IX-50 Misinformation (Patreon)
Content
Misinformation is a poison subtle in many ways. Obvious misinformation has been addressed in your general coursework. This course is about sifting through more insidious forms of misinformation that pervade the source itself.
Sometimes those who deliver misinformation to you do not know that they are wrong .This is the most dangerous kind of misinformation, for it finds its roots in a tainted primary source. If one primary source is tainted, then it's very likely that the environment is compromised as well. Worse yet, this information will also cause your entire structural analysis of a situation to be placed in doubt, for whatever world model you apply to simulations and predictions is now potentially inaccurate.
These bits of misinformation usually result from a variety of factors, such as individual ignorance, stupidity, dogma, and so on. You must link the exact cause to the exact individual, and from there work backwards to find the origination point of this mistake. Perhaps the harder part is noticing the mistake in the first place, for this category of misinformation is not so easily picked out from the rest of the crop.
Assuming your enemy's military forces are inherently corrupt, then it will be hard to tell what resources they have to bear. Simply guessing that they are weaker in every aspect and that they cannot adapt to our movements is a gamble that New Albion cannot afford. There have been a great many nations riven and rotted to the bedrock by corruption that have fought to their last and somehow prevailed due to the heroism and great skill of their esteemed individuals.
Never forget, we live in a time of the individual over the masses, in the time of the exalted elite. As such, the influence a single person may have on the grand scheme of the board cannot be understated. As such, you must be the difference maker yourself. You must notice all incongruities, and you must isolate any piece of the story that does not fit. That which is assumed can be fatal, and that which isn't known is unacceptable.
Worst of all, misinformation can infest anyone, from the lowliest of fools to the greatest of minds, for information is not intelligence, and intelligence comes second to information…
—Aviary Analyst Qualification Training
IX-50
Misinformation
The Thief lingered in a state of tense silence for a good few seconds, in part waiting for Shiv to say something else, but also hoping that the Oroborous would devour the Deathless as it proclaimed its user to have spat a lie. Neither happened, and so the Thief was forced further into discomfort. Such was much to Shiv's pleasure; he so rarely attained an edge over his master, and he would relish in this moment, especially with his comfort so paltry now—he would sip triumph from whatever puddles were offered.
“He's still himself?” The Thief's question was bookended by bated breath. He wanted Shiv to think on that, to say something different, but he didn't. He simply answered with a nod, one with such immediacy that the Thief was thrown for another loop. “This cannot be the case. He shouldn't have… Roland—”
“Isn't there,” Shiv growled, clenching his teeth tight. “Neither he nor the girl are here. They ran off after Roland shot an arrow through Adam's eye. He killed his mortal body, but Adam came back. He's fully immortal now, resurrected in more ways than one. He's bound to the Sage's myth, and through all our talks, the Sage only echoed grumbled inside Adam. Beyond that, he never took center stage. He never snarled at me, never barked. Adam has him locked down tight, or they're attuned so tightly together that it doesn't matter, and the Sage has bowed to an acceptable tyrant in its stead.”
Shiv smacked his lips together and tutted apologetically. “Sorry, Master, but I'm afraid your information might be wrong. Adam isn't just a god; he's full-on immortal. Roland shit all over the floor, and I have to mop it up again because Adam is somewhere north of hateful. I am now the only moderating influence on his behavior.”
A panoply of expressions flickered across the Thief's face. He was at a complete loss for words, and Shiv fell to the swell of dominance—the flavor of this edge is so sweet and refreshing that it annulled much of his weariness.
At least for now.
“Something must be wrong," the Thief began.
Shiv smirked, and he smirked so wide that the Thief began glowering at him. "You're right, Master. Something or someone must be wrong, and I think I have an idea of who I want to bet my mithril on."
“Stop leering at me like a fox outside the hen house. Tell me everything about him. Tell me all you have learned. Tell me, and stop mocking me, for this is of grave importance, especially in our campaign against Avalon. Something has gone wrong. Something does not fit, and I, as you know, am so rarely incorrect.”
And though Shiv wanted to continue rubbing salt in his master's wounded ego, he didn't, for the Thief was right about that last part. He was so rarely wrong, and now they both had to figure out why he was this time.
***
Recounting his reunion, the Thief listened with rapt attention, and Shiv, despite his discomfort, spared no detail. It was essential that the Thief knew everything, not to mention that he would sift things out anyway. No point in being coy or sly about the truth.
