Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Welcome to book 1 in the Center for Dungeon Management series. I'm giving all Patreon subscribers access to the first 30 chapters. For any chapter beyond that, you will need to subscribe to the Intern Tier (Center for Dungeon Management only; if you were subscribed to Wishlist Wizard you're already set) or Become a Legend (DEGM + CDM access).

Anyone subscribing to an author Patreon probably knows this, but please consider rating, reviewing, and following the series on Royal Road. The algorithm feeds on those, and that's an amazing kindness to do for someone if you enjoy their work.

Hope you enjoy the story.

Chapter 1: Orientation

“This is your desk,” he said.

He never actually shared his name. When he saw that my ID matched his list, he told me to follow him. Between the lobby and my corner of the fourth floor, he didn’t say anything at all. When I say “my corner,” I mean that collectively. Six desks were crammed into the cubicle, three on either side, and the five interns already there had to suck in their stomachs and pull their chairs tight to their desks for me to pass.

“Username is last name, first name. Your password is your birthday. Log in, change your password, and then start the orientation module.”

And he was gone.

“They’re not being rude,” the woman next to me whispered. She was noticeably petite and wore dark-rimmed glasses. “They’ve got a pile of reports to process before end of day. We’ve had a rash of dungeon crashers, and it’s created a mess.”

I nodded.

“Dungeon crashers are people who sneak into dungeon gates,” she added.

“I knew that.”

“Wasn’t trying to be rude either.”

I raised my hands. “No, no, it’s okay. I didn’t take it that way.”

“Good. We get kicked around a lot. You need a thick skin. I’m Megan, by the way.”

“Dorion.”

She raised an eyebrow.

“My mom liked books.”

“Right. Sure. I’ll stop bothering you.”

I sat. My chair wobbled, and the hard plastic frame beneath the cushion poked through. The mouse felt cheap, and the login screen hung for a frustratingly long amount of time. I changed my password, and I started orientation.

The Center for Dungeon Management was a well-known federal agency, so I learned relatively little from the 127 slides I cycled through. Most of it was recent history.

For reasons still unknown, dungeon gates appeared around the world, and humans everywhere were introduced to the system. Pretty quickly, we figured out that not running dungeon gates led to dungeon surges, which loosed all manner of monsters into the world. Adjusting to the new normal sowed a great deal of chaos and ended an untold number of lives.

That was seventy years ago. We only recently reclaimed South America for humanity, so talks had begun about doing the same for Asia, an even bigger challenge. My grandfather was alive for the beginning of all of this, and he described pre-dungeon-Asia as having the most populated countries in the world. Multiple historians believed that China and India in particular had the capacity to become global powerhouses of technology and manufacturing.

That was always hard for me to picture. How could so many people lose to monsters? 

Japan and Taiwan, who survived because of their island isolation, blamed Europe. The bar corner pundits would say those countries had to put the onus on Europe because dead Soviets can’t take responsibility or pay restitution. It was more profitable to pitchfork the countries still around. Anyone not from Japan or Taiwan blamed the Soviet Union. 

The gates opening so soon after World War II hastened the Soviet Union’s demise, and no one disagreed with that conclusion. Not only was the country mired in corruption, but its people still reeled from 25 million war casualties and an extreme shortage of resources. The dungeon gates they knew about were rarely closed, but it was the gates they didn’t know about that ultimately led to Asia’s fall, or so we were taught in high school history.

Back then, we had no way to detect the appearance of gates in isolated areas and vastly underestimated how many there could be. We now know that gates have an equal chance of appearing on land anywhere in the world, so the vast frozen stretches of uninhabited Soviet Union land were just as likely to get a gate as Manhattan. The difference was no one was around to witness most of the gates in the Soviet Union, so no one closed them. 

The Soviet Union’s legendarily brutal winter killed many of the monsters that emerged from gates, but eventually ice-type monsters surged. They thrived in the cold, naturally, and the more isolated villages had no way to fight them and no way to call for help. In other words, the people who might have sounded the alarm never got the chance.

Then spring came, and all manner of monsters surged forth to join the ice-type monsters.

The Soviet Union refused outside help and was overrun. By the time the rest of the world realized intervention was a necessity in everyone’s best interests, so many dungeon gates had surged that nuclear strikes seemed like the only option.

The Center for Dungeon Management, or CDM, didn’t give a shit about what happened in Asia. They only beat this story to death because it was the ultimate justification for their existence. Without the CDM managing gates and crawlers, American society was doomed to fall, just like the communists.

Finally, I reached the final registration step of the orientation module. This was all information I had submitted before on multiple occasions. Allegedly, they asked new hires to repeatedly fill in the same forms in an effort to catch falsified profiles, like someone hiding their level or their class. 

After working there, I laugh when anyone acts like the repetitive data entry is by design. It wasn't. We had three databases that depended on crawler profiles. None of them could sync to one another, and we didn’t have budget for an IT project that big.

When I finished my intake, it looked just like my system profile:

Dorion Carmino

Class: Archer

Level: 1

XP Progress: 1/100

Str: 4

Dex: 5

Con: 4

Int: 3

Cha: 3

Abilities: (none)

Traits: Ranged Accuracy

Spells: (none)

My 1 XP came from killing fifteen giant rats when I was a kid. I was in the loft of a barn when I spotted the monsters below. I dropped hay bales on them and got in trouble for ruining all that perfectly good hay with rat guts.

I told myself that every intern started with system profiles like mine. I didn’t know the other five interns working around me, but I suspected they were there for the same reason I was: a job at the CDM was our only chance to earn XP. We couldn’t afford licenses or dungeon fees to earn XP on crawls, and grinding the wilds was as dangerous as it was impractical. 

Any monster that escaped a dungeon was considered “wild,” and the areas overrun by such monsters were called “the wilds.” Though these were all monsters that once inhabited dungeons, the system made their XP value nearly worthless when they crossed over into our world. A 500 XP kill in a dungeon was a 5 XP kill when that same monster went wild. No change in difficulty. Just less XP.

The mana crystals found inside monsters remained after they escaped a dungeon gate, but they were useless black charcoal if you cut them out, so there was no money to be had in wild monster hunting either.

The CDM managed gate access, dungeon fees, licensing requirements, and another dozen tedious administrative functions. Crawlers had to be licensed, and the rights to run gates were purchased via a government web portal, with the highest-level gates sold in an auction format. If you weren’t licensed and didn’t have the rights, you weren’t permitted to enter the dungeon, even if no one ever bid on it. Low-level gates in remote areas were most prone to going unclaimed.

Even a low-level dungeon surge could decimate a community, so the CDM deployed crawlers to close those gates before that could happen, giving an intern like me the chance to get some real dungeon time. Some argued those gates should be open to the public to allow crawlers who couldn’t afford licensing and training a chance to break into the industry, but the government didn’t believe in giving anything away for free.

So the CDM had “cullers” who were dedicated to clearing dungeons about to surge. Low-level schlubs like me comprised the majority of that force, but they had a handful of elite units who flew around the country to close gates no one else could. For example, if a gate opened on Mount Rainier in the middle of winter, that gate still needed to be closed, so the high-level CDM cullers would get sent in. The money was shit, though, so the best crawlers at that level were in guilds or on teams.

No, I didn’t have dreams of becoming an elite culler. I just wanted enough levels that I could luck into a decent crawl team and make some okay money for once in my life.

When I completed the orientation, a whole new set of modules loaded. I had six more trainings to complete in the next three days. The topics ranged from data-logging procedures for crawls with fatalities to the liability policies for cullers who err on the job. For example, unless you were a healer class, any first aid we provided had to be within set boundaries, which was several steps below what care paramedics could legally provide patients. If you violated a policy like that, the liability fell back on you, the individual.

I loaded a module titled “Trouble in the Dungeon: Good Samaritan Considerations Across Classes” and started to read.

“Osheski, grab your bag,” a voice said. 

A man in a tight pink polo with similarly tight jeans leaned over the intern cubicle, addressing the girl who introduced herself as Megan. His head was shaved to stubble, and his beard was shaped to a manicured point to emphasize his jawline–or, perhaps, to give him one. Who knew what kind of chin was or wasn’t under that beard.

“Sorry,” she replied with a frown. “Enforcer Meyers has me on something.”

The man sighed. “Leminson?”

“Can’t.”

“Saito?”

“Wish I could.”

The man grumbled, “Which one of you is actually available?”

Megan jerked her head in my direction. “He is. First day.”

