Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In a follow-up to our "Project 1933" series (and in anticipation of the book version coming next year), Moira and Adrian talk about the new movie Fatherland and the historical figure at the center of it. Directed by Paweł Pawlikowski, Fatherland stars Sandra Hüller as Erika Mann, Hanns Zischler as Thomas Mann and August Diehl as Klaus Mann. They then delve into the life of Erika Mann -- the women, the fast cars, the drugs, and the W.H.s Auden.

Comments

Andu Z

me when ibwtr posts an hourlong discussion of some european I've never heard of

Maude Guillemin

Saw this movie a week ago because I got locked out of my apartment so I went to the theater while waiting for my roommate to be back. I got sloshed off one beer (this movie theater sells beer) in a room of people all aged above 50 and can't remember anything that happens past the Manns getting to East Germany because I was thinking too hard about what Adrian and Moira would think about this movie. Excited to see your thoughts !

David in Brooklyn

Will there be an audiobook version of _Project 1933_ (hint, hint)?

GNK

Oh gosh I want to see this. Btw, Jesus, Joy of Man’s Desiring is a cantata from a larger work written by baby Bach while he was employed by the court in Weimar. There were like, dueling dukes and shenanigans that led to Bach’s arrest before he fled for Leipzig I think.

Erika V

*Looks around uncomfortably while being named Erika*

Sophia

This is so GOOD. And timely. I just finished rewatching Klaus Maria Brandauer in Istvan Szabo’s Mephisto (based on a story by Klaus Mann) and reading Colm Toibin’s The Magician. Keep the weird German 20th century celebrities coming. Thank you

Charlotte

Ohhh yes! I saw Fatherland (as Vaterland) at a German film festival in September. Such a good film, and so well-acted! I was surprised by how short it was. I need to see it again. Also, I hadn't realised the Manns were basically all queer (I just knew about Klaus) and read up on that afterwards.

Charlotte

Fun fact: The two German anthems are in the same key and and same rhythm signature, so you can mix both the text and the melody bar by bar, or sing one text to the melody of the other. We had an assignment in secondary school music class to make a mixed anthem, which I thought was great - and I think that's totally what they should have done after reunification. (I like the East German anthem better than the one we now have, but of course they never would have kept that in full for political reasons. But I think a mixed one could have worked.)

Nick

Re Erika and WH, do you guys know about February House, aka the gayest and coolest artist colony maybe evs? For a year 1940-1941 WH Auden, Carson McCullers, Benjamin Britten, Peter Pears, Paul Bowles, Jane Bowles and Gypsy Rose Lee lived in a house in Brooklyn together with guests including Klaus and Erika Mann, Salvador Dalí, Richard Wright and Anaïs Nin

Charley

That sounds so cool as a big Carson McCullers fan 💜

Lu

I want Jiu jitsu sufraggette movie made in the low budget style of jesus christ vampire hunter

Hannah Raines

So excited to see this!! Still praying for an episode on Ken Russel’s The Devils 🙏 especially since it’s getting a wide home release

Nick

I read about it in Jen Shapland’s book My Autobiography of Carson McCullers, maybe you should check it out! She wrote The Member of the Wedding while she was there I think

Ben Schwabe

Moira claims she wants nepo babies to be doing drugs and having sex, yet complains about Bard College...

Laurel Hall

I just let out a little squeal of delight!!

audioboy

Moira literally what is the point of an audio only pod if you're NOT recording in pajamas sometimes??

Charley

I will. Member of the Wedding is one of my favourite books!

Charley

Loved The Magician - great novel!

In Bed With the Right

The main character in Mephisto, of course, being based on a man who gets slapped in Fatherland!

David in Brooklyn

Another fun fact is that Hanns Eisler, who wrote the GDR anthem, was a serious classical composer, probably the best composer of the Second Vienna School not to be included in the holy trinity of Schoenberg, Berg and Webern. I've performed some of his "non-political" chamber music--it deserves to be heard much more often. It's unfortunate, but no coincidence, that his later, overtly political music, as well as his music for film, are counted against him so much. Any insistence that art not be social or political is, itself, very political, no?

lsh

Sounds to me like Erika was touring a live podcast through America. What else is being a political lecturer ?

Nina V~

truly, i would be HONORED to be "well, *actually*"-ed by adrian, especially if he's adjusting his glasses as he does it 🤭

Nina V~

seconded!

wibbelkind

I remember seeing the movie posters around and I was wondering if Adrian had heard of it yet. 😅 If you're a long time IBWTR listener like me, seeing that in the wild felt almost like having an inside joke. 😏

Christa Morrow

Totally different subject - any chance you all will do an episode on the commentary that followed the SNL Sister sketch? I, (a sister) was going to forward the video of it to my brother but I just couldn’t do it because while it made me laugh i also wanted to hit something.

Matt

This movie review makes me want an IBWTR reaction to La Bola Negra. it's not about Germany, so less on the nose, but it is about gender and fascism in Spain. has made every queer i know (including me 3 times) ugly cry in the theater. this ep has made me want to go see this film, so thanks Adrian and Moira!

Bruce

I saw the movie in Germany in June at the Munich film festival and was really bowled over by it, so this was just a perfect pod for me personally. What you guys said, that it's not a movie that hits you over the head with its themes, and kind of requires some deep historical knowledge makes me wonder if its reception will match its quality. I hopeful for a best international film Oscar nom, still. Sandra Hüller is so, so good in it (as is August Diehl). Really made me sad that she was so poorly used in Digger (though that was not the film's major issue, to be sure).

Christian Baji

Podcasts are the intellectual lecture circuit of our time

Jenny

This begs for a sitcom adaptation!

Teresa Ritterhoff

Loved this and loved the film— saw it in a German cinema 2 weeks ago and the audience was riveted. Here’s hoping Sandra takes you up on your invite & that you get a summons to at least one of Ezra Klein’s productions that starts with a “p.”

Theo

I would personally love to hear more about Gustaf Gründgens, whom you mentioned in this. I feel like the accounts of his life are often conflicting, in that he was apparently a coward willing to work and thrive within the Nazi regime, but is also portrayed as trying to criticise from within etc combined with him being gay. I am really curious about the different portrayals and rewriting of his history and how they come about. (Yes this interest is mostly informed by the fact that the theatre in my hometown is still in a square named after him 👀)

Susan Olson

Fully as delightful as I'd hoped! Showings don't start in my area until Friday, and I'm so glad to have richer background knowledge of both the characters and the filming going into it. Please do a de-nazification series whenever you're ready! The dearth of English language media around that topic/period really isn't doing us any favors.

Amanda Daquila

There was joint research project a few years back called "lesbische Lebenswelten" that you all might find interesting. Booklet zu „Lesbischen* Lebenswelten im deutschen Südwesten“ – Professur für Geschichte des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts https://share.google/9S0H2pJMDm66EMKvh

Kat

I said “ew” (out loud, to myself, at home) at precisely the same moment as Moira when Adrian said Winifred Wagner may have had a relationship with Hitler. I feel seen.

Claire Saint-Amour

because of this episode Fatherland is my new favorite Christmas movie