IX-49 Outburst (Patreon)
Content
Hatred is addicting. Cruelty can become comfort. Sadness is a sanctuary when it seeps into the right thoughts and calcifies into routines.
Such is the insidiousness of one's heart. Humans are not built to be perfect creatures. No being of emotion is, but emotion is not a flaw in and of itself. Emotion is meant to warn you. It is meant to impart lessons upon you, but these lessons can be misshaped. These instincts, these impulses, are that which reside long past our beasthood, from the point where we should have been as mere monsters as well.
As individuals, we must learn to ride and grapple with our emotions, as a charioteer must understand how to direct their steeds. Your heart seeks not only to betray you but also to feed you, to engender patterns of behavior that support and ensure your survival. These patterns are blind, and the animal inside of you is not so mindful, as the brain and the mind are dramatically different.
So too must your discipline be part of the equation, and thus you must decide and shape yourself, for what one controls, in actuality, is not the world within. If you are honest, then you would understand so much of your emotion is felt on reflex. You cannot force joy upon yourself, not without significant acts of meditation and self-rearrangement, but you can affect the environment around you. You can guide your thoughts, and you can harness the world between.
A great part of individuality and sapience is understanding that you are merely a byway, a bridge, for the reactions of that which is basest and the world outside, which resides under the highest. The best individuals know how to affect both vicinities at the end of that bilateral path, which they represent.
And always remember, you are what you do, and you are especially what you do in repetition and by habit. But habits can change, repetition can be broken, and a new pattern can be sprung. It is a simple thing in decision and action, but difficult for the heart. All you need and must do is to break the pattern before it repeats anew.
Or be fortunate enough to have someone else break the stability of your life so that they can impart a better pattern upon you.
—Whim and Futility: A Mage’s Guide to Internal Psychomancy by [Name Redacted by Inquisition]
IX-49
Outburst
“He’s gone fucking mad! Deathless! Deathless! Do you hear me? It doesn’t matter who he was to you! That man is gone, and what stands in his place—”
A deafening crackle echoed through the kitchen as Shiv sank his lunarite chef's knife halfway through the cutting board. The fact his knife was only half through the board was a sign of control and restraint, as Shiv's cutting aura could peel through all unattuned matter with little resistance. Another sign that he was more annoyed than outraged was his expression: tight and weary, but bereft of anger.
A long sigh hissed out from Shiv as he stared both the Educator and the Councilwoman down, with the former more agitated than the latter, while Veronica continued to scheme and plot in private.
“That's the first time I've ever heard you curse,” Shiv said. “But you picked a hell of a thing to waste your virginity on.”
Maia’s glare and nostrils flared with equal intensity. “Hell of a thing? Hell of a thing? You were there. He clung to your leg. He begged you for your mercy. And you abandoned him. You abandoned him to this degenerate shadow, this ruined, decaying thing that you still see as your battle brother!”
A spark of obsidian black flame split from Shiv's irises. He pressed his lips together tightly. “First of all, he is still my brother. Second, he's not degenerating. He's not gone senile. He's not suffering from whatever godly dementia that ate through you and is still eating through whatever Ascendants are still left alive. I would have noticed when I glanced at his soul, and if you were paying any attention at all, you would have understood that he hasn't gone wrong in the head. He's just gone hard of heart and soul—and I'm fully aware of how bleak things are.
“I don't much like watching him grow hateful and angry and vicious and tyrannical, but considering the circumstances, I'm happy that he's still as much himself as he is rather than the Sage running around using him as some kind of meat puppet to crush everything and torture everyone until they obey his sovereign idea of peace and heroism without recourse. Because let me tell you, from what I know of the Sage, there would be no Stormhalt as Avatar—no orc enforcers. There would be no one but the Sage and the Sage alone speaking to us. If it was just the Sage, then we'd have been funneling our asses back out from this palm along the anchors before we entered because there is no possible way, no possible argument on my part, no matter how persuasive I am, to convince that titanic jackass away from giving you all a mandatory jewelry fitting.”
“Is that your response?” Maia's voice took on a hysterical tint. “That we should just be grateful he isn't worse, that he could be even more of a monster if he fully gave in to the presence inside of him? That's what I should take solace in?”