“Name?” he asked me.

“Dorion Carmino, sir.”

“Dorion?”

“Yes, sir.”

“Alright, Gray, you’re with me. Grab your kit and meet me at the elevator in five.”

“I’m sorry,” I replied, “but I said my last name was Carmino.”

“Nah, you’re Gray now. Carmino sounds too badass for an intern.”

When he turned, I called, “Wait! I don’t have a kit.”

“For the love of- Fine. Go to the elevators and wait for me there.”

And then he was gone. 

“Good luck, Gray,” Megan said with a playful snicker.

A few minutes later, the man appeared at the elevator and pushed a bag into my arms. A round shield and a sheathed sword were tied to it.

We got in, and he pushed the button for the ground floor.

“I’m an archer, sir.”

“If you actually need that kit, we’re both dead. Well, I’ve got a shot at getting out. You’re definitely dead.”

I nodded.

We found our way to the parking garage and got into an SUV with CDM emblazoned on the doors in white and blue.

“So… do I call you Mr. Pink?” I joked.

“Absolutely not,” the man gruffed back. “Enforcer McDouglas.”

Making friends your first day anywhere was always so much fun.

“I know you're new,” he continued, “so I’m aware you don’t know anything. Your job is to observe and then type the words I tell you to type into that tablet there. We’ve got a team complaining about dungeon crashers at an E-ranked gate. Two people on this is overkill, but we always do fieldwork in pairs. Enforcement is easier with an extra witness present.”

I listened.

“You’re allowed to ask questions if we’re in the car.”

“What do we do if there are actually dungeon crashers?” I asked.

“Unless we have special orders that say otherwise, we take the report, set up surveillance for when the crashers exit if they haven’t already, and pass everything off to the investigation department.”

“I thought crashers got arrested.”

“They do,” McDouglas answered, “but not by us and not right now. Trying to arrest a whole crawl team at the same time is like shaking a bees' nest before you try to remove it. Our report will help the investigation team ID them, and then they’ll get arrested one at a time. No big battles or showdowns.”

That was less exciting than the television shows made enforcement out to be, but it also made sense. A fully armed party riding high on combat adrenaline could do a lot of damage before they went down. Yanking them out of bed at 3 a.m. was far safer.

“The majority of fieldwork is deescalation and paperwork about the deescalation,” he continued. “If you’re dealing with a crawler, assume they’re pissed before you even get there. In this case, these guys reserved a gate, geared up, and stepped inside to find someone was already clearing it. That’s pretty frustrating.”

Yeah, I would be frustrated by that experience too.

We drove south of Pittsburgh for a little more than thirty minutes and pulled onto the shoulder of a semi-rural highway. We weren’t far from the dense sprawl of the city, but we were far enough that there were patches of farm and wilderness all around.

We joined four pickup trucks and two cars parked on the side of the road, all with crawler passes in their windows. I couldn’t see the dungeon gate from there, which wasn’t unusual. This part of the state had a good number of hills, gullies, and hollows, so gates being out of sight was common.

I only counted four people, and as if anticipating my question, McDouglas said, “Most of a team will just go to sleep when this kind of thing happens. Always assume there are people in the cars until you’ve confirmed otherwise with your own eyes.”

McDouglas tossed me a lanyard with a badge and got out of the car, putting his own on as he went.

When I reached to grab my kit from the backseat, he chuckled. “Don’t bother.”

Two of the crawlers wore old platemail, another had a mismatched set of leathers and chainmail, and the fourth wore a pair of camouflage utility pants and a matching light jacket. Military surplus, I guessed. 

The guys in plate were probably fighters or a similar martial class. The one in leathers might be a rogue or a ranger, and the one in camo was likely a caster of some sort. The system penalized casters for wearing armor, so most relied on their party and protective spells to avoid harm. Higher-level casters used enchantments for additional protections, but anyone running E-ranked gates couldn't afford gear like that.

One of the scruffy guys in plate spit a brown glob into the tall grass and stepped forward to greet us.

“I’m the party captain,” he said, holding up his crawler license to prove his identity. “Whole first fifty yards of the gate was cleared when we got here. Turned back and called you folks.”

“How long ago was this?” McDouglas asked, flipping open a small pad to take notes.

“Hour and a half or something like it.”

“See anyone go in or out?”

The crawler snapped a can of snuff closed and tucked the wad into his lip. “Nope.”

“What kind of dungeon is it?”

“Looks like a vermin dungeon to me. Bunch of big-ass rats.”

McDouglas nodded and asked, “Ever have someone crash your gate before? If not, I can walk you through your options.”

“This is a first for us.”

“For an E-ranked gate, your two choices are to walk away or to go into the gate anyway to ensure the gate gets closed. If you walk away, you’ll get credit equal to what you paid for this gate to put toward your next run. If you choose to close the gate, we’ll return 100% of the dungeon fee and give you a 25% credit toward your next gate of the same rank.”

“We still keep the loot if we get our money back?”

“Yep. Sometimes you luck out and the crashers didn’t get very far, so your profit ends up being pretty good. Also a chance for the opposite, of course.”

The lead crawler put a finger in his ear to scratch it. “Give me a minute to check with my guys.”

As he stepped away to rejoin his party, McDouglas spoke softly, “We want them to take option two to get the gate closed for sure, but we also can’t promise them any specific returns, so I try to play up the best-case scenario a little bit while still being honest.”

“Do crawlers ever fake crash reports to get that deal?”

“Probably,” he admitted. “You can’t get away with more than one or two, though. Our record system will flag any anomalies for investigation, so if one team is submitting above-average crash reports, we’ll know about it. These guys will take the deal, by the way.”

“You’re sure?”

“Rednecks love to gamble, and anyone reserving an E-ranked gate is usually not in a position to pass up a potential payday.”

The lead crawler came back. “We’ll make sure it’s cleared.”

“Excellent,” McDouglas said and pulled the tablet from my hands. He flicked through a few menus. “Need your signature. This says you agree to close the gate and that you know it’s a crime to attack or attempt to apprehend crashers. Only self-defense is permitted. Otherwise, let them leave.”

Not bothering to read anything, the crawler used his finger to sign and handed the tablet back. 

“Thank you, crawler. One last question: what kind of beer do you prefer?”

“We’re Yuengling men, through and through.”

McDouglas nodded. “Alright, please wait one more moment.”

He passed the tablet to me and went back to the SUV. I heard the back hatch slam, and McDouglas returned, setting a case of Yuengling on the tailgate of one of the crawler trucks.

“What’s this?” the lead crawler asked.

“You guys are doing me a big favor by closing this. Unless you don’t want the beer, I can-”

“You can leave it right there,” the lead crawler laughed. “What’d you say your name was?”

“McDouglas.”

The lead crawler shook his hand. “Appreciate a classy fella. Thank you very much.”

“Keep your heads in there.” To me, he said, “Go to the car and start logging the report. I’ll set up the trail cam.”

McDouglas joined me a few moments later. We wouldn’t be responsible for retrieving the trail cam, but we would get a copy of the images and footage it recorded. 

“Beer isn’t part of CDM policy, and a good few of my colleagues would disagree with that move,” he said, checking his phone before we pulled away. “My advice? Make crawlers your allies. You’ll see a lot of the same faces on this job, and everything about your life will be easier if even one crawler on the scene likes you a little bit.”

“And you happened to have a case of Yuengling?”

McDouglas laughed. “I’ve got four brands in the back, two cases each. Like I said, this is an off-book decision that is technically a violation of our ethics policy. I don’t see it as bribery, but I’m not the one who brings down the hammer, you know?”

“Understood. What usually happens if crawlers find crashers in a dungeon?”

“That’s pretty rare. Crashers know if we get an image of their faces, that’s it. AI facial recognition is too damn good. Your average crasher will hit the beginning of a dungeon like they did here. They get in, get some XP and a few drops, and then they get out–all before we ever show up.”

“That makes sense,” I said.

“Good. Now get all of that interaction logged.”

McDouglas turned up a classic rock radio station and didn’t say another word to me the whole way back to headquarters.

Chapter 2: Emergency Contact

“Good first day?” Nathan asked. 

A little milk dribbled down his chin when he stuffed a spoonful of cereal into his mouth. He went to college for sociology but now worked for an HVAC company. He was a little softer than he was when we were freshmen, but he was still reasonably athletic.

“Was in the field for an hour, which was kind of cool,” I answered. “But mostly I did trainings at my desk.”

