Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

'Tis the damn season. With a brand new Taylor Swift album, there are of course, brand new hot takes to share. The brave divas who put their hands into the snake den this week are saluted. On the docket: Taylor Swift's devolving girlboss journey, the continual disrespect of TTPD, ethical quandries about Actually Romantic, and the future of artistry in the TSCU. Enjoy! 

Comments

Aaron O

Oh mama we’ve been needing this. Now I can get through work today. Thank you Zach and Madeline for giving us our fix

Hattie

Oh I’m seated

Lucy

The way I ran to get my headphones thank you snakes 🙏

IrishSwiftie

I read a rumour that this album is rep tv vault tracks. I love the title track and fate of Ophelia and that’s it

Sarah

just in time for lunch time!!! yesss

gv

im in lecture for another hour but i cant wait 🫶🫶🫶

Em ✨️

Eek so exciting!

Sheridan S

Not the rage bait at bed time 😂

Erin

Why leave it off??? It could be about ANYBODY!!!

Tatiana Butts

gobble gobble gobble cant wait to listen to thisssss

Pooja Nair

Does anyone have the discord link the one that’s posted isn’t working. I’m Canadian and I can’t link my Patreon to my discord

Sheena Walker

I don’t care for ruin the friendship. I understand the overall theme of the song but I’m fatigued with the high school references.

stephaliceo

ugh so real about the haters and non-swifties in general giving all their hot takes - i have a friend who’s always hated her who keeps listening to the album and complaining about a different song to me every day. ok thanks for the streams mate 😂

Morgan

There’s a video of Emrata and Harry styles making out somewhere but I think that’s all we really know about it.

Jojobear

I just wanted to give another take on the wish list discourse (it's personally a skip for me because Im not into the fat ass baby face or designer talk personally). I'm a stay at home mum (right personal choice for me & my family at this point in life for lots of reasons), who PARTICULARLY focuses on teaching my daughter the importance of feminism, that education, consent & choice is key. we have many bedtime story books featuring women throughout history etc etc. & as someone who has many working/studying mum friends who I respect & am in awe of, I can sometimes worry I haven't achieved enough. I haven't given an example of an ambitious woman to my daughter?, maybe did I lose myself to motherhood somewhere at some point? Even though it was my personal choice (my husband would & has always supported my goals & life choices), I let these thoughts creep in from time to time. But hearing that the most successful woman in the world might just look at my life with the kid & the partner, no basketball hoop, but bikes & slides outside, & think it was worthy of a "wish list" life, I can't help but let that make me smile. (I don't think she's actually saying she wants to be a stay at home mum mind ha ha). It made me think of the interview where Taylor said music can often be a mirror for the consumer. Just a little bit of an alternative look at things. I still skip the song & my favourites are Father Figure & Ruin the friendship.

mallorey garrett

My hot take is the more I watch her interviews the more it makes me dislike the album. Watching her do mental gymnastics and throw together word salads when trying to make a song like Wood sound anymore insightful than what it really is is frustrating to me.

Alli Johnson

RE: Harry and Emrata (for brevity), not sure about them officially dating but were publicly seen making out.

Erin

I’m stupidly holding out hope that the incessant bread talk has gotta mean something, as well as the whole “2 exits” thing. Like why does every interviewer give ANY time other than thank you for the bread, to the bread… guys wtf.

Bonnie

I can’t wait! 😂 My hot take is I don’t think making an album through the intense burnout of the Eras tour was the best move. Even someone as highly productive as Taylor would be affected by burnout from such a demanding 2 years. I think it may have had a negative impact on her writing abilities. That said there are a few songs on this album I really love and I’m happy she is a workaholic because we don’t have to wait long!

Ohdearjon

People correlate chart gaming with a good album. The writing is dead in the water with a few exceptions.

Ohdearjon

It’s about as deep as that bathtub she’s not drowning in

Chas

During one of the 2019 year in reviews, Zach said Lover was the first time in her career she couldn’t fully explain or stand by her work and I would argue this is the second time.

Ohdearjon

I’m a Swiftie and not listening and still hate a new song every day lol

Alli Johnson

Anyone that thinks that isn't media literate. Over half the album is very clearly about her love for TRAVIS, and Actually Romantic ties back to recent events. Even sonically the vibes are completely different outside of maybe Cancelled and Elizabeth Taylor.

Ohdearjon

I liked it at first but I stopped because my ears started bleeding

stephaliceo

hahaha look that’s so fair, i feel like i’m the opposite a lot of them are growing on me, earworms

mallorey garrett

Yeeeees I would have much rather homegirl go home, sleep and vacation for 5-6 months and then start a new album. It was so rushed.

mallorey garrett

Agreed. I wish she just came out and said something like “i just wanted to make something that perfectly illustrates how much fun and in love I am” and leave it at that. We’d all have clapped and cheered

Roberta

I think the bread talk is the equivalent to cat talk from rep/lover eras. A marketing tactic to at least somewhat relate to the common man. But who knows! Either way, I'm tired of hearing about it 🥲

iLaney90

This is exactly how I feel. There are some good songs on this album but even the good ones sound tired. Vocally, she doesn’t sound like she has much energy to give and lyrically she goes from good but not spectacular to lazy across the album. She's really proud of herself for doing this while being under so much pressure, physically and mentally, and I will give her her due that it was a feat to make it happen. But she should never do it again.

Sarah

literally me during « me! » and LOAS😂😂 like i AM those swifties that left after lover, lucky for me there were like a couple of months between that and the glory that was folklore

Erin

I saw someone comment that you can only truly enjoy Showgirl if you’ve been a fan for a long time because you’ve seen how much she’s been through and if you don’t it’s because you’re a local… girl bye LMFAO I’ve been around since early Fearless and I just don’t love this album and that’s FINEEE it PMO how these people have to make everything so deep

Kikimora

Don't you think you should do more phones-a-snake per episode 😁

Alex

Sometimes on this album I feel like she was trying to shoehorn the song into a pop song and it feels a little inorganic like shes trying too hard. 1989 feels effortless and natural and I think she tried too hard to emulate that and it turns out a little weird. My example is when TFOO gets into the chorus, that first line with the melody just feels forced.

Erin Macdougall

Might not be better than TTPD but it appeals to the masses. Def up for album of the year

Sheena Walker

I agree she should’ve waited. I was thinking that with TTPD, too. I think TTPD didn’t get the attention it deserved because she was busy. Showgirl REALLY suffered because of it.

Anna Rama

I just wanted to let you know that I get what you're saying on a personal level. I walked away from my job to take care of my daughters and elderly mother, and those doubts about modeling independence enough for my daughters are very recognisable to me. That said, I viscerally hated that line in Wishlist. It felt like the woman I'd bonded over with my daughters, and was so proud of for being her own fervent champion in her art and business, was tossing all that away. I came around when I saw the film. I appreciated her being in her Marilyn Monroe costume in the lyric video, calling her boyfriend and talking dreamy nonsense with him on the phone. Hearing her talk in general has helped me process what she's saying in her songs, in a more generous way than I originally did. I'm now listening to the entire album, as the melodies are so infectuous. My favourites are Elizabeth Taylor, Opalite and Father Figure. My nine-year-old is incessantly singing she's not a bad bitch 🫣.

Nina

I agree with the ruin the friendship take, but mainly because other songs on the album (cancelled, wish list) also have an out of touch self-centeredness that we havent seen before from Taylor in such a manner.

X

i'm bothered by the dismissing of this album as not that serious or not thought out. TPD, folklore, and evermore are the three albums that taylor didn't put much effort into editing. on folklore and evermore she was just having fun and didn't even expect people to listen to them. and on TPD she was just writing out her feelings. life of a showgirl is the album taylor is saying she put her all into, edited tightly, and thinks is her best work.

I survived Taytrivia 10/2/24

Madeline, I want you to know that Harry Styles did date Emily Rat I do remember that! In reference to your final point, I do feel like she has learned from her past mistakes and is now very selective about what she shares about herself and her partner for better and for worse. Like it seems like Travis has built this specific persona that she is maintaining through her music

X

this is the album that max martin and taylor agreed to do instead of doing reputation tv. the rumor i've heard is that max martin didn't want to re-do his work so he didn't participate in the taylor's versions.

Swiftologist

This is such an interesting conversation!! Love to see the different perspectives expressed so thoughtfully and respectfully <3

X

"what it really is" what is it?

Elise Cooper

Ok I went to a Taylor Swift Club night on Oct 5th where they played the Life of Showgirl in its entirety and this album really hits different in the club, a little drunk with people that just have love for Taylor

Jojobear

That's so interesting we both had different reactions. this definitely shows why her lyrics are put up for so much debate. I also had the same reaction as you to the movie, especially with her on the phone in the wish list lyric video. I said to my friend who I was with, this is her on her tour missing this new guy she's head over heels with & she's got a quick 5 minutes & she just wants to tell him something dramatic so he knows how much she misses him. I just also wanted to take the time to say, you're a great example to your daughters. Walking away from your job to care for not just them but your mum, IS strength. (Also my 3 year old is obsessed with the new music video & I feel like she's learning the dance routinely very quickly 😂)

Sheena Walker

I agree. I feel she set our expectations for something different.

Chas

I knew we were headed for I love Travis territory with this album when she walked out at the Grammys to So High School.

Pooh Khanum

The insane outro to this was my zach choking on his match when that elizabeth taylor bass dropped

X

when you say no hits, what are you possibly basing that on? i feel like you guys have spent the last year claiming that TPD was actually loved by the general public based on billboard chart metrics. but all of those same metrics indicate that life of a showgirl is WAY bigger and more loved by the public. fate of ophelia is about to have more chart points than anti-hero ever did. all of my immediate family members, who don't even like taylor that much have listened to this album and messaged me, unprompted, saying that they like multiple songs. you guys, this album is a hit.

Anja Dott

I also think it's a relatability marketing shtick with the bread. I mean she can't only talk about Gucci, Cartier and her million dollar engagement ring.

Jenny

My hot take on this album or rather the dislike of this album is that a lot of swifties are desperately searching for deeper reasons as to why they don’t like it because it baffles them so much they just can’t accept the fact that they simply don’t like the album she put out. I think that’s why the discourse around it is so heated. But it’s absolutely okay to not like one out of 12 (!!!) albums. It doesn’t make you less of a fan.

Rose

i paused the episode to read the essay Zack mentioned and holy shit, it is really good and very affecting

Chas

Yes. I did the same.

Jojobear

thank you that means a lot! I always appreciate your work & journalism, even when I don't always agree with your takes, i love them all the same. also while I have your attention ha, a little video idea ... Maybe the way pop culture & music works & effects South East Asia ... This might seem niche or an odd request, but I used to live in Bangkok for a very long time & I found the roll out & culture around music & pop culture to be very different. I found your 'celebrities you've met' video so interesting because you touched slightly on how that world works in Singapore. Anyway, thanks again!

Chas

Jenny, yes!! You put into words exactly what I’ve been struggling to understand re: the Swiftie reaction to this album. I think you nailed it. I also think it may be embarrassing for some Swifties and that’s not a feeling many of them are used to. (Lover aside which…if I can speak my truth, is a better album!)

