollll

Jade Olivia

I had the EXACT SAME reaction to the first two songs and I feel so seen 😭

Laurel

Omg I thought I’d be at work but miscalculated the time and JUST GOT HOME FROM WORK. Yay!!!

Holly

God forbid Taylor is secure

Danielaaaa

Ngl the notes that I had- mainly the Elizabeth Taylor over and over😗 she’s a cute girl but yeah lolz I liked it overall!!

Nicola

I’m literally having a full on crisis like I saw a clip of the graham Norton interview and I just couldn’t watch it

Mary Massed

“I think I’d like to say nothing about that” is so relatable.

Vanessa Vieites

I just assumed cancelled was about Blake lively being dragged through that astroturfing campaign by Justin baldoni and his team

Archie

Diva after this reaction we need an emergency video asap after you have lived with the album for a little longer and saw the explanations from her

anne

it’s morning in Manila after the release day and i’m still in my bed, cannot get up because i legitimately feel SICK because of how bad the album is!! now i’m ready to get up and make coffee and watch your reaction!!!!! i think reactions to this album will be more entertaining and satisfying than the album itself 😂😫

Vikki

Cancelled! is my immediate favourite by a mile.

Tayswiffer

Somebody needs to make a gif of Madeline's face when she looks up after reading "I have been afflicted by a terminal uniqueness". It is KILLING ME.

Archie

The midnights comment is so on POINT this was what I expected midnights production to sound like, darker pop

Nicole

The immediate.. “that could be about anybody” I’m dead 😂

Edith Ferrufino

Oh my godddd. I want to press play so bad rn!!! I just got to a boys house 🤠🤠🤠 you know hehe. Low-key want to just drive away and say an emergency came up.

Swiftologist

I def cheer for defending Blake Lively!! Still can't cheer for the song though

Sheryl Guerrero

She says “I protect the family” 6 times.

Danielle

been dying for your reaction all day 😭

Elaine

I’m seated, I’m sat, I’m ready. It’s Madeline’s turn, yay!

Erin

Girl I don’t think Taylor could fathom what Eldest Daughter was about either.

Diego Del Rey

At first when you posted not liking cancelled I was confused but after reading the description i understand 100% why I forgot about that… thank you for reminding me 😂

John Santana

So interesting seeing a total different type of reaction than zach, I’m interested to see you both discuss it. Especially just comparing moments that made you go pause here that made him get excited. Ofc yall will be civilized about it but as someone who reacted more like Zach, it is confusing when Madeline would be appalled at something that I just didn’t see being an issue. I’m excited for the next podcast

anne

i feel you. when elizabeth taylor came on i instantly felt anxious that the album was going to be baaaaad

Noni

She was secure when she wrote Reputation and look at the difference.

Laurel

Oh Madeline…..I’m just at the reset. I feel for you. You look amazing.

melissa_meritt

Thank you so much for sharing this reaction! ❤️

Becky

Your makeup is gorgeous! I’m sorry this may not have been the experience you hoped for but since I’m watching a reaction, this is so much better than I could have ever imagined. How you feel about the album doesn’t affect my feelings, I’m here to hear you. Your emotional struggle here and how you articulated it from your words, to your facial expressions and body language was SO entertaining. And that’s your job! 👏 Miss Piggy would be proud.

Casey Fison

so excited to see what you think

melissa_meritt

I think she sampled the Jackson 5? Love! ❤️

Nefelibata

The asthma attack after listening to “cokes got you brave”

Kylee

Spotted: Ophelia doing the stage dive back into the water. You know Madeline, selective hearing is truly an incredible tool when accurately paired with that insane Shellback melody & production. 👏👏 (Double clap count? You get it.)

Danielaaaa

the chip😭😭 GAG and you look so good queenie🤍

j.bean

Not you and Zack both feeling humiliated for a moment in costume. I’m with you 😭 James, what was that…

Kylee

You’re trying to pinpoint the era and I know exactly what you’re saying!! It’s late 70s mixed with mid 90s — that’s where I’ve got it right now, girly. I watched a little bit of one of her interviews and one of the morning show hosts was spiraling out a little bit, you could tell she was really nervous, and she spews out something about 80s synth pop, and you could tell by the look Taylor flashes her that she was thinking, ohh she definitely doesn’t get it. 🤣

Abby

Obsessed with your walkout music queen 🥰

Girl so in love 💝

Eldest Daughter is the worst Taylor song I’ve heard I’m crying I wanted to love this album

Abby

OMG YOU LOOK SO GOOD 🔥

Bean

The boa is OFF 😩

K Scott

OMGGGGG IM SO EXCITED FOR MADELINE CANCELLED REACTION

Amy Cosner

My exact reaction to Eldest Daughter!! I just want the incredible song that's somewhere in there between the meme speak and attempts at a viral TikTok sound 😣

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Sheep in wolves clothing is such an eldest daughter vibe. She is sooooo good. ✨

Katy Anne

Never thought I’d ever say this- but I wish I ordered the clean version of this album

Mskyma

Like Archduke Franz Ferdinand being shot…

Mavi💖

This reaction is everything I hoped for and more. We stan an honest diva "it's her right" when listening to wood I'm diying

X

Cancelled is about Blake Lively. Literally every lyric in the chorus is a Blake Lively reference.

j.bean

Also the hair glitter is glittering 🫶

Charlotte

tbh i dont think actually romantic is necessarily in response to SIAK, it seems like charli has been saying shit behind the scenes too so i wish she wouldve delved more into that lyrically to prevent confusion

Mikey

THE RESET IS TAKING ME OUTTTTTT

Emily Elser

I went to the release party in theaters and honestly thought some of the clean lyrics were better than the original

X

TS hasn't even known brittany long enough for brittany to have stood by her while she was being cancelled.

Ally ❤️

The you were just a pose/she was in her phone is about Trav’s ex—

briar

i too had to pop out the nebulizer during my first listen of the album … lmao

Travis

First listen I was way too focused on the lyrics and I got so bamboozled and only liked 2 songs. Today I just put it on in the background and now I GET IT I don’t know why but it needed some time I think it was just a very different energy than what I expected and that threw me off

Maurice

the Actually Romantic GAG LMFAO

Ally ❤️

Same! Sans the dick versions… for the first time, I opted for clean versions of FF and Actually Romantic

Casey Dodd

The father figure clean version is soooooooo much better in my opinion

bluetybloop

i was super confused about your cancelled! reaction but i think i understand it better now. i really liked cancelled! only because it feels SO CLEARLY about blake. That she "girlbossed a little too close to the sun" is a direct Candace Owens quote. "CANCELLED" (spelled with 2 Ls) was a headline from the daily mail about blake. the firm "i do not give a shit if she has controversies, she's my friend; she stood by me and i'm standing by her" is actually really meaningful and it will encourage other women to stand behind blake as well. to me, that outweighs the potential of people interpreting the song as being about brittany, because imo it is MORE IMPORTANT that people have support blake lively than that they condemn taylor's friendship with brittany. i mean this politically. the fallout of the amber heard trial and the blake livley cancellation has had a silencing impact on pretty much every victim of sexual violence that i know, including myself. for someone as well-liked as taylor to be so unabashedly loyal to a women who has gone through this public lashing is incredibly meaningful and I appreciate her deeply for that. i can see why you think the song is irresponsible, but i don't think it's as clear cut as the song being "objectively" a bad look.

Ally ❤️

The scorching that Scott Borschetta got from FF 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Lily Sea

We love an HONEST REVIEW!! Love you and the REFRESHING energy you bring to your reviews! I absolutely felt the same way on the undertones of this album… like, not to be reading too much into things, but this album is so tone deaf.

Kris Knutson

About eldest daughter, Taylor loves to flip a metaphor. First born children/daughters have no older siblings to watch and learn from; they will make the mistakes, get hurt, and learn from their own mistakes. Their younger siblings learn from their mistakes. So, they weren’t wolves in sheep’s clothing (i.e., something dangerous/threatening pretending to be innocent), they were the first lamb to the slaughter (i.e., the innocent child being harmed by a cruel world…think Robin “the time will arrive for the cruel and the mean, you’ll learn to bounce back like your trampoline. But for now we’ll curtail your curiosity. In sweetness”). Thus the sheep in wolves’ clothing. She was innocent and naive and had to dress herself as the big bad wolf and pretend she was a “bad bitch.” Taylor is an eldest child, a daughter. Travis is a youngest child.

Drew Rosen

not u skipping ruin the friendship

Deli

Does anyone else hate the “oh oh ohs” in opalite. And it sounds christmassy too (I personally don’t like Christmas music)

Vee

They’re rlly getting her on Twitter and TikTok for it like it’s bad 😭 and i kinda agree writing a song about how u like ur friends cancelled when ur friends with brittany mahomes. Like the song is definitely about blake but i understand why people are mad with her it is tone deaf

Giovani

The thing to remember is we’ve NEVER gotten a Taylor record where she’s fully like I have found the one, I can just make something for me, for him, for us. So much so, that I’m actually going to, with my full chest, just say what I’ve been wanting to. And suddenly, she does that, and everyone hates it. It’s strange. Like think about why she held back so much in reputation, she probably felt somewhere intuitively deep inside that Joe was not forever. And Joe, as a muse, didn’t invoke anything but a feeling of security as she tried to mend her wounds. A lot of reputation is co-dependent, whereas LOASG is very I’m in love and it feels like a drug and this is what happens when you take that drug. In addition, we’re all so used to intellectualizing EVERYTHING SHE DOES that you (not Madeline specifically, just in general) can’t even just like enjoy the music anymore. Like a showgirl’s life is not glamorous… so idk why people thought the album would be 12 ICDIWBH. A showgirls life is incredibly normal, and that’s what makes her a showgirl, is because when she goes on the stage, you forget she’s literally just a person living her life.

anne

hahaha good lord :(((

Nicole

Thank you for sharing your initial reaction with us queen. I still don’t know how I feel about many songs. Sometimes songs need to sit with me for a bit before I really know. 🫶🏼🤍

Noni

That's just plain inaccurate. Reputation is not a co-dependent, insecure album at all. It's a pure love album. She flat out says, "You don't need to save me" in Call It What You Want. And affirms their commitment to each other through the good and bad times in New Year's Day.

bluetybloop

i can see how anyone who interprets the song as being even mildly ambiguous would be very annoyed. i'm just far too steeped in the depressing lore of this bullshit trial to NOT know what it's about. it's probably she could have been more specific. while someone REALLY invested in defending blake (me lol) would get the references immediately, most people aren't going to get that and are going to take what they want out of it. for every person mad at taylor for being friends with mahomes, there's at least one person very invested in her being friends with brittany because it would justify supporting the president while creepy potshots at her. at least in their tiny minds.

Gabrielladid

The discussion between madeline and Zach is going to be incredible!!

Kyley

You look amazing

John

I had the same thoughts on cancelled

Jaymie

omg Madeline your facial expressions kill me!

Miss Liz

Here’s my issue with Eldest daughter…I was right there for “I’m not a bad bitch” especially right now with teenage kids and work and on and on. That’s something I could scream sing in the car. But to follow it up with promising to also not let someone down? That’s adding more to the list of all of the responsibilities to me…unless I’m not fully getting it. Will see. It’s still not a skip for me always.

Lisa

I love father figure so much! Definitely my favorite. Madeline, when I watched your reaction to Chloë, Sam, Sophia, or Marcus and you had this moment where you just saw the vision and understood everything in a moment – I feel like I had that experience when I listened to father figure! I’m pretty sure it’s about Scott Borchetta and when she flips the perspective to herself being the father figure with big dick energy as she whispers “I protect the family“ I gasped out loud. I feel like I just saw the vision right away. Also, if I’m right, then I think “protecting the family“ refers to her masters-they are her family

Teresa Johnston

I definitely see where you're coming from with cancelled. I just jumped to Blake but I do think she needs to think about how these songs are going to be used on social media.

Sierra ♡

I am cryingggg at your first reaction to Actually Romantic 😭😭

Tony

YOUR LOOK IS GORGINA! SHOWSTOPPING! CVNT SERVE OF THE EON. 🦎🫶🏼

Cassandra Griffiths

“…well that could be about anyone” I literally spat out my drink laughing so hard

Celeste

I’m glad I’m not the only one that clocked the 70’s sound. Opalite, the oh oh ohs literally sound like the Eddie Money song Take Me Home Tonight. The part that the featured singer Ronnie Spector does. Then you have the Jackson 5 soundalike song, Wood. Actually Romantic has a bit of Teenage Dirtbag sound. I love the album, but it seems like a LOT of “inspiration” has been used throughout. At least Wishlist sounds like her own song, Glitch. LOVE your review!!! Can’t wait for the video where you and Zach are together, chatting about the album.

Maria Augusta

well the last thing i expected to get from your reaction was it being soo funny!! I laughed so much with the faces you made! And about the CANCELLED! perspective i did not think of it as a far right anthem until you pointed it and now i can't unsee it ._.

Jenny Gustafson

Her friends were also cancelled for stupid things?

Megan Dohm

Your reaction and mine are aligned. 😄

V

I had pretty much the same reaction to the album. Especially cancelled. No one will hate you for saying that Lizard Queen. And yes to the “I love Travis and hate all women”😫 it was the vibe she gave off. And she called women in honey and the title track bitches in like mean ways not in like a “taking the word back” way, which is kinda… hypocritical when you think about Kanye famous-gate lol. Like oh so now it’s okay to call women bitches? Nowww of all times? Coupled with her silence on the administration and women’s rights stripped…. Like no matter how she means it, she’s adult enough to get how it comes off😫

elly belly

can’t wait to hear you guys talk about the album eeeeekkk

Becky

“Wood” makes me think of Sabrina as Rachel McAdams and Taylor as Amy Poehler in the “I’m not a regular mom” scene

stella greene

the dramatic introduction was needed

popestanleytucci💔

Spinning ready for it and taking a sip of champagne as a palate cleanser/coping mechanism killed me

Drew Rosen

She realizes at the end of the video thank god

Jenny Gustafson

MAGA are the ones cancelling people since a good few years?

Savvy

Did she skip ruin the friendship?

Danielaaaa

Madeline the way you said chihuahua gagged me

Ashley

Madeline, serving! Loved the intro! 🫶✨

kyla

she mentioned that it wasn’t in her saved album at the start and i don’t know why she decided not to go to the album page and play the full thing lol

Andrew Farmer

Taylor is and always has been “cringe.” In some ways I think this is a return to form, just as TTPD was a return to diaristic, confessional writing. There are so many precedents to songs people are “getting her” for. “Actually Romantic” is punching down and just as obnoxious as “Better Than Revenge” and “Mean” “Wood” is sexually TMI like “Guilty as Sin” and “Dress” (albeit far less eloquent or interesting, and loaded with jokes) As for Cancelled… nothing could be more MAGA than “Picture to Burn (Homophobic Version)” in my mind. In summary, Taylor is really gagging fans who joined around Folklore, but the OGs know she has always been cringey, whacking people over the head with her lyrics, and as Madeline says, “rich and a little bit of a biieeetch (LMFAO, btw)” I’m so happy with this album.

K.C.

here for the blown out bday candle scent appreciation 🎂

makanani

so it goes is actually the perfect song to encompass tloasg

Joey Caleb

You made the right decision. Exposing Van Gogh to this level of pop girl cuntitude would blow the other ear off 😭

Kalyn

ME TOO!!

Eden McFadden

she played it at the end asked skipping it accidentally

makanani

the megaphone is everything

Sam

the immediate confused face seconds into the album LMAOOO….yeah

hayden

my only thoughts are james… what was that

Hey12345

I study the radical right in political science and U.S. History (post 1913). I monitor the far right, the Bannon RW, paleoconservatives; the ideological framework that has defined maga. It’s pretty clear to me that in *both* “Wish List” (very trad wife coded), and “Cancelled” & that other petty song, she’s at best very absorbed in Travis’ world, including his friends & the women in that universe. Taylor is an adult with free agency, but I recognize the language. Wasn’t Matty Healy exposed saying highly racist and problematic things? It really seems to me that Taylor majorly overlooks values and/or behaviors when she is extremely invested in a romantic relationship.

David

I mean what else is she gonna write about him other that his dick? Exactly

V

Also it’s funny how the “hey thank you for the lovely bouquet” from title track chorus is note for note the Jonas brother “cool” chorus🤣🤣🤣 so random🤣 and the “it’s locked inside my memory” form Ophelia is exactly like the “And there’s no remedy for memory” from Lana’s dark paradise, even same ending word. Idk very random🤣

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

I love Cancelled. I can very clearly see where she's coming from with it and who she's referencing. I also agree with the general message, "I'm gonna get to know you before I make decisions about you based on the GP" and just overall not placing much value in others reputation after hers was dragged through the mud for no good reason. I can see how that can absolutely be criticized when it comes to Brittany Mahomes, but CANCELLED! is mainly just a cunty serve. If we're gonna include her friendships why skip over the one she's actually talking about (this is not in response to Madeline, but the general public). Let's not forget that song can also easily apply to Sabrina before Brittany. It's not the best time for her to release it, but 2017 was also not the best time for her to release Reputation. Whoever wants to misinterpret it will do that, same as whoever wanted to think she was actually a snake after Reputation misinterpreted her. I wish she would've been more clear, though. Same with Actually Romantic.

mallorey garrett

YOU SAID EVERYTHING THAT I AM THINKING QUEEN! Thank God I’m not the only one!!!!

popestanleytucci💔

The midnights clock EXACTLY!!! Ugh I love your take doll as always

Saanal

Okay repeating myself but…these looks y’all served for this moment absolutely bodied. Speechless. Stunning performance.

Jaymie

My popcorn will be ready for your review.

K.C.

I need a super cut of both snakes reaction faces from today 🙏🙏

makanani

it took me until my second listen to like the first half of the album lol like i needed to warm up 😂 by actually romantic i was all in and loves the back half then restarted and loved the songs so much after i didn't like them a couple min ago the first time around. it's grown on me so much since then. i'm obsessed with all the tracks but honestly those first two tracks on my first listen were WORRISOME 💀

Nicole

Coming home from a Taylor Swift club night at 3am and immediately locking in

Lain Kiverling

Love your reaction as always, please always keep it real this was soo entertaining

Vanessa Vieites

Yes! I clocked it as being about Blake too

Anna

you are the funniest person alive i was dyinggggg

Vanessa Vieites

My fave is father figure. That outro 🥺

Forty2times

The amt of Maga moms that are going to be using Cancelled! over tik toks & on facebook😅🤣

Miranda

As Actually Romantic came on all I could hear was London Boy…am I cuckoo? I need a mashup expeditiously

Andrew Guthrie

I honestly didn’t make the “CANCELLED” connection to the current (TOXIC) political climate, but I can definitely see what you’re saying right away. That being said, I really enjoy the vibes and the drama emenating from the song. ..but it’s definitely fair to say “shhhhhhh… not now pls”

Catherine Coleman

Actually Romantic 💀 I’m cackling at your reaction

Becky

I think it’s absolutely The Life of a Showgirl! It’s about the things happening in her real life in addition to having to be a Showgirl during the tour. Falling in love, the fight to get her Masters, possibly a friend passing away that she went back to TN for, Brat being released, relationship scrutiny and professional scrutiny on Travis - the real backstage.

miya

you look sooooo beautiful!! your reactions were exactly the way i reacted the first time too 😭😭😭 the first few songs are fine i guess but i wasn't gagged or even dancing to them or anything, then eldest daughter and that chorus made me cringe i cant 😭 after actually romantic i had to take a break for a min bc it really felt unnecessarily mean, i HATE wood its just too much, cancelled is sooo corny and tone deaf what are we doingggg im just sooo confused at every song tbh and i haven't even WANTED to play it again, but after getting to listen to it the second time on zach's reaction and bits here, i dislike it more and more 😭😭 i dont knowwww

K.C.

this is sophisticated thinking, but I see a lot of smart takes doing a lot of work to excuse Taylor of the responsibility of her writing. she did C- writing on this album. it's just what it is. also to your point: a billionaire's life is glamorous????

Vanessa Vieites

Eldest daughter was such a let down. Ruin the friendship or father figure should’ve been the track 5

Taylor Rae

i’m choosing to believe cancelled is about blake for my peace of mind

Fernanda Suarez

I feel Taylor gaslighted everyone into believing the supposed theme of the album, It is not giving life of a showgirl much lol

Natalie

Your reaction is almost identical to how I feel!

Jade Olivia

Just finished watching. Thank you for keeping it real with us as always, lizard! You’re def not alone in your feelings and reactions here.

Diego Del Rey

Did she skip ruin the friendship?

Vanessa Vieites

Well apparently the kids are “anti woke” now and bringing back all the slurs and she’s trying to appeal to them so this tracks *sigh *

Miranda

Also - in Wood 🙄 she capiltalizes “New Heights of manhood” It PMO!!!

Bryson Moran

This is such a hilarious reaction as someone who’s now processed the album

Alexandre Marcelino

this reaction is so opposite to mine and that's everything to me i'm obsessed

K.C.

really good call on the anachronistic writing!!! drives me nuts. Ophelia, towers & vibes 💅

Amanda

Thank you diva!!!! 🦎

Leslie

That killed me, I had to go back and watch it several more times

Bridgitte

Madeline you are one of my favorite humans in the world lmfao this is FASCINATING to watch especially after Zach’s

Liv

Your reaction to Actually Romantic is actually everything to meeeee

Erin

Yes and I think the way it’s CANCELLED! is absolutely on purpose as that’s how Trump announces who he hates on social media. And Trump said he loves Brittany Mahomes so… kind of anti-MAGA if you think about it. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Megan Claire Hatfield

The way that this was my exact reaction song for song. I’ve literally been waiting for your reaction all day because I’m like wait how is everyone’s reaction not exactly this

K.C.

sorry also hate to ask but love bra! where from?

karisa

just saw you take out the megaphone… going to predict it will be used several times in this reaction

K.C.

👏👏👏

SM R

I actually like most of the album, it’s also continued to grow on me but Eldest Daughter (at this moment) has not and it was disappointing for me. It’s currently the lowest ranked song for me on the album and out of all her track 5s but I liked watching your interpretation of the song.

jacquie o

Madeline you look amazing

Maria Chavez

I feel Cancelled is more about Sabrina more than Blake, really don’t see Brittney in it

Kenna

It’s so funny to see Madeline struggle with this album because that’s how I felt with ttpd when it first came out. You’ll come around. I certainly did 😂

Deli

I low-key hate this album. This is the first time it’s ever happened. Even lover didn’t leave me feeling this way. The agregious lyrics about slang and Travis’s dick. The unpleasant casual misogyny run rampant. The mediocre melodies. The tone deafness of cancelled. Actually romantic is so cheesy and poorly written, even tho it is a GAG. Saying her dick is bigger was off putting. The only song I can find myself listening to is ruin the friendship because it is so sweet and shows a glimpse of old Taylor. I kind of enjoy Elizabeth Taylor. But wow. I can’t believe she flopped THIS hard. Anyone else?

phoenix

The backstreet boys intro unlocked something feral inside of me

V

Dark times😫

tyler

is it hateration for me to say jack and aaron...come home the kids miss you

Deli

Girl I thought the same thing. I was also excited to watch her hear that the first lyric is about a megaphone lol.

Deli

It is so cute!

Kaitlyn Garrison

She referred to the album content as what goes on after the show, behind the scenes of a show girl. And more than half the songs are i love travis. you could have said that any time! don't promise me musings of a super star and not deliver! It's not even that it's bad, it's that what she described is not what was made here. I think she tried to pretend it's another extension of the eras tour to give it more traction. I'm interested in what she's going to do next. She said there's no more songs for the album, but I think with the reception she might end up adding a few more songs that maybe didn't make the cut. Like, releasing a surprise deluxe version and say that was always the plan and I fooled you! This album was baffling to me.

Erin

And who types in all capitalized letters with exclamation points (like how the title is typed) riling up their base to hate someone and cancel them? 🤔 And that same person said they liked Brittany…

K.C.

take all my money, Madeleine, we agree!! 😭 I toootally thought the same re: 70s inflected folk pop was what I was expecting on the midnights that wasn't

Selina

as one diva said, "suddenly I feel like a fool in my headdress." and I hope Mason got the full vision today! gorgina 🫶

Erica

Nooooo stop cutting yourself off from saying your thoughts we wanna HEAR!! (And the ones you did say THANK YOU had a similar first listen)

Katie

completely agree. some of the songs are enjoyable to me but overall feels like a continuation of the decline of quality of her music in the past few years.

Leslie

It's about "oh shit I need a track 5 for this album"

Makayla R

I was confused about how Eldest Daughter was combining those two themes, but luckily Taylor kind of explained it and made it more understandable. This idea of being the Eldest Daughter having to put on the brave face, taking care of the family, needing to be strong for everyone, not show emotion. That is connected to this idea of apathy on social media. And then in the chorus she says how as the eldest daughter she still is loving and nurturing and finding joy. So the lyrics make more sense now, however I was hoping for it to be targeted on being the eldest daughter and the responsibility and hardship of it. So it’s technically my most disappointing song on the album. Probably would skip occasionally but I don’t hate it.

Sofie DLC

Oh I love the world market candles! Pink musk is a perfect pick for showgirl for sure

chappell roan

all this sympathy is just a... bullet? that took 3 tries to hit the target?

April

I walked out 30 min into the amc event. I think maybe I was expecting something different but I felt lile I could get all that on YouTube for free

April

I got got by taycapitalism

chappell roan

first verse is about swiftologist chorus is about Karlie kloss second verse is about me bridge is about Obama

Emma Brown

Thank you for being you Madeline

K.C.

THE TRUTH IS HEALING

Deli

Yes! It won’t stop declining and that is devastating. I don’t understand why she won’t try her best. If we got an album like soeak now today it would be crazy bc her artistry had gone so downhill since then.

Danielle

i think my biggest issue with it is she overestimated how much we actually care about her an travis. like yes we love the love story but there is a theme and you talking about his dick does not fall into that!

K.C.

baffling.

K.C.

crazy I said the same to my sis!! 😭

Katie

feeling similarly about this album....this is the first time where i've felt genuinely underwhelmed and a little bit repulsed by the vibe. she comes across as not a nice person? which is so contradictory to her public persona. ruin the friendship is my fave off of the album, i love her when she is being wistful

Nicola

Snakes I feel really sadddd I’m just down now ahhh look at least we have ttpd

Katie

i also keep thinking about what Zach said in his live earlier today, that there are "good" songs on this album but no "great" ones....

Elaine

I don’t hate you for your commentary on ‘cancelled!’. Why the double ‘l’? IDK, regardless you’re right. It’s all a bit tone deaf. I think she’s still mad about the whole Matty Healy thing, when his racist podcast comments came out and honestly? I think she ghosted him, lol. She’s still mad at some of her fans for the pressure they put on her because she truly didn’t get why people were upset, and this song - not a very good one - is part 2.

Nicola

Woah yeah I have a ticket for tomorrow I’m debating not going

Elaine

Does this mean ‘wood’ is now 45 seconds long?

Erin

Eh… the MAGA moms also used Not Ready To Make Nice for videos. It was funny irony then and it’s going to be funny irony now because they are the masters of cancelling people and TALKING IN ALL CAPS WITH EXCLAMATION POINTS!! while also saying they hate “cancel culture” lol.

April

Im gonna be so honest. It was not good. There's barely any exclusive content and its just small clips before each song of Taylor speaking on her thought process. It was fun and cute to see all the little girls having fun and dressing up but also loud and disruptive lol

Miranda

Also also - rhythm on life of a showgirl is giving Jonas Brothers cool and Charli Boom Clap. I think Max is spent on beats 😬

Sabrina 💖

it's something I love about you madeline like I love the album so much and there's a lot of hate about it online which is like... upsetting negativity vibes but seeing your genuine self move through the emotions of being like what am I listening to lmao is so refreshing even the way you talk about the songs/writing you don't like feels very authentic rather than hateration idk if this makes sense

Ashlee

Definitely feel the same. I think the album was marketed as “show girl” and we were all expecting more of a concept album with cruel summer level bangers (because of the way they described it on the podcast) but this is really “I love Travis” mixed with rage. I guess it’s like lover/rep mixture but without any songs in my mind that really stand out. But I do really enjoy the title track. Maybe once we all are used to the fact this isn’t what we were told it was, it’ll grow on us. 🫶🏻

Jomazel

your looooook hereeee eeeeeekkkkkkkk💚

Brandon H

So I hate to be hateful, but the “we all dressed up as wolves and we looked fire” line is by far the worst lyric she’s ever written. Like no one around to tweet it is Shakespeare compared to this. Loved the reaction though ❤️‍🔥

Gail

Your reaction to actually romantic is killllling me😭😂

Laura

I see a lot of people saying that it’s still on the theme because she’s a showgirl and it’s everything happening in her life, but that can literally be said about every song she could possibly write (unless it’s fictional), so I find this excuse incredibly weak. I think it’s completely valid to want to see more of an exploration of what specifically being a performer and being so famous is like on all of the songs.

Maria

Can't believe she skipped Ruin The Friendship... I was wondering if she was gonna cry 😄

tea with GRIFFON

I really loved the album, and I am trying to maintain my peace; is this video going to make upset, or is it mainly positive?

Deli

This is the first time I have ever been able to tell a white woman billionaire who loves self righteous feminism wrote this. The misogyny actually surprised me in Honey and TLOAS. The tone deafness in wishlist and cancelled. It’s getting harder to separate art from artist

Paula C

I agree. Every time she says protect the family I want to tear up

Diego Del Rey

I thought I was the only one who noticed

Alex

visceral ick with the fate of Ophelia, opening the album with the concept that she would have been lost forever if not for this one specific guy?? Tayfeminism is dead? Father figure was a GAG but otherwise there is a shallowness, lack of humility, and a kind of darkness ‘I give up’-ness to it in a weird counterintuitive way. When I heard cancelled I truly thought why could she be singing this from the perspective of Donald trump. I felt like a different lady wrote most of this album (ruin the friendship excepted). I don’t know.

Allison Gobeil

Really disappointed in the lack of “showgirl”.

Deli

It probably is; were you too smug? Line probably references how everyone thought she was rude in interviews

chappell roan

I know most of this will probably stay on the patreon but I personally think the world needs to see your actually romantic reaction, specifically "this could be about anyone!"

Anna Rama

Cancelled! was one of my (few) favourites, but now that I've heard Madeline's reaction, I can't unhear the MAGA-anthem potential... And then there's the showing off the ring, making every interview about him, that line in Wishlist, dedicating her track five to her declaration of love and commitment to him, the existence of the song Wood ... I think she's trav/dwiving way too much for my liking. Should I even go see the release party? I don't want to anymore.

G

I don’t get the big deal a lot of people are making about that lyric

Deli

SAME WHY WOULD SHE CAPITALIZE THAT it’s just like she’s forcing references in

Alex

I thought she would have more to say : /

Eden McFadden

Couldn’t agree more than nothing really stood out :/

Lissi Tamayo

dont be shy tell us your first thoughts

Madelin Siedler

I didn't hate TFOO nearly as much as Madeline, BUT the whole "I was trapped in a tower until you saved me" angle is atrocious. Like no, girl, you were headlining the biggest world tour in history and he was a peanut with a friendship bracelet who got bounced from outside your door.

Jamie

I’m here to say that he intro to this video was iconic. I’m seeing them in Vegas on NYE and this intro just made my 40 year old BSB heart so happy! 🫶

Taylor

I’ve been saying the exact same thing about this album sonically being what I had expected for midnights!

Deli

Same it was so… unprofound. Shallow. It didn’t provoke thought or discussion. Every song is exactly as it seems. This same person wrote ttpd? Folklore? I can’t believe it

Shondi

Diva DOWN. This album was…not good :( Even after a few re-listens, I just can’t get on board. Was expecting SO much more from a Max Martin/Shellback & Taylor collab. Super disappointing!