“When do you start doing crawls?”

I shrugged. “No idea. I don’t know how that works.”

“Are you deep enough to tell me what the government is hiding from us?”

“There are at least fifty active gates at any given time in our jurisdiction. I didn’t think the number was that high, but I also don’t think that’s a secret. They haven't shown me the freezer with the aliens yet.”

Nathan chewed and swallowed. “Fifty? No wonder they’re so shit at securing them.”

“It’s very obvious we don’t have the staff to handle it. I’m surprised they do as well as they do, to be honest.”

“Yeah. It’s a wonder this country still exists. Ah, bad news, I saw the stomp sisters leading a frat boy with a keg up the stairs.”

I groaned. The stomp sisters lived above us, and they were endlessly noisy. When they hosted a party, the whole building seemed to shake. I needed earplugs and melatonin to get any measure of sleep in those cases.

Nathan and I moved into this apartment as sophomores because the Southside of Pittsburgh was popular with college kids. Carson Street was loaded with bars, and this part of the city was known for being the party neighborhood, so it attracted visitors from all over. 

Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays were like mini war zones.

Parking turned into a lawless free-for-all, the streets were jammed with traffic, drunks yelled at all times of the night, and then there were the fights. A shooting or two each weekend was expected, as were two or three system fights, which meant that at least one party involved triggered one of their system-earned abilities in the scuffle.

At a minimum, that was equivalent to pulling a firearm in the eyes of the law, but that didn’t stop mages from throwing fireballs through storefront windows or barbarians from fighting every bouncer a club had, simultaneously.

All of that was great as undergrads. Now? Not so much.

We wanted to move, but we couldn’t afford anything else. In fact, we wouldn’t be able to afford the apartment we had if it wasn’t rent controlled. The prices they charged now for the same-size unit were absurdly high, and people paid it.

I pulled a cold hotdog out of a pack in the fridge and sat at the table to sift through my mail. Utility bills. Student loan payments. Donation solicitations from my alma mater. Three promises of preapproval for hundreds of thousands of dollars.

And then one envelope hand-addressed in a style I recognized.

Nathan saw me frown at it. “Sorry, man. I had a feeling that wasn’t good news.”

“I thought ignoring texts and calls would be enough,” I said.

“If they start showing up here, I’m not dealing with them. Your mom scares the shit out of me.”

“I don’t think it will come to that if it hasn’t by now. At least I hope it won’t.”

I skimmed the letter. It was the usual plea to atone for my sins and to join the side of righteousness in the fight against satan’s invasion:

You know in your heart that you walk through the valley of the shadow of death. You’ve seen the light, and it will welcome you back.

For a while, she had tried guilt, sending me texts with messages like:

Gram is getting older. If you don’t come home for Christmas this year, you might miss her last Christmas.

That one they had used for the last six years. Gram was powered by a potent combination of hate and spite. She would never die.

I had a few professors who were old enough to remember the pre-dungeon world, and they said that religion was a lot different then. Still plenty of extremists and such, but the dungeons galvanized an upswing in intensity to the point that the religious and secular could barely coexist. In some places, that meant another source of conflict for governments to manage. 

Fortunately, our city wasn’t a hotbed for that kind of activity. Ohio, West Virginia, and the middle of the state had a number of church communities. My old church was in West Virginia, by the way.

I crumpled the letter and tossed it into the garbage can. I missed.

Nathan chuckled as I went across the room to pick it up.

“We’ve got 2 episodes of The Wilds: Alaska to watch,” he said. “The dire bear cliffhanger has been killing me.”

“I can do one, and then I need to get some sleep. I’m beat.”

“One could argue that watching The Wilds: Alaska is a professional obligation, given your new job.”

I shook my head. “The CDM isn’t involved with anything outside the state, and you won’t see me signing up to run the wilds. I don’t know that I’d want to go to Alaska even if it wasn’t overrun.”

“You got me there, bro. It’s crazy to me that people ever lived there.”

“One episode. Then I’m going to bed.”

***

As was common for reality television, the dire bear cliffhanger was a red herring. Frost trolls attacking the camp in the night, however, was not. Two of four cameramen were killed, as were three of the twelve hunters. Everyone on the show, even the cameramen, was over level 20, a height that only a small fraction of crawlers ever reached. 

Me? I’d be lucky to get enough dungeon time to hit level 10.

Level-10s made decent money, to be clear, but they were grade schoolers compared to level-20s. A level 10 mage could blow through a door with a fireball. A level 20 mage could blow up the whole house.

And they still barely survived in the extreme north of the wilds. If monsters could ever coordinate a proper army, Canada and the United States wouldn’t stand a chance. Thankfully, no monsters showed that level of intelligence. A tribe of trolls or bugbears might attack as a unit, but a few skirmishes now and then at the border were easy to overwhelm with firepower. 

The real danger of the wilds was their unpredictability.

Dungeons had measurable ranks, making it easier for crawlers to know if they could or could not survive a particular instance. In the wilds, you weren’t as likely to encounter low-level enemies because the stronger monsters ate all of them. Any monster strong enough to eat a low-level monster could eat a low-level person just fine. The right boss or mini boss could consume entire towns.

One episode turned into three, and I didn’t get enough sleep. I was determined to make this career work for me, so I had four alarms set to make sure I got to work on time.

I beat three of the interns to the cubicle the next morning, including Megan. The other two already at their desks had their headphones on, and their eyes never left their screens when I shuffled by. I was offended at first, but then I found myself barely managing a wave when Megan sat down. I had so many modules to slog through that I couldn’t bear to waste a few seconds on small talk.

Before I knew it, a finger tapped me on the shoulder.

“There’s a Pamela’s around the corner,” Megan said. “We’re going to grab a quick lunch. Want to come?”

I looked at the time. How had I been working for five hours already?

“Yeah, I’ll go.”

The interns Amanda Leminson and Tom Saito joined us. Leminson had the bulky strength of a softball pitcher, and Saito could maybe weigh one hundred pounds if he chugged a bunch of water. I had Megan pegged for a volleyball player, but no, she played soccer up through her junior year of college.

Maybe not surprisingly, dungeon jobs attracted a fair amount of jocks. I had played soccer when I was younger and then a ton of intramural racquetball in college. For some reason, my dorm was obsessed with racquetball, so I got sucked into it too.

And I haven’t thought about racquetball since, actually. Writing about it now is the first time it’s come to mind in years and years. How was racquetball so popular in college but ceased to exist as soon as I graduated? I never heard about any adult casually playing racquetball. There were probably rec leagues somewhere, but it wasn’t like hockey or soccer or football, where casual interest continued on beyond undergrad.

At any rate, I ordered a tuna melt and listened to the other interns gossip.

Internships lasted six months in the enforcement department, and they weren’t hired as cohorts. Each of us was on a different month. Leminson was on her sixth, Saito was on his fourth, and Megan was on her second. The idea was to give a first-month intern like me visibility into every level of the process, piece by piece.

Megan said that’s not how it really worked out. She was already doing the work a six-month intern was expected to do because there were never enough bodies for the volume that came through.

“Where are you hoping to get placed?” I asked Leminson.

“Anything with fieldwork. Once I hit level 10, I’m multiclassing and going independent.”

“You can afford that?” 

You couldn’t choose the class you were born with, but you could choose your multiclass. For the average person, the cost of multiclassing put it out of reach. It required a prohibitively high number of refined mana crystals, which were processed monster drops, equivalent to a year of running C-ranked gates. 

“I’ve been saving since I was a kid,” she answered. 

“That’s also why she only ordered grilled cheese and will make a play for your leftovers,” Saito said, grinning.

“The money I’ll make after will make up for it.”

“If you don’t mind my asking, what build are you aiming for?” I asked.

“Spellsword. I was born with fighter, and I’ll multiclass into black mage. Pure fighters tend to hit a ceiling as crawlers. The rare abilities make it possible for you to push over level 15, but I’ve never gotten lucky with anything. Mage is the surefire way to be sure I can get to 20.”

“She dreams big,” Megan added. I got the sense she was less optimistic about Leminson’s future.

With a mouthful of grilled cheese, Leminson asked me, “What class are you?”

“Archer. What about you guys?”

“Brawler,” Megan answered.

With a sigh, Tom said, “Monk.”

It wasn’t surprising that we were all martial classes. Magic users got snatched up for prep and apprentice programs. They were so valuable that recruitment essentially started at birth.