“Yes, Maia.” Shiv suppressed the growl threatening to slip into his voice. “Yes, you should take solace in that. You should take solace in the fact that Adam still regards me as his battle brother. You should take solace in the fact that I hold genuine affection for him, and he does for me, because if that wasn't the case, nothing would stop him from giving you a wreath, and there would be nothing, not even of your Divinity, that would spare you from such a miserable existence.”
A bitter chuckle escaped his throat. “Your heart breaks for your friend Matthew. You feel sad that your fellow Ascendant is so tortured, so miserable. Well, you would feel worse if you got to experience everything he did firsthand, because there's nothing left of him. It was nothing, nothing that magic could fix, nothing that I could conceivably put together after ten trillion years of effort, even if I was the greatest Psychomancer in Integration. There was simply no foundation to rebuild. Whatever ego I would slap on him would be an ego forcibly imparted. It wouldn't be him anymore. But you want to know what the Sage did? It fixed him. It restored him to his fullest health in an instant: all of him, soul, heart, mind, everything. Some-fucking-how. There's another thing too: the Sage, right, has an influence over the world. It restructured an entire part of reality without using any mana at all. None.”
Shiv leaned across the chrome stove-top to impose his shadow over Maia. “Do you have any clue how that works, how that is? Because I sure as shit don't. Every other god has to use their Divinity to force things into being—mana. Yeah, sure, they fill up all of reality, but I can still see that. I can sense that, but what came from the Sage is another kind of force altogether, one I have no godsdamn clue about. Do you? If you know anything now, Maia, you better tell me, 'cause I'm going through a lot of surprises—and believe me when I say that it’s taking a lot on my part to keep myself together. Because the truth is, I'm too godsdamn late. Too late to stop my friend from being hardened by hatred. Too goddamn late to stop Roland and—and Nullity from being dumb-fucks and—”
Veronica did a double-take. “You're blaming them?”
“Of course, I'm godsdamned blaming them!” Shiv snapped. He bubbled with miserable laughter. “However vicious Adam is, whatever darkness was coming over him, they tried to strike a deal with Avalon. Well, at least that's what Adam said, and considering that my Oroborous didn't come out and just swallow him, he’s not lying. So yes, they are dumb-fucks. Yes, this is their fault. Yes, they made a dumb fucking decision. They shit all over everything, and now I have to wipe their remaining… fucking… residue away and pull Adam back from the edge. I need to be the one that carefully puts Adam’s broken heart back together after they broke him even more!”
He planted his palms atop the heated stove and sagged with emotional exhaustion. “The worst part of it all is that he's wretched now, but he isn't entirely wrong.”
A ragged noise escaped Maia as her heart sputtered with indignation and anguish. “Isn't wrong? Isn’t—he’s tortured—Matthew—”
“Is only going to get out of this because I decided to be smart instead of blindly emotional,” Shiv said through clenched teeth. “I gave Adam an out, and at least he's considering it. I gave him a means of asserting himself and a means for the Sage to let this poor son of a bitch go. I can only do that by giving him my company so that I can use him to pragmatic ends. To lure Roland and Nullity out so I can speak with them. And Adam probably knows this on some level. Even the Sage does. I'm a scheming bastard, and they've been there since the start of my days, but they decided to go along with it because I didn't tread on the Tyrant's myth, and I appealed to Adam’s better virtues. Because he’s still a God of Heroism, and saying no is self-mutilation too.”
Maia clenched her fists. “How could he be a God of Heroism and indulge in such… such vile—”
“Revenge can be extreme, and heroism doesn't mean mercy or nobility or charity.” Shiv's Harbinger, already overstretched against the dam of his heart, gave some of the Deathless's resolve. It went away as he rolled his eyes in open mockery of the Educator.
"Look at me.” She didn’t. Something burst inside Shiv—and his fist dented his board and sent clean-sliced meat spattering everywhere! “Fuck you! Don't turn away! Look at me. You too, Veronica! Look at me!”
And they did, though neither of the two seemed particularly pleased with his tone. Frankly, he didn't give a shit about that. Not anymore, not right now, maybe not ever again, because they forgot themselves. They sank into themselves. If there was an overarching sin that defined the two of them, it would be selfishness: everything for them and only them, everything to feed their ego.
