Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 542300012.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hey y'all!

We stayed up late to react to Taylor Swift's new album, The Life of a Showgirl, and we couldn't wait to share our first listen with you! Enjoy!

<3,
Matts

Files

Comments

Cassidy gajewski

Ruin the friendship is about her friend in high school that she went to prom with. He ended up overdosing a few years after Taylor got famous ( i believe around the fearless era). That’s also who she wrote forever winter about. She flew back for his funeral and sang at it.

Christine

This is definitely one that needs multiple listens and now I'm OBSESSED

Elyse F

Father figure to me is so from the perspective of Scooter Braun like I will make you rich and pretend to care about you and tell you I will protect you but then betray you in the worst way when you feel safe.

Bri Renneisen

So obsessed with this album beginning to end. I did ugly cry to Ruin the Friendship for 2 hours last night tho… lol

Jess

Could not wait to watch your reaction video this morning! Thank you both for being you!!❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

Christian Seibold

Was too tired to listen to it last night, so now I'm extra excited to listen to it with y'all!!

Abbie

2GM cross country feud confirmed

Christian Seibold

LOVE this album and this reaction! I actually think the Fate of Ophelia is a great single! I love the chorus melody, and even more importantly, it introduces the theme of the album. What I love about the song Honey was that she wasn't saying random men were calling her "honey", but actually *women* who were judging her for things. It's a necessary perspective. Ironically, some women who have said they felt insecure judged her for stupid things; "honey" is a knife in this song, weaponized by other women unfairly. It is no surprise to me that minorities, women, gay people, etc., can often propagate harmful behaviors and language of society and those who influence society (i.e., straight white men). Taylor's not the first woman to portray this, of course. I love Elizabeth Taylor a lot as well, and Opalite! Still listening to the album again, but this album is excellent. Eldest Daughter is probably my #1 on the album.

Autumn

I really really hated this album

Nasir

actually romantic is boring and childish. not even a big charli fan but sympathy is a knife is better and nuanced

Nasir

cancelled is about blake lively. she’s been friends with her for years and people thought she should drop her bc of the justin baldoni scandal and lawsuit. also so shocked you loved eldest daughter bc it’s so thin lyrically for a track 5.

Christian Seibold

Sympathy is a knife is great sonically, but it's immature. She's using her insecurities to justify hating people for no reason, and it's wrong. And she did it to two people now. She should refrain from public attacks and seek therapy. People shouldn't have to walk on eggshells around her, wondering if they're somehow making her feel small just for existing. The suicidal ideation (SI) of that song feels like a trivialization and mockery of people who have this issue about things much worse than her feelings of jealousy, regardless of possible intended hyperbole. I have dealt with suicidal ideation in my life. The lyrics of the song feel like a smack in my face, considering the way mental health language is weaponized to gain sympathy or to attack people. She says in the song she wants to shoot herself because she has to see someone she doesn't want to see *just* because she's jealous. That's *her* words. What a smack in the face to people who deal with SI. It's valid to feel insecure and jealous, especially when you compare yourself. But when you start using that to actively hurt other people, or weaponize your own life as a threat, that's when you need to figure your issues out and stop blaming other people. P.S. Forever Winter and Before You Go (by Lewis Capaldi) are more realistic depictions of serious SI issues, and they handle it with greater care and context. And more importantly, they aren't used to attack others.

Chey

"Ruin the Friendship" is an absolutely devastating song, but Matt P yelling "SHIT!" when he realizes what's happening will live rent free in my mind 😂

Christian Seibold

P.S.S. Some might say "Sympathy is a knife" is nuanced because it portrays sympathy as disingenuous, but Sympathy Is a Knife fails to admit that sympathy can sometimes come from a genuine place. Instead the lyrics promote blanket distrust of others, which is unhealthy and should be explored in therapy. So no, it's not nuanced. It's very one-sided.

Nasir

i do not care enough about charli to argue over this LMAO. however i will say, taylor’s response is still pretty shallow and the song itself is just boring. also the SI you mention is very clearly hyperbole

Christian Seibold

Opalite gives me Taylor's version of a Beatles love song, and I actually love it, lol.

Lynn

This albums a grower! People hating off first listen when it gets much better everytime.

Christina Struckmeyer

Matt Steel’s reaction to “Ruin the friendship” is 100% my same reaction. I’m still not over it.

Christian Seibold

Yeah, it's heartbreaking. I didn't realize it was possibly about the same person as Forever Winter (which is another song I hold close to my heart). Ruin the Friendship has to be one of my top favorites on the album, I think.

Lee Darby

Enjoyed your review.

Mellie Lou

Omg when you said Yacht Rock I screamed “Thank you!” 😂 That’s exactly what I said to my husband and also why I probably am loving the album so much, because it’s just those vibes.

kiamia

Oh come on, it was a playful slap back to someone who was publicly wishing for your heartbreak because of their own admitted insecurities, even when you'd been nice to them. If the first step is acknowledging your insecurities, isn't the second step not making them everyone else's problem?

kiamia

It's probably Scott (her father figure) drinking the liquor and driving a Jag? And the first devil he was making a deal with was Scooter? She hates Scooter but Scott was the one who betrayed her after pretending to treat her like family, which cuts deeper.