Rebecca

Paid to see this reaction. WORTH EVERY PENNY

James

To be fair, TTPD had a lot more to work with in terms of volume. We're talking 31 tracks vs 12.

Kenna

Oh absolutely! I feel like I’m still parsing through that whole album!

Christopher Marshburn

Disappointed we didn’t get your reaction to Ruin the Friendship. The misplaced Track 5.

Sam

I am torn about Cancelled! I don’t hate the song musically, and I do think it’s very clearly about Blake based on the part about sticking by Taylor when she was canceled. That would have nothing to do with Brittany or really anyone but Blake at this point. Through that lens, I think the intention of the song is simply to make a “public statement” about Blake and correcting the discourse that they’re no longer friends. I doubt MAGA was even a consideration. I am not 100% up on the Blake situation because I just don’t care, but from my view it always seemed like her only provable “crime” was being really fucking annoying and arrogant.

Elaine

‘A 🥜 with a friendship bracelet who got bounced’. This is sending me, lol

Hannah H

It’s at the end

Eden McFadden

No seriously like even after midnights I didn’t feel so disappointed. None of the songs stood out and I don’t feel like any of the songs, even title track, really fit the theme. :/

anna stimac

Ruin the friendship is the standout track from this album. Not showgirl at all but I cried almost everytime I heard it. It’s beautiful. Elizabeth Taylor maybe the only showgirl song here.

Rachel

I’m hearing John Travolta say Tracy Turnblad when she hits the ohs in opalite

Elaine

IDK, man. Almost the entirety of ‘wood’ is utterly hideous. Like, come ON.

lorena

i could see the light of hope in your eyes when you liked elizabeth taylor. i loveeeed the reaction Madeline and you look amazing

Emily Sawich

I also that CANCELLED was directly about Blake and loved it for that! Taylor should have said it was about her in the movie instead of being so vague and it would be better for PR because I also do see Madeline's point as well....

Gracie Day

Actually Romantic is actively ripping off “Where is my Mind?” by the Pixies and I don’t know why it’s not a bigger conversation! I guess it’s just a chord progression but it’s the same tempo and so obvious. I think it’s a pretty funny song but I have to say, “Sympathy is a knife” is a much better song. I wasn’t planning on being Taynegative but this was a worse experience than when Midnights came out. Appreciating TTPD even more now

Tyler

I don’t think canceled is supposed to be maga, I think she’s just very out of touch and thinks like when the internet freaks out like when she dated Matty is the whole experience of cancellation

Elaine

She’s always got to have a beef with somebody, and it’s making me so very, very tired. Very tired. Yes, I know that’s Taylor, blah, blah, blah. But folklore and evermore and, to an extent, TTPD had nuance and style. But, I really loved this production on this, tbh. It was a refreshing change, but come back Aaron and Jack! Max and Shell, you’ve served us well, but that’s enough for now.

oPaulo

This reaction compared to ttpd is so sadddd. Madeline i feel bad for you because you look so disappointed. I hope atleast some songs click in place for you 🤞

Genevieve Smith

The GASP immediately follow by silence and then... “ that could be about anybody” made me WHEEZE

Deli

This album made me love So High School, crickets. We didn’t know what we were in for. Not to get all Joe widow, but I think that something in Travis and his field and his friend group don’t bring out artistic excellence. They don’t have to, that’s fine, but Taylor is letting it affect her work I think? What are y’all’s thought?

chloe or sam or grace or marcus

the sudden egregious use of the word "btch" to refer to other women on this album was among many of the lyrical choices that left me slightly reeling and wondering who tf i was listening to... that coupled with the untimely implications of cancelled... we are in dark times girls.

Elaine

I really loved the production on this album, but yes. Back you come, Aaron and Jack!

Aderra

It is lover 2.0 unfortunately...

Nici Z.

Yes, the same person before she got (Ah!)matized...🙄

Lindsay

Oh yikes I listened to the pixies song….

Jh

charisma

10:49 my reaction exactly

Laa Toii

This is a five songs album to me, the rest are just so bad and i don’t think it’ll grow on me. She tried too much to make an album that travis will love and it seems he has horrible taste

mallorey garrett

Even if she didn’t like it, it shouldn’t ruin your love for it. I don’t get that..

Lauren

Her reaction to Ruin the Friendship is at the end of the video, she realized she missed a track!

Ian Sanchez

I think this is extremely fair for a first reaction. My first listen was the most chaotic first listen for any album, let alone a Taylor album. I remember being confused listening to TTPD but it was still different than this. Definitely not what I expected, but I don't hate it. I just think, compared to TTPD, the stakes were much higher because there are only 12 tracks and no more on the way compared to TTPD which had 16 and eventually 31.

Emily Sawich

😂😂😂this comment is so funny I'm dead 😂😂😂

Elaine

She covered it at the very end when she realized she’d accidentally skipped.

Brandon H

Very true! But what does being the eldest daughter have anything to do with looking fire dressed as a wolf 🤣🤣

Brandon H

And she’s saying it with a straight face

Elaine

🤮

sandrine

MADELINE THE TRUE SHOWGIRL❤️‍🔥

loathinglately

NO BUT WHAT DO AARON AND JACK THINK I NEED TO KNOWWWW

Alyssa (originalparafan)

I’m scared that I don’t want to replay any of the songs. The only song that hit first listen as catchy was Ophelia, sonically it was like yesss great pop song. Everything else to me is more social commentary than actual stand alone songs.

Leslie M

LMAO I love it so much 🤷🏻‍♀️

Deli

I love that! I was talking about the lyrics (I should’ve specified that lol) but I def need to listen more and focus on production

Sarah Dunsmore

maga anthem is facts and its actually not funny

Gracie Day

Absolutely. Agreed. Also… she claimed, as a music industry fan always watching TRL, that she never heard 3LW’s “the players gonna play and haters gonna hate”… don’t believe it for a second!

CHRIS 01 🪽 #HOUSEWIFE

i was so disappointed and went through the 5 stages of grief last night, but now im accepting it. ‘til the next album 😭

Elaine

Internalized misogyny is the very worst. But so many women are susceptible to it and some even embrace it. Gross and offensive.

Vanessa Vieites

So that one’s my favorite too but when I heard it I didn’t really catch the switch up to her bring the father figure. Who is she being a father figure to? Not Scott Borschetta…I get the reclaiming the masters link but when she says “I WAS your father figure” at the end who’s the father figure and who’s the protege ?

Amber

"when the coke's got you brave" SHE HIT THE PENTAGON

Gracie Day

“Keep it 100” Travis poetry

V

Yes! The worst part is Taylor talking about her own internalized misogyny in miss americana being like “there is no such thing as a bitch” etc. and I’m like… come on😫 What happened😫 It does make it seem like her GOP circle is rubbing off on her vs when she was living with like liberal European art ppl in London… idk

maryna

About ruin the friendship: in another podcast someone pointed out that she sings it was not convenient to go to the grave, maybe an old classmate died when she was on tour. So this would have been one more thing that she would have had to cover up sort of put behind her and just go on with being a showgirl...

Alyssa (originalparafan)

Why is “The Fate of Ophelia” the only song that hits for me. Madeline haaaated it instantly lmao i was expecting way more energy from this album. I was expecting 1989 level pop bangers. I think my expectations were too high!

Elaine

Is the release party worth going to? I’m seeing mixed reviews but have tix for Sunday

Chelsyi

Thank GOD i am not alone in these thoughts. Lord save me bc its my sisters birthday and we got tickets to TLOASG film but lord i cant sit through lyric videos right now

Laura

I don’t think she intended cancelled to be a maga anthem, more because of the timeline for the album’s creation than anything else. But that doesn’t excuse anything, it would be so easy to just leave it off the album. Someone on her team should’ve clocked the stark similarities in rhetoric even if she somehow didn’t.

Emma Jacobs

your reaction had me DYING thank you so much for this

Emily

the way that 10 second clip of ready for it hit so hard after getting through ophelia omg thank you for your service 🫶

Maja Gunhold

this album is like every critic and bad reputation that has been lobbied at taylor in one album

Elaine

I’m the same - my reaction was much more like Zack’s right down to the disappointed face when I heard ‘wood’. I also loved the production. Once was enough for wood, never ever again. She isn’t Sabrina, with a cheeky nod and a wink, nor should she be.

magicmeyers

Madeline making the exact same faces I was while listening 😂😭 I feel so seen

Gracie Day

The cognitive dissonance of her themed marketing and the actual album is wild. You guys should rank the best matched promo and output… Midnights, Lover, this… botched AF

Vanessa Vieites

Tbf people on the left get cancelled too. The right were the OG cancel culture warriors back in the 70s and 80s and have always done it to marginalized people and people who were subversive to societal norms . So not just some MAGA delusion

Vanessa Vieites

Ruin the friendship being linked to forever winter 🥺

Casey

I was really happy that Taylor stood up for Blake on cancelled. It literally never occurred to me it was about anyone else. Blake has a campaign with Gucci, the whiskey, the flowers. It's all in the lyrics.

Tommy Collins

Someone clearly went into this with hateration

Miranda

Brought new meaning to ICDIWABH 😭

Vanessa Vieites

Top 3: father figure (Scott Borschetta tea?), actually romantic (i know i know but the production is so good and her vocals sound interesting to me) , honey (catchy and cute turns of phrases)

Elaine

Exactly. She is still mad at that open letter from some of her more parasocial fans telling her to dump Healy. I’m no fan of his, but that was a bit much, really.

Miranda

That part

Vicky

Hands down best reaction video out!!!!! I was laughing so hard. This album was diabolical!!!!!!! I love it! ❤️

Carissa

I completely understand where you are coming from with the pattern of her kinda shitting on other women in the lyrics. I thought that from first listen and was not sure if I was imagining it. ‘Bitch’ in Honey bothered me as well as ‘whoring’ in the title track. And I didn’t think of CANCELLED! in that way before and it’s a valid and good point!

Hammie

I cried listening to Ruin the Friendship too

Sara Sweet

i also summoned jack and aaron in the end.............. funny how that works...................... diva down (me)

Teresa Johnston

That being said I just saw the Actually Romantic edit from Gavin Newsom and it was 😂

Vanessa Vieites

Ruin the friendship is a gem and should’ve been a track 5

Hammie

actually romantic… “that could be about anybody” dyingggg laughing 😭

maryna

This album really is the let down of the century 😔 I'm so sad that I'm not enjoying it. I'm really only listening to two of the songs at this point and even if they didn't exist I'd be fine with it... I know this is a very harsh comment and I'm spreading a lot of negativity... But I'm just so disappointed. I feel like no one gave her criticism or made her second guess things, everybody just says yes, queen and this is the result. It does not feel like an album she has had to make for herself, because she needed it. And I understand that not every album can be ttpd in that sense, that you have to do it otherwise you're going crazy. But it feels like "I'm releasing an album because I can" at this point... 😔

Vanessa Vieites

This album was not giving showgirl. It was giving messy boots girl in a relationship who only knows how to talk about her bf lol

Anna E

I am a die-hard swiftie and I am truly disappointed in the album and seeing your reaction made me feel sane.

Elaine

Dare I say that brat is a much more cohesive and, well, sonically coherent album than Showgirl? I like Showgirl more than most on this thread it seems, and I did love the production, but what was the theme, really? My life offstage when I’m in the bath exhausted (as she said on the podcast) when really she’s sticking the knife into Borchetta (love it) and Charli (don’t love it, but it made me chuckle at the pettiness, not gonna lie). But why beef with Charli, gurl, you are 1,000 the megastar Charli will ever be.

Matthew

The punching down in Actually Romantic, the trying to apply cancel culture to normies (our friends aren’t dripping in Gucci), and thinking that most people want yachts and helicopters when we’re in this political climate/economy… it’s just nothing that I can or want to relate to

Maggie

thank you for being honest, much appreciated and i agree with you on most of your thoughts, especially about cancelled….

Vanessa

Thank you SO much for pointing out the issue with Cancelled. Even if it wasn't her intention, it's an extremely harmful/problematic message to be sending across, and i've loved her so much my whole life but this one's really making me struggle...

Vanessa Vieites

Tbf MAGA does their own cancellation of anyone even slightly left of center they don’t like so it’s not just the left who cancels people

maryna

Same. Im experiencing the biggest disconnect I have ever had with Taylor... I listened to the leaked version on Thursday and was going crazy about how untouched I am by this...

Bailey_Ann

Genuinely, I think some of the let down with this album is due to incorrect assumptions and understanding of the album. I don’t think the marketing for the album helped this fact. However, she did state that the album was not about the eras tour, on stage, it was about the life of the showgirl that only those closest to her are allowed to see, who she is when the show is over. So that said, during the European leg, she was finding love in a way she never had before, which is why I think it is the main theme.

Elaine

True, true. Not her strongest record lyrically, that’s for sure. Although ‘Father Figure’ was clever. Loved the production, though!

Emily Christine

It gets better with time lol 🤣 it’s so funny how you were procrastinating at the beginning 😅😅😅

maryna

But why release an album in the first place then? Because you're Taylor Swift and you can? 🙄

Wilderhardt

Honestly I'm so glad to see I'm not the only one who had such a mixed/negative first reaction to the album. I've listened to it several times now and I'm sorry, I'm still baffled by both music production choices and the clunky lyrical writing across the board. And now that you've pointed it out it is a little crazy how bitter she sounds in a lot of these songs, specifically toward other women? IDK, there's just a lot of wow look at all these stupid people who hate me and Travis, that's fine cuz he's got a dick the size of a redwood tree. Ummmmmmmm okay. It's not giving showgirl, it's giving I'm out of touch after hitting a new high in my career. My top songs were Elizabeth Taylor and CANCELLED!, but I totally understand your criticism of the latter. It is only adding to the out of touch tone of the whole album.

Vanessa Vieites

Well she had to write something he could understand after all

Kirby

The production of Opalite reminds me a lot of I Can See You, does anyone else hear that?

Josiah Covington

Don’t like how strongly you relate the things you’ve seen online to what the songs could be about. The version of Taylor inside everyone’s minds are different, but this came off very parasocial..

Elaine

Both worthy track 5s. Father Figure is the best track on the album, imo.

Laura

God, typo, that should’ve been “anthem,” but I’m horrified lmao

Athena Bermudez

I’m kinda relieved I’m not the only one torn on most of this album 😭

David Bergee

We need merch that says “That could be about anybody!” 😂

Vanessa Vieites

I loved the production on midnights on first listen tbh.

Vanessa Vieites

So that’s why I liked actually Romantic so much lol I loved that pixies song

cami

especially after the lyric change in better than revenge TV, it seems so out of left field for her

David Bergee

This definitely isn’t my favorite album, but if all I get out of it is Ruin The Friendship and my situationship hilariously saying it looks like she took the cover in the Steamworks hot tub, I’m happy.

Shaina

Cancelled is a good song by itself but with the added context, it is disgusting. I don't expect her to be politically correct at all times. But this is really not it. She needs to stop looking at every celebrity's cancellation from the self-projected lens of her own experience with it. A lot of her "friends" are MAGA and Blake Lively/Ryan Reynolds are straight up Hollywood villains (they got married in a plantation, mind you!) With everything that's going on right now, it feels disgusting. It's a song for white supremacists and elitist wealth hoarders. I would've liked it during reputation but not this! And I think this is a hazard when you're not only a famous white billionaire but also pride yourself on being offline and tuning out the noise. Maybe if Taylor did watch the news, saw what people have been saying about her said "friends" from a bird's eye view, and actually saw what kind of people are actually being criticized and cancelled, she wouldn't have put this song out.

Vanessa Vieites

agreed. I got near chills listening to it

chappell roan

not anyone here or in this video... was it u per chance? xx

Sarah Crawford

Kind of shocked at the negativity coming towards this album. It’s all valid, but I actually loved it. It’s a good album albeit not a stellar album (by Taylor album standards). It’s just very different and I feel like a lot of the disappointment/dislike is just culture shock from how different it is. I would be so interested in a retrospective reaction to the album in a few months after the dust settles. There are gold stars to be given to this album, just not the places we expected to give them.

maryna

Yes. Maybe it's just her need to be the best in everything. Ttpd did not get the critical acclaim she was maybe hoping for, then Sabrina who was her opener became a huge success, espresso being _the_ song of the summer. This could also explain the use of sexual language and double entendre on this album, it makes her more like sabrina...

chappell roan

listening to this song was a drive by shooting after drive by shooting like BAM BAM BAM BAM BAM istg it was like "mr. president they hit the tower again it's the seventh time this morning"

Hammie

Ruin the Friendship is one of my favs. Glad you got to it at the end 🥲

Matthew

52:37 is KILLING ME😂😂

K.C.

could you imagine if there were secret sessions for this

Vanessa Vieites

Although I gotta say, sometimes artists write their thoughts and feelings without necessarily agreeing that those thoughts and feelings are good/right. Lana Del Rey describes herself as an American Whore in A&H but I don’t think she agrees with slut shaming. She’s more so describing society’s perception of certain women as a matter of fact, if that makes sense

Zoe Cane

I have mixed feelings but ruin the friendship got me.

chappell roan

personally I always thought that its about like what happens after showgirling - thats what I got from promo at least. still not really in the album tho LMAOOOO

Abby

Yes I felt like she wanted to cry and not in the way we love! That could be me being weird, but it made me sad.

Matthew

She does seem more bitter towards women in this album! That paired with more references to fantasizing about cheating- it’s just gone too far…

Vivi Biazini

finally a vision about travis that i can relate to

Vivi Biazini

about the slangs, she is chronically online but her internet is logged at the beginning of 2021

chappell roan

enjoyed this reaction more than the album :) seriously tho I laughed my ass off wagtching this and you are also very astoute with your observations!!

lavendersnake

In 2017 I was nervous that IDSB was treading dangerously close to m*ga territory with certain language and the witch hunt imagery (very big at the time). Little did I know what was coming 😵‍💫

Courtney

I don’t see any of the wrong optics with Cancelled, but I don’t live perpetually online and the real world is not as bad as online makes it to be. Literally never thought of it being far right till you said it and still don’t see it. You might be reading too much into things.

sam

my voice of reason in these dark times thank you queen i owe you my life this weekend

Abby

That was the first lyric on the album that made me audibly say wtf nooo lol

Gracie Day

I don’t mind the production on Midnights at all… but that’s usually not what I’m critiquing when it comes to Taylor… it was like a hazy obfuscation of purpose and a missing prowess of poetry… there was something sort of surface level about it all…

Shaina

The marketing is so misleading. And people have already started talking about how we don't get it. Like I saw the vision with TTPD but this doesn't make sense. Not everything Taylor does is genius. Some of her more dedicated fans need to accept the L when they should. This album is kind of an L. The poem in the vinyl says something way more interesting than 60% of the record. I needed to hear more of what makes her keep doing it over and over again, to want it so desperately that it makes your skin so thick and the love-hate relationship she has with performing and performance arts. Like it has to be more than just money. There are glimpses of it here and there. When she says, "i swore my loyalty to me, myself, and I" in the Fate of Ophelia. Father Figure as well where she says that you need to really want it to actually make it and then you protect it with all you've got which makes you turn into one of the industry's big bads that you were once so scared of. The title track is good. Ruin the Friendship is a stand out track for me where she talks about how she's missed out on a lot of opportunities and life paths because she chose to walk the showgirl path. "And things I said were dumb 'Cause I thought that I'd never find that Beautiful, beautiful life that Shimmers that innocent light back Like when we were young" is a lyric that really stood out for me from Eldest Daughter as well about how she's had to pretend not to care about certain things cause that's just showbiz. The album was lacklustre. Travis does not make a good muse but that's on him being a good partner. But there are only so many songs I can take about how she's going to marry him (so high school was ENOUGH) and have a bunch of babies. It's really off-putting when you're being called a secret MAGA supporting white trash billionaire who's going to be a tradwife to Travis who has his group of MAGA friends.

Ohdearjon

I had the same thought about CANCELLED! She thinks she’s saying one thing and she’s saying another. This album is overwritten albeit too quickly.

Kelly Donovan

The fact that you're crashing out in track 1 is simply incredible

Batty

Someone said MAGA moms are going to claim Cancelled! and that did kill me a little bit inside 🥲

Quinn Cason

Seeing you process this is fascinating!

Diana

Madeline has taste and I loved her reaction to all of these!!

Veronica

the intro is sending me bahaha 😂 also you look gorgeous queen ❤️‍🔥

Laurahogan

Your actually romantic reaction had me cackling 😂😂😂😂😂

Elizabeth Sandman

I appreciated your reaction very much. Thank you for your candor, humor, and thoughtful perspective as always. I hope that feedback such as yours makes its way to Taylor and that she course corrects. Xx

Emily

I enjoyed the album, but it does feel a little lazy compared to the rest of her discography. Part of me wants to blame Max Martin on this, Jack and Aaron on this album might have made it much better. Too many of the songs reminded me of other songs that already exist. I was getting Weezer, Kid Cudi, Lady Gaga, Jackson 5, and like a Skye Sweetnam tone. A lineup that is all over the place, much like this album. Maybe I'm wrong to blame Max Martin but I'm doing it.

LH

You look INCREDIBLE

James

In a good or bad way?

K.C.

I can't sleep this album is haunting my day. the fact she says, "my advice is:" in RTF--writing 101: just state the advice. don't put "in conclusion" #notmyenglishteacher

Katie

yes!!! her most sincere song on the album

Ro2207

Madeline, you are the bravest soldier. I felt your reaction deep in my bones.

Bernice Trapp

I think you need to let it marinate and percolate…

.

Madeline thank you for giving voice to those of us questioning this album 😭😭😭 Great reaction

Christina

Going from the masterpiece of Cardigan to Wood is……………a lot

finalclaire

I came away from this album with like, 4ish new Taylor songs that I like just fine and a feeling that she desperately needs a couple years off of working and touring

Matthew

She went from covert narcissism to overt narcissism

Aster Sumano

As someone who needed this album to get me through this week I was shocked at how much I actually didn't really love it. It wasn't bad but there were very few WOW moments and the lyricism... oh. When the record ended I was just left confused.

Shanice Marie

I think you guys are taking this way too seriously. What exactly do you think the life of a showgirl sounds like if not overdramatic, catty, and fun? She's clearly having fun experimenting on this album and at this point in her career that's perfectly ok. And actually expected. You don't have to like all her creative choices but she's an artist with her own agency and creative vision. You don't always have to understand everything, somethings are just fun. She's being a character for a lot of this just like a showgirl would. I'm not understanding how so many of you are missing that.

Travis Fry

I like the album, but I think my biggest issue with it is the Showgirl theme. I completely understand that this is a look behind the curtain, but sonically there was a major disconnect from the showgirl concept. I was expecting some jazz, some horns, something more show tune-y. She still could've talked about the behind the scenes of it all while still having the sonic soundscape of "showgirl," so to me, it just feels a little lost or misguided. I absolutely love pop Taylor, 1989 is in my top 5 favorite albums ever, but this isn't infecting me in the way her other works have.

Natasha Nelson

Your silent reaction to every song sent me

Alexia Bozigian

The fate of ophila and opalite sound like I can see you and electric heart …. Recycled ….

Justus 🤍

Everyone in this community thinks too hard

Cameron Van Sant

"Everybody knew she was going to be Traving" True, true XD

Justus 🤍

No we went from cardigan to Ophelia and the lakes to wood lol. Be for real

maryna

I respectfully disagree. Taylor is something very personal to all of us and we all look for the connection to her music. And if it's not there, this can be a little disappointing. Will I jump out of a window because of this? Probably not. But I love having music that makes me feel something and gives me that connection and I don't feel it with this album, so yeah I'm a little disappointed. And this is a Taylor Swift space where all we do is discuss Taylor, so I feel like a new album and its perception is kind of one of the main things you would expect to be discussed on here. And an artistic vision can always be approached from more than one angle because there is no one angle for art.

Justus 🤍

It’s obviously talking about in hindsight for that situation. And just how much she regrets it. Stop being so literal

Justus 🤍

Yall said this for her last 6 albums lol

Natalia

playing So It Goes before the reaction… I love you, Madeline

Justus 🤍

I genuinely think people are having a hard time associating her with being happy. The showgirl wasn’t the theme. It was the life OF a showgirl. Which for her is love and scandal. Stop thinking so deep. Yes a couple songs are not great. But people need to let an album sit. Yall have said every album of hers is boring since rep

Laurahogan

MAGgots would literally NEVER use a Taylor song for their cause… ever. They will die on the hill that she is an evil leftist. I also felt like cancelled was a moment of recognizing the patriarchy always wins? I didn’t get the women hate vibes from the album at all.

Liv

I think what’s still puzzling to me is that she said on the new heights pod that she wanted to make an album that made her as proud as she is of the Eras tour. That set the bar SO unbelievably high. I don’t think it’s a bad album, but I wouldn’t say it feels like a ton of thought went into the execution of it (unlike Eras). She even said on a radio show today that she has no complicated feelings about the album. From what she’s said about Eras, it sounds like she does have complicated feelings about it — being so proud of and exhilarated by 2 years of touring a 3.5 hour show while also feeling completely drained and exhausted by it. There’s something really interesting there, but it’s not explored at all. I guess the album is supposed to be about her life outside the tour, but I keep getting hung up on the visuals emphasizing the showgirl part and not so much the life part. I think I need to sit with it for a while. And at the end of the day, the beauty of being a swiftie is that there are always 11 other albums to revisit ❤️‍🔥

EN

MADELINEEEE I always love your reactions queen I live for them, as usual you had me cackling!!

thalia

at least the fathers are doing the whoring in title track ;)

mindyrose

I’m fed up with the people yelling “it’s the LIFE of a showgirl” it’s about her life. Like. why is the album not just called “life” then? Or “the life of Taylor Swift” ? Or anything else that is unrelated to her career or the eras tour. Taylor chose to put “showgirl” in the title and do the whole Vegas outfit with sparkles and feathers. That was misleading. It’s not really my biggest gripe with the album, but it is annoying to be told that my expectations were wrong when I based them off the information I was given. I feel like a better title would have been “the wife of a football player” smh Loved the reaction bestie <3

Britanii

So It Goes appreciation is appreciated!!

Katherine

This is rouge but I feel like mason would be an Elizabeth Taylor enjoyer

Nancy P

I started liking it more after watching the movie. I think it really needs to cook

Laura

Same!

Mikee Dayrit

There are rumors of a blake-ryan divorce or being on the rocks so maybe that’s it?

Emily

I don’t think anybody said any of this about the last 6 albums. Lover definitely needed to cook tho, I’ll give you that

Shaina

Literally! The marketing is so misleading. And people have already started talking about how we don't get it. Like I saw the vision with TTPD but this doesn't make sense. Not everything Taylor does is genius. Some of her more "dedicated" fans need to accept the L when they should. This album is kind of an L. The poem in the vinyl says something way more interesting than 60% of the record. "You don't get it!" No. Shut up! What I get is that Taylor Swift had a vision when she started writing it and then the demon that is being possibly engaged to travis kelce took over her soul. (I'm not calling travis kelce a demon, I'm just saying it's a rather overwhelming feeling to have found the one)

Laura

I had fun!

Jonas Reich

U know that MAGA isn't a slur, right. It's not contagious. U can say it 😂

Erin

Ok but MAGA ARE the ones cancelling people and SCREAMING ABOUT IT! Like how Trump tweets. That all caps with exclamation point was very purposeful. The same MAGA moms who claimed “Not Ready To Make Nice” will also try to clam this song and it will be hilariously ironic all over again.

Maeva

Mind you track 5 went from "I'm not a princess, this isnt a fairytale" to "I'm not a bad bitch, this isnt savage" ...

Jonas Reich

Oh, to be miserable and be sensitive about everything. Some of us are gonna just eat our food but that's your journey

Kris

I think the issue that she herself (Taylor) set the bar too high. Bulletproof. 12 straight bangers. 1989 and folklore. Taylor set herself up big time. No showgirl in the actual music. She didn’t even follow her own theme. The songs aren’t relatable at all. It’s bad album after bad album (not including TTPD). There’s so much Taylor fatigue with all rerecordings and the tour. She should’ve just chilled. Had life experiences etc and come back fresh. She released an album last April

neets220624

Yes. Opalite sounds ABBA ish that was my first thought, cheesy pop.

Jonas Reich

Oh, to be miserable and be sensitive about everything. Some of us are gonna just eat our food but that's your journey

Jonas Reich

Oh, to be miserable and be sensitive about everything. Some of us are gonna just eat our food but that's your journey

Kris

Loooooool these reactions are funny

Jonas Reich

Oh, to be miserable and be sensitive about everything. Some of us are gonna just eat our food but that's your journey

Jonas Reich

Oh, to be miserable and be sensitive about everything. Some of us are gonna just eat our food but that's your journey

Aaron

“That could be about anybody” LOLLL

Nathan Anthony

Taylor’s adverting for this album was totally misleading. Like why? So she’d sell more vinyls? Because it is definitely not high energy pop like advertised

Deli

Tell that to the underpaid Honduran and Nicaraguan children making her wasteful merch. Fr tho, I think we just have different perspectives on what we want from Taylor, and that’s ok! This is an issue I personally care about, but we all have different priorities.

Jonas Reich

At least we don't murder people who disagree with us...

Kris D

@justus "it's just art don't think about it" bruh...critisism is a huge part of consuming art, you'd think you'd know that considering you're in the swiftologist patreon

Jonas Reich

Oh, to be miserable and be sensitive about everything. Some of us are gonna just eat our food but that's your journey

Deli

Unfortunately there is little food to enjoy😭 I’ll have to cook on it a bit longer tho and give it a couple months

Stacey Campbell

I think I'm grieving the album that I thought this was going to be. I was thinking more showgirl burlesque vibes almost and at the same caliber as 1989 or reputation. This isn't that. But, I know I will like it for a different reason once I can let go of the vision I had for this album. Fate of Ophelia is super catchy and after several listens its right up there as a favourite alongside father figure, cancelled and the life of a showgirl. I'm a bit bummed to be honest that this isn't the 1989/rep mix of my dreams.

Chas

Scream

Jonas Reich

Oh, to be miserable and be sensitive about everything. Some of us are gonna just eat our food but that's your journey

Matthew

Respectfully, I disagree. Many of us were there for Lover and enjoy it. Same with Midnights. There were misses on those albums but this record is like 90% misses for me.

K.C.

LOL ok but also I'm not being literal, this has nothing to do with literal, actually the issue is the writing is being too literal, bless 🙏

K.C.

lol thanks but I also just imagined W🪵🪵d being played for first time with her in the room

Kris D

@jonas "jUst eAt Ur fOoD guys shUT up" enjoy the album and comment that you did. dislike it and comment that you did. why are you insulting this random ass girl, go focus that energy on something productive

Momo

you removing the boa is so funny, because zach was like "i feel like a fool in my headdress now" when he listened to wood 😭

Kelly O'Halleran

Lmaoooo I loved the album but this is such a good critique

Kelly O'Halleran

You look so fucking good!!!! The hair!!!!!!!!!!! I wish you loved Opalite, I thought you'd ride!!!

reckless mermaid

I hope the album grows on you Madeline!! Even though I kind of agree with all your criticisms, I actually love this album!! It’s not really giving 1989 pop bangers, it’s more like TTPD writing with Reputation/Midnights production so I thought you’d really like it! I do think this album needs to simmer and I expect to like it more as I listen to it. I also think that every single song is showgirl coded, not with the lyrical/ subject matter but I can see every song with a chorus line. Weirdly, I think it sort of suffers from being so short because there just isn’t enough meat to digest amidst the Travis love fest. I definitely wish fewer songs were about Travis and that she didn’t use so much dates millennial slang… we know she can do better and there are some real clunkers and not enough good stuff to balance it out

Shanice Marie

It wasn't the marketing. I'm afraid you guys didn't understand it from the start and now you're blaming her for your own disappointment. What exactly do you think a showgirl's life is like?