Martial classes were far more common, so pretty much every normal working person had one. My fourth-grade teacher, Miss Tarvoski, had the barbarian class, and she was the sweetest person I’ve ever met. The guy who filed my taxes was a defender. That class specialized in shield work.

Monk was one of the hardest classes to train, however. The few weapons the class permitted, like bo staffs and tonfas, were useless against many common monsters. A sword could be enchanted to slice rock, so a fighter could always make use of their weapon. Monks, however, were not permitted to wield enchanted weapons.

And then there were the armor penalties.

Grinding monk levels eventually unlocked exceptional abilities, but getting to those heights was precarious with all of the class restrictions. Tom would find it difficult to ever do fieldwork for the CDM, but that was only a fraction of the organization. The bulk of the employees working there never went beyond level 1. His life wasn’t over because he drew a crappy class, but his options were more limited.

Archers, brawlers, and fighters had it far easier than monks.

“How was the ride-along with McDouglas?” Megan asked.

“Short,” I answered. “We spent more time driving than anything else.”

“That’s most calls,” Saito said. “And all long calls are bad calls. Best to hope for short.”

I nodded. “Fair.”

Megan rolled her eyes at Saito. “It’s not that grim. McDouglas isn’t the worst enforcer to shadow for a run, either. Chapman and Grensmith are the hard ones.”

“What makes them hard?”

“To some people, teaching interns is just a part of the job. Something that has to be done. Then there are enforcers who treat interns like robots. They probably got shit on when they were new, so now they shit on us. Tons of grunt work. Absurd sticklers. I once got a twenty-minute lecture because I failed to italicize the period at the end of an italicized sentence. They basically just make everything harder than it needs to be.”

Leminson and Saito nodded along as Megan spoke. 

“Six months go quick,” Leminson added. “It’s not so bad.”

“Is this your first pick for a career?” Saito asked.

I shook my head. “I tried to be an English teacher.”

Megan lit up. “I tried to do elementary ed! Can barely live on teacher money, right?”

“Yep.”

Megan pointed a fork at Leminson. “She majored in anthropology. Wanted to be an archaeologist.” She turned the fork to Saito. “He was an art major.”

They both shrugged.

None of these stories were surprising. I didn’t know a single person who worked in the field they majored in. Not one. And no, I didn’t know any teachers. I never got that far. I spent sophomore through senior year expecting teacher salaries to rebound. They didn’t, so I threw a resume at a CDM posting when I graduated.

Internships with the CDM weren’t that competitive. Crawlers made good money. CDM employees did not. An internship with a guild or a crawl team–now those were competitive. I didn’t even get a rejection from most of them. I submitted my application, and that was it.

I did get the hint, of course.

“I’d like to join a guild or a team eventually,” I said. “If my degree is useless, at least I have the chance to retire early as a crawler.”

The three interns eating with me looked at each other but didn’t say anything.

“What?”

“I just went through this,” Leminson said. “The reputable guilds all grow their members from level 1. I couldn’t figure out why I never got anywhere with my applications, and finally one of the admin staff at a guild broke the news to me. They see the quality of our training as inferior, basically.”

“I know it’s competitive,” I replied.

“No, that’s not what I’m describing. A competition means you have a chance to win, even if it’s small. If your application has CDM on it, the software rejects you immediately. A human won’t ever see it. I’m not out to crush your dreams or anything, but I wish someone had explained that to me when it was my first week on the job, so that’s why I’m telling you. I’m going independent because of that.”

Saito offered me a sympathetic frown. “There are a few independent teams out there. The money and XP aren’t awesome, but you can make a living on E-ranked gates if you really have to. Could get lucky and pick up a D-ranked or two sometimes.”

Independent teams were capped on their profit potential. Guilds had full-time harvesters in-house to milk gates for all they were worth, collecting monster parts, mining ores, recovering artwork, and pushing media campaigns. Not only did they extract every speck that could be sold, but they also built members into celebrities so that footage of crawls themselves could be monetized.

Nearly everyone recorded dungeon runs. Some did it for training and liability purposes, but most tried to use it for social content in some manner. Mounting a GoPro to a helmet was simple enough, so YouTube was flooded with crawl videos. Most saw no more than a few hundred views, but some crawlers made more on the footage of a run than they did on the run itself.

Livestreaming dungeon runs was growing in popularity, but presently, only large guilds could afford the hardware it took to get a signal out of a dungeon gate.

Guilds were not the same as crawl teams, to be clear.

Crawl teams could be as large as guilds and chased all the same profit sources, but they contracted out for everything but crawlers. Some people argued savvy teams made more money than guilds because they could better control expenses. If a person wasn’t needed for the job, they didn’t have to pay them to sit around and wait for work to come in. If a guild didn’t need a mining team for a week, they still had to pay theirs.

Independent teams could rarely afford the upfront costs of all that infrastructure, so bidding for and harvesting B, A, and S-ranked gates was typically out of reach. C and D gates were harder to come by, but not impossible.

I wanted guild or crawl team money. Surely the actual market wasn’t as bleak as they believed. I didn’t argue with them, though.

“I’ve got time to figure it out,” I said. 

I breathed a sigh of relief when Saito changed the topic to complain about the train always being late in the mornings. Leminson was obviously sensitive about her dreams of guilds and teams getting dashed, and I didn’t want to rub any salt in her wounds by talking more about my own goals. I was going to make it where she didn’t, however. I didn’t care how hard it was.

Looking back on it, I’m not sure if I was optimistic or naive. Or perhaps those two ideas are one and the same?

Chapter 3: Unpaid Overtime

On Monday night of my second week, my phone rang at 1 a.m.

“An E gate needs cullers by 2 a.m. Are you available?”

“Yes,” I managed.

“Thank you for your service. I am texting you the address now.”

I opened the message and groaned aloud when I saw that the gate was in Clairton. That was a thirty-minute drive, and from looking at the location on a map, I was pretty certain the gate was in an old steel mill on the Monongahela River. 

Coal mining and steel production used to be big business in this corner of the state, but now it was all ghost towns. The boom of American production during the war moved overseas when Africa as a continent came into its own. Ethiopia and Buganda could produce more steel for cheaper, so one by one the mills and plants that made Pittsburgh possible closed down. 

Eventually, nearly all of American manufacturing followed the steel industry and moved to Africa. Blue-collar Americans cost too much money, and safety regulations were too restrictive. After a couple of decades, the height of American industrialism was a distant memory.

A few folks tried to hang on in the smaller steel and coal towns, but stray monsters were still a reality even if you didn’t live in the wilds. Plenty got loose and bred in the early years, but towns that couldn’t afford police and fire departments couldn’t afford to have experienced crawlers on standby. After a few tragedies, most everyone moved closer to the city.

Clairton was one of those ghost towns.

I grabbed my CDM training gear, thankful that one of the few perks of the internship included passable equipment, and walked two blocks to my car.

Traveling these old steel town roads creeped me out. Nothing was torn down. It was just abandoned. There were still swingsets in yards and rocking chairs on porches, like the people living there had only recently stepped away and intended to return soon.

Streetlights weren’t necessary if there were no people, so nothing existed until my headlights shone on it, glinting off broken glass and casting long shadows. More than a few horror films were set in towns like this, and I could see why. Being in the ruins of civilization was a special kind of isolation, even if those ruins were relatively close to home.

When I pulled up, I was happy to see a gray-haired CDM culler leaning against his CDM SUV and scrolling on his phone. I was worried I would have to fumble my way through an abandoned coke plant with only my headlamp to find the gate. Coke was an important material in steel production, if you didn’t know.

“Name?” he gruffed as I got out of my car. Based on the battle-axe, I presumed he was a martial class.

“Dorion Carmino.”

“Says here this is your first cull.”

“That’s correct, sir.”

“Oh, you have the archer class. That makes you a lot easier to babysit.”

I didn’t know what to say to that.

“We’re waiting on three more. Go ahead and get geared up. Don’t leave anything valuable in your car, by the way. Break-ins out here are pretty common.”

My gear was simple enough to put on over my clothes: a leather tunic, a quiver, a bow, a shortsword, shin pads, and a helmet. Though it was made of metal, the helmet looked more motocross than medieval. 

The system had rules for what could damage monsters and what could withstand damage from monsters. Kevlar could stop a bullet, but a goblin arrow would sail right through it. Similarly, an arrow fired from a recurve bow would do more damage than a bullet fired from a rifle if the target was a monster. 

