Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Files

Comments

Cocogigi

Happy upcoming hatch day Madeline 🐣🐥

xKami

you look great Madeline✨

Morgan

Opening line was absolutely iconic

Morgan

The movie pmo so badly. Also it was so awkward sitting in a theater full of people to watch lyric videos 😭

Meghan

I was actually so excited to see the music video twice. I would have sat through it 4 more times if I could 😅

Lilly

Love you sis but its not going blurry

Katie

Happy Early Birthday Madeline!!! 🩷 thank you guys for all of the wonderful content

Ait

Madeline you touched on something when you said that TTPD was more of a look behind the curtain than life of a showgirl..

ducky

The locals in the theater went CRAZY for Cancelled! 🫩 the entire experience was insufferable ngl

Hannah Landry

I think that Taylor looks a lot like Nicole at the end of the all too well 10 video

Dana Marie

My daughter and I went twice. I know, Please don’t make fun of me! Anyway the Friday night showing was kinda wild. We went to the last showing and people were into it. We went again late Sunday. We brought a non-Swiftie friend with us and she really enjoyed it and appreciated the explanations and said that would help her with other Taylor albums. That crowd was younger and not as rowdy. PS I don’t see you getting blurry.

karisa

THE TITLE ME

JJ

Omg I really think you nailed it. The problem with the movie, the album, visuals is that our expectations were sooooo high that we disappointed ourselves

Lisa M

🫶🥳🙏lol the squeaking Yesss get glasses!! You would rock them too. Join the club.

Katie

Also agree, this is the first time where idrgaf about Taylor hate related to this album or feel personally affected by it

Emma S

LMAOOO THE INTRO

kitsch

As a non makeup girlie I feel you just press play period

Elle Kaye

The thing with Actually Romantic is that objectively it’s not that mean. In the grand scheme of things, calling someone who is talking shit about you behind your back a toy chihuahua isn’t a nuclear bomb. BUT —it’s so precisely targeted at Charli’s insecurities and THAT’S what makes it feel so vicious (and imo, delicious).

rachel☁️

I'm not noticing any blurryness

Elle Kaye

Oooh that’d be an interesting survey: How much have you spent on Taylor products vs. how do you feel about LOAS? I’ve enjoyed the album, interviews, music videos, etc., but the last time I bought anything from the Taylor Swift store was Red. I just don’t buy fan merch and only buy vinyls for specific genres of music. I felt like my expectations for this era have been met and surpassed. Maybe it’s because I haven’t financially invested in Taylor?

Jomazel

i also missed the mv in the beginning and was pissed since i paid!!!! 😹😹😹

Alexandra S

Thank you for making this!

Stacy Davydova_13

The Mulholland Drive on your profile picture ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ so beautiful I can’t

Kikimora

People are NOT normal about Actually Romantic. I saw tweets about how Charli should do a "They not like us" diss track aimed at Taylor with pictures of Taylor with men she dated when they were teenagers and she was in her 20s (Harry, Taylor, Connor K.). I think Charli is not cool and a little crazy and she might actually do something like that

Luiza Lodder

I think your feelings and your reaction perfectly mirror mine

Charlie

The woman sitting next me was sobbing during the Eldest Daughter lyric video, which I found so interesting it was worth the price of admission for me!

Sarah

I went with my cupcake friend. We had fun but I still felt the same way as you. I didn’t even really feel like going to it. I just did as an excuse to hang out with her because she’s chronically busy with school and I only get to see her every once in a blue moon

Leslie

Can I say it kinda pmo that the "prologue" for this album is four separate poems so you have to buy 4 copies of the album to have a complete prologue. I know you can just find it online or whatever, but getting a CD and sitting down with the booklet and reading the prologue before pressing play used to be such an integral part of my album listening ritual. It just feels like another part of swiftiedom that's been paywalled :/

Leslie

I agree with what you said, that it's like a C-tier pop album. It's like Man's Best Friend for me. That album was mostly kind of in one ear or out the other, save 3-4 songs that I actually like and kept in my library. I'm pleased with that if it's from an artist I casually listen to/enjoy. But when I'm used to a Taylor album becoming part of my DNA, only having 3-4 songs I feel like returning to makes it a miss.

maryna

We need a brat green t-shirt saying "bratually romantic" 😬🤪

maryna

Fyi: It did go blurry for a second around minute 17 ish

Katie

No that genuinely made me feel like nothing is sacred anymore lol

Tha P

It is so hard when they make the variants available for only a little time, then you dont know if you will regret not getting them. I will be returning my pre order ones though. She got me on the cds though because of the trinkets and the autographs.

