Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 544383449.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hey y'all!

This week, your two favorite Matts discuss the endless discourse around Taylor Swift's The Life of a Showgirl album release, Bad Bunny announced at next year's Super Bowl headliner, Keith Urban & Nicole Kidman announcing their separation, and more!

Files

Comments

Christian Seibold

I wanted to say, Matt Steele, that I cannot stop thinking about your astute observation on how people have different ideas about Taylor's writing style. Some view her as the romantic fairy-tale oriented artist, while others associate her more with a mature everyday life poet type of thing. The thing I find so disappointing about this reality is that from my perspective, this shows how deeply those who might love Folklore misunderstand that album and how it connects to her previous and subsequent work. People are disappointed there's not another Folklore because they do not realize how Folklore is just another expression of the same romantic impulse that has defined ALL of Taylor's lyrical writing. I have always viewed Folklore as a mature evolution on the Romanticism that Swift always displayed within her work. There is a reason she compares herself to Ophelia's descent into *fantasy*, a similar sentiment to "I Hate it Here" where she dwells within the secret *gardens* of her mind, the same very focus on nature that so heavily features in Folklore, in Red, and even in Speak Now. In Red we have images of wind in your hair as you're driving in your car, and the glistening fall of snow that symbolizes the death of a relationship, much like the death that happened in Back to December on Speak Now. A similar sentiment to "I Hate it Here" is conveyed in the Folklore bonus track The Lakes, where she talks about wanting to get away from the city and live alone out in nature. Swift's entire perspective is centered around conveying deeply human emotions with intense symbolism of color and nature and myth. She speaks of Romeo and Juliet, the infamous traditional weeping on a lyre so skillfully described in Teardrops on my Guitar, swells of red passion and intensely unique variations on color like in Maroon, the autumn of rebirth contrasting with the winter of death, Ophelia's drowning into water turned into a rebirth out of water, dark grey cloudy skies and hazy fogs of color that blind you from the realities of a failing relationship. All of these characteristics define the Romantic literary period. I would place every single one of her albums in this Romantic tradition for this reason. It is no wonder that she is deeply influenced by Romantic Poets like Wordsworth. There is no dichotomy between Folklore, Speak Now, and The Life of a Showgirl. They are variations on the same artistic perspective and literary tradition.

Two Gay Matts

Well put and very interesting! I definitely agree that her perspectives have always felt very clearly her even if they vary in style or level of intricacy. -Steele

Christian Seibold

Exactly! Taylor's writing and perspective is so uniquely her, and it permeates throughout all of her work in characteristic ways. She loves using colors, myths, and nature as symbols for emotional states and journeys throughout life. It is why her greatest ballads resonate so well with people. But more importantly, this unique and very characteristic perspective is what makes her a great artist in my mind. She has a defining style and point of view. And to me, art is about connection first and foremost. Her defining style is our means of connecting to her perspectives, her experiences, her point of view, the way she sees the world, and we don't have to have shared these experiences to grasp what they feel like, and that is the entire purpose of art to me. Obviously I have a tendency for academic language and logic. But what I find in art is not just the ability to convey some academic argument, but rather a means of conveying truth through emotion and connection. This truth can be the subjective experience that so intensely defines postmodernism, or the rigorous reflection of objective reality that defines realism/naturalism. The ability to do both things at once is what I love about Art and why I chose to go into a humanities-influenced field in College. The rigor of philosophy, emotional truth of mysticism and physical embodiment of spirituality, and the in-between of literary interpretation is so well-intermixed in the field of Theology. I would say the entire point of art is the audience coming to the artist in the "I-Thou" relationship that Martin Buber so aptly developed. One thing not a lot of people realize is how deeply spiritual some of the Romantic Poets were! Wordsworth conveyed spirituality through natural symbolism. Swift might not be so heavy-handed on the religious symbols and references, but she's deeply spiritual in the same way. The Romantics also loved folktales and folklore, and frequently used folk literature and music as inspiration for their own artistic works, or even tried to imitate folk. This is another characteristic that connect Swift so easily to the Romantics.

Christian Seibold

Well, anyways. Sorry for the giant essay, lol. I just couldn't stop thinking about this. Writing this out has helped me develop my ideas into something that I intend to use in future writing projects.

Christian Seibold

I have to add that part of the critique of artists like Taylor Swift is that romanticism is seen as overly sentimental or melodramatic. An example of this would be the critiques of Tolkien's Lord of the Rings as childish and escapist, which is frequently charged at romantic-influenced, and fantastical, works. However, I think this is a complete mischaracterization of romanticism's attempt to find spirituality in everyday life, something which the philosopher Abraham Heschel would call Radical Amazement. And this makes sense when we consider that romanticism and existentialism occur within the same century and share many characteristics with each other. Both traditions critique enlightenment in different, yet related, ways.

Eurocheese

I was banned from Twitter and I genuinely don't remember why. I reached out to their support and apparently I'm banned for life. And you know what? Love it.

maura

I appreciated the nuance to the conversation you had about Showgirl. I enjoyed the album upon the first few listens but the internet definitely brought my enthusiasm. Many of Taylor’s fans seem to hold her to some impossible standard. Thanks for the reminder to just listen to what I like and enjoy it!

Christian Seibold

100% agree about the impossible standards! I also agree with Matt P that the fans are ignoring the fact that music is much much more than just lyrics.

Jaime Ramos

Eldest daughter is my fav. I dont get all the hate. Maybe because im the youngest daughter...

Christian Seibold

Matt S, you should definitely watch Taran's interview with Ashley on RHAP here, if you haven't already: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLRyF7ZuCXQ He created a bunch of clips editing together feeds that show some of Ashley's best gameplays. Taran finally gave Ashley the edit she deserves!

Christian Seibold

Not gonna lie, while at first I was pretty iffy on the song CANCELLED!, since seeing a lot of the discussion about the album, I'm starting to think that maybe Taylor is at least somewhat right. Like, someone had the audacity to say that her song chastising the fans for their patronizing her for dating Matty Heally was "tone-deaf". Since when is the wide discussion of people's private lives like this acceptable? Taylor is a freaking artist and a fallible and complex HUMAN BEING, not some damn politician people can aggressively nitpick and crap all over 24/7. It reminds me of the way Biden's son was blasted by the public so aggressively. Artists engage with their audience in their ART. They don't owe us their damn lives too. She might not be cancelled, she still has money and some social power, but the fans and public are *absolutely* not respecting boundaries at this point. I could never do what Taylor does. Absolutely Romantic would be innocuous next to what I would write if I were in Taylor's position, lmao. I would make a whole freaking album blasting the fans, personally. Yeah, I'm petty like that.

Christian Seibold

Same thing happened to me with Facebook, except it was me being banned from creating a new Facebook account, lol. It was weird. But also, it's for the better.

Teresa Salas

As far as the deranged Swift outrage, even people upset that she referred to herself as an English teacher completely missed that this was a direct reference to fan memes. Someone made a post about how those two dating was akin to your English teacher dating your gym coach. And, she probably saw that, cracked up and used it. It’s never that deep 😂