Kris D

that entire verse was soo puzzling, like we're going from laughing and trampolines to her first heartbreak to eldest daughters are wolves, idk man. the reference to memes with the sad piano in the background made me laugh out loud

Shanice Marie

Or perhaps you're reading reading too deeply into it.

Alex

The slang is old bc she’s a millennial lol. this is how I talk to my Gen z staff 😂

Madeline

you can put in conclusion in essays. they encourage you not to do that in high school because they want you to use more complex language, but when you get better at writing in college you can use first person in essays. Like “In this essay I will…”

Erin Hastey

@41:13 the Lizard went full Rotarian with the 4-way test 😂 “Of the things we think, say, or do: is it the truth? Is it fair to all concerned? Will it build good will and better friendships? Will it be beneficial to all concerned?”

Melodie Roehrig

I think it’s funny that the 70’s sounding songs off this album fit the aesthetic of the Midnights photoshoot way better

dumdum

Madeline I hope you see this but because of your influence im getting to see Cece Natalie live I thank you so much for finding her!!!!

ImogenLucy

Fuck So it Goes is just THAT girl

Natalia

me when I thought you’d skipped my album highlight Ruin the Friendship 🫥🫥🫥🫥 also, she should’ve just marketed this as Lover 2.0

Ada

I’ve been dying for this

Cassady Lynn

I feel like cancelled is solely about Blake and how she isn’t going to pass judgment on her because she stuck around when Taylor got cancelled and I actually love it.

Leslie

I got a HQ leak yesterday afternoon (I know, bad swiftie) so I've listened to it probably 10 times now and it's just not growing. The only melodies sticking with me are Opalite and Father Figure. By this point Midnights (the only other album I've immediately disliked on first listen) had started growing on me and revealed itself to be more than met the eye initially, but I'm just getting nothing from this one. I'll keep listening through the weekend and hope it clicks at some point but I'm not optimistic.

Shaina

This is exactly what I mean when I say the "dedicated" fans will cook up anything to justify any kind of misalignment in the expectations and the reality. The writing is lacklustre and inconsistent in a lot of places. The production is expensive and lush but that's just not going to cut it. Actually romantic (And I'm not even a Charli XCX fan tbh) is unnecessary and so is Cancelled. I'm a taylor swift fan which is why I'm a member here. And I'm saying it's not the best work she's put out there and all the hype wasn't worth the product we got

Ada

Dare I say the fame has gotten to her and she’s gotten far too out of touch? She’s surrounded by yes men. I can’t believe how unlikable this narrator is for half of the songs. It no longer feels facetious to me. It’s not self aware. It’s actual melodrama and punching down.

JJ

Let’s just let this Taylor album cook guys and come with proper opinion next weekend…

Carmel

Maybe you should try having thoughts

Ada

Girl she is their nazi Barbie. They have AI generated vids of her endorsing trump. The locals who aren’t up to date on her “politics” loveeeee her

Carmel

You need to chill on people not liking the album - some people actually do think about the art they consume and want it to be good.

CHRIS 01 🪽 #HOUSEWIFE

taylor advertised this as the next pop bible and made the worst album of her career 😭😭

Rachael Evansco

Love that you got your reaction up so quick! Just wanted to say, I love the Backstreet intro. Iconic! 👏

Melodie Roehrig

So you’re just copy and pasting this shitty reply to multiple people’s comments, Jonas? Maybe go “eat your food” instead of commenting at all. 🫶🏻

Hannah T

@Jonas Oh my god are you just going to reply this to everyone who has any ounce of criticism? You're on the EOAS patreon not cupcake swiftie patreon.

Travis Fry

Agreed I think she actually might've over corrected with the length of this and think it could've benefited from a few more tracks. It does feel too Travis heavy when thinking of the theme of the album

Ada

Girl don’t ever be afraid to hide your real opinions and thoughts I’m dying to hear everything you said. Resetting to Ready For It was very appropriate lol

K.C.

🙏🙏 you get it! and I like some of it but Madeline was really speaking for me in her reactions tn

Carmel

Compared to you, who knows exactly 😂

K.C.

sure yes but songs are not essays (so my bad genuinely for pulling that example from essay writing) but tay's writing weaknesses are all over this album: mixed metaphors to the moon, repetitive rhyme schemes, over writing (often being too literal), and just the general need to edit for voice ("ok--I'm trying to say this here, but it's clunky or too on the nose or too simple--how do I elevate it? refine? sharpen") the fans who are disappointed are also fans who love her writing and know how good it can be tbf: I'm a lyric first listener. and man oh man that was a ride with this album.

Carmel

You see how it's only the guys in the comments being so rude/saying we're reading to deeply into it. Maybe you should learn something from these comments instead of pushing your heels in so deep for a popstar who phoned it in

dancingaroundit

Girl this is better food than what Taylor served us last night. Thank you Queen 👑

Bswizzle

She barely acknowledges anything about being a showgirl on tour which is what she said the album was about. It’s so weird, she could’ve just said “this is an album for Travis mostly”, we wouldn’t have been surprised or disappointed with that.

K.C.

you know what tho? it *does* match the vibe of being announced on a football podcast lol I'm joking but also I'm not 😢

Bailey

Personally I don’t see how you got cancelled as a MAGA anthem 😂😂😂 lol that’s funny

rachel☁️

im crying at you and zach in your show girl regalia feeling like boo boo the fool after cringing at this album 😭😭

Molly

I love Actually Romantic but the Charli of it all makes me so sad 😂 can’t deny it’s funny tho.

Ellen Kay

I like all the melodies

JJ

But cancelled is about Blake and Ryan specially due to the line about they stood by me before I was exonerated

Bswizzle

I thought it was “we dressed up as wolves and we liked fire”… boy is this disappointing

Stacey Campbell

I'm so glad for your reaction, a lot of what you were saying resonates with my first reaction. The production fell so flat compared to what we came to expect after 1989/reputation - I can't see how they did bangers from 1989 and reputation and then came up with this? The production also mimics other songs, it doesn't sound new and fresh - I saw someone on tiktok literally do side by sides of each song against existing music and it was uncanny how close they were. I hadn't picked up on the cancelled political reference (not American and try to bury my head in the sand in relation to American politics for my own sanity). I love all of her other albums, it's difficult to feel this way. I wanted to love it. And it's not bad, it's just not the 9/10 out of 10's that I'm used too. It reminds me more of lover than any other album.

m

oh i’m EXCITED to see zach and madeline debrief after this…they have quite differing opinions on ‘cancelled’ in particular, and i think in general, he enjoyed the album more than madeline did. at least based on first reaction

Caroline James

Love you Madeline!! This reaction had me on the floor! Especially for Father Figure and Canceled.. lol. I feel like your interpretation of Canceled was something I didnt even think about on my first listen 👀... but now im SAT. I have to say that I am sooo glad that I claimed Honey 🍯💕 as my song lol. Overall I really liked the album though!!

Taylah Louise

I have come to not trust how she markets an album and just be surprised when I hear it haha

Britanii

The reset with Ready For It had me dead lmao 😂

Roh

I don’t think she was saying it’s intended as a MAGA anthem, but it sounds like one. Going a step beyond the boring and typical “cancel culture is toxic” narrative, Taylor appears to be reframing the concept of being cancelled as a badge of honor that denotes one part of some exclusive group of people with deeper insight than the rest of us… which is exactly how the alt-right ‘anti-woke’ crowd thinks of it as well.

Nat

Love you Madeline. I totally respect and value your opinion so thank you for sharing it. You can see how much Taylor means to you with your anxiety to press play on the album for the fear that it will disappoint. My first listen left me thinking "What the hell was that?" but I also felt that with TTPD and I ended up loving it. My biggest quip is the cringe lyrics from someone who can write so beautifully and so cleverly. The tunes are catchy but not ground breaking - for me, a lot were sonically similar to other songs such as "Actually Romantic” sounding like the Pixies “Where is my Mind?". I will be interested to hear your thoughts after a few more listens, and look forward to watching you and Zack share your thoughts and unpack the album together.

Abby

Funniest person alive btw

Miss_Lippy

Have any of yall actually met any far right type people?? Do you not have the misfortune of being related to any of them?? Well, I’ve got news for you: They unanimously HATE Taylor. The same Taylor who endorsed Harris & the same Taylor who is often publicly targeted by their orange icon? That Taylor? The same one who has been dragged repeatedly by basically every conservative podcaster, influencer, host, etc? The Taylor who chanted “FUCK THE PATRIARCHY” with crowds of thousands and thousands of women every night on her tour? Yeah, sorry but this take really makes no sense. I think anyone with half a brain is going to realize that & maybe it takes a few listens before it sinks in for some ppl, idk. But if you're still holding onto that opinion after multiple listens then I can’t help but think there’s some kind of projecting going on or something because that just ain’t adding up guys. If you want to hate the album on actual merit or personal taste then that is your right, but let’s not grasp in the dark for reasons to hate it that aren’t really there. Taylor being “far right” is a truly unhinged take tho any way we cut it lol

Valtteri Iivarinen

MADELINE YOU LOOK PRETTIER AND C*NTIER THAN EVERRRR!!!!!

Molly

I heard a lot of confidence in the album. Like this is the energy she wishes she had when she wrote IFTYE and YNTCD.

Bailey

I just hear about how she says she’s gonna stick by her friends when they’re being cancelled like they did for her when she was cancelled. But yeah I definitely don’t think about it that deeply

emma 🌷

you and zack showed out with outfits! so cute!!!

rachel☁️

Actually romantic is the Thank you Aime of this record but vicious

Rachael Evansco

I love this album! I think every listen it gets better and better. I also went to the movie today and seeing the lyrics and her describing the songs really helped with it all. Also- Idk when you're going to the movie Madeline, but when she describes Wood she even knows she's being coy with us and smirks. The audience in my showing yelled Liar! At the screen at her words about Wood lol the music video was so good and helped me like Fate of Ophelia way more. 😊

Ash Owens

"Travis does not make a good muse but that's on him being a good partner" this is the right take!

CHRIS 01 🪽 #HOUSEWIFE

this is only my 4th release including re records so i just learned this lesson 😭😭😭😕😕

Mae Osbourn

I love Madeline so much. Two seconds of Elizabeth Taylor and we cut to ready for it. Diva!

DrEmily

Wait wait wait… is Jeff Lang the guy in You Belong With Me? Is that what Ruin the Friendship is saying?!?! Is that just me? Madeline, you look FIRE ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

Ada

Yep. She is insulting her own talent by releasing these songs and speaking about them so confidently

Shaina

Thanks for saying that! I mean there's only so much you can write about a healthy and fulfilling relationship, right?

Zana

heavy on this album being salty towards women. i noticed it on first listen and i'm glad you and more people are noticing it. it comes off weird

makanani

i was in the car w my bf when the album dropped so i played it and was actually so embarrassed i only played the first 4 songs lol u was def like uhhhhhhhh idk what this is BUT THEN i listened to the album in full and liked the back half once i got warmed up then listened to the whole album again and loved the whole album on the second listen then more and more with every listen as i understood what was going on better. i am SO excited to hear you and zach's thoughts once you've had time to marinate with the album

madelon

Retweet 🫰 this is the first comment in this jungle of negativity that i related to

rachel☁️

cancelled seemed so adressed to blake i didnt take it that way but i also live in Canada lmao so maybe its more tense in the US

rachel☁️

wait where is ruin the friendship

Madeline

she said anti hero was one of her favorite songs that she’s ever written, never forget

Ada

36:10 I’m dyinggggg

Mae Osbourn

In father figure I feel the reference to ‘jag’ as a reference to the car brand also draws predatory allusions to the animal

Madeline

yeah it’s so disappointing. it’s like you’ve had so many years away from each other and this is what you cooked up? they’re all just flat and boring. it feels stale. why couldn’t they have WAITED and put some THOUGHT INTO IT??? the production could’ve been so much more bombastic if they let it marinate and she could’ve put it out later and she didn’t have to market it as inside info about the eras tour

Madeline

just keep thinking that

Lizzy Gravelle

Father Figure is abt Scott and her Masters, I’m confused else it’s could realistically be

Hailee S

Love the honest reactions! Your take on cancelled was interesting & I’ve been seeing a lot of discourse abt that elsewhere as well. I disagree though. It’s not my fav on the album but I don’t think the intention was to come off as conservative vibes. I do think she was being a bit “out of touch” but not in the way that a lot of people are taking it. From my perspective I saw it as her calling out the misogyny that happens with female celebrities & cancel culture. “Did u girl boss to close to the sun” “did u make a joke only a man could” ect.. aka the man 2.0. On the other hand i also think she is poking fun at herself & others for being out of touch. “Tone deaf & hot lets Fing off her” I think she knows she is out of touch & surrounded by others that can be considered out of touch. She is arguably one of the most famous women alive today & all of her friends are famous with the exception of a few people. When you are at that level of fame I don’t think u can be relatable in the sense of “a show girl” & “cancel culture” when one of us regular people get cancelled it’s hundreds & thousands hearing abt it & weighing in… when it’s someone like Taylor or Blake it’s millions. From the show girl perspective I don’t think it’s meant to be relatable at all & her making the “tone deaf” comments I think was her way of poking fun at it (basically just regurgitating what the media has said abt her & her friends & accepting that) & being like well yes I am rich and famous & powerful & so are my friends but I’m still a women in the industry & so is she & we are being torn down for this , this, & that & then if a man did/ does all that no one cares but bcs it’s a famous women they get tore down on another level. To me it seemed like she was poking at it being like well yes I am rich & so are they ect however we shouldn’t have to apologize for being successful just bcs xyz occurred & we got cancelled & I won’t not support Blake just bcs she’s “out of touch” “cancelled” in the public perception bcs she supported me in my cancellations ect.. This is going off of the assumption this was abt Blake & that whole situation. This does NOT include racist cancellations. I don’t think taylor should be supporting that & I would hope she never would. As for Brittany I think people tend to forget that Patrick is travis’s close friend, team mate, coworker, quarterback aka “leader” & Travis maintaining that level of closeness with him is important for his career on & off the field. There ability to read each others moves, get in the other persons head to determine a play, be able to lean on each other ect is important in terms of football & his off the field relationship can also greatly affect the dynamic on the field. Brittany is obv his wife & not the greatest person but I personally think taylor has wanted to fit in with Travis’s friends as anyone in a relationship usually does. Taylor has also said so herself that she just wants to fit in & be “cool” bcs she feels like she isn’t. When it comes to the football teams & their “groups” “clicks” whatever u wanna call it typically the more successful players/ their wives are typically more popular or famous than others. I really think her friendship with Brittany is just to fit in with travis’s friends but also the wag group. Hence the dinners with Brittany & other wags. They seem to be friends but not best friends. It really just comes down to her need to want to fit in. In my opinion I think Taylor is a smart enough woman to make her own choices & lead with her own morals & consciousness when it comes to her faith/politics without letting the people around her make her waver in her morals/where she stands.

DrEmily

I think the second verse of Opalite is about Travis’ past relationship where he wanted more from it… he was sunshine, she was in her Instagram

Leslie

THANK YOU. These takes are so condescending. Obviously we knew the album was about her life offstage/behind the curtain, but I thought it would still be through the lens of Taylor Swift the performer/celebrity/CEO/Eras Tour diva. Instead it's just...her life and she happens to also be a showgirl. If you're going to apply the concept that broadly then it could describe any of her albums pretty much. Red is the life of a showgirl because she wrote it about her life while on the Speak Now tour! Even love songs about Travis could have been through this lens. How did they navigate the distance and nurture a fresh relationship with such busy schedules and on different continents? What did it feel like when he came to the shows? How did it feel like to support and celebrate each other in your shared successes? There are a million ways she could have written about their relationship through that lens, and I'm frankly baffled that she didn't because it's much more interesting subject matter than what we got. Also...the title track is literally about the costs of fame and passing your hard earned wisdom down to younger artists. That track ostensibly serves as the thesis statement for the album. So don't give me this "It was never supposed to be about showgirls" BS.

Maria

It’s yacht rock. I love it. I didn’t love it the first time though.

rachel☁️

oh i saw it.... imo just don't think the song is good enough. clunky lyrics and cringey. it gagged at first but once the shock value wears off its embarrassing. sympathy is a knife has a lot of layers to it at least.

Maria

What can I say... The girl has range

DrEmily

Are you objecting to meaning of RTF, or just the grammar and “Strunk & White structuring” to her advice?

Leslie

Who is "y'all"? Zack and Madeline certainly haven't, nor have I, nor have many other fans.

Sydney

I was expecting a higher quality project - especially having Max Martin on these tracks. Even though the album has grown on me over the past 24 hours, something about it remains confusing to me. Like I don’t know how to describe it besides confusing. There’s songs I enjoy but not a single TRUE banger on the entire thing.

rachel☁️

ruin the friendship is objectively the most well rounded song to me in terms of writing and production together. not showgirl vibes tho. also didnt expect it to be forever winter pt2

Sarah

no. you cannot « the man » everything.

Leslie

The tagline of Zack's channel and this patreon is literally "THOUGHTFUL pop culture." That's literally why we're all here. If you don't like deeper analysis and elevated conversations about music then stan twitter is that way.

rachel☁️

agree tbh i feel like she made it pretty clear it was being cancelled unreasonably for trivial shit and being a woman

stef

“And I’m in the outfit, this is humiliating” I love you so much😭😭

rachel☁️

i fear she mislead us in her descriptions and marketing and gave us the wrong expectations so extreme everyone ik is having this confused reaction

Em ✨️

Your reaction really validated my experience with my own first reaction. Ive been gaslighting myself and re-listening because I really want to like it. I think I'm still in shock that its not what I had imagined and im going to let it cook!

rachel☁️

The writing is so bad on this album it pains me to admit

rachel☁️

Wow she fumbled the marketing so badly we all thought we were gonna get a 1989 album

rachel☁️

So true. The marketing really had us having a totally different expectation. If it was packaged as yacht rock I think people wouldn't be having such adverse reactions

Cloudyskies

Ok… so I went to the theater showing in the US… I wish I hadn’t 😭

Marco Rubboli

Your reaction made me feel so validated about my feelings about this album

Keira Campbell

I really wanted to love this album but it just isn't hitting. Some songs are great, but the lack of Showgirl theme is disappointing. I think she needs to take a long break. Also the "puuuuuuuh" after the first line of Actually Romantic has me fried because I think I reacted the exact same way when I first heard it 😭

Hailee S

When she is saying things like “did u make a joke only a man could” u can the man it bcs it’s the same topic just from a new perspective.

Sophie R

It’s actually fitting that this album was released on oct 3rd because Taylor has me feeling like Cady’s mom in mean girls looking at her daughter and asking “who are you?” This is the fertility vase of the Ndelebele tribe, Taylor! Does that mean anything to you? (Sorry for the deep cut reference lol)

Ada

What is it like ppl are saying it’s bad but with no details

DrEmily

I do give her room to cook with cancelled given that she wrote it summer 2024, before the election and ensuing insanity. She was pointing out double standard for women trying to girl boss who tick off the guys. References to jokes men say, shattering glass ceilings. The Gucci was just tagging Blake bc she was spokesperson for them. At the time of writing/recording, it was height of the Baldoni PR smear campaign and the backlash over the press for the movie. It says “Blake was a ride-or-die for me when I was in snakegate, so I got her back now.” My interpretation. And I clap.

Stacey Campbell

Oh wow, I just saw she has credited most of the songs as being interpolations of others... like Jackson 5, Wheezer, Lorde, Lenny Kravits etc. That makes more sense for why it sounds like stuff we've already heard before. (Oh actually, I see anyone can add credits like this on Genius... so maybe not!).

Ada

I think that the fame has really changed her for the worst over the last few years

Cloudyskies

… “Money pwease” The music video for FoO (I can’t believe I just typed that) is ok- very self-directed Taylor. The behind the scenes isn’t awful… but the lyric videos… low effort for such a beautiful visual album… BUT. The clean versions of the songs were, imho, atrocious. Swapping “skies” for “thighs” in wood is criminal, just one example. If you are gonna sing about your soon to be husbands dick- own it. No one is forcing you to do that. Idk just feeling a lot of things at the moment. About the whole album. But yea, show was a waste of money.

DrEmily

Make sure you give the movie a chance. It is definitely worth it, and helps a lot.

Ada

Well yes. People have been bootlicking for so long that she knows she doesn’t even need to try. She’s been calling this her “perfect” album. Her ego is so inflated that she actually thinks this is a masterpiece- and many people will agree with her

Ada

Perfect taste.

Ada

Yep. The second half sounds as if you’re overhearing someone scroll through tiktok. The slang filled phrases and subject matter are soooo stupid

Marco Rubboli

YES. On this album in particular she sounds like she hasn't lived proper life experiences in too long and she's looking at life through weird VIP lens.

Meli

I think it’s definitely about Blake and had her in mind when writing this song, but what Madeline is saying is also true. She seems to be redefining being “cancelled” as some type of bad ass trope when in today’s climate there are people who deserve to be deplatformed or “cancelled”

Kris

You're so real, soo relatable

Miss_Lippy

I also assumed this was totally about Blake and thought it basically sealed it as so when she mentioned something about how they stood by her in the past, etc. The ironic thing about Blake’s whole court debacle is that it all started with a woman making reports of sexual harassment and a man retaliating in response by hiring a PR crisis company to launch an online smear campaign against her -with the aim to make the public hate her and therefore discredit her allegations. This is all evidenced in court documents and court obtained text messages between the man, his crew and the professional smear machine ppl (who literally say to him in one court obtained text message “We can bury anyone”) but it doesn't even matter to a lot of ppl because they had already been brainwashed by the smear machine with “Blake = bad” so usually if you try to engage with people about this online and point this irony out to them, they can only ever revert to “but Blake = bad” and even when you tell them that the only reason they even think that is because a man accused of sexually harassing her paid a company to make them feel that way toward her they will still say “but Blake is bad” so it’s actually pointless trying to even reason with them but it doesn’t take a genius to see that if a woman claims sexual harassment an innocent man doesn’t respond by hiring a team to smear her & ruin her reputation so Taylor incorporating the double standards in this sexism is even more apt when you consider the scope of Blake’s public image and legal issues as of late. Also, I can guarantee that if this had all happened in the “me too” era there’s no way the public would have so readily gobbled up the Blake hate bait while ignoring all the allegations against this man.

Maeva

Well, now I need both Madeline & Zack reaction/review/opinion TOGETHER in the same video because he was sunshine and she was midnight rain

Hanna

Actually Romantic could have been sooo good if it wasn't that specific about Charli.

Katy

This album didn't need to be made. The promo didn't fit the songs (behind the scenes of the eras tour, where!?) and the lyrics were just cringe. Like girl...why all the bitches and slag!? Actually Romantic is so embarrassing for her!! Not one song is one I'd listen to again. How did we go from 1989, rep, Folklore and Evermore to this!?

CHRIS 01 🪽 #HOUSEWIFE

he said he was disappointed on a live he deleted so i feel they have the same opinions on it. still seated tho!!

Kylan Kikuyama

I completely agree with the marketing/theme of the album. It doesn't fit. I think Opalite is a better summation of the album as a theme. It's just as gorgeous as the showgirl theme. Although Opalite as a title track song would be a little bit of a letdown compared to the rest of the album and I know some of the more cutting songs might not fit that theme exactly.

Meli

Who is “yall”? When has Madeline ever said that her albums are boring since reputation??? I’d like to see the video or audio of her saying that.

tyler

just saw some idiot on tiktok say that taylor dissing charli like that is the equivalent to a child talking back to their mother…this diss track may be a lot of things but child talking back to their mother ???? im like actually floored at that girls

Kinley

completely agree

Stacy Davydova_13

Tbh this album is humiliating. She promised 12 fucking bangers. 12. Fucking. Bangers. And she wasted this beautiful concept album and Max Martin collab on diss tracks, dicks and MAGAs. I woke up today angry as fuck. This is lazy and out of touch

Henry C

The only things I knew about the album was the title and cover. My first listen was in the theatre - despite the embarassing writing in various songs ... I do enjoy it. Maybe it's because I had no exposure to the marketing and had no expectations? The MV + BTS looked fun bringing the whole Eras Tour cast together and the commentary for each song. I didn't know Sabrina recorded her piece whilst on the Tour in May last year.

Hannah Ramirez

Your intro and the reveal of the whole look!! Hahaha I loved it and you look so gorgeous and hottt!!

Maeva

Oh I didnt know. From his reaction it was quite “positive”. We’ll see, waiting to be fed 😌😌

Emily Sawich

Oh noo CANCELLED needs to be canceled.... the irony. Madeline is right unfortunately it's already too late and will prob already be used by the alt right even though I definitely think Taylor had good intentions/ wrote the song about Blake...

DrEmily

But she lists several clear points that are directly related to being cancelled because of being a girl boss - jokes men make, shattered glass ceiling, etc. it has The Man vibes to me. Just about her longtime friend, who was ride or die for her when the whole world cancelled her. And written /recorded before the 2024 election. And the insanity since then.

Stacy Davydova_13

And do y’all remember when she said on podcast “writing matters to me”? THIS writing? Girl, are you gaslighting yourself or us?

kly

thank god i am not the only one that felt like cancelled was so tasteless and it pissed me off. i agree that it is the most out of touch i’ve ever heard her be and it really put me off, like… queen you’re a white american billionaire.. PLEASE!!! i think i just don’t care much for it when she talks about society issues bc she tends to always just center herself. overall, this album let me down upon the first two listens. i only find replay value in the first three tracks personally, but father figure is interesting to me as a deeper story. i love taylor i’ve been loving her since 08… this one was ..something 😭

Meli

It’s always a man

Meli

Most people just want to make it to next week

DrEmily

Almost didn’t go. Didn’t think it would add anything. Glad I did. I thought it was fun. MV for FoO was good. Enjoyed seeing the Eras group back together. And the explanations were helpful. Similar vibe to how she used to explain things in secret sessions and I think that was maybe the goal. Made me enjoy the songs more. And I liked the clean version of Wood better, more subtle tongue in cheek.

Vaidehi Khaladkar

Ikr?! I can't believe she described this as a tight concise pop banger which she loves as much as she loves the Eras tour like that's crazy! It feels a little delusional 😭

rachel☁️

Actually romantic is so bad. Charli expressed her true feelings in SIAK and Taylor made fun of her

Nina

Zach's reaction: Open mouthed gagging, Madeline's reaction: Nervous ASMR

DrEmily

There must have been some CXCX behaviors going on we didn’t even know. My friend showed me some shocking photo with her mimicking being a casualty victim with bloody friendship bracelet on a severed hand from August 2024. It caused outrage in Europe since it was released around the time of UK stabbings in Southport at the Taylor-themed kids dance class and the cancelled Vienna dates from terror threat. Right in the middle of writing/recording this album.

Cloudyskies

So I do disagree. The lyric videos were just eh at best- one looped 2 second video manipulated for a kaleidoscope effect (like the visualizers already posted for free)… at times, the lyrics were unreadable. Like give me a little bit of effort queen. For me, this showing not being all that good does ignite a classist rage. Movie tickets are expensive. That was an hour and a half of essentially nothing. I feel scammed. I feel disappointed. This album is a tale of two cities in an incredibly difficult world. I’m glad you had fun. Good for you. But this ain’t it.

Mikee Dayrit

Oh Madeline if you feel so just pan the album. There was hesitation in ur caption and vid but Taylor needs a reality check, this is not good

Meli

She tends to morph into whoever she is with involved romantically

Nina

Thank you for validating the unwitting MAGA narrative ick. I explained a similar thing on YT, but I think my comment got deleted, so THANK YOU for mentioning it at least.

Megan Zemke

@35:44 your read on eldest daughter is so good. My take on the slag, especially because it’s outdated slang, is emphasizing the fact that she will never be cool, no matter how hard she is trying her coolness comes off awkward. Like when your mom tries to use current slang. So she’s like, with you (or, travis) I can finally just drop this whole act. But that doesn’t make me a fake poser, it makes me feel like I can be myself with you.

Elise Cooper

I want to love Honey and The Life of a Showgirl but I HATE women being called a bitch and agree with your hate women statement. I think I'm going to have to listen to the clean version of Honey going forward just so I don't hear her say 'that bitch at the bar' and even The Life of a Showgirl because why 'bitches who wish I'd hurry up and die'. After everything that happened with 'that bitch' in Famous I really thought we were above this

Bella

I’ve never listened to one of her albums and actively disliked what I was hearing.. maybe it’s a grower . idk. I’m in a state of idk

R M

Again with the useless comments, dude. Go away.

R M

I CACKLED in sympathy seeing you struggle after just one song in.

Hannah

you're cooking, thats a great point about her gripe with famous! ick

Katie Winfree

The Charli online erasure is crazy to me.. as if her and her possy haven’t been vile and nasty online

june

MADELINE THE DRESS IS GORGINAAAAA

Milosh Shhhh

Hopefully there’s some willingness to be nuanced in interpreting Cancelled. She (obviously?) means people who are cancelled in bad faith - why are we immediately saying she wants to exonerate and be friends with people/men who are cancelled for actually valid reasons? Also, these days the conservatives control so much of the public space, they’re the ones doing the cancelling now as well… Other than that, yeah the album is underwhelming. It’s just so… unambitious and slight. It just feels small and undeveloped.

Lindsay Manzella

So glad I just subscribed to Patreon if only to hear your reaction to CANCELLED! I didn't catch that perspective on my first listen, but I have to agree, no matter the intention behind (or actual meaning of) the song, this is so easily going to become a MAGA anthem and it was best left in the vault for that reason.

plutobybjörk

Madeline don’t be afraid to speak your mind! I know because of your position it’s hard to give anything a less than a positive review, but we love you for your honesty and it’s ok to pan the album. Unfortunately it just isn’t good 😭

Milosh Shhhh

I don’t think so. MAGA control so much of the public space now, they’re the ones doing the actual cancelling now. We can make it an anthem AGAINST them…. Like an FU to them and everything they’re trying to change and cancel

Anderson

Yes! Very Pixies but like….a very, very filed down version lol

maryna

And love story became fate of Ophelia, both Shakespeare related... Not sure, but maybe there has been a bit of calculation for this album, a la "oh, I want this album to go no 1, so I'm using all of the tricks that have worked for me in the past"... The album does not feel like an album that came about organically, because she needed to write it...

CHRIS 01 🪽 #HOUSEWIFE

who is the target demographic of the album? Sorry im just yapping in these comments i just CANT with this album. I wish i could unlisten to this :(((

Hanna

Havent seen the live but even during his "positive" reactions, you could see that it wouldnt last. The spark wasn't there...

Mustafa Mehdi

We as a fandom need to let Taylor know this is not the thing she thinks it is . So I’m not gonna pretend its great or even a good record so she can do better with ttpd yes it was too long but the bad reviews were just the hate train . Cuz the record was brilliant. This i am not gonna support and i blame midnights for all of this cuz she thought she can make a mid record and get away with it

Juna

I love your reactions Madeline thank you for sharing so quickly 😭

Alison Bell

She’s only done that for Father Figure, as I understand it. The rest should sue lol.

Green Wolf

Unfortunately, playing the victim in all matters is their modus operandi.

Hannah

I had a mental breakdown so I made a playlist of songs that are more showgirl than this entire album. There are only 3 TLOAS songs on it: ICDIWABH, Elizabeth Taylor, Anti-Hero, You are in Love, YOYOK, Mirrorball, Clara Bow, Father Figure, LWYMMD, Bejeweled, Long Live, and TLOAS ft. Sabrina.