Erin

TTPD is a sprawling record, but I disagree that she didn’t edit on Folklore and Evermore. Editing happens in all phases, and it starts with having a clear and consistent vision, which those sister records absolutely do. They represent a very curated moment sonically, visually, and thematically. I do think Showgirl needed more time in the incubator. There’s something to be said for whittling down, but you can’t truly whittle down when you stop at 12. She did edit herself in that she wrote to Max Martin’s melodic math and kept the tracklist tight, but I don’t see consistent editing applied to the sonic direction, theming, or songs themselves. I can describe Folklore and Evermore in a quick elevator pitch, but I can’t do that for Showgirl because it’s trying to say a lot of different things, which to me indicates that it does need some editing.

Anja Dott

It makes me wonder as well, with TTPD I really had the feeling, she wanted to make all that music. I feel there are other reasons she released this album which are not writing or creating the music hence why a lot of it fell flat, the production isn't exciting etc. Some possibilities: - money pweeeas (obviously) - hiatus is planned and she didn't want to leave it with TTPD - Travis and some fans have demanded an I love Travis happy record asap - reaction to the criticisms with TTPD (but then she could and should have taken more time imo) - bc her audience has broadened with the whole football crowd take advantage of newly interested listeners (Lover in a sense was marketed to appeal to younger people, maybe showgirl is meant to broaden her appeal to men and the football audience, maybe even conservatives in the US, hence the travwiving) - maybe it is about the chart successes and records bc TTPD wasn't able to keep her relevant due to lack of mainstream radio playability

Jenny

I mean, I also felt a little embarrassed when I heard “did you girlboss too close to the sun” for the first time hahaha it’s absolutely okay and I just decided it’s not for me, I saved the songs I liked and then moved on with my life. And I absolutely agree with you, lover is (to me) the better album!

Erin

Re: the lyrics stuff, while we’re reuniting old legends, can we give Liz Rose a call…

X

personally, i feel like i learned a lot about how taylor feels about travis on this album. I feel like Opalite is about how Travis is someone who can create his own happiness, like creating a man-made Opalite sky. And that's something it seems like Taylor really admires about him and wants to learn from. Additionally, I think Honey is about how Travis, by being so transparent and trustworthy, makes Taylor feel safe enough to take the things he says and does at face-value instead of questioning his intentions or being offended. And this allows her to release and heal from the baggage that those words (like honey) and actions (like calling her late at night asking what she's wearing) had accumulated over her life. of course, it's up to interpretation. but i think this is consistent with what taylor's been saying in interviews about the album too.

Nefelibata

I agree 100% with the ruin the friendship take. But i understand it comes from the fact that I am actively grieving someone I love, so it does sounds bad to me.

Nefelibata

So it is a PERSONAL thing

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Honestly, the kool-aid has kicked in, and this is a great album. ❤️‍🔥✌️✌️ I thought she might be doing a Lover 2.0, and I do think Showgirl is a better album. It's STILL not the flavour she said she was serving, but I've mourned.

X

is there any evidence that there are any unreleased folklore/evermore tracks at all? more than a handful? i feel like people are starting from their feelings about the album, then reasoning backwards to what must have happened to create them. the fact is max martin doesn't work in a way that produces a lot of tracks to widdle down from. he'll only take an idea forward if he thinks it can be great, and then he keeps working on the same track until it is great. this is how 1989 and reputation were made as well.

h

Yes and it's just so unrelated to anything else on the album. Feels completely random for it to be there

Katie

“Ruin The Friendship” answered the “Question..?” Open the case!

Katie

I thought he was gonna get his own album after I heard that new era Title 😭

Katie

As someone who was in a club on my birthday for ttpd night.. I can confirm this album bops. Sometimes it’s best not to listen to close

Boo

After almost a week I think I know now what my problems are with it. It is not unpopular, but my expectations were misplaced for multiple reasons: 1. The title After hearing The Life of a Showgirl I thought sonically more theater, more jazz, more exciting mix of pop and grand orchestra. Where are the drums, the horns, the trumpets. Where are the grandiose, the dramatic, the theatrical? I know there are some of these elements, especially in the title track but I expected Chicago, Burlesque, Cabaret, Moulin Rouge, Back to Basics kind of album sonically. The good news, I can listen to them. The album is right up my alley, I'm a millennial women from Europe, so it is nostalgic, but it would've been good knowing this. Again, a single drop can manage these expectations. 2. The song titles and the order of them When I first read the titles that told an other story. I think this is a problem of mine in part for one reason: the trick / easter egg thing with the titles shaping the Eras Tour Stage. I think of Eldest Daughter specifically. I am an eldest daughter with all the disfunction and parentification and all that jazz. I thought that song is gonna destroy me. I think that naming that song and put it in the fifth place is altered because of that little trick. Emotionally Ruin the Friendship is the fifth. And the title is not telling what Eldest Daughter is about. It is weird naming it that. Especially after Father Figure. I thought that two song will be sisters in some way. For example she sings about the same thing but from different perspectives like in folklore. She mentioned specifically folklore when she talked about TLOASG. So I think the names and the order of the songs sometimes misplaced just for that little trick. Which is a choice I guess... 3. The Showgirl of it all... Again, the title gives me sisterhood, sacrifice, troubled relationships, female rage, sexual expression, physicality, drama, greatness... The dark realities boiling under the shining facade. I think she didn't wanted a darker tone, or going deeper. But I wanted less Travisongs and more female rage and sisterhood. Also in one song "my dick is bigger" is a negative expression of toxic masculinity and a real power struggle but in the next time I should be happy about a big dick? This is not a thematically cohesive concept album I wanted to be, for sure... My bad. So I think all of this was because of the marketing was misleading about the theme and about the sound (not to mention greedy with this 24 hour releases not just for the vinyls and CDs, but even in iTunes. WTF), one easter egg over artistic expression, and the complete lack of singles to manage expectations. I enjoyed 3/4 of this album very much once I sit with it for a couple of times but this is not a good ratio for a short album like this.

h

I'm so glad you talked about the fact that she really hasn't shown WHY she loves Travis in any specific way on these songs, beyond him being fun and happy and wanting kids too. Not that she has to reveal anything, but it makes the music much less moving and impactful compared to how she described her connections with past boyfriends. It feels so shallow and empty overall. If I'm marrying someone it's because I feel a deep soul connection with them, not just because we have a fun time and have sexual chemistry

Katie

See when she said Showgirl I was ready to defend all the out of touch moments cause it’s SHOWGIRL

Katie

Video idea Tayvis Halloween predictions or inspo

Lucy Anne

my little tin hat theory is that ONE of the reasons she is doing soooo much press for this album is because she knows the work can't speak for itself

Lucy Anne

but maybe that's me being hopeful that she knows deep down this isn't her best work

Nia

As a Harry Styles fan, I will say Harry and Emrata making out is simultaneously the funniest and most embarrassing thing he has done. However, I think that is all it was. He was walking home with his friend in the early hours of the morning, and Emrata was never seen or associated with Harry again, as far as we know. It probably seemed longer because Olivia Wilde decided you felt slighted by this and started posting things on her IG story.

Katie

Daisy bare naked was SO PROMISING

X

yes, i think you're right. and i think it's manifesting in this strange need to not only dislike the album, but also be validated in the belief that there isn't something deeper in the album they're not getting. i've seen among my own group chats some friends basically demanding that people who like the album "at least admit it's just not that deep." it seems like saying it's "just a fun album" is the only safe opinion to have without offending someone. it's the fear of missing out. but the fact is that, yes, not liking the album will be a bit of a barrier to discovering deeper meaning behind it. it's not an insurmountable barrier, but it is challenging to want to analyze art that you don't like.

Chelsea Bauscher

Not my hot take not making the episode (that this should've been a 5 song EP) and Madeline literally saying "this could've been a 5 song EP" 😩

Katie

Her friends like your posts is a good thing. If there was anything to be objective about it was Wood. ..Zach that video is so funny and gives a great example of balance as a Stan

libakri

i gotta defend the second verse of actually romantic, the viscous prescious line is like my favorite part of the song (after stop talking dirty to me ofc), to me it flows pretty well and the "that's how much it hurts" is a total gag. i totally agree with your thoughts on using the word bitch in honey though, the clean version of this song is so much better. also wish list becoming a single is my worst nightmare, but i think she'll just pick one of the most streamed songs, probably opalite imo

Katie

They were wrong about TTPD and now we pay consequences

Katie

12 is a lot! She gets graded of a curve. We know this.

mallorey garrett

Uh, a song about her finances giant penis. That’s it.

Boo

Also, the theater theme aligned with featuring Sabrina on the album.

Marta S

as a new snake here, where do we submit our unpopular opinions?

Katie

Girlhood didn’t get a moment in this record until title track. If anything actually romantic walked us back whatever steps girl, so confusing gave us lmao

Katie

Kylie Kelce has a bit about pet names. I think that’s where Honey came to be

Katie

The us vs. them reminds me of her fairytale Disney princess trope

X

my theory: i think she's doing press again because 1) as she explores on TLOAS, she's reached a new place of acceptance of her "fate" as a showgirl, so she feels comfortable coming down from her tower and participating in telling her story like she use to before reputation era. and 2) i think she also wants to thank the fans for making the eras tour such a success. it feels to me like TLOAS was made more "for the fans" than her last several albums.

Jenny

I actually kinda feel like the opposite? Because to me the album really is not that deep, I had no struggles to understand what she’s talking about whatsoever, but I feel like a lot of people are manically searching for this deeper meaning which leads to the whole tradwife and “opalite is racist” accusations. But that’s just my personal interpretation of the bubble I’m encountering online. I’m mostly trying to disengage with everything surrounding this album on social media now because it has taken on a very weird dimension haha Edit: I think you’re talking about a different side of this whole thing and you’re also right!

Katie

Girls are hateful tho. So I have zero doubt Tay has gotten so many side eyes whe she’s simply just being nice and talking to a man talking to her

Katie

She said she wants a basketball hoop and no more touring and it was offensive for us to think that?

Katie

I don’t fall for the “he’s a PR relationship” but this was maybe a PR album rollout

Katie

I was so sure TS13 Wifey Taylor was taking its time to cook and wasn’t gonna Wood all over my showgirl

Katie

Fortnight was really just her saying “get your expectations aligned cause this album is for my two week fling, not my 6 year thing”

Erin

That’s a fair point about the process, but I don’t necessarily just mean that she should have written more tracks (although I do still think the record would have been better for it). That’s kinda what I was getting at when I said editing happens at all stages. Sometimes you have to circle the drain a few times to arrive at what you’re trying to say. I can’t really put my finger on what she’s trying to say here in the way that I can for her records that feel more edited from the initial idea.

shelby

It’s been bothering me that people have reduced the poor choices on this album to be Travis’ fault - is that not just another iteration of sexism? That she can’t be responsible for her own less than stellar work? She’s also not helping the “Travis is dumb” rhetoric when she portrays him so one dimensionally. Nonetheless, I think the way she marketed and talked about this album before its release was the main let down for me. If she would’ve said from the beginning it was Lover 2.0 I’d be clapping and cheering! But unfortunately the concept of the record feels half baked and the lyrics desperately needed an editor in the room with her.

h

I think she does realize now that it isn't her best. That interview with Zane Lowe was very revealing. She was directly acknowledging the backlash, saying all press is good press, and looked genuinely pissed off while trying to be chill about it. I've never seen her talk about backlash to an album that defensively, and it felt like a cope for her to say, well maybe people didn't get it because of the place they're in in their personal lives. I've never needed to be in the same emotional place as her to enjoy her albums. It's just about quality

Dani

yes! and let’s get the Rosetta Stone of Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus in there!!

stella

rage bait needs to stop getting air time to make space for the thoughtful opinions😭

Lucy Anne

Do we think we're going to be getting more than one music video this album rollout or ...

