Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

We are about 49 days away from the Tortured Poets Department being released and as you all MAY know or remember from past releases or my past posts....most of the time with a new record, as soon as I get the tracklist, I pick the order in which I will be listening to the songs on my first listen. I literally rearrange the tracklist for my first listen based on a stupid system that I make up for no reason other than I'm deranged. I didn't do this for Folklore or Evermore because I didn't have time obviously, and I also didn't do it for Midnights because of....I'm not sure why actually LMFAOOO, but I HAVE however been doing it for the TV's. 

Some of you may be wondering what order I plan on listening to the tracklist for this release as well....well to tell you the truth, I actually intend to listen to it in order even though having to wait that long to hear what exactly "loml" is going to sound like is going to be torture to me, and it's because I have a crackpot theory that the tracklist tells a story and is chronological. This is based on two factors :

1.) Delusion

2.) The titles SOUND like they're chronological, with Fortnight and the title track kicking it off. Fortnight will set the scene and the title track will describe what the Tortured Poets Department even is and WHAT the album is going to be discussing. Then, My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys, Down Bad, and So Long London all being about the end of her relationship with Joe (I made this up but it sounds real to me). 

Then, But Daddy I Love Him, Fresh Out The Slammer, Florida!!!, Guilty As Sin?, Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?, and I Can Fix Him being about the immediate post break-up chaos and dating Matty Healy. This would be a period of time where she's trying to put a band-aid on the problem, act like she isn't screaming inside and dealing with the termination of her relationship, trying to pretend like she's doing fine, throwing herself into a new chaotic romance and her work to avoid facing her own problems. 

Into part three, which I believe will be the "dust settling" portion of the record - Loml, I Can Do It With A Broken Heart, The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived, and The Alchemy. This is the part of the record where she will finally accept and realize her and Joe, her longest relationship ever, is really over, she has no distraction like Matty to keep her from feeling her true feelings about it, and all she has to pour all her energy into is her tour (I Can Do It With A Broken Heart will sureelyyy be about that realization.) 

Clara Bow I think will just be a commentary on her place in pop culture and her career and how people see her at this particular moment in time, maybe even just a reflection on how she BECAME this Clara Bow type figure to people - it's really the only way I can make sense of that kind of a song being the closing track. I think she will use Clara Bow to describe herself and relate to her. I do not think there will be any songs about Travis on this record, to tell you the truth. 

The bonus tracks.........I HAVE NO IDEA they definitely won't fit into any chronological order because they're not even on the official tracklist really if you think about it, so those are on their own. But THAT is my true theory, and when you think about the track titles it does make sense, based on my doll house characters and etc etc...and THAT is why I will be listening to the album in the order provided, because I believe it is as GOD INTENDED IT!!! It would be THRILLING to have a tracklist of hers be chronological and tell a story like that, considering how choatic a lot of her tracklist choices have been in the past. 

Honestly, I am so attached to this personal theory of mine that I'll be literally gagged and shocked if it isn't true 🥺 but what do you guys think about my theory??? Do you have any of your own theories about the tracklist??? 

Comments

Forty2times

To be fair, Taylors tracklists are usually equally delusional and unhinged so you're just matching energy 😆

chappell roan

i want to believe this theory, but it’s going to be the opposite of what we believe. she’s frickin psychotic. that’s all i know. have lots of fun at the eras tour zack!!! ur shoes were so cute in the video i wish i could see them in action, Fearless was my fav.

Rachel Bullock

I approve of this theory 🫶 Vibes are on point. I have no personal theories. I have not one original thought.

thalia

i also believe in the chronological theory like ever since i saw someone say it, it just stuck so now i cant think of it any other way lmao. but alas i fear the chaos

April

Your theory makes the most sense but knowing Taylor she just can’t and won’t let things make that much sense track order wise. It’s always gotta be wild and non sensical somehow. I’m seated and I need the album right NEO

Ash

I relate to 1) feeling convinced it's chronological and 2) feeling super attached to my own theory! I actually never got into theorizing before and just like to wait and be surprised. But this time, maybe it's because I'm in this community now, I'm not sure, but I am not only theorizing this time around, I am also OBSESSED with my theory! 😂 I'm the unhinged girlie with the 4 different institutions / case files theory from the TTPD event last week, where I think each bonus track pairs with a side of the record and represents a different institution. I can't unsee it, and I can't wait to find out if I'm the biggest 🤡 ever or was onto something. 😂 Seated either way! Counting down either way! Thanks for hosting such a great space to be an unhinged nerd. Idk how I went so long being an offline Swiftie with like 1 or 2 IRL friends to talk about her with. 🥲

KCK

How’s the weather in D Bay and are the sunsets Flamingo Pink??? The track list does have a strong chron feel so I agree w that but the problem is 2 timelines: the events being discussed and the songwriting time of reflection. So that is what could lead to things that happened “before” being reflected on later in the sequence, if u know what I mean?

blake

well yes!