Everything came to a sudden halt when Shiv addressed Roland's betrayal and rebellion. "You claim that he tried to strike a bargain with Avalon," the Thief said with a scowl.
“I don't claim anything. That's what Adam told me, and the Oroborous didn't eat him. Unless he has Oroborous-defying power… Maybe he has; he's exerting a lot of influence over reality. The force he compelled is not mana, but it is still an undeniable force. I felt it.”
“It shouldn't be that,” the Thief muttered to himself. “Avalon is capable of wielding Canons, though it is reluctant to use them. My graver concern is with Roland. Avalon, at least the Avalons I have corrupted and swept through, know nothing of this bargain. They know not where Roland is. They have not Excaliburized him. They are still hunting for him. Furthermore, they know nothing of the girl either—the one spawned of you, the one Adam calls Nullity.”
The last embers of amusement went out within Shiv. Tension took hold. “But how is that possible? If Adam didn't lie, and you don't know, and if the Oroborous has eaten neither of you, then what are we missing?”
For once, the Thief looked as disturbed as Shiv. “I… do not know.”
“Those are the most terrifying words you ever said to me," Shiv mumbled.
“It continues to be the most terrifying thing I tell myself,” the Thief agreed. “There are only a few possibilities. Either the Avalons have formed intelligent cells unto themselves, which could be possible, but with each of them being a Superintelligence, they shouldn't be able to keep so much information hidden away from me. I have penetrated deep across their entire network. There are few of them who remain spared of my presence, and even they have been pulled into this abyss. There is no way out for them, and I will eventually see all of them infiltrated. But for them to hold this from me means that we might be dealing with another interloper, another force that none of us know about.”
A chain of theories went through Shiv's mind: conspiracies deduced from likelihood and convenience. "You think that the Great One might have another disciple aside from you, other instruments of use?"
The Thief considered that and then rejected the idea altogether. "The Great One would be all but helpless without me. Even with the Dreaming Throne, much has gone awry across the years. The appearance of omniscience is merely a facade. She is limited in power and influence. If she had another knight to play, I would know.”
“The Challenger, then,” Shiv said.
“That option begs the question: Why would Roland agree to such a deal? Why would the Challenger wait for so long, a full decade, before attacking the last bastion of peace once more? No, the Challenger, I suspect, still slumbers. If Roland could escape and if Roland could strike his son, then the Challenger would have seen Roland perverted and bent to his own means, even if the Challenger was manipulating Roland through usurped or false Avalon. That leaves another thing to question: Why have the Avalons not struck the Challenger down for this act of sacrilege? If they are working together, I should know. That should leak from some place at some point, and I have interfaced with a great many orcs. Most are still searching for their fallen father. The likelihood of his involvement is low.”
“Then who else do we got?” Shiv said. “Because unless Chorus is present down here and playing a game we don't understand, I'm completely out of players to bring up.”
“Contrarily, I have too many individuals to consider, but few of them have cause or reason to be present.” The Thief turned away from Shiv and began pacing, trying to burn out his interest and agitation. The Deathless adopted his master's demeanor, both of them circling the other as they thought and worked at the question. Shiv constructed a series of minor simulations, trying to narrow down potential adversaries, slotting in practically everyone of power he knew, but he lacked the information. Thus far, the information seemed tainted, and so, with the Avalons themselves compromised of useful knowledge, where then would they find the truth?
“The source,” Shiv realized. “I need to get to the source. I need to make contact with Roland and Nullity. Then I need to question them too.”
“Indeed. I lay my discomfort bare for you right now. I expected Roland to be here. I expected him to be a pillar for Adam to hold on to, the only reason why there is any Adam left at all after all he suffered. Instead, he has rebelled against his own son. Worse, he slew his own son in an act I would have never considered possible, even under the direction of his patron god. Unthinkable. It is unlike him in all aspects. More importantly, something else does not fit. The logic does not correspond.”
“I have a guess," Shiv said. "You're wondering about why Roland betrayed the Sage. Even if the Sage was eating away at Adam, even if Avalon offered a deal, why would he take it? Avalon has no reason to abide by honor, and if the Sage falls, then there's no protection from the Avalons either. Sure, if Roland completely despaired, he might give himself over to paradise, but I don't think that's him. He's got traumas, but he's not the kind to just fold, not after a few meager decades. Not after everything he's already sacrificed. But Adam said something about Nullity talking him into it.”