Katie

I think Tay wanted to make FYP friendly tunes. TTPD gave her no trends or spins or people dancing

Tayllor

The Ruin The Friendship conclusion that “you should kiss your friend even if they’re in a relationship in the off chance they die” is literally what Anthony Fantano’s take is lol😭😭

X

dismissing her success as "chart gaming", calling her songwriting "dead in the water", saying that your "ears started bleeding" from listening to TLOAS? with fans like you, who needs haters? 🙄

Katie

Opalite single would’ve been a good single it’s a close hit

h

Taycheater emerges once more 😅😭

♡ MoMo ♡

Welp, I love the album. Opalite, Wood, Elizabeth Taylor, Honey, Fate of Ophelia, Father Figure, Actually Romantic & Wi$H Li$t & Life of A Showgirl have been on repeat & will stay on repeat. I love love love happy showgirl Taylor. Been having a great time & only better with each Taylor interview & new heights episode 🥰🫶🏻💕🎀✨

Katie

She’s allergic to an ep

Renee Darline

BTS moments that should have been songs -- her four poems all could have been songs. Also her anecdote about Travis and Greta Gerwig in the tent at Eras tour could have been a song

Katie

They think it’s Travis making her stupid but she’s just like this in her Honeymoon phases

Nina

Of course, but in previous songs such as who’s afraid of little old me, she comes across as more self-aware in her monster on the hill of it all. She is cheeky about being the diva, and we love to see her be the diva. To me, wish list feels disingenuous because of the 32 or so variants she brought out. I think ruin the friendship wouldn’t irk me if the message would have been ‘should have told you, you meant something to me’ and not ‘should have kissed you’. Having kissed someone or not feels a bit trivial when it’s about someone having passed away.

Kb8248

I think Taylor knew she was likely to get married and she wanted to put out a spicy album about her partner that covered the beginning of their relationship before the wedding. Boyfriend content is probably different from Husband content. It’s Rep coded w/o the anxiety and it’s more direct because she wrote it as a 34 year old woman comfortable in her sexuality as opposed to a 26-27 year old experiencing a real committed relationship for the first time and the blissful feelings that comes with that.

Katie

Yes!! We need to know what makes him The One?!??

Katie

He’s hot, loyal and likes her back. I can’t find anything else on the record that says why this love is the one.

Jasmine

I just can’t stand the tradwife allegations and people taking anything she says about Travis in bad faith. She just got engaged of course she’s excited and wants to talk about it. It doesn’t mean she’s saying end women’s rights fjfjcj. I also think maybe people thought TS was gonna tell us all about Travis and really we don’t learn anything about him besides the common you’re my person tropes. And I think even though she is talking about him, it’s still a very private relationship. Is it a deep album, no. But I’m having fun with it. It’s bops.

Lauren

Omg University of Iowa mentioned

Katie

Makes me happy that even after you deserve prison but you won’t get time, she’s still like yeah.. I’d do it again. Let’s ruin the friendship 🥹

Justus 🤍

Or maybe women have just been mean to her lol. Just because she is a woman doesn’t mean she has to love all other women who say whatever. I also think she just likes to say bitch lol

Justus 🤍

And yes I think the lesson is people are never happy with wherever she is. And yall seem to enjoy happy Taylor in hindsight

Jasmine

All this media and we couldn’t get a good interview either. I need someone to just poke into her brain. We need good questions. I need someone who is ready to ask another question about her answer not just prompts.

Katie

I also remember similar lyricism when she wrote about Joe, like “and I’m highly suspicious that everyone who sees you wants you” but it just sounds so much meaner on this album and I don’t get it

Natalia

you guys’ conversation about whether Taylor can produce another hit is sooooo interesting. I think it’s all about Taylor loosening the reins. if she doesn’t do that, we get Jack using very similar production across several albums. we know for a fact Jack can be more versatile. I think she needs someone saying no to her which… DK if that’s possible with her being who she is now. I remember how Zach has said she needs another Liz Rose and I think that’s what it boils down to. I thought Max might curb some of her worse instincts on this album but that didn’t happen. is it because they’re now more on a level playing field and she’s now ungovernable????

h

The comparison to songs like TTPD is wild. In TTPD she's like, no one else gets me the way you do, we are soulmates, everyone who knows us sees why we're each other's destiny. It's SO different to how she talks about Travis. I'd be offended if I were him haha

Madison Hart

I need these convos about Honey and all the bitches. This is one of the cutest songs that I find the most off putting 😩 I have the clean version which is better but I still can’t shake it

Lauren

Thank you for all the uploads snakes, I’m sorry that this release week has been so stressful but the commentary has been the highlight of my week 🫶🏽

anonplz

This is a good point

Tracy Erin

I think this should be track 5

Shannon

Just got to the point where Madeline said she should have released Ophelia as a single so that people could have tempered their Showgirl expectations and been better prepared for the album, and I think this is at the heart of why so many people, including the Snakes, are so down on this album. It didn't meet the expectations they had built up in their minds, so it's going to be a disappointment. But those Swifties who don't care about staying on theme (me) and locals out there in the world who didn't think about the album for even one minute before it dropped...we're dancing and clapping and cheering. There's no cognitive dissonance to manage. I feel so bad for the Swifties who are struggling to get past this aspect so they can enjoy it as much as others.

Sarah

about the songs order she said it was only made to look like the eras tour stage… well…

h

Ungovernable made me laugh 😂 on point tho

Justus 🤍

These TRADwife things are actually going to make me go crazy! Let her be in love without projecting!!

Tracy Erin

It's extremely controversial! She compares herself to Travis' ex gf's and almost gf's who are mostly (in public awareness) Black. She disses them and calls them Black onyx and says she makes him happy because she's not Black. POC are upset about this song, Eldest Daughter, and Wishlist

h

I'm sorry that you're going through that right now. Wishing you all the best in your healing ❤️

Shannon

This has been happening to me too! So many people who aren't Swifties have been messaging me saying they enjoy the album! From my perspective, it seems that the general public is reacting to this album a lot more favorably than Swifties are. Personally though, I've actually been enjoying this album. 🫶

Abby

Agreed! The tradwife allegations make me feel crazy. And on all the songs where Joe was the muse, did we really learn all that much about him or why she loved him so much? Yes you could infer stuff but I'm not sure they were SO much more revealing than anything on Showgirl (TTPD aside of course, but that was a post-mortem). Her songs have always been more about how other people make her feel than the people themselves.

Justus 🤍

Also bring a tradwife isn’t a bad things if that’s what the individual wants. As long as they aren’t forcing it for others. That’s literally feminism

Katie

So Taylor has been comparing black-and-white night and day red and gold like this is her thing. I’m not saying Opalite is very deep, but it has a good message which is to create your own sunshine.

Katie

I would’ve picked it as a single because it takes no time to pick up unlike Ophelia. That’s because she wanted and I love Travis song as a single, personally I think title track would’ve been great.

Nicola

I actually find it so crazy that he will be Mr. Swift and what we know about him (or his song character at least) is what Zach and Madeline said - he's hot, knows how to ball, has a big dick, saved her from her tower. I think her portrayals of her ex's and the portraits she paints in her songs are really incredible. I do hope we get a bit more complexity when it comes to Travis, I'm sure we will. ❤️

Renee Darline

Oh I've been PRAYING for Elizabeth Taylor music video. We need more. Stop the press tour and back on the soundstage

Justus 🤍

Yall will eat your words with Opalite and Fate of Ophelia. I have so many of my normal non swifty fans who are LOVING those songs… and wish lost lol

Miranda

The 🎭 of Honey is so real. I love it until it gets to the chorus. And then it keeps repeating! She usually switches up the chorus. This whole album is the first pancake with Trav as muse, but so high school told us everything we needed to know 😭

Sarah Patricia

My initial takeaway from the bridge in Eldest Daughter is that she got her girlhood back.

Justus 🤍

It will probably be second. Both that and fate of Ophelia are smashing with normals

Katie

Don’t forget Gorgeous exists OK, she’s like this in every honeymoon phase. It’s her Disney princess syndrome.

Abby

Being a tradwife involves a woman submitting to her husband and enforcing traditional gender roles. It is often also about romanticizing the past, when women had less or no rights. It's not just being a stay at home mother. People can do what they want of course, but it's not feminism just because a woman does it

Tracy Erin

The trash talk about TS12 is not just about Taylor, but also all white women. You mention Lena, people say oh she likes Lena so Tay's a bad person. They're calling Taylor a pedo for dating younger boys like Harry, Taylor and [a Kennedy? was he young?] another one. Three racist tracks - Opalite, Eldest Daughter, and Wishlist. POC are telling Swifties to study intersectionality. People are pissed about the inflated versions and album limited additions. I think their are 30 different ones? They say TayCapitalism is unnecessary. Universal Music Group is full of evil overlords at the top and while they have 2/3 major label artists, Taylor seems to have more power and could change things like vetting rid of the white supremacy zionists. Another group says Taylor is infantalized. I don't see this. Their arguments are weird. The photos with the racists are unfortunate. Taylor's video saying that not liking the video keeps the album being discussed was considered a bomb. People are wondering if Taylor will hold herself accountable for the racism. If she does acknowledge this, people will mock that as well. For large groups of the population to expect Taylor to have an expertise in intersectional femininism is maybe not fair, but someone should probably have told her to not release this album. And yes, too much media. More material for haters.

Tracy Erin

Oh yeah - Canceled is being said to be a dog whistle for Conservative maga people. I wonder if a couple of these tracks are Rep vault tracks because there is Rep coding on some and the album seems rushed.

Hannah

This is so cynical but I really think all this promo is because she wants money pwease. I think the eras tour activated the most aggressive form of money pwease in her brain and now we’re seeing that

Renee Darline

Seth Meyers had the best, I think

Jasmine

Have we stopped to think that the woman in Honey was a witch because HER man was looking at TS wrong. Why is she making it TS’ problem huhhhhh talk to your man sweetie.