Tha P

100% i will actually print the poems and just add them to ny vinyl becauss that was messed up. They didnt come in the cds either! Only on the vinyls. So they expected people to buy the cds for the trinkets and autographs and the vinyls for the prologue. I guess UMG is trying to make the money they dont make on the masters in merch sales instead.

Leslie

I didn't know they only came in the vinyls!! wtf

Tha P

Her latest post definitely hints at something

Tha P

Her words do "shoot to kill when she is mad" lol i guess i am the same way when hurt, so I like the song too lol Charlie knew what she was doing poking the bear, and wishing they'd break up and saying it out loud in a song wasnt really innocent of her either.... she knew what she was doing... I agree with you...

Tha P

I think Zach said it well when he said this is the closest we will get to the secret sessions ever again. I feel the same way as you do about this album, but after clowing way too hard for rep tv during the eras tour, i realized i need to take a step back from clowning and just enjoy what she puts out as they come. Lower my expectations so i can enjoy things for what they are. This is a fun, lighthearted album from a girl who is in love with a guy she never thought would give her the time of day, and turns out he is CRAZY about her. She is on cloud 9. He proposed! She finally got a ring on her finger! His family is awesome and loves her! Her family loves him. He wants kids. The world may implode around her, she wont even notice it, and how can I blame her? Things are heavy out there. I'd wanna escape too.

Sheena Walker

Watching this after I’ve removed myself from Taylor’s email list and unfollowed on instagram. After all the releases and saying she’s not adding more songs, she releases 4 CDs with 2 acoustic songs each. Now, she’s releasing digital album with voice memos all to rack up album sales. It’s gross

alex

I only got the pre-preorder CD and somehow I still managed to be disappointed. For all the talk about wanting us to have so many images from this album, the standard booklet has multiple songs crammed onto every page and there's like 3 pictures total on the inside of the booklet. Compared to standard/manuscript tortured poets that had tons of pictures and was much less visual in terms of the marketing, it's kind of disappointing to see this booklet be so minimal

j.bean

This makes me feel so much less alone, I also unsubscribed and unfollowed today and the me of a few years ago couldn’t have even imagined that. I think I’m just outgrowing this and it feels bad

Rachel

"at this point the poems are more exciting than the album" PREACH! I really don't understand what happened with the theme here. We know she can do the theme because the poems are on theme! She WROTE them and then decided to throw Wi$h Li$t and Honey on a 12 track album 😭 shiny bug pop hit was right there!

Rachel

And to be clear I like honey....on a different album lol

Gabriela Cameron

madeline, are your purchases of Taylor Swift vinyl's and cd's write off's??? dream job. i do music for a living and i'm trying to write off buying taylor's music as "research" 😝

Sheena Walker

I’m sorry you feel guilty for protecting yourself. I believe Taylor said it herself when she said not everyone is deserving of your energy. And right now, she isn’t deserving of it. I just saw a quote from one of her interviews saying that as long as her name is being spoken on album release week, it’s great for her. Good or bad.

Rachel

Okay I know it's not normal to pay attention to someone's Instagram likes lol but did you see the weird racist post Charli liked on Instagram 😭 not exactly an unbothered queen

No Thoughts

Madeline you are a gem of a human being ❤️❤️

Angie Nichole

My theatre had 5 people total including me and my friend.

Leslie

That was crazy

Rachel

I feel like Charli had two potential ways to come out looking good here: 1. Say nothing 2. Drop an absolute banger And instead we got this 😭😂

Tony

The inflection on that intro was uncanny. 😂

Gregabug

I don’t comment that much but wanted to say Madeline perfectly laid out my thoughts on the album! I’m not doing swiftie defense rn & if this was another artist it wouldn’t be so upsetting. It’s only this frustrating because it’s a C tier Taylor record when she’s capable of A+

ella

I'm convinced her making us sit through those lyric videos was a humiliation ritual. might be because I went to a 19+ theatre (so no one was singing) and I was the only one that wasn't drinking but sitting through them was excruciating, I was embarrassed the whole time lol

Cloudyskies

My boyfriend, not a swiftie, got us tickets to see the “movie” and after he was like “that felt like forever” and I said, “yea, it did and I’m having trouble processing that rn”.