“It shouldn't be enough between a daughter he never knew and the son he raised alone. What competition could there be between the two? Who would hold more influence?” The Thief squinted. “We are groping blind. We are in the darkness, both of us. And you are right, Shiv. Our priority now is to uncover the position of Roland Arrow and the girl. We need to find them, interrogate them, and understand what looms ahead. Something is awry in this picture, and I despise the fact that I do not know what.”
“I think I have a means to comfort you," Shiv said softly. “A plan. I think I talked Adam into returning the Starhawk to me, but even if he doesn't give me Matthew, I don't think I need him. I just need to make enough of a consistent pattern to lure out the girl. She still has my Garden of Wounds and Broken Things and the Red Rider's Hand, and I think that if I sabotage and cause enough destruction, she'll follow that trail. It'll be risky, but I might be able to draw her out that way.”
“Immensely risky,” the Thief rebuffed. “And the chance of success is not worth potentially losing you to Avalon.”
“Well then, I suppose I better not fail. We need to find them and talk to them as soon as possible. Because I don't want whatever nasty surprise is waiting at the other end of this to spring up on us like a spell-mine.”
“Indeed. I will hunt for them as well—redouble my efforts. It is good that you brought this to my attention.” The Thief's face crumbled into a look of inward disgust. “To be so wrong, so blind, so foolish, it is unbecoming of me. I beg of you forgiveness. I have debased myself in front of you. I have debased both of us.”
The apology caught Shiv off guard and reminded him about how little he understood the Thief. “Apologies are unnecessary. We just have to get this right. Otherwise, the consequences are going to fall on our necks again.” The Deathless licked his lips and looked away. A series of words trembled inside of him, words he wanted to ask, left over from his bitter resentment experience moments prior.
“I don't know if there's actually any Valor left inside of you, or if you're just using his shadow to string me along. I don't know a lot of things about you, Master, but I do know this: You were here for two hundred years, and you never failed me. I know where I stand with you. I know what you want, at least enough of what you want that things can't be said simply but directly. I want to keep people alive, and you want to put them down—and that part's still the same. I'm not going to let you just kill everyone, but…”
Shiv sighed. “I don't know. In a twisted way, you've never disappointed me. In a twisted way, I could always rely on you. You've always had the answer. You always had a solution. You always had a direction to push me in. I would still be trapped at the bottom of an Avalon without you. This isn't exactly an admission of affection, but… Look, in a really fucked-up way, how Adam feels towards me, I feel a little bit towards you. You never failed me, and so we can't fail each other. Not about this. Everything else, we leave that for later. Right now, we're the only ones we can count on, so can we put all that other scheming on pause until we figure things out?”
The more Shiv spoke, the more of a tilt bled into the Thief’s neck, until he was almost looking at Shiv sideways. Shiv almost chuckled. “What? Why are you leaning that way? Master?”
The Thief drew a long and deep breath. “You really should just let me kill her. You really should just let me kill both of them. You say you don't fully understand me. Well, I don't fully understand you either. To a lesser extent, of course, but I don't understand why you won't let me remove the burdens upon your spirit. She is not your grandmother. She's never been your grandmother. And the other is merely an interloper, a pawn, even if she has stolen a bit of my own master’s fire. They should hold no worth to you. Why do you let them bother you so?”
A rasp of annoyance left Shiv. He was unbalanced. He gave away too much, too much emotion, too much of his heart. Now the Thief caught on: this vulnerability would come at a consequence. “It's not who they are. It's what they represent, what they've done, everything that's come of them.”
The Thief stared at Shiv for a long moment, and then he nodded once. “I see. And I apologize. I thought this to be a thing of emotional vulnerability. No, it is philosophical exhaustion. I know the feeling well. I sympathize. You see the end of mortals, their terminal points. They go no further, but you, one, can bear witness to mortality in more ways than one and be disgusted by the mortals in more ways than one. They are a curious bunch, are they not? Very, very vivid, surprising, sometimes even quite lovable, but they always break our hearts. Always.”
The Thief looked away as he mumbled something under his breath. “…When I invest myself in my echoes, when they inherit parts of my story, when I create people like Valor Thann, like Silence, when I forge these identities, I live among the mortals to steep myself and remind myself of consequence and mortality. But every time I return, it leaves me feeling wronged. I feel defiled, and I feel it still now.”