Tracy Erin

I see this answer online in response to valid criticism like about the three overtly racist songs. Taylor is held to a different standard, yes. However she set that standard

Alyssa

I think Madeline/the caller really cracked the case with this just needing to be a fun little EP. I think Taylor really wanted to hard pivot from TTPD because it’s so unreflective of how she’s been feeling. Remember her releasing that long Instagram caption at the release of TTPD emphasizing that this stage of the poet’s life is dead and gone, along with happy snippets of her life in the fortnight challenge? Multiple times on this press tour she’s referenced being miserable writing TTPD but that during its release she was as happy as she is now almost 2 years later

Justus 🤍

There are no racist songs. You need to grow up if that’s what your opinions are of her. That’s disgusting. Saying that in general and not to you 😂

Tracy Erin

Zack and Madeline, If either of you can see Max Martin's musical "&Juliet," I'm curious about your feedback on it

Justus 🤍

So what??? If that’s what she wants? She can have whatever she wants. It’s not up to you to say that’s good or not good for her.

Ria

I think regarding the comparison of Taylor’s old vs new pop hits is when I look at TLOAS, Ophelia for example, its a great melodic hook which is all Taylor. But the lyrics are incredibly generic- like there’s nothing that would make me go ‘oh that’s Taylor’ other than the forcing of what she calls ‘Shakespearian’ language into a pop song that just doesn’t work. With blank space, cruel summer etc etc there’s still good writing where as Ophelia is just I was alone and then you saved me. The sentiment, the lack of details means it really could be coming from anyone. There’s no mark of Taylor on it

Aline Tschopp

the this-dude-is-dumb-cause-he-runs-after-a-ball-take is really boring sorry. have anyone ever talked to him? no. saying he cannot read etc. is crazy. Taylor would never choose a stupid man. also its kinda misogynistic, saying he is a bad muse. as if she has no agency over her own songwriting and it‘s all him? huh? with this take YOU are making her a trad wife.

Anja Dott

Honestly, I like So High School more than any of the songs about Travis on this album lyrics wise (TFOO is catchier but I don't like the lyrical content at all, Ophelia is not Rapunzel). At least So High School made a point about his personality; him being funny, making jokes, it's s*xy in a more subtle way. Ok, the high school reference is kind of old but I like some of its writing poetry wise; the part with the "blink of a crinkling eye, I'm sinking, our fingers entwined, cheeks pink in the twinkling lights, .... the brink of a wrinkle in time" has got a nice rhyme scheme going for it. Better writing than all or almost all of showgirl I think

mary

I’m sorry but the idea that she is referencing the race of anyone via gemstones and not just making a dark/night and light/day comparison is just crazy to me 😭

Tracy Erin

I've never been able to work it and am a member for a while. Good luck! I hope someone answers you! 🫶

mary

they usually post a phone a snake link on patreon a few days before the episode; it’s open for 24 hours :)

Katie

Well, it feels not like a grown woman comfortable in her sexuality, more like watching my young cousin fall into love head first fearless and wanna be married the next day, but they can’t tell me why he’s perfect …just that he likes her back and she thought she was cursed.

mage

Women are allowed to dislike other women. Stop couching your dislike for other women and being fake in the name of fake feminism, just say it with your chest. I don’t remember hearing ‘Kendrick is so successful why is he taking the time to diss Drake isn’t he 35’ takes. And that’s interesting. Alexa play ‘The Man’

Anja Dott

Disagree. 1. As the commenter before said the tradwife esthetic is distinct far right Christian white nationalist propaganda. These are people who want to take women's rights away. That's different to individual choice, being a stay at home mom or parent. Which is not inherently problematic, though it can also cause issues like financial dependence on the partner which should be considered in any case. Also, most people and especially women with children don't necessarily have a choice (be it they have to work to secure an income or be it because they have to stay at home to do necessary care work). So the choice argument falls short because it only applies to a narrow group of people. And the tradwife esthetic and propaganda are decidedly anti choice. 2. Regardless of point 1, to everything Taylor Swift does and says, there is the performance aspect to it. She isn't an individual woman making choices in a vacuum, what she does and her lyrical output rubs off on her audience, especially younger girls and women in her audience who look up to her. She doesn't need to be a perfect role model all the time, but it is something to consider at the scale she is operating on. She's not your friendly neighbor telling you being a stay at home mom or wanting kids and a suburban life was the right choice for herself. She curates an esthetic that penetrates the cultural zeitgeist and influences people consciously and subconsciously.

Tracy Erin

I think that. There's a mix and songs like Canceled, Ruin the Friendship, Elizabeth Taylor, and maybe a few others that could have been updated with details and add new Travis songs. The album is very Rep-coded.

Chas

Get her, Anja! 😭

Sarah

i’m gonna need a reaction from BOTH of the head snakes in charge of the voice notes. but behind the paywall because i’ll only allow criticism from our own 🤭

Leslie

I'm a So High School shooter from day one. It's one of my favorite Anthology tracks. I understand what people don't like about it, but I think the melody is so great, I think it's GENUINELY funny, and the "in the blink of a crinkling eye" part is one of her most clever rhyme schemes. It blows every single Showgirl love song out of the water.

Tracy Erin

She looked amazing during that interview!

Sara Macc

Hi! I never jump in but…. I wonder if this light record is what the general public needs to escape this dark crazy time we have been in all of 2025. And maybe a small part of Taylor knew that? Or in her subconscious? In my experience since day 1 (yes original Swifty here) she has always seemed to be there when we need her. Is this no different but instead it’s culturally speaking? Perhaps she is now she is showing up in a way we aren’t used to so it’s polarizing? Selfishly and personally speaking, perhaps we can shift and talk about the stuff that’s great on this album bc you had said you liked 9/12 ha — my nervous system needs some positivity and lightness. Signed, Overwhelmed in Chicago :)

Chas

We’ve definitely lost the plot

Leslie

I find it interesting that this is coming to the surface on the album she wrote during the Eras tour which was in many ways a celebration of girlhood. Why is THAT when this internalized misogyny decided to bubble to the surface? It's interesting.

Leslie

This is an insane interpretation

Moonbeam009

My partner came home yesterday and one of his male friends had apparently asked him, "Has she turned on Taylor Swift now that she's conservative?". I was like, excuse the fuck out of you? I have been avoiding social media for my mental health, so any Taylor commentary I have received has been from the Swiftologist channel. I told my partner that this was bullshit and who is he going to believe, his dumb friend or me? I have listened to the album on repeat all week and have a direct line to the Taylor Swift experts: Zach and Madeline. If there was cause to be concerned that Taylor was suddenly a fascist, I would know. She's just in love and it's NOT anti-feminist for a woman who has already proven herself to be strong, intelligent, cunning, and successful to want to "bed down" and have kids. Wanting to be a wife or have kids is NOT anti-feminist. Feminism is about equality for all genders. It's about respecting women's choices. If she wants to have a driveway with a basketball hoop, she doesn't need anyone's permission to do that. It doesn't make someone conservative to want those things. I do understand the current political climate in the US though, and I do understand the concerns that her vocalizing these things isn't necessarily helping to turn the tides against conservative values. We already know Taylor is myopic and doesn't scroll. She's an out of touch billionaire who makes music. We shouldn't be looking to billionaires to save us from other billionaires. That's my take.

Leslie

Honestly I think she was just pulling out all the stops promo-wise to beat the Adele first week sales record

Kylie L

Something I’ve been cooking on is why this album seems kind of immature - and to a point Zach has been making, why it feels stuck in 2016. I think that between 1) revisiting Rep to try to make a Taylor’s Version, and 2) being in a new relationship, she’s been re-trodding ground from a traumatic time in her life that she’s never really gotten over. When you’re with a new love, so much of getting to know each other is laying bare all of your past wounds, and I bet she was doing a lot of letting Travis into what her life was/has been like since snakegate. I wonder if her psyche while making this album was truly oscillating between being back in that time period and being in the present moment with the joy of loving Travis, and contrasting that all with the triumph/confidence boost she got from Eras. My hope is we get more of her own self-awareness and analysis of this in the future.

Leslie

People point to the sales numbers but when so many of those sales happened before a single note of music was released, it's clearly not a reflection of the quality of the album.

Octomew

I have a theory that a lot of the intense anger to this album are people are sick of seeing seeing rich monsters ruin the world without conciquences. As a entertainer, Taylor FEELS like someone you could potentially hurt or knock down a peg. Her writing tone death songs in a mid album isn't helping though.

Leslie

In one of the interviews she did in the UK she said something like this is the kind of album Travis likes because he's a vibes guy. I think if she had framed it that way from the start -- fun, good vibes, not that serious -- it would have gone a lot better. Trying to sell this as her pop magnum opus was a huge mistake, and one she seems to be trying to walk back in the press tour.

Leslie

Lol me. I keep having "AND ANOTHER THING!!!" moments with this album

Ohdearjon

And she’s so big that people listen no matter what. I think she’s burned a lot of good faith with this album and the next one people won’t be so forthcoming with their money

h

Saying he's a bad muse doesn't take away her agency. It's still her writing it. But it's realistic to acknowledge that she DOES change her whole vibe and aesthetic in line with who she dates and always has. From cosplaying as Jackie O when she was with Connor, to being a pop princess with Harry Styles, to doing Bleachella with Calvin, the soft English poet with Joe, the tortured poet with Matty, and now the label queen using frat bro language with Travis. All of that is her choice and not her boyfriends' fault. But come on, she totally is affected HARD by her muse, always. She even acknowledges this herself in Mirrorball

Casey

He has a podcast. Yes, people have heard him talk at length and can form whatever opinions they want.

Jojobear

.... Huh? She sings about midnights, night Vs day, light vs dark a lot. this is her saying her mum told her "it's alright, you've had a lot of dark times & sleepless nights but you've made your own happiness" (opalite is man made).

kc

i fear that some of these phone calls worrying about taylor being a trad wife misogynist are actually misogynistic 😭😭 some points to be made for sure, especially with all the bitches flying around, but people are doing a lot…

Kb8248

I appreciate your opinion. I disagree. Even though I’m not a huge fan of Eldest daughter, it’s clear from the song she thinks Travis makes her feel like she can reclaim her optimism and a bit of innocence she lost over the years. She said in a recent interview her family and friends think she’s never been more herself since she’s been with Travis.

Sophie Rose

I honestly like this Album. I think there are a lot of subtle “behind the curtain” moments. I liked in the lyric video of wishlist that she is on the phone like when you are a show girl you are away from home a lot and at the end of the night just want to be home with your family and not on the road. I think people just had a different idea of what the look behind the curtain would be. More traditionally show girl themed there is the line on life of a showgirl “pain hidden by the lipstick and lace” What I like about this album is that it has a unique sound. It’s not your basic pop.

Jojobear

Im really sorry you're grieving 🩷

alex

I also really liked the wi$h li$t lyric video for that reason!