Autumn

Published critics typically get an advance copy before the release date, that seems like why they are published so quickly. I dont think a negative quick review is less valid than a positive one

Tara Dwyre

Had to come check out your reaction because for the first time I was very disappointed by an album of hers at first listen. This is my second listen and I like the first 3 now and the title track, some lyrics I just can’t get past - like father figure - but I’m sure a few others will grow on me. Always love your takes!

Jaime Ramos

Ruin The Friendship took a turn I didn't see coming and there were tears.

Jaime Ramos

Your guys' reactions always improve my feelings towards an album/song, and if you don't like it, I feel validated.

Sam Rodriguez

Taylor is 100% going to make a musical about her life or using her songs on Broadway one day and I can’t wait

Ambar Fleites

I’m so glad you liked it!! I loved the album then logged on to everyone hating it 😂😭 also unrelated but I’d LOVE it for you to cover Hayley William’s Ego Death At A Bachelorette Party!

Lee Decker

This whole album is a BOP! The music video of Track 1! Will be out on YouTube! This Sunday at, 7pm!

Christian Seibold

People like it because, imo, not everything is about lyrics. Minimalism is a valid art-form. Cliches can be used in their proper time and place; they are cliches for a reason - because they work. So much so that cliches are the basis of genre.

Christian Seibold

Been listening to this album a lot. Regardless of the critics, I love this album. I don't let the reactionary pressure of others tell me what I should like. I'm not bothered by the overwhelming criticism from UK critics, because the irony is many of the classics of today were heavily derided when they were first released. Just ask Melville, F Scott Fitzgerald, Jane Austen, James Joyce, T. S. Eliot, Earnest Hemingway, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Emily Dickinson, Emily Bronte, Oscar Wilde, etc. Tolkien, the father of modern Fantasy, wrote Lord of the Rings, which was derided as childish (juvenile) and escapist at the time. Oscar Wilde's Picture of Dorian Gray was met with outrage and accusations of immorality and decadence that corrupted readers. People called Moby-Dick rambling, confused, and, ironically, anti-religious. Van Gogh's style was called crude. Beethoven was called obscure. People called The Beatles' music disposable. Mozart's the Magic Flute was derided as lacking artistic depth because it wasn't high opera. Importantly, this criticism has come from both the critics deriding "low art" as well as the public deriding "high art". Whether the art is "low" or "high", crude or pompous, doesn't matter. Being a great artist means being willing to challenge people's notions of what great art is. Nobody can say Taylor *hasn't* done that. That's what makes her part of the greats, along with many others. I rest knowing that what people say now or in the future doesn't matter. The whole point of art is that it touches someone, makes them feel seen, improves their day, or teaches them something worth knowing or feeling. Even the most obscure art works have cult followings for this reason.

Peter

Cancelled, Fate of Ophelia and Opalite are my top 3!

Kylie

I’m so glad you guys liked it as much as I did!!

Georgia Milionis

Opalite reminds me of Fleetwood Mac so much. There is something about the chorus.

Georgia Milionis

Who is Charli? 🤣🤣 My thoughts exactly: Who TF is Charli?

Ashley Tobin

Matt Palmer is me, cancelled is the one dud of the album for me

Christian Seibold

Agreed. I also relate to Matt Palmer's sentiment here. It's my least favorite on the album. I don't think it's terrible though, but it's the only song I'm a bit iffy on, personally.

Grace M

no one: nobody: not a single soul: Matt Palmer: I bought the red pizza box!!

Jen

It’s great! I love it! It’s no Midnights to me but the hits are hitting!

JB

Obsessed with wood and Elizabeth Taylor today

Sophia

Same. It's so beautiful, and such a poignant message.

Jane Lane

Never have i heard a bigger insult to Fleetwood Mac

Georgia Milionis

Too bad, so sad. I heard it immediately and now I have seen that exact comparison in multiple reviews. So weird to be watching a reaction video for a musician you don't like. 😬

Christian Seibold

Yeah, this album has soft rock influences, of which yacht rock, which was mentioned in the review, is a sub-genre of. It's the clean electric guitars, the tight lush harmonies, the rhythmic piano/synth chords, the mellow mid-tempo beat, and the melody focus, which all define soft rock and yacht rock. So it makes sense you see similarities between it and Fleetwood Mac, lol.

Christian Seibold

No offense @Jane Lane, but Opalite is of the same genre as many Fleetwood Mac songs (soft rock). But I guess if you think the literal musicians who also have a lot of experience in reviewing and critiquing music, rather than the one-off reviews-in-an-hour articles you see on other critical websites by non-musicians, are wrong about the yacht rock influences, then that's certainly a choice. *sips tea with side eyes*

Ashley Hartle

Scott Burschetta is who Father Figure is about i think ;)

Christian Seibold

I think I would place it above Midnights for me, which is wild because I LOVED Midnights when it came out :D Something I noticed in this album is in three songs (Eldest Daughter, Ruin the Friendship, and Honey), she's doing these low rising vocal slides that give Midnights. I believe this is a melodic characteristic she developed fully in Midnights, which is cool.