Craftsmen who could work with the mana crystals from dungeons pushed to incorporate more modern ideas into crawling gear, but there was always the risk the system wouldn’t recognize an item as compatible, so it would remain mundane even if the materials were expensive.

Two cars pulled up in close succession. One was another veteran CDM culler. She had a spear and a kite shield. She wasn’t as old as the one who greeted me, but I guessed her to be in her 40s. This definitely was not her first cull.

Megan popped out of the second car with a cup of coffee in her hand. Her CDM kit was identical to mine except she had a longsword and a shield instead of a bow and quiver. She smiled at me.

Which was weird, because it looked like her eyes were still closed. The time of night sucked for a cull, but she seemed to take it exceptionally hard.

The last person to arrive was an intern with the investigation department. His gear matched Megan’s, but I learned later he wasn’t a fighter or a brawler. He was a rogue.

“We don’t have time to learn names, and you don’t need to be trying to remember if it’s Daniel or David when you have calls to make. These cull teams are always thrown together, so get used to doing it this way. I’m the captain. I’m steering the ship.” 

He pointed to the woman with the spear. 

“She’s a ‘guard.’ Short for lifeguard. Being nervous for this is fine, but mind where you’re swinging and shooting. Guard and I have been stabbed a few times by interns and would prefer to not experience it again.

“The two biggest rules are stay in formation and do whatever the fuck we say. E-ranked gates can still kill you, but if you listen when we speak, this one won’t. Any questions before we head in?”

The rogue raised his hand. “How does the loot split work?”

The captain clucked his tongue. “Someone didn’t pay attention in orientation. Sorry, bud, I’m not a Powerpoint presentation. Any real questions?”

No one spoke or raised a hand.

“Alright. I’ve run a few gates in this place before. Mind your step, or you’ll get your money’s worth out of your tetanus shots.”

The captain led the way, and the guard brought up the rear.

“The CDM gets the mana crystals,” Megan whispered to the rogue. “We get XP.”

The rogue released a disappointed huff but didn’t say anything otherwise.

The Clairton steel mill was a small town in and of itself, and a few decades of decay and graffiti-loving interlopers made it a maze of multicolored rubble. I tried to imagine what this place would have looked like in its heyday. Cranes loading steel beams onto trains. Furnaces roaring. A coal barge passing by on the river on its way to the city.

All I saw now was dirt, rust, and spray paint.

We stopped outside of what the captain said used to be a blast furnace. The dungeon gate was next to it. Wider but shorter than a standard doorframe, this particular gate was a natural stone arch whose opening was covered by several pieces of mismatched lumber nailed together. That was this gate’s version of a door.

When you learn about the dungeon gates in history class and how much trouble they caused when they first appeared, you can’t help but think, “How could a dungeon gate ever go unnoticed?”

If it weren’t for the CDM tech that could detect dungeon gate signatures by satellite, no one would have ever known this gate was here. We were well away from the road, so the few people who might pass by would never have an eyeline to the gate. If they did, they weren’t likely to notice a gray stone arch amongst the ruins already here. Graffiti artists clearly trafficked this place, but they were even less likely to report a gate. The CDM weren’t police, but more than a few people saw them as one and the same.

So this door would have sat here long enough for a dungeon surge. Easily.

Some dungeon gates were more noticeable, particularly the upper-ranked ones. An S-ranked gate might be something like a drawbridge or a giant cave mouth. Most gates, however, weren’t larger than a set of double doors, and they all presented in the same way: a freestanding entrance structure and only the entrance. A simple dungeon gate looked like something you might see in a home improvement showroom.

Except it was a portal to a dungeon full of monsters instead of the aisle with all the toilets.

The captain tossed the wooden cover aside, crouched, and shuffled through. It looked like he disappeared into a pool of black paint.

A cavern lit by torches was on the other side, and though the ceiling was low in this section, I could stand fully upright.

This was my first time in a dungeon, and it felt surprisingly ordinary. Aside from the conveniently placed torches hanging from the walls, this seemed like a normal Earth cave, not a different dimension.

The captain asked Megan and the guard to take the frontline. The rogue and I were directly behind them, and then the captain brought up the rear. I took that as laziness at first, but he did a surprising amount of coaching for how bored he looked. Levels were great, but the system didn’t teach or instill party tactics. That was up to us to learn, so I was happy to have an experienced culler telling me what to do.

The goblins we fought were clustered in groups as if waiting for us to arrive, and the guard never let us noobs get overwhelmed. These were level 1 enemies, and she brushed them off like picnic ants.

My first goblin headshot was a bit of a thrill, but by the tenth kill, the effort felt more like a gym exercise. Draw, aim, loose. Draw, aim, loose. Over and over and over. 

Nothing remarkable happened. There were no exciting or interesting moments.

I thought the boss might be, but the guard told us to wait outside. The CDM didn’t want a party with levels as low as ours to go up against a goblin berserker. So she killed it, and then we hiked out, cutting out the mana crystals of our kills along the way for the CDM to keep.

No, the rest of us didn’t XP for the boss. The system split XP equally between party members, but it omitted anyone who didn’t actually contribute. If a healer stood ready to help their party but never actually did anything, they would still get an equal share of XP. The security they provided was a contribution by the system’s standards.

If someone came along with the express purpose of not participating in battles, they didn’t get XP. That meant no “carrying” someone through easy gains simply by having them present. Crawlers had spent years trying to game and trick the system, but as far as I know, no one has ever found a workaround to get easier XP.

The sun had begun to rise by the time we returned to our cars. The captain and the guard were the first in their vehicles and the first to leave.

Megan went to her trunk and pulled out several towels.

“Going to the beach?” I asked.

“No, I don’t want goblin guts in my upholstery.”

Shit. I hadn’t thought about that.

“See you in a couple hours,” she said as she sat.

I waved when she pulled away. The rogue followed her, and I stripped down to my skivvies to try and spare my car seats. It already had the permanent funk of a gym bag. I preferred not to add rotting goblin flesh to that scent bouquet if I could help it.

I checked my progress while I waited for my GPS to load:

Dorion Carmino

Class: Archer

Level: 1

XP Progress: 37/100

Str: 4

Dex: 5

Con: 4

Int: 3

Cha: 3

Abilities: (none)

Traits: Ranged Accuracy

Spells: (none)

That XP count had read 1/100 for much of my life. Seeing that change didn’t seem real at first.

With the XP split, every goblin was worth 1 XP. I was grateful for the training wheels the CDM provided, but that seemed abyssmally low for the effort I put in. Once I gained a few levels, I’d be able to farm more challenging E-ranked gates as well as D-ranked gates to earn better XP.

But this was a start.

***

I had enough time to shower before my workday but not enough time to sleep. This was part of the deal, and I knew to expect days like this. Still. It sucked.

A few minutes after I sat at my desk, Leminson set a tall cup of tea in front of me and another on Megan’s desk. She wasn’t in yet.

“Thank you for this,” I said.

“Don’t expect a delivery after every run, okay?”

I laughed. “I won’t.”

And that’s where morning small talk ended and the work began.

Saito saluted me when he arrived, and so did John Bruce and Tristan Lofold, my other cubemates. They were nice enough but weren’t ones for socialization. Leminson and Saito invited them every time they invited Megan and me somewhere, but they always declined. I liked that they continued to extend the offer just to show the others they were welcome.

Megan was twenty minutes late or so, but the CDM was lenient in these circumstances. They understood what a cull entailed, after all.

She microwaved her tea–which horrified Saito as a tea snob–and started banging away at her keyboard like everyone else.

A couple of hours later, a man with a gray ponytail and carrying a clipboard arrived at our cubicle. He wore a sport coat, a t-shirt, fashionable straight-leg jeans, and spotless sneakers.

“I need three grunts,” Enforcer Grensmith said. “Hope none of you have had lunch yet.”

Chapter 4: Crawler Recovery

Enforcer Grensmith drove me, Megan, and Saito to the north side of the city and into a densely packed residential neighborhood with steep streets. A gate made from black stones and a wrought iron portcullis stood in the middle of an asphalt road that was so old the original bricks buried beneath showed through. 

Orange barrels and caution tape marked the area as crawler-only at one point, but locals moved them to open up more parking spaces, turning the twenty-yard minimum buffer around the gate into a few feet.

That happened a lot, I learned. When it came to parking spots, the streets had their own laws. Fighting them as an enforcer usually wasn’t worth the effort.