The Thief gazed into Shiv's eyes, and there came a building pressure, one that made Shiv's hairs stand and made him feel as if his instincts were wailing for him to fight or flee. “I despise the love, the true, genuine love Valor Thann held for you. But it is merely an expression of vulnerability. I despise his weakness more. I despise every wrong he's committed, every person he butchered and murdered merely because he was incompetent, or he was angry, or he was blind and didn't know better. I despise all of that: failed expression of self-domination, failed expression of what it means to be a Pathbearer. What point is there to merely be another organism, here and forgotten? Once and never again. The System gave you so much, bestowed all that power upon you, and you couldn't even return it tenfold. How aggravating.”
“What do you mean?” Shiv whispered.
“The partiality of consequence is that the mortal will never fully imbibe the wrongness of their deeds. They will never feel the full weight of their inaction or the full pain that unfolds after they perform a wrongful action. When you burn a land, when you salt the fields, nothing grows for generation after generation. In the moment, it might feel good to offend a great enemy, perhaps a defeated enemy nation, perhaps something to starve their children and for you to settle in the future. If you live long enough, you will come to see your own people spread, and then there will be nothing to feed them upon such lands. You will lament your momentary anger, now long distant and forgotten, as a feeble echo of a feeling, as much as the people you loathed are now but shadows, reflections, and ripples upon the water. Only you endure, and then time goes on further. You realize your people are not your people anymore. They fragmented or died out because of their own folly, because one among them had a brilliant idea while everyone else starved. They were so confident the others listened and followed that fool off the hill, like a pack of lambs charging toward oblivion and naming it paradise.”
Scorn and acerbic venom leaked into the Thief's voice, but it was not acerbic venom directed toward the human condition, but rather the fact that anyone failed at all, that anyone was so blind, so self-destructive, so unwilling to be the master of their own fate. The Thief hated everyone downstream of another's consequence, for how could he not? He was downstream of the Great One, and he defied the Great One. He attained the Great One's interest, then seized the measure of power over his master and everyone else who'd ever failed. What worth had they in the beginning and at the present?
The Thief of Lost Acheron was who he had always been: selfish beyond measure, selfish and blind to it, selfish and unwilling to accept everyone as they were—for if such a thing were to breach the walls of his heart, he would have to suffer the full horror of what it meant to be a mundane person: what it meant to be talentless, powerless, helpless.
The Thief glided across the distance and placed a comforting hand upon Shiv's shoulder. He guided the Deathless back toward the exit and continued his speech. “I delighted in training you. More accurately, I delighted in leading you down the right path, in sending you up the right hills. You fell, much in the same way as the mortals. You are a lamb, but with each fall you are less of a lamb, and now you are no lamb altogether. Now you begin to grasp things that they cannot, that they never will. You feel it: that misery, that burden, that feeling of consequence cast away from them because they simply die, because they simply move on or run away or blame another for what they have done. It is not a consequence willingly delivered, but a consequence generated by the incompetent ripples of their actions. They are at once too powerful and too blind and too weak, paradoxically. The waters they disturb continue to crash outward, building without friction, without resistance, until we all must suffer their misdeeds. And now you feel it.”
“And you feel it more than I do,” Shiv said, “because those crashing waves resonate more than just in the material world. They crash down across your soul too. They damage your legend. How many times have you been misshapen? How many times have you given yourself over to the people, only for them to ruin you in some way, to leave you wounded of soul, and force you to rebuild yourself in the span of centuries?”
The Thief squeezed Shiv's shoulder and winked at him. “Sometimes, my boy, you are too blind, and other times you see too much. You are too accurate in your guess. I'm glad you can learn this lesson faster than I, and I am glad that it is sinking into you. You must let it sink into you, for they cannot be relied upon, none of them. Even the ones you find great affection in, I allow them to live because it is to your comfort, and perhaps that is my weakness, but you understand now: It is never fully their fault. They will never understand how much of the fault is theirs, and so it will be you and I, and if you speak truly, Adam, who must shape things, who must endure. We are purer than they, purer by far, purer beyond their ability to ever attain. I beg of you: let them go. Accept their presence, use them, play with them, do as you will with them, because they were never lasting to begin with. In that, they might as well never be real.”
The implications behind the Thief's words were horrifying, but worse yet was how easily Shiv drank it all in.
It all made sense. And more than making sense, it felt right in too many ways, ways that Shiv couldn't fully reject, ways that left him stewing in his own silence.
