Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Pull up a chair, grab some bergamot pancakes and let Moira tell you the story of some young people who came to the Big Apple with nothing but an NYU degree, a trust fund and some truly fucked opinions. Let her introduce you to a bored-looking twenty-something who apparently embodies the Vibe Shift (TM), but sort of just looks like an adderall addiction, a penchant for saying the r-word and a check from Peter Thiel got hold of a trench coat. Smoke with these genius iconoclasts inside China Chalet and shoot the shit about how revolutionary their best friend's play is and how it also just sort of sucks. Stroll past an endless phalanx of journalists looking to profile a bunch of antiwoke neo-beat poets, discussing how not giving cash to a homeless dude is "praxis". That's right, Moira is taking you to Dimes Square, a fabled place and equally fabled social set that launched a million think pieces and literally zero careers. CONTENT WARNING: Contains podcast on podcast violence.

Comments

Dayin

In bed with the right take on dimes square … this is like GTA 6 dropping for me. happy early Christmas !!

Dylan Stephens

Oh this one is for the real fucking sickos. I didn’t know I needed this but I don’t know if I’ve wanted an episode on internecine twitter jackasses more. 10000/10 great work gang

Kevin

Dang, we are really getting a lot from y'all recently. Every episode jumps straight to the top of my queue!

miller

YES between this and the lesbian nuns episode I have to ask… is Moira in my walls???

Axel H.

I hate that I know as much as I do about these people, but I’m loving hearing you dunk on them (even if I am a long-time Chapo listener! I can take the heat). I unfortunately got introduced to Red Scare years ago when people were still trying to claim it was “dirtbag left”. I gave it a listen and heard fairly typical right-wing whining about vaccines and trans people. I was unimpressed, to say the least. Also, I appreciate the groan when mentioning Elizabeth Bruenig. I've never cared for her, and saying so did not go well in some other podcast fandoms...

Nina V~

THANK YOU for explaining who these odious people are! i've heard them casually referenced many times in other shows. every time they were, i instantly became the "i don't know what that means, and at this point i'm too afraid to ask" meme

thayden

I continue to be endlessly impressed by both the quality and frequency of your episodes. Thank you for teaching me so much, about so many topics I was unaware of.

Maxine Iglich

My relationship difficulties in 2021 could be summarized as: I listened to “Call Your Girlfriend” and he listened to “Cumtown”.

Brian

I want the ~30 seconds about primary ideological (or libidinal) motivations against feminism (and later liberalism) inevitably leading to the right tattooed to my forehead. Not the first time I’ve put this in Patreon comments, banger of a line, Moira.

Jeanette Wall

I have some dark stories from college about Gasda. Woof. Also he is in his late 30s/early 40s I think but stilll. He was a pest around Syracuse University.

Will Robinson

see, this is one of a million reasons why I hate the right in this country. I'm not allowed to call these losers "decadent" without sounding like I have a marble statue as my profile pic on twitter. also, TIL chapo was attempting to be "intellectual" - oof. the bar is real low folks

daisy

Wow y’all are keeping us fed! If Red Scare has no haters I’m dead!!!

GNK

I somehow missed the whole Red Scare thing. It just *sounded* like it was probably stupid. 🤣

sistertotherain9

I've also heard of some of these people, but they were a reference I just didn't get and didn't care to look into because, well, they sounded like assholes.

Astraea

I have never in my life been more grateful that I never got into the Bernie-to-dirtbag-left pipeline. All of my half-articulated "I dunno I just get bad vibes from these people" feelings from 2016-2018 have been fully validated!

kathleen

I've withered away into a heap of witchy crone dust after listening in rapt horror to the saga of these awful young(er than me) people. [Cue my ghostly voice from the afterlife: Children, Camille Paglia is no friend of yourrrrrrs!] I'm kinda thankful I'm out of touch. [Edit: and from the inconsequential midwest, from whence I missed allll of this.]

Kathryn m

I'm only a few minutes in, but Moira's description of the restaurant made me wonder whether either host has been to Cafe Gratitude (now just in SoCal, but there used to be one in Berkeley). I would pay dollars to hear Adrian and Moira snarkily review that place

Lu

Charley

Glad Moira intimated you guys are gonna do a Camilla Paglia episode 🙏 I dislike her intensely now for obvious reasons but I was briefly enamoured of her as a 90s “edgy” student (🙄) so there’s some residual embarrassment here 🤦🏼‍♀️

Charlotte

Im 10 minutes in and still confused as to what Dimes Square even is. 😭 I'm happy this all completely passed me by.