Shiv looked around the kitchen, a kitchen barren of Adam's Awareness. Though the Tyrant's omniscience was absolute, he held himself back. He refused to breach his privacy because he trusted Shiv, but that didn't mean Adam was stupid. Far from it: he was hateful, rageful, bitter, resentful after all he went through, but he was not stupid. He likely knew that there would be plotting and scheming, people whispering in Shiv's ear about what he needed to do.
But still, he expressed trust in Shiv. Yet the trust was also a test to see if Shiv was still who he was, and if not…
Well, Adam was immortal now. He would survive whatever betrayal Shiv could plot. It would darken him for sure, but he would survive, and that would place Shiv in the most miserable of circumstances.
Circumstances that Roland and Nullity clearly failed to consider—or simply refused to think about at the end of their patience.
“What’s happening to us now,” Shiv began, trying to keep his hands from trembling, “is your godsdamned fault. Both of you.”
Both Veronica and Maia responded with offense, which Shiv cut off with a raised hand, especially toward Veronica, as he pointed the harshest glare of his life at her skull.
"Grandma, I'm saying this as sweetly as I can, but if you use your voice on me, if you argue with me right now, I'm going to carve through your fucking Magical Resistance, reach into your soul, rip out your Rehtoric, and beat you with it until you go crawling to Adam begging for a crown instead.”
And he meant that. He meant that in so many different ways, and all the rage, the fury, the unaddressed emotions he had to put up with in relation to her, came spilling out.
“You two selfish damn…” Shiv swallowed, barely managing to get a hold of his aggravation as his lips twitched. He clutched his hands together hard enough to turn coal into diamonds and let out a slow, calming breath, forcing his anger to go cold. “How do you think we got here? You know what, never mind that. Let's start with another question, a simpler question: How would you define fate?”
The two looked at each other, and he felt Gone listening by the doorway. She'd likely heard a rumble of anger from the outside. But no one else intruded. No one else dared. She was the only one, and he took no offense to that.
“What is the point of riddles?” Maia asked.
“Fate,” Shiv answered on her behalf, “in my definition, is being downstream of someone else's choices and therefore the inheritor of consequences that aren't your own. An inheritor of consequences that aren't your own." He repeated himself before sweeping his eyes across the two of them pointedly. "Does that sound like something you two are familiar with? We're all a little bit beholden to someone else, of yours. We all have to suffer a measure of fate. But I gotta ask: What the hells fucked the two of you up so much that you had to dump so much shit downstream? Hm? Tell me, because I really want to know. Mainly so I can spot and prevent it in other people, so that no one else has to suffer from this specific set of repeating tragedies again.”
A stressful sheen of sweat was beginning to build upon Shiv's brow, and he wiped it away. It was the closest hint to the inner turmoil his Harbinger now warred against. “Before all the other bastards was the Great One. Sure, fine: original sin attributed to original sinner and all that. I'll get to her in time, but you two, you had a choice. After you realized what was going wrong,” Shiv looked at Maia, “you could have given up your godhood entirely, but no, you're still holding on to a measure of that. Once you managed to stop your dementing, you decided to work with Udraal. And look at that mess. Look at what happened there. Look at the shape of all your sins standing in front of you, now lecturing you for everything you've done. Where is Udraal? Where is he?”
No answer from Maia.
"Udraal?" Shiv called aloud and held a hand next to his ear. “No answer from Udraal.” Shiv shook his head and laughed, mainly to mock his distant, absent creator, but also because he knew Udraal was likely listening in some-fucking-how, observing him with that stupid smirk on its face as all his plans came together regardless of whatever unpredictable nonsense occurred. “You're just another patsy, another pawn. All your attempts at playing the game, and you never got anywhere.”
As he finished with Maia, his gaze swiveled to Veronica, and his face underwent a series of acrobatic maneuvers.
Now that he had time, and was forced to witness the depths Adam had sunk to, he traced part of that back to Veronica, and it took a Legendary-Tier effort on his part not to launch himself over the table and strangle her, resuscitate her, strangle her again, and repeat all that for a thousand times. He knew in his bones that it would feel good, but he stopped himself, because he was a slave to neither myth nor trauma, and he would never be.
He had to be a little bit more enlightened. He had to be the smart one, the decisive one.
Adam was now a god and therefore crippled of free will, and Shiv had to be free will incarnate to make up for that.