Brinley Murray

if i can be really honest… i bought tickets last month as soon as it was announced but i canceled them and got a refund the morning of because the idea of sitting through lyric videos for some of these songs was so humiliating to me i couldn’t imagine doing it 😭

Lia Russo

I enjoyed it cause I did go with a swiftie friend and we had a blast, I'm also super into the BTS stuff and seeing the amazzzzing video on the big screen was CUNT!!! However we said the same thing about the lyric videos! They couldn't just film her doing something for 3 minutes? Like she's a fucking superstar just point the camera at the diva and let her cook. I think next time she should just actually MAKE A MOVIE about the making of her album and show that in the theatres in between better lyric videos. Nothing crazy just even filming herself with her producers. Would've been way better!!

ella

also I really relate to kind of checking out of this release cycle. I made the last year of my life about ttpd but this one just really doesn't make me want to do swiftie behaviours, it's a good enough album but it really doesn't inspire the crazy devotion other Taylor releases did.

Deanna

i'm feeling tayfatigued tbh

Sarah Hollars

One of my co-workers said she had a similar reaction to Eldest Daughter. It seems to hit different for some; maybe it goes back to Taylor’s comment about wanting to “hold up a mirror” with her songs? I unfortunately heard the opening notes of Robin in the start of Eldest Daughter and shut down immediately.

Sarah Hollars

Yea, you look great with and without makeup in all honesty. It didn’t even register that you didn’t have any on until you mentioned it.

Andres

Happy early birthday libra twin!! (My birthday is tmr )

Lia Russo

I'm a small business owner and if she's not writing all of this off then she's making a mistake 🧡 hopefully she is!

Ada

The last time I bought multiple copies or anything directly from her site was when I was 15 and bought all four Lover Diaries. Big mistake, HUGE. I finally started trusting her prerelease marketing again and now I have three copies TLOAS when I hate half the album :/ Shes lucky she looked hot in those pictures is all imma say

Rachael

think it makes sense to pivot away from a ton of Showgirl content on the Lizard Review if you’re not feeling it. Focus on the things that bring you joy ☺️ I like (don’t love) the album, but I’m pretty casually invested in Taylor. That being said, I’ve even felt insane with the discourse and I truly can’t imagine what it’s been like for you since the release. I really appreciate the emotional honesty you bring to your content—the highs and lows and the disappointments! I obviously love your Taylor content, but fwiw my favorite episodes of the Lizard Review over the last year were on totally different topics. And I discovered Sunday 1994 through you!! Protect your mental health and your energy. I think Taylor’s gotten so big that a lot of the fun has been sucked out of the Swiftie experience. I’ve felt recently that the dynamic between Taylor Swift the person and Taylor Swift, Inc. are intertwined in increasingly complex ways. Some of that’s on her, some of that’s on the algorithm, and some of that’s just how it goes with that level of fame. I don’t quite know how I feel about it all!

Anne

Alamo theaters had some merch they gave away that said Alamo's version.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

I actually loved that he music video played twice cause it was SO much (in a good way). It was also cool to see after learning how things were done. :-)

Bryn

OMG I said the same thing Re: NICOLE KIDMAN!!!

Asher Conniff

I bought one deluxe edition and my target cd at the midnight release! thats all!

Bryn

Also my theater was exactly the same, mostly sitting in silence and a bit awk!

Foob

What!? What was the post!?

Foob

I'm a new Patreon subscriber and every penny was worth feeling this validated in my feelings and your comment section is finally SANE 🫶

Bryn

me too but I also can't look away LOL

prajith

girl madeline its time for that eye doctor visit...