Two CDM SUVs blocked traffic in either direction. A single red light spun on the roof of each of them. We parked, and Grensmith lingered after he turned the engine off. No one had talked the fifteen minutes it took to get there. Megan and Saito stared out their windows with pale faces and grim expressions the whole way, so I already knew this wasn’t going to be a good day.

Grensmith had been with the CDM for thirty years and had a reputation for being strict and heartless. If he needed a moment to brace for what was ahead, could I handle what I was in for?

“Put on your plastics and grab a weapon from your kit,” he said.

Slamming the door behind him, Grensmith walked the few feet to the gate to confer with an older woman carrying a radio in one hand and a cellphone in the other. I couldn’t hear what they said.

“If you get sick, find a corner and let it out,” Megan said, weakly. “No one will think less of you, so take the time you need and get back to helping.”

I nodded.

The “plastics” Grensmith referenced were full-body disposable suits. Rubber gloves, boots, masks, and safety glasses completed the ensemble.

The three of us waited alongside the car until Grensmith was done conferring with the woman from the culling team. She stepped away to take a phone call, and he turned to us.

“This is a C-ranked gate,” Grensmith said to us. “Nine of ten wiped. Our job is to ID the crawlers, take detailed notes of their condition, bag their remains, and bring them out of the gate. The investigation team will pick up the bodies and take it from there. Gray, our role here is to back up the cullers inside and to create a chain of custody for the remains coming out of the dungeon. Until we prove otherwise, we have to act as if a crime has been committed here.”

Grensmith slipped plastic booties over his immaculate sneakers and went in first. We followed.

This dungeon had a traditional stone structure. Hewn stone for the walls. Cobblestone for floors. Glowing quartz embedded in the ceiling every five feet for light.

Our feet splashed in blood the moment we came through the gate, and my boots stuck to the floor with each step. Grensmith took several pictures with his phone and then gestured for us to begin. I stuck close to Saito and did what he did.

First we searched for IDs. All of these bodies were hauled here by the cullers, and very few of them were complete. We found most of the IDs with their appropriate owners, but three were missing. A good bit of their bodies was missing as well, so their IDs were likely somewhere deeper in the dungeon. They might never be recovered.

We noted the state of each body. We inventoried their belongings. And we put them into body bags, one piece at a time. Occasionally, a member of the culling team would drag another piece to us and head back into the dungeon.

Technically, this was a task for the investigation department. Enforcers weren’t evidence collectors, but being understaffed and underfunded meant that most people in the CDM did a little bit of everything. The primary investigation teams were already on assignments, so we got sent in to help. That happened often, apparently.

Six cullers eventually appeared from deeper within the dungeon. I took them all for martial types because of the weapons they carried, but the woman with the mace was a cleric, I learned later. That was technically a martial type as well, but most people grouped clerics with healers. They could fight, but their restorative and support magic was what made them useful for a party. I was surprised to see a valuable class like that on a CDM cull team.

A stocky man with white beard stubble stopped to talk to Grensmith while the other cullers waited to exit the gate. I assumed that meant they killed the boss, which triggered the countdown for this instance.

“Gate’s closing in ten,” he said. “Bugbears with a necro shaman.”

“No shit?” Grensmith asked.

The stocky culler shrugged. “Rare but not unheard of. Looked to us like the crawlers fought halfway into the dungeon. When the shaman raised everything they had killed to that point, they got boxed in.”

“Thank you,” Grensmith said.

“Yep.”

With a quick whistle, the rest of the cullers followed the stocky man through the gate. We dragged the last body bag out a few moments later.

Coroners from the investigation team had arrived with vans at some point, and most of the bodies we had recovered were already loaded for transport when we emerged. A muscular man in a suit stood off to the side of the scene, talking with the older woman we met on the way in.

“Everything in the medical waste bin,” Grensmith gruffed. “Disinfect your face and hands before you get back in the car.”

“That guy is the general manager for the Mill Rats,” Megan whispered, indicating the man in the suit. “These crawlers were on his team.”

I knew the Mill Rats. They were one of the larger crawl teams in the city and had a decent reputation. A wipe like this was a tragedy, but it was also very bad for business. Everything the team invested in training and equipping the party was lost. The harvest partners they contracted had already mobilized resources for this gate, but there was no harvest happening now, so that meant more wasted capital. On the media side of the business, fatalities usually meant a drop in followers and a spike in trolls which also meant a dip in revenue.

After a wipe like this, every video and stream comment turned into a dig at the crawl team. A few would express genuine concern about crawling practices that led to that many deaths, but mostly the comments were as toxic as they were twisted.

In the SUV, Grensmith glanced in the rearview mirror to catch my eye and said, “Gray, review proper handwashing procedure when we get back to HQ. I’ll send you the module. Have it done before you leave today. Also, when you’re doing recovery, use two hands to keep pieces from breaking into even smaller pieces. That’s better for the investigators to work with than soup.”

“It's Carmino, sir.”

“No, it’s Gray.” 

“Yes, sir.” Enforcer MCdouglas had made a hobby of spreading my nickname, it seemed.

“Where’d the tenth crawler end up?” Saito asked Grensmith.

“Hospital. The ambulance was here and gone before we arrived.”

“Oh, so she didn’t run.”

Grensmith shook his head. “Not this one. Looks like a straightforward wipe. Don’t get many of those.”

“Umm…” I began, “what do you mean by that?”

“Murder in a dungeon is rarely a person attacking another person. Usually, monsters do the work, and the murderer just makes sure the target is vulnerable at the right time. You put that scene next to a run-gone-wrong? They’ll look the same. What was malicious? What was incompetence? What was bad luck? And then the crime scene disappears.”

“Does that mean there are more dungeon murders than people think or less?” I asked.

“We investigate every death hard as a deterrent. My opinion, murder is a big step for a person to take. I believe in the core goodness of humanity.” Grensmith made that statement with such monotone dryness that I couldn’t tell if he was being serious or sarcastic.

No one talked the rest of the way back to headquarters. 

None of us ate lunch–My appetite wouldn’t come back until late the next day, in fact. We didn’t talk in the cube either. When the day ended, goodbyes were little more than head nods. 

I was the last to leave. I had three quizzes on handwashing to take.

***

“Late one today, huh?” Nathan asked from the couch when I got home.

“Yeah.”

“Bad news,” he yelled. “Sandra changed the Netflix password. Two years on an ex’s account is a pretty good run, right?”

“Sure.”

Nathan turned. “Shit, man. You alright?”

“Had to clean up a party wipe.”

“Eesh. That sounds terrible.”

“I might just go crash,” I said. “I’m way behind on my sleep.”

“Alright, man. Text me if my shit gets too loud or if you need anything.”

“Thanks.”

After a long shower, I flopped onto my bed. I was tired and sore, but when I closed my eyes, sleep wouldn’t come.

I knew that days like today were inevitable. The work the CDM did wasn’t a secret. I had seen the news reports since I was a kid, I had seen crawlers die on stream, and the CDM interview process addressed the eventuality of a horrific dungeon scene directly with candidates. Death and gore were part of the job. Always was and always would be.

But I believed the dream of getting onto a team or being recruited by a guild gave me a sort of grit to keep going, to face those awful moments in the service of my greater goal. That grit was imaginary, I realized, and the future I aimed for was even more fanciful. If the other interns were right, no team or guild would want a CDM-trained crawler.

Dungeon crawling was my shot at surviving on my own as an adult, though. I might not have “fuck you” money, as Nathan would call being ultra-rich, but I’d be able to move out of this shoebox apartment, and I might even pay off my student loans someday. If I got a crawler job after my time at the CDM, that is.

I needed to confirm if my chances of getting into a guild or onto a crawl team were as hopeless as my coworkers said.

Say that it was. Was the headache worth it if I couldn't get recruited like I planned? I already made the mistake of getting an entire degree before realizing I was traveling in the wrong direction. That was not going to happen again. If crawling wasn’t going to pay off, I wanted to get out now and move on instead of waiting several years to come to my senses.

If it was true that CDM crawlers didn’t get good jobs, I had the following options:

1. Cut my losses and bail.

2. Aim for a long-term career with the CDM.

3. Figure out how to buck the trend and get the job I want on a team or in a guild.

4. Find a way to make independent crawling not suck.

Three of the four options required me to stick with the internship and level, so taking my time to solve this was on the table. And there I went doing it again. I wanted to put this off forever and blindly hope for the best. 