Tee say

Most pop starts eventually get married and none of them get called a tradwife. People are just too obsessed

Navya Gupta

on the topic of what song on this album can be loved by the non-swifties, i think opalite is the only one cuz it's a love song love song, it doesn't have the things her biggest hits do but i think if she makes it a single, it has the highest chance of infiltrating the gp

X

"someone should probably have told her to not release this album" ????? 💀💀💀

David Bergee

So I liked Travis independently of Taylor because I’m from Missouri (whole family loves the Chiefs) and genuinely thought he was funny on SNL. I really am getting sick of people acting as though he’s the dumbest man on the planet because he’s a football player from Ohio. Sports aside, the man clearly is a good businessman (New Heights was making him millions before Taylor came along). Working in hospitality has shown me how bad most people are at social intelligence. Being able to talk to everyone and make them feel good is a skill. I would have loved a song that expanded on the brief glimpse we got of Travis’ perspective on the second verse of Opalite. What was so different about Taylor? What were his life experiences growing up that impacted his outlook on love? I liked in his GQ interview how he mentioned his mom was very ambitious in her career. Is that a quality he’s drawn to in Taylor? Like Zack said we know he’s hot and has a nice dick, but what else is there to him? What about when he went to Trader Joe’s after Brazil to get ice cream because those were rough shows for her? There’s so much we don’t know.

Gail

hearing celebrities liking swiftologist taynegativity posts makes me so sad even though I agree with them 😭

Dan

I don’t think Travis has made Taylor more dumb but I think being with him and in his world and him being in her world has made Taylor even more unaware and out of touch, that’s my take. If you’re both money loving attention whores, who’s going to push you to look outside your world and perspective and take those things seriously? When you start living that way 100% you start to excuse things that don’t explicitly hurt or threaten you, and anything that does slightly threaten you you immediately shut it out in the name of “self protection” or “people are just being haters” etc etc and that’s how you get songs like cancelled or wishlist lol

Jojobear

I'm glad other people think this about the lyric video. I feel like that one clip of her on the phone explained the song so much more than her explanation or the lyrics did 😂 it's actually what made it click for me. Plus that clip is gorgeous! should have been one of the many alt covers ha ha.

OneRainyWish_Again

I think Travis is a smart and charming man. I don’t have a problem with him. Taylor’s “love” songs on this record are still lacklustre and weirdly resentful/bitter. It’s not his fault, Taylor is responsible for her own songwriting and it’s okay to critique her songwriting. I’m sad because I know she is so talented and unique and she can do so much better than this album, especially when it comes to love songs. If she doesn’t want to reflect on any details about Travis that’s fine. Her fictional love songs like Mine, Cowboy Like Me, and Speak Now title track are fantastic. Her non-romantic songs like Father Figure and Anti-Hero are fantastic.

Tracy Erin

She does fund friends of the israeli army and other things that kill kids through the well-known and established Universal Music Group pipeline. Taylor and Kendrick could stop that. She seems to not only have no cares, but be disconnected about why people find the 30 different colors of albums released to fuel that pipeline as being problematic.

Erin

Omfg he’s so deliberately obtuse sometimes it PMO so bad 😭

Tracy Erin

It's that she's punching down. Taylor Swift is the most popular musician. Her fan base mobilizes. Was it necessary of her to attack Travis's exes? No. Charli XCX - people are taking that all linds of ways. Many suddenly like Charli. Kendrick AND Drake both made money for themselves and UMG with their feud. Taylor is only making money for herself (and UMG) regarding Travis's exes.

X

omg @zach can you react to max martin's instagram stories??? he's reposting explanations of the meaning behind Fate of Ophelia right now!

Tracy Erin

It has some problematic areas that should have been edited. The attacks that it's racist and has conservative and eugenic dog whistles could have been avoided had someone said let's rethink these particular areas.

Tracy Erin

I just watched the Max Martin musical &Juliet last weekend. You might like its Instagram page. There's some Taylor influence there.

Moonbeam009

I had no idea that Universal Music Group was funding friends of the Israeli army. That's some real shit right there. I would also like to reiterate that we shouldn't rely on billionaires to regulate other billionaires. If she really doesn't care, then it's kind of up to us as the people to boycott UMG and all their artists. Corporations only speak one language: money. We live in a capitalist hell scape and one of the only ways for us as the common folk to have any kind of voice is to choose where we spend our money. Like how we did when they fired Kimmel, ABC took a stock hit and changed their tune. If it was better known to artists and to the general public that this was happening, we would be more informed and therefore better able to mobilize boycotts. Idk, I just feel like we're all so stressed with the rise in fascism. I didn't see any of it in her music myself, so it was kind of upsetting to hear that people were projecting that stuff onto her art. I really do think she's just a selfish billionaire, but I love her, her music, and still respect and look up to her in many ways. She and the other rich people should be publicly condemned for the shit they do.

Leslie

I need a Question/Ruin the Friendship/Chloe or Sam sister songs episode immediately

Kelsey

She did mention in an interview she has more time for more music videos. So I would say probably?

Aline Tschopp

and because they talk about sports in the pod he‘s dumb? form your own conclusion but i know a lot of professional athletes and they are not dumb quite the opposite. just because he‘s not interested in the same things as you or taylor does not mean he‘s stupid🤷🏻‍♀️

Aline Tschopp

its her not him. and we all go through different phases in our life, saying that she cannot write antoher folklore because she‘s with him is such a weird take i heard people make on social media. she does not lose her writing skills just because she‘s with travis. thats what i am trying to say.

Tayswiffer

See Honey could’ve had the same concept and still implemented “showgirl” by mentioning how “honey” has been a term that’s tainted within show business rather than these random normal situations which she can’t relate to anyway

X

thank you for the rec! checking it out now.

Tayswiffer

Fr I am so SICK of this shit, like men can freely criticise and call each other heinous things but I feel like we’ve gotten to a point with “girls supporting girls” where we are willing to ignore toxic (I’m gonna say it) BITCH behaviour because it’s not feminist to have arguments with fellow women? Like 😭 I’d argue Taylor has been more overtly pro woman in her actions than any of the others. She’s been championing the girlies through shout outs in her Instagram, inviting them on stage, doing collabs. Like just because she says bitch a few times on the album doesn’t negate how much she actually does support other female artists irl in ways that many of the “feminist” artists don’t.

Tracy Erin

It's not the fan opinion that I'm relaying. In "Eldest Daughter," Taylor says she isn't a "bad bitch" nor a "savage" when these are racially toned words that Black women have been reclaiming as a source of power. Before Taylor, Travis was rumored to be with Megan the Stallion (I don't know this, it's just from the essays I read from Black content creators). POC being seen as "savage" has led to so much violence. Taylor says she's not this. By saying she's not, people think she's being white supremacist. Avoiding the dog whistles would have been so much easier in the first place. Travis's ex deals with Swiftie grief often, so not referring about her would have been kind. Have any of you read the reviews discussing it? When this many POC tell us to consider something, to not consider it is telling. You can look for yourselves. This is discussed in all places of the internet. People are crucifying Swifties for not acknowledging this.

Tracy Erin

These are my thoughts. I've loved Taylor for so long. I met her when she was little. I wish her no harm. That said, there are many problems and she's not being held accountable nor is the fanbase. Should anyone be held accountable? Depends on who one is or who one asks or who this affects.

reckless mermaid

I was actually getting my tin hat on yesterday pondering if Elizabeth Taylor is a vault track from Reputation that had to be left off because she already had an Elizabeth Taylor reference on Ready for It?

Sarah Munson

My main take on this album: she said "you don't know the life of a showgirl" and I said no I don't, I wanted to learn, but you didn't tell me anything about it.

Sarah Munson

Also, whoever asked if Travis's dick is taking the feminism out of her, that is disgustingly misogynistic.

Kelsea's Comments

Being a feminist doesn't mean being a doormat. It means you see women as equally as deserving of both praise and shade as men because THEY'RE EQUAL. She's allowed to be a feminist and still call out women for being bitches to her.

reckless mermaid

My big concern moving forward is that Taylor WONT hear the criticism and pivot moving forward. I just imagine that she’s in a sort of “don’t listen to those haters, just enjoy the success” echo chamber now because that’s how these super white out of touch crowds run… it’s how they insulate themselves from the affects of their privilege.

Kelsea's Comments

I don't think she comes off as resentful. I think it comes off as she's just sick of everyone's shit and she's done being nice to people who treat her like shit.

Aly

I just am starting to doubt Taylor’s own commitment to self awareness/personal or creative growth without external adversity being the main motivation, be it from romantic conflict, the industry, the public etc. it’s fine to be settled but definitely don’t want endless albums of the same ideas and perspectives over and over

V

Such a good point. I mean if you are a billionaire with power to release in countless ways, and you choose to funnel money into facists doing a genocide against children, you are objectively not against it. That goes for anyone. It’s not just that she doesn’t care, again she has countless options of how to release her album. She does have that much power.

Lucy Anne

i don't think the concern is about the calling out of women but more the language she has chosen to use

Kelsea's Comments

And I'm saying that it's not against the "rules of feminism" to call bitches bitches. Lol. She doesn't owe anyone niceness if they're treating her like garbage.

Andre

While I love the podcast, Zach, and Madeline… I’ve heard Zach refer to women as bitches more than once. Yet here we are lol

Tracy Erin

I think this album is Rep Vault with new songs. Canceled is a song that makes more sense for that Era. I don't see Taylor releasing it as a track to quietly support Blake or whatever. Some of the phrasings on the tracks I suspect are Vaults are specific for that time period.

Kelsea's Comments

Exactly. It's a weird double standard they hold her to. 🤣

Andre

Okay but there’s 11 other albums of self awareness (and lack of it), of great writing, and everything else you could imagine. She made 1 album that debatably doesn’t meet those standards, and the think pieces are going crazy. Sure, debate and ponder all you want, but the “it’s the end of the world, she’s completely changed and there’s no going back” tone is… concerning to say the least. Mind you, I agree it’s a mid album lol

Emily Sawich

Thank you for choosing my voicemail best bday present ever!

Sarah Munson

Being a trad wife is definitely a bad thing. It's by definition giving up all power and agency to let a man be your dictator. But wanting to get married and have kids doesn't mean trad wife.

Anja Dott

I wonder if the whole Matty Healy episode and the parasociality of her fans (which she has invited and profited from, it's a cage of her own making), the backlash bc Matty couldn't be easily incorporated into her brand and image and both break ups lead to her resenting her fans (who are mostly female). We can see this on But daddy I love him and the Prophecy to an extent. Maybe she has a resentment towards women who can have the one thing she seemingly can't have, a normal romantic relationship. Maybe she's romanticizing the life outside of the public eye bc she doesn't really know the hardships a life without all her privileges brings. We have seen her ruminating about what a normal or less public life might have looked like for her in I look in people's windows and midnight rain. But ultimately, with the decision to do the massive Eras tour, she seems to have made her decision to not retrieve into a private life. In a sense, the break up from Joe symbolizes her choice to go for fame and money instead of privacy and a more normal life. And the breakup from Matty (if she played a role in it and the narrative she creates on TTPD isn't entirely accurate) symbolizes her choice to opt for a more brand friendly partner who isn't as unpredictable as Matty in spite of what her heart might tell her at any given moment.