Hana Doyle

I cant wait to see Zach and Madeline speak about this album because their reactions are so vastly different! I was expecting some hateration from Zach but I really enjoyed his reaction as i really agreed with his level of gag-this album is the first taylor album ive liked on the first listen, nothing really had to sit with me! Xx

Septima

I agree that this was her intention but Taylor is really bad at reading the room and this is terrible. "Cancelled" is a loaded term used constantly by the far right to victimise themselves. She could have used a different phrasing to make the point stick, but she jumped onto an overhyped, very politicised phrase clearly having no idea what that means. And that just highlights how sheltered and out of touch she is, which is uncomfortable to listen to

Alison Bell

I’m so validated by your reaction to Actually Romantic as it’s so unnecessary I almost want to un-stan ha.

Septima

It really gives white feminism and "I only care about women when I am personally affected". Not realising how this song would come off is WILD for a woman in her 30s living in the US.

Septima

Love your reaction! Probably the opposite of mine, I loved The Fate of Ophelia and have had it on repeat while trying to forget some of the other songs exist 😂

splendidvie

Exactly THIS!! You know it's bad, if the clean versions are better than the explicit ones.

Jadz

I also think people are totally ignoring how sympathy is a knife literally says I hope your boyfriend dumps you because I can't stand seeing you around... It's not as sweet and innocent as everyone thinks

Sarah

mid 30’ republicans white women

Matteo

In the “movie” Taylor said father figure was a song about the two sides of someone having power over someone else, like a mentor. And how she has been at both ends of that type of power relationship. So I’m really thinking it’s partially a Scott Borchetta DIE song and partially about her actually also not being afraid to SUE your ass…

Miss_Lippy

Ah yes because there is nothing MAGA loves more than Taylor Swift, who their orange goblin idol repeatedly targets publicly online, along with all their fav right wing podcasters & influencers who also absolutely love Taylor. Because if there is anything MAGA just can’t resist it’s Kamala-endorsing cat lady Taylor Swift. I can see it now: A sea of red hats chanting “FUCK THE PATRIARCHY” at her next tour while they pass around occult objects during the witchcraft themed sets and belt out the tunes about a sexually empowered woman and her affinity for her “Pfizer shill” fiance Travis and his huge weiner…..Be so fucking for real guys 😆😆

Katie Winfree

Yes exactly. Like I’m sorry, I’d be pissed too if someone I platformed early I their career and gave opportunities to shit on me like that.

Saanal

While I share a lot of thoughts on its bad timing…y’all seem to keep pretending like Swift hasn’t been consistently attacked by MAGA lol.

h

"my reaction to The Fate of Ophelia was like when you stick your hand into the sink and touch wet food" 😂😂😂 god I love you Madeline

Ella Clarke

In my opinion it’s seems to be more ab ‘boring Barbie’ and being happy about matty Healy ghosting her which she says in the song so If charli is saying all this behind the scenes I think it’s fair for Taylor to get her. She’s doing sympathy is a knife publicly and the bts she’s being very catty according to Taylor’s song

Shaina

OMG THISSSS!!!! SAY IT LOUDERRRRRRR!

NikiaFalcon

It also sounds like Beverly Hills by wheezer

Sarah

tay should’ve never said anything about it. what do you mean 1989 w/ folklore lyrics GIRL GET UP

Carrie Rose

I’m the same, I spend the whole time leading up to release desperately waiting, then the album arrives and I’m like “I don’t wanna listen 😭” 😂

Ash

I love father figure and it really fits the theme of the album more so than some other songs. It’s inspired by Scott but also how predatory the music industry is. I think this perspective of the industry is definitely an important glimpse behind the curtain of what’s going on behind the scenes with a lot of our favorite showgirls.

🍰

Please wake me up from the nightmare that is Taylor Swift, pushing 40, making kidz bop for millennial MAGA women.

Jadz

These reactions are kind of making me want to log off the internet... I genuinely think this album is great. It sonically clears her other pop records (especially rep, sorry not sorry). Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but this blanket hatred is really colouring my own joyful experience of this excellent record!

Kalina

Madeline PLEASE we need a lyrical analysis of Father Figure asap!! 😭 I thought this was about Scott Borchetta first and I thought she just kinda didn't make the change of perspective very obvious in the bridge but now I think... Has she been the father figure all along? Is this about...? Oh now I'm silent...

Alex

I'm having really confused and conflicting feelings with this album, its the first of hers that I just cant seem to connect to at all and I dont know how I feel about that. I had to kind of force myself to listen more than once because I just had no urge after the first listen. Even though most of the songs are catchy and I enjoy listening to them, theres just something inherently taylor missing from them. Anyone feel the same?

Tayswiffer

Opalite is just so awful, I hate it. I’ve always disliked 70s music. It’s too corny and doo-woppy for my taste so it just sucks that Taylor chose this sound 😭

Sarah

i need someone to do an edit of this because the way i screamed

D1989

Pushing 40… right

Alex

To the point where it has to be intentional right? Is the showgirl of it all being that its lifeless? I choose to believe that because the other option is more horrifying - that she actually believes this is a 12 track perfect 1989/folklore level album. idk i guess after lover comes folklore so theres still some hope?

DrEmily

Given that vinyl pressing takes 10-14 months (supply demand issues), not sure what she could do other than scrap her whole album rollout machine Especially to have vinyl on day 1 of release, and at this volume of units. She has already sold 3.5 million vinyl albums. With all the photos, MV, publicity, merchandising, we are talking loss that is near what it cost to buy back her masters. Should she have used a different word? Probably. But also, the volatile climate could have settled/calmed. No way to know. She can’t see the future

Joan Chan

Omg just starting the reaction and i really relate to you!! I felt “Uh Oh!” so many times on first listen. I have actually come around a lot to several songs but certainly can’t say it’s my favorite album nor her best album

D1989

absolutely feel the same! she is there if you really search (ruin the friendship) but I am really searching…

Stephanie Nation

The album is definitely I grower, once I got more about what she was singing about I liked it a lot more. I have to say I really like the production. There’s a definite 70’s grove and it is layered and orchestral. It’s maybe not what we were expecting but I actually think it recalls that 70’s showgirl height and I can see her influences clearly on more listens.

Dora Paczur

Thank god for your review! Im feeling exactly how you are feeling and i felt a bit alone by being so underwhelmed after Zacks review i knew you would resonate with me so much more. I absolutely love this space that thw two of you created and i cannot wait for you guys to review the album together (also shout out to so it goes greatest song ever made)

Jenny

honestly your reaction is so valid, i've listened to the album over 10 times now, it has not grown on me, i only feel like it got worse. I'm just going to pretend it doesn't exist from this point on 🫩

🍰

If you think a woman her age and her talent should be putting out music this juvenile and embarrassing, that’s very much your problem.

splendidvie

The typography of all of the lyric videos is so bad. As a graphic designer my eyes where bleeding. WHY WHY WHY? With all the money she has, this really just looks tasteless.

Hana Doyle

Well yes! wood for example deserves hateration! I jsut mean in general his first reaction was more positive than madeline's xx

Marissa

Thank you Madeline, I felt the same listening for the first time. A day later I’m honestly even more disappointed, it all feels tone deaf to me. Nothing is actually interesting: not the writing, not the production. But to everyone who likes it: I’m very happy for you, no shade, but this is not for me. I’m sad because as a swiftie since Fearless I want to like it so bad.

Josieee

I feel so seen by this reaction…. Having lived Taylor since 2010, this album gave me such complicated feelings. I want to bop along with Taylor but this was so out of touch and culturally tone-deaf…

maryna

Ok, my theory is: She originally reunited with Max and shellback to re-record rep during the European leg of eras. She got the news that maybe she would finally be given her masters around the same time, so a re-record would not be necessary. Plus ttpd was not doing as well as she was hoping and she was probably already conjuring up a new, better record in her head. So she changed the recording sessions for rep and decided to make an entirely new album, possibly repurposing some of the material that was already there... ? This might explain why cancelled sounds like I did something bad in some parts. Someone on Instagram even compared the two musical tracks and showed that they were very similar. The way she sings certain lines are extremely similar too. In actually romantic there are parts that sound like king of my heart... Elizabeth Taylor sounds very rep too... Is this something that could be true or is this too much of a conspiracy theory?

🍰

I’m not the same person I was when I attended Fearless tour, and neither is she. People change. Money, especially, changes people. I no longer recognize this person she’s become, and that’s ok, that’s life. She makes terrible art now.

Matt Jeffrey

so i listened to the album a couple days early (sorry i couldn’t help it) and was like 👁️👄👁️ now what the hell is this. but after listening to it a bit more especially once it released it’s really starting to grow on me. i think showgirl is more of a sleeper hit than an instant classic.

Josieee

Something about not calling other women “bitches” at every turn… 🥲

Ria

I’m sorry but actually romantic is perfectly reasonable and idk why people expect Taylor to always just take the hits. The song clearly states that Charli was being catty and bitchy behind the scenes, repeatedly, esp w the Matty Healy situation (we all saw how much that affected her). So Taylor has every right to hit back and I’m glad she did!

maryna

Obviously, these are our first impressions. If a first impression is negative it is just as valid as a positive one, I would assume... Your argument can be construed the other way around. You could like the album now and then come to find a boring in two weeks. This is always an option with a new album... But in this comment section specifically we are sharing our first thoughts, all of us. No one has lived with the album for longer than anyone else...

Josieee

So true… it’s like Madeline said, she’s relating everything to her own experience and not cultural reality

🍰

It seems like it’s the 2006-10 fans who are most disappointed. “Everything has changed.”

Josieee

This reaction and all the comments make me feel so seen

Anja Dott

His first reaction to thank you aimee was also extremely positive. I'm excited to hear Zach and Madeline's more fleshed out thoughts, whether something's more positive or negative in hindsight. I have to say some of the songs only stick after 2 to 3 listens. But the lyrics and the not that interesting production are quieting me about this album. This needed more time.

King Sothis

Wish List is going to sit next to my 3 least favorite Taylor songs “Me, Daylight, and Innocent.” I love Taylor being happy, but she lowkey acted super pretentious on Wish List only to go straight into Wood which was a 180 to what Sabrina does. It was vulgar in a way that wasn’t fun and I felt like I got too much of a visualization of Travis’ manhood from it. I do really enjoy the first 6 songs though and I interpreted CANCELLED! as a Blake Lively song not a MAGA/Brittany one. As someone said in the comments, MAGA does most of the cancelling to people nowadays so connecting it to them doesn’t make sense. Overall I love seeing different perspectives on albums, I seem to align more with Zack than I do Madeline which is rare!

Tilly

I just watched the release party and i kind of prefer the clean versions.... for the first time in life

Tilly

I get everything you say, but "trad-wifey"?

🍰

Charli’s song was vulnerable, beautiful, sonically forward-thinking. Taylor’s response is petty, juvenile, embarrassing. You sound as shallow as the song.

Tilly

Was the pushing 40 part necessary...

Marissa

Well yes! But I did love Tortured Poets, which was only released a little while ago when she was already a billionaire. So I think she can still make art, but she doesn’t take enough time to really reflect and work on something great or at least interesting. That’s what annoys me about it. Of course she can do better, she’s Taylor Swift!

🍰

Taylor’s gender politics have never been as regressive as in songs like Fate of Ophelia and Wish List. It’s gross.

Tilly

Yeah I think the reaction would be different if she didn't push as the second coming of Christ

Anja Dott

A moment of silence for all the girlies who bought 1000 different versions of this album and now have to gaslight themselves into thinking this is greatest album of all time...

Meagan

Loved this reaction because I had very similar thoughts, especially to Ophelia. I’ve listened a few times now and my opinions really haven’t changed. The cringe lyrics and lack of showgirl content was disappointing. I think my fave is Father Figure! I don’t think there are any “bangers” that non Swifties will enjoy. Still love you Taylor but this wasn’t it for me.

Marissa

I agree with 🍰. Especially in Wish List it feels like she’s also looking down on people who choose something different in life. And maybe I am sensitive to that, could be. But it rubs me the wrong way.

Josieee

To be fair though, I feel like it didn’t always used to be like this! When I think about Speak Now and Read and 1989, those were all marketed exactly as they were. Then Rep was mostly mystery, which worked well. Lover was a mess but for a number of reasons not just this one. And then we had so many surprise drop albums… I really feel this album is a new level of having been misrepresented…

Tilly

I don't hate it all but the decisions made here are making me worried about what she considers to be good these days and how it will look moving forward...

🍰

LOL serves them right for feeding the Money Pwease monster

rhi

oh my gosh you phrased that so perfectly

Sarah

exactly! and ppl need to understand that our disappointment is because we don’t want to see our goat washed! she is the greatest like yes i’m gonna expect excellence from the greatest lyricist of our time!

Anja Dott

The thing is, MAGA is desperate because most if not almost all artists and all good artists are liberal to progressive in their politics. Fascists from their ideology alone have problems being creative or creating anything that's not plainly derivative and algorithmic. They would gladly take a blonde blue-eyed, straight rich white acclaimed songwriter into their ranks and claim her. She would have to loudly voice progressive values and distance herself for them to not claim her. (Just like they did pre 2019) which atm she doesn't want to do

Miss_Lippy

Where are these MAGAS I am hearing about? Are the MAGAS in the room with us?? I am so perplexed by some of these comments. It’s starting to feel like ppl who didn’t like the album but didn’t know why they didn’t like it just lost their minds and just started saying “Taylor right wing extremist”, “Taylor MAGA”, “Taylor trad wife”, etc. and it sounds insane to me.

Anja Dott

I want to agree with you but the fact that you had to put a question mark behind the obviously is exactly the issue. In the current political climate in the US it's at best tone deaf, at worst insidious to not make those points clear

Alex

The predominant feeling ive felt since this album came out is just sadness tbh. Sad with what we got, sad that she kinda proved all her haters right, sad with how lifeless this era feels. What I keep thinking about is this radio interview she did right when the album came out where they asked what her favourite lyric was and she said it was "I pay the check before it kisses the mahogany grain" which is a perfectly fine lyric but the way she was so excited with it...??? This was the girl who wrote "you made a rebel of a careless mans careful daughter", or who just last year put out ttpd which is filled with lyrical highlights. And yes I know its a pop album but that doesnt mean that "im not a bad bitch and this isnt savage" should be allowed. I've been a taywarrior and will continue to but I think I just have to accept that I won't enjoy this album like I have with every one of her other ones (even lover had more charm and redeeming qualities), and I guess thats why im feeling this sadness? Im just hoping this was a misstep and not a sign of things to come.

Alex

Completely agree. When reputation came out and she did the whole "the old taylor was dead" thing, we could see straight away when the album came out that she was still in there just playing a new role. This time it really feels like shes gone.

Eeeee

we know it’s about “the life” of a showgirl, and we know Travis is a big part of her life, but I agree she should’ve merge those topics together. I was expecting the happier version of I can do it with a broken heart, I don’t hate the album tho I actually love it but I don’t like the way she marketed it as a showgirl theme.

Anja Dott

I fear that there's in issue of not enough people being critical of Taylor's work anymore and helping her course correct when necessary. In her inner circle I mean. But I also see that at her status it might be quite difficult to find people you can trust who aren't just yes men or grifters

🍰

I too have been feeling this sadness. It’s coming from grief. We are experiencing loss. I'm not the same person I was when l attended Fearless tour, and neither is she. People change. Money, especially, changes people. I no longer recognize this person she's become, and that's ok, that's life. She makes terrible art now.

Josieee

This is all so true. First time I listened to the song I loved it, but now that I am reflecting on the impact, I’m horrified. I also feel like it’s very disappointing if this is her well-intentioned support of Blake. Blake was not cancelled for “girlbossing too close to the sun”, she was cancelled because men who sexually harassed her enlisted JOHNNY DEPP’s PR TEAM to conduct a smear campaign…. There are so many layers to that whole situation, beyond simple white feminism, and IF Taylor was going to engage with that, this would be a really superficial and misleading way to do so…

Anja Dott

I felt so bad for Zach during Eldest daughter and especially Wood. The way he was all cheered up bc of the cool production of wood and it being a fine innuendo with "i ain't got to knock on wood"... and then the "ah matized" line hit and his face sank. 😔 it's not even funny to watch, it's terrifying

Rae

Eldest daughter is horrifically bad writing. Actually shocking that 3 icons of the music industry published that. Scary.

Josieee

It genuinely seems like there is no one to edit her anymore!

Josieee

I would if she did this as track 5 like you said and just left Eldest Daughter out completely…

🍰

Thank you. It is horrific.

Josieee

If I was Aaron, and I previously saw this woman create evermore and Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve - I would be silenced

Hattie

Loved this reaction, thank you Madeline. Both you and Zach had similar reactions to me which made me feel so seen! I was so scared I was the only one. I think my overall issue with this album (after multiple listens mind you) is that it is simply not the concept she sold us. It is 'I love my new man' with 'fuck you Charli and Scott Borchetta (?)' sprinkled in. Which is fine!! But don't sell us this Showgirl/ Eras Tour concept just for it to be Lover 2.0. That PMO! Plus, she's working with these industry famous producers and yet none of the songs are instant "bangers" to me?! Like what is going on? Look forward to hearing more of your thoughts after you've had more time with it

Miss_Lippy

Is it a direct response to a “vulnerable song” or a response to things that were said/done behind the scenes that we maybe weren’t privy to? Because if it is about Charli & we are to believe Taylor’s lyrics then essentially Charli was roasting Taylor over lines of coke while partying with The Rat and giving him high fives in approval of him “ghosting” Taylor, which would also be “petty, juvenile and embarrassing” behavior on Charli’s part, no?

Abby

You’re making the same negative comment over and over. It’s weird behavior to be trolling behind a paywall.

Josieee

I think if she had executed it the way she explained that, I would have enjoyed it. For me this song is a skip and a big disappointment

Cosmic Clarity Circle

Yes! Nearly every song’s production is a copy! I don’t understand how she can get away with stealing?

🍰

Whatever background info these songs are based on, we’re here judging pop music. And Charli’s song cannot even be compared to anything on this album. The gap in quality between the two is staggering, and makes Taylor look a fool for trying.

Anja Dott

I don't think it's just MAGA. It's horrible people in general, we joke about Taylor or Blake getting canceled for non-valid reasons but Madeline was thinking of people who have a habit of doing the most vile, criminal and abusive things and end up getting canceled for good reason and rightly so. Taylor is, in a sense, aligning herself with those people who cry about 'cancel culture' the loudest and they tend to be the most horrible anti-accountability people. That's how I understood her. It's not necessarily about who is actually the most anti free speech/cancelling etc. That's just a weaponized talking point to not be held accountable for horrible words or deeds. We know the far right doesn't actually care about free expression of opinion. I totally agree with you on Wood. There's a way to even say "my man is so hot and treating me so good" without focusing on one body part. Which also gets into body shaming territory when it comes to men... I thought of Sabrina in Juno saying "I love the way you fit, God bless your dad's genetics". This actually does it right in my opinion. It's alluding to it and saying the same thing without actually saying "your d*ck is so great". It's also not shaming men who aren't super sized but says "you fit me" which is a way nicer way to say "you're right just as you are"

Brittany

I think I’m gonna see myself out of this conversation because I’m clearly in enemy territory. I absolutely loved this album. We’ve had enough of sad, I don’t wanna be here anymore, Taylor. It’s about time she gets to be happy and silly. This is about HER life of a showgirl. You guys probably all hated TTPD when it came out too. As far as Cancelled goes, she’s obviously sick of fans trying to tell her who she can and can’t be friends with. She told everyone in But Daddy I Love Him the same thing when it comes to her lovers. And she said it’s BULLET PROOF POP. This album is full of bangers, pun intended 😁.

Michelle Akin

I had a completely different reaction to my first listen, but what I will say is I appreciate how thoughtful you are as you're listening. I think being careful with our words, especially before we've had enough time to really formulate an opinion, isn't practiced a lot anymore. I didn't see some of the things you did on first listen, but understand what you're getting at. Thanks for putting out your real reaction!!

Marissa

I’m literally not?

🍰

Literally where are the bangers you speak of?

Brittany

You just didn’t get what she’s trying to tell us. She’s letting us know “guys I’m not actually that cool, I’m not like the rest of the pop divas but I’ll always be here for you guys regardless.”. She’s a cringy millennial and she’s finally letting her freak flag fly high!

V

Wait where can I watch that livestream? Hehehe

Brittany

If you’re a hater just say so. You’re in ALL the comments being negative about everything. You should eat some cake 🍰. Maybe you’re just hangry.

🍰

People who lack critical thinking capacities always think valid criticism is trolling. Maybe learn to think beyond a binary of “negative” and “positive.”

Ro2207

At this point, I've been a fan of Taylor's for almost 20 years. There have been times where her music has resonated with me profoundly (Speak Now, Red etc) and times where the music just hasn't quite hit me the same (Lover). But regardless of how I've ever felt about an album, I've always still been able to recognise the artist and the artistry. With TLOAS, I've never felt so far removed from Taylor as an artist. Who is this for? How is this supposed to resonate? I just cannot reconcile the growth of her work over the past two decades with the type of writing and perspective found on this album. I have always loved Taylor's work primarily for her storytelling and lyricism. That's what's carried me through any genre, any topic. I will happily move with her through country, pop, soft rock, folk music, anything, because I believe in her ability to write and convey a story. That can be the sharp, concise distance of 1989 or the confessional sprawling of TTPD. It is not that I want every album to be literary or tied in complex metaphor. I know for a fact that her pen is just as talented when directed to concise pop writing. But this? I just cannot reconcile this level of lyricism, perspective and storytelling with the artist I have spent more than half my life admiring. There is just very, very little for me to connect to as a listener. I understand that the days of relating to Taylor's life on a personal level are behind us (e.g. she is not the girl-next-door of Debut and Fearless and I am also not a 15 year old girl anymore either.) I understand that Taylor's life is so far removed from anything I could imagine for myself. But that removal has never been an issue before. Midnights and TTPD (and albums beyond those) still hold those universal moments of storytelling and lyricism that I can connect to, regardless of Taylor's life, because Taylor as an artist has ALWAYS resonated. I don't feel that way with TLOAS and it's left me feeling quite flat towards the album. I know for a fact that if this was written by anyone other than Taylor, I would never give it another listen. It's a strange position to be in. Despite my accidental essay above, it's far from the end of the world that 1 of Taylor's 12 albums doesn't resonate with me. She still has a remarkable catalogue that I will continue to adore. I have faith in her artistry overall and know future projects will resonate with me differently. In the meantime, I'm still super excited about the possibility of Debut TV coming out for the 20th anniversary, or whatever else the next year could hold for her artistry. Again. So SO sorry for the essay. 🥲🥲

Taylah Louise

Don’t forget the marketing of midnights. I think with this one, what she’s been saying is true ‘it represents her life during eras era’ these were the things she was afflicted with during that time. It’s just the showgirl cover of it all that made us expect some more glitz and glimmer but she was explicit in saying the songs weren’t about being on stage.

Rae

I fully understand what’s she’s saying Brittany, in fact I understand it too well because she’s hitting us over the head with it. It’s a badly executed concept and I expect more from her. This is an artist 20 years into her craft.

Mary Massed

Wait - now that we’ve all listened, can someone explain how “the shiny bug collection” fits in?? I’m confused!

Rae

No I’m actually worried that fashion isn’t the only thing she’s developed a bad taste for

Briana

Madeline is once again a national treasure that should be protected at all costs, resetting after the first song killed me 😂 also very much agree with your point on her and Travis’ problematic fascist friends. She seems to either have zero awareness of this fact or she truly does not care that she’s tied to far-right bitch babies. Both are problematic. (I’m a grad student studying 20th century German history, so you can imagine the alarm bells that have been going off in my head since she’s immersed herself into maga land)

Hailee S

well yes I think she’s always had a hard time talking abt things she doesn’t relate to as many do however from the lyrics “I like em cloaked in gucci & in scandal” I think that was purposely meant to be bold & satire & that’s a perfect example of the satire throughout the album. as for the white feminism allegations she is white yes & anything she could have said abt politics, money, fame ect was always gonna come off as “white feminism” & “tone deaf” just bcs of the current state of the world & recent events however u have to remember when this was being written & pressed that was not accurate for the time. I think people are making it out to be something it’s not just bcs a lot of people are on edge rn (rightfully so) however at the time that was not the case hence why the “it’s concervative” “its giving Brittany” ect is not an accurate or fair assessment. The anger & concern people feel abt her saying a few badly worded sentences needs to be redirected to the actual politicians, political figures, current administration ect…

Alex

"I know for a fact that if this was written by anyone other than Taylor, I would never give it another listen. It's a strange position to be in." exactly this

Chantel

thank fucking god i needed this reaction more than i needed this album

🍰

When Brittany characterizes valid criticism as being “negative” and a “hater,” it tells me what I need to know about her critical thinking capacities. It’s disappointing, and sadly reflects so many uncritical, unthinking swifties. Taylor became a billionaire off these people.

Laurel

It’s a grower for sure. It’s not my favorite but it’s “hits different” after a few listens. I don’t hate it but it won’t be one I revisit often. Taylor likes to document her life in albums and for me this is a snapshot.

Missy

I’m sad for you that your first listen was…not what you expected. Big respect for you for putting your honest first thoughts out there. Eager to hear more from you once you have time to process.

Lou

Right! If the album was doing what that song does it would be an actual moment that would get attention and praise because nobody else is Taylor Swift so nobody else has that perspective

Lou

The self awareness has left the room at this point

Madelyn Fornia

I had the same reaction keep listening and it’ll get better

Lou

Oh my god thank you, Midnights is really what started it all. The downfall

Lou

Because of the time we live in

Jill

The “I’m not a bad bitch, this isn’t savage” line in Eldest Daughter feels so weird on the same album as Actually Romantic and CANCELLED! Like…are you sure?

maryna

I loved reading this. I feel the exact same way (even though I became a fan later then you did, but obviously I know the entire back catalog and connect with it). Showgirl is not special. Maybe I can accept that some songs are bangers and people are fond of them, but the magic is missing. It is not lightning in a bottle, it does not showcase her talents, except maybe for vocals. But this is not an album that cements her legacy. I think the general public like it because it is also a very safe album, these are regular pop songs you could hear on the radio (obviously. I mean she worked with the biggest producers in the world, so of course they at least come up with something that is decent, these are professionals), so what's not to casually like? But casually liking something as a background track when driving in the car or sitting in front of the computer should not be the bar that Taylor should want to clear, I think. She's the biggest popstar in the world and this album does not do this status justice.

Lou

Deleted?

Kaila LaBonte

Do we think she made Actually Romantic the shortest song on the album as another dig? As in I’m spending time on your song the least. I’m sure I’m way behind on that theory but just dawned on me

Ash

As someone who has the ick from Wood, I’m not sure if this makes it better or worse, but maybe it’s a slap at Matty. He’s the smallest man who ever lived and didn’t measure up in any measure of a man so she’s rubbing it in his face that her new man is great in bed.

JD IHateItHere

If a showgirl allows someone to open for her and said showgirl publicly and privately talks shit about you in the most hurtful and down phase of one’s life, said showgirl is going to annihilate someone. That’s show business, baby. So……it’s not a friendship bracelet, but it’s honest about the betrayal. — that said, the conceit, if turned on Taylor about Kimberly, is withering in the assessment of loving what you spend time being obsessed about. So, there is that. Divas……take it for what it is. It is funny and move on.

D.D.

Never apologize for an A+ essay!! 🫶

Amelia

The best angle for appearing unbothered, if that's what she was going for, would be to not address it at all.

Stacy Davydova_13

I’m from 1989 era and I’m fuming 😭😭😭

Silas Chester

We were deprived of a “my dick is bigger” reaction and I will never forget that.

e

honey sounds like a reheated jack antonoff song from midnights and the lyrics omg... "you can call me honey if you want because i'm the one you want" sounds so off i cannot believe it made it out of the studio. and i agree with your opinion on cancelled! i cant imagine any situation in which i would like to listen to that song. the whole album was marketed as a look behind the curtain especially with the bathtub symbolizing her exhaustion and recovery and we just got another love song album with a few songs that are legitimately confusing me. the only song i sonically really like is actually romantic but just because it reminds me of olivia rodrigo lol

Ria

And you’re in every comment coming for people who like the song/taylor. You sound just as obsessed as Charli is with Taylor. You can prefer one song over another but my god let others disagree, in fact, my comment said absolutely nothing about the comparison of the 2 songs, just that Taylor is allowed to hit back. And you also completely skipped over the part where she was clearly being bitchy to Taylor BTS.

Jaqi Jarboe

Why did you cut through the songs! It would have been great to see your reaction to by dicks bigger

Maurice

after 2 days with this album it‘s giving the opposite effect of TTPD…this is just faceless

Anuradha Srinivasan

Same! I enjoyed the clean versions so much more and gave me a complete different reaction to my first listen.

Taylor Rae

And this is why she needs Jack in the room imo. He’s much more in tune with what’s going on, speaks out when necessary, etc. He’s also her friend, and seems to keep her grounded. Max & Shellback aren’t American, so they aren’t as familiar with the current affairs in this country.

Nicole

You summed up exactly how I feel

Shikhar

Thank you for sharing your personal anecdotes but this feels like a whole lot of nothing. I would need specific examples of lyricism from the albums that you love and resonate with contrasted against the ones from TLOAS that you dislike to understand where you're coming from. Without that, I can only assume the reason this album feels “far removed” for you (and many others) is because it’s Taylor finally owning her power. She’s comfortable in her status, and that confidence can feel alienating when you’re used to meeting her in the cracks of heartbreak, self-doubt, and grief (which either one or more were present on every single album till this one).

Shanice Marie

Notice how I didn't say a damn thing about you liking the album or not? Or do you just not have basic reading comprehension skills. This was a ridiculous jump to make and honestly proves my point. Grow up, ffs. This wasn't a conversation about the merits of the album. I do not gaf what you did and didn't like about the album. I'm specifically talking about the marketing which I fully believe alligns with the concept of the album. I'm starting to see that you guys can't pick up on context clues, AT ALL. Your ability to understand something isn't the problem, its your reaction to your misunderstanding that is. "I CAN'T BE WRONG. IT'S CLEARLY THE ARTISTS FAULT I DIDN'T UNDERSTAND THE PITCH". Omg, if anyone here can't handle criticism its you. My statement had nothing to do with me being a "dedicated fan" who defends everything Taylor does. I'm merely pointing out that this product is exactly what it was advertised to be. I'm not sure why I'm surprised given the state of the literacy crisis. You guys seem to be allergic to critical thinking and intellectualism. You think that your interpretation is the only interpretation to be had and therefore everyone else is wrong. I hate to break it to you but that's exactly what art is. I understand her concept because I didn't go into it expecting her to execute it a specific way. Doing that is expecting an artist to execute YOUR creative vision not theirs. You are free to not understand or dislike that vision, however, that doesn't mean there wasn't a vision or that the artist didn't do it "right".

ipekbaltacioglu

LOL nobody outside USA thought cancelled is relevant to the MAGA propoganda. IT’s OBV ABOUT HER FRIENDS CANCELLED WRONGLY LIKE BLAKE. I’ve never seen anyone even in twitter talking about it being out of touch. WHY ARE YOU STIRRING already existing useless hate about taylor and this album. You always talk about and brag about being one of the older swifties. I feel like every video you find something to make fun of. You act like its funny to be a swiftie. But generally say hand heart etc. You really need to “hand heart” at this current situation. We all can agree this album being a little far off the concept. Still there are bangers.

Shaina

And I oop- why are you so pressed, Shanice? YOU replied to MY comment. And said "you guys didn't get it". Sorry if I chose to repsond? But okay. Y'all are what makes this fandom so insufferable.

