Post Mortem: Lessons Learned from Wishlist Wizard (Patreon)
Content
Wishlist Wizard has come to an end on Patreon and will shortly be doing the same on Royal Road. The series was originally planned to be six books, but I revised it to be a trilogy when I could no longer convince myself that engagement wouldn’t magically pick up.
That probably sounds like sour grapes. It’s not. Throughout my creative career, I’ve tried a lot of things. When an idea doesn’t land like I thought it would, I have a habit of hanging on for too long. That’s part sunk cost fallacy–I’ve come this far so I should hang on a bit longer to turn it around–and part naive optimism–I love this so it’s only a matter of time until every one else does too.
As hard as it was, ending Wishlist Wizard as a trilogy was the right decision. I’m proud of the work, but I’m also proud that I was able to step away.
More importantly, I’ve come away from the project with a few lessons that will serve me well in the future. For the other authors out there, maybe my honest reflection helps them avoid the same mistakes in their own work.
1. Publish 5 times a week or don’t publish.
For both Dead End Guild Master and Wishlist Wizard, I started with a light posting cadence of three times a week. When I pushed Dead End Guild Master to five chapters a week, I saw a noticeable improvement in reader retention. I couldn’t, however, do the same for Wishlist Wizard because I was unsure that I could maintain that volume. Five chapters of DEGM and then three chapters of WiWi a week was a lot, and I was skeptical of my ability to manage ten total chapters a week.
2. Subscribers show up for the book that hooked them, not everything.
I should have known this from my work in livestream event production. When a streamer switches to content different from their usual–say a Super Metroid speedrunner jumps into a game of Overwatch–viewership tanks instantly. As much as viewers like the streamer, they show up for very specific reasons.
Applied to serial fiction, I shouldn’t expect someone who likes one series to automatically subscribe to everything, especially when the tone and the style of the options vary significantly. This is especially scary because the same cliff exists at the end of a series. When DEGM ends, how many people will stick around for the next thing? Historically, for other authors, the answer is a small fraction. For as much as readers say they want stories that conclude rather than go on endlessly into dozens of books, actually ending a series is a risky proposition because it’s unlikely that the majority of the audience will follow you into the next series.
Again, not sour grapes. That’s just how the market works, and if I’m honest, my consumer habits are probably the same.
3. Fair use is prohibitively risky for publisher relationships.
Once upon a time, Wishlist Wizard was signed for an audiobook release, with a paid advance and everything. When the publisher realised how often I quoted copyrighted content like game manuals and magazines, they pulled out. What I saw as a clever play on nostalgia, they saw as a massive liability, and frankly, that’s totally reasonable on their part. Fair use is easy to say but very expensive to defend. Even if I’m right that my application counts as “transformative,” the legal costs of defending that notion are substantial. In the future, I need to lower my expectations for experimental content and think long-term about how potential partners would react to my choices.
4. I don’t actually understand the litRPG audience.
I read litRPGs more than traditional fantasy these days, but I believe there is some fundamental difference between what I get from them and what the broader audience for the genre gets. I thought WiWi hit the right hooks, played with the right ideas, and had the right tone, but it didn’t land the way other series that released around or shortly after it did. The chapter release frequency is likely a factor here, but I still can’t help but look at what’s ultra popular and scratch my head when I compare it to Wishlist Wizard.
That’s an exceptionally spooky thing to admit on the cusp of releasing the Center for Dungeon Management, another attempt at a litRPG, but going into this series I’m doing something very stupid: I’m ignoring everything else that’s happening in the genre. This story is purely what I want a litRPG to be. I believe strongly in serving your audience, because without them there isn’t a point in a publishing, but CDM is calibrated entirely on my own tastes instead of my perception of what works in other stories in the genre.
To be clear, audiences aren’t “wrong” for liking other stories over WiWi. Books are meant to be fun, and it’s my responsibility as an author to give readers the fun they’re looking for.
5. Aggressive marketing is important.
My day job is running a marketing agency and has been for the last 20 years. I’ve launched books for other people. And I’ve launched games, software, hardware, services ranging from app development to home organization, and on and on. I know that marketing is important, but after a day of doing that work for clients, I find myself lacking the energy to apply all of that to my own work. Where I’m telling clients that hope isn’t a strategy and that customers won’t find you, you have to find them, I turn around and focus only on the product–my stories.
The challenge here, if I’m being honest, is also deeply personal. Patreon comments are easy to keep up with, but I often dread keeping up with RR reader comments because, frankly, I’m fragile. A crappy reaction, no matter how baseless, tanks my day. I’ve been writing and publishing online since I was 19, so none of that is new to me, but I find that my resiliency continues to decrease as I get older rather than improve. My thick skin has gotten awfully thin, and I don’t know how to correct that.
Still, I need to suck it up. If I’m going to pay my bills with fiction, then I need to make sure I get X number of Reddit comments in a day, I need to post X times in the right Facebook groups, and I need to not avoid engagement because I’m worried someone will say something cruel.
…Or I could disappear into my own imaginary world and keep writing in solitude like I enjoy. Yeah, I like that better.
What’s Next
I am so outrageously stoked for the Center of Dungeon Management to go live. That happens later this week, and I’ll be posing daily chapters for the first 30 days and then going into a five chapters a week schedule. As a reminder, DEGM is on track for book 6 to be the final in the series. The manuscript is complete, so there is no danger of that series not getting a proper finish.
Molt & Mire as well as the Merchant of Mikata are still in the works. With book 1 of CDM fully written, I’ll be working on the next entry in the DEGM universe, so don’t think that I’ve gone back on my promises there. Something about CDM deeply satisfied me as a creator, and I had to chase that even if it wasn’t in the original grand plan.
Here’s hoping that doesn’t turn into the number one item on my next post mortem.