Erika Fern 🌿

Charli XCX announcing a movie today….Taylor’s need to put out Actually Romantic making a lot more sense.

mage

exactly!! and which girl supported Taylor?👂🏽 She got to the top and looked around and said not one of you bitches have shown me kindness or respect so you know what? it’s fuck you too. you all just wanna tear me down and take my place. i’ve seen so many artists take shots at her and curse her variant game while doing it themselves. and she said no more!! (Edit to add of course she has Haley and Selena and we know how hard she rides for them)

Liv

Agreed. I get the concept, but it just doesn’t feel like the best execution of it imo.

Shannon

For the person who said Travis is making Taylor a worse writer: what a bunch of patriarchal BS. You're basically saying that Taylor needs a male muse to be an amazing writer. Sorry, but no.

Rachel Kottkamp

Appreciate your take on Honey. I was trying to figure out why I loved it at the movie theater and keep skipping it at home listening to it. It was an unnecessary use of the word bitch and the clean version with “chick” instead sounds so much cuter and less ick lol so going to just enjoy the clean version now in my playlist vs trying to love that mean line. Overall love the album and can’t stop dancing to it but there are definitely moments like in Honey where you can tell she just lives in a very protected billionaire bubble now and doesn’t interact with the current world/cultural shifts especially now that’s she’s engaged to Travis and they both only have famous friends in their sphere vs when she was with Joe wanting to be a semi-normal person and hanging out with more low profile folks. Interesting stuff

mage

yeah i’m so bored of the hateration. like im having so much fun with this album!

mage

it’s called self care and learning not to be a doormat or the industry punching bag.

Chasity Mcdonald

I don’t mind that people have this take it just really upsets me that it seems to be a lot of white people telling me that I (a black woman) am just not smart enough to see the dog whistle. Like I don’t have decades of lived experience that inform how I hear things myself. I believe that some POCs hear some of the lyrics that way and I respect that, but most of the discourse Im seeing is white women trying to explain racism to me which pisses me off.

Sheena Walker

The thing with them bringing up her saying bitch is she had an issue with Kanye saying it and it started a feud. I’m sure she had an issue with him saying they’d have sex and she owes him because he made her famous. However, the statements she made were essentially about him calling her a bitch.

mage

the same people telling her to be a better feminist are the same people contributing free labor to sexual assault victim smear campaigns. she knows it’s all cap.

Kelsea's Comments

Yes. Because SHE WAS NICE TO HIM. There's a HUGE difference between calling a woman a bitch just because she's a woman and you are using that word to degrade them, and calling a woman a bitch BECAUSE SHE'S BEING A BITCH.

Ria

When the entire varient discourse was going on during TTPD discourse I was defending her bc I really didn’t gaf like buy it or don’t. However her releasing digital releases even in the last 10h of the tracking week when she is already confirmed to have surpassed Adele’s record for highest US sales in a week days ago is truly perplexing like…u got what u wanted. If u want to share these voice memos now then why not just post them

Ria

I’m sorry but if Taylor is going around saying 12 perfect pop songs, most proud she’s ever been, and repeatedly saying it’s a look behind the eras tour and how physically exhausting it was and then the album is NONE of that, you can’t blame swifties for ‘having built up unreasonable standard’. they’re literally just holding her to her word

Hannah

Exactly! Also with TTPD, yes the variants were unnecessary but there were only like 4 main ones no? And then the anthology but I was fine with that because it was an entirely new album. Folklore had at least that many variants as did Midnights. It was never something I was super into but with showgirl it has genuinely reached another level. I think she’s gotten everything she wanted in terms of fame, love, and cultural power and now the only thing left is money and numbers

Kelsey

I think there is also a critique around are you calling an imaginary person bitch or bitches or an actual person. If she called Charli a bitch in actually romantic, that I think is more equal than just Taylor saying bitches. (But I do think it’s fair to spot the weirdness around in some of these lyrics)

Stella

Honestly the fact that people are out there calling Taylor a "tradwife" because she's indicated she might want marriage and children is crazy. Lefties really just want to hand marriage and children to the conservatives now I guess 😬😬 No wonder the American left is losing.

Kelsea's Comments

I mean yes, there's a difference between calling vague characters in a song bitches and calling specific people a bitch. But I still think most of us would have (and shouldn't) have any problem with her calling Charlie a bitch straight out after all the disgusting things Charlie has done to her. Whether they're real people or not, the most important part is that there's a difference between calling a woman a bitch just because she's a woman and calling her a bitch because she's a bitch.

Jasmine

But this is a man calling a woman a bitch which should be outlawed. That’s way different than women calling each other this.

Shannon

Fair enough, which is why I have sympathy for people of that mindset, as I said. But what I'm also saying is, why is that aspect so important? Forget the title of the album and the pictures. The music is joyful and fun. I'm also saying that I couldn't disagree with you more about this not being an album of perfect pop songs. I'm not a huge fan of Cancelled, but this album is the first no skips Taylor record for me. The social media circles I frequent are saying the same thing. So maybe it's just that this album isn't for you, not that it's terrible in everyone's opinion.

Pia Fleig

I actually enjoy the album, but I’m equal parts happy and annoyed about the promo tour. I love getting interviews from her again, but this isn’t so much an album promotion as it’s a Travis my Savior tour where I get to learn a lot about him including the size of different body parts.

Nitzan

HR lady at my job today said she liked Fortnight. Lead singles are for the locals and should be treated as such

OneRainyWish_Again

Please dive deeper into analyzing the bitter, resentful undercurrent of this record. It really intrigues me and I just can’t stop hearing it whenever I listen to the songs. I do like the album, but I can’t deal with all the people online saying it’s her happy, loved-up record. That’s a very interesting topic for discussion and analysis imo

sophie

Just wanted to throw out there: the reason why the discourse on this album is so insane is also that conservatives in the US currently control like all social media platforms, and they like nothing more than ragebait engagement which creates likes/ad revenue. It’s never been this bad, and that plus AI/botting is just compounding the issue. You actively have to seek out normal opinions like your podcast, otherwise your feed is just AI slop and things that will generate feelings of rage in people, which increases engagement/gets these platforms more money. All that to say: thank you for being normal and please keep it up!!! You have hundreds of us who appreciate your level-headedness.

Pauline Chatelan

Why is it evil to like your reaction video to Wood? It’s very entertaining and relatable… it’s not evil to post it, why is it evil to enjoy watching it?

Abby

Yes everyone has insane takes but Taylor wants that. She doesn’t want to only be in the swiftie ears she wants world domination

Justus 🤍

Literally liberals have been making this horrible too. It’s been both sides. Liberals are calling her racist and maga, and homophobic. And the right just attacks her because orange man said he doesn’t like her lol

Leslie

I agree! This is THE takeaway from this album for me, the thing that's going to keep me returning to it and ruminating on it despite not liking the actual music that much. It's very interesting and I don't know what to make of it. We need to open the case!

Catiana Keys

I'm wondering if "Ruin the Friendship" is about a friend who passed about more than a decade ago, then why is it on an album marketed as the BTS of the Eras Tour moments? Am I missing something?

Leslie

Well she did say "and you're never ever gonna"

Jojobear

I told my friend who can get quite angry about hate comments, to just remind yourself theres a high chance that this is two bots arguing with each other. When you think of it this way (even if it's not), it makes it seem so ridiculous &you stop engaging.

Nefelibata

Thank you that is very sweet

Jojobear

I've also seen clips of him & his brother talking about how they were raised to know both parents were equal in their roles at work & at home... the way he spoke was sincere & thoughtful. he also seems to give a lot back into STEM & sports programs for kids. I also noticed something really small but to me was significant during the podcast, she was making fun of herself not knowing the rules of football & instead of joining in & making fun he said "it's the way kids would have played it in the yard growing up, that's what you know". I thought it showed emotional intelligence for him to acknowledge she didn't know his world & that's okay. I'd love so more of that in the love songs because, I know after dating not nice narcissistic guys, it's so good when you meet the right one

sophie

That’s fair! But I’m not both sides-ing fully when one party controls everything about American life right now and is most benefiting from the division.

sophie

Seconded! I feel like this happens often with her (i.e. her marketing Rep as a vengeance album when it was mostly an I <3 my boyfriend fest), but it’s more extreme here. Like girl, if you’re so happy, why do you have so many grievances to air about all the bitches in your life?? Why do you care?

James

The guy talking about ruin the friendship is actually insane. She's talking about making the shots you don't take and also thinking about if she had gotten into a relationship he might still be around.

Sheridan S

Someone somewhere said she wrote him one last song before getting married and that's a nice thought even if it's not true

reckless mermaid

I think Zach’s having mixed feelings about contributing to the mainstream dogpiling on this album. On the one hand it was a genuine take that people enjoy and resonate with, but since it’s breached the perimeter it’s getting weird attention from nothing knowers with no perspective

reckless mermaid

That’s what I’ve been saying🤣🤣😅

Sam

The problem with making the argument “but it’s about the LIFE of a showgirl” is that the problem isn’t with the life part.. it’s with the showgirl part. It was marketed through visuals and by her saying it that the album would be about how being a showgirl/The Eras Tour affected her life offstage. But it could have been called “Life from 2023-2024” it would have been the same songs 🤷🏼‍♀️

Elise Cooper

This album doesn't feel like a good body of work which is so unlike Taylor. I have always felt her albums are best heard as a whole instead of individual songs. TLOAS has some great songs but eh as an album. It doesn't help that this album was marketed and visualised in such a specific showgirl way and that's not how the songs sound.

Chasity Mcdonald

Ok so this might not make sense, but I feel like I want to say this somewhere. a lot of the people trying to raise the conversation of race in these lyrics maybe started from a place of good faith, but more and more it just seems like fake activism. Like okay I get it you aren’t racist congrats. I think people need to remember that some of us have been on the receiving end of overtly and covertly racist comments our whole life and we don’t need white women “allies” to find it for us. I saw a reel today that was a white woman earnestly saying that “All my white diamonds and lovers are forever” was Taylor saying she will never ever date a POC. Like guys be serious who is that helping?

Chasity Mcdonald

Also sorry for the wall of text I just feel crazy

Elise Cooper

Women are totally allowed to dislike other women, I just think it's a little hypocritical to publicly express your distain for being called "that bitch" in a song and then go use the term in quite a nasty way in your own song. There is no reason she needed to say "and the bitch was telling me to back off".

Elise Cooper

Why does the girl need to be called a bitch tho?? Does the lyrics not work the same if she says "and the chick was telling me to back off" like Taylor sings in the clean version??

Elise Cooper

Could've been in my top 3 tracks for this album but I just shake the undertone

Deedles

I might be in the minority here, but I disagree with your take on Ophelia. It hit me straight away. I lost my damn mind lol.