Lauren Hickcox

But she didn’t say it was about the eras tour? She said it was a look behind the curtain at her life during that time. To me that’s what she gave. The eras tour was the showgirl moment.

Stacy Davydova_13

Right?! TTPD was getting better, and this one just getting worse and worse…

mallorey garrett

How are you in “enemy territory”? That’s silly. We are all Swifties at the end of the day, regardless of how we felt about this album. Zach sounded like he really liked it, a lot of people still did?? I didn’t love it myself, but girlfriend has 11 other albums in her discography for me to enjoy, it’s not the end of the world.

Nicola

Totally agree on the first few tracks matching the aesthetics of Midnights, the 70s Fleetwood Mac guitar vibe. The album is very disappointing for me overall. She is capable of so much more and so much better. I like tracks 1-4 but they are just perfectly fine pop songs. This woman made Ready For It? and Blank Space. Ugh 😣

Heather

Thanks you! Reading the comments I was thinking the same. She is allowed to be happy and she clearly is. I never used to listen to album reactions i would simply listen to her album, enjoy her songs, and that was it. Im thinking going forward I will go back to that. With that said - Elizabeth Taylor (in my opinion) is an amazing song! I truly love the whole album but that song is incredible.

Dorka

I am sorry it wasn't a great first listen. It is a grower and the melodies get way better over time and if you really dissect the lyrics, there is a lot of great lyricism there, I am sure you will feel differently after watching the film. Cancelled! is one of my top songs, and I haven't really seen anyone doing a maga spin on this, to me it is the complete opposite, a return to rep, it is so witchy, it cites from Macbeth, it is IDSB, it is the dark version of Karma taking all her friends to the summit. Maybe it is the word cancelled that has been so loaded over the last 10 years. I like my friends being badass and unapologetic is rather what she means... I am also far removed from US politics and think the majority of the listeners didn't have that perspective.

Jaqi Jarboe

What an unfair analysis lol. She’s clearly not maga Donald probably wants to shoot her because she won’t give him a handy. Please take the maggot talk out of here

🍰

Despite everything you’ve written, Taylor’s attempt at a diss still sucks. It’s bad music, and that’s what we’re discussing here.

Vanessa Vieites

Clearly not because here you are under every other comment, super bothered 🤣

Vanessa Vieites

You quite literally do lmao some maga dipshit just shot up a Mormon church, another killed two people for allegedly making fun of Kirk, and another one shot two dem law makers this summer and killed one.. so nice try. you’re delusional 🤡

Vanessa Vieites

Then why are you here? Go eat your food 😘

Jessa Jayne

My complaint about wood is Travis is from Ohio and Buckeye trees are also really tall Redwood is so California. It’s a stupid nitpick but it’s also right there

Emily

Watching this kinda put me in a sour mood. I feel like this got way too misinterpreted and personal biases came into play. I love madeline but just a little disappointed in this.

Shanice Marie

I used my literary analysis skills and sermized that this album lives up to the concept pitched. I didn't realize using those skills meant I was making things up that weren't there. I guess I'll throw my bachelor's degree in English literature and writing in the trash now, Shaina. Clearly everything I know about analysis and literary theory is a lie. You're right and I'm wrong, you win and I lose, you're smart and I'm dumb. Happy? 😐

Amanda

Exactly how I feel! Very well said!!!

Ro2207

@Shikhar I mean this in a respectful way, but I don't particularly feel the need to prove my perspective to a stranger on the internet nor do I see the point in providing anyone with an itemised list of lyrics I like just to see if someone will approve of my personal opinion. TLOAS wasn't for me personally. I have many friends who really love the album, for many different reasons. I totally respect how they feel and am happy they connect with the album in all the ways they do. What I will say is that I do not need (nor have ever needed) Taylor to be caught in heartbreak or betrayal or pain to connect with her work. I have loved Taylor's work throughout her entire career, through all spectrum of emotions and experiences. She has depicted her joy, power and voice from her very first album. Those are qualities I have cherished and valued from Day 1 of being a fan.

Kate Zhuzha

Thank you for your honest reaction to Cancelled! So relatable.

Amelia

Yikes dude, this is pretty ageist tbh.

mindyrose

Can I just ask why you chose to be a member of THIS podcast and then asked people to “stop thinking so deep” like…thinking deeply about Taylor swift is kinda the whole bag here ???

La Barrah

I’m from the UK and I also connected the dots to MAGA. Also, politely, STFU and get off Madeline’s ass. Respectfully.

Jenny

As a German swiftie - I immediately thought of Brittany Mahomes. Sorry.

Shaina

Well, if we're bringing up degrees then I'm definitely winning here with a literal Master's degree in Media Studies with a final year thesis about popular culture. You will lose that fight, darling. And it was never about winning or losing over this btw. It’s about having an opinion about a piece of media without some annoying stan telling me that "I don't get it." Check yourself.

Jessie Rose Sorensen

Don’t get me wrong, I want people to like the album, but I am happy to hear I wasn’t the only one walking away confused. I feel like we really got served dirty expectations vs reality with having it promoted as “Eras Tour”, “behind the curtain”, and “show girl” when it was mostly a “I’m happy with Travis” album. It also feels very surface level and I was hoping for something more diaristic. But the vibes are good and I am liking it more with more listens.

pricila

Yes some of the lyrics are giving millennial/ how you do fellow kids, and i feel the theme of the life of a showgirl behind the curtains could of been more prominent but after my third listen and watching the release party im warming up to it ! Love opialite, ruin the friendship, honey, and wood so far ❤️‍🔥

ipekbaltacioglu

“They stood by me before my exoneration They believed I was innocent” its OBV about blake

La Barrah

Omg you’re so right 💀💀💀

Shikhar

you are paying dollars to be on this patreon and talk shit. twitter is free and full of like minded individuals like you

Shanice Marie

I'd suggest rereading both of my comments to understand what is being said and what is not. I'm not responding to your critique of the album because I do not disagree with your assessment on the merits of the album 😐...

Ria

No, that’s what you’re discussing even when no one is conversing back with you about that

Erin

Yall beggg for her to share her immediate reactions and then act like this lol

micky

orange looks soooo pretty on you Madeline omg

James Meyer

You need to calm down...

olli

I mean this is just her first reaction, not a review or anything. Of course this entire thing is going to be filled with personal biases

Shannon

Yeah that's the irony of the song? She is so unbothered but then she is making a whole song about it lol

KT_p

This *isn’t* a Taylor Swift fan club echo chamber. It’s a place to discuss all aspects. People are so uncomfortable with critical thinking, it’s actually a little disturbing. Opinions that differ from your own aren’t invalid. Some like it, some don’t. Neither opinion is more valid than the other.

Shannon

I think "The Shiny Bug" was the name of one of the poems she wrote to include with the variants. The poems were more showgirl that the album at this point lol

JD IHateItHere

The fear people have of criticizing Taylor is unwarranted as is the fear of loving her music. Just be. Just savor. Just disagree without hate. It’s music. Yes, we love her for many parasocial reasons, but we can bop as well as look askance. We love the girl, we watch the show, and we walk away the better for it. The sounds are wonderful. The happiness is clear. The derangement is real. What do you want from the woman raised in the asylum? She is the woman who says we are soft kittens if we can’t take it. Diva up and dance. I know we are in hard times. It’s not playing a fiddle while Rome burns. It’s trying to say, in the end we all try to love love. Breathe in the fresh air. The Speak Now Reputation Midnights of it all is overwhelming and a bit de-centering, but in a way that is a spoonful of sugar. Just my fifth listen take of the album. Love Madeline and feel for the showgirl doing this in front of us all. Diva!

Kyla

the birthday candle smell is 10/10!!!!!!!!!!!

James Meyer

I'd have no problem with Taylor hitting back, but she did it in very embarrassing way. Not clever or self-aware. She claims she is so unbothered, that Charli can't hurt her... well, still she wrote this song, so clearly she is hurt and bothered. And the trope of you're so obsessed with me you must love me is so Regina George. Maybe Katy was onto something...

Shannon

This I can't get over that this is a track 5. Rhyming "meme" with "seen"

Yara

Thank you for not being a boot licker about Cancelled, watching people getting dragged to modern concentration camps and listening to her sing about Britney really broke something in me.

Kyla

also thank you for the apple music representation🤍🤍🤍

Kaitlyn MacGilvray

i think she’s mad abt the stuff behind the scenes hence the boring barbie comment!!

Kaila LaBonte

Not to also be nitpicky, but the Ohio Buckeyes are a rival of the Cincinnati bearcats, his college football team. Calling him a Buckeye would have been an insult 😅🫣

Anita

I feel like this album is overall good, but very out of touch, and some songs are just bad. She is currently very out of touch with reality because she does live in a completely separate world. I think this is one of her first albums that I cannot relate to any song

Noelia

Orange IS your colour!! 🧡

Francesca

Someone said the republicans mom will post photos from rallies with cancelled as a song and now I can't usee it 😭

Rose Lebeau

Great point and great comment. I tend to agree

Deb

I am new to this site, but it seems to be a forum for hate and ridicule. Madeline's reaction video was an embarrassment. And No, we don;t agree the song Cancelled was tone deaf. It is more relevant than ever when you consider that the President was trying to cancel Taylor just a few months ago. Perhaps Madeline is out of touch with the divide in the country? I also think Taylor used words above people's understanding. According to Slangsphere, “ah-matized” means "something has been done with a ridiculous, over-the-top energy, almost as if by an unpredictable, chaotic force. " People just put the dic in front of the term with their own imagination. The slang nailed that perfect balance of sounding like a legit term but being totally goofy — which is prime meme fuel. I really think the folks that start out with "I hate the music" usually lack understanding of the poetry.

Eva Warwick

It's not about Brittany. It's about Blake. The bridge where she references how much her and Ryan supported her while she was getting cancelled reveals that

Marco Rubboli

I'm Italian and my first thought was: Republican song

Erin

ok Deb

Hannah Traveller

Am I the only one who actually enjoyed the album? The first four songs were bangers to me instantly. The rest of them were enjoyable enough but not as strong. I do agree that it’s not really on theme but I still had fun with it. And before y’all light my ass up, I’m extremely liberal socialist. (I keep seeing people saying only maga will like this)

Hattie

Maybe I read too much into it and was barking up the wrong tree but I thought “show girl” and “peek behind the curtain” would give us more of a behind the scenes on the experience of the Eras Tour; going on stage every night no matter how she’s feeling, regardless of what’s going on in her personal life, ICDIWABH vibes. That’s the vibe I was getting with the album photoshoot 🤷🏼‍♀️

Angela

I totally get everything you said about Cancelled but I loved it so much upon my first few listens b/c I’m a Reputation girl and I loved the sound and some of the lyrics (“I salute you if you’re much to much to handle” spoke to me as someone who is a hot mess and too much to handle sometimes lol). But I do struggle to connect the Taylor who is BFFs with someone like Brittany to the one crying on her doc b/c she wanted to be on the right side of history when it came to speaking out about politics. I have no good answer so unfortunately have to be a hypocrite on this one and enjoy the song and pretend it is a literal rep vault track. 😵‍💫

Becca

There is a difference between hating on an album and respectfully not enjoying the songs because they’re not your vibe. I feel like you and Zach both fit into the latter, and there is nothing wrong with that. I don’t think I’ve heard either of you say that other swifties are dumb or whatever for liking this album. I like the album, but I’m not going to be like “omg how can you not like this album?!” to other people either. That’s disrespectful, as everyone has their own tastes. “The customer is always right in matters of taste” as the line actually goes.

Sam

Eldest Daughter is Track 5 so the super cringey lyrics in that one are meant to be emotional, profound, etc. That makes it way worse than Wood imo which is cringe but it almost seems to be the point? It’s certainly not taking itself seriously so it feels easier to just try to enjoy the music. I loved the music of Eldest Daughter and would give anything for her to rewrite the lyrics.

Emrose

The clean version (that they used for the movie so it wouldn’t get ticked for ratings and she could avoid all that) changed that lyric to hypnotized because she is referring to dick. If it wasn’t she wouldn’t have to change it to be considered Clean.

Valeria Corvalán

After listening to the album all day yesterday...I just want to say that Taylor looses skill when she has a long term muse. The Turkey was a long term muse. And Travis is and will be a muse for a looong time..I fear for the music we will continue to get after she is married...I don't know

anne

yeah ive been trying to convince myself too that this would have happened eventually anyway and the question was when… we know though that she will make another smash album in the future and the question is also when…

Eden McFadden

Does anyone know when their joint episode will come out? They posted a release week schedule but I can’t find it anywhere

Savanna

great take

Anja Dott

I feel like that makes it worse bc body shaming is such a low blow. It's such a sensitive point for men given our culture's (and porn's) obsession with d*ck size. I would have much preferred she had highlighted other qualities like him taking good care of her or going out of his way to pleasure her. Focusing on a body part a man has no control over 👎🏻 that's low imo

Hailee S

I think the whole concept of the album was not supposed to be relatable to the general public. Being a “show girl” is not generally how normal everyday people go abt their lives. Hence why it seems so “out of touch”

Justus 🤍

You don’t need to protect her. Grow up

Sam

Overall, I think my general consensus now is good not great, and I think the most honest she’s been about it was that creating new music was the only way to sustain herself during the Eras Tour. Through that lens, an exhausted Taylor gave what she could with what was going on in her life and then tried to apply a cohesive concept after the fact. I still think production was good on a lot of the songs and it was good for her to work with Max and Shellback again. What Taylor needs and doesn’t have is someone who pushes and edits her lyrically. She doesn’t have that with any of these guys- find a woman haha.

Justus 🤍

Yall just hate fun. I was watching some music producers react to that song and each one commented on how well the song is put together and how good of a pop song it is

Justus 🤍

Well… someone isn’t a swifty lol

Gaussia

Absolutely agree on the surface level thing. I’m also feeling like she’s singing a lot of it kinda… flat? Don’t get me wrong the vocals are good technically but they are like lazy and lifeless a bit? You’d think she’d be more emotionally on when singing about a non-hypothetical love story

Emrose

If I think of this as Lover 2.0 I’m happy… I’m feed. None of these songs are gonna crack my top 10, probably not top 25. It’s fun vibes and it’s not that serious.

Anja Dott

Sorry to inform you that MAGA propaganda is everywhere not just in the US. The USA have been the cultural and economic hegemony for the last several decades.

aubs

I agree that it’s probably about Blake howeverrrrr that’s not really the issue. It’s moreso the tone-deafness of it all, yes unfortunately where you’re literally the biggest artist in the world you do have to worry about how your music will be taken both in and out of context. Most casual Taylor Swift listeners don’t know about Blake and Ryan staying friends with Taylor when she was cancelled, so while they may connect the dots- if they don’t it CAN look bad. Personally I like the sound of the song but the lyrics are SO corny. The way she sings “cancelled” is really cringe, and usually I’m a live your truth and be cringe kind of girl, but it’s the sort of word you don’t want to use in a song because it won’t age well. In 10 years will we all be saying “yes Cancelleddddd timeless classic”? I really doubt it. That doesn’t make it “bad” but I do think there’s quite a bit Taylor could’ve done to make it better and also less ambiguous.

Gaussia

Am I the only one tired of all her albums being growers lately? It’s great when they get better in my eyes but I have a bit of a feeling like I’m Stockholm syndroming myself (fitting for a Max Martin album lol)

jacquie o

I feel where you’re coming from but I think there needs to be space for her to have an authentic moment otherwise she won’t do them anymore! Reactions are your body literally reacting to stimuli, it’s knee jerk - they aren’t trying to be reviews. I’m fascinated watching her make sense of it in real time. The review will come later :)

V

Oh nonono in the standard review they said “ Obviously the Swifties are pulling double shifts in the streaming mines to get the album to number one”😭 I’m dying I’ve never heard someone say the streaming mines before😭 Clocked em! Like all ppl frantically streaming are so in the mines for their overlords😭

Padraic

So does being a swiftly mean you must blindly nod and enjoy every single thing Taylor does because that is fucking insane

Ria

So she can’t say anything? Bc then she’s obsessed? It’s the first time she’s spoken about her so lmfao

aubs

I was thinking that this morning too lol! Like it is a little funny and ironic that like 2 seconds after she says “I’m not a bad bitch - this isn’t savage” she calls Charlie xcx a coke head and compares her to a chihuahua in a purse 😭 I like AR but miss girl I’d call that pretty savage

Dorka

I loved it at the first listen, it maybe grower for others. I didn't like Midnights on first listen. TTPD and this was instant love for me.

Anja Dott

Completely agree, make up and outfit were serving 🧡✨️💄

La Barrah

‘We don’t agree’, ‘Madeline’s reaction video was an embarrassment’ - the tone of this comment is just nasty for nasty sake, which is kind of ironic isn’t it? Maybe this site of hate and ridicule is the perfect place for you after all

Ria

And I gave my opinion? I think you might be a bit removed from ‘critical thinking’ if you think that me disagreeing with something/liking something that Taylor does makes you unable to have respectable thoughts

Jessie Rose Sorensen

I see it. Like if this is the real love of her life I am not feeling the passion. The songs are giving more “he has a great dick” and “I am happy to not be alone” than he is THE one. We were told pop bangers and I felt like there was this almost a softer atmospheric vibe to it all.

Anja Dott

Stop 😭😭 I'm seeing visions of all the MAGA Brittany Mahomes type girlies choosing Eldest daughter as their wedding song

Hattie

"hate and ridicule'', then calling Madeline's reaction an embarrassment? lol ok diva deb

Isabela Krall

The more I listen the more obsessed I am. I hope soon Madeline and other people on here start enjoying it more! Not because everyone always needs to love everything Taylor does, but because life is just way more fun when you’re screaming and dancing new Taylor music all day 🥰

Karibunt

Madelines reaction was also mine

Cassady Lynn

I’m not sure that’s Taylor’s responsibility BUT I totally see that side

🍰

Ria just can’t handle that the song fucking sucks lol

Abby

HAHAHA the Ready For It reset 😂😂😂😭😭😭

Rachel

CANCELLED! is 100% about Blake and how the media and public demonize women, and how a friend is going through something Taylor previously went through. Idk how people can get MAGA vibes or Britney Mahomes from it, as Britney has been cancelled and disliked before her and Taylor ever met.

Shanice Marie

I'm sorry for being defensive and making you feel like I was directly attacking your opinion. I think you misunderstood my intention and point. I think we, as the audience, are supposed to be the ones figuring out how the work connects with the concept and by extention the marketing of that concept. In my opinion, the album matches the marketing thematically but that doesn't mean I think she executed the concept well. I can acknowledge that you and I probably have different ideas about what "The Life of a Showgirl" is as theme and concept. I'm not disagreeing with your opinions about how well she did it per say. I actually agree with you on the artistic merits and quality of the album overall. Which is why I stated several times that my comment had nothing to do with that. However, I don't think the marketing for the concept was off, misleading, or that the concept isn't there. To me, everything fits the album thematically in the sense that drama, scandal, cattiness, and performance are what make a showgirl, a showgirl. To me it makes sense that the "drama" would bleed into her reality, it feels like she meant to be hyperbolic but that made it difficult to tell when she was being serious. Some tracks embody the concept very well, are well written, have productions highs and make for a fun listen. However, other tracks do leave more to be to desired. Some are even to the point that the production doesn't distract from the objectively bad writing. ALL of that is true even if she's playing a character or being hyperbolic. I full agree that this is most definitely not her best work or album, I was not negating that fact. Nor am I negating that this album is messy though I do think some of the mess is intentional due to what I've stated about the showgirl of it all. I do see why she said some of the album is evermore adjacent, some songs are just storytelling. I do agree with you to an extent, her comments about wanting this album to be clear, deliberate, and concise are baffling. I really want to know what she cut if Eldest Daughter saw the light of day. I think that track is her worst writing on the album and maybe even her whole catalog. At least ME! and Robin make sense sonically and lyrically. Idk what she was thinking or why its even there when Ruin the Friendship is objectively a better song.

h

I would guess on Monday

caroline

The album had already been recorded and gone to press by the time all their drama had happened though.

aubs

I’m so in between you and Zach’s reaction which is kind of great because I agree with both of you. I do REALLY like the Fate of Ophelia, honestly I personally like the first 3 tracks the most on the record. However the writing on this album…um…Taylor baby what was that. I’ve waxed poetic about Cancelled in a different comment but also Eldest Daughter? Even Wood which is like a Sabrina song gone terribly wrong? I think Taylor just doesn’t SOUND good trying to do some of the things she was doing on this album. It’s like 5 songs I really like, 3 songs I vibe with pretty okay, and 4 songs that I genuinely wonder how they made it out of the studio. Which for another artist would be quite good I suppose? I think part of it is that expectation that if Taylor Swift is releasing a 12 song album it’s going to be extremely concise and tight. At worst maybe one filler song and that’s it. I’m also sort of disappointed with the production on this album? It’s good but it’s not really *interesting*. Addison had more interesting production on her debut album than TLOAS which doesn’t make me “sad” but it’s kind of insane. I don’t know, I do LIKE the album, I by no means hate it as much as some people do…I just don’t really understand why she released it now? It feels so unfinished and like the lyrics in so many of the songs are half baked drafts. Frankly I’ve heard demos of her songs where she hasn’t finalized lyrics yet that were miles better than what we got on this album. And I’m not even asking for TTPD lyricism or Folklevermore type shit, it’s a pop album! But I would’ve loved to see writing akin to 1989 or Rep. Even Rep feels like it will age 10x better than this album and this album JUST came out. So anyway, that whole essay to say, thank you for reacting and being honest. It’s definitely not really what anyone was expecting and it’s not “hater behavior” or anything like that to not LOVE something immediately

Kylee

There’s something about it that feels timeless (not the song, Timeless, although its lyrics actually kind of feel like that too but for different reasons 😆) But it has this easy listening, almost late 70s soft rock, sound to it i.e. Brandy (You’re a Fine Girl, Escape (The Pina Colada Song), and most of the Steve Miller Band discography. I like it— it’s nice.

Leslie

Sunday. The schedule is in Instagram

Kylee

This is great! I was just thinking I did not have the life of a showgirl as a political movement/stance on my 2025 Bingo card but here we are. 🍿🍿🍿

Alex Iscream

<3 Thank you Madeline for a lot of interesting and honest takes ! It was a ride to surf this with you and honestly me and my friends had lots of same reaction as you.. especially i clap and cheer at what you said about Cancelled! being a perfect MAGA anthem .. I am really disappointed and worried about several things on this album hinting at Taylor being more and more tone deaf disconnected white rich girl with too many maga "aquaintances". Wish list makes me cringe in that context too. First time i feel its getting hard to relate with her actually. Thanks for this video- and the witchy intro haha :) Long love Father Figure hopefully.

Rachel

The Blake drama started when the It Ends with Us movie came out last August, over one year ago. That’s plenty of time before she had to complete the album

Ria

I think the person who can’t handle someone having a different opinion is you. Mind you, YOU are the person who is coming into my comment going at it again and again with arguments that have no relevance to my original comment. And since you want to go throwing your weight around, come on, put your name out, say it with your chest! Hiding behind a cake emoji…pathetic. Feel free to dislike the song. But honestly get a life and accept the fact that I don’t think that the song was unnecessary.

Alex Iscream

uhm we do know about maga in europe and we have problems with the rise of fascism too

Kylee

Well….💀💀💀

micky

On the New Heights podcast when she started talking about being offline and we all were like "she's definitely getting updates from her assistants" n stuff... I feel like that was the premonition that there were gonna be pieces of this album that were out of touch.

Void Vanderwall

Is it just me or did she skip ruin the friendship?

Taylor Rae

Thank you for your review. It’s refreshing to see Madeline be a fan without being a sycophant. That’s exactly why the Snakes have my support and money. I really tried to convince myself I liked this, thinking maybe it was just me. But it hasn’t grown on me with repeated listens or time to marinate and click. If anything, it’s decayed rather than bloomed. I’m so disappointed and honestly a bit embarrassed as a fan. I feel like Zach in a headdress hearing eldest daughter or you stripping the boa 3 lines in. Someone above put it perfectly: “If this were by anyone but Taylor Swift, I wouldn’t ever listen to it again.” I really hope this is a floppy era like Lover that leads to something better. Now if youll excuse me, Imma hit the back catalog.

Justus 🤍

Clean versions are better for some songs. I think it’s ok to embrace the cringe. Like with cancelled. It’s supposed to be a moment and more theatrical. Her writing is still very good on this album just some cringy lyrics

Justus 🤍

She literally recorded wish list not that long ago she said. Blake stuff happened awhile back!!

Justus 🤍

Same. It gets better and better. Also clean versions of some songs are better

Erika Rodriguez

Dang - I’m just over here dancing nonstop. It’s just a fun good time. The hate is boring honestly

Justus 🤍

Yes. This is how every fan base is. There are just way more swifties. Why be so negative?

Joan Rood

Taylor was right when she said in TTPD that she writes the worst men best - or something to that effect.

Alex Iscream

lightning candles hoping she actually wakes up and come back better. the grief feeling gets a bit too real

Justus 🤍

Yea no. Joe gave us some of the best songs. And this is our first album with Travis. Does patience exist to yall?? Fate of Ophelia is her best single in a LONG time and that’s about Trav. Joe gave us cruel summer. Calm down and realize that her talent is her owns and not because of any man. That’s extremely misogynistic.

ducky

Ruin The Friendship had me crying until the theater like a clown. Also I'm genuinely confused why everyone missed that it's LIFE of a Showgirl, what went on off stage. Not Life of a SHOWGIRL. she made it clear in the interview

h

I heard a low quality leak of Ophelia, and I absolutely loved it, but I realize now that it was partially because I couldn't make out what she was saying lol. The melody and production are gorgeous!!! But hearing keep it 100, in my tower/honing your powers, pledge allegiance to your hands your team your vibes, etc. completely took me out of it. It was so much better to me when it was unintelligible 🫣 I think I'll seek out that fuzzy recording again and just enjoy that hahah

Anja Dott

I can get behind that. Ruin the friendship also seems like a track she was writing during TTPD or Midnights and maybe felt it was too Pop to include

Shaina

This I agree with 100% Like I was just saying that there’s only so many songs one can hear about being Travis Kelce's girl. She's happy. Yay. But the approach could've been much more different. Imagine if we got an album where she talked about falling in love AGAIN during the most emotionally exhausting yet professionally fulfilling time of your life. The back and forth of that whole thing. She has told us that Travis Kelce is different with the "no one like you" stuff. But I still want to hear why is it and what makes him different. She said it in the pod that it's about the times she would come back from the concert and just lie there in the bathtub absolutely exhausted and then do it all again. How did she manage to be invested in someone else during those times? I needed to hear that. Which is why I said that it is there in the vinyl poem but it's not on the actual record. But i personally do think that actually does involve the marketing aspect of it. The photographs, the vibe, the aesthetics are much more darker and grittier even with the vibrant high gloss nature of the roll out. I think there is some misalignment there

Taylor Rae

Even if it's not about her specifically, its so tone deaf given what were living through. A deep lyrical autopsy doesn't change the vibe a song like that gives in 2025.

Anja Dott

She skipped it accidentally but will listen to it in the end

Hannah

I had the exact same reaction to cancelled as you so I’m feeling very validated

ella

saw someone say that this album is from Taylor the billionaire/icon not taylor the songwriter or taylor the popstar and I think that explains all of the ups and downs, it could only be written by someone who's work and life (while she was on eras) revolves around herself and her public image. I think the high points on the album are when she is engaging with that (Elizabeth Taylor, father figure) but when it stops being a subject and becomes a filter for how she sees other things it becomes very tone deaf

Ana Kh

honestly i think actually romantic is about more than one person, i feel like some lines could be about other famous ppl…… djt

Alex Iscream

yeah.. i also thought about blake lively and loved cancelled sonically when i heard it first, it was one of my favourite, but then i started thinking and still it totally agree with Madeline and weither we can think its about blake or not, the way this song has a maga resonance is so bad... and about wood - i am 100% not interested in listening to 2min30 of visually too clear bad jokes about trayvis d*** .... i was all for taylor being horny and blunt but please then talk about your body/sensations/clit whataver.. not the fact that your boyfriend has a big tree omg... this is so ... i mean... feels like she just want to be appreciated by tacky mans , travis friends at this point... this is kind of anti feminist too in a way.

Kelsie Smith

The concern around this is so odd to me. Theyve been using Rage Against the Machine and George Orwells 1984 lol theyve always twisted the most liberal things to force them into their own views. Im not sure why this seems to be such a talking poiny

🍰

Fans without critical thinking capacities are so embarrassing

Kelsie Smith

I enjoyed it a lot! Im also v liberal, and love cancelled lol. Republicans also use George Orwells 1984 and rage against the machine lyrics so theyre gonna take anything they want to misinterpret anyway lol

Valeria Corvalán

Yeah...but it also gave us some of the worst writing ever as well...Joe was also in the room for Me! And Daylight which are not good...Travis is the same...'Cause Fate of Ophelia is wet food in the sink 🤣, and Wood is just 🫠 I worry because she is not capable of writing good songs when she is in love.. she needs to know that her inner world is more interesting that the purses...and when that happens we'll start hearing songs deeper than "Travis saved me" lyrics again, like we used to

🍰

I understand why Ria is so angry. The album is abysmal.

Alex Iscream

Tilly this comment got me dead hahahaha <3. true.

Ria

Once again, trying to antagonise instead of actually having something of substance to say🙏 god bless you on your hateful journey bc I’m done arguing with a child! Enjoy spending your money on a subscription just to reiterate again and again how much you hate something to people who really don’t give a fuck!

Deli

I think we can nuance both perspectives. SIAK is a much better song, but actually romantic is not in response to it. I think charli has been talking shit. I don’t love actually romantic (but I’m still disillusioned with the album), but I can admit it’s a gag and Taylor kinda got her lol. Still doesn’t mean actually romantic was well executed

Gaussia

Completely agree. It’s also such a striking contrast to how profound she was talking about breakups in loml, How did it end etc

Kylee

This is what I keep trying to say! I have impeccable selective hearing, I can turn it on and off when I need to, sometimes it turns on without me even trying 🙃 (FOO is one of those songs hahaha I just realized that’s what that is... ) Anyways, FOO is one of those times. I’m so completely swept up by the production that I could care less what she’s saying. My heart is kind of breaking for her right now, the way the Internet is ripping her to shreds. Taylor Nation just dropped a clip of her talking about how she wants somebody to throw the football at her for the chorus and she’s just so happy with herself… 💀💀💀 We just gotta let her cook everyone. After Eras? She earned it. I try not to take these things so serious, but I’m also not belittling anybody that does. Music is incredibly subjective, the blanket statements just don’t work. I personally enjoy the album, I’m not offended by it in the slightest. There’s never before done Taylor on there, and I don’t think I could ask for anything more.

Kelsie Smith

I take the "im not a bad bitch" line as her pulling back the curtain to Travis. Its mirrorball. Shes not naturally a bad bitch or savage. She can be when she wants to obvs, but it's not the real her.

🍰

Despite their claims to the contrary, Ria clearly does give a fuck.

Brittany Hogue

It is so funny to me that Zach is usually the more "critical" of the two.of them and Madeline is the "omg it's Taylor- YESSSS!!" but they totally switched roles for this album reactions. lol

Kylee

Love this. Keep it 💯 😭

Leslie

Thissss. She said on New Heights that she thought every song on this album packed a punch and was vital to the record, and that she went into this process wanting to make an album she's as proud of as the Eras tour. I want to know if that's really how she feels about this album in her heart of hearts. Because if it is...idk man. It's not even that the album is THAT bad, for me. It's the fact that she sold this as a pop magnum opus, and if she thinks that's what this is, it doesn't bode well for her creative direction.