I knew the lifetime CDM path wasn’t for me. I didn’t want to be a Grensmith or a McDouglas. The job was too much work for too little money.

That left getting a team or guild spot where everyone else failed, somehow making myself the exception, or inventing an approach to independent crawling that made better money than all the independents before me had managed. 

I knew too little about either option, and I knew too well that I would never be the exception. People in my family never got the lucky break.

So what the hell should I do?

I gave up on trying to rest and went out to the living room.

“Can’t sleep?” Nathan asked with a mouthful of potato chips.

“Nope.” 

“You cool with a LootLootLouis stream? Totally fine if you’d rather not think about crawling.”

I shook my head. “No, it’s fine. Is this a VOD or live?”

“Live. B-ranked orc dungeon. Run started 35 minutes ago.”

LootLootLouis was a spellsword and top 10 crawler from Europe. B-ranked dungeons were a light challenge for him and his party, so they had more freedom to make fights dynamic and entertaining. The lulls between encounters had the friendly banter of an intelligent podcast. Plenty of streamers went the loud and louder route with their content. LootLootLouis was one of the few who didn’t.

But he was exciting to watch. He had thick dreads down to the middle of his back, and he insisted on wearing garishly bright outfits on stream. He sometimes described himself as a court jester with a sword, and he wasn’t afraid to go on stream with a velvety purple bathrobe with pink tights beneath.

As a spellsword, he had to rely on enchantments to avoid the casting penalty for armor. Where most high-level crawlers settled on a look for their personal brand, Louis embraced absurdity. One time, Nathan and I turned on a stream to see him wearing one of those full-body green man suits for a whole run. On another, he wore the jersey for his favorite football team–soccer to us–and white bell-bottom pants.

The crazy part was he made it work. The most outlandish clothing looked good on him. I used to think his dark complexion helped there, giving the bright colors a strong contrast that a pale boy like me could never manage. Nathan argued that it was one hundred percent swagger. Louis was just that confident and cool.

After a few years of watching his runs, I agreed. Louis had an intangible quality to his personality and presence that made everything he did or wore look good.

“Nad-Nade is putting together a crawl team,” Nathan said. Nad-Nade was an energy drink brand. “They’re planning an Asia run, from Poland to Japan in a year basically.”

“Jesus.”

“Right? I don’t care how much money you throw at that. There’s no way that’s happening.”

“I don’t know, man. They’ll send a small army along for an escort and for media.”

Nathan laughed. “Nope. Ten-person team, they said. They're doing all their own filming. No crew.”

“Yeah, not a chance.”

“How much money do you think they’re getting?”

“An absurd amount,” I said without thinking. 

Huh. That was interesting. Could an independent crawler get that kind of deal for hunting the wilds, or did I need to be an influencer?

Chapter 5: Workplace Safety

My next few workdays were spent at my desk auditing crawler reports. After every gate, crawlers were required to capture a range of data to help the CDM better rate the estimated difficulty of gates or to uncover other patterns in how dungeons were structured. Satellites could log the mana levels of a gate with relative accuracy, but that was a crude estimator of difficulty.

Two different combinations of monsters could have the same mana reading, but one combination could be far more challenging than the other. The bugbear wipe we cleaned up, for example, had the same mana reading as a bugbear dungeon that only had vanilla shamans, no necromancers. 

There were always rumors that better gate technology was coming, and the conspiracy crowd believed that tech had already been invented and buried to protect some unnamed billionaire’s interests. 

Me? I figured there was too much money in dungeon crawling for better tech to not get out if it existed. I didn’t doubt people were working on new ideas, but I wasn’t optimistic about what the future held on that front. We had been using more or less the same tech for fifty years. We got better at logging and analyzing data, but the method at its core hadn’t changed.

My role in this CDM effort was to ensure that crawlers properly filled out their reports. If they didn’t, they would get reprimanded, which could eventually lead to their crawler licenses being revoked.

When Grensmith grabbed me for a day of fieldwork, I leapt out of my chair as quickly as I could.

“Have you done harvester audits before?” he asked as we pulled out of the garage.

“No, sir. Only the training modules.”

“Good. Everyone else teaches it wrong. You’ll have a better foundation this way.”

I nodded.

“What’s the highest-ranked gate you’ve visited?”

“C.”

“Our list today is all Bs and As,” Grensmith said. “These sites are different animals entirely. If a B gate pops up downtown, suddenly we’re rerouting traffic and have to make sure that the worksite is safe and secure for the workers as well as the civilians. It’s never not a mess.”

Bridges, tunnels, and highway interchanges closing unexpectedly were regular occurrences. The one time you didn’t check your route before you left was the time you got stuck in gridlock at the Liberty Tunnel for three hours. Most people had automated alerts for changes on their usual routes, but everyone had at least one story where a gate opened right when they were between exits on the interstate, and then they ran out of gas waiting for traffic to move.

The first gate was in one of the extended lots for the city’s professional football stadium, which was the most convenient location for a gate within city limits I had ever heard of. 

Grensmith seemed to agree. “This gate will be more orderly than you’re likely to ever see again,” he said as we pulled up to a guarded entrance.

A temporary chain-link fence wrapped the lot, and I couldn’t actually see the gate from the outside, only mobile trailers and a collection of semi-trucks with empty flatbeds. 

He flashed his credentials out the window. The man at the entrance made a note, and then we were let inside.

“Feels like a fortress, right?” Grensmith asked.

“Definitely does.”

“Harvest teams usually try to obscure as much of the gate activity as possible, so that’s why we’ve got this wagon circle of trailers. More than half your citations will be placement violations because these crews only care about the gate. If three driveways and a pedestrian bridge get blocked, they’ll go through with it because it’s easier.”

Looking around at the expanse of the scene as we drove deeper, I said, “This looks like a lot of ground for two people to cover.”

I had done all of the modules on these regulations, and they could be exceptionally granular. In the early days, workplace safety regulations didn’t extend to dungeon harvesters, and a lot of people got hurt and exploited. Now, most any rule that would matter in a factory or on a construction site applied to dungeon sites. 

Personal protective equipment like hard hats, eye protection, and gas detectors, for example, were just as mandatory in a dungeon as they were on more traditional hazardous job sites. For harvesters. Not crawlers. Crawlers were treated more like military mercenaries.

Get the job done without dying. We don't care how.

“We’re auditing audits,” Grensmith explained. “We do these at random or with problem harvesters because you’ll write a citation for blocking a street with a forklift, they move it, and then as soon as you pull away, they put it right back. So, when you start doing audits yourself, pull the history for every outfit on site. It’s hard to catch all the problems with a walkthrough, but if there’s oil on the pavement, you figure you got an oil leak, right?”

“Right.”

“These guys have a history of skimping on harvester security and equipment inspection logs.” He handed me a white hard hat with the CDM logo on the front and put one on himself.

A young, clean-shaven man also in a white hard hat approached as soon as we stepped out of the SUV. His hard hat had the Dungeon Delvers Guild logo on both sides. They were one of the larger guilds in the country, and the Pittsburgh chapter was the largest guild in our region. 

“Enforcer Grensmith! Good to see you.” 

His flop sweat and darting eyes did a poor job hiding how anxious Grensmith’s presence made him. I was told that Grensmith was a stickler, which I experienced directly myself. If he was like that with internal procedures, he was probably just as harsh during inspections. He was not the enforcer you wanted to see walking onto your job site with a clipboard.

“Showing an intern the ropes,” he answered.

“We just had an audit yesterday.”

“I have to quality-check our reports,” Grensmith said. “Not my call, unfortunately.”

“No, no, I understand. If you need me, anyone on site here has a radio. Ask them, and I’ll be right over.”

“Appreciate it.”

All the harvesters going in and out of the dungeon had heat-protective suits, heavy-duty goggles, and special gloves. So this was a fire-type dungeon. 

Seeing workers ratchet-strapping dead fire salamanders for transport confirmed it. The monsters were roughly the size of cars and had to be loaded with cranes. If this gate had appeared in a neighborhood like Beechview with near-vertical Pittsburgh streets and lax parking rules, the trucks wouldn’t have fit, and definitely not a crane.

But the harvest would still happen regardless, so I could see how easily regulations and procedures could fall by the wayside when the gate location was awful.

Once all the valuable monsters had been extracted from the gate, the mining team would go in next. I saw a few of those teams starting to stage their gear, so the monster harvest for this gate was probably near completion. Fire-type dungeons often meant volcanic environments, and any dungeon with a lot of natural stone had potential for mineable resources.