“Grandma, I don't know what happened to you when you grew up or after. You don't tell me these things because you're afraid that I might try to use whatever knowledge of you I have to kill you, like your first kid or whatever. But I'm not your first kid. I can kill you right now. I can let Adam kill you right now. And I'm not going to, because I'm not blind or stupid or selfish enough to be like you! Not only because you're still useful and an extremely competent Pathbearer, but also because I don’t much like repeating that specific set of behaviors!”
Shiv was basically fuming now as he stared at her, his own eyes wide. “‘Councilwoman of the Yellowstone Republic.’ What a fucking joke! What ‘Councilwoman’ are you? Is this ‘Republic’ in the room with us right now? You're just a fucking queen, and you're an incompetent queen at that. You're a queen who's feeding off the drunkenness of the gods above her. You're a queen and a pimp and a drug dealer and a boss of children, of broken fucks that should have never been gods. Daughter is a victim. Her mother cares about her sometimes, but not nearly enough because she's drowned too. The Starhawk, Kathereine, all of them could have been remedied if you applied any bit of morality to the situation, but never mind morality. Let's move on to pragmatism. The Ascendants are on a death spiral, and you just let it run! You let them fall! You feel bad for poor little Matthew. Oh, you do? I feel bad for everyone who's died during one of my fights. I feel bad for all the poor, unfortunate orphans who are born with the sin of being godsdamn orphans in the Yellowstone Republic, because if they're a girl, they are probably getting fed to a psychotic killing machine that didn't even need to be that, and if they're boys, they're probably ending up in the Inquisition to butcher political disidents. I feel bad for the millions of people who died in the Abyss thanks to the Starhawk’s mad crusade. And I feel bad for everyone who lived under the both of you, because it's all about you, you, you! The only time a single person matters is when it's someone you care about. When it's one of your people. All of you are like this! You don't think outside of yourself. You don't imagine what it means to be a person, and you don't feel the weight of killing people. You don't think about what you're doing to people. You don't think about what you're doing to your own home, your own kingdom, to the world, to yourself, until it's too late. Then, when the consequences come back around centuries or decades later, I have to pay them! Me, and then Adam and Uva! Us! It's fucking absurd! Ridiculous. Hopeless. Gate Piety was fucked from the start, but you all sure did your best to ram the Challenger’s fist just a few centimeters deeper up our collective ass.”
He began chortling with laughter. He chose laughter because, if not for laughter, he would either tear his own head off or give in to a berserk frenzy of violence. “Matthew is a screaming, wretched wreck of a man, in part because you didn't do anything early on. If you'd nipped the problem in the bud, if you'd decided to be wise, even if you weren't kind or decent, we wouldn't be here. Submission wouldn't have been burned. You're whining about Adam torturing Matthew? Well, let me tell you this: Adam gave Matthew a little crown. You want to know what that crown does? It makes you relive all the suffering of your past sins, all the misdeeds carved into you, burrowing deep. All that suffering, all that agony, inflicted over and over again until you learn to master it. All your sins, never forgiven, never forgotten, but you still have to carry that weight. And somehow fucking Havel Van Stormhalt managed it! One of the most pathetic motherfuckers I've ever met!”
Shiv shook his head and held his hands up apologetically to nobody in the room. “You know what, good for him, good for him! I didn't know he had it in him! I was ready to mourn his loss, but I guess people do surprise us sometimes.” And an almost-sob escaped Shiv in the form of a scoff. “I just wish you would… You didn't need to be my grandma. You don't owe me anything. I don't care that you abandoned my dad because you're afraid of your position, or that you've abandoned me only to use me as your attack dog. I don't care about any of that now. It's been fucking centuries. I'm past a lot of this inherited trauma bullshit. But looking at you still makes me want to cry because what a miserable life, what a pointless series of sacrifices. No real family, no real power anymore, because guess what: all the vehicles of your power turned out to be degenerated, and you decided to feed their sickness instead of treating the disease. And now look at you, at my mercy, spared from someone else's tyranny. You're going to hate it here, Veronica. I know you will. But what else do you got? Paradise? No, that's not yours. You can't choose Avalon either, because it'll just rip you away from yourself. You won't even be your own ruler in the most ontological senses, and that would be hell unto itself, wouldn't it? Wouldn’t it?”
Veronica's composure proved impressive even now, but her stoicism on the outside could not hide the damage inflicted within. She was a nest of cracks, and all the stuff spilling out from her was pain and regret and hopelessness.