Chloie 😝

Why are you surprised that when you subscribed to a music critics paywalled content, you encountered criticism…? Why are you here in the first place lady

Chloie 😝

Showgirl era proved this to me like 😭 she’s so CUNT in esp like a burnt orange.

TiffK83

I guess, as an artist, when you're too woke, too conservative, embarrassing, bold and brave, a trad wife, a business savage having a sexual awakening, too in love, too out of touch, too specific, too broad, AND somehow both a beautiful singer and a shitty one you're really doing something right. Everyone's favorite song is someone else's least and vice versa. Man, what a talent. Needs to be studied.

Shanice Marie

I understand where you're coming from! Omg, I completely forgot about her mentioning being in the bathtub after a show on the podcast. You're right there's absolutely none of that dark ruminating in the track list. Though it is present in the darker vibes of the photoshoot and possibly the music video? I'm going to the release party shortly which I hear has track by track commentary. Now I'm interested to see if any of the darker imagery is present! If not, you're completely right about there being a misalignment with the marketing. Thank you for this perspective because it solidifies that her concept was half baked. Either that or it was a red herring and I don't see the purpose in that all 🙃. Definitely doesn't do the Ophelia metaphor any justice. Once again, I apologize for coming off rude. I'll get back with some more concrete thoughts after the party.

Leslie

This is how I'm feeling too. People keep saying this album is a grower but every time I listen to it I find fewer things to like about it, not more. I've never experienced that with a Taylor album and I've been here for every release since Fearless. This joins reputation, Lover and Midnights among the ranks of albums I disliked on first listen. reputation grew on me very quickly. Lover was inconsistent, but there are a few career highlights on that album that make it tolerable. Midnights never grew on me sonically, but the more I listened the more I found interesting things to unpack in the lyrics. Showgirl just becomes more and more bland with every listen. There's nothing to unpack here, and aside from Father Figure I can't even remember any of the melodies after listening to the album multiple times.

carxleigh

MADELINEEEE YOURE SLAYINGGGG HAIR BAG SHOES gorgeous

calicoqueen

yeah… i think it’s time for me to get back into metal or something. i’m turning in my gun and badge. i can’t work for this woman anymore

Leslie

He didn't save it

Leslie

I'd add The Lucky One too!

Shaina

Omg, I have already watched the music video and stuff. Can't wait for you to see it! She looks incredible!! It's a good music video. It is actually both vibrant and gritty at the same time. Which is what made me think that the overall concept got overshadowed by the lover-esque "I love my Travvy baby" songs. Also, I'm sorry too. I'm always an overzealous b*tch. Hehe. We love Taylor Swift's music at the end. Tbf this has been a really fun conversation through the day. I hope you like the theatre experience. One thing about it is that nobody is doing it like Miss Swift!

Tammy Sawyer

“Hard rock is on the way.” A ring is on the way.

Leslie

This is what I'm saying!!!

Leslie

Charli fans are extremely delusional

Amber

It's a double entendre because she could also mean a pounding 😳

Leslie

This and "I feel like a fool in my headdress" are instant snake classics

Amber

I disagree, and even if she's married to Travis life doesn't end there - I can't wait for motherhood to be a muse, family dynamics, the continuing joy and pain of life past marriage

netsirk

Perhaps a study on the 5 Stages of Grief

Leslie

Yes. And those albums also had lead singles to give us a taste of what to expect. If she's not going to be releasing lead singles to contextualize the album before it's out, then the visuals and marketing need to be an honest representation. Show me you have a VISION and aren't just throwing incoherent vibes at the wall.

Dan

Your reaction to cancelled was totally warranted I had the exact same reaction, I can see what she’s getting at but it’s just sooooooo lost in her own perspective so tone deaf especially for the times we’re currently in…. Honestly I’m not surprised. She’s been on this trajectory for years and once she started dating a guy from the nfl (esp the chiefs…) I knew it was down hill for her awareness

Juby

😅🤣 the intro is GIVING ME LIFE!🤤

Steph

"according to slangsphere" im howling lmao

Shanice Marie

That's great to hear, I've heard the video is great and that she included the clean version of Wood. Which was another song where I had an issue with the writing there's too many innuendos and rhymes!! To the point where the clean version makes no sense "his love was the key that opened my skies"? How does that make sense Tay?

Alaina

I think your take on Actually Romantic is correct. I don’t think Taylor would feel the need to clap back over one song where the message is pretty clearly not a diss, but I feel she may have context that the rest of us don’t. People are acting like this was an unprovoked but if she’s constantly hearing shady things being said behind her back, I kind of don’t blame her for this one.

Taylor Rae

Guess only Yass Queen! BOOT DOWN SLAY is is the only reaction permitted? Its okay to have thoughts and opinions. Doesnt make one a hater. Being unable to tolerate dissenting opinions isnt fandom, its culty.

Shaina

Maybe like she was caged bird? Idk. The writing's inconsistent throughout. She really shouldn't have said "Folklore writing" with Max Martin production in the podcast. It has surely come back to bite her in the a**. Lol

Dan

It’s pretty clear charli was also being petty and embarrassing and immature behind the scenes but acting like she wasn’t, which is just as bad as being outright petty and embarrassing in a song. They’re both acting like fools!

Or Shaolov

I respect your opinions and love that you’re genuine. That said, all the Instagram posts with absolute statements against the album, before you’ve really processed or understood it, are kind of disappointing. Remember how you didn’t realize TTPD was about Matty or that Thank You Aimee was about Kim on your first listen? That’s just how first listens are, obviously. But that cancelled post was a bit much. Its obviously about Blake

Taylor Rae

Same. We live in a time where horrible people celebrate and relish the fact that decent people find them and their actions repugnant. Thats why the Maga parallel is being drawn. Maybe she and Blake were "unfairly" canceled and 2 years ago, this song and sentiment would have hit differently. But in 2025, it comes across poorly and tone deaf at best to my ears.

Emma Deschamps

I think we’ve gotten really used to the deep songwriter angle that we forget she can be just… fun. This is the same woman who wrote Shake It Off and Bad Blood. Not everything has to be TTPD and Evermore. Don’t get me wrong, I have issues with the album, but I think writing it off without sitting in it for awhile is a classic mistake with Taylor’s albums that the comments section on socials always tempts us to make.

Taylor Rae

Same. 2 years ago it would feel totally different. But in 2025, it feels very "horrible people relishing being rejected for their cruelty" coded.

Or Shaolov

I just feel like we’re losing all sense of nuance. Like with the reaction to sabrina, the moment someone steps even slightly outside the “perfect feminist” image you’ve built in your head, you can’t let it go and start judging her unfairly

Karen Valentino

Loved your intro so much! I had the same desire not to press play and I didn’t for a full half day. Also I love the megaphone - I think it’s the first pretty one I’ve seen.

Brianna Tullius

I’m gonna skip this one to keep my peace. I love the album and no one is going to ruin that for me

Nicole Burgos

Zach was way too positive to this album, I really needed you 😂

Miriam Bevan

I think the biggest problem is how she sold it. 12 back to back bangers ‘tis not.

McKenzie

In terms of actually romantic I think it’s pretty clear even in the lyrics that charli is talking shit about her. I mean we know they sort of run in similar circles and to me those lyrics make it very clear that while sympathy is a knife is mentioned it’s not really the crux of the issue. I mean “I hear you call me boring Barbie” and even “you keep sending me funny valentines” and “how many times has your boyfriend said why are we always talking about her” conveys to me that this is on going and a lot of stuff has made its way back to Taylor.

Tash

Why is it wrong to hold people (not just celebrities, all people) to feminist standards? Are we judging her unfairly or just judging her actions? Obviously people take it to far, hate is unwarranted and over the top, but it’s ridiculous to act like any critique is unfair

Roh

Shake it Off and Bad Blood were slightly silly / camp but also had undeniably catchy melodies and strong production for the time… not to mention, they were also just two among an album of many other excellently written pop songs like Style, Wildest Dreams, etc. No offense, but when you all posit this argument for Taylor, it makes no sense because songwriting / lyricism is her entire thing. She is not a stand out vocalist, she cannot dance (nor is any other visual counterpart to her music typically all that compelling) , and—at least in this album—the production wasn’t bad but it also wasn’t anything special, so what else would people look for and focus on?

Or Shaolov

Because there’s l nothing anti-feminist about loving a man and wanting a family.

Eli

I can’t lie this album makes me wanna listen to midnights

Taylor

In the least parasocial way, on my second listen of The fate of Ophelia, I thought: Mason will like this. Maybe it’s because the last Kiki y’all were talking about I Can See You being his fav. It reminds me of I Can See You.

La Barrah

Charlie was absolutely making a girl squad of women that hate Taylor during the Brat era

kc

your reactions are very valid, but your instagram posts are worrying me. i think these initial thoughts lacked nuance and ignored intention, which is of course okay bc it’s just the first reaction — it’s supposed to be candid and uninformed, but don’t discount it so quickly. i’ve always loved seeing how things grow on you, and i hope you allow this album the same chance

McKenzie

I agree and furthermore that photo of the severed arm with the friendship bracelets right after the stabbing at the Taylor swift dance class…I can’t believe the way that people just let that go. That was heinous. If Taylor did something like that we’d be hearing about it until the end of time.

Sacred_sunflower

💯 and she stood there cheering and clapping at the Grammys for her salty ass smh charli can eat a 🍆

Kat

In his youtube reaction video, I thought he just didn't like Eldest Daughter, Wood and Wish List?

Karen Valentino

I agree on Charlie - it’s kind of a small space there at the top and there’s a lot of interconnection. I’m sure if she says she heard this other person refers to her as Boring Barbie, that did not come out of thin air. And also that there was rejoicing when Taylor’s 10-year fantasy and heart were both smashed. You can go one down on a song, that happened in SIAK, but this song leaves me with no doubt Taylor got some behind the scenes intel. REALLY good point about Taylor being better about dishing than receiving, though! Oh, she cares!

Kat

I feel the same way! I loved the production overall for the album. The first time I heard the Fate of Ophelia when the album came out on Spotify, I felt like I was ascending. I think the only song that I don't really care for is Eldest Daughter... Wood is very corny but I can enjoy it because Taylor is very clearly aware of how silly she is being. I think the lyrics could have been a bit better but the production is super cool.

Kat

I know right? The first time I listened to this album, I really liked the first four songs, then I felt kind of confused for the middle songs, and then I liked the ones at the end, especially the Life of a Showgirl and Honey. I feel like you have to listen to a Taylor album at least a few times to full understand them and get a feel for them. I didn't really understand most of TTPD when it came out but the more I listened to it, the more I appreciated it.

Kat

Yeahh... even just 3 or 4 more songs would have helped I think. I understand her wanting to respond to the criticism about the length of TTPD but there's nothing wrong with having a short album and then having a deluxe addition like with 1989 or folklore / Evermore

Rose

I feel stupid now for thinking I was going to get bangers. Why did she say it was lighting in a bottle? I’m so confused…but mostly sad because I’m here for the music and the music, FOR ME, wasn’t great.

Eruvere Silverblade

I sooo agree with behind the scenes. in SIAK, charli suggests several times she didn't really pretend to be nice to taylor. "I don't wanna force a smile" "why can't i grit my teeth and lie" i honestly think there was some mess between them bts that the public just didn't see and know about

Tash

Nope luckily I have a sense of nuance and am able to identify things that actually go against my values :)

Karen Valentino

Madeline, I just love watching you process. Love your videos so much. I was so curious to see what you’d have to say about Wood. “It’s her right.” “You gotta learn to take a joke.” “Too many jokes.” Perfect summary.

John Butler

But she didn't say that. Travis did.

Debby Ajide

Same. Exactly the same here! I spent 2 weeks planning the most elaborate release party, with full decor, activities, costumes and all. And I’m utterly devastated. I rode for her hard even during Lover. But I’m crushed, disappointed and humiliated now. My forever defence when people criticised Taylor for her dancing or singing was - she’s first and foremost a LYRICIST, all the other things are just essential job requirements. But her lyrics and sharp pen are the thing that drives her artistry. And now I’m left here with redwood, bad bitch, savage, and a pretty Kitty. Heartbroken is not a good enough word to express how I feel now

Mary Massed

Omg THANK YOU I was so confused.. that makes sense!

Cierra Hand

The songs are ok and will grow on me as I listen more. But there isn’t a true stand out like other albums even on a first listen. Theres not a lot of highs or lows just mids

🌷Elle🌷

Girl I support you and your thoughts. It's okay to be critical when we don't like things, it's okay!!!!!!

chrystalnyan -

i think we have to remember that charlie had like a whole "bully a swiftie" campaign going on with the photoshoots, the ducki shoutouts, the comments, comments she and gabriette or whatever shes called liked, than what shes been saying behind closed doors, like these two have known each other for a while now, been in the same rooms, charlie shaded fka twigs and rina over matty healy and than probably gossiped about her - i would also be like "girl put down the coke wtf"

chrystalnyan -

theres also twitter talking about the possibility that charlie gossiped infront of lorde and since she and lorde have gone no contact again, maybe lorde told taylor about the boring barbie thing

Pepa

This actually the first Taylor Album since Rep and folklore/evermore that I loved from first listen 🤷‍♀️ lover first listen I had a couple of faves but that's it, I did not get midnights AT ALL for the first weeks, and TTPD (now in my top three) didn't click until I started to just listen to the anotholohy. So I was actually pleasently surprised when I came out of my first listen loving the álbum and being able to recommend it to everyone lmao

Burtasaurusrex11

I listened to it as soon as it dropped at midnight and went "well, that was the album". I'm starting to get more into the songs now that Ive been able to listen to them in the car. However, we are in fall now. So I'm going to have other albums on repeat lol. I'm sure this is going to go much harder for me in warm weather.

Dainty Donna

Madeline I just want you to know that with me being a paying customer at this here Patreon and I am fundamentally here for you and Zach and your commentary first and foremost. Parasocial much? WELL YES! But at this point, regardless of your opinions and if they differ from mine or not, I am here for you guys. I know it’s not as simple as this, but this should always be a safe space for you to speak your unbridled truths. Now speaking of the album specifically, I am so curious to know more detailed thoughts later on what you didn’t like about the production because overall I enjoyed it. However, let it be known that I am not a fully converted Swiftie, most of her discography I discovered through this channel. Even tho the first song of hers I heard was Teardrops on my Guitar in 2006 I never did a deep dive or anything. That all being said, I HIGHLY respect your opinion when it comes to all things Taylor. Can’t wait for a more thorough breakdown and no matter what I’m here for the Kiki and piping hot lawsuit inducing tea 🫖!

kc

of course i was worried that she was discounting it too quickly for her own sake! the north remembers her initial thoughts on ttpd, and now she loves it. glad to hear she’s engaging with some positivity in other online spaces also, we both clearly care about someone else’s opinion if we’re paying for this patreon lol. it’s fun!

Karen Valentino

The theme Life of a Showgirl - along with her comment about how it’s about what has gone on behind the scenes - is so broad it could be about anything. Because of that I had no expectations. It turns out to be about her life and not her show.

John Butler

100% correct great post, great album. This "reaction" was.... something.

Megan Abner

Thank you for filming this and talking about your opinions. I wish I would have heard the raw thoughts but I can see why you dialed it back based on some of these comments 🥴 I like the way Cancelled! sounds but I don’t like the subject matter at all. Can’t wait to hear what you think when you’ve sat on it!

Sacred_sunflower

Love that he knew the album contents and gave her the hard rock after recoding the announcement 📣 on new heights 💍 💎

Miriam Bevan

That’s semantics. I think the theme and concept set a different expectation hence why a lot of people’s initial reactions may seem a little disappointed.

Jackie

Love seeing everyone have a range of reactions to this album. We all had such high 1989 hopes and it's not that, but it has some major highs and lows for every real fan. Love having more pop songs from Taylor even if it isn't what we could've expected. Not as strong lyrically as other albums (though there are some iconic lines here for sure), but I'm having a fun time processing and relistening to all of the new gifts she's given us. Thanks for being yourself and letting it fly, Madeline! I'm just so happy to see Taylor so happy and in love after all she's been through to get to Travis. Bring on the Tayvis cheesy jams. :)

JD IHateItHere

This is why I’m not Instagram or Tik Tok. The environment creates the pressure cooker of having to say something soon or not be on point. On point is not what reactions are. It is a first listen. I get the shock — I am older and less disturbed by by this album because I come from a time of savage rock and pop stars didn’t have to be perfect. In fact, perfection was not the goal. They were debauched, and we loved them. This kindness to people who deeply wound us — especially when Taylor gave her the stage to open at Reputation? Unforgivable. Feminism doesn’t ask us to be blind or sweet when we are stabbed in the back while a man eviscerated U.S. so I love the album. I stay in my lane. I don’t mind that others hate. It bops. The lyrics are jarring like Rep was. I feel them adjusting into place for me with the vocals and melodies and guitar that are Fleetwood Mac, ABBA, Ronnie Spector, Jackson Five, Weezer, George Michael, and more while being so Taylor. Don’t listen and I respect that. She didn’t co-sign Brittany Mahomes. She co-signed not cancelling someone that isn’t known personally after having been cancelled falsely. Full stop. For me that’s not a problem.

James

The life of a showgirl!

Eden McFadden

Yes but I actually liked midnights more than this one. There were stand outs like you’re on your own kid and karma, this one, nothing is standing out to me

maeve

LET HER SPEAKKK !! i liked the album but had the exact same reaction to especially cancelled! .... such a bad move and solidified the criticism she gets for being out of touch at a time of unrest for the majority of people and an abundance of real suffering in the world

chrystalnyan -

i saw people cooking up the idea that maybe it is not as good as it could be because even a showgirl has to dial down sometimes and she holding the finger up to the music industry

Shannon

Seeing people's reactions to this album makes me feel like I'm living in an alternate universe because I truly loved it. Seeing so many people talk about how they're devastated or massively disappointed, etc, has been the biggest joy killer. Critique of lyricism, production, etc, is valid of course. Like every other album on this planet, this release isn't perfect, but the drama in comment sections across the internet is mystifying to me. I think people are pressed about two main things: the tongue in cheek lyrics from Wood and the fact that she didn't do 12 different versions of the can-can so that the theme of Showgirl makes more sense to them. We asked for bops after the emotional devastation of TTPD, and she took the note. Now people are sad that she didn't make intellectual bops while line kicking across a stage? Make it make sense. The more I listen, the more I love it. This is the first no skip album of hers for me, and I've loved them all since I came on board with 1989. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Kim Fanning

I learned after TTPD that I have to give myself a little time with a new one because at this point I've built mythical epic expectations. I'm STILL discovering new love and appreciation for songs of hers that are over a decade old at this point, so I have to reserve judgment for a bit, but hearing So It Goes at the start of this vs. Wood makes me nervous about the lyricism at this moment in time.

Sydney

Exactly this!

caley

i think this album would have been received better if she just suprise dropped it. the constant showgirl and banger associations set the expectations too high and into a diff direction. i like most of the songs but had the exact same reactions as you on a lot of em. great vid, loved your realness

Brianna Tullius

I agree and Evolution of a Snake is my favorite TS podcast. But I’m learning that watching other people hate something you love is not fun. And I’m paying to have my feelings hurt lol. She literally said in the New Heights interview that this album is not about performing, but about her LIFE offstage. I think the album art confused expectation, and that is not great. But the album is great

🌷Elle🌷

Your reaction to Cancelled is WARRANTED, I had the same exact reaction. I won't lie, this album has given me the ick in different ways for different reasons. IDK diva, I get it.

Jordan

I like this album a lot if I remove the title of “Showgirl” from it and distance myself from the idea of it being a look behind the curtain of The Eras Tour. To me…it’s not that. Missed opportunity for more of a burlesque moment and to really lean into the idea of being a show girl but nevertheless, I don’t hate it. It’s just not “Showgirl” to me. It’s something else entirely, in my opinion.

Casey

I fully understand what you’re saying, but who doesn’t talk sh*t with their friends?! Taylor does - it’s immortalized as a lyric. I don’t care at all about Charli XCX, but I don’t think talking about someone with your friends is a reason to eviscerate someone on a worldwide stage and try to cut them to their core. That is a disproportionate response from the most powerful person in the music industry. It’s mean girl behavior and I don’t love seeing it from someone I respect so much.

Shannon

I couldn't agree more. I love the Snakes and value their honest opinions, but watching them be sad and disappointed (and so many people in the comments cosigning) is just the biggest buzz killer. I'm going to step back from watching their content for the immediate future just to protect my happiness and enjoyment of this album. I need all the positivity I can get these days. I'm not going to throw away a whole album of new TS music because she sang about her man's dick for the lulz. 🤷🏻‍♀️

h

Just asking for the gossip lol. What do you mean Charli and Lorde have gone no contact?

Alexis Book

Truly the first three tracks deserve a car listen because sun up windows down is a VIBE for them. Unfortunately the rest of the album still gives me 🤷‍♀️

Favour

zach didn't like every song so idk what you mean

Cocogigi

Yeah, bummer Madeline didn’t like it but I’m LOVING it. Are some of the lyrics cringe? Yes. However, the production, vocals, and 99% lyrics make me smile, cackle, and levitate! I had to stop watching this cuz I don’t want my vibe killed. Anyway, I’ll be dancing around and enjoying this era to the fullest ❤️‍🔥🤘

🌷Elle🌷

No because I literally have been downloading all the faves from early 2000-2010 ahaha *hiding tears*

🌷Elle🌷

THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!! It's why I love her and her reactions, and the things she has to say whether I agree with her or not (for example, I don't think Blake was unfairly cancelled)

kc

i love your perspective so much. even w different takes overall, we both had the same initial favorite 😇🤞🏻

SP

This is the part I just can’t get past- how are people missing this or confused about it- it’s the LIFE of the showgirl… it isn’t titled “BTS of the showgirl’s show”. It’s about her life when she wasn’t on stage. Under the glitter and after the curtain, she was falling in love and fighting for her music, and apparently dealing with drama lol. It’s just her life and her feelings but it’s still set musically to the show (the tour) that was happening at the same time. I love this album!!!

Sacred_sunflower

I’ve been seeing so many people taking cancelled literal. I hear it in a more satirical tone like she’s being sarcastic. She mentions specific instances of people doing horrible stuff as well as things that aren’t worth being cancelled over, so it’s kinda the reputation persona singing “karma” think of it that way and see if it changes for you. This is coming from someone who believes Taylor is not friendly with Blake anymore after being used as a pawn in these whole lawsuit shit. If someone called me THEIR dragon. Like a possession she OWNS is wild. If never talk to them again after finding out they’re using me.

Tanner K

favorite comment

Shannon

Exactly! I'm just going to be dancing through my apartment to this album and letting everyone else feel their own feelings about it. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Kylee

I love the insight, and I completely agree. I think you just highlighted exactly a thought I was having earlier, seeing how immediately everybody is putting out their ‘this song is ‘xyz era’ coded’ takes. I’m guilty of it too, it truly is involuntary. I’m really trying to figure out why everybody is having such a visceral reaction to the slangology of it all, and I think I kind of figured it out. Im a peer age of Taylor and celebrity or not, I think when you reach a certain age there’s a part of you that disconnects from that. It really comes down to it truly being that you just don’t give a fuck, and this is exactly where she’s at. She doesn’t care if the slang is from back in our day, or if she’s saying the most relevant versions. She’s just a woman in her mid 30s that is actually that dorky, trying to keep it 💯. 😭 We’re officially on the closer end to 40, there’s not much time left. Let us live! 💀💀💀 (and yes, I will use as many fucking emojis as I want because I’m a millennial dammit and that’s what we do.)

Shannon

I don't know how everyone is missing this about the theme! She literally said come look behind the curtain. What was she doing back there? Falling in love, fighting for her music and friends, and getting railed. 😅 I'm here for it all! 🙌🏻

Emrose

Based on the movie explanation, this seems to be accurate with what Taylor was saying

Archie

“Did you girl boss to close to the sun, did they catch you having too much fun” come on now how can this song be a maga anthem, it’s not giving defending trad wives

Sebastian

This album is probably the first album by her that is aging REALLY bad

Nicole bee

FYI IN OPALITE Travis’s ex was ALWAYS IN HIS FACE WITH THE PHONE. Every you tube vid of them is her doing this constantly. Looked annoying.

Kenna

Ruin the Friendship sounds like a Speak Now vault track 💜

Sebastian

Exactly and some of her best songs like CS, False God, Cornelia etc but this is just…. Safe in a bad way

Lisa

I feel validated by your reactions, I had a very similar experience. I would also add to the MAGA anthem list “wishlist”. It screams “look at all these other people who want these material things and awards for their accomplishments but I’m just a simple girl who wants a basketball hoop in my driveway teehee”. Bitch, who are you kidding? (Bitch said in a loving way, I promise). You want all the awards and money too! And you’re a billionaire!!! She says it’s all fine that others want those things but this is what I want…you want them tooooo. Probably more than a lot of people. It’s just silly. I love Taylor but yikes.

Jackie

I blame Sabrina Carpenter for influencing Taylor. That's how we got Wood. Lol

Erin

I had the same thought! I think it’s a really touching song 😭

Erin

We love a mature and reasonable queen ❤️❤️❤️

Jenna Quigley

I think the marketing and packaging of the album did not match up with the tracks, that being said I had so much fun with it!

the tortured briggy department

for cancelled, i think was referring to people who have been unfairly attacked for no reasion specifically - think "they're burning all the witches even if you aren't one", but i'm sure you caught that too. what makes it kind of tone deaf is if she really IS talking about blake specifically. like i get what you were going for taylor, people wanna "cancel" anyone for anything these days, but idk girl...

SP

I took it very differently. I felt like she was moreso acknowledging she is at a place where she already has so much, she’s made so many of her wishes come true and now her wish list is just him. And she hopes everyone else gets all their wishes too but right now she feels content. Just my opinion though.

SP

Agree. I also think that we can take a step back and stop applying it to only a few certain people. So many people around her, herself… all been cancelled. It’s tongue in cheek for sure. But I also think it’s not the worst message that you can love people for who they are even if you don’t agree with them 100%. We are so quick to assume some moral superiority but… glass houses, man.

Erin

Yeeeah, I had no clue people were expecting showtunes lol. I was expecting pop bangers and damn if that chorus of Elizabeth Taylor didn’t make me jump up and dance… lol. I am playing the clean version at work (a store) today and a customer started singing to CANCELLED! and I joined in of course. You’re not alone. I love this album and so do plenty of other people!

peri

Ruin the friendship is hitting like guilty as sin and I can’t explain it further than that. I thought I was going crazy when you got to track 12 and I didn’t hear it……….. LMAO

Anja Dott

The thing is, she could and would make it clear if she wanted to. But she doesn't. It's giving fence sitter vibes to secure the broadest possible audience.

Amy-Louise McCall

The fact that you were suffering through the first few songs, and it turns out those were the best of the album, it only got worse from there!

Bell

she desperately needs a cringe consultant when she finishes a song

Anja Dott

Less so about the material stuff because we know she has all that and it's tongue in cheek. What gave me pause were lines like "people who call their dogs kids" (mean to make fun of people who maybe can't have kids or don't want any (very valid) for whatever reason) and the "complex female character" (what's wrong with that? Do you want to be a simple female character?). She contrasts the material stuff and the complex female character or let's call it "alternative" lifestyles with her simple dare I say traditional wishes? It's really throwing me for a loop right now. But what else could it mean other than positioning herself as a grateful, demure trad wife happy to live the "normal " suburban very white American life?

Clara

charli and lorde are still friends, she commented on her IG about being sad that she missed the italy wedding cause she was starting tour

Shannon

This album has some great pop bangers, and I'm hoping that others will listen more and come around on it like they have with previous releases! But in the meantime, catch me singing along and dancing in my kitchen. 🤷🏻‍♀️💃🏻

Naomi Hyde

I also took it as a song about supporting your friends even if they’re not perfect and have made mistakes in the past, with Taylor using the metaphor of being cancelled to say that!

Clara

none of what you said is true. charli called out her fans for saying taylor should die, she didn’t participate in that at all. you also can’t attribute what a specific fan says and make it sound like charli approved of that behavior, how would she know what a fan of hers says 24/7 about any celebrity. also gabbriette hasn’t liked any shady comment and von dutch’s muse was never confirmed by charli, fans have just made things up, some say it’s about azealia banks. as for rina, she lied about matty (and the rest of the band including George) owning her masters, they don’t so that falling out was entirely on rina’s part for publicly lying about her supposed friends and label mates.

Emma

This take really made me miserable 😩

Nicole S

Is this how you always act when someone has a different opinion than you?

Clara

that photoshoot was planned and shot way before that stabbing incident took place. how was charli supposed to know that would happen? she’s not in control of the creative direction and the photographer who shot it explained the concept which had nothing to do with taylor. those also aren’t supposed to be friendship bracelets, they’re kandi bracelets which are a part of rave and club culture.

Naomi Hyde

100% agree! I love Taylor’s lyricism so kinda miss that on this album (although there are some gems), but I’m also just glad she’s in a good place rn and in a healthy relationship, and this album feels just like that - light, fun, and upbeat :) Not her best album imo, but I’m enjoying it for what it is and appreciating the great production and fun vibes!

Nicole S

There’s clearly many of those types of swifties in this chat it’s actually blowing my mind

McKenzie

well I’m definitely happy to stand corrected on that

CuddlingDeath

I think its very interesting how much 2016 truly impacted her, in the way that you can kinda tell its the last time she really interacted with internet culture and most slang. She's probably picked up words here and there from people around her but I think its becoming more noticeable that she's been offline and maybe even checked out of pop culture since 2016.

Caitorade

The midnights comment 1000000%

Clara

also matty has been super open about his struggles like on his brat remix and also has talked about toxic masculinity and his flaws on his recent album/tour

Nicole S

woke up angry as fuck is sending me cuz like yeah 😭😭 did my one listen and won’t be doing that to myself again

Shannon

I don't know where else to put this, so I'm putting it here for possible discussion. Lol I saw a comment on YT today that this is the first time Taylor has written both ABOUT a man and TO a man, so the reason people don't like it is because the lyrics are overly simplified for Travis' sake. To which I say, since when is she not writing TO a man? She spent a decade secretly writing about and TO Matty Healy. Her videos and lyrics and stage sets are packed to the rafters with direct references to his work. That was her having a secret with him across a crowded room, and I think she wrote in such an intellectual way all these years because of course, that's just her amazing brain, but also because she wanted to appeal to his idea of what constitutes good or deep songwriting. She said "You're not Dylan Thomas" because this man obviously holds himself out as a real poet of his times, on his fucking typewriter even. She matched him on it to be more appealing to him, as well as because it's her style, and people ate it up. You'll never convince me that she wrote TTPD with anyone other than him in mind as an audience of one for at least half the songs. The note was make lighthearted pop bangers, and that also seems to be the kind of music her fiancé prefers, so we get Showgirl. 🤷🏻‍♀️ Remember on Now That We Don't Talk when she said "I don't have to pretend I like acid rock"? She does what so many of us do: like or pretend to like the stuff our partners are into. I can't blame her for that. And if Travis is responsible for this album of bops with funky 70s/80s vibes throughout, then LFG! 🤷🏻‍♀️

BrieAnna Older

I really want to know ypur thoughts on Father Figure👀

Shanice Marie

I just got home and I'm even more baffled because the music video for once embodies the concept to a T. Like its damn near perfect so how did we end up with so many inconsistencies. It almost feels like she wrote two albums and smashed it all together. I did find it very revealing that she said Honey was like the first song they wrote for this album. Honey as the starting track makes perfect sense for the songs that don't feel as showgirl as they should. I really want to know the thought process, I get how Honey lead to Wood, even with its one too many innuendos but how did we get to Father Figure or The Fate of Ophelia from there?