Erin

THIIIIISSSSSS THANK YOU

Erin

I remember listening to songs like Afterglow on Lover when it FIRST came out and being like “Wait, this is her feeling super happy and secure?” And I was tarred and feathered for it on Twitter 😭

Rachel

I saw it as part thinking about her normal life before seeking stardom, and part a veiled reflection on her attitude regarding Matty. (I also see the song as face-value). She already has a regret about not pursuing a relationship. It makes her mindset with seeking out Matty make even more sense, and adds another layer to it. She already wondered once and regrets it, so she doesn't want to wonder again. In TLOAS release "movie," she says before the song something like "sometimes you just have to answer the question." ...Question? :O

Rachel

I also found the frequent use of the word "bitch" interesting, especially in light of 2016... not that this excuses it, but I've always felt like Taylor was actually more upset about the "we might still have sex" line, but because she had approved the lyric, she couldn't bring that up. In the recording of the phone call, she sounds kind of uncomfortable, and I bet in the moment she was so surprised, she didn't really know what to do and just agreed with it. Only with some distance did she realize how messed up it was. I know I've been in that situation before.

Katie

I toooootally agree

Katie

NOT SAYING they are going to break up EVER but the undercurrent of resentment with this album is similar to the undercurrent of anxiety in Lover 1.0. Just something I’ll be keeping my eye on

Kat

She seems comfortable with herself and owning her power, which she previously had to hide and dim in other relationships. I think this album is her feeling like she has unconditional love, not a love album. If someone was a bitch to her, why can’t she say that? If that phrasing misses the mark for you, just listen to the clean version. It doesn’t mean Taylor has a bitter undertone. The thing is, we have to leave room for complex emotion and experiences. Tons of women are navigating corporate America, and the expectations for women in power are still different. We have preferred behavior for women that is more nuanced and subjective. I think our instinct to try and control women is engrained in our society. When can women earn the right to be less perfect? Most career women I know understand the impact of these standards and the frustration of not being able to exert the power you’ve earned. We don’t want permission to act like men, just to share the playing field. And our reactions to women prevent that. The undertones in these criticisms reveal a lot about our sphere of tolerance for powerful women. Don’t care if ppl like the songs, but women don’t always have to be palatable. Women have less flattering experiences and opinions too- why does one of the most powerful women have to hide that?

Elle

lol I feel the same about the album- I don’t hate it-it’s got some happy bops but it’s not my favorite or really my thing which is ok! I get the feeling Taylor just wasn’t that serious or diving that deep into her feelings/inner world when she wrote most of these songs which is her journey and makes most of them just light fun. I think she struggled to write a track 5 in this kind of headspace. As an eldest daughter (some might call me an elder of the eldest as I’m the oldest grandchild on both sides)-I get it but I barely related to the message of the song as it’s so broken up. The internet-bad bitches-Sheep-The trampoline from Robin makes an appearance… ferris wheels-flowers-timelapse-bad bitches again-it feels like a spew of metaphors or very fast running thoughts in her head. I think she was trying to make a song that shifted so fast into different imagery it felt exactly like scrolling on your phone. That’s how I feel with this song-which is why I can’t get very emotionally invested in its message. It’s doom-scroll the musical which is actually a pretty cool concept I just don’t know if it was executed well. I respect the song and cool if you really relate to it- I’m just still here scratching my head but in a good way! I like dissecting art! That’s why we are here!

X

i think the use of b*tch was an intentional callback to the 2016 kanye drama, now that taylor can articulate the nuance better.

X

i feel like comparing the writing sprawl of TTPD, which didn't even try to be a pop album, to TLOAS is missing the point so hard. if TTPD had been aspiring to be a pop album, it would be objectively very badly written.

Rachel Kottkamp

Thanks for sharing! Can’t believe they construed the white diamonds line like that

Chasity Mcdonald

I’m sorry I just disagree that just because some people have declared that something is racist that we all have to accept that it is overtly racist. You can’t call it a dog whistle and overtly racist those are literally two different things.

Sheridan S

You know... there are a lot of people in the fandom who haven't touched grass in the last week and that is abundantly clear, meanwhile Taylor is on talk shows talking about how this is the best album rollout week she's ever had while down here in the trenches it is an absolute hellscape and I just think... there's nothing more TLOAS about that 😂🧡

mary

Did you use AI to write this? Savage is a bigoted term historically used against indigenous people, particularly in the Americas, by European settlers. It’s not just “not the fan opinion”; it’s not the opinion of anyone mentally sound.

mary

Can you explain to me why Taylor would intentionally put white supremacist dogwhistles in her music and thus fully alienate the MAJORITY of listeners?

Emily

Please explain more!!

Shondi

I’m confused by this. So, I myself am a stay at home mother to my three young children. I have put my career on hold to be home to raise them instead of sending them off to an expensive daycare to be raised by strangers. I take care of the kids and the home and my husband works and pays all the bills. Does that make me a “tradwife”…? And if so, then how is this lifestyle bad? We are doing what we believe is best for our family. And if Taylor wants to shift her focus towards being a wife and mother after spending so many years grinding and hustling, then isn’t that her right? Please explain?

Miss_Lippy

I truly do not understand some of these takes 😫 I could care less if she says “bitches” in a song bc she’s a grown up, there actually ARE feminist messages woven into this album, & it just feels like a nit picky thing to focus on tbh. It’s certainly not the same as a grown man calling a young woman a “bitch” on a song designed to further humiliate her, *after* already humiliating her in front of the whole world as a 32 yr old man who stole a microphone on stage from a 19 yr old girl. Oh and let’s not forget he also made Taylor nude in the mv 🙃 So why on earth are we comparing *that* to a woman talking about another grown woman who maybe told her she hoped she dies or pmo (er, pho)? It just feels like some people are really going out of their way to arrive at these shitty takes with this album & I honestly think TikTok has eaten everyone’s brains. People are attributing things to some of these songs that just aren’t even there too. “Honey” is not an angry anti-feminist song about being mad at women ffs. If you’re a millennial woman closer to Taylor’s age & the stage of life she is rn then I guess you’re inherently “cringe” but maybe you’re also better suited for understanding what she is actually saying? Maybe it’s why some of us know exactly what she is talking about when she talks about being called “honey” or “sweetie” in a diminutive or antagonistic way. The verses are full of moments where Taylor felt scrutinized or humiliated (in bars, bathrooms, gossip circles, being body shamed, harshly criticized, etc). and over time she had come to associate those pet names with these painful moments and feelings. Taylor’s telling us how sweetness has been used against her- yes, maybe it’s by a jealous woman “(Ooooh! 🔪😤 Get her!”) but also maybe it’s by a dismissive chauvinist man, or a fake friend who betrays you, or your rat bf who is too high to even remember wtf is going on from one day to the next, let alone what you were wearing the night before. It seems to me that “Honey” is about how when someone gives you real, authentic love and makes you feel safe and comfortable, it’s powerful enough to even change the meaning of language for you. The choruses show us that softer, more intimate, and secure side and she’s saying how when he calls her "Honey” it’s not diminutive or condescending, instead it’s sweet and affirming. “You touch my face, redefine all of those blues." makes it sound like she is describing reprogramming her nervous system after years of being mocked, objectified, and analyzed and now she gets to allow herself to trust and be loved without any underlying cruelty. I see it as her reclaiming that tenderness as power.

Eva

I feel like in the past Taylor often tried to write songs that would impress her snobby boyfriends/exes. („Indie record thats much cooler than mine.“) Or she wanted to impress the industry or the haters who said she isn’t highbrow or whatever. But now she doesn’t have to impress anyone anymore, she doesn’t have to come across as refined. She knows Travis will love anything she puts out and even more that he will love it when the lyrics are corny, raunchy, simple, contain lots of swear words, etc. cause that’s kinda his vibe. I think that’s why the quality of the writing is so low compared to her other albums.

Katie

I’ve been wondering if the regret in Ruin The Friendship is also TS thinking about ways her friend could have been saved from his ultimate decision. If her kiss could have saved him the way that Travis saved her from being deep in tortured poet darkness.

Zack Currie

Let's talk eldest daughter becUas I think people are hating but not listening; I think it's her saying she's spent her whole life under this masquerade of desperately trying to seem cool and be something that she's fundamentally not. She's not cool; she's not a "bad bitch/savage" a la Ariana grande. She's not Kim Kardashian effortless inflience. She's not brat. And it was killing her trying to act like that. And while it may be cringe to say it, what she is is a hopeless romantic and what she offers is that cringe, millenial, unapplogic love and devotion. The laughing fits and being silly where she completely lets her guard down, and now that she's with Travis she's saying she can take off that mask she put up to hide her true self in the exploration for cool. Which is actually kind of a very sincere thing to write about

Jojobear

Coin doom scroll the musical right now

Hannah

She’s not reading classics anymore as she isn’t bored out of her mind and catering to an elitist partner …

Becky

Wood will be the most popular song at weddings for women in their 50s to drunkenly dance to by 2028

jordan

I think it’s such a cheap shot to act like Travis has made Taylor dumb because you (not you guys specifically, just in general) don’t like the FIRST full album with him as the muse. Are some songs/lyrics questionable? well yeah that’s not news, but it feels more like poor execution rather than Travis sucked the braincells from her head. Now….if TS13 follows this same pattern, then I think it would be constructive to question it. I know it’s hard to not be reactive when she releases a new album, and I’m guilty of it too, but everyone needs to take a deep breath.

Katie

It just adds a (subconscious?) darker edge to the lovey albums that makes them more interesting and revealing of the dynamic imo! “I don’t want to lose you” in Cornelia street tracks all the way through into peace and you’re losing me. So might be interesting to follow the “fuck everyone except for us” thread!

Katie

😭

Chryssa

please review the tloasg merch that just dropped!!

Katie

Exactly but I think she IS trying to impress Travis and that’s why she’s adopted his lingo and humour

Caitlin Krasin

I haven’t heard one person say anything bad about either of those songs

Ava Lindseth

Colleen Ballinger LIKE LMFAO. Madeleine I am like you, listened to cancelled once and never again HAHA

mouse

it's not that travis is causing her to dumb herself down, but romantic love teaches you something about your wounds when it ends, and some crusty ass dude ALWAYS comes in just as she's about to really learn and integrate them lmao. from 1989 to rep to lover to the pro-ratty parts of ttpd - they keep interrupting her development as a human being/as a writer and it's starting to really show. eldest daughter is the only self-reflective, intimate moment on the record, and even THAT moment only exists to connect back to him. girl.

mouse

i actually agree about the awful cringe being on purpose and tbh i think the chorus is mostly endearing, but, my god, the second verse and pre are an absolute mess.

Yara

Actually romantic is the most annoying song she could write, every single comment even if it’s respectful and is only constructive the comments are full “oh that’s actually romantic” in the most snarky way possible 🫩 it’s always going to be like this going forward, isn’t it?

Lizel

I turned 50 this year and this comment makes me sad. What are my peers doing at weddings 🫣? Personally, I don't drink, I don't dance (in public) and Wood is not my favourite song on this album at all. I do love CANCELLED! and The Fate of Ophelia and Elizabeth Taylor and the title track.

Tayswiffer

No bc this is so true!!! I’ve BEEN saying it since her break up with Calvin. I don’t think it’s normal how she just hops from one to the next and then declares the next one to be the one she ACTUALLY wanted. She did that with Joe, then with Ratty, and now with Travis. So which one is it girl? She physically cannot be without a man for longer than a few months and that’s definitely a trauma response. This might come across as slut shaming but as a fan I really worry about her position as a self-actualised human being. The Travis world tour at the moment seems to me a bid to overcompensate for how lonely she might actually be. Her songs have been worrying for a long time and I don’t think we can blame Joe for all of it…..