OuijaFBabysMama (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-21 04:00 I have wanted to know what the Sheila Heti interview w Red Scare was like @moiradonegan @inbedwiththeright because I respect Heti as an artist and the red scare girlies i have less respect for and so it makes me wonder many things….. but I wont pay!! So i dont know alas @moiradonegan @inbedwiththeright ps haven’t listened yet and cannot wait!!! I was literally thinking the other day about how I missed this cultural moment while working my ass off
2026-11-19 10:21 I have wanted to know what the Sheila Heti interview w Red Scare was like @moiradonegan @inbedwiththeright because I respect Heti as an artist and the red scare girlies i have less (post listen correvtion: NO) respect for and so it makes me wonder many things….. but I wont pay!! So i dont know alas @moiradonegan @inbedwiththeright ps haven’t listened yet and cannot wait!!! I was literally thinking the other day about how I missed this cultural moment while working my ass off

I have wanted to know what the Sheila Heti interview w Red Scare was like @moiradonegan @inbedwiththeright because I respect Heti as an artist and the red scare girlies i have less (post listen correvtion: NO) respect for and so it makes me wonder many things….. but I wont pay!! So i dont know alas @moiradonegan @inbedwiththeright ps haven’t listened yet and cannot wait!!! I was literally thinking the other day about how I missed this cultural moment while working my ass off

Rosie

Jesus christ, I completely missed these guys. These people suck and I'm sorry they were awful to Moira. And fuck these guys for perpetuating the "eating disorders as fashion accessories" myth. I feel I need to defend the moral virtues of anorexics, now. I have known many, growing up in inpatient facilities as a child & teenager, and in times since when I've struggled more with the illness. The vast majority of us are just trying to survive it and not be ruled by it. We're the last people to recommend it as a "lifestyle", because we know how much it hurts and can ruin your life. I know this isn't what the episode is about, and I don't for a second think Moira meant to put the boot in, but it's such a harmful stereotype this idea that it's an illness for wealthy white beauty-conscious young women to wear like a fashion accessory. I'm a masc lesbian (aspirational), I've never cared for traditional femininity and comp het was a big factor in me losing my shit as a kid and retreating into an ED. So were "woke" anxieties about climate, animal welfare and the meat industry. Famously, anorexics don't think they're thin, if they did, they wouldnt be anorexic! If it really gets its hooks in, you can't do things like be an influencer, you're lucky if you can leave your bed, and you aren't likely that interested in policing the bodies of others - it's just not what the illness is like. It's an ugly and unglamorous illness and a killer, and it's a dangerous myth that you only get it if you care about beauty or thinness aesthetics. Actually, there's a huge intersection with queerness, dysphoria, autism, sensory processing differences, alexythmia, difficulties with the gendered body, or having a body at all. Honestly I could talk about queerness, neurodivergence and eating disorders all day but I won't (sorry for being long). (I know ordinary unhappiness covered EDs recently but I'm a bit scared to listen) P.S. I only really know UK services but support is out there if you need it - https://www.beateatingdisorders.org.uk/ https://www.beateatingdisorders.org.uk/get-information-and-support/about-eating-disorders/eating-disorders-and-autism/ P.P.S. Moira you are great and definitely not cancelled. Sorry tone is hard by text. And also in general.

beesher

The other day I listened to a Matt Bernstein episode on Dasha Nekrasova, and now this episode on Dimes Square. I think I might have Mandela-effected over from a timeline where there was no Dimes Square. How did I miss all this? I am usually on top of things.

Skylar

Before you do your Camille Paglia episode, I wanted to warn you that it's pronounced "pall-ya" just like "imbroglio=imbroll-yo". It's Italian. Maybe you're choosing to mispronounce it out of disrespect, and fair if so, but I wanted to help avert another BARy Weiss situation

OuijaFBabysMama

I am dying waiting for you to mention Kaitlin phillips, please and katherine nicole prickett and their little posse please tell me how I knew their bullshit FROM NEW ORLEANS IN 2016 please god please why god why

Solomon Freilich Photography

Moira, I am autistic and I didn't love that you said the R word aloud instead of just saying "the R word".