Mira

this record somehow feels so unpersonal shallow and tone-deaf (cancelled) which we’re not really used to (ESPECIALLY after ttpd)

Shondi

This might be a hot take but I personally think Taylor is a lot more conservative in her political beliefs than she claims to be. And I think this applies to a lot of celebrities actually. It’s not “cool” to be conservative and also not aligned with the image that most celebs try to portray of themselves. Tay is no exception. I’m not saying she’s secretly a Trump supporter or anything (you can be conservative and still despise Trump) but we have to remember that at the end of the day she is a business woman and will do and say what she can to boost whatever image of herself that she wants us to see. Which is why her associating with MAGA people doesn’t surprise me much. I just don’t think it’s that deep for her.

Stacy Davydova_13

10000%! First and last stream this album will ever get from me

Caitorade

Dude when you said “um jack? Aaron?” Bc GIRL I said the same fuckin thing. 😂😵‍💫

Moonbeam009

Also "Did you make a joke only a man could?", "Were you just too smug for your own good?", etc. There is nothing in there to indicate to me that it's about fascism or even anything political. To me, it's clear as day she's still harping on about her cancellation with Snakegate. I saw the movie yesterday, and she literally says it's about not judging people based on what the Internet mob thinks but instead as you know them to be. She talked about how the other famous people who get cancelled call her for help/sympathy. I do understand that the word "canceled" has now basically been coopted by American fascists, but for me, there is enough context here to know it's not that.

Archie

Omg!!!! yes you’re so right. Madeline got me worried thinking so much about it yesterday but the more I think about it the more this song seems like more woman supporting woman through being cancelled by the other side. Like you said did you make a joke only a man could, that’s such a feminist line in my opinion. There’s no way a maga person can use this song for their rightful cancelation. But I know this is just a reaction I’m excited to see her actual review and see if she had time to sit with it and change her mind.

Inga

I’m really glad you said what you said about Cancelled. Thank you. I have a lot more to say about this but not sure this is the space… I’ll just say for now that it was a relief to hear you express those thoughts and feelings so quickly and clearly. I’d love to hear more of your thoughts, if you can share. It seemed like you were holding a lot back.

Callisto

2 songs in and this going down in reaction herstory. Like trying to understand what’s happening 😭😭😭😭😭 I blame travis kelce for this

Nicolle Trampe

Yupp. No one around is telling her that's a bad line or anything negative it seems. She is also too addicted to her job. Let people miss you, take time and really come back with something worth while to say.

Dawnnnnn

Im liiiiiving for your takes madeline 🫶🏻 just got patreon to see this

Laura

the main feeling i get is “girrrrl haven’t we learn not to put all out for men????” i’m kind of disappointed

caroline

I think it’s time we all have the conversation that Taylor markets her album themes much differently than what they actually are. It always comes back to what she doesn’t say, in other words

leticia hernandez

For Opalite listen to: 1+1= 2 enamorados from Luis Miguel

Louise

I feel so validated because my first reaction was very similar to yours

🌷Elle🌷

It's the whole cancelled for something stupid vs cancelled for a real insane, crazy reason like trying to ruin and bury a man using Me movement as a weapon...

Klara Ipek

Thank you Madeline!!! Your feelings are SO valid

🌷Elle🌷

I'm a blake hater (lol) but when I first heard this song I immediately thought of Ariana and Sabrina. Am I the only one?? Even the Mahomes woman. I'm pretty sure this album was completed before the whole Blake stuff went down I definitely don't think this pertains to that mess. HOWEVER I agree with Madeline. It's super tone deaf and I can 10000% see how it's being interpreted as something that was going to stir the pot. I dislike this song as well.

hannah

My main issue with ‘Actually Romantic’ is that I wish she had John Mayer-ed her and made a song that sounds just liiitle too much like a Charli XCX song (I personally think she could do it, it could be really Rep coded). Really big missed opportunity there that frustrates me and feels so obvious that imo it speaks to some laziness :/ Also I 100% think she has SOME kind of tea on Charli that would show just how unprovoked it was and if she’d just done a little more not to seem like such a mean girl she really could have done the Kendrick thing and written a diss track that also reveals to the public something scandalous about the person in question. Bc there’s nooo doubt in my mind that the Charli-Matty-Troye clique have been running their mouths and I don’t think that Charli is some kind of “girls girl” by any stretch of the imagination. But anyone can see how mean it is to respond solely to ‘Sympathy is a knife’ which is a really vulnerable song. Taylor could have preserved her public perception that much more and done an actual victory lap by doing slightly more to reveal whatever it was that pissed her off so bad bc I don’t think it was just the song.

Dawnnnnn

I know 😂😂😂 but I'm not

emmy

Yeah I heard it and immediately thought the trav-wives are gonna love this, but it’s hard because like you CAN be normal about wanting a family and want the happy married life but MAGA and trad wives are gonna take this and run with it, and that’s not really her fault (at least in this song). I think this was just more of a I ❤️ Travis album than showgirl album, if it were marketed differently it would’ve been received differently. I think Wood is probably the worst song of the album next to Cancelled and not just because the messaging but the lyrics were childish. Plus she doesn’t like her friends cancelled because she distances herself from them to protect her brand so it’s kinda🦗🦗🦗

emmy

I’ve seen maga women use this as a defense against any criticism though…it does read a bit tone deaf, at least to me. It’s reminds me of when rich people say “everyone struggles” and “everyone has to work hard”. We live in the context of societal values now and with conservative values at an all time high I can see why people would think this will be used for MAGA I can also see how it can be argued opposite. At the end of the day once art is out in the world to be interpreted, we interpret it how we want to interpret it. I think the song is a little too kitschy for my taste and I agree with Madeline, but this is just my opinion.

Lia Russo

I don't think the song is lazy at all, I love it, but making it a Charli sounding song would've been CUNNNNNTTTTTT

SeraRose

Sympathy is a knife is also a more interesting song, because Charli's exploring aspects of herself in relation to Taylor and Taylor's just going "la la la you're obsessed with me"

SeraRose

This album is Lover without the inner conflict so...good for Trav and Taylor, I guess?

SeraRose

I do actually love a lot of the sounds, tho

Heatherist

It’s been 1 day though 🤨 I’m not saying it’s great but how can you say that after 1 day?

SeraRose

I too wonder if she was thinking about Blake with Cancelled! I think I saw an interview where she said that she's being satirical and playing a bit of a character here?

SeraRose

Father figure is about Scott Borchetta, right? And she flips the perspective halfway through

Kelly

It was touching wet food in the sink for me.

Terry B

saw the movie release of her album 🥳 in VIP (19+) cinema: every track she sits in a director's chair explaining what inspired her. We all giggled 🤭 when she awkwardly explained "Wood": "uh, it's about superstitions" 🤣 First 4 tracks audience 👏🍻🥳 others were kinda 🦗 none sounded "bad", maybe forgettable or grow on me like TTPD 😅. Anyway they're all short so I won't bother skipping 🤷‍♀️ Her rehearsal moments in non-glam mode pony-tail T-shirt shorts are adorkable 🙂‍↕️

Alex Iscream

Girl... I kinda feel you... felt really embarassed with my friends in my super decorated living room with my glittered face and all..

Jaime

thank you for your honest reaction. Agreed with what you said completely. Your reaction is VALID. This album gives off far right trad wife billionaire agenda.

Archie

I think what maga girls use are none of my business lol I think this especially irrelevant now that I found out the tiny violin is an Easter egg that this song was for Sophie when people were saying she was partying and working to hard to be a mom, and Taylor did pap walks in support of her

GalacticBorb

I feel like I’m in a different universe. Loved it. I danced in my kitchen to so many of these songs- and I think people are completely misunderstanding cancelled. Seems like shes celebrating that old friends got cancelled bc they deserved it, as well as defending others who didn’t. It seemed tongue in cheek. Like a how are you gonna handle this? kinda thing.

Krista Dabel

MADELEINE! 🤣 your reaction to the first line of Actually Romantic had me dying! I thought my phone froze!

Katie

The song actually sounded like Olivia Rodrigo which makes me think it was her way of getting at both of them

Makayla Smith

I agree with everything you said! At this point I feel bad for the people who don’t like it cause I’m over here dancing and having fun!

🌷Elle🌷

I strongly disagree. The Blake stuff is not silly hehehaha drama, it's something serious (that she caused herself). I personally don't believe Taylor would use that sort of serious topic to sing a campy song. It's the same reason she hasn't publicly supported Blake.

Alex Iscream

I mean.. it starts with "everybody's so pOnk on the internet" ... .. :')

Emily

Me too!!!

D. H. Prescott

This was kind of a downer to watch. I had to go back to the Two Gay Matts’ review to lift my mood.

Shoug

im pretty sure she said the album was about her life behind the show not the show ,so it makes sense for her to sing about her relationship he majority of the album,but the rest of the review was great!

Makayla Smith

Your under almost every comment spewing the same bullshit, I think it’s time to log off and go touch some grass sweetie

Momo

my exact reaction listening to this album lmao

AlisonDSWills

Here's my thought on Ruin the Friendship.... She was probably super down on herself over the Matty stuff and in a way regretting taking that step. But maybe after pondering the situation more, she realized it was better for her to have known the answer than wonder for the rest of her life what could have happened.... And that reminded her of her high school friend that she had a crush on and lost the chance to give it a shot when he passed away. That's how I think "the eras tour" plays into that -- the Matty of it all got the conversation started.

Paulrissa

Cancelled is something that I can't get past. I understand it's probably about several people, but it's very tone deaf considering what Americans are going through right now. I think if they hadn't said it was the storytelling of Folklore and pop of 1989--a lot of us wouldn't have expected the writing skill level of Folklore / TTPD.

Momo

songs can be fun AND have good lyrics. see most of 1989 and rep and a lot off of lover. most of the showgirl songs have bad lyrics.

AlisonDSWills

My initial feeling on Cancelled was that she wrote it "for" Sabrina while they were becoming close friends on the Eras Tour. I didn't think about Blake or MAGA or anything serious. I imagined her having a chat with Sabrina about how Sab was "cancelled" during the wake of the "Driver's License" release. It's still in my bottom two songs regardless, but I just didn't take it too seriously.

hannah

Oh don’t get me wrong when I say “lazy” make NO mistake cuz I’ve been pressing play again and again🤭issa bop…. But yeah we could have had a cuntquake of epic proportions and it’s a missed opportunity imo

SP

Edit to add: this is more a response to the discourse that I see in the *comments here* reacting to Madeline’s reactions. Taking her comments on some things further to match what’s being said online re: maga. Disagree 1000%. Which is fine. Maybe it’s not for everyone. But the MAGA discourse (here and out there) is really pmo. She has been very clear where she stands politically. Very. Clear. It is also a very dangerous time for someone like Taylor to speak out considering the political violence and violence in general that has been happening with this administration. Secondly- you can still want marriage and love and fairytales and an absolute fire sex life, want kids and a house and a basketball hoop… AND continue to work and perform and do your thing. I found my person, had a family, and I still practice medicine. And guess what, I’m also a democrat. AND I didn’t cut out every conservative person in my life because I refuse to be part of this “who’s the goodest, most perfect liberal” nonsense. Like can we stop with this insane narrative. This album is fun. Let a woman be happy. Good god.

Cailee

To be fair TTPD was very on concept

L. Kelley

I subbed to the patreon specifically to see your reactions and you did not disappoint! Thank you for keeping it real! I felt similarly to you, hoping that it grows on me, but we’ll see. If not then there are plenty of other Taylor albums I love to relisten to in the meantime.

Qweefeeweefee

Totally agree! They sold It like It was gonna be the album of the century.

Qweefeeweefee

I *really* think the song is literal and is about who Forever Winter is about

Qweefeeweefee

This was the funniest reaction. I was DYING. We reacted the exact same way to everything

HaleyJean ASMR

your reaction to Actually Romantic was the exact same as mine HAHAHAH “im not saying its right… im saying its funny”

Cailee

So well said!! All of it!

Cailee

This 🙏

Lia Russo

I don't see how it has anything to do with what Americans are going through. I interpreted it as Blake Lively calling Taylor for advice amongst her current "cancellation" and Taylor being like "welcome to the club!!!" based on what happened in 2016. It's really no more complex than that imo

Cailee

It is funny though because rep was so jarring and “cringe” too when it first came out. One day a showgirl song will be a palate cleanser too

Mikee Dayrit

it’s more likely the haim sisters who are friends with charli

TiffK83

Ohh! Running to them now! Thanks!

Lia Russo

I LOVE the album and I still said the same thing!! Hahaha. I'm enjoying it so much but I feel Jack & Aaron outsoldddd

SP

This is actually an interesting take! I thought from the beginning that it’s too obvious to be about one specific person. Whether that’s Blake or Brittany or whoever. It’s very “yeah I’ve been there, done that, someone is always mad” lol

Lia Russo

Yes! I don't blame her for choosing to hold back but it makes me really sad that she doesn't feel safe on her own Patreon. I say a lot more on mine than I'd ever say publicly

🌷Elle🌷

Yees I was saying somewhere in here that Cancelled gave me Sabrina/Ariana vibes more than anything. I can see why people find it tone deaf though.

DrEmily

Even Madeline admitted she got her. You can think it wasn’t warranted, and think Charli has a great song. But AR still holds up. It’s ok not to like it tho. Just don’t think you’re going to ever convince people who do like it that it’s not. And definitely not those who think it was justifiable. Maybe go stream Charli and take a deep breath? It’ll be ok.

Lia Russo

I agree with you!! I value Madeline's opinion but I was actually shocked hearing that's what she got out of it. So interesting. For me it's 100% that Blake got cancelled and Taylor is playing spooky witch in the haunted underworld again like in WAOLOM. Like "welcome to the club of witches they've burned at the stake, it's fun here but it'll hurt ya!"

DrEmily

Yep. Just don’t think it was the original intent or even the same reality when written and recorded. 20/20 hindsight is a luxury and time travel has not been invented yet (pretty sure)

Lia Russo

Madeline, just wanted you to know that your reaction was almost as anticipated for me as the album itself 💗 even though I don't agree with a lot of your feelings on it, I'm not disappointed -- always enjoy seeing you listen, react to, and interpret songs. You and Zack actually have original thoughts in your minds unlike a large number of content creators who just regurgitate the hive mind. Appreciate you!! 🦎✨

DrEmily

Yep. Don’t know the details that warranted the clap-back. Feel like there is more tea there. But I did chuckle.

Archie

Would you mind checking my TikTok @arturogiassinyc I posted my first video ever because I found a news article about Sophie and the custody of her kids and a TINY violin was mentioned!!! I’m not hearing anyone else talk about. I really think it’s all about Sophie. She supported her in a big public way too

DrEmily

Same. I clap and cheer for them both. I hope they love it more on repeat listen, but still ok if they don’t

Lia Russo

To be fair, I don't remember Madeline being one of the voices saying "we need bops now after that" but even if she was, she's allowed to not like the bops that were provided! I'm with you though, I adore this album. Don't be sad about others' reactions -- it's just their opinion. That's all. Doesn't change the album for the rest of us who are living 💕

elly belly

it’s not fun. it’s stupid TikTok nonsense with outdated slang. sorry but she knows how to make GOOD pop music and this is NOT it. stop getting mad at people for holding taylor to higher standards than whatever this absolute slop is

SP

lol ok have fun being miserable. “Holding Taylor to higher standards” 😂😂 lmk when your music career takes off.

Lia Russo

Zack was pretty into it though! It seemed like to me he sees the album as a net positive. I was cheering cause he loved the first few songs so much as did I. I think Ophelia is so undeniable, but like I said above, I respect Madeline's view on it. It was fun fangirling along with Zack though. I really enjoy the two of them having their own podcast/channel and then this one together.

Lia Russo

My opinion is a lot of this stems from the bloody swifitie arm with the bracelets. The rest is just jealousy and cattiness but imo that was a little too fucked up and dark considering the stabbing incident and terrorist threat that occurred around the same time 💔

Laurel

I think with 12 songs we didn’t need 2 diss tracks. I really enjoyed all the others

Terry B

Album vibes: "Life of A Showgirl / Your English Teacher bragging 'bout her Happiness with Gym Teacher by Good Karma" 🤣🥳 Clean version has words instead of bleep out 😁 kidz bop T.V. 🙉 this time her swears words flow more naturally 😅 e.g. Down Bad "F*** It If I Can't Have Him" just feels off(?) #4 F.F. "My d*** / check's bigger" mic-drop 😶🫨🤣 #1, #3 ~= Gorgeous (smitten), "Failures Bring Freedom" 🙂‍↕️🗽 #2 Tumultuous Romantic LOAS, Don't Blame Me #4 Ugly ShowBiz LOAS, sentimental & ruthless--both things can be true 🙂‍↕️ #5 ~= I Hate It Here is > poignant. Who she's singing to: friends / fans / family? 🤔 💭 #6 the teen who became showgirl wondered about her choices -- lesson: No Regrets! A bit odd, but glad she can decide on tracks, not MENtors🙄 #7 Punk 🎸90s 🎶 "Chihuahua from a tiny purse" 🤣 saw one on the train 🐶🥰 #10 "Matching scars 😉", "Shattered Glass is a lot more Sharp" she's lightened up 😁🤔💭 Demi's 🤣 1-sided feud (re: Swiftologist's YT) #8 smitten delulu ~= Lover, Call It What You Want 🤔💭 Songwriting is her life; maybe a different genre: 🚼🪇👩🏼‍🍼 lullabies? 🤭 random trivia: women 35+ have higher chances of twins so a basketball / volleyball team to get "the whole block looking like you" is possible 🤭 #9 🪵✊ was ok(?) #11 🍯 feels filler / redundant ~= Ophelia #12 "I'm immortal now 🙂‍↕️" Eliz. Taylor and Father Fig. are more Showgirl-ish though 🤔

DrEmily

Yep. All while she was writing the album. And right after NY magazine did feature of CXCX and tracked Taylor down for comment in the middle of the biggest tour of all time. Taylor took the high road, heaping praise on CXCX talent. Then Charli response to opinion on Taylor was essentially “trust me I have my reasons”. Then the bracelet photo to accompany it. My friend in Europe says it hit sour note over there but there was hope that the bracelet pic meant upcoming collab like when CXCX made peace/collab with Lorde. No such luck. Charli is entitled to her opinion on people, would never argue with that. She can write as many aggressively vulnerable songs she wants and talk shit all over the world. But occasionally there will be a response to that. And Taylor got her here. No details or list of grievances, which kinda makes Taylor come off unbothered, but at the same time she points an obvious finger at the culprit. Which is a wild contradiction in one song.

Abby

Listening to Actually Romantic, couldn’t help but think of the line from girl so confusing where lorde says “it’s just self defence until you’re building a weapon”

Jaime

*TRIGGER WARNING* At least for me, cancelled came across as tone deaf and a MAGA anthem because in the context of 2025 and the fact that we have a president who is involved in scandals after scandals and we know that she and DT are not friends and it’s not about him…but lyrically it gives empowerment to right wing people supporting this criminal ped***** administration. I know that’s harsh but it’s extremely important to have these conversations about what we are consuming in the broader context of current culture. And then in wish list, the lyric of the whole neighborhood looking like you in the context of ICE raids removing brown people from communities…everyone will come for me but we SHOULD hold Taylor to high standards…look at this roll out with the multiple variants and fans buying movie tickets for lyric videos. If no one asks questions, it’s just blindly following. I’m not saying this is what she means with these lyrics, but it doesn’t sit well with me personally. I also do not like the message of a man coming to save the woman from misery in the fate of Ophelia. I think that is a disempowering message for young women. Unfortunately the production doesn’t really save the album either because of all the copying from other artists- weezer, pixies, Jackson 5, Jonas brothers, olivia, Sabrina. Which is kinda poor taste after some for Olivia for cruel summer credits. Just so much of this doesn’t feel integral and that truly has made me sad and disappointed because I LOVE Taylor and have been defending her genius Thank you for coming to my ted talk. I know people will come for me but 🤷‍♀️🫶

🍰

*You’re. Illiterate swifties without critical thinking capacities are so disappointing.

karisa

BAR FOR BAR MY SAME REACTION LMAOOO

LittleDoeLady

Maybe I’m reaching but even before the album came out I didn’t think it would be “showgirl” because she said it’s about life off the stage. Which I imagine for most “showgirls” is not showgirly (I’m saying showgirl too much) and mundane. So when they’re off the stage and the makeup and costumes are off, they AREN’T showgirling.

Alie

She said the same about Joe and she was lying then too

Marla Stecki

I can't wait to hear you and Zach talk about this bc u both have different opinoins about the album!

LittleDoeLady

I actually like the first 3, but because of the production and they’re fun to dance to. But I agree, it all felt very tone deaf to me and just didn’t hit for me. I don’t hate it, I don’t love it. Maybe I’ll appreciate it more later when it matches my mood.

Marla Stecki

I really want to go back and see your reaction to TTPD! Is it still on here?

caroline

True, but her album pictures were giving sexy lingerie rather than tortured poet. There’s always a disconnect somewhere as far back as 1989.

Chas

Me writing Jack and Aaron letters in my bedroom while I process this album tbh

Chas

It’s the only song stuck in my head

🌷Elle🌷

Funny enough the one song that is stuck in my head is Wood, but I attribute that to Jackson 5, not Taylor lol

Terry B

🙂‍↕️ true, quality time with partner is important (sports games podcasts 🏒🏈🎙️) I suppose a brooding artist makes great art coz it invokes yearning and introspection, whereas a happy artist makes comedic content which may come across as simple and shallow...🤔💭 thus Oscars favour drama over comedy, but I do appreciate the creativity / elements of surprise / wit required for comedic scripts -- tragedies are often touching but predictable, i.e. multiple deaths are tragic and impactful, but we can't have the same goofy mishaps repeated -- first time it's funny, then we'd get bored. So, Travis the happy muse may dull her writing a bit, but I'm hopeful that she'll continue to strive for excellence because it's her deep rooted personality: She wants critical acclaim (eligible for 2026 CMA Hall of Fame perhaps 😉😁?) in the past she sought approval from wrong places (So Long London artsy Boys) lyrically Matt was a good muse I guess she accepted that "Failures Bring Freedom" and wanted answers instead of questioning herself what could've been 🤷‍♀️ e.g. in #2 Eliz. Taylor "I'd trade the Cartier for someone to trust -- just kidding" 🤣 if any woman could juggle both success and happiness, it'd be the statue of liberty 🗽 a.k.a. our Queen 👸 🥳 🤗 happy 😃 listening 🌟

Archie

Period. Especially after a terror threat that canceled 3 shows and all the political assassinations happening. It’s her responsibility to us for her to be Switzerland in politics as fans can become targets. We can all get informed somewhere else

Katie

Yeah it is

Emily Kern

to me, Eldest Daughter is about maintaining your sensitivity and softest even though the world prioritizes apathy and coldness to be “cool”. being a soft and sensitive person myself, it makes love hard and it makes you want to give up, but while it’s oftentimes extremely difficult, it leads you to finding the right person. reject the apathy and hold on to your softness, even in a cold world that tells you it means you’re weak.

Katelynn

I gotta say I find one of the most interesting things that Taylor said in interviews/podcasts is that her and max and shellback had been building up their powers apart for the last 7/8 yrs to come back together to make this album “she’s always wanted to make” and it was like catching lightning in a bottle and it’s all bangers. In my mind she markets this album as a concept she’s been wanting to do and it was their best work together yet. My opinion is that this album doesn’t hold a candle to 1989 AT ALL. This felt like a Katy Perry type of downfall album hahaha

Shaina

IKR! "Wrote two albums and smashed it all together" is actually the perfect way to explain this. I have no idea where the whole "behind the curtains" showgirls concept even came from. There aren't enough about "showgirls" or even "life" in this album. Lol. Seems convoluted

ALCHMY (Alyss)

I have felt like I’ve been having a stroke for 24 hours now because other than like 3 tracks I really liked it T.T

Meghan Sullivan

Yup :/// all her brand wearing maga peeps smh

ALCHMY (Alyss)

Am I the only one who thinks the title track sounds like cool from the Jonas brothers?

Robin Vaughn

I get it's a reaction. I think what's hard is the reactions are sooooo parasocial and even though she does write about her own life, I don't think it's meant to be listening to it as a confessional. I love actually romantic but I'm not listening to it as what happened to her but more so of what I relate to jt

Amy Lenhardt

I really respect Zach and Madeline’s opinions but I think they haven’t evolved their expectations of Taylor as she has grown. They took her for her word when she said things like, “That 1950’s shit they want from me” even though she said otherwise. In reality, Taylor has ALWAYS wanted to have a true partner, get married, and have kids. She also wants to have her music career and be amazing. Why can’t she have both? Maybe Travis just isn’t a “purse” and is her person. I think they can’t really appreciate some of these songs until they realize that Taylor doesn’t want to die all alone as a girl boss, with nothing but her cats and Grammy’s as company. She actually wants a family. ❤️ P.S. Seeing Zach and Madeline’s reactions to “Wood” was really funny and I knew they’d hate it. It’s actually one of my favs because it is so catchy and it’s just supposed to be fun. 😉 P.P.S. This album is about the LIFE of a showgirl, not her feelings while performing. It’s about what was happening in her real life during the tour and what was happening was her falling in love, getting back her music, and perhaps thinking about her mistakes from the past. I really love it.

noicingcupcake

I'm surprised by your reaction to Cancelled honestly. Like, I thought at the very least musically it would be your vibe, but at the same time, to me this read as a response to the Blake Lively thing. Maaaaybe the Brittany Mahomes stuff too but really my first thought was Blake. Idk, maybe I would feel differently if I was American but my mind didn't go down the same route as yours

Kyley

To me this album is what happens when you get with a man like Travis. It was stated he doesn’t know the lyrics to Red. Her style has significantly changed since they got together, her dripping in designer clothes. She’s appealing to Travis not the fans. He saved me, he chose me! Selling the narrative she’s happy when there’s still insecurity at play.

🌷Elle🌷

I almost feel like she forced this album, which is never a good thing, but I think she wanted to make it clear she loves her man (instead of leave us with TTPD which is a very sad album). Personally, I wish she had cooked more before jumping to another era 😅

Miss_Lippy

I cannot understand the mental gymnastics involved for the people who are connecting any of this to maga/politics etc but this comment is actually helpful because there really is ZERO logical natural connection whatsoever and the way Taylor saying “I’m so in love and you bring me so much joy that I hope our children resemble you” and somehow connecting it to ICE raids was truly insane ffs 💀Um yeah so this has been illuminating lol carry on I guess

🌷Elle🌷

Beautifully written! This is exactly how I feel 🫶🏼

Roh

Makes sense why she was holding back based on the comments. All the “omg it’s not that serious you guys HATE FUN !!” “this is not about MAGA and she’s a PROUD liberal stop putting words in her mouth !!” “It’s about Blake Lively not Brittany Mahomes” many people with very limited critical thinking skills unfortunately

🌷Elle🌷

This is how I feel. I’ve been here since the beginning and surprisingly this is the first time I don’t care to listen to the album a second time (because we don’t always fathom everything on first listen). I just don’t care to listen to this again.

Alex

Right when some of the tracks were starting to grow on me BOOM she hits me with the AI stuff. Girls... its bad. Shes kind of unrecognisable now.

🌷Elle🌷

It’s not that she believes otherwise, it’s the song itself and all the surrounding nuance that Madeline was talking about.

Hannah Ramirez

Just here to say I’m with you on cancelled. Totally tone deaf 🙄

🌷Elle🌷

Agreed! I pay to hear their thoughts, pick their brains, I love listening to them talk whether I agree with them or not. It’s fascinating because I enjoy their personalities.

Pia Fleig

I’m not up to date, which AI stuff?

R.L Cantale

yep and aldo I am so happy she is not doing the super bowl , i think that would have been the worst idea ever. The SB is so not for the fans dude like who of us peasants it's going to pay 10.000 to sit on a bubble and watch football with le diacraip and kris Jenner come on , So that is a positive !

Amelia

Wrong song babe. They're talking about cancelled, not wi$h li$t.

Pia Fleig

That’s well said. I feel a little alienated by who she’s becoming since she’s with Travis. The constant logo flashing, using slang, and… writing songs like Wood.

Alex

Theres promotional videos you access with QR codes across different cities with cryptic clues in them. At first I thought the videos were CGI but the closer you look it has the weird features of AI like random objects disappearing as the camera moves or objects morphing into different objects etc. Pretty disappointing she couldve easily had an actual computer artist do it.

Natasha Sepehri

I watched this 6 times in a row. Even when your stumped (or hiding) the words. Your expressive emotions are so clear. It’s so vulnerable, honest, and enjoyable. I really appreciate how you argue with yourself and try to see if from many points of views/sides even as your own feelings are so strong. Thanks for all your reactions/rants/diatribes/tangents. They brighten my day. I have also gone through a weird experience phase where I spent nights staying up to read the testimony of all the titanic survivors. When I heard you share that I laughed out loud.

Just Deas

Tell them gurl!!!! There are no bangers on there….. missed opportunity

Debby Ajide

I had 10 girls over. I designed and printed cards for everyone where you can rate the song and write first impressions and lyrics highlights. Andddd thinking the songs will be hard to get on first listen, I printed every lyrics for everyone… so imagine- we seen ALL the fumbles😭😭 not a single line was missed.

Miss_Lippy

Reread OP. She mentions both. But fwiw I assumed cancelled was about Blake Lively- who is only in court bc a man retaliated against her reporting of sexual harassment by hiring a crisis PR firm of smear campaign experts to destroy Blake’s reputation and discredit her allegations/ make the public hate her, all while boosting content that promoted his own image. Sadly, this worked beautifully in his favor bc the public is dying to hate a woman anyways (Fun fact: his hired crisis PR rep literally says this in court-obtained text msgs that were subpoenaed between PR and this trash director man!!! She actually says how it’ll be easier to bury Blake bc of how readily ppl hate women -you can’t make this shit up!) So I find it really sad that anyone would mislabel the song as “a maga anthem” when it’s actually supporting fellow women and a close friend who was a victim of sexual harassment and coordinated public attacks via Hollywood hired smear machine. But sure, let’s go with “maga anthem!” 🙄

Miss_Lippy

I mean she kinda just did publicly support her with this song tho 😆 And have you not watched Zach’s videos on his YT breaking it down ? damn, that hired PR smear campaign was effective af huh? lol

Trudi

That is where I went - definitely about men in the music industry taking advantage

Eddy

wait could canncelled be about sophie turner ijbol

Beth

I'm an American living abroad & my mind didn't go down that route either. I thought the same thing as you did, and I really liked it (e.g., how she growls "matching scars" at the end of the first chorus). But now that I think about it, yes, it could (and likely will) unfortunately be used by the people Madeline specified...yikes. I can't believe I didn't pick up on that!!!

Bella

Oh my … it’s identical

Ivy Fuss

cancelled seems to be 90% about blake and for that im saying YES. the smear campaign got her for doing essentially NOTHING!!!!! so thats why ‘maga anthem’ never crossed my mind, bc she’s not talking about politics, she’s talking about making a joke that gets taken out of context etc

Rachel

She has said in interviews that she is the most her and herself she has ever been. Maybe yall just don’t like the real Taylor at her most authentic happy self. Blaming Travis for YOU personally not enjoying an album of all things is wild.

Rachel

Brittany has been hated by the American media and public for many years, way before her and Taylor interacted. So being newly cancelled like the song is talking about can’t apply to Brittany. And the only people being cancelled in America are liberals (Stephen Colbert; Jimmy Kimmel) so I don’t get MAGA vibes at all. If they use it, they don’t get it and that’s not on Taylor.