Tayswiffer

Oh come on, how is that even a comparison? Context matters. He was using it to mock their power imbalance and attribute her fame to his humiliation of her. She’s just making an off the cuff comment (that literally anybody in normal life has 100% done) about how some lady was getting mad at HER because her man was looking at her sideways.

Tayswiffer

Mind you, being bored out of her mind and reading good literature catalysed her to produce some of the best pieces of work she’s ever put out so this isn’t the insult that you think it is lmao

mouse

i don't think the way she dates is particularly WORRYING but the way she clings to that arc as a writer definitely limits her. to your point about loneliness - i thought she was finally beginning to accept loneliness, and really the idea that you can't have it all on the prophecy. it would've been sooo intriguing to see her wrestle with basically leaving her thesis as an artist behind and asking questions like "why tf can't anyone just meet me up here? why is romantic love even this important to me? and why has it been so important for me to be at the tippy top of the tower? now that i'm here, do i regret any of it?" she'd have such a unique and frankly profound pov on all of that. i just hope she's still making music by the time she gets there and that i'll still care lol. we're gonna be waiting til album 20...but when it comes!!!!

Kat

What’s wrong with that? Internet hate has reached such an extreme, and people seem to be truly obsessed with the people/creators/celebs they hate these days. This song is commentary on where we are as a society. What if ppl started quoting this song as a response, not just to Taylor? Doesn’t mean it’s the only response, but it matches the moment we’re in online pretty darn well.

Yara

Oh 100%, they’re trashing her for made up things that no one asked them to even look into. But there’s no constructive criticism about her art anymore. There’s too much toxicity in the fandom. If anyone makes any comment at all everyone just lashes out, she’s even mentioned sometimes she just can’t do it. Remember when she asked people to chill about John Mayer and people were literally saying “I don’t care what she tells me I’m still going after him”. It’s insanity. People that have been here since day one are getting chewed out by people that weren’t even born when debut was released 🫩

Yara

So you don’t think that Zack and Madeline should provide constructive criticism because it’s just hate? There comment section should be filled with “that’s actually romantic”. Seems mature.

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

This isn't a fair comparison. Actually Romantic is clearly a response to someone who's obsessively rude and jealous. That's not constructive criticism. I think people using Actually, Romantic as a response to immature targeting/hate is a great thing!

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

This is really getting into slut shaming, parasocial territory. Let's not forget that Lover, one of her most "in love" albums, was made over a year into her relationship with Joe. She goes through very normal cycles of falling in and out of love. I'd hope that every person everyone is with, they believe is "the one". That's a normal part of being in love. To imply she has some sort of psychological condition because she wants to marry a guy she'd have been dating for years is absurd.

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

This is exactly what I think, too! I actually really want to write about how the "indie" crowd, specifically, clings to false activism towards Taylor, and how it's almost always a mask for misogyny

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

I'd love to see a more in-depth commentary on her use of the word "bitch", but from what I'm hearing, I really dislike the narrative that something is soo bad because it's not 'We're all best friends!' in reference to other women. The lyrics in Honey is NOT "the bitch looked at me wrong" it was "the bitch at the bar, mad at me because HER MAN looked at me wrong" and I believe it's more of a commentary on a misogynistic woman. There is a conversation being had about the use of "bitch" towards women, particularly by men, as almost a slur, but I don't personally see any of that here. Taylor being hated on by other women is nothing new, and I think she's truly just calling it out from her perspective in the song. Like what's with the sudden "girl power!" response to Honey? I thought we agreed that it's moreso "girl, so confusing"

Becky

I just think within 3 years it will be a song embraced by women that were bumping WAP in the school pickup line in 2020. Even Taylor is closer to 50 than to 20.

OneRainyWish_Again

My issue with “Honey” and that term is that she’s shoehorning this hostile sentiment into a love song that’s trying to be sweet. It’s as if she were trying to smash “Better than Revenge” into “Sparks Fly” or “Ours”. Or “LWYMMD” into “invisible string”. It’s ineffective songwriting and takes all the romance and sweetness away from the chorus; the narrator has most of her energy and interest invested in aggression from/towards other women, then pretends to be happy and in love for two seconds, then goes back to seething. The narrator of the song and of the album keeps insisting she’s happy and in love but cannot enjoy it, and also can’t muster the enthusiasm to describe or explore love very much. If that’s the case, then write “girl so confusing” songs and explore female relationships and negative emotions, great, but don’t try to forcefully jam that into a love song. It’s just not fun or interesting or inspiring or beautiful or good to listen to … Of course all art is subjective and et cetera, at least on this level of discussion I’m using the term “the narrator” to try to divorce the song from anyone’s positive or negative associations with Travis 😅 and explain why imo the song is a disappointing failure even when evaluated on its own merits. I’m really criticising Taylor as a songwriter, not pushing some restrictive morals on her. She’s so talented and has such a unique writer’s voice, she can do so much better than this

OneRainyWish_Again

Your analysis and defence of the song is more heartfelt and emotionally resonant than the song itself honestly. I understand the idea Taylor was trying to get across, but to me it feels (I said this in some other comment lol) as if she is trying to cram “better than revenge” into “sparks fly” or “mine” (except way less beautiful and fun than any of those). Or like she’s trying to cram “thank you Aimee” and “smallest man” into “you are in love” while insisting she’s so happy and everything is so wonderful... I don’t mind if she writes songs that explore negative emotions, including towards other women, but this is just bad songwriting imo

Miss_Lippy

I wholeheartedly disagree. This song has none of the vitriol of “smallest man” or “better than revenge” etc. and I have no idea where you are getting that. Maybe the song didn’t feel heartfelt and emotionally resonant for you but it was for me & everything I covered in my prior comment is pretty clearly laid out in the song. Imo, if you’re really listening to it, it’s all there. And she is not coming from an angry or bitter place like those songs you mentioned. She is talking about times that she felt harshly criticized, demeaned or humiliated.

TookeyTookey

I just watched the best reaction to this album by YouTube channel called Switched on pop . I really implore people to go watch it. If you loved this album there is a lot of there in defence of it. To help you defend it. And if you were disappointed in it or did not think it was showgirl… listen to them explain how it is…

Jojobear

this is a great conversation & I think your non reactive and respectful response is a great example of critical thinking, so I feel comfortable responding with my take,so firstly thank you! Addressing Taylor the songwriter is so important because, even though we can often feel like we're reading her diary ( I mean teh roll out of lover she literally sold her diaries), songwriting is often dramatised so beyond reality. My take on Honey is, she's giving the reasons she was 'sour' before. The 'bitch' in the bar, the girl who told her she looked like shit & made her cry, the guy who called her while high & made her feel used the next day. these things made her feel sour, this new person makes her feel sweet. I totally see your take as well though & I really enjoyed reading it. I think this is why thoughtful discussion on Taylor the songwriter is important. but I think Taylor the songwriter and Taylor the billionaire are becoming more and more difficult to seperate for a lot of people, particularly in the world we are in today. Anyway, thanks again to you and OP 😊

Caves🫰🏻

You should react to Switched On Pop on YouTube,they breaking down Taylor’s album in more of engineering stuff/melody,I think it’s gonna help you to understand more all the songs and answers your questions about “what’s showgirl about this” https://youtu.be/rUM3iMp7IFE?si=JZk0n3WQRBixF3P4

Stephi

I'm wondering if relatability is easier to achieve on the more painful / negative spectrum of emotions, especially given the massive wealth disparity. It's easier to relate to a heartbroken billionaire than a freshly engaged, supremely happy one. It's easier to nurture a parasocial fan relationship when you're out there "slaying dragons" with eachother. It's hard enough to be friends with a newly engaged, elated friend when you are miserable. Now imagine that friends is also a billionaire, living in a different stratosphere. So long as Taylor was in and out of shitty relationships, at least her life was lacking in that very universal sense. I don't think that Taylor doesn't care about the fan base anymore. But the fan base is now harder to distinguish from the general public, post-Eras Tour. While I'm thrilled for Taylor to finally be in a solid, supportive relationship, I'm also not interested in the Tayvis brand becoming a thing.

Sasha

I wonder if Taylor Swift has exhausted the limits of diaristic storytelling...not because her emotions or experiences are finite, but because the form she built to express them has begun to collapse in on itself. After years of training her audience to decode her private life through lyrics, every new line now arrives pre-interpreted. What once landed as raw confession no longer carries the same weight, because she’s performing *feeling* itself. To me, that is the conceit of The Life of a Showgirl. It takes artifice as its subject, with flashes of brilliance when she momentarily peeks out from under the feathers. The awkward lyrics and sense of distance aren’t just lapses in form (though there are a few truly indefensible lyrics 💀); they reveal what honesty sounds like after it’s been commodified for two decades. I think the album asks what it feels like to live inside your own mythology when self-expression, performance, and survival have fused. Maybe her final act will be to disappear under the stage and reinvent herself, and the form, entirely.

Rachel

I don't like the use of the word either, but isn't "Honey" meant to portray duality? Like "this was a bad situation in the past" and "this is the good situation now."

Kris Knutson

I agree. There’s also a gender element to this. People are okay with a successful woman when she’s miserable. They’re not interested in/are quite angry with a successful woman who’s happy.

Kris Knutson

I also don’t love the use of the word “bitch,” but given the context of the lines, why is she calling the first woman a bitch? Because the other woman is upset with Taylor because her boyfriend looked at Taylor? Why isn’t she upset with her boyfriend? When Dolly Parton finds herself in a similar situation she pleads with Jolene to not take her man. When Taylor is out and about, minding her own business, other women call her out and make her the enemy for their partners’ actions. So, while calling the other woman a “bitch” isn’t really pro-woman, blaming a woman for a man’s wandering eye is also not pro-woman.

Kris Knutson

You’re welcome to not like Actually Romantic. Anyone’s welcome to not like any song. I don’t know that I have any strong feelings about it one way or another, but I don’t think “she’s such a boring Barbie,” “I’m glad her boyfriend ghosted her,” and “she’s tacky” are constructive criticism. They’re just mean.

Miss_Lippy

Thoroughly enjoyed this! Thanks for sharing. I’ve noticed how basically every musician seems to respond positively to this album, despite what TikTokers might have us believe

Mateao

Someone help, is father figure about Olivia?? I’ve heard things and can’t imagine why. Like i know the public comparison but didn’t she give her the ring? The way I see it taylor has enemies and liked colleagues and I thought Olivia was one of the colleagues.

S B

Something hasnt been able to leave my mind ... Taylor repeatedly talks negatively about her fans? In BDILH and now in wish list for the world to leave them the f alone ... But who's buying all the CDs and vinyls she's putting out?? Her insane fans! It's hard for me to feel special as part of the fandom when she talks more negatively about us than positively. Idk

Meghan Sullivan

Yes Emily and harry were seen kissing in Japan iirc