Juliana McKenna

It is going blurry, can you put the camera on manual focus? It’s not like you’re moving it to different locations

Juliana McKenna

😂😂😂😂 meanwhile I’m wearing orange silks with my orange cut crease and my orange nails and my orange hair 🙂‍↕️

Juliana McKenna

This is so beautifully put. Because tbh, I can’t understand the taymoves. Thank you for putting it so clearly

Juliana McKenna

If nicki and cardi wouldn’t do that, why would tay and charli. Sometimes people think they’re marketing geniuses instead of owners of common sense

Tanner K

there is something camp and sad clown about this. i don't mean to diminish the very real feelings of despondence that were shared. just that somehow it emanated cunt and i feel like i watched something artful. my condolences, Madeline

Stacey

It's really hard though when you have to make a snap decision before something sells out. I'm not even sure what I ended up ordering. I moved so everything is being shipped to my parents' house and I won't know what I have until I go see them next week. Some days I wish I hadn't ordered anything and just bought 1 physical vinyl and 1 cd after they were released. I would have gotten them sooner and not paid shipping and not bought too much. It's really hard to fight the hype.

Nicole Ouimette

I got the target vinyl and I also feel despondent about it

Juliana McKenna

If I didn’t receive ttpd I would have never become so invested in her as I am now. TTPD was the key to my happiness. Best album for being the most raw, because it allows all my raw feeling to go somewhere

Juliana McKenna

I had a decent time at the movie, my mom got a phone call the moment we walked in at the Elizabeth Taylor lyric video… I had a full theatre full of the whole gambit. Kids, moms, 30 something’s in bejeweled dresses, middle schoolers in eras tour hoodies. We all sang, but really I sang. I considered going again but I doubted I would’ve gotten an excited crowd, and that’s 70% the reason I even bought a ticket

ChuckWithABob

This is truly just a theory about what’s happening. I think the internet has been convoluted with swifties & non swifties hot takes and wanting to be the first ones to call the album bad and whatever and that ruled the internet the past few days but I’m seeing a lot more videos of people loving the album now. I weirdly noticed this with ttpd as well and then people admitting they judged it too quickly. I noticed on your first listen both you and Zach were so hyper aware of what you thought were her “cringy” lyrics but I think that’s because you guys may be more scared of how non swifties or tayhaters will perceive her. Like you (and I) wanted her to come out and make a slam dunk pop album and make everyone who is loud about their hate shut the hell up but then we have to remember as you guys say Taylor is cringy! She’s a 35 year old millennial. Millenials aren’t as chronically online anymore and they aren’t as scared of being cringy. Maybe it’s harder now because she’s a billionaire so it feels like we can’t just defend her artistry & quirks. It feels bigger than that now and people are valid in their dislike for her being a billionaire. Idk I’m just rambling but I know for me when listening with anyone who doesn’t enjoy her music like I do I’m hyper aware of what she’s saying in her songs and so I often don’t even put her on when I’m around normies for fear of some rude comment they will make.

ChuckWithABob

And I agree with all the variant purchasing I just buy 1 cd for my car and 1 vinyl for my collection this time and I feel good about it haha.

Lia

You starting by quoting the 1989 voice memo absolutely sent me… that shit is drilled into my memory.

Ana GdeS

In a way the fact she can spot it makes me think she doesn’t need to go to eye doctor 😂

jaana

i watched the movie alone (in a basically empty theatre... literally 10 people too) knowing exactly what it was going to be, same atmosphere as your experience, the girls there had the same reaction to actually romantic and wood... overall it was fine, a pleasant afternoon activity and i expected nothing more, but it still kinda PMO that she had the audacity to release these shit from a butt spotify canvas lyric videos in THEATRES. they're perfectly fine as normal youtube videos that only 5 people will watch, but if you're creating a theatre experience... idk. im feeling the same as you... a little disappointed, kinda unsurprised... she couldve elevated the songs with real visuals and contextualised them within the wider ShowgirlTM narrative if she wanted to. and it just kinda kills me sometimes like you have all the money in the world, all the resources, the final say in your creative process, and more than enough cultural cache to have people WAIT for you. if not track visualisers, maybe some halsey vevo live style performances, like what she did for the great impersonator? thats VERY showgirl to me. or even like long pond studio session style, tho i guess the music doesnt lend itself to that. but the format wouldve been great to see in theatres too. she doesnt HAVE to do anything, but sometimes when there is so much missed opportunity its hard to look past it since she is literally THEE taylor swift. she could do anything. anyway. i went regardless so im still swiftie-ing. but its just interesting... i also wanted a popcorn bucket. OR A CUP!!! anyway