Ben Schwabe

Disappointed the hear The Dare is involved. I heard Girls on WEQX (Vermont's Finest Rock) and the DJ introduced the song by saying "this band is called The Dare, but maybe STD Soundsystem would be better."

Axel H.

“Hipsters, but right-wing” is probably the best way to think of it.

Moira Donegan

Adrian and I talked about this, and decided that for our purposes, we will use the word when describing other people saying it, in part to give clarity to our audience, and in part to preserve the status of the n word, which has a special horribleness that makes it actually unutterable. The point was not to offend.

Jenny

My husband lived in downtown Manhattan during those same years in his early 30s and he has also never heard of those people. Their supposed importance really is just self-importance, inflated by their proximity to media power.

Kelly G.

Oh no! I read Lost Lambs! Didn't know she was part of this movement. The book was bad and incredibly Islamophobic, which now knowing her affiliation with this scene is not surprising.

Ivan Krasovec

Gotta admit I loved the brief Wyndham Lewis callout XD

kathleen

OK I just read the menu for Dimes and 1) it would have been dull in Saint Paul MN in 2015. (Meet you at the American Swedish Institute in Mpls for things on toast that are much, much better.) 2) The remaining nine circles of Hell will have to freeze before I drink a wheatgrass margarita. Again. ASI in Mpls. Get the Bloody Swede. 3) They serve breakfast but don't have coffee?

Coco

I love all of your episodes, but this variety of “one of you tells the other one something that only one of you knows about” is one of my favorite flavors because it inevitably involves both of you laughing a lot, and your laughs are delightful! Did I miss the episode on the Outcome movie? I can’t seem to find that one, and now I need it like the addict I am!

tina dee garland

I was not privy to this scene while it was happening (I was chronically offline in 2018) but as a pop music stan I often think about the fact that charli xcx wrote a song inspired by dasha. I don’t think charli was a part of this scene but she clearly followed these people online and revered them and she does not get dragged enough for that tbh.

Reggie Debris

I gotta say the name of the neighborhood well predates this reactionary scene and it was just a funny moniker among the people who lived and hung out there. And the people who run the restaurant are not right wing and have nothing to do with the right wing turn at all. It’s just where these red scare idiots happened to all live during Covid , and I’d venture that when they all moved there they were at least semi left wing

Moira Donegan

Cringe and embarrassing on her part, though tbh I don’t really expect my pop stars to be smart.

Amelia Barracca

As someone with a diagnosed ED I can’t think of anything less revolutionary than having anorexia lol.

Andrew Shields

I just read about Dimes Square in Eva von Redeker’s “Dieser Drang nach Härte”. I looked it up and thought that y’all should do an episode on it! And a couple hours later, here it is!

dunahay

This episode makes the latest weirdly transphobic season of Next Gen NYC make sooo much more sense to me

A Felt

Right?! It perfectly articulates something I’ve been trying to put my finger on since I first got involved in leftist spaces as a college student and was troubled by all the guys I met whose core values seemed to be “ i hate my liberal mom”

In Bed With the Right

Fun fact: I (Adrian) put "What is Camille Paglia's whole deal?" note in our VERY FIRST doc of episode ideas back in 2023, because I badly needed Moira to explain this person to me! So this episode has been a long time coming!

olly

24 year old me is called out so hard here…but im sad to hear Moira describe herself as a liberal.

reportress

thank you for diving into the aggressive thinness component. “taking a flash photo of an underweight girl and posting it to the internet” is truly the most evocative phrase i’ve ever heard

Astraea

I believe "Outcome" is discussed in the episode titled "Catching Up on the Cinema of Cancellation." (?) It doesn't have a dedicated episode, but it's part of an episode that discusses multiple movies.

Astraea

Ngl, a certain set of writers in NYC write about "culture" or "controversies" and are just writing low-stakes local-news filler stories, but they fundamentally *do not understand* that that is what they're writing . I've been to NYC exactly once. I don't know where any of these places are, and I don't care. And while I think it's actually very good to be connected to your own community and know, like, local microcultures, I really don't think that I, living two thousand miles away, need to care about it at all. :P

Astraea

Sincerely: many thanks to Moira for not being afraid to talk about all the shit she got for pointing out that many "serious" mainstream criticisms of Clinton were just misogyny. I felt like I was being gaslit for 18 months straight! And when I didn't get fully on board with the dirtbag left after the election, that was somehow proof that I was secretly a conservative (lol no) rather than proof that I was getting some pretty icky vibes from these "being offensive will magically cure the world" doofuses. Hearing Moira straightforwardly call misogynistic things misogynistic helps keep me sane. :)

Astraea

Note for clarification: there are many legitimate criticisms of Clinton. I'm not saying there aren't. I'm saying that there were a ton of really mainstream criticisms that we were told to take seriously that were really, truly, just code for, "Look at this arrogant bitch thinking she should be President."