Because he was right. Shiv knew he was. There was no real rebuttal to his words. It was the rawest of truths, not something one could deflect or argue away with sophistry or games of logic. She was at his mercy, his and Adam's, but because Shiv didn't want to be like her, she was spared from the fate she most certainly would have inflicted if she was in his place.
More importantly, she wanted to be in Adam's place. She would have likely desired to wield the Tyrant in another life. Perhaps she would have made a fine wielder indeed, but that wasn't this life, and that wasn't her lot. A big part of that was simply because she kept making the stupid, short-sighted, simple-minded choices.
“Easy power for a few more years. Kick the ball down the road. This group of nobles is going rogue. Kill them, Shiv. Oh, you randomly killed thousands of people including a bunch of kids? That's alright, Jessica! You're a Legend, so let's just get you addicted to the memory of your dead husband. What? We need to sacrifice children to sustain one of our Ascendants? Well, just use the orphans. Who gives a shit about them anyway? Longinus is a roving, gluttonistic, pedophilic, hedonistic, slave-keeping rapist murderer psychopath? Forget omelets and eggs, you can't have eggs without forcing someone on a few chickens! Am I right? Huh? You fucking…”
Shiv swallowed hard, his hands twitching so hard he almost couldn't control them. “You know… I used to wonder what it would feel like to be human. If my mind wasn't based off of that of a Tarrasque. Now I wish I was more Tarrasque so I could just hate you truer, deeper, hate you as much as you should be hated, because somehow, despite everything, I still think of you as my grandma. Isn't that fucked up? Well, that's just my weakness, I suppose. You would never make that mistake now. Just give away all your kids and pretend that you're stone. But how powerful are you now? How indestructible?”
For all the threat he posed and all the dark desires he wished to inflict, he was an implacable bullwhip. He was a true immortal as well, and he let nothing stop him. He was truest to himself and only himself, and there was a sanctuary in that. There was a reassurance of that.
The Thief would have never allowed such a thing to transpire. The Thief would have silenced the Ascendants. The Thief would have quelled anyone who betrayed their own legend. And for the first time, perhaps ever, Shiv realized what it truly meant to be the Thief: to be so disgusted with the wrongness infesting everyone else, not just their morality, but their imperfection. Mortality was a disease in more ways than one.
And so deep was Shiv's bitterness that the Harbinger joined in as well. “Always someone else's problem, always someone else's burden, always someone else's consequence, and pray that I die before it ever comes to roost for me.”
“Adam.” Shiv pinched the bridge of his nose to mask the depths of his sadness. “He deserved a lot more than to become this. He deserved more than all his suffering. We were all barely twenty. We were kids. Kids wiping the asses of gods. And the only one who ever consistently lived up to their godhood was the fucking Challenger—which makes me want to throw up. But Adam always had his eye on the ball. Every time there was a quest, he was on the quest. Every time there was a problem, he tried to solve the problem. Every time he came close to breaking, he pulled himself back because he couldn't just leave me by myself. No, he couldn't, right? He couldn't leave me alone. He couldn't abandon me. He had that responsibility in him, more responsibility than his father would actually know.”
Now Shiv was just fanning the flames in his own stomach, his angry rant crashing from one person to another. “Fucking Roland Arrow, stupid cocksucker, dumb motherfucking cunt. For a man so ‘fundamentally decent,’ he really consistently does the most fucked-up thing he can at the worst possible time, huh? He's like you, Veronica, in all the ways you probably hate. He could have said no to the Starhawk. What else was the Starhawk supposed to do? Find someone else? There's no one like Roland. Who else was going to descend down the Abyss? Who else would have burned Submission and murdered hundreds of thousands so easily? Who else could have rebuffed Sullain? Another miserable bastard eaten by fate. Godsdamn all of you for making me feel bad for him! But the fact that he ever became an issue in the first place is also Roland’s fault. He could have just been left alone to prophesize and do whatever faith shit he wanted downstairs, but no, we had to keep the Republic strong! We have to spread our stolen Divinity upon every citizen! It would have totally worked. All the Phylacteries in Submission would have definitely ascended everyone to perfect equal godhood forever, no flaws this time! Surely!”