In addition to a range of ore types, dungeons might have rare gemstones. Any gemstone that came out of a dungeon was infused with mana, a process that couldn’t yet be duplicated in a lab, making them exceptionally valuable. A volcanic dungeon might have mana-infused onyx, for example.

Once the harvest was complete, the crawlers would return and beat the boss to close the gate.

“I spot two code violations,” Grensmith said, crossing his arms.

Great. A test.

I scanned the job site. The obvious items seemed to be in order. I saw PPE on every worker. High-traffic areas were kept clear and unobstructed. Equipment and chemicals looked to be properly stored and secured. They had an alert system for when the main thoroughfare was off-limits for anyone on foot, such as when a small convoy of resources was on its way out. 

Shit. I couldn’t see anything wrong.

“I don’t know,” I admitted.

“You can run through the training again when we get back,” Grensmith said as if he was magnanimously letting me go outside for recess early. “First thing, any fire-type monster must be secured for transport with fire-resistant hardware. Those ratchet straps aren’t fire-resistant. They will probably be fine with fire salamanders, but about two months back we had a load of hellhound corpses break loose in the middle of I-70. They stay hot for a while, even after they’re dead. Heat went up, and the hardware failed.”

I listened closely and nodded along. 

Grensmith pointed to a row of wooden pallets, lined up on their sides like books on a shelf. “Pallets have to be stored flat. You store them like that, they warp, and then the next thing they carry wobbles off and crushes someone.”

Man, I wasn’t sure I’d ever notice something like that. Proper pallet storage procedure? That was entirely invisible to me.

Next, Grensmith got me inspection records for every piece of equipment on site. The foreman offered me a table in one of the trailer break rooms, and I sat down to review several dozen pages. While I did that, Grensmith went into the dungeon to continue his audit.

I looked for missing dates, inconsistent maintenance records, and falsified paperwork. If the crane had a perfect inspection history, then the maintenance records should reflect the effort it took to keep it in such good condition. Usually when harvesters forged one, they forgot to forge the other.

Grensmith also reminded me to enforce formatting standards. Dates were to be written with hyphens and the full year, not slashes and two-digit year entries. All times had to be in the military format, which was rarely enforced by anyone but Grensmith, apparently. He gave me a ten-minute lecture about why that breakdown could snowball into the collapse of the CDM, but I could see a “pick your battles” argument on that one.

I needed an hour to review everything, and the only issue I found was the use of the two-digit date format instead of four on a few records. Grensmith had me file a formal citation for the error. 

As I handed that notice over, I could feel how much the foreman loathed me. It occurred to me then that this could be another reason why CDM-trained crawlers rarely got picked up by guilds and teams. They spent the first legs of their careers pissing off the people who would decide whether or not to hire them later.

That was a terrible way to network, and I desperately needed to speak with someone at a guild or on a team who could confirm my chances of getting recruited post-CDM.

On our drive up the North Shore to the next harvester audit, I worked up the nerve to be direct with Grensmith.

“I hope this isn’t out of line, but I’d like to learn more about how guilds and teams work. How do you recommend I find someone to talk to about that? I’d like to get the inside perspective, if that makes sense.”

Grensmith glanced at me as he drove. “Looking to level up with the CDM and then jump to crawling?”

I didn’t see any point in lying. “Yes,” I answered.

He nodded. “I have a friend who’s in the Homestead Strikers. Are you familiar?”

“I know that they’re one of the oldest guilds in the city. Nothing else.”

“They’re an… interesting outfit. I can connect you with a crawler manager there, former CDM. She’ll shoot straight, but you should know their organization is a bit different from the modern crews.”

“How so?” I asked.

“The Homestead Strikers trace their lineage back to folks who fought in the Battle of Homestead. Andrew Carnegie sent in Pinkertons and the National Guard to break up a mill strike, once upon a time, and it turned into an actual battle. A good many steelworkers died, and they took down a few Pinkertons too. The Strikers bring that sort of energy into crawling.”

I had no idea what I was supposed to take from that.

“In case you’re struggling to keep up,” Grensmith said as if reading my mind, “they don’t trust outsiders, the majority of their people are legacy members, and they love an excuse to throw down.”

“Thank you for the warning.”

“Funny enough, groups like theirs drove a lot of the harvester safety regulations we’re enforcing today. This next gate is in an old mall, by the way. That sounds like it would make for a cleaner job site, but there are always squatters and looters causing trouble in places like those. Then we’ve got one in Squirrel Hill. That’ll be a disaster zone, and I expect you to catch every infraction I do.”

When Grensmith didn’t seem to want to talk anymore, I spent the rest of the drive reciting regulations in my mind. Maybe I could pull it off and find all of the same issues he did if I applied myself.

I could not, in fact, pull it off.

***

The Homestead Strikers manager Grensmith connected me to was a short but visibly powerful woman with a shaved head. I was always terrible at guessing any age under fifteen and any age over fifty, but she looked like an exceptionally healthy sixty or so years old to me. I couldn’t guess her class, but I had a feeling her level was pretty high. Over 10 at least.

Or maybe old women scared me. It’s hard to know for certain.

“Grensy told me you wanted to get a better view into how guilds work,” Kara said as she led me through the guild grounds for the Homestead Strikers.

The layout and scale of the place reminded me of the old steel mill I got to explore several days back for that Clairton E gate. Big buildings with sheet metal walls and rooftops. Wide lanes for tractor trailers and other machinery to move about more easily. Out-of-service railroad tracks running along the far edge of the property. The operation was massive, and most staff used golf carts to get around because walking would take too long.

“Yes, that’s right,” I answered. “He also mentioned you were CDM at one point?”

Kara chuckled and pointed me through a door. “Fifteen years of a forty-year career. That place is a meat grinder.”

Kara’s office was in one of the sheet metal buildings, and it felt more like a factory foreman’s office than I anticipated. She and seven other crawl managers shared a space with one of the guild’s refineries, making the air smell metallic and giving every surface a permanent layer of industrial grime.

Apparently, metals were the only dungeon resource the Homestead Strikers regularly processed in-house. Anything else brought out of a dungeon was sold off. Very few guilds processed any of the materials they harvested themselves.

“So,” she said as she sat, “what do you want to know?”

“I wanted to hear a perspective on the work from someone on the other side of the fence, and I’d also like to learn more about how you choose crawlers and harvesters to hire.”

Kara’s eyebrow raised. “Crawling is the only thing you actually want to talk about.”

“It’s the topic I’m most interested in, sure, but I do care about the other stuff.”

“I’m not saying you don’t. The pipeline from CDM work to guild work is a pretty common topic, is all. With the right CDM resume, management and harvesting are solid exit plans. If you survived the bureaucracy of the CDM, any other office job feels downright utopian, and the brains of a guild will welcome you with open arms. Crawling isn’t open at all, I’m afraid.”

“Is it that hard to get a chance?” I asked.

“That’s the thing. There is no chance to get. Groups like the Strikers rarely bring in an outside recruit, and if they do, it’s a caster class of some kind. Otherwise, the crawlers are all the great-grandkids or whatever of the founding members. I worked my way up from associate manager, thinking I could get a shot at crawling once I was on the inside.”

Kara paused to shake her head.

“Nope. Didn’t happen. It’s the same story with any of the other CDM guys at any other outfit too.”

Now I saw why Grensmith facilitated this conversation. He was giving me a reality check. I wondered if this was something he did to all interns who had goals like mine.  

“I’m sorry to come down on your dreams like that,” Kara said, sincerely sympathetic. “I wish someone had talked sense into me earlier. Adjusting would have been easier.”

“You struck me as someone who leveled a bit.”

Kara grinned. “Always nice to get a compliment from the next generation. Anyway, I never said you couldn’t crawl. You’re just not getting in with any of the major guilds or teams. I ran gates on my days off. Lost money on them most of the time. D and E gates are duds more often than anyone lets on.”

“I see.”

“Listen, crawler management isn’t a bad gig,” she said. “I don’t get to run dungeons, but supporting the crawlers who do gives me a little secondhand taste of it.”

“What does that kind of work entail?”

“My job is to ensure that my crawlers enter a gate as prepared as possible. That means keeping gear maintenance schedules on track, coordinating crawl logistics and timing, administering payroll, and sometimes making party-level changes so that the best combinations of people are working together.”

“Oh, that does sound cool.”

Cool for someone who wasn’t me.

Files