Jen

I can definitely see why. If it weren’t for Karma, Midnight rain, you’re on your own kid and Bejeweled. Oof I mean…the choices coz I’ve had Fate of Ophelia and Opalite on loop in my brain. She sure can write the ear worms.

Jen

Add wood to that list

ibrahim khan

Loved the reaction felt authentic to mine as well

Jubinav Chadha

You guys have to watch the music video of THE FATE OF OPHELIA.... It's the most showgirl track on the Album

Camille Platts-McPharlin

The melody,especially in the bridge, just does it for me so much. And her vocals also are stunning

Wendy

Can't wait for you to see the Fate of Ophelia video.

Madi

Hahaha his straight face tiny bouncing is so real. Least fav for me as well

Camden :)

"I thought we were having fun at prom!?" Is so real

Nancy Ward

Love you guys!!! Matt when you had that expression on Cancelled, I had a feeling you weren’t into it and then when you admitted it was your least favorite, I was LMAO😅. Agree to disagree. That’s what I love and respect that we don’t have to agree on music or songs we like or dislike and that’s okay. I want to live in a world where you can have different opinions and still be respectful of each other. Thanks guys!! Great album review!!!

miss b

There's a good article in the guardian about Actually Romantic

emma

i’m an eldest daughter skeptic for sure but seeing you guys love it is softening my heart

Jen

I’m eating my words. This album slaps too hard!

Emily

Always love, love, love hearing y'alls take on Taylor! But also, you two okay? Seemed like a notable amount of tension between the Matts that made for a kinda awkward vibe :( But even so, super fun to listen your take on this new album!

jessica diora

such a fun album! The fate of opehlia is a such a banger and the best opener shes had in a long time

Katie Kimmel

Father Figure is from Scooter's perspective in the first 2 verses. She flips the script in the 3rd and bridge. The "you remind me of a younger version of me..." at the end refers to the fact that she's grown and surpassed him in maturity, wisdom, how to fight and her BANK (thus the "find your card canceled... who's picture is on the mantle..." I could go on and on and on about the symbolism in each line of this song.

Katie Kimmel

Also, notice she says," I protect the family" 6 times. 6 albums she bought back.

Sara Beth

Scott Borchetta not 🛴 though

Sara Beth

Us all collectively getting taken out by the third verse of a track 6 😭 not even fair. Track 6s are for recovering from track 5s

CassandraRN

OMG This is so great!!! I'm really glad you guys are just appreciating the album as it is. So many people are upset that it's not "Showgirl" enough. Bitch, you're not the showgirl, how would you know what it's like?

Ana Ramirez

I'm not a swiftie, I knew maybe 2 or 3 of her songs. Never understood what all the hype was about. I'm an RnB girlie, not that much into pop music, but one of favorite things is to watch are reaction videos. I ended liking this album a lot. I'd say out of the 12, I like 6 songs, definitely some bangers. But what is crazy to me is that many self-proclaimed swifties hate this album. Some comments going so far as to say she doesn't like black women and that she's MAGA. I mean wtf, she endorsed Kamala for heaven's sake?! But yet with all this so called hate, the album still sold 3.2 million units. Anyway joined specifically for this reaction video.

Ana Ramirez

Well get used to it @Jane Lane cuz I've watched several reaction videos, like 10ish, and that is a recurring comment about Fleetwood Mac.

Christian Seibold

Taylor started with Country, not "pop". That and pop isn't really a genre even though people use it as such. This album is more soft rock influenced than all of her previous albums. 1989 and Midnights were synth pop, Reputation was RnB pop, Speak Now had rock and punk elements in it, but was mostly country, Red is country-pop, and Folklore and Evermore are folk pop. These sounds all cannot be reduced to "pop music". They are all very very different from each other. It'd be like saying Baroque, Classical, Romantic concert music, New Age piano, and contemporary classical are all the same, lol. We tend to call all of those "classical music", but they are all very different sounds. It's also important to remember that historically, "pop" in the 1960s was used to mean popular. It was not a genre. It included popular music from rock n' roll, rnb, "traditional pop", and vocal groups. In addition, Rock was influenced by rhythm and blues, and jazz. Genres are extremely fluid, which is why almost all music nowadays is labelled with 2+ genres, lmao. But yeah, I agree. Some of the criticism is pretty crazy and ricidulous. P.S. Respectfully, if you "never understood what all the hype was about", well, that's easy to say when you only knew 2-3 of her songs.

Christian Seibold

I didn't notice anything. The two are in different places, so the music is playing at slightly different times for them due to internet delay. The two videos are edited to sync the reactions up. So maybe that is what you are noticing?

Angela J Reeves

Your “Eldest Daughter” was so intensely wonderful. Thank you.

Lori Bland

Didn't like Cancelled... I can't come back from that. She has always been an underdog and this is specifically pointed at Blake Lively.

Lori Bland

The BS about her supporting MAGA is a lie. That is 100% made up

Hazel Hardy

I'm late to the party, but love ya'll so much!! Currently feeeeling the reaction to Ruin the Friendship. Yessss, we all need an inhaler!! 😂