Ro2207

As a small-scale vinyl collector, it was frustrating to see TLOAS vinyl being offered in such a panicked way - "buy now or you'll never see these ever again." Especially considering we were purchasing without the knowledge of how many more drops there would be, or which versions would end up being your favourite. It is just not a fun way to buy physical media. I can accept that vinyl variants are just a part of the music industry now. I wish this rollout had been similar to Man's Best Friend, where there were different variants rolled out but it was without the scarcity fear added on. Most of the MBF variants are still available to buy now, and it let me listen to the album and figure out which variant I felt most connected to/best represented the album. What's weird about buying vinyl for TLOAS is that I've never not loved a Taylor album. There was a lot of blind faith in pre-ordering an album I'd never heard before, but it was blind faith built on nearly twenty years of being a fan. Overconsumption is a massive issue in the fandom these days, but Madeleine, I wouldn't beat yourself up over buying your copies. You thought you would like the album more than you did, but that wasn't a foolish belief to buy into. Also, don't beat yourself up over your folklore collection. Those are super hard (and expensive) to come by these days so you have a cool piece of Taylor vinyl history for an album you do truly love. Hopefully, in time, when TLOAS has found its natural place within Taylor's long discography, the disappointment will just sit with you in a different way. I don't blame you for feeling a little burnt out atm with Taylor content. I do think 2026 will end up being a beautiful celebration not only of Debut, but of her entire career, so there is plenty to look forward to. Take all the time you need to explore other music and content in the meantime.

Dora Paczur

Just an idea: you could always sell pieces of your collection, that way it could go to other Swifties. I only ordered the OG vinyl, but since this is my least favourite album of hers (after several listens, it is simply not for me), i will send it back or sell it. There are Swifties who adore this album, therefore my thinking is that my copy that i will sell will make someone else very happy 🤷🏼‍♀️

Zoe

I agree with you, I was a panic buyer without even hearing the album and I was hooked in by the ‘only available for 24 hours!’ tactic. Will I learn my lesson? Probably not!

Brittany L

I think actually romantic could have been about the more generic haters. The people who always comment that they don’t like Taylor, without realizing that engaging with content means you’ll be fed more of it. The choruses could have been the same. Just the intro would be different.

Finley

completely agree about the ATM thing… i rlly do feel like an atm this time around bc im not cheering that bad. i like the album, its fine, maybe bottom 4 for me, but her consistently posting the “buy my acoustic CD!!!!” every five seconds on her instagram story these last few days just has tired me a bit tbh.

Robyn

My cinema was in a small English town so I knew absolutely no one would be singing… and I was right. People just clapped after the songs hahahahhaha

Melinda

I’m with you. I never buy anything from her because I can’t bear the thought of giving a billionaire more money. I still stream though, and actually I do kind of feel bad about it. I’m not sure how to grapple with an artist who is a billionaire.

Melinda

I think at next album release I’m going to comment to the lizard and remind the lizard not to buy more than one cd/vinyl. I’ll link back to this video.

Sara

I never buy any albums, I just stream so I never feel like an ATM like that but paying 18 (!!!) euros for this """film""" when a ticket for a proper feature film hundreds of people spend 2 years producing costs like 10 euros was...frustrating. like did that really have to cost EVEN MORE than a normal ticket?

Aline Tschopp

i missed the music video at the beginning too because there were no ads before the movie, so i was late… i was quiet bummed and then happy when the video played at the end

Jennifer Lux

Card cancelled💀 Happiest birthday to you our dear lizard🥳🌟

Claude Favor

the amount of variants you bought really showed how much you are excited for this album only for you to receive the most mid quality music

Lauryn

Tbf for the first time basically ever things were actually only available for 24 hours

Jaqi Jarboe

Actually romantic is funny! You take it to seriously, like Sabrina’s album cover. Plus songs like that only benefit both fandoms and give them both more streams. There’s really no victim here

Lauryn

It’s so weird because I’m feeling so much more tayfatigued right now when she’s barely done anything in comparison to that crazy period of Speak Now TV to 1989 TV to Eras movie release… I was eating

Lauryn

I went to see it hungover after a wedding and grandma’s funeral the next day…. IJBOL excruciating is the right word but the ticket was nonrefundable 💀

Sara Sweet

Does anyone know if the OG vinyl has an insert photo of her in the brown wig drinking a martini?