How many more years? How many more eons? How many more mistakes? On the magnitude of the Ascendants, how much could he suffer before a deeper nihilism took hold, a blacker cynicism in which he decided not to deal with the frivolous incompetence of people, leaving them to their own suffering, their own devices?
The Harbinger warned Shiv to center himself, but the Deathless was not in a mood to hear such things. Instead, he thought about Adam, poor, broken Adam, Adam who was by his side and went through crucible after crucible only to arrive at his present point. Adam, who defied everyone's expectation, even the Thief's.
What was his reward? What did it cost for him to become who he was? To truly attain immortality?
The answer was hatred, pure, unbridled, traumatic, calcified into Divinity.
And the Thief wasn't so different. The Thief was broken in just the right way as well.
And so was Shiv.
It takes one being the right kind of monster to survive the brutality of Integration.
When the Harbinger replied, it sounded so close to Kelhaus, and Kelhaus pulled back just a bit, just a few steps beyond the brink. "But do not give yourself to misanthropy. Do not succumb in your entirety. Fight, hold, for what this world is worth. Take the pain, and do not break. Take the pain, and come back every time. For she represents another path. Even if she is narrowed in her own way, she is not broken. She is nourished."
“I understand,” Shiv whispered.
“Good,” the Thief said, patting Shiv and pushing him out on his way—ironically ignorant to who Shiv actually replied to. “I know you do. I am proud that you do. Now find them, Roland and Nullity. Find them and put them to the question. We need answers. We need to know what we do not. In the meantime, keep a close eye on Adam. Renew your bond. I admit wrongness when it is exposed, and I was wrong to assume so little of your battle brother. He might yet be a good, great boon to our future—another eternal player in the greatest and highest of all games.”
“Of course,” Shiv said. “He's throwing a festival in my honor, right? He's calling it the Day of Reunion. We got a lot of catching up to do, and frankly, I have a lot of cooking to improve on again.”
The Thief laughed. “Surprise him, overwhelm him, take every order from every person across this entire realm. I think it is time for you to give your nihilistic flame its due reward, is it not? Sear and smoke flavor that they have never tasted into their desired meals, and finish your meals within those loops of yours. He might be a god, but no one else has a myth like yours, and so impose your potential upon him. From what you say, he is already emotionally latched to you. Make him operationally and materially reliant as well.”
“Always another angle with you.” Shiv snorted. “Speaking of, are you going to greet him, now that he’s an immortal? Or are you going to keep hiding from the Sage?”
“I leave you to bear my regards," the Thief said without hesitation. "I am no fool. I know what power he wields, and from what you claim, he has unlocked the deeper mechanisms of his Heaven as well—and so, beware of the Sage, for you stand in the presence of something older than the System itself. Something powerful enough to make reality quiver and quail even without the philosopher’s stone that is mana.”
“Sounds terrifying; does it have a limitation?” Shiv asked.
The Thief smirked. “I leave you to find out. I suspect Adam will reveal much to you in time—but know that you might already have the one to engineer his downfall.”
“The one?” Shiv asked.
The question went unanswered as the Thief pushed him back into the kitchen. “Go. Enjoy your festival and the resurrection of your brotherhood. Enjoy and evolve in peace. I will begin the search on my end, and when you are prepared, begin the hunt as well.” He pressed his lips together. “It’s only us here playing the great game. It’s only us that will see the end of all the others, and so we must do what we can. For each other against their follies, and against each other to refine ourselves to peaks beyond peaks. We are the immortals, Shiv. We are of a kind. In this, we are not alone. Do not let the broken ephemerals torment you. Not even if they are of your blood. Someday—sooner than you think, you will think nothing of them. Nothing at all. And then, you will be free.”
“And then, we will be another kind of broken,” the Harbinger mused.
As Shiv took a step beyond the door, he wrapped his fingers around the key and gave the Thief a final look. “Master. If you find Roland first—”
“I will bring him to you,” the Thief said. “And then you will bring him to Adam—but ensure Roland’s survival if he is immortal as well.”
“If?” Shiv asked.
“Adam endured. But his father failed.” The Thief gave a small shrug. “I was wrong. Deeply so. And with all else that has been claimed, I must contend with the possibility and disappointment that the great talent of Roland Arrow… will go to waste.” He almost looked sad. “Let us hope he might stand amongst us. He will be a most entertaining player.”
“Let’s hope,” Shiv breathed, as he turned the key again, and sealed the path shut.