Shiv sighed again. “Look at Matthew now. Look at all of us. Look at what you did to your favorite son. Look at what he did to his son. And look at what he did to you. How the hells am I supposed to bring him back from the brink? I don’t even know if I can! And I hate that. I hate it. I hate how I’m always fixing someone else’s sins. Someone else’s mistakes. I hate how I’m the only one that learns. Me and…”
He couldn’t finish. A great ennui threatened to consume him—his Harbinger driven to the brink.
But Shiv himself made a choice: to reject despair.
Because he could—and he found power in spite and responsibility. “You know what? Do whatever you want. I don’t give a shit anymore. I’ll handle it. I'll be the adult you all should have been while you were busy playing at being Pathbearer or god. And right now, I want some time to think and plan, but I want to do that alone. That means I need you out of my fucking kitchen, right now, because I have some very rusty skills to sharpen for the Reunion Festival. And if you guys can’t keep it down during the celebration, then you can stay here, or back in Road’s End with the Thief. Up to you. For now, just leave me alone. Please.”
He leaned halfway over his stove, staring at the ruined ingredients he'd scattered in his earlier outburst. Maia and Veronica lingered a bit too long, but they finally departed when they realized he meant what he said and that he was done—that the resentment he held toward them was alive and strong even now.
They fled, silent shadows breaking in two different directions at the door. For what else did they have to say to each other? Even less did they have to say to him, but with their banishment came another intruder, the one Shiv didn't cast away.
Gone sped fast across time and distance, briefly hugging him before breaking away. "You alright?" Gone said.
He didn't have the strength to meet her gaze. He shook his head. "Not right now. But I'll bounce back. I always bounce back. I'll get back on the proverbial griffon after that. You should go speak with Adam if you can. He’ll be happy to see you. Really happy. He probably needs this more than I do.”
But Gone didn’t leave. “I’m sorry your grandma isn’t a real grandma. I wish the Realmrunner wasn’t my dad.”
Shiv snorted. “Fuck Veronica, but she’s still better than that insane sack of shit. Gone.” The goblin blinked, waiting for him to continue. “Just… don’t destroy yourself. Don’t sink into the pain. It’ll just take from you. Take and it won’t give back. I know you're still hurting. I know it's an unreasonable ask, but everyone tells themselves a story about the pain they have and the scars they develop. It doesn't make you better. It just makes you adapt to the hurt, but also, that makes you crippled another way. If you can be a whole person again, you try, and if you can be better than whole, you do that too. I’m tired of carrying the mistakes of broken people. I’m tired of everyone being broken. Everyone but me and the other freaks and monsters.”
“You’re not a freak or a monster,” Gone said softly.
Shiv snorted. “Then, what am I?”
She patted his leg and smiled. “The best of us.”
Then, with a bolt of golden lightning, she lived up to her name and blasted out from the kitchen-mansion into the mists to seek out Adam. The relief of her presence lasted long after the fading of her afterimage.
Drawing in a long breath, Shiv reached into his cape to deal with the next conversation. He was already in a dogshit mood, so he might as well speak to his master. Shiv wasn’t going to be cooking anything decent in this state anyway.
Thus, Shiv thrust the key out and twisted, and with that came a snap and the opening of a door. On the other side was an empty glass cavern, devoid of life or mana. Not unexpected. The Thief wouldn’t just be waiting there if Shiv intended to betray him to the Tyrant—he could avoid and escape the mists if he wasn’t taken by an ambush.
Crossing over, Shiv staggered with every step as he tried to regain his composure—only to groan as he sensed his master’s presence behind him.
“Not quite the happy reunion you expected, is it, my disciple?”
“Master,” Shiv began, turning to regard the Thief with a tired nod. “I hope you weren’t too lonely while I was gone.”
“I survived.” The Thief grinned. “More so than you, I see.”
“Hm,” Shiv grunted. “Yeah, about that. I’d like to start this conversation by calling you a liar, and asking why the Oroborous didn’t eat you.”
The Thief’s grin faltered. “Oh, and why is that?”
“You kept going on about how much of Adam is left and how much the Sage must’ve eaten away, and how his mortality was going to bother me… Was that all just to psyche me out, or were you really ignorant to the fact that he’s immortal now too?”
The Thief blinked, and failed to reply promptly.
“Oh,” Shiv breathed as the dark clouds inside him broke to give way before savage relish. “You didn’t know. You assumed, and you assumed wrong. Well. Isn’t that a first.”