Sara Sweet

I mean but if you love the album and wait until it’s out you’ll have to pay resale prices for any variants you want😭

Mia Mar

A makeup Kiki with Madeline as I’m watching while doing my makeup too, what more can a girl ask for🤭

HaleyJean ASMR

i agreeee the visuals of the lyric videos were sooo disappointing 😭 if she was gonna force us thru them she could have actually made them interesting. billionaire budget where ???? not only were some of the clips blurry ass snapchats with powerpoint transitions … but the kaleidoscope effect was disorienting. it bothered my fiancé so much he had to close his eyes for 2 of the songs. 😂

sophie

it does!! it’s on the vinyl carrier thingy (genuinely don’t know what that’s called), but it’s the part that you stick the vinyl into.

Alex

No popcorn bucket seriously pmo. The movie was dumb. She tried to do what Miley did and failed. I saw it twice tho so what can I say? 🤷🏼‍♀️🫶🏻

Aimee

I was happy to watch it twice 🫣 clapped and cheered!

Sarah

Good for her actually. Maybe she understands something all of us don’t

Kat Doyle

Happy early birthday! I haven't noticed blurriness or anything being out-of-focus in your videos, for what it's worth. Not in this one or in the last one when you thought it might be happening.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

I am just hoping there are videos for each one! I want them all linked together! :-D

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

I'm so sad that I didn't get to show off my outfit for Snake Tour - I planned on making the TTPD dress but in "brat" green with quotes all over from any time Taylor had been a brat over the years... I was supposed to go to the Seattle show and then Canckles McTaco Tits was elected and started threatening Canada and I just didn't feel safe going 😭💔 I was too depressed to finish it, but I'm charged up now! 😅

erin

Check your signed copy!!!! Someone opened theirs and it had CAT HAIR

J

The I Know Places voice memo reference IJBOLLLLLLL

rachel☁️

The way you described your disappointment and feeling like an atm machine without getting a return on profit is how I feel too

Neeni M

i actually liked seeing the music video twice. after watching the behind the scenes i was able to notice a lot more things than i did the first time (like her catching the football, or the photographers in the windows) however, when i realized the "movie" was just youtube videos i got really annoyed and bored. especially cuz it was the clean version. i loooove listening to her talk about the process behind her songs, but it was just not worth $14 USD to me.

Neeni M

genuinely yes, and it's not even really her. it's people that hate her taking every opportunity to make me feel horrible for liking her music

Neeni M

i feel the same. like the booklet was kinda unreadable to me. and only 3 pictures :(

Karina Artamonova

My reaction as well, I got married recently so maybe you should be in a very-extra-mega-once in a lifetime “my lover and I against the world” mindset to like this song

Anton

The camera IS blurriing. Butwe rock!!!!!

Sarah

HAPPY BIRTHDAY MY FELLOW LIBRA 💜💜💜

Kathryn

I fear Taylor and Nicole are starting to look more alike as they both fall victim to the Forever 35 Face. Feeling a very similar type of way to you about the album. But most importantly: Happy Birthday!!!

hal

It would be so fucking funny to sell that on eBay and see what people would pay

Denise Taylor

Happy birthday, fellow Libra!! Mine was yesterday! =D

Jacinta

I think that’s the biggest thing about TLOAS, it was just a massive let down for something I was looking forward to

MwanaLesa

What did Madeline mean when she said “we all know what happened mere days later”? What happened related to the building and painting of the Fate of Ophelia set?

MwanaLesa

I LOVED how your right eye looked at the 11:00 minute mark. It looked perfect!! Just a hidden little pop of color. Also I agree that the girls heckling & jeering & pointing & laughing during Actually Romantic would make me uncomfortable. I prefer a Kumbaya moment as well!! There is DEFINITELY a lot of nonsense around it. It’s annoying.

MwanaLesa

I LOVED seeing the music video twice! Seeing it after she talked about the making of it was really great and interesting.