Rachel

Freaking insane connecting the cruelty of ICE to Taylor Swift songs. And the only people getting cancelled in America are liberals (Stephen Colbert, Jimmy Kimmel). MAGA gets away with everything. I truly don’t get these wild takes.

Jaime

Actually the moment I read the lyrics, that’s what it made me think of. No mental gymnastics whatsoever if you’re paying attention to what’s going on in the world. There is for one, a genocide happening whilst people are being detained unlawfully and inhumanly. “The whole block looking like you” really sounds like saying a whole block looking like typical white American man. White suburbia was by design from a system of oppression. For how smart Taylor seems, it comes across as insensitive in 2025. Not to mention “bodies in the attic” in cancelled is just so disturbing. It’s obviously not literal- but with people disappearing and the US president covering up s*x trafficking involvement- it’s just a very bad look on so many levels. Taylor has enough money to scrap projects and to hold out on releasing projects. She has the right to say what she wants but all of this is a lil disturbing (for me) when she’s hanging out with MAGA and being photographed with them. You don’t have to agree, but I feel it’s important for people to look at what we are consuming and not just follow blindly. Let me be clear, I am a FAN of Taylor. I have her records. I preordered this record. This is not hate for hating her sake. If her lyrics are what we respect her for, shouldn’t we understand their impact against the broader landscape of culture- American culture specifically because she is American.

Lydia

I struggle to make sense of her saying that she’s very offline. Then how did she find out about Charlie being shady in her song and on social media? And all the so called “ice cool hot takes on the internet” on Eldest Daughter… also how is she supposed to know her position in the culture if she doesn’t know what the public thinks of her? Of course she reads album reviews and stuff but still. I’m dumb

Paula C

She’s lying lol…she’s more online than she wants to admit

Lynn

Sorry don't agree with Cancelled. I dont care if she has friends on either side of politics. I have friends, in fact I even live with my Son and we both voted for different parties. Who cares. Doesn't matter you can have family or friends who vote different, gosh we even talk about it like adults. I'm in the UK so maybe we feel different about it? Mad I'm a little disappointed in your reaction (and yes I know its a reaction vid) but I have to say I really like 90% of this album on the first listen. But I still love being behind the paywall. You guys are awesome 👍 🥰

Lynn

Who cares if he doesn't know the words to all her songs. How many songs does she have? Why is everyone so bothered he doesn't know the words?

Rimon Nisan

As a non-American I have to say, cancel culture in America has gone completely off the rails. Canceling someone for being a republican IS stupid and I’m saying that as someone who generally aligns more with democrats. People have to understand that it’s okay to disagree and even dislike someone without making it a point to completely ruin their career and life. For that reason I LOVE cancelled, not to mention that it’s more than a fair reaction to the Blake Lively stuff and people thinking that Taylor would stop being friends with her for it.

Lynn

She's in love? My God what did ppl expect. Of course she gonna have some songs abt being happy and in love.

Lynn

Tots agree. I think the super bowl would have been an awful choice

Rimon Nisan

Only sane comment ever award

h

The thing is, being a Republican in America today is a completely different universe from normal conservatism. It's straight up fascist. I used to be able to lend grace to conservatives, but now they are literally Nazi wannabes. It's terrifying

Rimon Nisan

I think that’s unfair demonization. Yes there are extreme voices on the far right BUT the far left has shown it’s own variety of psychos too lately, and I think it’d be best for everyone not to assume that anyone on the opposite side of politics is automatically an extremist.

h

Anyone who supports Trump at this stage IS an extremist, I'm sorry. There is no nuance in what he's doing, and there is nothing on the other side that is even close to equivalent. At all

Rimon Nisan

This type of black and white thinking is not even remotely productive and leaves zero place for conversation. There’s always nuance. My country is currently governed by a right-wing President who I personally think is single handedly ruining the country and sh*tting on all of its citizens, and I still don’t automatically hate everyone who votes for him. And I still am interested in their reasoning and open to a discussion. I do think it’s interesting that you call every MAGA extremist while failing to see that hating half the population of your country solely based on their politics makes you an extremist.

h

Being against literal fascism, and a regime that's building concentration camps, is not an extremist view, but I guess we just won't agree here. I think people are not immune from judgement when they support Nazi wannabe dictators. If it makes them sad that people don't like them, I'm sorry lol

Lynn

I'm UK and tots agree with this x

andré romero

girl i felt the same way the first time around, second time i fell for it 🚬

Hey12345

Awesome. You’re in the U.K. We have a deranged president & those around him who are ignoring the Posse Comitatus Act and is trying to turn our military on U.S. citizens. Note for you: Bannon, key architect of Trumpism, is pals with your own right-wing extremist, Nigel Farage

Alex Iscream

WORD. good for her if Travis bis shoulders and d*** got her blind and deaf to all that is happening in the world but we dont have to be. why are you maga when you could be glaad taylor LOL ..?

🌷Elle🌷

I wish Blake defenders would catch up to everything happening in court instead of holding on to her statements. All that stuff has already been debunked, there was no smear campaign. A woman got dragged for being tone dead, or for being a woman, but nothing was done specifically against her. She couldn’t prove it because it never happened. Sadly she sucks at marketing and her ego got her to this point.

Bridget

This whole album to me feels like the Shake It Off music video. It’s fun, it’s silly, it’s goofy. The fact that it came after TTPD I think is making people not like it. They were expecting the same deeply lyrical thing but this doesn’t have to be that. First the first time, she is with someone who makes her laugh and feel joy the way she did when she was a kid. Trav is just a big silly goof and he brings that out in her and THAT’S OKAY. If she wants to be married and have kids and get a taste of “normal” life for the first time since she was a child, THAT’S OKAY. It doesn’t stop her from being Taylor Swift. This is one more era. There will be plenty more.

🌷Elle🌷

You can disagree, but if the made up campaign is all you can say to “offend” me, I don’t know what to tell you. I think critically and have been following this case because of TS involvement. I make my own decisions and consider all facts not just what someone wants me to believe 🫶🏼

Einhorn Taschentuch

This is genuinely the most insane take I have ever read. This IS pure mental gymnastics and reaching. I'm genuinely speechless

Alena

As a Canadian, when I first heard CANCELLED! I was a bit gagged and kinda like I can respect her for being loyal and I liked the production, it's got energy. It was giving the rep character, which I felt I could lean into to feel badass too. However, I live in a very different political climate than Americans. The situation for human rights in the states is becoming more dire by the day. So I understand that it WAS a bad call for her to put out a song like that as an American right now. It was tone deaf and I realized that after thinking about the state of things in the states and seeing your reaction Madeline

Chantel

alright little miss gate keeper, i’ve been a unwavering fan since fearless

Wojtek

Sadly, this reaction is such a waste of time.

Amanda Starker

Thank you for also clocking the Jackson 5 sound of Woo—haven’t seen anyone else say that!!

Celiaarrghh!

No need to apologize for your feelings on the album. This album was not it. There are points where I liked the songs melodically, but holy crap some of the lyrics were terrible. And worse than that some of the lyrical content painted a real bad picture of who Taylor is as a person right now. 🫣

Rachel

You don't live in America. This is a hypothetical conversation to you. There is no nuance to be found in today's GOP. My neighbors are being kidnapped by my government, my rights have been and will continue to be stripped away, and our democracy is crumbling in front of us. Of course people are angry, they should be.

Bridget

I’ll give you the fact that it was marketed differently from what it actually is.

Eddy

Sophie turner “matching scars” Taylor and Sophie both dated and I think were cheated on by Joe but that’s just a theory

Enzo Reis

46:41 The showgirl aesthetic is one of the most paradoxical ever invented: glittering on the surface, but profoundly tragic beneath. It is made of sequins and tears, of self-promotion and self-annihilation, of sisterhood and backstabbing. Deep down, rivalry isn't a flaw in this archetype—it's the driving force that makes it exist. Think of the stage: a single spotlight, a single star. But there are dozens of women vying for that ray of light. The showgirl embodies an archetype of survival in a system that transforms the female body into a spectacle. Rivalry arises not from the essence of women, but from the structure that pits them against each other for the same male gaze, the same spot, the same applause. Showgirls (1995) only radicalized what show business itself has always been: an arena. Nomi and Cristal are two sides of the same beast—the hungry young woman and the hardened veteran—trapped in a game that only accepts winners for the day. And taking it out of context, you can say, "We all have crowns," but just because everyone has them doesn't mean you'll automatically love them all. Disagreements still exist and will occur. We're human, and we won't get along with everyone. And I think what Taylor says on this album isn't: I hate women, I think it's: I hate the stan community. Zach said it better than I in some videos of his but stan community (ex: gay men - not all of them - can oftentimes sexualize women in other to them be the "diva" if they are sexualizing themselves they say "diva" but if she's being herself and less that they consider it a "flop". And there were this type of stans and people doing that to Taylor in 2024, clamming that "Taylor died" , "The Eras Tour is going for to long" that "Ttpd was horrible, flopped, etc".

Ashley Tobin

I think what ppl are forgetting about actually romantic is that the song is likely not JUST a response to sympathy is a knife. I’m sure that Taylor has heard a lot more stuff that Charli has done and said about her in private amongst their mutual friends

Ashley Tobin

Yeah cancelled is the only one I can’t listen to. Everything else is fine to me - I can bop to all of them and some of them I really like sonically. But I cannot listen to cancelled. And honestly it’s more because of the sound. It’s just hookless.

Mar

Same I’ve always been curious about Madeline’s reactions!

Mar

Oh nooooo it is so similar

Ivy Fuss

was she cancelled though, or did she just get divorced? thought it was just the latter but idk

Alexis

It’s so interesting to me that you are pausing the songs on your first listen! You’re reminding me of Dr. Kirk Honda when he reacts to something - he’s known for all the pauses

Shalini

“Chip” coming out after father figure is my favourite use of a prop 😂

Zanne

The record sounds 100% AI generated. It lacks humanity.

Shalini

Chip was so gagged by father figure his eyes were looking in different directions

Alexis

I loved it immediately and it’s been on repeat since release!

Alexis

Why do you say it’s about Britany Mahomes? I completely hear it being about Blake

Madeleine

Can’t believe the MAGA apology and both sidesing going on here….crazy……

Alexis

I really liked some of the clean versions - they help some with the cringe factor

Alexis

My two cents: I listened to the album the whole way through when released and I’ve loved it as a fun, boppy, sometimes petty, and very much in love and happy album I hope it grows on folks!!

Alexis

I’m in the US and very politically active and liberal and I only heard it as public support for Blake (references to Gucci, joke only a man could, flowers, too smug) I understand the US political climate and how this song could be interpreted by the Magats but it’s not for them. Taylor and Travis have been openly liberal so I’m confused by the jump

brey

Madeline this is your private paid video, you should feel free to say whatever you want to say to the snakes without censoring yourself!!!

Alexis

“Did I say the n-word once?” Who of Taylor’s friends said that?

Amanda

Disliked this one so much that I had tickets to the release party and decided not to attend because i was like “cannot sit through this again so soon” - which is crazy because I’ve been a fan since fearless and I never thought I could actually react like this to anything she puts out

Miss_Lippy

If Charli is talking so much shit that even her own bf has told her he’s getting annoyed by how often she talks about Taylor then she probably doesn’t even need the internet for some of this to get back to her. And since charli’s bf is Matty’s bandmate for all we know Matty got high af and started spilling a bunch of shit to Taylor about stuff he’d heard her say or maybe Matty even got into it with Charli at some point in defense of Taylor when they were dating, who knows.

Laura Kelly

Madeline, you look SO good here. And I agree with (almost) everything! 🤪🥰😘

Suhaib Baleegh

omg ya'll need to say what you want to say. We payed you to literally be free of criticism. This is safe space😭😭

Suhaib Baleegh

YOUR CANCELLED! OPINION IS SPOT ON MADELINE DON'T BACK OFF.

Suhaib Baleegh

unfortunately the album is such a low, if everyone sat there with a camera on their face, they'd have the exact reaction.

Taylor B.

I say this as someone who lives in LA and is like very very very tangentially on the outermost skirts of Charli’s most extended friend group. Charli has been shit talking Taylor since the reputation tour.

Melissa

Thank you sm bc I feel so seen. I had the exact same reaction to the album and most of the songs, except I also hate wish list. But omg I had to stop and take breaks the same way and just didn't understand what was happening 😂 Now the narcotics have seeped in more and I'm bopping to some. 🫶🏻

Melissa

Did your current administration label your son a terrorist just for existing?

Melissa

I think she was making a general example about privilege and cancel culture.

Sofia Di Rado

how is no one talking about how madeline felt like she needed her megaphone just for the first line of ophelia to be about a megaphone!!!!

Sofía Hernández

Omg, Madeline was really on a rollercoaster with this album, I can't blame her 🤣🤣

Marie

Their song is listed as an interpolation

Morgan

I am cracking upppppppp and feel so validated lolol

Natalia

Did she react to ruin the friendship?

myheartgoespewpew

Ahhhh watching this is just.... I felt very similar and I felt so bad about it for some reason

☆

it's at the end, she accidentally skipped it

Rhaven Moon

Me too man, I feel guilty a little for not loving it and like, I don’t even wanna say that online bc I don’t wanna add to the hate ahaha 🥲

Lisa M

Omg we’re back againnn intro was great. And yes she was so offended in actually romantic. I believe there is beef we don’t know about. It’s not just sympathy is a knife it can’t just be about that song only.

Hayleeeeeee

THE OUTFIT ALONE!!!! GAGGED

Hayleeeeeee

the cringe at fate of ophilia is sooooo real.

Hayleeeeeee

WE WANT THE UNFILTERED HATERATION ON THIS ONE DONT WORRY

Hayleeeeeee

your immediate reaction to actually romantic is so real lmaooo

Tiffany

Madeline disassociating for 15 whole seconds after the first line of Actually Romantic 🤣🤣🤣🤣

reckless mermaid

I just learned about the photo Charli posted of the dismembered hand wearing a friendship bracelet after Taylor had to cancel a few shows due to threat of terrorism. The fact that there wasn’t more mainstream backlash about that shows that people really don’t see Taylor as human; she’s the “monster on the hill” and no one is gonna take up for her. So then how is her writing a clapback punching down??? Like if no one else is gonna check Charli on that horrid behaviour, why can’t Taylor?

reckless mermaid

As a fellow Canadian Swiftie I have to agree. I think the song itself is actually fine; if she hadn’t given it an alt-right coded title it wouldn’t be as much of an issue in terms of optics and message. It’s unfortunate because the lyrics of this song are the only ones balancing out the light misogyny sprinkled throughout the album; if Taylor had made her point about women being held to different standards more directly (if that was indeed her point) the song would do a lot to correct the weird tone of the rest of the album instead of being this weird maga dog whistle

Alexis

Actually Romantic is a diss track, but What’s the second one? Cancelled isn’t no?

Alexis

Hear hear!

DrEmily

Everyone will always interpret song lyrics based on their own life at the moment. You are not “wrong” to have these feelings. IMO, since it was written/recorded before the 2024 election, it may have been thought to release during a very different looking presidency. If albums didn’t take 10-14 months to press into vinyls for release, there might have been more ability to pivot here. But the many many references to women being cancelled for being too aggressive in a man’s world (girl-boss, jokes only men make, breaking glass ceilings, etc) made the original intent pretty clear to me. As for Wish List, I took the lyric to mean that they grow their family so much that it fills the block up. It’s a badly written lyric (not the only one on the album) but it feels like a sanity-defying stretch to take a racist interpretation and believe that she would ever write about wanting to live in an all-white community.

Bee Elle

Followed by "that could be about anyone" 💀 😂

Halen Cox

The gaggery on actually romantic...🫢

phoenix

This is a beautifully crafted comment!

Chas

Girl read the room 🤣

Kate

I liked the album. At first we've listened to it with my group of swifites, that i've made friends with during eras tour, and we were silenced for the first moments, we've liked some of the songs, didn't like other ones, we've thought that it is not Taylor's vibe at all, but it was so fun to listen to it together. In general I think this album grew on me. It's not perfect, but i can find aspects of it that I like. I dance to those songs all day, I like to listen to it. It's fun to have fun as Taylor said. Having said that - I do understand the constructive criticism, but some people are delusional when it comes the amount of negative things to say - i do not understand it.

Dancho

This is giving “we’re so back, it’s so over” 😂

Becky Tucker

I’m so confused… I loved the album back to front immediately…

Margaret Schinkel

Girl I knew cruel summer was a super model on the first listen

Shaina

Exactly. That's what I've been saying. It feels so inconsistent.

CaRo!iNe

the reaction to the first line of Actually Romantic is sending me lmao

MwanaLesa

Gurl! Please stop being a tease and saying “I’m not gonna say anything”. Just don’t say anything. lol….. It’s OK. I feel like I’m leaning all the way forward in my chair to hear what you’re about to say and then I just fall on the floor because you pull back from saying the thing. 😂😂

MwanaLesa

Yeeessssss!!!!!! That’s why I came here to hide and say it just to/with the real fans. We have to get it out somewhere! 🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️

MwanaLesa

Hate. Wish. List. It’s the most basic shit. A basketball hoop in the driveway?????? Gurl bye! She would NEVER. Maybe a basketball court in the backyard. Maybe.

MwanaLesa

Yyyyyyeeessss!!!!!! Omg…. Her biting her younger so much and saying “I’m not gonna say anything” was almost painful. I mean it is literally why I am here! To hear you say allllllll the things.

MwanaLesa

Yeeeessssss!!!!!! Thank you sooo much for saying this!!!!!!

MwanaLesa

How is the reaction a waste of time? Are you saying it’s a waste because the album is bad or because the reaction is bad/poorly done?

MwanaLesa

I agree. I thought it was a nice song about loyalty and sharing battle scars and being in the trenches with your friends fighting the bullshit. So yeah…. I really appreciated Madeline’s perspective.

MwanaLesa

Exactly. She built up the writing too much to then give us “we were fire”. I want more Folklore poetry.

MwanaLesa

Is Opalite the other diss track? Or Father Figure?

MwanaLesa

I agree. But I think what AlisonDS is saying is that Taylor came to that realization regarding that particular real-life friend because of what Taylor went through with Mattey.… And the wondering of is it the right thing to do the risky thing… And that the regret may be worse than making the “bad decision” to do the risky thing.

MwanaLesa

Yes!!! Absolutely. I agree!! You are right!!

MwanaLesa

I agree but it was still an unnecessary dig by Taylor. Taliyah has people running to that nobody girl’s page…giving her clicks and views. It was punching down. You got the guy….and the ring. Move. On.

AlisonDSWills

Yes! Thank you both for completing my thought on this... when I was typing it out I had JUST told my friend this theory, so in my head I had already explicitly stated "Forever Winter" , and i didnt realize I didn't the that bit.

Rocio R.

Not her best album, but it’s still a bop. I will say that being a victim of theft (my TS CD was stolen in transit) made me appreciate this album more 🤷🏻‍♀️ guess you don’t know what you have till it’s gone ….

Madison Hart

Thank you for saying all the songs randomly say “Fuck all these bitches.” I was so weirded out on first listen by her referring to women as bitches in so many songs. I made a playlists with the clean versions🥲 this was the first album of hers I actually got “mean girl” from her and was so sad and confused.

Espritlumiere

Girl you're almost edging us every time you say that you're not gonna say anything 😂 We wanna hear what you think!!!!

Espritlumiere

I hate that I love this song 😭 I just love the beat and production too much 😭

Espritlumiere

48:48 I thought it was "ahmatised me" as in he was the one to finally make her orgasm 😂

h

I could see perhaps a climate controlled indoor court, adjacent to the steam room and sauna lol

Espritlumiere

I almost cancelled my ticket but it was my birthday and I thought it would be more fun 😭

Espritlumiere

Why are you here paying money for this reaction if you find it boring?

Espritlumiere

Yes agreed! I'm an Aussie and actually love this song, but it's the melody and production that got me, not the lyrics! If some of the lyrics were different, this would very likely be my favourite from the album; which also goes for almost every song lol

Espritlumiere

Yes thank you! This is what I've been saying and I've been called a hater and not a true fan lmao. Taylor herself misrepresentation this album BADLY and set expectations WAY too high!

Espritlumiere

I remember some bullshit recently about people being mad at her for going out and having fun after the divorce, while leaving the kids at home (presumably with a babysitter or family). People were not happy about that, it's ridiculous

Espritlumiere

Yes exactly this! She herself said this would be an album full of bangers like a 1989 2.0 but with the lyrical prowess of Folklore and Evermore. Is the good writing in the room with us?!

Espritlumiere

I wish the lyrics were more concise and would've painted this picture better. I never would've gotten that without reading your comment!

Espritlumiere

I'll give you the outdated slang point but does that really matter? If she wrote the songs with more current slang, they'd still be cringy and shit lmao Taylor writing slang into any song is weird

Espritlumiere

Yeah same. I understand why Americans are bothered about it but Taylor has never been one to take a firm stand on politics in her music. Not everything is about politics. The rest of the world exists 😭

Wojtek

I pay for other materials, which I like. This one is just an empty video with some noises, no comments, no content.

Sarah

just came to watch madeleine’s reaction and saw your comment, happy (belated) birthday fellow libra ♎️ 🎉

Brandon wood

I've literally never laughed as hard as I did watching you respond to "Actually Romantic"!!!

Andrew McCanna

36:05 - Madeline became a President.

Alena

Some of her lyrics are amazing! Like there is one line on eldest daughter that I love about reflecting that shimmering light back... but then there are lyrics that totally take me out of it and ruin it for me 🥲 a total tease

Justine Paulette

15:04 this is so funny, it’s the first song and you’re like ‘and I’m in the outfit’ 🤣🤣🤣🤣 weren’t we all… weren’t we all 😭😂

reckless mermaid

That’s a major gripping mine as well… nearly every song has something weak or wrong with it. I actually think the bridge in eldest daughter is the best writing on the album which is unfortunate because the song is so bad I can’t listen to it

Thomas Lopes-Soares

Watching this on 10th, I knew the boa was coming off real quick bc the showgirl was not in the room with us😂 Now that the album has marinated I can safely say I only like Elizabeth Taylor. However, the acoustic versions make Wish List and Ruin The Friendship work for me.

DrEmily

Your experience and opinion are valid,and understandable with how the album was marketed and the world we live in today. The album should probably have been called Reflections on Love, or some such. She is definitely in the Lavender Haze right now and living in a kind of love bubble. I happened to be off work on release day, and never expected more of the “Release Party” than the Midnights videos of the bingo ball generator, only with included lyric videos. So the MV and rehearsals were a nice surprise. I guess it’s all a matter of expectations vs reality - I am an older Swift fan, and my life and work has conditioned me to limit my expectations and just live my life in the moment, treating every day as a gift. So, everything I enjoy on top of that is a nice surprise. I just spin all of Taylor’s songs together on shuffle at work or the gym, so when they play it’s a nice little disco vibe that can lift my mood (though I often skip past C! when it pops up). I am sorry you were disappointed though. That is never a great feeling.

Shana

Yup. Being breezily cheeky and gauche is harder than it looks. :)

Psychobabbler

Devils advocate question here, if things had worked out between Matty and Taylor, do we think we still would have received an album like this? Giving the influence Matty had her on stylistically, I wanna say no? No idea what kind of album we would have received but I think it would have been very different.

h

I agree. She is heavily influenced by her muse and what they're like as a person. I don't think she would make an album like this for Matty. And if she did make a love album for him I think he would also be featured on it in some way. Maybe even a full combined project like Kurt Vile and Courtney Barnett's album together (they're just friends, but I'm saying like a whole cowritten album where they sing some songs individually and many together)

CJ

I’m kind of upset that I paid to see this reaction. People really just don’t get it and it’s about time Taylor is finally happy and saying “fuck you” in the nicest way possible.

SP

Ok sweetie

Jasmine Snowberger

well so everyone is entitled to their own opinions lol madeline doesn’t exist to please you specifically

Stamkitty

I thought the same. It wasn’t a great example. Agree with M’s overall point though that Taylor was in her tunnel vision writing about the kind of things that got her and her friends “cancelled”. The song comes off tone deaf, especially the end. However, the song’s opening lines are true - the hearse is picked out and people are not always trying to be fair and proportionate. And the line “tone deaf and hot, let’s fucking off her” is a succinct description of what people object to about her crew. Taylor is clearly triggered by double standards for men and women. What doesn’t come through as clearly is the message that woman shouldn’t aspire to the same problematic behavior that men have gotten away with.

Stamkitty

We all know what is Actually Romantic is how many good songs Taylor has written about Matty. She knows it too. This song is Matty adjacent and it is a banger. It has to be tongue in cheek as Taylor spends a lot of time thinking about people who have wronged her. “You’re so vain, you probably think this song is about you” type of circularity. It is brand enhancing for Charlie XCX as her fans have rallied and people who don’t know her music are listening to see what the drama is about.

Rebekah

Just started to watch this. You picked So it Goes … because it’s brilliant!!!

Zoe

I chose to believe Cancelled! was trying to be Blank Space but it really missed the mark

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Ya I felt that too, it's missing a bit of something... And it sounds too Disney to me instead of cunning.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

It's not random though, it's women that have done her wrong. I still don't agree with it, but it's not a question that the women are being awful.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

I dont think it's about Blake... It's just about many of her friends and her getting canceled over very little - we punish women for so little while there is literally a felon in office. My only critique is that it's too Disney for me.

bubb

“I’m kinda upset I didn’t get the echo chamber I wanted, so I’m just gonna pretend it’s more complex than it really is.”

Madison Hart

Taylor didn't think it was casual when Kanye called her a bitch in a song, and she said in Miss Americana that she doesn't believe there's such a thing as sluts and bitches so this is definitely a departure.

Callisto

i come back to watch the start of this reaction on a daily basis.

Aleeza Alam

You’re not American so for you, this is a funny hypothetical. I’m watching my country descend into facism because of MAGA and republicans. That is my lived experience as an American. I couldn’t care less if some rich white people are getting “cancelled” for having harmful opinions. You can’t even fathom how harmful those opinions really even are because you don’t have to suffer the consequences of them. My worst case scenario as a woman of color is so much worse than just getting “cancelled”

Aleeza Alam

I’m so tired of non Americans weighing in on the party lines in the United States and how it plays out socially and culturally. I am literally watching my country descend into facism. I am a woman of color. Your right wing in the UK and mine aren’t even remotely the same. “Respect both sides !!!” is a hypothetical for you. You are not a victim of the American right wing. You don’t know what you’re talking about.

VK

If My Tears Richochet was the crying ghost of Taylor at the hands of Scott Borshetta, Father Figure is the demon come back from the grave to bury him alive ... Brrr

Rachel

I should’ve also had my own reset moment with Ready For It when I listened to this album for the first time 😭😂

lulu

ty for cutting off the sinister parts of eldest daughter i was itching to skip bc i cant listen to it...

Lisa M

“That could be about anybody” takes me out 😂

Heather

I actually think ruin the friendship is matty coded. She talked about the whole tragedy with Robert lang in forever winter, but I think this is her answer to “question”. She wishes she would have just went for it with matty a decade earlier to save herself from 10 yrs of obsessing over him and essentially ruining her life as she put it.

Heather

Probably was

Heather

Well said. I didn’t think about the clapback to the Stan community, but that makes much more sense

Heather

Did she say lyricism, or storytelling? Because I see the storytelling and how each song fits in the puzzle based on what was happening in the background of her life during eras

Heather

I’m a moderate democrat and the thing is not every republican is MAGA. I’m a gen x and these latest generations and cancel culture is one of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse. No one should have the right to ruin someone else’s life no matter what. Karma baby, it comes back on its own

Heather

I’m sure she hears abt Charlie in circles, esp because there circles are intertwined. The internet words were just a play on her saying she’s not cool. I’m not saying she’s not on the internet, but I’m pretty sure she’s not on twt, & TT. She leaves that to her team to navigate

Heather

Yeah I don’t think there’s anything political about this song. Someone said the Gucci line is because Blake used to be an ambassador for Gucci

Gaer

I'm honestly pretty shocked! The difference between Zach and Madeline reactions, Madeline seems to fangirl a lot less in her first reaction. I'll see if this is true in her other reactions but I love it <3

Olivia G

Madeline’s reaction to The Life of a Showgirl: fight ❌, flight❌, freeze ✅

Teaplease

It wasn't just a post, it was a NY Magazine photo shoot. So what's scary is there was editorial direction behind it

Teaplease

Poison flowers in CANCELLED gives Blake's character in It Ends With Us, who is a florist

Teaplease

It feels like in Taylor's moral code, cancellation as a concept is only about taking a successful woman down using wrongful accusations about her character, not her actions. Because that's what happened to her. And sexual predators deserve what they get, right?

Teaplease

I do agree there's a whiff of the Matty situation here. All of her songs about him are packed with questions about what COULD be our what COULD HAVE been (including in the song titles...Question...? Guilty as Sin?...). When in the outro of RTF she says "My advice is..." it almost sounds like she's talking to an imaginary audience of up-and-coming showgirls and reassuring herself for taking the bold step to find out how the story ends

Teaplease

YUP YUP. Been saying the same thing. When people talk about Joe being a ghostwriter on folkmore, they don't realize she is just channeling the tastes of her muses. She's so versatile she can make it her own so it's not just pastiche (like the opening of Dear John). But she is definitely, definitely playing to her muses' styles and tastes on everything from folklore to TTPD

Teaplease

You left me no choice but to stay here forever, amiright?

Teaplease

I bet Aaron was that person for her

Teaplease

It's the unfairness. That's how she experienced it, and that's how she defines it

Bell

There's something to that. Cause Jack will really just let her go and there's something controlled and tight about her songs with Aaron. He's so gentle and kind though, I wonder how he, or really anyone in Taylor's orbit, pushes back or gives feedback to her.

divatron

10:59 LMFAO MADELINE YOU ARE SO REAL

divatron

The grimace I can’t lmfao

divatron

She is stressed

divatron

The “uh” and “um” of it all has me HOWLING I love you

divatron

I love seeing Madeline being embarrassed to be a swiftie right now because it is very relatable lol I too am embarrassed

Sophie

36:17 “that could be about anybody” 😂😂😂 I died dead 😂😂😂

Chas

It’s giving Temu, dollar store version of BS

Val

I actually love the album but you're hilarious 🤭

Chas

Girl I think she’s ten toes down not feeling this album as she shouldn’t!

Chas

Girl she’s ten toes down not feeling this album as she shouldn’t!

Jordan Braidwood

WHERE HAS THIS REACTION BEEN MY WHOLE LIFE?! the pauses, the concerned faces… it has it all!

Jordan Braidwood

The moan when you heard the first lyrics to “Actually Romantic” takes me out! 10/10, no notes. 😂

Penny

of course it would have been very different... we never would have got tortured poets if it had worked out with Matty so literally everything about her catalogue would be different!

Jenny 🪡

i hadn’t watched this hilarious reaction and i had such a visceral reaction to eldest daughter because is the only song in taylor’s entire catalogue that i have ever blocked. it’s beyond, her worst song ever tbh. at least cancelled you can run to, at least ME! you can laugh at. eldest daughter is a broken promise, a betrayal if you will. the fact that a group of seasoned musicians felt the it was alright to publish that, and as a track 5!… it knocks the air out of me every time (bridge cute tho which makes it worse)

Allison Gobeil

I am rewatching this in May in preparation of seeing you guys tonight in Philly and I literally shit myself laughing at this reaction video. Thank you for the dopamine hit.

Nils Sjöberg

It’s so funny when you reset with ready for it

Jaxs

Watching this again and I just can't get over how gorgeous you look well yes chip is an icon oh hi 💖

SwiftieMoonie

I love watching Zack’s reaction back to back with Madeline’s. The contrast always takes me OUT. 😂