T

Theory feels supported. I feel pretty confident there will be matty healy content. At least 1 song

Tyler

I got a terrible feeling yesterday that I haven’t been able to shake that it’s going to be an entire record of songs that sound kinda like afterglow (obviously different lyrical content) and that would just bore me to tears and I truly with all my heart that we get a top 3 Taylor record and not a mid one or bottom tier one

Swiftologist

LMFAOOO THAT THEORY WAS TOOO MUCH FUN TO READ

emma 🌷

49 days feels so far awayyy

Gianna

I need this chronological thing to be true so bad! I highly doubt it’ll be that way but TO ME it needs to happen this way.

Megan

Hoping and praying that your theory is right. It also struck me that songs feel paired together (fresh out the slammer and Florida!!! as an example) so even if the entire album isn’t chronological at least we might get a few two-three track runs where it FEELS chronological, even if for just a moment

Teresa

I am with this theory, except I hope Alchemy & Clara Bow are post Travis. lol

Ash

Ahahaha im glad you enjoyed. It was my first time submitting anything really and I was hoping it wasn't tooooo mentally ill 🤣

Taralynn

I am 100% attached to this theory as well. If it does not come to pass well... I guess I'll just kms. But anyway please film your reaction to at least your most anticipated song bc I think it would be the absolute gem of the century if you did.

Liz

this made me lol, why afterglow??

Yasmin

It definitely seem fair that's for sure!

Mary Elizabeth

I agree with this theory! Also, this is my theory on The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived: I think Taylor will be reflecting on Joe's fragile ego in hindsight, which is why it's so late in the tracklist. She may have gained this perspective through personal reflection and/or through her relationships with Matty and Travis. Both Matty and Travis were/are proud to be seen with Taylor, and it seems like Joe wanted to avoid being seen with Taylor by any means possible.

Julie

I am seated for this theory, but something I don’t get is that But Daddy I Love Him is after So Long, London. To me that sounds like a song that should come before the final goodbye and when her dad says baby girl pack up the damn carriage and then in So Long, London she’s like okay you’re right that’s it goodbye. Then Down Bad could come after where she’s obviously still a little ‘down bad’ but it follows with a bop and mess of Matty. Idk those are just my thoughts, but I really do hope it’s chronological!

Allie Olives

So Long London is a slow paced jazzy song and there will be lyrical parallels to London Boy

Kate!!!

ohhh i like this theory!! the first half of the track list definitely feels joe-centric. i’ve heard some people say they think down bad could be about travis but i think down bad is going to be the dissolution of joe and taylor and the devolution of meaning of “down bad” from being down bad in love to down and bad as terms of loss. i can fix him (no really i can) could be about her tendency to go for broken artist bro types and could be about both joe and matty. i think that’ll be a banger for sure and maybe even a single? i think the alchemy might be the only travis song if there is one? i think the smallest man who ever lived could def be a reflection of how joe treated her after realizing she could be hyped up by more secure people like travis or matty (even tho he’s annoying dhdhdh he was mesmerized at those concerts unfortunately) and i think i can do it with a broken heart could also be a reflection on fame… not sure, i def think this is a break up album but i really hope she includes some songs that introspectively comment on how she’s processed the last year of her life. the increased attention and fixation on everything she does this last year is unlike anything i’ve ever seen in her life or any famous person’s… i really want to know what she thinks of it all and how she manages it mentally

Kate!!!

if we knew when the writing period for this album ended, i’d feel much more confident in making predictions dhdhdh

Joanna

At this point I can’t tell if I actually objectively believe this theory or I’ve somehow gotten so used to it in the short amount of time we’ve had the track list simply due to my ever increasing mental illness. I think I may just have a case of confirmation bias at this point, so if it does turn out to be incorrect when the album drops I’ll probably have a hell of a processing phase to go through and will most assuredly be gagged, and maybe a little (a lot) disappointed.

Rose Lebeau

I want it to be chronological SOOOO BAD

Betty O

I'm just amazed and happy about how much Taylor is sharing with us. We want to know what happened--well with 1989 vault songs, she told us what happened with Harry. Now she's going to tell us what happened with Joe. These songs, OMG get ready! It's going to be EPIC!!! I don't think any other artist is as close to their fans as Taylor.

Laine Wagner

I am definitely getting chronological vibes as well and think this is correct! i saw a theory the other day that the album is split up into the stages of grief. not sure i buy into that, but i am intrigued…i think if there is to be any Tayvis content it will be the smallest man who ever lived and the alchemy. i think the smallest man who ever lived could talk about the juxtaposition of how physically and culturally large travis is vs how simple and small the life he lives is and how that’s what she wants and needs. BUT we did just find out this is an explicit track so i’m not so sure. the alchemy could be about the magic between her and travis. OR the alchemy could also be about the magical healing effects of being on the eras tour while in the midst of a heart break.