Eric Quirk

I’m mentally preparing myself for the Red Scare vocal frying before delving into this juicy episode

Karen Cox

Thank you!! I have the distinction of being retweeted by Elizabeth Bruenig where she listed her resume because I said she would have made a great professional baker but was a lousy pundit.

Karen Cox

And we do need to discuss the BernieBro misogyny.

Coco

Ahhh yes. Thank you!

Lisa

Gee, what a bunch of weirdos. I'm so happy all the information I have on any of the podcasts of that era is second-hand. Thank you guys for keeping me informed at what seems to have been great personal expense this time!

Lisa

Do you happen to have a link to that episode?

Moira Donegan

Many people are liberals who don’t admit it!! Me, I admit it.

Sam

as a long time hater of red scare, thank you for keeping us fed 🙏🏼

Karen Cox

I AM that liberal mom! (Luckily my Gen / Gen Alpha sons don’t hate me; they rather like me in fact, but there are many young men in their age cohort and just older who cannot forgive Mom for objecting to bad table manners/ BO/ and misogynist video games.

Sam Brink

I’m always so surprised at the limited physical footprint of these cultural moments. Last week, I asked my wife something that I hoped would sound totally normal: “is there an Erewhon in Michigan?”

lsh

The Praxis video girl is called Simone Norman !

mink

I really don’t think dasha seems stupid in the sailor socialism clip. She’s not really saying anything complex about socialism and she seems really performatively cool in a kind of annoying way, but the infowars person wouldn’t have responded well to a complex argument for socialism and whom among us hasn’t been performatively cool in an annoying way in our early 20s. I think the clip is very funny honestly, because she’s just refusing to give the infowars lady the reaction she was looking for. I wish that she had just kind of disappeared after that 😭 because she revealed herself as pretty stupid in the rest of her career.

Alexis Nast

You said a "sheen of intellectualism" and I heard "Shien intellectualism" and I think that's perfect.

American Campus Podcast

“Did you know Bernie lives in a $3M house?” Yeah girl he lives in DC

Catherine Reilly

As someone who is too old to have tracked this in real time and also left new York in 2010, I feel extremely seen.

Lydia

Literally thank for god this because I also saw Ivy Wolk in New York Magazine and was baffled

Moira Donegan

Many thanks to Simone Norman, a comedic genius for our time. 🙏

jacq

having survived bushwick without turning polyamorous (shoutout polyamory it’s just not for THIS nonbinary person) & just got an mfa in new york………this episode is really important to me

David in Brooklyn

Respecting you highly but until they spelled it out, I didn't know which "r" word they were talking about. So for me it served at least some actual purpose to say it (once). Plus when people use that word w/r/t autism, that's just plain ignorant of them, in addition to evil, since that isn't what the word means or has ever meant.

Belle

Where did you guys talk about “the devils”?

Teddy O’Mara

Dang, I went to college and had several classes with Honor Levy, had not thought about her since, did not know she achieved any kind of notoriety/was involved in this movement. Crazy jump scare to hear the name, and wild when I confirmed it was the same Honor Levy. I guess I’ll just say I wouldn’t have necessarily predicted a reactionary turn, but I’m not at all surprised 😂

Lisa

thanks bro :)

jalapeño chip

I saw the ivy wolk article and immediately though that yall should do a dimes square episode. Positive manifesting I guess ?

Tia Carley

I am sad to hear the r word stated in full multiple times, with no warning or explanation as to why. I really enjoyed the episode over all but that left a bad taste in my mouth, as someone with a disabled wife. Also Charli xcx wrote a song about the red scare girls!!! Mean girls

Nancy Jean Ross

I liked that Moira said, my one wild and precious life.

pixlaw

So is it just my imagination, or could you kind of describe these Dimes Square types as kids who grew up watching South Park and ingesting cynicism and nihilism at too young an age?

Kelly Moran

Oh my god you guys this episode just made the offputting and confusing vibes on substack FINALLY MAKE SENSE